# Appendix — Children's Legal Foundation, Inc. v. Action for Children's Television

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385010_2113%3A2

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Appendix
- **Published:** January 1, 1992
- **Citation:** 503 U.S. 913

## Text

-~ SS FILED
Sat HOV 2.6 198i
No.
OFFICE OF THE cum |
IN THE

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
October Term 1991

CHILDREN'S LEGAL FOUNDATION, INC. AND
AMERICAN FAMILY ASSOCIATION, INC.,
PETITIONERS,

FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION AND
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
V.

ACTION FOR CHILDREN'S TELEVISION, et al.,.
RESPONDENTS

APPENDIX TO PETITION FOR A WRIT OF
CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES
COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE DISTRICT
OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT

JAMES P. MUELLER
Children's Legal Foundation, Inc.
2845 East Camelback Road
Suite 740

Phoenix, Arizona 85016

(602) 381-1322

(Counsel of Record)

PEGGY M. HODGES
American Family Assocition, Inc.
107 Parkgate Drive

Post Office Drawer 2440

Tupelo, Mississippi 38803
(601) 844-5036

November 26, 1991

No.

IN THE
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
October Term 199]

CHILDREN'S LEGAL FOUNDATION, INC. AND
AMERICAN FAMILY ASSOCIATION, INC.,
PETITIONERS,

FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION AND
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
V.

ACTION FOR CHILDREN'S TELEVISION, et al...
RESPONDENTS

APPENDIX TO PETITION FOR A WRIT OF
CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES
COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE DISTRICT
OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT

JAMES P. MUELLER
Children’s Legal Foundation, Inc.
2845 East Camelback Road
Suite 740

Phoenix. Arizona 85016

(602) 381-1322

(Counsel of Record)

PEGGY M. HODGES
American Family Assocition, Inc.
107 Parkgate Drive

Post Office Drawer 2440

Tupelo, Mississippi 38803
(601) 844-5036

November 26, 199]

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Relevant statutory provision ..........--++ee ee eee A |
Decision of the United States Court of Appeals....... A 2
Denial of Suggestions for Rehearing En Banc........ A 15

Report and Order of the Federal Communications
Commission . ... 0.6255 60 c eee see eee ee A 17

Comments of American Family Association and
Children’s Legal Foundation, et al.............-.--4 A 90

Reply Comments of American Family Association
and Children’s Legal Foundation, etal............. A139

Comments of Morality in Media..........-.------ A183

Reply Comments of Morality in Media............ A222

Al

No.

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
October Term 1991

CHILDREN’S LEGAL FOUNDATION, INC. AND
AMERICAN FAMILY ASSOCIATION, INC.,
PETITIONERS,

FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION AND
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

ACTION FOR CHILDREN’S TELEVISION, et al.,
RESPONDENTS

APPENDIX
RELEVANT STATUTORY PROVISION
§ 1464. Broadcasting Obscene Language
Whoever utters any obscene, indecent, or profane language

by means of radio communication shall be fined not more
than $10,000 or imprisoned not more than two years, or both.

A2

ACTION FOR CHILDREN'S TELEVISION, et al..
Petitioners,
V.

FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION and
United States of America,
Respondents,

Children’s Legal Foundation, et
al., Intervenors.

No. 88-1916.

United States Court of Appeals,
District of Columbia Circuit.

Argued Jan. 28, 1991.
Decided May 17, 1991.

On petition for review of an order of the Federal
Communications Commission (FCC), the Court of Appeals,
Mikva, Chief Judge, held that FCC's order, promulgated at
direction of Congress, barring all radio and television broad-
casts of “indecent” material violated First Amendment.
Petition granted; order vacated; remanded.

Constitutional Law ~90.4(3)

Telecommunications ~383

Federal Communications Commission's (FCC's) order,
promulgated at direction of Congress, barring all radio and
television broadcasts of “indecent” material violated First
Amendment; there must be safe harbor periods during which
indecent material may be broadcast. 1& U.S.C.A. § 1464;
U.S.C.A. Const.Amend. 1.

A3

Petition for Review of an Order of the Federal Communica-
tions Commission.

