# Appendix — Minnesota v. Berndt

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385011_2281%3A2

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Appendix
- **Published:** January 1, 1987
- **Citation:** 479 U.S. 1046

## Text

25 1986

IN THE

pPUPTeIne VUUlL, Vids

EILED

\ JOSEPH F. SPANIOL, JR,
RK

Supreme Court of the Gnited
October Term, 1986

STATE OF MINNESOTA,

Petitioner,

vs.

ORVILLE BERNDT, JR.,
Respondent.

APPENDIX TO
PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI
TO THE MINNESOTA SUPREME COURT

THOMAS L. JOHNSON
Hennepin County Attorney
VERNON E. BERGSTROM
Chief, Appellate Section
Hennepin County
Attorney’s Office
BEVERLY J. WOLFE
Assistant Hennepin
County Attorney
Hennepin County
Attorney’s Office
C-2000 Government Center
Minneapolis, MN 55487
(612) 348-8794
Counsel of Record
Attorneys for Petitioner

LS
224-7631 - Review Publishing Ce, 257 E. 6th St., St. Paul, Minn. 55101 — 224-7631

APPENDIX INDEX

Appendix A—Order, Opinion and Judgment of the
Minnesota Supreme Court ;
Appendix B—Opinion and Judgment a Siananate
Supreme Court... .. sh are age eat oan eee |
Appendix C—Order and aiiaitieaitinan of the Henne-
Re Be ae. re
Appendix D—Motion for Order Directing District
Court to Deliver Trial Court Exhibits to Minnesota
i one errs pel na hase’ seat ;
Appendix E—Motion to Accept Photo Mieneenticns
of State’s Exhibits Nos. 18 and 19 .
Appendix F—(State’s Exhibit 18) .
Appendix G—(State’s Exhibit 19). .........
Appendix H-—Letter of John R. cick and Ceeitabie
Appendix I—Petition for Rehearing .
Appendix J—Transcript Excerpts of Ward Mahlen’ 8
ES ore ME Sar cl IN, ln b fasdtnl es terse Ora 9 sd
Appendix K—tTranscript Excerpts of Fire Marshal
Jerry Pedlar’s Testimony | aig.
Appendix L—tTranscript nisi of James Carl-
son’s Testimony

Appendix M—Transcript ieee of Deinihildin

Bhatt’s Testimony |

Appendix N—Transcript Sine of Richard Ton-

tarski’s Testimony .
Appendix tn Peennietas Rieiateind of ualienaney ian
taining to Gasoline Odor
Appendix P—Transcript Excerpts of Fire ‘Marshal
Bruce Ryden’s Testimony

Page

- 7 Ae

- hn
it |
iS Rte iI Sb KE TA Rit rha a A “

Perr ree ene verre Teter ot)

Al 3S ee aDONCE ae Ne tA:

App. 'I17

(8) The decision overlooks the fact that at the same time
Appellant claimed that there was an isolated fire in the area
of the dining room and kitchen, Appellant’s next door neigh-
bors Linda Kavai and Charlie Catron woke up to the roar of
a fire and observed a fire from out their back window (T.242-
43, 246, 253). Reference to State’s Exhibits No. 3, 4, and 5
show that Ms. Kavai and Mr. Catron could not have possibly
seen the fire from their bedroom window before Mr. Catron
went outside if the fire had been where Appellant claimed it
was before he allegediy ran out of the townhouse.

(9) The decision incorrectly states that:

As Berndt came out the door, his next-door neighbor

heard him screaming for the fire department.
Berndt, slip op. at 3. Appellant’s neighbor Charlie Catron
specifically testified that when he came out of his townhouse,
it “seemed” to him that Appellant was coming out of his town-
house (T.255). But Mr. Catron also testified that:

I didn’t see [Appellant] come out the door, but we both

went onto the lawn at the same time.
(T.255). Mr. Catron stated that when he first saw Appellant,
Appellant was either on or very near the front step (T.255).
At no point did Mr. Catron testify that Appellant was scream-
ing for the fire department when he came out of the front
door (T.255-56). Thus, the only evidence showing that Appel-
lant came out of his townhouse at the same time Mr. Catron
came out of the townhouse next door is Appellant’s testimony.

(10) The decision overlooks the fact that if Appellant did
not pour the gasoline and ignite the fire, a third person would
have had to break into the house, pour gasoline upstairs on the
stairs, around the first floor and near the sofa without waking
up either Appellant or Brenda who were allegedly sleeping on

App. 118

the sofa. Even Appellant adinitted that it was unlikely that
this could have happened (T.1224-25).

C. The Decision Overlooked and Misconceived Material
Facts Concerning Appellant’s Relationship with the
Victim Brenda Berndt. |

The decision overlooked and misstates material evidence

concerning Appellant’s relationship with his wife. Among
these facts are the following:

(1) The decision incorrectly states the following:

The state in this case sought to establish a motive by
introducing evidence relating to Berndt’s relationship
with Brenda, in particular, his propensity to flirt and
be promiscuous. Incidents in corroboration of this con-
tention occurred long before the fire date. Moreover, ap-
pellant did not deny the incidents, but contended those
problems had been resolved well before the fire. No evi-
dence rebuts that assertion.
Berndt, slip op. at 7 (emphasis added). The evidence showed
that there had been major problems with promiscuity through-
out Appellant’s and Brenda’s seven year relationship. First,
as soon as Brenda and Appellant began living together in
1974, Appellant attempted to have a sexual relationship with
Brenda’s sister Marla Henne (T.610, 612). After he and
Brenda married in 1975, Appellant again physically grabbed
Marla Henne in 1978 (T.615) and repeatedly called her to
ask her to meet him in a motel for a sexual relationship
(T.616, 1155-56). Although Appellant ceased making over-
tures to Ms. Henne in late 1978, Ms. Henne did not tell Brenda
about Appellant’s propositions until 1980 (T.617, 624). In
addition, there was evidence that in 1979 Appellant physically
grabbed a thirteen year old babysitter (T.511-14) and Appel-

App. I19

lant admitted having three extramarital affairs during his six
year marriage with Brenda (T.1150-51).

More importantly, despite Appellant’s claim that he and
Brenda had worked everything out a year before the fire
(T.1113-14, 1157-59), there was significant evidence to rebut
this assertion. Specifically, there was evidence that Brenda
had a sexual relationship with a mutual acquaintance named
Scott Tollin several months before her death (T.653, 655).
Also, a couple of months before Brenda’s death, Appellant
physically grabbed the breasts of Sandra Jacobs in Brenda’s
presence (T.659, 1157). The evidence also showed that before
Brenda’s death, Appellant and Mr. Jacobs spent time together
at Ms. Jacobs’ home without Brenda being present (T.1263-
64). Finally, the evidence showed that either on the night of
the fire or shortly before that night, Appellant suggested to
Glenn Snow that the two of them do some wife swapping
(T.632-35).

Also, although the decision correctly states that no one
observed any argument between Appellant and Brenda at the

Earl Brown Bow], it overlooks the fact that Brenda’s ex-lover
Scott Tollin was present at the bar that night (T.630, 640).
It also overlooks the fact that Appellant took one of the women
from the bar out to his car for a ride where they were alone
together for at least fifteen minutes (T.642, 1122-23).
(2) The decision incorrectly states the following:
Appellant claimed he was unaware of his wife’s life
insurance policy furnished by the State of Minnesota

where she was employed. He was not even a named
beneficiary on this policy.
Berndt, slip op. at 7. At no point in Appellant’s testimony did
Appellant ever claim that he was unaware of his wife’s in-
surance policy through the State of Minnesota (T.1108-1223).

AILABLE COPY

App. 120

To the contrary, Appellant told police investigators on the
morning after the fire that Brenda did have a life insurance
policy through her employer (0.118).

Also, although the policy did not specifically name Appel-
lant as beneficiary, the decision overlooks the fact that Appel-
lant as Brenda’s spouse had first priority as her beneficiary
(T.705-06). It also overlooks the fact that with both Brenda
and the boys dead, Appellant would be the only immediate
family member left to collect the insurance.

(3) The decision’s statement that the trial court may have
“arguably” abused its discretion in admitting evidence as to
Appellant’s extramarital affairs overlooks the fact that the
trial court excluded other evidence pertaining to Appellant’s
previous conduct. Specifically, the trial court ruled that the
State could not introduce evidence showing that Appellant
attempted to make a bomb to kill a police officer whom he
suspected was having an affair with his first wife (0.202-07,
250-51). Also, the State agreed not to introduce evidence
showing that Appellant had assaulted his first wife (0.201).
IV. EXAMINATION OF THE MATERIAL EVIDENCE

THAT WAS OVERLOOKED AND MISCONCEIVED
BY THIS COURT MAKES CLEAR THAT THE EVI-
DENCE VIEWED IN THE LIGHT MOST FAVOR-
ABLE TO THE VERDICT WAS SUFFICIENT TO
SUSTAIN THE JURY’S VERDICTS.

