# Petition — Crawford v. United States

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385011_0241%3A1

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Petition
- **Published:** January 1, 1983
- **Citation:** 464 U.S. 894

## Text

yf Office-Supreme Court, U.S,

83-239 Srey

AUG

15 1983

ALEXANDER L. STEVAS,

ERK

|

IN THE

SUPREME COURT OF THE UMTRD STATES

October Term, 1983

KENNETH CRAWFORD, - - - ~- Petitioner,

versus

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, - -_ Respondent.

PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT

LOWELL W. LUNDY
P. O. Box 380
Barbourville, Kentucky 40906
606—546-4162
Attorney for Petitioner,
Kenneth Crawford

WESTERFIELO-BONTE CO., 619 W. KENTUCKY-P.©. BOX 3251, LOUISVILLE, KY.

QUESTIONS PRESENTED

1. Where petitioner was charged in a thirty-three
count indictment with willful violations of mandatory
safety standards for underground coal mines in viola-
tions of the Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act
of 1969, as amended (30 U.S.C. §801, et. seq.) over a period
in excess of four years, and where thirteen of the alleged
violations occurred at a mine operated by the petitioner’s
brother and at which three miners were accidentally killed,
and for which violations the United States had virtually
no evidence to connect the appellant with his deceased
brother’s mine, was the District Court’s failure to sustain
petitioner’s Motion under Federal Rules of Criminal Pro-
cedure, Rule 14 for a severance an abuse of discretion and
a denial of petitioner’s right to a fair trial under the Due
Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment?

TABLE OF CONTENTS

PAGE
PTT EEL Lee Eee i, 2
OE OE l
Daa euaagccscsssceccccces ee 2
Constitutional Provisions Involved ...............05. 2
Statutes and Federal Rules Involved ......... ...... 2-3
I ccc scccnesscscccsccececes 4-5
Reasons for Granting the Writ ..................... 5-8

I. Where Petitioner was Charged with Thirty-three
Counts of Willfully Violating Mandatory Mine
Safety Standards at Four Mines over a Four Year
Period, and Where Thirteen of the Alleged Viola-
tions Arose from Operation of a Mine with which
the United States had Insufficient Evidence to Con-
nect the Petitioner, and Where Three Accidental
Deaths which Occurred at That Mine were Ad-
mitted Into Evidence, the District Court Abused
its Discretion in Failing to Grant a Motion to Sever
in Order to Prevent Prejudice to the Petitioner and
Protect His Right to a Fair Trial under the Due

Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment. ........ 5-8
Ce cc ccerecccccccces S
TP CCEUEGGEbeehesesccececccccccccceces 9-42

ES EE AS 9-11
Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act of 1969,
as amended, 30 U.S.C. §801, et seq. ........... 11-23

30 CFR Chapter I, Subchapter H, Subpart A ..... 23-42

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES

Cases: PAGE
Schaeffer v. United States, 362 U. 8. 511, 4 L. Ed.
G81, 60:8. Ob. 2608 CRRRD) svn ccvaccetaeesacess 6
United States v. Halper, 590 F. 2d 422 (2d Cir.,
BUTE) cveiasacebarivesasngasasasaeepeeaiasas 7
United States v. Satterfield, 548 F. 2d 1341 (9th
Che BOF) 0s sa0cn cn ctddsusenkkanenceaeiees 8

Statutes and Federal Rules and Regulations:
Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act of 1969

(20 UB.G. Gr, Oh. G06) voces. aeiesin ess 1, 2, 3, 4
Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure, Rule 8(a) .... 3,5
Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure, Rule 14 ..... 2, 3, 4
Federal Rule of Evidence, Rule 404(b) ........... 3, 4,7
30 CFR Chapter I, Subchapter H, Subpart A ..... 3

Miscellaneous:

8 Moore’s Fed. Practice 8.02(1) .... cc cece eee ues 6

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

October Term, 1983

No.
KENNETH CRAWFORD, - - - - Petitioner,
Uv,
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, - - Respondent.

PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT

Petitioner prays that a Writ of Certiorari issue to
review the judgment herein of the United States Court
of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit entered in the above-
entitled case on the 15th day of June, 1983.

OPINION BELOW

The opinion of the Court of Appeals is not yet
reported. It affirmed judgments of conviction of pe-
titioner for ten counts of willfully violating mandatory
safety standards for underground coal mines in viola-
tion of the Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety
Act of 1969, as amended (30 U.S.C. §801, et seq.)
The convictions were rendered in the United States
District Court for the Eastern District of Kentucky.

JURISDICTION

The judgment of the United States Court of Ap-
peals was eutered on June 15, 1983, The jurisdiction
of this Court is invoked under 28 U.S.C. §1254(1).

2
QUESTIONS PRESENTED

1. Where petitioner was charged in a thirty-three
count indictment with willful violations of mandatory
safety standards for underground coal mines in vio-
lation of the Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety
Act of 1969, as amended (30 U.S.C, §801, et seq.) over
a period in excess of four years, and where thirteen
of the alleged violations occurred at a mine operated
by the petitioner’s brother and at which three miners
were accidentally killed, and for which violations the
United States had virtually no evidence to connect
the defendant with his deceased brother's mine, was
the District Court’s failure to sustain petitioner’s Mo-
tion under Fed. R. Crim. P. 14 for a severance an
abuse of discretion and a denial of petitioner's right
to a fair trial under the Due Process Clause of the
Fifth Amendment?

CONSTITUTIONAL PROVISIONS INVOLVED
Amendment V

‘*No person shall . . . be deprived of life, liberty,
or property, without due process of law .. .”’

STATUTES AND FEDERAL RULES INVOLVED

1, The statute under which petitioner was prose-
cuted is the Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act
of 1969, as amended, 30 U.S.C, $801, et seq. Because
these provisions are lengthy, their pertinent text are
set forth in the Appendix at pages 11-23.

3

2. Rule 8(a), Federal Rules of Criminal Pro-
cedure

‘‘Joinder of Offenses. Two or more offenses may
be charged in the same indictment or information
in a separate count for each offense if the offenses
charged, whether felonies or misdemeanors or
both, are of the same or similar character or are
based on the same act or transaction or on two or
more acts or transactions connected together or
constituting parts of a common scheme or plan.”’

3. Rule 14, Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure

‘Tf it appears that a defendant or the government
is prejudiced by a joinder of offenses or of de-
fendants in an indictment or information or by
such joinder for trial together, the court may
order an election or separate trials of counts, grant
a severance of defendants or provide whatever
other relief justice requires . . .”’

4. Rule 404(b), Federal Rules of Evidence
‘‘Other crimes, wrongs, or acts. Evidence of other
crimes, wrongs, or acts is not admissible to prove
the character of a person in order to show that
he acted in conformity therewith. It may, how-
ever, be admissible for other purposes, such as
proof of motive, opportunity, intent, preparation,
plan, knowledge, identity, or absence of mistake
or accident.”’

5. Because of its length 30 CFR Chapter I, Sub-
chapter H, Subpart A, passed pursuant to the Federal
Coal Mine Health and Safety Act, 30 U.S.C. §801
et seq. its text is set out in the Appendix at pages
23-42).

STATEMENT OF THE CASE

Petitioner was charged in a thirty-three count in-
dictment with violations of the Federal Coal Mine
Health and Safety Act of 1969 (30 U.S.C. $801 et seq.).
These counts extended over a period of more than four
years, from July 29, 1976 through October 27, 1980,
and involved four different mines. One of these mines
the petitioner did not even own; it was the property of
his brother, Frank, who together with two others died
in an accident in that mine on October 27, 1980. De-
spite the fact that the petitioner did not own this mine,
thirteen counts brought against the petitioner arose
from operation of that mine.