Timothy B. Dyk, for petitioner and for Capital Cities/ABC,
Inc., and CBS, Inc., with whom Henry Geller and Donna
Lampert, for Action for Children’s Television, John A.
Powell and C. Edwin Baker, for American Civ. Liberties
Union, James Popham, for Ass’n of Independent Television
Stations, Inc., Steven A. Lerman, Dennis P. Corbett, and
Laura B. Humphries, for Infinity Broadcasting Corp., Fritz E.
Attaway, for Motion Picture Ass'n of America, Inc., Henry
L. Baumann and Stephen A. Bookshester, for Nat. Ass’n of
Broadcasters, Howard Monderer, for Nat. Broadcasting Co.,
Inc., Theodore A. Miles and Karen Christensen, for Nat.
Public Radio, Andrew Jay Schwartzman and Jan G. Levine,
for People for the American Way, Jonathan D. Blake, for
Post-Newsweek Stations, Inc., Paula A. Jameson and Nancy
H. Hendry, for Public Broadcasting Service, J. Laurent
Scharff, for Radio-Television News Directors Ass'n, Jane E.
Kirtley, for The Reporters Committee for Freedom of the
Press, and Bruce W. Sanford, for Soc. of Professional Jour-
nalists, were on the joint brief, for petitioners Action for
Children’s Television, et al. Molly Pauker, for Nat. Broad-
casting Co., Inc., Lois Schiffer, for Nat. Public Radio, Martin
Wald and Janet E. Milne, for Post- Newsweek Stations, Inc.,
and James M. Smith, for Radio-Television News Directors
Ass'n, also entered appearances for petitioners.

Eric M. Lieberman, with whom John Crigler, William J.
Byrnes, and Edward de Grazia, were on the brief, for peti-
tioner The Pacifica Foundation and intervenors PEN Ameri-
can Center, Allen Ginsberg, et al.

Robert L. Pettit, Gen. Counsel, F.C.C., with whom Daniel M.
Armstrong, Associate Gen. Counsel, Jane E. Mago, Sue Ann

A4

Preskill, and Laurence N. Bourne, Counsel, F.C.C., and
Barbara L. Herwig and Jacob M. Lewis, Attys., Dept. of
Justice, were on the brief, for respondents.

James P. Mueller, for Children’s Legal Foundation and
American Family Ass’n, Peggy M. Coleman, for American
Family Ass'n and Paul J. McGeady, for Morality in Media,
Inc., were on the joint brief, for intervenors and amicus
curiae.

Before MIKVA, Chief Judge, and EDWARDS and THO-
MAS, Circuit Judges.

Opinion for the Court filed by Chief Judge MIKVA.
MIKVA, Chief Judge:

This case presents constitutional challenges to a
Federal Communications Commission (“FCC” or “the
Commission’) order, promulgated at the direction of Con-
yress, barring all radio and television broadcasts of “inde-
cent” material. We believe that the disposition of this case is
governed by our prior decision in Action for Children’s
Television v. Federal Communications Commission, 852
F.2d 1332 (D.C.Cir. 1988), in which we rejected vagueness
and overbreadth challenges to the Commission's definition of
indecency but found that the Commission’s curtailment of
“safe harbor” broadcast periods impermissibly intruded on
constitutionally protected expression interests. Accordingly,
We grant the petition tor review.

I
The particulars of this case are best understood within
the history of government efforts to regulate the broadcast of
indecent material. Since 1927, federal law has prohibited the
broadcast of “any obscene, indecent, or profane language.”

AS

18 U.S.C. § 1464 (1988): see also Radio Act of 1927, § 29,
44 Stat. 1172 (1927) (original prohibition against utterance of
“obscene, indecent, or profane language”). In 1975, the
Commission essayed to “authoritatively contrue; }” ihe term
“indecent” and to distinguish it from the modern definition of
obscenity, as formulated by the Supreme Court in Miller v.
California, 413 U.S. 15, 93 S.Ct. 2607, 37 L.Ed.2d 419
(1973). See Pacifica Found., 56 F.C.C.2d 94, 97 (1975). The
Commission defined indecency as “language that describes,
in terms patently offensive as measured by contemporary
community standards for the broadcast medium, sexual or
excretory activities and organs,” and emphasized that its
primary regulatory interest lay in protecting children froin
“language which most parents regard as inappropriate for
them to hear.” /d. at 98. The Supreme Court uphcid the
Commission’s finding that a radio station’s afternoon broad-
cast of a George Carlin comedy monologue entitled “Filthy
Words” was indecent under section 1464. See Federal Com-
munications Comm'n v. Pacifica Found., 438 U.S. 726, 738-
41, 98 S.Ct. 3026, 3034-36, 57 L.Ed.2d 1073 (1978).