This court’s general standard for reviewing a claim of in-

sufficient evidence in a criminal case is set forth as follows:
In reviewing a claim of insufficient evidence we must
determine whether, under the facts in the record and any
legitimate inferences that can be drawn from them, a
jury could reasonably conclude that the defendant was
guilty of the offense charged. State v. Merrill, 274 N.W.

App. [21

2d 99 (Minn, 1978). The evidence must be viewed in the
light most favorable to the prosecution and it is necessary
to assume that the jury believed the state’s witnesses and
disbelieved any contrary evidence. State v. Wahlberg, 296
N.W.2d 408 (Minn. 1980).
State v. Ulvinen, 318 N.W.2d 425, 428 (Minn. 1981). Although
the evidence of Appellant’s guilt was circumstantial in nature,
this court has repeatedly held that:

The circumstantial evidence in a criminal case is en-
titled to as much weight as any other kind of evidence
so long as the circumstances proved are consistent with
the hypothesis that the accused is guilty and inconsistent
with any rational hypothesis except that of his guilt.

State v. Morgan, 290 Minn. 558, 561, 188 N.W.2d 917, 919
(1971). See State v. Jacobson, 326 N.W.2d 663, 665 (Minn.
1982) (circumstantial evidence showing that fire had been
intentionally set and that defendant had financial motive to
set fire held sufficient to sustain arson verdict). This court
has also repeatedly held that normally a jury is in the best
position to evaluate the circumstantial evidence surrounding
the crime and the jury’s verdict is entitled to due deference.
See e.g. State v. Daniels, 380 N.W.2d 777, 781 (Minn. 1986) ;
State v. Anderson, 379 N.W.2d 70, 75 (Minn. 1985).

Examination of the evidence in this case pursuant to the
above-stated standards compels a finding that the evidence
was sufficient to sustain the verdict. It is respectfully sub-
mitted that this court’s holding of insufficiency was premised
upon both its overlooking of material facts and its miscon-
ception of the arson testimony. Accordingly, the State re-
spectfully requests that this holding of insufficiency be either
reversed or modified.

That the insufficiency holding was premised upon a mis-
conception of the evidence is demonstrated by the following

decision excerpt:

App. [22

The state produced evidence which, if credited by the
jury, would sustain its contention that the townhouse fire
had been ignited with the use of gasoline accelerant...
Some circumstances proved were consistent with the
state’s claim of an intentional fire, but other circum-
stances proved were generally consistent with the rational
hypothesis that the defendant was not guilty.

Berndt, slip op. at 10. Despite this court’s agreement that
consideration of the evidence in the light most favorable to
the verdict supports a finding that this was an arson gasoline
fire, it relies upon evidence supporting the defendant’s theory
of an accidental fire to justify the holding that there were
“other circumstances” consistent with the rational hypothesis
that Appellant was not guilty. But the jury rejected the
credibility of the evidence showing “other circumstances”
since this evidence was inconsistent with the evidence that
showed that the fire was a gasoline fire.

Based on the rapidly spreading fire, the classic suspicious
low burn patterns and the positive gasoline findings, the
State’s experts testified that it was their conclusion that this
was an arson gasoline fire. One defense expert disputed the
gasoline findings and the other defense expert claimed that
the fire could have been caused by a smoldering cigarette. The
issue at trial became one of credibility between the two sets
of experts. The jury’s verdicts demonstrated that. it accepted
the expert conclusions of the State’s experts and rejected the
opinions put forth by the defense experts that were contrary
to these conclusions.

Examination of all of the evidence in the record below
shows that the jury could have reasonably credited the evi-
dence proving that this was an arson gasoline fire and have
reasonably rejected the defense testimony that was contrary

App. 123

to a finding of arson. More importantly, the record shows that
the evidence proving that this was a gasoline fire is consistent
with the hypothesis that Appellant is guilty and is inconsistent
with any rational hypothesis except that of his guilt.

A. The Circumstantial Evidence Proving that this was a
Gasoline Fire Compels the Conclusion that Appellant
Poured the Gasoline and Ignited the Fire.

That this court overlooked material evidence in this case is

evident from the following excerpt from the decision:
Except for the fact that appellant was physically present
in his home when the fire started, there exists no other
circumstances consistent with the state’s hypothesis of
guilt.
Berndt, slip op. at 8. Appellant’s guilt was not proven by his
presence in the home. On the contrary, his guilt was proven
by the evidence showing that he could not have possibly been
present inside the townhouse when it was ignited. The positive
gas samples and the suspicious low burn patterns showed that
gasoline was poured throughout the first floor with the largest
amount poured in the living room near the sofa where Appel-
lant claimed he was sleeping (T.372-75, 408, 549). See State’s
Exhibit No. 18. Since the State’s experts testified that a fire
in an area filled with gasoline would result in the immediate
ignition of the entire area (T.717, 794, 934-35, 1070, 1071),
the living room would have ignited while Appellant was still
on the sofa. State’s Exhibit No. 18 shows that had Appellant
been on the sofa at the time the fire began, he would have had
to run through a living room full of fire, a hallway full of fire
and a front entryway full of fire to get out the front door.
The State’s experts testified that Appellant could not have
escaped in the manner he claimed he did without suffering
severe injury (T.782, 783-84, 1077). These experts were aware

App. 124

that Appellant had incurred slight singeing of his hair on his
left side and claimed to have brown feet but they obviously
did not consider this to constitute severe injury (T.782). In-
stead, it was reasonable for the jury to infer that the singeing
on the left side was more consistent with Appellant standing
outside throwing a match onto the gasoline than it was with
him running through a house full of gasoline fire. Moreover,
it is submitted that it was rational for the jury to conciude on
the basis of the experts’ testimony that Appellant’s injuries
would have consisted of more than brown feet had he run
through the entire length of the townhouse while it was ablaze
with ignited gasoline. -

The decision’s statement of the facts show that this court
accepted Appellant’s claim that he was on the sofa when the
fire started. See Berndt, slip op. at 2-3. It is respectfully sub-
mitted that this court cannot accept Appellant’s story of es-
cape as true if it views the evidence in the light most favorable
to the verdict. Acceptance of Appellant’s claim requires rejec-
tion of the evidence showing that this was a gasoline fire
since there could not have been an isolated limited fire in the
dining room for any period of time if gasoline was spread
throughout the house (T.717, 794, 934-35, 1070-71).

Because the evidence shows that Appellant could not have
been inside the townhouse at the time the fire was ignited, the
only rational inference is that he was outside of the house.
Evidence showing both that he was outside of the house and
that he lied about being inside the house at the time of the
fire leads to only one rational conclusion—that Appellant ig-
nited the fire and lied about being inside in an effort to divert
suspicion from himself. What other rational hypothesis could

App. 125

there be?® It is not rational to conclude that Appellant stood
outside watching while some third person broke into the house,
spread the gasoline throughout the house, and ignited it.

In rejecting the jury’s finding that the circumstantial evi-
dence ruled out any rational hypothesis except that of Ap-
pellant’s guilt, this court relied upon the following factors:
(1) no one detected the odor of gasoline either on Appellant
or at the fire scene; (2) there was no evidence showing exactly
where Appellant obtained the gasoline; (3) no empty gasoline
containers or siphoning equipment was found at the fire
scene and (4) Appellant had insufficient motive to commit
the offense. If the jury’s finding that this was a gasoline fire
is accepted on appeal, none of the above-cited factors make
rational the hypothesis that someone other than Appellant
was the arsonist.

(1) No odor of gasoline.

The State’s arson experts were aware that no gasoline odor
was detected either on Appellant or at the fire scene. But
these experts, all of whom had extensive experience in ex-
tinguishing gasoline fires, testified that it is not unusual to not
smell gasoline either at the fire scene or on the person who
poured and ignited the gasoline once the gasoline has been
ignited (T.141-42, 156, 165,173, 774, 847, 1089). The expert
testimony established that when gasoline is ignited, the pre-
dominant odor becomes that of smoke and heat and these
smells will mask any gasoline odors (T.141-42, 156, 859).
Although the defense expert Mr. Gallien testified that if this
was a gasoline fire the witnesses should have been able to
detect gasoline odors both at the scene and on Appellant

5 Although this court stated that there were “other circumstances
... generally consistent with the rational hypothesis that the
defendant was not guilty,” Berndt slip op. at 10, the decision never
explained what this rational hypothesis was.

App. [26

(T.1321-23), Mr. Gallien also admitted that he no longer had
the ability to smell anything (T.1324). More importantly, the
jury obviously rejected Mr. Gallien’s opinion on this issue.