Petitioner moved for severance pursuant to Fed.
R. Crim. P. 14 on the grounds that the government
had insufficient evidence to connect him with his
brother’s mining operations and that he had been
charged with these counts in order to connect him with
evidence of a mining accident, thus prejudicing his
chances of acquittal] on the other counts. The trial
judge denied the motion, and evidence was admitted
as to events involving this mine, including the three
deaths. Petitioner was convicted of ten counts, none
of them involving his brother’s mine,

On appeal, the Sixth Circuit ruled that despite the
great length of the indictment, there was little potential
for jury confusion or cumulation of evidence, and that
the evidence as to bis brother’s mine would have been
admissible under Fed. R. Evid. 404(b) to show motive,
intent, plan, or absence of mistake or accident. There-

5

fore, the Court of Appeals held, petitioner was not
prejudiced, and his conviction was sustained.

REASONS FOR GRANTING THE WRIT

I, Where the Petitioner was Charged with Thirty-Three
Counts of Willfully Violating Mandatory Mine Safety
Standards (30 U.S.C. §801, et seq.) at Four Mines over a
Four Year Period, and Where Thirteen of Those Alleged
Violations Arose from Operation of a Mine with which
the United States had Insufficient Evidence to Connect
the Petitioner, and Where Three Accidental Deaths
Which Occurred at That Mine Were Admitted Into Evi-
dence, the District Court Abused its Discretion in
Failing to Grant a Motion to Sever in Order to Prevent
Prejudice to the Petitioner and to Protect His Right to
a Fair Trial Under tae Due Process Clause of the Fifth
Amendment.

Fed. R. Crim. P. 8(a) allows two or more offenses
to be charged in the same indictment in a separate count
under certain circumstances: 1) where the offenses
charged are of the same or similar character; 2)
where the alleged offenses are based on the same act
or transaction; or 3) where the offenses charged are
based on two or more acts or transactions which are
somehow connected or constitute parts of a common
scheme or plan. Otherwise, offenses may not be joined.
However, even if a joinder of offenses is permitted, the
court has the power to order separate trials of the
counts where a defendant’s rights may be prejudiced
if a single trial is held. Fed. R. Crim. P. 14. Peti-

tioner’s motion for such a severance was denied.
‘“(T }he trial judge has a continuing duty at all

stages of the trial to grant a severance if prejudice
does appear. And where, as here, the charge which

6

originally justified joinder turns out to lack the
support of sufficient evidence, a trial judge should
be particularly sensitive to the possibility of such
prejudice.’’ Schaffer v. United States, 362 U.S.
511, 516; 4 L. Ed. 921, 925; 80 S. Ct. 945, 948
(1960).

Thus, the United States Supreme Court has recog-
nized the danger of prejudice to a defendant in trials
where several counts have been joined. As Professor
Moore stated:

‘*Trial convenience in criminal procedure is not a
goal on which all parties can uniformly agree. In
liberal joinder the convenience is usually that of
the prosecution—not simply convenience in pres-
entation of proof, but convenience in obtaining
convictions as well. Few will deny that there is a
positive correlation between the number of de-
fendants and offenses accumulated within a single
trial and the likelihood of conviction.’’ 8 Moore’s
Federal Practice, 8.02[1].

In this case, the United States presented very little
evidence connecting petitioner with the operation of
his brother’s mine. Yet, by indicting him with vio-
lations at this particular operation, the government
was able to repeatedly drag before the jury three
deaths occurring at that mine. [Tr., Vol. IV, pp. 166-
168; Vol. V. p. 48; Vol. I, pp.149-152; and others] In
a case involving violations of mine safety standards,
almost nothing could be as damaging to a defense as
evidence of deaths in a mine. Yet, this is exactly what
was permitted to be introduced into this case, even

7

though petitioner’s connections to this mine were, to
say the least, highly questionable. By introducing
these additional charges, and by introducing the three
deaths, the defendant’s chances of acquittal on the
other counts were highly prejudiced in violation of his
right to a fair trial under the Due Process Clause of
the Fifth Amendment.

The better rule as to joinder of offenses of the same
or similar character was set forth by the Court of Ap-
peals for the Second Circuit in United States vy. Halper,
590 F. 2d 422, 431 (2d Cir., 1978). As set forth by that
court, the rule:

‘*. , , requires a severance of offenses that are pur-
portedly of the ‘same or similar character’ unless
evidence of the joined offenses would be mutually
admissible in separate trials or, if not, unless the
evidence is sufficiently ‘simple and distinct’ to
mitigate the damages otherwise created by such
a joinder.’’ [Citations omitted.]

Here, despite the Sixth Circuit’s statement to the
contrary, the offenses were not ‘‘simple and distinct.”’
Thirty-three offenses were charged. The indictment
was long, complex, and difficult to read.

Furthermore, even if evidence of the severed of-
fenses charged would be admissible at a separate trial
under Fed. R. Evid. 404(b), it would be restricted to
u narrower field of showing ‘‘motive, opportunity,
intent, preparation, plan, knowledge, identity, or ab-
sence of mistake or aeccident.’? The Court of Appeals
for the Ninth Circuit stated it this way:

8

‘The evidence put forth to prove an offense for
which a defendant is tried will generally be more
extensive, and thus more damaging, than that
which would be adduced to establish a prior crime
as proof of such matters as motive or intent.”’
United States v. Satterfield, 548 F. 2d 1341, 1346
(9th Cir. 1977)

The Second Circuit also advised prosecutors and
trial courts to exercise caution in such cases. United
States v. Halper, 590 F, 2d 422, 431 (2d Cir. 1978)

While the government argues that all the charged
offenses are parts of a ‘‘common scheme or plan’’, the
acts charged are all of the same or similar character
and the above reasoning applies. The petitioner's de-
fense was prejudiced when his motion for severance
was not granted, and he was denied his right under
Due Process to a fair trial.

CONCLUSION

For the reasons aforesaid, it is respectfully prayed
that a writ of certiorari be granted to review the judg-
ment of the United States Court of Appeals for the
Sixth Circuit.

Respectfully submitted,

LoweLL W. Lunpy
P. O. Box 380
Barbourville, Kentucky 40906
606—546-4162

Attorney for Petitioner,
Kenneth Crawford

APPENDIX

No, 82-5149
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT

Unitep States or America, - - Plaintiff-Appellee,
v.
KennetH Crawrorp, - - - Defendant-Appellant.

ORDER—Filed June 15, 1983

Before: Excer and Conti, Circuit Judges; and Peck,
Senior Circuit Judges.

Kenneth Crawford appeals his conviction following a
jury trial of violations of the Federal Coal Mine Health
and Safety Act, 30 U.S.C. § 801 ef seq. (“the Act’).

Crawford and three of his sons were named in a 33-count
indictment alleging willful violations of the Act occurring
over a four-year period at four mines in Whitley, Ken-
tucky. Thirteen of the 33 counts involved activities occur-
ring at the Frank Crawford Coal Company, No. 1 Mine,
which was operated by his brother, Frank Crawford, Jr.
The government alleged that both Kenneth and Frank, Jr.
operated this mine, Crawford made a motion for severance
pursuant to Fed. R. Crim, P. 14, claiming that there was
insufficient evidence to connect him to his brother’s mining
operation and that the government charged him with these
violations in order to produce against him evidence of an
accident which killed three miners, including Frank, Jr.
The trial judge denied the motion. Crawford was acquitted
of all 13 charges concerning the Crawford mine, but he was
convicted of 10 of the 33 counts listed in the indictment.