The Commission, bv its own account, subsequently
“took a very limited approach to enforcing the prohibition
against indecent broadcasts.” /n re Infinity Broadcasting
Corp. of Pennsylvania, 3 FCC Rcd 930 (1987) [hereinafter
Reconsideration Order ]. The Commission essentially re-
stricted its enforcement efforts to material broadcast before
10:00 p.m. that involved “the repeated use, for shock value,
of words similar or identical to those satirized in the Carlin
‘Filthy Words’ monologue.” /d at 930. Between 1975 and
1987, no broadcasts at all were found actionable under this
narrow prohibition. See id.

By 1987, however, the Commission had concluded
that “the highly restrictive enforcement standard employed

A6

after the 1975 Pacifica decision was unduly narrow as a
matter of law and inconsistent with our enforcement respon-
sibilities under Section 1464.” /d. Returning to the generic
definition of indecency it had developed in Pacifica, the
Commission issued three rulings declaring material that
would not have violated the “Filthy Words” test to be inde-
cent. See Pacifica Found, 2 FCC Red 2698 (1987); The
Regents of the Univ. of California, 2 FCC Red 2703 (1987);
infinity Broadcasting Corp. of Pennsyl7 ania, 2 FCC Red
2705 (1987); see also Neu Indecency Enforcement Standards
to be Applied to All Broadcast and Amateur Radio Licensees,
2 FCC Red 2726 (1987) (summarizing Commission policies).
Significantly, two of the cited broadcasts had aired after
10:00 p.m., the time period pre~iously identified by the
Commission as a “safe harbor” during which the risk of
children in the broadcast audience was thought to be mini-
mal. See id. at 2726. On reconsideration, the Commission
affirmed its warnings with respect to the three broadcasts and
noted, in response to requests for more specific rules regard-
ing time channeling, that 12:00 midnight was its “current
thinking” as to when the risk of children in the broadcast
audience could reasonably be thought minimized. See Recon-
sideration Order, 3 FCC Rcd at 934, 937 n. 47.

Reviewing the Commission's order, we first rejected peti-
tioners’ vagueness and overbreadth challenges to the
Commission's generic definition of indecency. See Action for
Children’s Telellsion v. FCC, 852 F.2d 1332, 1338-40
(D.C.Cir.1988) [hereinafter A C7 / ]. However, we vacated
the Commission’s rulings that the two post-10:00 p.m.
broadcasts were indecent. In addition to calling the
Commission's findings “more ritual than real” and its under-
lying evidence “insubstantial,” /d. at 1341-42, we opined that
a “reasonable safe harbor rule” was constituuionally man-
dated. /d. at 1343 n. 18. Accordingly, we instructed the
Commission to determine on remand, “after a full and fair

A7

hearing, ... the times at which indecent material may be
broadcast.” Jd. at 1344.

Before the Commission could carry out this court’s
mandate, Congress intervened. On October 1, 1988, two
months after the ACT / decision issued, the President signed
into law a 1989 appropriations bill containing the following
rider:

By January 31, 1989, the Federal Communi-

cations Commission shall promulgate regula-

tions in accordance with section 1464, title 18,

United States Code, to enforce the provisions

of such section on a 24 hour per day basis.

Pub.L.No. 100-459, § 608, 102 Stat. 2228 (1988) (emphasis
added). Concluding that “[t}]he directive of the appropriations
language affords us no discretion,” the Commission promul-
gated a new rule pursuant to section 1464 prohibiting al!
broadcasts of indecent materials. See Enforcement of Prohi-
bitions Against Broadcast Obscenity and Indecency in 18
U.S.C. § 1464, 4 FCC Rcd 457 (1988) [hereinafter Order /,
codified at 47 CFR § 73.3999 (1990) (restrictions on the
transmission of obscene or indecent language). The Commis-
sion also “abandon{ed its] plans to initiate a proceeding in
response to the concerns raised by” the ACT / panel. Order, 4
FCC Rcd at 457.