It is inconsistent for this court to accept the jury’s finding
that this was a gasoline fire even though no gasoline odor was
detected at the scene and yet refused to accept its finding that
Appellant was the arsonist on the basis that no one detected
gasoline odors on him. Although this court implied that it was
not rational to infer that Appellant, with a blood alcohol con-
tent that at its highest could only have been .12 or .13, could
have poured five gallons of gasoline “without spilling some of
it on his person or clothing,” Berndt, slip op. at 6, the alterna-
tive is even less rational. Even if the court could assume that
Appellant’s story of being inside the house was feasible, he
would have had to run barefoot over carpeting drenched with
gasoline in order to escape from the house. It is highly im-
probable that Appellant could have run through this gasoline
without getting some of it on his feet.

Finally, the court’s holding that the absence of gasoline
odors makes it irrational to infer that Appellant was the
arsonist is inconsistent with its recent decision in State v.
Daniels, 380 N.W.2d 777 (Minn. 1986). In Daniels the de-
fendant was accused of setting an apartment on fire with
middle petroleum distillate consistent with mineral spirits.
See Daniels, 380 N.W.2d at 780. In that case, as in this case,
the defendant had been drinking alcohol for several hours
prior to the fire. See Transcript for State v. Daniels, pp. 81-
83, reprinted in Petitioner’s Appendix. Also, as in this case,
the defendant did not have any odor of petroleum distillate or
mineral spirits and testing of his clothing did not reveal any
finding of a petroleum distillate. See Transcript for State v.
Daniels, pp. 179, 194, 359, 361, 393, 398, 401, reprinted in

App. [27

Petitioner’s Appendix. Despite the absence of any petroleum
odors on the defendant in the Daniels case, this court held that
the evidence was “consistent only with Daniels’ guilt and in-
consistent with any rational hypothesis except that of guilt.”
Daniels, 380 N.W.2d-at 782.

(2) Absence of Evidence Showing Exactly Where Appel-

lant Obtained the Gasoline.

It is submitted that the absence of evidence showing exactly
where Appellant obtained the gasoline does not make irra-
tional the jury’s finding that Appellant was the arsonist. The
evidence showed that a relatively small amount of gasoline—
five gallons—was used in the fire (T.930). The evidence also
showed that Appellant had a number of ready sources fro.
where he could have obtained this gasoline, including the
caretaker’s garage (to which he had a key) (T.910-11) and
nearby cars (T.1230-32). One of the nearby cars was Ap-
pellant’s own car (T.972-73). Five gallons of gasoline is not
a large amount— it is less than half a tankful for most cars.
The fact that no one reported gasoline missing does not make
the jury’s finding of guilt irrational. Appellant could have
easily taken gasoline from the caretaker’s garage or he could
have taken small amounts of gasoline from several parked
cars. The jury could have reasonably inferred from common
experience that someone could siphon one to two gallons from
a car tank without the car’s owner noticing that any gasoline
was gone. More importantly, Appellant could have easily ob-
tained all five gallons from his own car’s gas tank. The jury
could have reasonably concluded that had Appellant done so,
he would not have reported the gasoline loss after the fire.

Although evidence showing exactly where Appellant ob-
tained the gasoline would have strengthened the State’s case,
absence of this evidence does not justify a finding of insuf-

App. 128

ficiency. This is not a case where the evidence showed that
Appellant could not have obtained gasoline that night. To the
contrary, there was ample evidence showing that Appellant
had several ready sources from which he could have obtained
the five gallons of gasoline.

Again, this court’s reliance upon the absence of evidence
showing exactly where Appellant obtained the five gallons of
gasoline to reverse the convictions is inconsistent with its re-
cent decision in Daniels. In Daniels, the State did not show
exactly where the defendant obtained the petroleum distillate.
Instead the State in Daniels, as in this case, showed that Ap-
pellant had access to these flammable liquids even though there
was no positive showing that the liquids in the apartment
storeroom were in fact the liquids that were used in the fire.
See Daniels, 380 N.W.2d at 780.

(3) Absence of Gasoline Container and Siphoning Equip-

ment.

Although the finding of a gasoline container and/or siphon-
ing equipment would have made the State’s case stronger, the
absence of this evidence again does not justify a finding of
insufficiency. The jury could have considered a number of
rational explanations as to why no empty containers or siphon-
ing equipment were found. Appellant could have used a com-
bustible container which would have been consumed in the
fire. Similarly, siphoning equipment could have been consumed
in a fire. Also, Appellant could have disposed of these items
either in the trash that was hauled away (T.778-80, 913-15,
920) or in another location not found by the investigators.

Since the evidence shows that this was a gasoline fire, it
is clear that the gasoline was brought to the townhouse in
some type of container. Because the absence of such a con-
tainer does not make irrational the jury’s finding that this

App. I29

was a gasoline fire, absence of a container also does not make
irrational its finding that Appellant was the arsonist. Again,
the court’s reliance upon this factor in reversing Appellant’s
conviction is inconsistent with its holding in Daniels. As in
this case, no empty gasoline container was found near the
scene of fire in Daniels. That the partially filled containers
found in the storeroom in Daniels were the containers used
was based upon reasonable inference and not positive proof.
See Daniels, 380 N.W.2d at 781.

(4) Appellant’s Motive.

In its decision, this court stated that it had “the firm im-
pression that the state failed to establish a credible motive
for causing Brenda’s death.”’ Berndt, slip op. at 7-8. This im-
pression was based upon this court’s acceptance of Appellant’s
claim that he and Brenda had resolved their problems a year
previous to the fire. See Berndt, slip op. at 7. As previously
noted in Section II(C)(1) of this Petition, there was ample
evidence in the record rebutting Appellant’s claim. The evi-
dence showed that in the months immediately before the fire,
Brenda had a sexual affair with another man (T.653, 655)
while Appellant physically grabbed another woman’s breast
(T.659) and talked about wife swapping (T.632-35). The evi-
dence at trial showed that Appellant’s and Brenda’s seven
year relationship was a troubled one that was marked by
infidelity by both parties (T.653, 655, 1150-51). The evidence
also showed that when Appellant drank, he would become
moody and would direct his anger at Brenda (T.218-25, 684,
961). Appellant was having financial problems at the time of

the fire (T.1168) and the insurance money provided him with
a financial motive to kill Brenda (T.702-06). The jury could
have reasonably inferred that Appellant may have concluded

App. [30

that if the boys also perished in the fire, it would make
Brenda’s death appear to be less suspicious.

More importantly, the jury found that this was an arson
fire so someone had to have the motivation to murder the
victims. Appellant was the only person who would gain from
their deaths. There often is not a rational explanation for the
crime of familicide and the precise motivation is usually un-
known unless the perpetrator confesses. See generally, Malm-
quist, Psychiatric Aspects of Familicide, Bulletin of the AAPL
Vol. VIII, No. 3 at 298. Although at oral argument Appellant’s
counsel argued that Brenda’s ex-husband Harry Gage had a
motive to commit the murders, there is absolutely nothing in
the record to connect Mr. Gage to the fire. Also, since Appel-
lant could not have been inside the house at the time it was
ignited, acceptance of a theory that someone else started the
fire requires acceptance of the theory that Appellant stood
outside, watched as someone murdered his family and then
lied to the police to cover up the murders. It is respectfully
submitted that this hypothesis is not rational and was properly
rejected by the jury.

Finally, as this court noted, the State “has no burden of
establishing a motive for the crime.” Berndt, slip op. at 7.
The evidence established that Appellant was outside at the
time the fire was ignited and that he lied about being inside
at the time of the fire. This evidence conclusively shows that
Appellant was the arsonist and the absence of a clear motive
does not justify rejection of this evidence.

B. The Jury Could Have Reasonably Credited the Testi-
mony Proving that this was an Arson Gasoline Fire
and Have Reasonably Rejected any Contrary Testi-
mony.

BEST AVAI

App. I31

Although this court states that the evidence most favorable
to the jury verdict shows that this was a gasoline fire, other
comments in the decision demonstrate that this court did not
reject the evidence that was contrary to the jury’s verdict. The

| evidence in this record showed two directly opposing positions.
: The first position was that gasoline was present in the town-
house and that the fire was an arson gasoline fire. The second
) position was that there was no gasoline present in the town-
| house and that the fire was consistent with an accidental fire.
| The jury credited the evidence supporting the first pesition
i and rejected evidence supporting the second position. Because
| examination of the record demonstrates that the jury could

ve rationally a¢cepted the State’s arson evidence and re-
jected the defens@’s theory of accidental fire, this court in
eviewing the evidence must also reject evidence inconsistent

ro>

App. K2

ignited it with a burning object, and there was automatic
rapid ignition. The entire area just went “whoom” in flame.

Q. Would you sometimes hear a noise when it flamed up?

A. You would at times, yes.

Q. When you heard a noise, did how loud the noise was
depend on the amount of gasoline or, rather, how long the
fumes had had a chance to collect?