Crawford on appeal does not seriously question that
joinder was originally proper under Fed. R, Crim. P. 8(a),

10

which permits joinder of offenses which are “based

on two or more acts or transactions connected together or
constituting parts of a common scheme or plan.” He in-
stead asserts that the trial judge abused his discretion in
not allowing severance under Rule 14, which provides:

If it appears that a defendant or the government is

prejudiced by a joinder of offenses or of defendants in

an indictment or information or by such joinder for

trial together, the courts may order an election or sep-

arate trials of counts, grant a severance of defendants
‘ or provide whatever relief justice requires.

Upon a review of the record as a whole, we find the trial
judge did not abuse his discretion. In order for Crawford
to establish that severance was required, he must show a
potential that the jury will be confused or will view the
evidence as cumulative, United Statest v. Davis, 80-5015,
80-5023 (6th Cir. May 13, 1983); Corbett v. Bordenkircher,
615 F, 2d 722 (6th Cir. 1980). The potential for prejudice
must be balanced against the need for avoidance of duplica-
tive trials involving similar proofs. Corbett v. Borden-
kircher, 615 F. 2d at 725, The potential for jury confusion
or cumulation of the evidence is minimal where, as here,
the counts involved were simple and involved distinct vio-
lations of the Act. This conclusion is buttressed by the
fact that the jury acquitted Crawford of several counts for
which he was indicted, Moreover, there was evidence from
which it could be coneluded that Crawford had a part in
running the mine,' which could have been admitted at trial

1The record indicates that Crawford’s brother, Frank, Jr., had
no prior mining experience upon taking on managerial responsi-
bilities at the mine on September 6, 1980. He was killed seven
weeks later. The evidence also indicated that Frank, Jr. was de-
pendent upon Crawford for help with the administration of the
mine, including the loan of labor and machinery.

11

to show motive, intent, plan or absence of mistake or acci-
dent. Fed, R, Evid. 404(b). Crawford therefore was not
prejudiced by inclusion of the counts, and severance would
have caused needless and duplicative litigation. <Ac-
cordingly,

Ir Is Orverep that the judgment of the district court
is affirmed.

ENTERED BY ORDER OF THE CovURT

(s) John P. Hehman
Clerk

FEDERAL COAL MINE HEALTH AND SAFETY
ACT OF 1969, AS AMENDED

§ 801. Congressional findings and declaration of purpose
Congress declares that—

(a) the first priority and concern of all in the coal or
other mining industry must be the health and safety of its
most precious resource—the miner;

(b) deaths and serious injuries from unsafe and un-
healthful conditions and practices in the coal or other mines
cause grief and suffering to the miners and to their
families;

(c) there is an urgent need to provide more effective
means and measures for improving the working conditions
and practices in the Nation’s coal or other mines in order
to prevent death and serious physical harm, and in order to
prevent occupational diseases originating in such mines;

(d) the existence of unsafe and unhealthful conditions
and practices in the Nation’s coal or other mines is a serious
impediment to the future growth of the coal or other min-
ing industry and cannot be tolerated;

(e) the operators of such mines with the assistance of
the miners have the primary responsibility to prevent the
existence of such conditions and practices in such mines;

12

(f) the disruption of production and the loss of income
to operators and miners as a result of coal or other mine
accidents or occupationally caused diseases unduly impedes
and burdens commerce; and

(g) It is the purpose of this chapter (1) to establish
mandatory health and safety standards and to direct the
Secretary of Health and Human Services and the Secretary
of Labor to develop and promulgate improved mandatory
health or safety standards to protect the health and safety
of the Nation’s coal or other miners; (2) to require that
each operator of a coal or other mine and every miner in
such mine comply with such standards; (3) to cooperate
with, and provide assistance to, the States in the develop-
ment and enforcement of effective State coal or other mine
health and safety programs; and (4) to improve and ex-
pand, in cooperation with the States and the coal or other
mining industry, research and development and training
programs aimed at preventing coal or other mine accidents
and occupationally caused diseases in the industry.

§ 820. Penalties

(d) Criminal penalties

Any operator who willfully violates a mandatory health
or safety standard, or knowingly violates or fails or refuses
to comply with any order issued under section 814 of this
title and section 817 of this title, or any order incorporated
in a final decision issued under this subchapter, except an
order incorporated in a decision under subsection (a) of
this section or section 815(c) of this title, shall, upon con-
viction, be punished by a fine of not more than $25,000, or
by imprisonment for not more than one year, or by both,
except that if the conviction is for a violation committed

13

after the first conviction of such operator under this chap-
ter, punishment shall be by a fine of not more than $50,000,
or by imprisonment for not more than five years, or both.

§ 825. Mandatory health and safety training
(a) Approved program; regulations

Each operator of a coal or other mine shall have a
health and safety training program which shall be ap-
proved by the Secretary. The Secretary shall promulgate
regulations with respect to such health and safety training
programs not more than 180 days after the effective date
of the Federal Mine Safety and Health Amendments Act
of 1977. Each training program approved by the Secretary
shall provide as a minimum that—

(1) new miners having no underground mining ex-
perience shall receive no less than 40 hours of training
if they are to work underground. Such training shall
include instruction in the statutory rights of miners
and their representatives under this chapter, use of the
self-rescue device and use of respiratory devices, hazard
recognition, escapeways, walk around training, emer-
gency procedures, basic ventilation, basie roof control,
electrical hazards, first aid, and the health and safety
aspects of the task to which he will be assigned;

(2) new miners having no surface mining experi-
ence shall receive no less than 24 hours of training if
they are to work on the surface. Such training shall
include instruction in the statutory rights of miners
and their representatives under this chapter, use of the
self-rescue device where appropriate and use of respira-
tory devices where appropriate, hazard recognition,
emergency procedures, electrical hazards, first aid, walk
around training and the health and safety aspects of
the task to which he will be assigned;

14

(3) all miners shall receive no less than eight hours
of refresher training no less frequently than once each
12 months, except that miners already employed on the
effective date of the Federal Mine Safety and Health
Amendments Act of 1977 shall receive this refresher
training no more than 90 days after the date of ap-
proval of the training plan required by this section;

(4) any miner who is reassigned to a new task in
which he has had no previous work experience shall
receive training in accordance with a training plan
approved by the Secretary under this subsection in the
safety and health aspects specific to that task prior to
performing that task;

(5) any training required by paragraphs (1), (2)
or (4) shall include a period of training as closely re-
lated as is practicable to the work in which the miner
is to be engaged.

§ 862. Roof support—Roof control plan; contents; review;
availability

(a) Each operator shall undertake to carry out on a
continuing basis a program to improve the roof control
system of each coal mine and the means and measures to
accomplish such system. The roof and ribs of all active
underground roadways, travelways, and working places
shall be supported or otherwise controlled adequately to
protect persons from falls of the roof or ribs, A roof con-
trol plan and revisions thereof suitable to the roof condi-
tions and mining system of each coal mine and approved
by the Secretary shall be adopted and set out in printed
form within sixty days after the operative date of this sub-
chapter. The plan shall show the type of support and
spacing approved by the Secretary. Such plan shall be re-
viewed periodically, at least every six months by the Secre-

15

tary, taking into consideration any falls of roof or ribs or
inadequacy of support of roofs or ribs. No person shall
proceed beyond the last permanent support unless adequate
temporary support is provided or unless such temporary
support is not required under the approved roof control
plan and the absence of such support will not pose a hazard
to the miners. A copy of the plan shall be furnished the
Secretary or his authorized representative and shall be
available to the miners and their representatives.