A panel of this court granted petitioners’ motion to
Stay enforcement of the ban pending judicial review. See
Action for Children’s Television v. FCC, No. 88-1916
(D.C.Cir. Jan. 23, 1989). Six months later, while briefing on
the validity of the Commission’s order was underway 1n this
court, the Supreme Court issued an opinion finding a blanket
ban on indecent commercial telephone message services
unconstitutional. Sable Communications of Cal., Inc. v. FCC,

A&
492 U.S. 115, 109 S.Ct. 2829, 106 L.Ed.2d 93 (1989). Be-
lieving that Sable left open the possibility that indecent
broadcasts may be proscribed if the Commission could prove
that no less restrictive measure would effectuate the
government’s compelling interests, the Commission sought
and obtained a remand from this court in order to assemble
ihe relevant data supporting a total ban. Action for Children’s
Television v. FCC, No. 88-1916 (D.C.Cir. Sept. 13, 1989)
(remanding record to the FCC for a “full and fair hearing on
the issue of the propriety of indecent broadcasting’).

The Commission subsequently solicited public com-
ments on the validity of a total ban on broadcast indecency.
See Enforcement of Prohibitions Against Broadcast Inde-
cency in 18 U.S.C. § 1464, 4 FCC Red 8358 (1989). After
receiving and reviewing the comments, the Commission
issued a comprehensive report concluding that “a 24-hour
prohibition on indecent broadcasts comports with the consti-
tutional standard the Supreme Court enunciated in Sable for
the regulation of constitutionally protected speech.” Enforce-
ment of Prohibitions Against Broadcast Indecency in 18
U.S.C. § 1464, 5 FCC Red 5297, 5297 (1990). Finding a
“reasonable risk that significant numbers of children ages 17
and under listen to radio and view television at all times”
without “active” parental supervision, the Commission
concluded that no alternative to a total ban would effectuate
the government's compelling interest in protecting children
from broadcast indecency. See id. at 5297, 5306. Current
proceedings before this court followed issuance of the
Commission's report.

I]

Petitioners, an amalgam of broadcasters, industry
associauons, and public interest groups, present several
consututional challenges to the Commission's acbon. First,
they claim (some more spiritedly than others) that the

errr ene ee

AY
Commission’s definition of indecency is unconstitutionally
vague and overbroad. Second, they contend that a total ban
on broadcast indecency cannot withstand constitutional
scrutiny. We address petitioners’ contentions in turn.
A. Vagueness and Overbread th Challenges

Petitioners contend that the Commission’s definition
of indecency — “language or material that, in context, depicts
or describes, in terms patently offensive as measured by
contemporary community standards for the broadcast me-
dium, sexual or excretory activities or organs,” Order, 4 FCC
Rcd at 457 —is unconstitutionally vague. A statute or regula-
tion is void for vagueness if it ‘“‘either forbids or requires the
doing of an act in terms so vague that [persons] of common
intelligence must necessarily guess at its meaning and differ
as to its application.’ “ Roberts v. United States Jaycees, 468
U.S. 609, 629, 104 S.Ct. 3244, 3256, 82 L.Ed.2d 462 (1984)
(quoting Connally v. General Construction Co., 269 U.S.
385, 391, 46 S.Ct. 126, 127, 70 L.Ed. 322 (1926)).