A. I would say that would probably depend, at least in my
experience, on the length of time that the gasoline was there
and the fumes were able to spread.

Q. The longer the fumes had to spread, the greater or the
more instantaneous the combustion?

A. No, I can’t say that that is true.

Q. The louder the noise?

A. At times. Again, it depends on the geographical area
you're using.

Q. Could you explain that, please?

A. If it’s in a confined area, at the time of ignition you
may get the breakage of glass, for example, and the sudden
energy of the ignition coming out through * * *

* . .
(T.768] (Thursday, October 27, 1983, Afternoon Session)
GERALD PEDLAR,
resumed the stand herein and, having previously been duly
sworn, was examined and testified further as follows:
DIRECT-EXAMINATION (Continued)

BY MR. BYRNE:

Q. I believe before you showed us the tape, you told us
you had checked the fuse and control boxes in the basement
and also two appliances down there, a washer and a dryer;
is that correct?

A. Yes.

App. K3

Q. I don't know whether I asked you at that time whether
you also checked the electrical appliances in the kitchen. If
I didn’t, I'm going to ask you now.

A. Yes, I did.

Q. What did you do to check those appliances? |

A. _.e checked the dishwasher to see if it was in the on
position, we checked the stove to see if any of the dials were
in the on position, and we checked the refrigerator.

Q. Did you check beyond examining the controls to de-
termine whether any one of those three items was the cause
of the fire?

A. We checked behind the stove to see if there was any
(T.769] indication of heavy burn.

Q. What did you find?

A. There was no indication of heavy burn behind the
stove.

Q. How about the other two appliances?

A. As 1 recall, the dishwasher was a builtin. We were
unable to get behind that. The refrigerator had a heavy con-
centration of soot and smoke buildup. We found nothing
mechanically wrong, although the refrigerator itself was
highly consumed by the heat.

Q. In your examination of these three appliances, did you
have reason to believe that they may have been the cause of
the fire, one or all three of them’

A. No.

Q. In addition to looking at the appliances, did you also
then look at the electrical outlets and sockets and such?

A. Yes, we did.

Q. All of them?

A. Yes.

Q. How did you do that?

App. K4

A. As we were going through each and every room, we
took the electrical plug or receptacle out.

Q. And examined each?

A. Yes.

Q. I guess we can assume that that which had been exposed
[T.770] to the fire was affected by the fire?

A. AsI recall, on the outer plates of the plugs, there was
some indication of heat.

Q. Did you examine the entire outlet in each case and the
wires leading to it?

A. Yes.

Q. What were you looking for?

A. For any discoloration or any beading of the wire which
would indicate a short or an arcing.

Q. What would be the significance of any beading or
arcing?

A. If there was beading or arcing, that would indicate the
possibility of an electrical fire.

Q. And did you find any beading or arcing?

A. No.

Q. In any of them?

A. No.

Q. Did you find any evidence at all in any of those outlets
that they may have been the cause of the fire?

A. No.

Q. Did you look at the wire back inside the wall at some
distance away from the outlet on these appliances? Not the
appliance but the outlets.

A. We were able to look at the conduit or the tubing in
which the wire went through in some given areas, but we
did not look through all of the wiring inside the [T.771] walls.

Q. Was there any need to?

App. K5

A. No.

Q. And why so?

A. There wasn’t any indication that this was an electrical
fire. We could find no beading of the wire, we could find no
discoloration, we could find no heavy significant burn in any
of the areas around the receptacle itself.

Q. Did you find any evidence of wall fires in the town-
house?

A. There was some fire inside some of the walls, as shown
in’ the videotapes, but there was no significant burn in the
general vicinity of all of the receptacles.

Q. Did you find in your examination some glass that you
found significant?

A. Yes.

Q. And was some of that glass taken into custody by your-
self or others?

A. Yes, it was.

Q. Will you take a look at what has been received here as
State’s Exhibit 25 and tell us what is in there.

A. It’s glass.

Q. Would you explain if there is any significance in that
glass to you as an arson investigator?

A. There appears to be a heavy crazing in the glass.

* ” *
[T.774' there were phonograph records. There were items
that in a fire would have probably given off more heat than
other items.

Q. Those items that were seized by you were then sent to
Washington, at least the combustible ones?

A. Yes.

Q. You were in the building shortly after the fire was
extinguished?

P

App. K6

Yes.
Did you smell any gasoline?
No.
Did you expect to?
No.
Is a fire scene, even with gasoline present, such that
the odor of gasoline may not be detected?
A. That’s true.
Q. Do you know that from your experience in the test fires
that you conducted?
A. Yes.
Q. You were with the defendant the morning some two
hours after the fire, at the Brooklyn Center Fire Department?
| ae, *
Q. Do you know what time it was when you were with him
and had conversation?
A. Approximately 7:00 a.m.

2>eoPop

[T.783] A. No.

MR. BYRNE: I would offer State’s Exhibits 35, 36 and 37.

MR. CASCARANO: No objection.

THE COURT: State’s Exhibits 35, 36 and 37 are received.

Q. (By Mr. Byrne) Mr. Pedlar, a couple more questions
for you. Based on your experience as a firefighter, training
as an arson investigator, your experience as an arson inves-
tigator, fire marshal, all of the information that you received
as a result of this investigation, including a report from the
laboratory in Washington, did you reach an opinion as to the
cause of this fire?

A. Yes.

Q. And what is that opinion?

A. The fire was started as a result of flammable liquids.

App. K7

Q. As an arson investigator, would you call that arson?

A. Yes.

Q. Based on your experience as a firefighter, your training
as an arson investigator, your experience as an arson investi-
gator, the knowledge you have acquired about gasoline and
fires, both in training and in your drills with Brooklyn Center,
based on all the knowledge you have acquired in your investi-
gation of this fire, in- [T.784] cluding the report from Mr.
Tontarski that five of those samples contained gasoline. do
you have an opinion as to whether a man sleeping on that
couch could have escaped through that front door after that
fire started as the defendant claimed? |

A. Yes, I have an opinion.

Q. And what is that opinion?

A. That he could not have done it.

Q. Do you have an opinion as to what the result would
have been to him had he been in there as he claimed when
that fire started?

A. I believe that he would have been burned as a result

of the fire.
Q. Do you believe he could not escape without injury?
A. Yes.

MR. BYRNE: I have nothing further.

THE COURT: Thank you, counsel.

Mr. Cascarano, you may inquire.

CROSS-EXAMINATION

BY MR. CASCARANO:

Q. Mr. Pedlar, you indicated to us that over a one-year
period of time, Brooklyn Center has 600 fires; is that right?

A. No. We have 600 calls.

Q. .I misunderstood. I thought you said 600 fires.

* * *

ll

App. K8&

[T.794] Jerry Pedlar—Cross

A. Yes.

Q. Now, when you go out there, you can see from one
townhouse down all the way down another. In other words,
they call that area a common cockloft; is that correct?

A. Yes.

Q. No fire stops?

A. There were no fire stops.

Q. You indicated to us that in a gasoline fire there is, I
think the word you used was automatic ignition of an entire
area. That is true, is it not?

A. I beg your pardon?

Q. I apologize. In a gasoline fire, I thought I heard you to
say that if there is ignition, there is automatic ignition of the
entire area, all the vapors burn or go off.

A. Yes, I said that.

Q. That’s true?

A. Yes.

Q. And that automatic ignition then, one would expect to
hear an explosion; that is correct, it it not?

A. Not necessarily, no.

Q. That would depend, would it not, on the amount of gas-
oline used ?

A. Possibly, yes.

Q. It would also depend on the amount of time that the
* * *

* * *

[T.810] Q. On the same tread, Mr. Pedlar, as a matter of
fact, 2 tread just below C-6, you took a sample, C-5, low burn?

A. Idon’t recall without looking at the notes exactly where
C-5 came from.

Q. Now, you gave us your opinion as to whether or not
Skip could get out of here?

eel eee a me

App. K9

A. Yes.

Q. That’s based upon your experience and the fact that
those black things there are gas?

A. Yes.

Q. I presume your opinion would be different if you found
out that wasn’t gas?

A. No, it would not be different.

Q. We talked about things that are of a suspicious nature
that are not pure signs of arson: V-patterns, low burns, char-
ring above, alligatoring, all of those things that we saw on
your videotape on the pictures, those aren’t sure signs of
arson, are they?

A. They are unusual areas.

Q. I agree with that, but they aren’t sure signs of arson?

A. No.

Q. There are some things in your experience as a fire in-
vestigator that are important, or perhaps sure signs of arson,
one of which is if you smell gasoline on the arsonist. That is
important, isn’t it?