§ 863. Ventilation—Equipment; approval; daily examina-
tions
(a) All coal mines shall be ventilated by mechanical
ventilation equipment installed and operated in a manner
approved by an authorized representative of the Secretary
and such equipment shall be examined daily and a record
shall be kept of such examination.

Standards for air in work areas

(b) All active workings shall be ventilated by a current
of air containing not less than 19.5 volume per centum of
oxygen, not more than 0.5 volume per centum of carbon
dioxide, and no harmful quantities of other noxious or
poisonous gases; and the volume and velocity of the cur-
rent of air shall be sufficient to dilute, render harmless, and
carry away, flammable, explosive, noxious, and harmful
gases, and dust, and smoke and explosive fumes. The mini-
mum quantity of air reaching the last open crosseut in any
pair or set of developing entries and the last open crosseut
in any pair or set of rooms shall be nine thousand cubic
feet a minute, and the minimum quantity of air reaching
the intake end of a pillar line shail be nine thousand cubic
feet a minute. The minimum quantity of air in any coal
mine reaching each working face shall be three thousand

16

cubic feet a minute. Within three months after the opera-
tive date of this subchapter, the Secretary shall prescribe
the minimum velocity and quantity of air reaching each
working face of each coal mine in order to render harmless
and carry away methane and other explosive gases and to
reduce the level of respirable dust to the lowest attainable
level. The authorized representative of the Secretary may
require in any coal mine a greater quantity and velocity of
air when he finds it necessary to protect the health or
safety of miners, Within one year after the operative date
of this subchapter, the Secretary or his authorized repre-
sentative shall prescribe the maximum respirable dust level
in the intake aircourses in each coal mine in order to reduce
such level to the lowest attainable level. In robbing areas
of anthracite mines, where the air currents cannot be con-
trolled and measurements of the air cannot be obtained, the
air shall have perceptible movement.

Pre-shift examinations and tests; scope; violations of man-
datory standards; notification; posting of “DANGER”
signs; restriction of entry; records; re-entry

(d) (1) Within three hours immediately preceding the
beginning of any shift, and before any miner in such shift
enters the active workings of a coal mine, certified persons
designated by the operator of the mine shall examine such
workings and any other underground area of the mine
designated by the Secretary or his authorized representa-
tive. Each such examiner shall examine every working
section in such workings and shall make tests in each such
working section for accumulations of methane with means
approved by the Secretary for detecting methane and shall
make tests for oxygen deficiency with a permissible flaine
safety lamp or other means approved by the Secretary;
examine seals and doors to determine whether they are

17

functioning properly; examine and test the roof, face, and
rib conditions in such working section; examine active
roadways, travelways, and belt conveyors on which men
are carried, approaches to abandoned areas, and accessible
falls in such section for hazards; test by means of an
anemometer or other device approved by the Secretary to
determine whether the air in each split is traveling in its
proper course and in normal volume and velocity; and ex-
amine for such other hazards and violations of the manda-
tory health or safety standards, as an authorized repre-
sentative of the Secretary may from time to time require,
Belt conveyors on which coal is carried shall be examined
after each coal-producing shift has begun. Such mine ex-
aminer shall place his initials and the date and time at all
places he examines. If such mine examiner finds a condi-
tion which constitutes a violation of a mandatory health
or safety standard or any condition which is hazardous to
persons who may enter or be in such area, he shall indicate
such hazardous place by posting a “DANGER” sign con-
spicuously at all points which persons entering such hazard-
ous place would be required to pass, and shall notify the
operator of the mine. No person, other than an authorized
representative of the Secretary or a State mine inspector
or persons authorized by the operator to enter such place
for the purpose of eliminating the hazardous condition
therein, shall enter such place while such sign is so posted.
Upon completing his examination, such mine examiner shall
report the results of his examination to a person, desig-
nated by the operator to receive such reports at a desig-
nated station on the surface of the mine, before other per-
sons enter the underground areas of such mine to work in
such shift. Each such mine examiner shall also record the
results of his examination with ink or indelible pencil in a
book approved by the Secretary kept for such purpose in
an area on the surface of the mine chosen by the operator

18

to minimize the danger of destruction by fire or other
hazard, and the record shall be open for inspection by in-
terested persons.

* * * * * . *

Daily examinations and tests; scope; imminent danger;
withdrawal of persons; abatement of danger

(e) At least onee during each coal-producing shift, or
more often if necessary for safety, each working section
shall be examined for hazardous conditions by certified per-
sons designated by the operator to do so. Any such condi-
tion shall be corrected immediately. If such condition
creates an imminent danger, the operator shall withdraw
all persons from the area affected by such condition to a
safe area, except those persons referred to in section 814(d)
of this title, until the danger is abated. Such examination
shall include tests for methane with a means approved by
the Secretary for detecting methane and for oxygen defi-
ciency with a permissible flame safety lamp or other means
approved by the Secretary.

Weekly examination for hazardous conditions; scope;
notification; repairs; imminent danger; with-
drawal of persons; abatement; records

(f) In addition to the pre-shift and daily examinations
required by this section, examinations for hazardous con-
ditions, including tests for methane, and for compliance
with the mandatory health or safety standards, shall be
made at least once each week by a certified person desig-
nated by the operator in the return of each split of air
where it enters the main return, on pillar falls, at seals,
in the main return, at least one entry of each intake and
return aircourse in its entirety, idle workings, and, insofar
as safety considerations permit, abandoned areas. Such

19

weekly examination need not be made during any week in
which the mine is idle for the entire week, except that such
examination shall be made before any other miner returns
to the mine, The person making such examinations and
tests shall place his initials and the date and time at the
places examined, and if any hazardous condition is found,
such condition shall be reported to the operator promptly.
Any hazardous condition shall be corrected immediately.
If such condition creates an imminent danger, the operator
shall withdraw all persons from the area affected by such
condition to a safe area, except those persons referred to
in section 814(d) of this title, until such danger is abated.
A record of these examinations, tests, and actions taken
shall be recorded in ink or indelible pencil in a book ap-
proved by the Secretary kept for such purpose in an area
on the surface of the mine chosen by the mine operator to
minimize the danger of destruction by fire or other hazard,
and the record shall be open for inspection by interested
persons.

Methane and dust control plans; contents

(o) A ventilation system and methane and dust control
plan and revisions thereof suitable to the conditions and
the mining system of the coal mine and approved by the
Secretary shall be adopted by the operator and set out in
printed form within ninety days after the operative date of
this subchapter. The plan shall show the type and location
of mechanical ventilation equipment installed and operated
in the mine, such additional or improved equipment as the
Secretary may require, the quantity and velocity of air
reaching each working face, and such other information as
the Secretary may require. Such plan shall be reviewed by
the operator and the Secretary at least every six months.