We have already considered and rejected a vagueness
challenge to the Commission's definition of indecency. In
ACT 1, we noted that the Supreme Court, entertaining a
similar challenge in Pacihca, had quoted various elements of
the definition with approval and had ultimately affirmed the
Commission's application of the definition to the broadcast
under review. See ACT /, 852 F.2d at 1338-39. In our view,
the Supreme Court’s decision in Pacihca dispelled any
vagueness concerns attending the definition. See id. at 1339
(“{I]f acceptance of the FCC’s generic definition of ‘inde-
cent’ as capable of surviving a vagueness challenge is not
implicit in Pacihca, we have misunderstood Higher Authority
and welcome correction.”); cf. Information Providers’ Coallt-
tion v. FCC, 928 F.2d 866, 874, (9th Cir.1991) (rejecting
vagueness Challenge to similar definition of indecency in

Al0

dial-a-porn context). Our holding in ACT! precludes us from
now finding the Commission's generic definition of inde-
cency to be unconsututionally vague.

Some of the petitioners raise the additional claim that
the definition of indecency is unconstitutionally overbroad.
They contend that, because the Commission fails to recog-
nize “serious merit” as an absolute defense to a charge of
indecency, the definition sweeps even constitutionally pro-
tected expression within its ambit. See Houston v. Hill, 482
U.S. 451, 459 107 S.Ct. 2502, 2508, 96 L.Ed.2d 398 (1987)
(noting that statutes “that make unlawful a substantial
umount of constituuionally protected conduct may be held
facially invalid even if they also have legitimate applica-
tion"),

We rejected an identical o- erbreadth challenge in
ACT 1. ‘ We noted that indecent material qualifies for First
Amendment protection regardless of merit, but that even
material with “significant social value” may leave a strong
negative impact on children. See ACT J, 852 F.2d at 1340.
We thus found the Commission’s method of identifying
material suitable for broadcast only during the late night, safe
harbor hours— whereby merit is treated asa “relevant factor
in determining whether material is patently offensive” but
“does not render such material per se not indecent” — to be
permissible. See id. at 1339-40. Given that our decision today
reaffirms the need for safe harbor periods during which
indecent material may be broadcast and invalidates the
Commission's attempt to ban such broadcasts altogether, we
have no reason to revisit ACT /’s conclusion that the
Commission’s generic definition of indecency comports with
constitutional overbreadth requirements.

SSS

All
B. Challenge to Total Ban on Broadcast Ind ecency

Petitioners’ core challenge is to the constitutional
validity of a total ban on the broadcast of indecent material.
Their contentions are two-fold: First, they claim that, under
Supreme Court and circuit precedent, the government may
not completely suppress indecent speech in any medium.
Second, they argue that even if a total ban could theoretically ~
be justified, the Commission's action here fails to satisfy the
Strict scrutiny standard recently reaffirmed by the Supreme
Court in Sable.

We agree with petitioners that circuit precedent
compels our rejection today of a total ban on the broadcast of
indecent material. In ACT /, we stated that:

Broadcast material that 1s indecent but not
obscene is protected by the first amendment;
the FCC may regulate such material only with
due respect for the high walue our Constitution
places on freedom and choice in what the
people say and hear.

852 F.2d at 1344. Addressing the scope of permissible

regulation, we explained that:
Content-based restrictions ordinarily “may be
sustained only if the government can show
that the regulation ts a precisely drawn means
of serving a compelling state interest.” [cita-
tion omitted] The Supreme Court has recog-
nized a government's interest in “safeguarding
the physical and psychological well-being of a
minor’ as “compelling.” [citations omitted |
But that interest, in the context of speech
control, may be served only by caretully-

tailored regulation.
Id. at 1343 n. 18.

We found that the Commission’s elimination of the
post-10:00 p.m. “safe-harbor” period failed to satisfy these
constitutional standards. Specifically, we concluded that:

[T]he precision necessary to allow scope for
the first amendment shielded freedom and
choice of broadcasters and their audiences
cannot be accomplished. we believe, unless
the FCC adopts a reasonable safe harbor rule.

Id. We therefore instructed the Commission, on remand, to
“afford broadcasters ciear notice of reasonably determined
times at which indecent material safely may be aired.” /d. at
1343.