* * *
[T.847] Jerry Pedlar—Redirect
* * * in the floor was not that significant. Therefore, we didn’t
feel it necessary to take it from that area.

Q. And in this corner here in the living room, also no
sample was taken. Why so?

A. Again, it’s in the area of the television. There is some
low burn on the moldings around the floor, but there were no
significant burns in the top flooring.

Q. You told us also you didn’t smell any gas at the scene.
Were there other odors at the scene?

A. There were a number of odors. We could not depict
what those odors were

App. K10

Q. Is that common at fire scenes, where there is smoke,
char, destruction of material?

A. You can pick up a number of odors at a fire scene such
as this.

Q. You also said that you saw something floating on some
water that you were interested in. What was your examination
of that? What was a result?

A. We saw some discoloration floating in the water in the
debris in the kitchen next to the refrigerator. We understand
that that came back negative.

Q. Mr. Cascarano was also interested in the shingles and
the drip-down potential there. Is there any way that shingles
could have melted in the master bedroom or the other bed-
room adjacent to it in the rear of the house * * *

* * *
[T.859] Jerry Pedlar—Recross
* * * this, right? You just told us that.

A. You can. Obviously, you can smell things.

Not only smoke or soot but other things, right?
If you get close enough.
No gas, right?

>O>eD

. No smell of gas.
MR. CASCARANO: I have nothing further.
THE COURT: Thank you, counsel.
Mr. Byrne?
REDIRECT-EXAMINATION (Continued)
BY MR. BYRNE:
Q. How many gas fires did you build with the fire de-

partment in those exercises that you told us about?
A. Approximately 64 hours worth.
Q. And how many fires?
A. Sixty, 70, 80.

App. K1l

Q. Did you smell gasoline when you went in after putting
those fires out?

A. No. Due to the intenseness of the fire, the vapors and
the fluid had burned off.

Q. Just a couple other questions. If you took a tile of the
kind that was in this entryway and in the kitchen, as you did,
placed it on a table, put a little gasoline on it and put a match
on it, what would happen?

A. The gasoline is going to be consumed and the fire is
* * *

App. L1

APPENDIX L

Transcript Excerpts of James Carlson’s Testimony

[T.1070] Carlson—Direct

* * * high heat tend to burn just above the surface of the
materials. Gasoline has—-without going into too much chem-
istry—has what we call a flash point of minus 45 degrees. In
other words, at 45 degrees below zero, we have vapors coming
off of this material. So we always, under normal conditions,
have vapors rising from gasoline. The vapors are heavier than
air but they do rise.

On warm days at a gasoline station, you might be able to
see these vapors coming out from your gasoline tank. The
vapors tend to dissipate, they are over whatever amount of
gasoline we have on the floor. They don’t stay at one particu-
lar spot. They tend to rise and flow along the floor. If we
could color these vapors, you might see a cloud traveling
through the room. This cloud or vapors given off by gasoline
is readily ignitable. And, when it meets a source of ignition,
it ignites immediately.

The turbulence within this explosion or rapid ignition will,
again, spread this gasoline. And, you have a fire that is ex-
actly the opposite of a slow-burning progressive fire. We have
one of very rapid ignition that happens within a fraction of
a second, resulting in a fire. If we have this used as a trailer
in a room, resulting in a fire that causes [T.1071] full involve-
ment of the entire room rather than having the fire start
from one spot, progress in a nice neat V pattern and go to the
upper levels.

Q. You say “full involvement” of the room, instantaneous-

ly?

App. L2

A. Instantaneously. And that is based on my own experi-
ence when I was a firefighter and I have had to use this on
occasion because everybody doesn't get a chance to work with
gasoline. But, in the '60s, when I was on the Rescue Squad in
Minneapolis and we did burn many homes on the north side
for firefighting practice, it was our job to ignite these houses.

And, as a young firefighter, we had a wonderful time throw-
ing gasoline into rooms. But, we did learn how gasoline re-
acted, how fast it ignited and the volume of fire that resulted
from that.

Q. And from that, you would say how quickly a roomful
of gasoline fumes would be involved?

A. A roomful of gasoline fumes, provided we had more
than a thimble full of gasoline, we have to have an amount of
gasoline. As vapors immediately form above this gasoline, and
once it ignites, it has immediate ignition of the entire room.

Q. In examining a fire or the cause of a fire, had you had
an occasion to examine fire caused by cigarettes left carelessly
somewhere?

* . .

(T.1076] A. They did,

Q. Did you go to the scene of the fire—I should say—

A. No, I did not.

Q. You became involved sometime after the fire had been
extinguished and cleaned up?

A. That's right.

Q. Saw a series of photographs?

A. I saw photographs and the videotape of the scene.

Q. And with your experience as a firefighter, arson in-
vestigator, and with the examination of the evidence available
to you through their investigations, were you able to come to

et

App. L3

a conclusion as to whether the Georgetown fire was caused by
arson?

A. Yes, 1 was.

Q. And what was that opinion?

A. That it was an arson fire, that it was ignited by hand
by the use of flammable liquid, gasoline.

Q. And bared again on your experience as a firefighter
and as an arson investigator, your examination of all of the
evidence available in this fire, were you able to come to an
opinion with reasonable certainty as to whether someone in
the townhouse, in the back at the couch, rear window, when
the fire started, cou'd have escaped without injury to the front
door?

A. Yes, I have that opinion.

{[T.1077] Q. What is your opinion?

A. That under those circumstances, it would be impossible
for a person to have been in the room at the time of the
ignition of these vapors and escaped without being killed or
at least harmed.

Severely harmed?

Not that I am aware of.

I say, severely harmed?

Yes, severely harmed.

On what do you base that opinion specifically?

I base that on the witnesses’ discovery of the fire, that
is their first knowledge of the fire as indicated by noises that
indicated rushing air sounds, whooshing sounds, sounds of
things falling, crackling and their immediate observation of
fire either reflected out the window or actual flames out the
window.

Q. In the rear of the house?

A. Pardon?

>OP>ro>e

App. L4

Q. At th. rear of the house?

A. At the rear of the house in the windows or apartment
adjacent to the witnesses’ apartment. This indicated that at
the time of th‘s first indication of noise and flame that that
room was fully involved with fire. From that point on, these
witnesses had to get their senses about them to see what in
the world had happened.

(T.1078] The witnesses state that they, one of them got.
dressed; he felt the walls; he went down the stairway; he
came out of the front; all of this time the full involvement—
that entire room was fully involved with fire.

At their first observation of this had indicated full involve-
ment of this room, and nobody is going to be in a room full
of vapors and indicate that they slowly progressed from one
point to another like a TV fire, where a person can run
through these little fires within a room without being harmed.

Q. Were there other factors involved in your judgment?

A. Yes. Primarily the time element, the indications of full
involvement, lots of flame reflections out the windows, and
the full physical evidence of the gasoline.

Q. Did this fire, in your judgment, have any character-
istics of an electrical fire?

A. None whatsoever. We have a room that is fully involved
with vapors that must be ignited and there was no indication
that any of the electrical service would ignite those vapors as
it sat under those conditions. Nobody was doing anything.
Nobody was cooking, operating motors. It was inconceivable
that you would have a gasoline vapors as shown, gasoline
(T.1079] spread throughout a dwelling and then have some
type of electrical malfunction coincidentally.

Q. It didn’t have any of the characteristics of a cigarette-
caused fire’

LLL

App. L5

A. Again, it was a very rapid fire as evidenced by the
firefighters and the witnesses at the physical scene, rather
than a slow-burning fire.

Q. Am I correct that the electrical fire would have been
a slow-burning fire, too?

A. That is correct. It would have been either in an appli-
ance or within a wall.

MR. BYRNE: Thank you, Mr. Carlson, I have nothing
further.

THE COURT: All right. This is a good time to take our
break for lunch.

Mr. Carlson, you may step down.

MR. CASCARANO: Your Honor, may we approach the
Bench for a moment?

THE COURT: Yes.

(Short discussion held at the Bench, not recorded.)

THE COURT: We have reconsidered. Stay where you are.

And, Mr. Cascarano, we will ask you to inquire.

MR. CASCARANO: Thank you, Your Honor.

” ” o
[T.1089} Carlson—Cross

Q. You are aware that nobody smelled gasoline on Skip?

A. lam aware of that which is not unusual, yes.

Q. You indicated that you base your conclusion on the
observations of the next-door neighbor, Charlie Catron and
Linda Kauai; are you aware that Linda said she never went
to her window and looked out; are you aware of that?

A. lam only aware that she did see through her window,
from what advantage point, I don’t know.

Q. Okay. You are aware, are you not, that you indicated
that it is not possible for Skip to get out. That Mr. Catron
got back in?