20
§ 872. Maps—Fireproof repository; contents; certification

(a) The operator of a coal mine shall have in a fire-
proof repository located in an area on the surface of the
mine chosen by the mine operator to minimize the danger
of destruction by fire or other hazard, an accurate and
up-to-date map of such mine drawn on seale. Such map
shall show the active workings, all pillared, worked out,
and abandoned areas, except as provided in this section,
entries and aircourses with the direction of airflow indi-
cated by arrows, contour lines of all elevations, elevations
of all main and cross or side entries, dip of the coalbed,
escapeways, adjacent mine workings within one thousand
feet, mines above or below, water pools above, and either
producing or abandoned oil and gas wells located within
five hundred feet of such mine and any underground area of
such mine, and such other information as the Secretary
may require. Such map shall identify those areas of the
mine which have been pillared, worked out, or abandoned
which are inaccessible or cannot be entered safely and on
which no information is available. Such map shall be made
or certified by a registered engineer or a registered sur-
veyor of the State in which the mine is located. Such map
shall be kept up to date by temporary notations and such
map shall be revised and supplemented at intervals pre-
scribed by the Secretary on the basis of a survey made or
certified by such engineer or surveyor.

* . * . * . *
§ 873. Blasting and explosives—Limitations on storage
and use of black powder and mudcaps
oe * . . * * *

Storage of explosives and detonators; mudcaps in

anthracite mines; restrictions; tests

(b) Explosives and detonators shall be kept in separate
containers until immediately before blasting. In under-

21

ground anthracite mines, (1) mudcaps or other open, un-
confined shake shots may be fired, if restricted to battery
starting when methane or a fire hazard is not present, and
if it is otherwise impracticable to start the battery;
(2) open, unconfined shake shots in pitching veins may be
fired, when no methane or fire hazard is present, if the tak-
ing down of loose hanging coal by other means is too
hazardous; and (3) tests for methane shall be made im-
mediately before such shots are fired and if 1.0 volume per
centum or more of methane is present, when tested, such
shot shall not be made until the methane content is reduced
below 1.0 volume per centum.

Permissible explosives, detonators, and devices;
firing; stem boreholes; nonpermissible ex-
plosives; compressed air blasting

(c) Except as provided in this subsection, in all under-
ground areas of a coal mine only permissible explosives,
electric detonators of proper strength, and permissible
blasting devices shall be used and all explosives and blast-
ing devices shall be used in a permissible manner. Per-
missible explosives shall be fired only with permissible shot
firing units, Only incombustible materials shall be used
for stemming boreholes, The Secretary may, under such
safeguards as he may prescribe, permit the firing of more
than twenty shots and allow the use of nonpermissible ex-
plosives in sinking shafts and slopes from the surface in
rock. Nothing in this section shall prohibit the use of com-
pressed air blasting.

§ 877. General safety provisions—Location of oil and gas

wells; establishment and maintenance of barriers;
minimum requisites; exceptions

oo»
Emergency medical assistance preparations; locations for
medical equipment; filing of implementation plans

(m) Each operator shall make arrangements in advance
for obtaining emergency medical assistance and transporta-
tion for injured persons. Emergency communications shall
be provided to the nearest point of assistance. Selected
agents of the operator shall be trained in first aid and first
aid training shall be made available to all miners. Each
coal mine shall have an adequate supply of first aid equip-
ment located on the surface, at the bottom of shafts and
slopes, and at other strategie locations near the working
faces. In fulfilling each of the requirements of this sub
section, the operator shall meet at least minimum require-
ments prescribed by the Secretary of Health, Education,
and Welfare. Within two months after the operative date
of this subchapter, each operator shall file with the Secre-
tary a plan setting forth in such detail as the Secretary
may require the manner in which such operator has ful-
filled the requirements in this subsection.

Self-rescue device; training of personnel

(n) A self-rescue device approved by the Secretary shall
be made available to each miner by the operator which
shall be adequate to protect such miner for one hour or
longer. Each operator shall train each miner in the use
of such device.

Identification check system; records

(p) Each operator of a coal mine shall establish a
check-in and check-out system which will provide positive
identification of every person underground, and will pro-
vide an accurate record of the persons in the mine kept on
the surface in a place chosen to minimize the danger of

23

destruction by fire or other hazard. Such record shall bear
a number identical to an identification check that is se-
curely fastened to the lamp belt worn by the person under-
ground. The identification check shall be made of a rust
resistant metal of not less than sixteen gauge,

30 CFR CHAPTER I
SUBCHAPTER H—EDUCATION AND TRAINING
Subpart A—Training and Retraining of
Underground Miners

§ 48.1 Scope.

The provisions of this Subpart A set forth the manda-
tory requirements for submitting and obtaining approval
of programs for training and retraining miners working
in underground mines. Requirements regarding compensa-
tion for training and retraining are also included. The re-
quirements for training and retraining miners working at
surface mines and surface areas of underground mines are
set forth in Subpart B of this part.

§ 48.2 Definitions

For the purposes of this Subpart A—(a)(1) “Miner”
means, for purposes of $$ 48.3 through 48.10 of this Subpart
A, any person working in an underground mine and who is
engaged in the extraction and production process, or who
is regularly exposed to mine hazards, or who is a mainten-
ance or service worker employed by the operator or a
maintenance or service worker contracted by the operator
to work at the mine for frequent or extended periods, This
definition shall include the operator if the operator works
underground on a continuing, even if irregular, basis.
Short term, specialized contact workers, su: h as drillers and
blasters, who are engaged in the extraction and production
process and who have received training under § 48.6 (Train-
ing of newly-employed experienced miners) of this Subpart

24

A may, in lieu of subsequent training under that section
for each new employment, receive training under § 48,11
(Hazard training) of this Subpart A. This definition does
not include:

(i) Workers under Subpart C of this part 48, including
shaft and slope workers, workers engaged in construction
activities ancillary to shaft and slope sinking, and workers
engaged in the construction of major addition to an exist-
ing mine which requires the mine to cease operations;

(ii) Supervisory personnel subject to MSHA approved
State certification requirements; and,

(iii) Any person covered under paragraph (a)(2) of
this section.

(2) Miner means, for purposes of § 48.11 (Hazard train-
ing) of this Subpart A, any person working in an un-
derground mine and excluding persons covered under
paragraph (a)(1) of this section and Subpart C of this
part and supervisory personnel subject to MSHA approved
State certification requirements. This definition includes
any delivery, office, or scientific worker or occasional, short
term maintenance or service worker contracted by the oper-
ator, and any student engaged in academic projects involv-
ing his or her extended presence at the mine.

(b) “Experienced miner” means a person who is em-
ployed as an underground miner, as defined in paragraph
(a)(1) of this section, on the effective date of these rules;
or a person who has received training acceptable to MSHA
from an appropriate State agency within the preceding 12
months; or a person who has had at least 12 months ex-
perience working in an underground mine during the pre-
ceding 3 years; or a person who has received the training
for a new miner within the preceding 12 months as pre-
seribed in § 48.5 (Training of new miners) of this Sub-
part A.

25

(c) “New miner” means a miner who is not an ex-
perienced miner.

(d) “Normal working hours” means a period of time
during which a miner is otherwise scheduled to work. This
definition does not preclude scheduling training classes
on the sixth or seventh working day if such a work schedule
has been established for a sufficient period of time to be
accepted as the operator’s common practice. Miners shall
be paid at a rate of pay which shall correspond to the rate
of pay they would have received had they been performing
their normal work tasks.

(e) “Operator” means any owner, lessee, or other per-
son who operates, controls or supervises an underground
mine; or any independent contractor identified as an oper-
ator performing services or construction at such mine.

(f) “Task” means a work assignment that includes
duties of a job that occur on a regular basis and which
requires physical abilities and job knowledge.

(g) “Act” means the Federal Mine Safety and Health
Act of 1977,

§ 48.3 Training plans; time of submission; where filed;
information required; time for approval; method
for disapproval; commencement of training; ap-
proval of instructors.

(a) Each operator of an underground mine shall have
an MSHA approved plan containing programs for train-
ing new miners, training newly-employed experienced min-
ers, training miners for new tasks, annual refresher train-
ing, and hazard training for miners as follows:

(1) In the ease of an underground mine which is oper-
ating on the effective date of this Subpart A, the operator
of the mine shall submit such plan for approval within 90
days after the effective date of this Subpart A.

26

(2) Within 60 days after the operator submits the plan
for approval, unless extended by MSHA, the operator shall
have an approved plan for the mine.

(3) In the case of a new underground mine which is
to be opened or a mine which is to be reopened or reacti-
vated after the effective date of this Subpart A, the oper-
ator shall have an approved plan prior to opening the new
mine, or reopening or reactivating the mine.

(b) The training plan shall be filed with the Chief of
the Training Center, MSHA, for the area in which the mine
is located,

(c) Each operator shall submit to the Chief of the
Training Center, MSHA, the following information:

(1) The company name, mine name, and MSHA identi-
fication number of the mine.

(2) The name and position of the person designated by
the operator who is responsible for health and safety train-
ing at the mine. This person may be the operator.

(3) A list of MSHA approved instructors with whom
the operator proposes to make arrangements to teach the
courses, and the courses each instructor is qualified to teach,

(4) The location where training will be given for each
course.

(5) A description of the teaching methods and the
course materials which are to be used in training,

(6) The approximate number of miners employed at the
mine and the maximum number who will attend each ses-
sion of training.

(7) The predicted time or periods of time when regu-
larly scheduled refresher training will be given. This
schedule shall include the titles of courses to be taught,
the total number of instruction hours for each course, and
the predicted time and length of each session of training.

27

(8) For the purposes of § 48.7 (New task training of
miners) of this Subpart A, the operator shall submit:

(i) A complete list of task assignments to correspond
with the definition of “task” in ¢ 48.2(f) of this Subpart A.

(ii) The titles of personnel conducting the training for
this section.

(iii) The outline of training procedures used in train-
ing miners in those work assignments listed according to
paragraph (c)(8)(i) of this section.

(iv) The evaluation procedures used to determine the
effectiveness of training under § 48.7 of this Subpart A.

(d) The operator shall furnish to the representative
of the miners a copy of the training plan two weeks prior
to its submission to the Chief of the Training Center.
Where a miner’s representative is not designated, a copy
of the plan shall be posted on the mine bulletin board 2
weeks prior to its submission to the Chief of the Training
Center. Written comments received by the operator from
miners or their representatives shall be submitted to the
Chief of the Training Center. Miners or their representa-
tives may submit written comments directly to the chief
of the training center.

(e) All training required by the training plan submitted
to and approved by the Chief of the Training Center as
required by this Subpart A shall be subject to evaluation
by the Office of Education and Training, MSHA, to de-
termine the effectiveness of the training programs. If it
is deemed necessary, the Chief of the Training Center may
require changes in, or additions to, programs. Upon re-
quest from the Office of Education and Training, MSHA,
the operator shall make available for evaluation by the
Office of Education and Training the instructional materials,
handouts, visual aids and other teaching accessories used
or to be used in the training programs. Upon request from

28

the Office of Education and Training, MSHA, the operator
shall provide information concerning the schedules of up-
coming training.

(f) The operator shall make a copy of the MSHA ap-
proved training plan available at the mine site for MSHA
inspection and for examination by the miners and their
representatives.

(g) Except as provided in § 48.7 (New task training
of miners) and § 48,11 (Hazard training) of this Subpart A,
all courses shall be conducted by MSHA approved in-
structors.

(h) Instructors shall be approved by the Office of Edu-
cation and Training, MSHA, in one or more of the follow-
ing ways:

(1) Instructors shall take an instructor’s training course
conducted by the Office of Education and Training, MSHA,
or given by persons designated by the Office of Education
and Training, MSHA, to give such instruction; and in-
structors shall have satisfactorily completed a program
of instruction approved by the Office of Education and
Training, MSHA, in the subject matter to be taught.

(2) Instructors may be designated by MSHA as ap-
proved instructors to teach specific courses based on written
evidence of the instructors’ qualifications and teaching
experience.

(3) At the discretion of the Chief of the Training Cen-
ter, instructors may be designated by MSHA as approved
instructors to teach specific courses based on the perform-
ance of the instructors while teaching classes monitored by
MSHA. Operators shall indicate in the training plans
submitted for approval whether they want to have in-
structors approved based on monitored performance. The
Training Center Chief shall consider such factors as the
size of the mine, the number of employees, the mine safety

29

record and remoteness from a training facility when de-
termining whether instructor approval based on monitored
performance is appropriate.

(4) On the effective date of this Subpart A, cooperative
instructors who have been designated by MSHA to teach
MSHA approved courses and who have taught such courses
within the 24 months prior to the effective date of this
Subpart shall be considered approved instructors for such
courses,

(i) Instructors may have their approval revoked by
MSHA for good cause which may include not teaching a
course at least once every 24 months. Before any revoca-
tion is effective, the Chief of the Training Center must
send written reasons for revocation to the instructor and
the instructor shall be given an opportunity to demonstrate
or achieve compliance before the Chief of the Training
Center on the matter. A decision by the Chief of the
Training Center to revoke an instructor’s approval may be
appealed by the instructor to the Director of Education
and Training, MSHA, 4015 Wilson Boulevard, Arlington,
Va. 22203. Such an appeal shall be submitted to the
Director of Education and Training within 5 days of noti-
fication of the Chief of the Training Center’s decision.
Upon revocation of an instructor’s approval, the chief of
the training center shall immediately notify operators who
use the instructor for training.

(j) The Chief of the Training Center for the area in
which the mine is located shall notify the operator and the
miner’s representative, in writing, within 60 days from the
date on which the training plan is filed, of the approval or
status of the approval of the training programs.

(1) If revisions are required for approval, or to retain
approval thereafter, the revisions required shall be speci-
fied to the operator and the miner’s representative and the

30

operator and the miner’s representative shall be afforded
an opportunity to discuss the revisions with the Chief of
the Training Center, or to propose alternate revisions or
changes. The Chief of the Training Center, in consultation
with the operator and the representative of the miners,
shall fix a time within which the discussion will be held,
or alternate revisions or changes submitted, before final
approval is made.

(2) The Chief of the Training Center may approve
separate programs of the training plan and withhold ap-
proval of other programs, pending discussion of revisions
or submission of alternate revisions or changes.

(k) Except as provided under § 48.8(¢c) (Annual re-
fresher training of miners) of this Subpart A, the operator
shall commence training of miners within 60 days after
upproval of the training plan, or approved programs of the
training plan.

(1) The operator shall notify the Chief of the Training
Center, MSHA, in the area in which the mine is located,
and the miners’ representative of any changes or modifi-
cations the operator proposes to make in the approved
training plan. The operator shall obtain the approval of
the Training Center Chief for such changes or modifications.

(m) In the event the Chief of the Training Center or
the Director of Education and Training disapproves a train-
ing plan or a proposed modification of a training plan or
requires changes in a training plan or modification, the
Chief of the Training Center or the Director of Education
and Training shall notify the operator and the miner’s
representative in writing of:

(1) The specific changes or items of deficiency.

(2) The action necessary to effect the changes or bring
the disapproved training plan or modification into com-
pliance.

31

(3) The deadline for completion of remedial action to
effect compliance, which shall serve to suspend punitive
action under the provisions of sections 104 and 110 of the
Act and other related regulations until that established
deadline date, except that no such suspension shall take
place in imminent danger situations.