App. L6

A. Iwas aware that he went in a few feet, yes.

Q. Few feet; who told you he got in there a few feet, Jerry
Pedlar?

A. Other investigators; Jerry Pedlar was one.

Q. Mr. Pedlar told you he got in just a few feet, did he?

A. He got into the kitchen.

Q. Finally, you relied upon the reports of Mr. Tontarski,
who indicated he saw the presence of gasoline in the graphs?

A. I haven't seen those reports, but I am aware of it.

Q. All right. Upstairs, are you aware that there were
some charred patterns by the front door of the * * *

os * +
[T.1093] Carlson—Redirect

Q. All right. We will then move on to the next question.

What kinds of materials or what can cause that kind of
rutting and scarring of the floor?

A. This is typical and consistent with the burning of
flammable liquid, petroleum products, gasoline.

Q. Do you know of any other cause for that kind of burn
pattern?

A. Only petroleum products which would burn hot enough
and long enough at the floor level in this kind of a pattern.
And, so the answer would be only petroleum products.

Q. Including gasoline?

A. Yes.

Q. Now, there was some discussion about—

MR. CASCARANO: Your Honor, may be approach the
Bench?

THE COURT: Surely, come along.

(Conversation at the Bench, not recorded.)

BY MR. BYRNE:

Q. There was some discussion about how a cigarette might
smolder on a synthetic rug to start a fire. In all of your ex-

-——

App. .L7

perience, is it conceivable that the kind of fire we are talking
about at the Georgetown Townhouse could have started by a
smoldering cigarette lying on a synthetic rug?

[T.1094] A. No, I don’t agree that it could start on a
synthetic rug in the first place. But there is no similarity
between this fire and the common cigarette-caused fire in
relation to the time element, the amount of smoke that would
come from a cigarette-based fire in a sofa or a chair. And,
primarily those two aspects.

Q. Well, let’s say that somebody was lying on a couch on
the first floor in State’s Exhibit 3, having fallen asleep while
watching television and there was a cigarette smoldering in
the carpet here. What would be the likely result of that person
sleeping on that couch?

A. This is in relation to a cigarette on the carpet?

Q. Or in some other location where it starts a smoldering
fire?

A. If it was in a piece of upholstered furniture smoldering
for an extended period of time, there would be considerable
smoke that would come from it. It would be evident on your
glass and surfaces as far as smoke over this period of time,
and, chances are, that a person involved would be asphyxiated
from the smoke within an hour-and-a-half.

Q. It was suggested in a question to you that that fire
could get started by cigarette smoldering in the wrong posi-
tion for up to an hour-and-a-half, like from 1:30 [T.1095] to
3 a.m. in the morning.

Is it conceivable, in your mind, that cigarette smoldering
for an hour-and-a-half, from 1:30 a.m. to 3 a.m., that at 3 a.m.
this townhouse would have been, for all practical purposes,
totally, that first and second floor, covered, filled with flames?

App. L8

A. Not at all. You would have had a fire confined to that
one area where it originated and, at the most, one room. If
this were in an isolated farmhouse, it would be different, but
we have people in the immediate area, adjacent, that would
have smelled smoke very early.

Q. There were questions asked of you about the elimina-
tion of an electrical-caused fire.

In your review of this investigation and your knowledge of
the evidence before you, do you consider the investigation
made of the electrical possibility a complete investigation?

MR. CASCARANO: Your Honor, I’m going to object to
that. It calls for a conclusion of this witness. This witness is
disqualified in that he didn’t conduct his own investigation.

THE COURT: Overruled.

A. May I answer? I would consider the investigation that
the other investigators made relative to electrical [T.1096]
cause, under these circumstances, to be totally sufficient.

BY MR. BYRNE:

Q. Incidentally, there was a discussion about the use of
the term “trailers” and you said you didn’t use that term.

What does the term “trailers” mean to you ?

A. It means material used to communicate fire from one
area, from the area of origin, to another. It is an arson, piece
of arson equipment, I guess, you would call it.

Q. Would you consider, whether you use the term origi-

nally or not, those burned characteristics as “trailers”?

A. As I said, I don’t—I didn’t use that term, but I would
consider that a trailer, yes. It communicates from one area to
another by use of a flammable liquid.

Q. The other question asked of you, I believe you conducted
the information that the neighbors, none of them reporting
hearing an explosion.

App. L9

Could you explain to us what sorts of sounds you might ex-
pect or would expect and have experienced in dealing with
gasoline fires when a quantity of gasoline fumes ignited?

A. First of all, the term “explosion” means different * * *
* x a

App. Ml

APPENDIX M

Transcript Excerpts of Sharadchandra Bhatt’s Testimony
[T.927] Scharadchandra Bhatt—Direct

Q. Specifically, have you had some experience with and/or
tested with gasoline?

A. Yes, I have.

Q. Could you describe that, please?

A. In addition to the observation of the damages produced
by burning of gasoline, the one particular type of testing that
I have done which can shed some light on certain aspects of
the involvement of gasoline in a fire is regarding the rate at
which gasoline fumes can be created from a certain amount
of surface area. If there is a gasoline spill, the gasoline evap-
orates at a certain rate. And I have been able to measure,
through the testing equipment that I have, as to how fast it
will evaporate and the kinds of conditions it can create in a
certain length of time.

Q. Were you asked by the authorities investigating the
townhouse fire in Brooklyn Center which occurred in August
of 1981 to analyze their investigation and make some—analyze
their investigation, first of all, to review the investigation?

A. Yes, I was.

Q. And in doing so, were you provided reports of the in-
vestigation for your reading?

A. Yes, I was.

Q. Were you also given an opportunity to view some video-
* * *

* * *

[T.930] * * * have used to form one particular opinion.

Q. Based on your examination, based on your experience
and training as an engineer and your experience as an engi-
neer and investigator of fires, based on your understanding

App. M2

of the properties of gasoline, based on your experiments with
and understanding of the evaporation of gasoline, have you
reached an opinion with reasonable scientific certainty as to
how much gasoline would have been present in the ground
level of that house?

A. Ihave not reached an opinion as to an exact amount, no.

Q. Have you reached a reasonable estimate to a degree of
scientific certainty that you feel comfortable with?

A. Yes, I have.

Q. And what is that estimate?

A. The estimate that I have reached is that a quantity of
about five gallons of gasoline would have been ample to pro-
duce gasoline trails of the dimensions that have been de-
scribed. What I am saying is, I’m not saying that no more
than five gallons of gasoline could have been used. What Iam
saying is, five gallons of gasoline would have been an ample
quantity, would have been sufficient.

Q. Referring just to the first floor?

A. Correct.

Q. Now, did you go beyond that conclusion to analyze what
the presence of five gallons of gasoline would do in that * * *
* * bg
[T.934] * * * actual thickness of the area could be slightly

higher, but half an inch is a good practical estimate.

It is also possible with the same amount of gasoline vapors
to produce a comparatively lean mixture which will still burn
or which will still flash, and that can be produced in the range
of 1.4 percent of gasoline vapors by volume and the rest of it
air. You can create a lean mixture like this. Of course, the
layer would be thicker, on the order of two and three-quarters
of an inch. But in one minute of evaporation, you can create
an explosive mixture anywhere from half an inch thick to two

and three-quarters of an inch thick.

———————

App. M83

Q. In your experience with gasoline, and in your literature
as well, could you explain to the jury what would happen if
that vapor would be ignited in some location in the house at
that time?

A. First of all, when these vapors are mixed with air to
form this combustible mixture in the range that we have been
talking about, it is capable of being ignited by a source of
ignition. The temperature of the source of ignition typically
is on the order of 800 degrees Fahrenheit, although for very
low octane gasoline, the ignition temperatures are somewhat
lower. When an ignition source like this is introduced, the
gasoline ignites and a flame front then travels through the
entire [T.935] mixture in a fashion somewhat similar to the
flame front traveling from a spark plug in an automobile
engine and then spreading throughout the cylinder. So from
the point of ignition, the gasoline will start to burn, and this
burning « | spread very quickly throughout the combustible
mixture of gasoline vapors and air. So in essence, there will
be a flash that would ignite the collection of these vapors along
the floor of that first floor. At that point, the heat that is
being created by the flash will be picked up by the trails of
gasoline, raising its temperature, and accelerating the process
of the evaporation of the gasoline. At that point, it becomes a
cyclical process, that the heat produced by the flash evaporates
more gasoline, which tends to burn, and that tends to evapo-
rate more of the fuel, and so burning like this will continue.

q. Would there have been an instantaneous combustion of
all those fumes, for all practical purposes?

A. For all practical purposes, yes.

Q. Would it have been possible for there to have been an
isolated fire in that downstairs area for any - significant

amount of time?

App. M4

A. No, not under these circumstances.

Q. -Mr. Bhatt, I now want to ask you if you are familiar
with the characteristics of electrical fires.

* * *
[T.944] * * * of an occurrence.