(n) The operator shall post on the mine bulletin board,
and provide to the miners’ representative, a copy of all
MSHA revisions and decisions which concern the training
plan at the mine and which are issued by the Chief of
the Training Center or the Director of Education and
Training.

[43 FR 47459, Oct, 13, 1978; 44 FR 1980, Jan, 9, 1979]

§ 48.4 Cooperative training program.

(a) An operator of a mine may conduct his own train-
ing programs, or may participate in training programs con-
ducted by MSHA, or may participate in MSHA approved
training programs conducted by State or other Federal
agencies, or associations of mine operators, miners’ repre-
sentatives, other mine operators, private associations, or
educational institutions.

(b) Each program and course of instruction shall be
given by instructors who have been approved by MSHA to
instruct in the courses which are given, and such courses
and the training programs shall be adapted to the mining
operations and practices existing at the mine and shall be
approved by the Chief of the Training Center for the area
in which the mine is located.

§ 48.5 Training of new miners; minimum courses of in-
struction; hours of instruction.

(a) Each new miner shall receive no less than 40 hours
of training as prescribed in this section before such miner
is assigned to work duties. Such training shall be con-

32

ducted in conditions which as closely as practicable dupli-
cate actual underground conditions, and approximately
8 hours of training shall be given at the minesite.

(b) The training program for new miners shall include
the following courses:

(1) Instruction in the statutory rights of miners and
their representatives under the Act; authority and respon-
sibility of supervisors. The course shall include instruc-
tion in the statutory rights of miners and their representa-
tives under the Act, including a discussion of section 2 of
the Act; a review and description of the line of authority
of supervisors and miners’ representatives and the respon-
sibilities of such supervisors and miners’ representatives;
and an introduction to the operator’s rules and the pro-
cedures for reporting hazards.

(2) Self-rescue and respiratory devices. The course
shall include instruction and demonstration in the use, care,
and maintenance of self-rescue and respiratory devices used
at the mine. Such course shall be given before the new
miner goes underground.

(3) Entering and leaving the mine; transportation;
communications. The course shall include instruction on
the procedures in effect for entering and leaving the mine;
the check-in and checkout system in effect at the mine; the
procedures for riding on and in mine conveyances; the con-
trols in effect for the transportation of miners and ma-
terials; and the use of the mine communication systems,
warning signals, and directional signs,

(4) Introduction to the work environment. The course
shall include a visit and tour of the mine, or portions of the
mine which are representative of the entire mine. A method
of mining utilized at the mine shall be observed and ex-
plained.

33

(5) Mine map; escapeways; emergency evacuation; bar-
ricading. The course shall include a review of the mine
map; the escapeway system; the escape, firefighting, and
emergency evacuation plans in effect at the mine; and the
location of abandoned areas. Also included shall be an
introduction to the methods of barricading and the loca-
tions of the barricading materials, where applicable. The
program of instruction for escapeways and emergency
evacuation plans approved by the Districi Manager shall be
used for this course.

(6) Roof or ground control and ventilation plans. The
course shall include an introduction to and instruction on
the roof or ground control plan in effect at the mine and
procedures for roof and rib or ground control; and an in-
troduction to and instruction on the ventilation plan in
effect at the mine and the procedures for maintaining and
controlling ventilation.

(7) Health. The course shall include instruction on the
purpose of taking dust, noise, and other health measure-
ments, and any health control plan in effect at the mine
shall be explained. The health provisions of the act and
warning labels shall also be explained.

(8) Cleanup; rock dusting. The course shall include
instruction on the purpose of rock dusting and the cleanup
and rock dusting program in effect at the mine, where
applicable.

(9) Hazard recognition. The course shall include the
recognition and avoidance of hazards present in the mine,
particularly any hazards related to explosives where explo-
sives are used or stored at the mine.

(10) Electrical hazards. The course shall include recog-
nition and avoidance of electrical hazards.

(11) First aid. The course shall include instruction in
first aid methods acceptable to MSHA.

34

(12) Mine gases. The course shall include instruction
in the detection and avoidance of hazards associated with
mine gases,

(13) Health and safety aspects of the tasks to which the
new miner will be assigned. The course shall include in-
struction in the health and safety aspects of the tasks to
be assigned, the safe work procedures of such tasks, and the
mandatory health and safety standards pertinent to such
tasks.

(14) Such other courses as may be required by the
Training Center Chief based on circumstances and condi-
tions at the mine.

(c) Methods, including oral, written, or practical de-
monstration, to determine successful completion of the
training shall be included in the training plan. The meth-
ods for determining such completion shall be administered
to the miner before he is assigned work duties.

(d) Upon proof by an operator that a newly employed
miner has received the courses and hours of instruction set
forth in paragraphs (a) and (b) of this section within 12
months preceding initial employment at a mine, such miner
need not repeat the training, but the operator shall give
and the miner shall receive and complete the instruction
and program of training set forth in paragraph (b) of
§ 48.6 (Training of newly employed experienced miners),
and § 48.7 (New task training of miners), if applicable
before commencing work.

§ 48.6 Training of newly employed experienced miners;
minimum courses of instruction.

(a) A newly employed experienced miner shall receive
and complete training in the program of instruction pre-
scribed in this section before such miner is assigned to
work duties.

35

(b) The training program for newly employed experi-
enced miners shall include the following:

(1) Introduction to work environment. The course shall
include a visit and tour of the mine. The methods of min-
ing utilized at the mine shall be observed and explained.

(2) Mandatory health and safety standards. The course
shall include the mandatory health and safety standards
pertinent to the tasks to be assigned.

(3) Authority and responsibility of supervisors and
miners’ representatives. The course shall include a review
and description of the line of authority of supervisors and
miners’ representatives and the responsibilities of such
supervisors and miners’ representatives; and an introduc-
tion to the operator’s rules and the procedures for report-
ing hazards.

(4) Entering and leaving the mine; transportation;
communications, The course shall include instruction in
the procedures in effect for entering and leaving the mine;
the check-in and checkout system in effect at the mine; the
procedures for riding on and in mine conveyances; the con-
trols in effect for the transportation of miners and ma-
terials; and the use of the mine communication systems,
warning signals, and directional signs.

(5) Mine map; escapeways; emergency evacuation; bar-
ricading. The course shall include a review of the mine
map; the escapeway system; the escape, firefighting, and
emergency evacuation plans in effect at the mine; the loca-
tion of abandoned areas; and, where applicable, methods of
barricading and the locations of barricading materials. The
program of instruction for escapeways and emergency
evacuation plans approved by the District Manager shall
be used for this course.

36

(6) Roof or ground control and ventilation plans. The
course shall include an introduction to and instruction on
the roof or ground control plan in effect at the mine and
procedures for roof and rib or ground control; and an in-
troduction to and instruction on the ventilation plan in
effect at the mine and the procedures for maintaining and
controlling ventilation.

(7) Hazard recognition. The course shall include the
recognition and avoidance of hazards present in the mine,
particularly any hazards related to explosives where ex-
plosives are used or stored at the mine.

(8) Such other courses as may be required by the Train-
ing Center Chief based on circumstances and conditions at
the mine.

§ 48.7 Training of miners assigned to a task in which they
have had no previous experience; minimum courses
of instruction.

(a) Miners assigned to new work tasks as mobile equip-
ment operators, drilling machine operators, haulage and
conveyor systems operators, roof and ground control ma-
chine operators, and those in blasting operations shall not
perform new work tasks in these categories until training
prescribed in this paragraph and paragraph (b) of this sec-
tion has been completed. This training shall not be re-
quired for miners who have been trained and who have
demonstrated safe operating procedures for such new work
tasks within 12 months preceding assignment. This train-
ing shall also not be required for miners who have per-
formed the new work tasks and who have demonstrated
safe operating procedures for such new work tasks within
12 months preceding assignment. The training program
shall include the following:

(1) Health and safety aspects and safe operating pro-
cedures for work tasks, equipment, and machinery. The

37

training shall include instruction in the health and safety
aspects and the safe operating procedures related to the
assigned tasks, and shall be given in an on-the-job environ-
ment; and

(2) (i) Supervised practice during nonpreduction. The
training shall include supervised practice in the assigned
tasks, and the performance of work duties at times or
places where production is not the primary objective; on

(ii) Supervised operation during production. The
training shall include, while under direct and immediate
supervision and production is in progress, operation of the
machine or equipment and the performance of work duties.

(3) New or modified machines and equipment. Equip-
ment and machine operators shall be instructed in safe
operating procedures applicable to new or modified ma-
chines or equipment to be installed or put into operation
in the mine, which require new or different operating pro-
cedures.

(4) Such other courses as may be required by the Train-
ing Center Chief based on circumstances and conditions at
the mine.

(b) Miners under paragraph (a) of this section shall
not operate the equipment or machine or engage in blast-
ing operations without direction and immediate supervision
until such miners have demonstrated safe operating pro-
cedures for the equipment or machine or blasting operation
to the operator or the operator’s agent.

(c) Miners assigned a new task not covered in para-
graph (a) of this section shall be instrueted in the safety
and health aspects and safe work procedures of the task,
prior to performing such task.

(d) Any person who controls or direets haulage opera-
tions at a mine shall receive and complete training courses
in safe haulage procedures related to the haulage system,

38

ventilation system, firefighting procedures, and emergency
evacuation procedures in effect at the mine before assign-
ment to such duties.

(e) All training and supervised practice and operation
required by this section shall be given by a qualified trainer,
or a supervisor experienced in the assigned tasks, or other
person experienced in the assigned tasks,

[43 FR 47459, Oct. 13, 1978; 44 FR 1980, Jan. 9, 1979]

§ 48.8 Annual refresher training of miners; minimum
courses of instruction; hours of instruction.

(a) Each miner shall receive a minimum of 8 hours of
annual refresher training as prescribed in this section.

(b) The annual refresher training program for all
miners shall include the following courses of instruction:

(1) Mandatory health and safety standards. The course
shall include mandatory health and safety standard require-
ments which are related to the miner’s tasks.

(2) Transportation controls and communication sys-
tems. The course shall include instruction on the proce-
dures for riding on and in mine conveyances; the controls
in effect for the transportation of miners and materials;
and the use of the mine communication systems, warning
signals, and directional signs.

(3) Barricading. The course shall include a review of
the methods of barricading and locations of barricading
materials, where applicable.

(4) Roof or ground control and ventilation plans. The
course shall include a review of roof or ground control
plans in effect at the mine and the procedures for maintain-
ing and controlling ventilation.

(5) First aid. The course shall include a review of first
aid methods acceptable to MSHA.

39

(6) Electrical hazards. The course shall include recog-
nition and avoidance of electrical hazards.

(7) Prevention of accidents. The course shall include
a review of accidents and causes of accidents, and instruc-
tion in accident prevention in the work environment.

(8) Self-rescue devices and respiratory devices. The
course shall include instruction in the use, care, and mainte-
nance of self-rescue and respiratory devices.

(9) Explosives. The course shall include a review and
instruction on the hazards related to explosives. The only
exception to this course component is when there are no
explosives used or stored on the mine property.

(10) Mine gases. The course shall include instruction
in the detection and avoidance of hazards associated with
mine gases.

(11) Health. The course shall include instruction on
the purpose of taking dust, noise, and other health meas-
urements and any health control plan in effect at the mine
shall be explained. The health provisions of the Act and
warning labels shall also be explained.

(12) Such other courses as may be required by the
Training Center Chief based on circumstances and condi-
tions at the mine.

(c) All experienced miners already employed at a mine
on the effective date of the Act (March 9, 1978) shall re-
ceive refresher training, as prescribed in this section and
in accordance with the approved plan, to begin not more
than 90 days after the date of approval of the training
program required by this Subpart A.

(d) Where annual refresher training is conducted
periodically, such sessions shall not be less than 30 min-
utes of actual instruction time and the miners shall be noti-
fied that the session is part of annual refresher training.

40
§ 48.9 Records of training.

(a) Upon a miner’s completion of each MSHA approved
training program, the operator shall record and certify on
MSHA form 5000-23 that the miner has received the speci-
fied training. A copy of the training certificate shall be
given to the miner at the completion of the training. The
training certificates for each miner shall be available at the
minesite for inspection by MSHA and for examination by
the miners, the miner's representative, and State inspection
agencies. When a miner leaves the operator's employ, the
miner shall be entitled to a copy of his training certificates,

(b) False certification that training was given shall
be punishable under section 110(a) and (f) of the Act.

(c) Copies of training certificates for currently em-
ployed miners shall be kept at the minesite for 2 years, or
for 60 days after termination of employment.

§ 48.10 Compensation for training.

(a) Training shall be conducted during normal working
hours; miners attending such training shall receive the rate
of pay as provided in § 48.2(d) (Definition of normal work-
ing hours) of this Subpart A.

(b) If such training shall be given at a location other
than the normal place of work, miners shall be compen-
sated for the additional cost, such as mileage, meals, and
lodging, they may incur in attending such training sessions,

§ 48.11 Hazard training.

(a) Operators shall provide to those miners, as defined
in § 48.2(a)(2) (Definition of miner) of this Subpart A, a
training program before such miners commence their work
duties. This training program shall include the following
instruction, which is applicable to the duties of such miners:

41

(1) Hazard recognition and avoidance;

(2) Emergency and evacuation procedures;

(3) Health and safety standards, safety rules, and safe
working procedures;

(4) Self-rescue and respiratory devices; and

(5) Such other instruction as may be required by the
Chief of the Training Center based on circumstances and
conditions at the mine,

(b) Miners shall receive the instruction required by this
section at least once every 12 months.

(c) The training program required by this section shall
he submitted with the training plan required by § 48.8(a)
(Training plans; Submission and approval) of this Subpart
A and shall include a statement on the methods of instrue-
tion to be used,

(d) In accordance with § 48.9 (Records of traini:@) of
this Subpart A, the operator shall maintain and make avail-
able for inspection certificates that miners have received
the hazard training required by this section.

(e) Miners subject to hazard training shall be accom-
panied at all times while underground by an experienced
miner, as defined in § 48.2(b) (Definition of miner) of this
Subpart A,

§ 48.12 Appeals procedures,

The operator, miner, and miners’ representative shall
have the right of appeal from a decision of the Training
Center Chief.

(a) In the event an operator, miner, or miners’ repre-
sentative decides to appeal a decision by a Training Center
Chief, such an appeal shall be submitted, in writing, to the
Director of Education and Training, MSHA, 4015 Wilson
Boulevard, Arlington, Va, 22203, within 30 days of notifi-
cation of the Chief of the Training Center’s decision.

42

(b) The Director of Education and Training may re-
quire additional information from the operator, the miners,
or their representatives, and the Chief of the Training
Center, if the Director determines such information is
necessary,

(c) The Director of Education and Training shall
render a decision on the appeal within 30 days after re-
ceipt of the appeal.

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385011_0241%3A1. Public record. Not legal advice.