Q. Is it possible to generalize as to the speed of the spread
of an electrical fire?

A. A purely electrical fire, yes.

Q. And what would that conclusion be?

A. The speed with which a purely electrical fire—and I
would like to explain what I mean by a purely electrical fire.
A purely electrical fire I would define as one that started at
an electrical source of ignition and spread through the normal
type of combustible materials that would be present, solid
combustible materials that would be present, in a residential
construction of the type that we are talking about. It would
be controlled by the type of materials that were present in that
construction. All I can say without knowing the precise type
of materials is that it would be comparatively slow, and by
that I mean I am comparing it with another type of combus-
tible material as a hypothetical.

Q. The other type of combustible material being what?

A. The comparison I am making to the solid type of con-
struction material is with combustible fumes, specifically of
gasoline fumes.

Q. In your analysis of this fire, was its origin consistent
with the presence of gasoline?

A. To the best of my knowledge, yes.

[T.945] Q. Was it consistent with an electrically started
fire?

A. To the best of my knowledge, and with the evidence

that has been made available to me, nc.

App. M5

Q. Might there be one qualification on that; might an
electrical something in the spark in one of the appliances have
touched off the fumes of gasoline?

A. Yes. To put it technically, an electrolyte may have
served as a source of ignition for the combustible fume and
air mixture.

MR. BYRNE: Thank you, Mr. Bhatt. I have nothing
further.

THE COURT: Thank you, counsel.

Mr. Cascarano?

CROSS-EXAMINATION

BY MR. CASCARANO:

Q. Mr. Bhatt, I just want to make sure I understand your
role in this. You were contacted by somebody from the sher-
iff’s office, presumably; right?

A. Yes.

Q. I’m sorry if I’m not making myself clear. The purpose
of their contacting you was for you to attempt to determine
how much liquid was placed on the first floor?

A. No, that is not accurate. Specifically, to the best of my
knowledge, I was contacted by Mr. Robert Williams of ATF
Division of the U.S. Treasury, I believe. And what * * *

* * *
[T.21983] SHARADCHANDRA NARBHESHANKER
BHATT,
recalled as a witness on behalf of the State in rebuttal, having
previously been duly sworn, was examined and testified
further as follows:
DIRECT-EXAMINATION
BY MR. BYRNE:
Q. Mr. Bhatt, I have just one question for you. It involves

the photographs that have been received here in evidence as

App. M6

State’s Exhibits 15 and 16. You will recall when you were
here before that we discussed these briefly?

A. Yes, I do.

Q. And I believe I asked you the question at that time if
these types of patterns in the floor were familiar to you.

A. Yes.

Q. And I asked, if you recall, if they could be caused by
gasoline. Do you recall that?
Yes, I do.
And your response was what?
Yes, as one possibility, yes.
And are there any other possibilities?
Yes, there are.
And what would they be?
The other possibilities are the burning of any type of
combustible liquid, such as gasoline.

[T.2194] Q. Flammable liquid?

A. Yes.

MR. BYRNE: Thank you, sir. I have nothing further.

THE COURT: Mr. Cascarano?

CROSS-EXAMINATION

BY MR. CASCARANO:

Q. I apologize. I did not understand. You said the burning
of any type of combustible liquid?

rPoPOoPr& Sp

A. Yes.
Q. That doesn’t have to be gasoline?
A. Correct.

MR. CASCARANO: Thank you, Mr. Bhatt.
(Witness excused.)

aa

App. Nl

APPENDIX N

Transcript Excerpts of Richard Tontarski’s Testimony

[T.547] Tontarski—Direct

A. Yes, I did.

Q. Can you tell us what is in that exhibit?

A. A-11 contains wood which is—which has come from the
kitchen windowsill.

Q. And after making your—or did you examine it in the
manner you described which is gas chromatography technique?

A. Yes, I did.

Q. Having completed that examination, were you able to
reach a conclusion as to the presence of any accelerant?

A. Yes, I did.

Q. What was it?

A. This particular item, or in this particular item, I de-
tected gasoline.

Q. Was there any question in your mind that it was gas-
oline that you detected?

A. No.

Q. I wonder if you will open item A-11, please.

Are the items that you examined in there, still?

A. Yes, they are.

MR. BYRNE: I wonder, Your Honor, if I might just hold
the can myself and pass it before the jury for their viewing?

THE COURT: You may.

MR. CASCARANO: Can I see?

{[T.548] MR. BYRNE: You certainly can.

MR. CASCARANO: Thank you.

BY MR. BYRNE:

Q. Mr. Tontarski, I am handing you what has been re-
ceived in evidence here as State’s Exhibit 21. Will you take

App. N2

a look at that and tell us what that is and how you were able
to identify it?

A. Again I am able to identify it based on the yellow tag
that I have attached to the item as well as the identification
evidence tape. The tape has a case number, exhibit number,
date and initials. That is what was received as Item B-39 and
also contains wood from the center of the entranceway is how
it is labeled.

Q. Did you run the same tests on that sample?

A. Yes, I did.

Q. Were you able to draw a conclusion as to the presence
of an accelerant?

Yes, I was.

What was that?

I also detected gasoline in this item.

Any doubt about that?

No.

Would you open this container also, please.

The contents are those that you examined?

A. Yes, they are.

([T.549] Q. They appear to be in the form of wood, is
that correct?

A. Yes, they are.

Q. And included in the couple cases, some tile pieces still
attached?

A. Yes, that is correct.

Q. Is this item I have now drawn out representative of
the others that are in there?

A. Yes, it is.

MR. BYRNE: May I show it to Counsel and jury?

THE COURT: You may.

BY MR. BYRNE:

2> Prop

App. N3

Q. There are items like this in the container, isn’t that so?

A. Yes, they are. That is correct.

Q. Next is State’s Exhibit 20. Would you see if you can
identify that, please?

A. Again, that is one of the items that we received in the
initial submission of evidence. And again, it has my yellow
label and evidence tape on it. This item was received as Item
C-6. It contains wood which is labeled to have come from the
second tread of the steps.

Q. On the ground level, if you know?

A. I don’t specifically know.

Q. Did you conduct the same examination on that exhibit?

[T.550] A. Yes, I did.

Q. And were you able to reach a conclusion as to the
presence of an accelerant?

A. This item also contained gasoline.

Q. Would you open that as well, please.

Are the contents that which you examined?

A. Yes, they are.

MR. BYRNE: May I show them to Counsel and the jury,
Your Honor?

THE COURT: You may, Counsel.

BY MR. BYRNE:

Q. Next item would be A-10, as designated by the Sheriff’s
Office and received in evidence here as State’s Exhibit 22. Can
you identify that, please?

A. Yes. A-10 was also received in the original submission
of items. Again it has the identification tape and my labeling
tape. This items contains green carpeting from the living
room floor.

Q. Did you run the same analysis of that sample?

A. Yes, I did.

App. N4

Q. Were you able to reach a conclusion as to the presence
of an accelerant?

A. Yes, I did.

Q. What was that conclusion?

A. Gasoline was detected in that item as well.

[T.551] Q. Would that have been—Let’s open it for a
moment.

As already been shown to the jury and examined by Coun-
sel, there are two items: One appears to be a carpet; is that
correct?

A. That’s correct.

Q. And under that, what appears to be some wood?

A. Yes. Some piece of wood, yes.

Q. Do you know in which of the items—or whether you
found the accelerant in both items?

A. No. Once the evidence is in this container, such as this,
there is no way to essentially separate the items for examina-
tion through diffusion, and simply being in the close proximity
with one item next to the other. Anything that might be well
on one, they will get transferred to the other and vice versa.

Q. Next as received here in evidence as State’s Exhibit 24,
I wonder if you could take a look at that and tell us if you
recognize it?

A. Yes. This item was received by me as Exhibit B-37.
This item contains wood from the northeast bedroom floor.
And did you run the same test on that?

Yes, I did.
With what result?
This item also contained gasoline.

> OPe

App. O1

APPENDIX O

Transcript Excerpts of Testimony Pertaining to Gasoline Odor
[T.141] Stanley Owens—Direct
* * * start those fires?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Often?

A. All the time.

Q. And have some of those drills been conducted in aban-
doned or otherwise homes, structures, dwellings to be de-
stroyed?

A. Yes. That’s our primary source of drill when setting
the fires is in those types of structures.

Q. How many fires do you suppose you staged in dwellings
as a volunteer fireman in which you used gasoline in starting
a fire and then put it out?

A. Well, as I stated earlier, we use gasoline primarily on
all of them to start the fire. And I would say probably 45 to
50 burns, because we get three or four out of every house that
we have.

Q. And in conducting those drills and after the fire is ex-
tinguished, have you ever been able to detect just with your
nostrils, without any sophisticated equipment, the odor of gas-
oline from those fires?

A. Not really, no.

Q. What are the common or dominant odors in such fires?

A. Weill, mostly just the predominant would be the mate-
rial that we have been burning: straw, old furniture that is
given to us or whatever.

{[T.142] Q. But not gasoline?

A. But not gasoline, no.

MR. BYRNE: Thank you, Mr. Owens.

THE COURT: Thank you, counsel.

App. 02

Mr. Cascarano, you may inquire.
CROSS-EXAMINATION

BY MR. CASCARANO:

Q. Mr. Owens, when you came on the scene of the town-
house, you indicated most all of the windows had flames
coming out; is that correct?

A. Yes.

Q. Now, this diagram that we have, or this model that we
have, of the house here, you recognize this as being the north
part of the four townhouses there?

A. Yes.

Q. It is true, is it not, that when you came on the scene,
there were no flames coming from—

THE COURT: Mr. Cascarano, can I interrupt? I just want
to be sure that the jury can see. You can use the pointer here
too.

MR. CASCARANO: Maybe I can stand behind. It that
better?

Q. (By Mr. Cascarano) It is true, is it not, Mr. Owens,
that when you came on the scene, there were no flames coming
out of this top front window; that is true, is * * *

* * *
[T.156] Gary Giving—Direct

THE COURT: Sustained.

One or two foundational questions, Mr. Byrne.

Q. (By Mr. Byrne) During all your time as a fireman,
including when you were being trained, have you participated
in drills involving fires started with gasoline?

A. Yes, I have.

How many, would you estimate?

A dozen.

Were you present when gasoline was applied?
Yes, sir.

re Pe

sinlveabitiah itachi

App. 03

Q. Did you see the gasoline cans or did you see the gasoline
itself ?

A. I seen the cans. I have seen the gasoline applied.

Q. Then my question is: In those dozen fires started by
gasoline, after the fires were put out, were you ever able to
detect the odor of gasoline?

A. No.

Q. What is the dominant odor?

A. Heat, burnt smoke smell.

MR. BYRNE: Thank you, Mr. Giving. I have nothing fur-
ther.

THE COURT: Thank you, counsel.

Mr. Cascarano, you may inquire.

CROSS-EXAMINATION
* * *
[T.165] Gary Giving—Redirect
* * * correct me if I’m wrong—that you said that at the fire
scene, the idea of gasoline did not enter your mind; is that
correct?

A. That’s correct.

Q. But sometime later did the use of gasoline enter your
mind?

A. Iwould say yes, after the fire.

Q. After the fire?

A. Was extinguished. Something was weird.

Q. Have you ever been in a fire situation where in fact
you did smell gasoline when the fire was still burning other
than possibly at your drills?

A. No, sir.

Q. How about at the drills?

A. Repeat what you said.

App. 04

Q. Do you recall ever smelling gasoline at the scene of
a fire when you knew gasoline was there because it was used
to start the fire during your drills?

A. Before?

Q. Atany time.

As -¥ee.

Q. When?

A. Atour drills.

Q. Before the fire, during the fire or after the fire?
A. Before.

* 2 *

{[T.173] Ronald Boman—Direct
* * * gasoline?

A. Yes, we do.

Q. How many of those drills have you participated in or
observed or directed as training officer or chief?

A. I would probably have to say ten to 15.

Q. In those fires that you knew were started by gasoline,
was the odor of gasoline detectable during or after the fire
was put out?

A. No, it wasn’t. After we entered the building after we
put the fire out, there was no detectable odor of gasoline in
the building.

Q. Let me direct your attention for a moment, Mr. Boman,
to what has been received here as State’s Exhibit 3. I would
ask you if you have had a chance to examine that at any
length to determine what it is.

A. Yes, I have. It is a duplicate of the building that the
fire was in.

Q. And the one portion of it contains furniture; is that
correct?

ds Sa el

App. 05

A. That’s correct.

Q. And another portion of State’s Exhibit 3, a model, is
empty. Do you know what that section of that exhibit is?

A. That would be the adjoining townhouse complex that
would be adjoining the burned building.

* * *
[T.1610] Shelby Gallien—Cross
* * * gasoline, put them out, started another fire, put it out;
started other fires, put them out, in the same house; they did
this numerous times, and said it was common that they did
not smell gasoline after getting in there and putting out the
fire. Would you disagree with them?

A. I would have to know the individual. If I walk into that
fire—

Q. If there was more than one individual?

A. If there was more than one individual. Your nose may
get acclimated to that gasoline odor, and you are immune
from smelling it.

Q. Well, something else can happen too, can’t it? If there
is any sign of gasoline left, it will be clouded over by other
scents of the fire; isn’t that so?

A. Possibly other scents may overrule it, a stronger odor
of something.

Q. Isn’t it also so that one of those odors being smoke,
which would have that impact?

A. Smoke has a strong odor, and it may override any other
oder that you have.

Q. There’s a lot of steam around when you first go into
a place like that?

A. There is possibly a given amount of steam from the

water in contact with the fire, that is correct.
* * *K

App. Pl

APPENDIX P

Transcript Excerpts of Fire Marshal Bruce Ryden’s Testimony
[T.2110] Ryden—Direct

MR. CASCARANO: I am going to object to any testimony
except in regard to flashback. I don’t need to state.

THE COURT: Sustained.

BY MR. BYRNE:

Q. Do you know what the term “flashback fire” is?

A. Iam not familiar with it. It hasn’t been used until I
heard Mr. Gallien talk about it the other day.

Q. You know he used the term to describe a certain kind
of fire?

A. Yes, sir.

Are you familiar with that kind of fire?

What do you call it?
A backdraft.
Q. Could you explain the characteristics of that kind of
a fire, please?
A. Backdraft is one where the room—take in this case, a
living room or a kitchen area that is enclosed, with windows

Q
A. Yes, sir.
Q
A

closed. The smoke builds up at the ceiling level and the oxygen
level will drop down to a point where it will either go out or
unless it receives a new source of oxygen. It is a great problem
for the firefighters because of the fact when this type of
condition exists, when they open up the door [T.2111] and
bring in a line or hose, oxygen is now readmitted to the fire
and it will cause a backdraft or a smoke explosion.

But it does have to be in a confined room.

Q. Like what?

A. All windows and doors closed. No communication to
free oxygen.

App. P2

Q. And why is that so?

A. Because you can’t get that much heat buildup in there
and get a concentration of products in the room.

Q. You say when the firemen open the door and oxygen
would go in, what would happen?

A. You would have a very violent explosion.

Q. Would there be an open flam: before that oxygen is
introduced?

A. Probably not. There probably would be some glowing
embers, but not open flame, no. You cannot have an open
flame and have a backdraft.

Q. The flame would start when there is new oxygen, is
that what you are saying?

A. That’s correct.

Q. How instantaneous would that flame spread through
the enclosed area?

A. Immediately.

Q. Would there be an isolated fire in a section of the
[T.2112] room existing for any significant time at all?

A. No, sir.

Q. Would that enclosed room have a heavy concentration
of smoke before the introduction of new oxygen which causes
the flash fire?

A. Very definitely.

Q. And smoke is lethal if you inhale it?

MR. CASCARANO: Objection, leading.

THE COURT: Sustained.

BY MR. BYRNE:

Q. Is it lethal?

A. Yes, sir. The basic component is carbon monoxide and
carbon monoxide is a known toxic gas.

Q. If someone were in the enclosed townhouse, first floor,
in approximately—maybe a precise cubic footage of 5,888—

App. P3

and there was enough accumulation of gases to cause a flash-
draft fire, would you expect somebody in the building, when
that fire started, to survive the smoke?

A. No, sir.

Q. Have you investigated fires of a smoldering nature
with some frequency?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Is there any rule of thumb that one might expect as
to the survival rate of any sleeping occupant in such [T.2113]
a fire?

A. Well, in order to have the decreased burning level, the
oxygen level within the room would have to decrease below
the normal—in this room, approximately 21 percent oxygen.
Fire requires approximately the same percentage of oxygen
as do human beings. As the oxygen level was consumed within
that room, it is going to drop from 21 percent down to 15, to
10. And, as it drops below 15 percent open flame and com-
bustion ceases. As it drops down to 10 percent oxygen level,
the amount of carbon monoxide that has bu#lt up in the room
and also in the occupant of that room, causes a great deal of
disorientation.

As the oxygen level further drops due to smoldering com-
bustion, once it gets down to approximately 6 percent, all
combustion will cease and all life will cease. But once it drops
below 10 percent, the mortality rate is extremely high.

MR. CASCARANO: What was that last rate, 10?

THE WITNESS: 10 percent, yes.

BY MR. BYRNE:

@. In your work as a Fire Marshal, have you experience,
personal experience with gasoline fires?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. You train Roseville Firemen in connection with your
* * *

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385011_2281%3A2. Public record. Not legal advice.