Our holding in ACT | that the Commission must
identify some reasonable period of time during which inde-
cent material may be broadcast necessarily means that the
Commission may not ban such broadcasts entirely. The fact
that Congress itself mandated the total ban on broadcast
indecency does not alter our view that, under ACT/, such a
prohibition cannot withstand constitutional scrutiny. While
“we do not ignore” Congress’ apparent belief that a total ban
on broadcast indecency is constitutional, it is ultimately the
judiciary’s task, particularly in the First Amendment context,
to decide whether Congress has violated the Constitution. See
Sable, 109 S.Ct. at 2838. Moreover, we note that introduction
of the appropriations rider preceded issuance of our decision
in ACT /; thus, the relevant congressional debate occurred
without the benefit of our constitutional holding in that case.
See 134 CONG. REC. $9911-S9915 (daily ed. July 26,

Al3
1988).

Nothing else in the intervening thirtyfour months has
reduced the precedential force of ACT J. Indeed, the Su-
preme Court’s decision in Sable. striking down a total ban on
indecent commercial telephone messages, affirmed the
protected status of indecent speech and reite. ated the strict
constitutional standard that government efforts to regulate the
content of speech must satisfy. See Sable, 109 S.Ct. at 2836
(noting that “[s]exual expression which is indecent but not
obscene is protected by the First Amendment,” and stating
that the government may “regulate the content of constitu-
tionally protected speech in order to promote a compelling
interest if it chooses the least restrictive means to further the
articulated interest’). See also Consolidated Edison Co. v.
Public Serv. Comm'n, 447 U.S. 530, 540, 100 S.Ct. 2326,
2334, 65 L.Ed.2d 319 (1980). Even the Commission, prior to
congressional enactment of the appropriations rider, shared
this view. See Reconsideration Order, 3 FCC Red at 931
(dismissing suggestion that section 1464 should be read to
totally prohibit the broadcast of indecent material, as such a
reading would “run afoul of [the] constitutional premise” that
the Commission “may only do that which is necessary to
restrict children’s access to indecent broadcasts” and “may
not go further so as to preclude access by adults who are
interested in seeing or hearing such material”).

Thus, neither the Commission’s action prohibiting the
broadcast of indecent material, nor the congressional man-
date that prompted it, can pass constitutional muster under
the law of this circuit.

I.
We appreciate the Commission's constraints in
responding to the appropriations rider. It would be unseemly

a a

Al4

for a regulatory agency to throw down the gauntlet, even a
gauntlet grounded on the Constitution, to Congress. But just
as the FCC may not ignore the dictates of the legislative
branch, neither may the judiciary ignore its independent duty
to check the constitutional excesses of Congress. We hold
that Congress’ action here cannot preclude the Commission
trom creating a safe harbor exception to its regulation of
indecent broadcasts.

Our decision today effectively returns the Commis-
sion to the position it briefly occupied after ACT / and prior
to congressional adoption of the appropriations rider. The
Commission should resume its “plans to initiate a procecding
in response to the concerns raised” in ACT J, which it
“abandon|ed]|” following Congress’ mandate. Order, 4 FCC
Red at 457. We direct the Commission, in “redetermin| ing],
after a full and fair hearing, ... the times at which indecent
material may be broadcast,” to carefully review and address
the specific concerns we raised in ACT / : among them, the
appropriate definitions of “children” and “reasonable risk”
for channeling purposes, the paucity of stauion- or program
specific audience data expressed as a percentage of the
relevant age group population, and the scope of the
government's interest in regulating indecent broadcasts. See
ACT 1, 852 F.2d at 1341-44.

For the foregoing reasons, the petition for review 1s
granted, the order under review is vacated, and the case 1s
remanded for further proceedings not inconsistent with this

opinion.

[tis so ordered.

7

AlS

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUTI

No. 88-1916 September Term, 1990)

Action for Children’s Television, et al

Petitioners

Federal Communications (Commiss

ind United States of Amer!

BEFORE: Mikva, Chief Judge; Wald, Edwards, Ruth B

Ginsburg. Silberman isu kley Willian [) Fd. f

The Suggestions For Rehearing f:n B
federal Communications Comm
the responses thereto have be
No member of the Court request

consideration of the foregoing 1

ORDERED, by the ¢

' r {,er
tions are Genie:

Al6

Per Curiam
FOR THE COURT:
CONSTANCE L. DUPRE, CLERK

BY:

Robert A. Bonner
Deputy Clerk

Circuit Judge Ruth B. Ginsburg did not participate in this
matter.

Ee

g

Al7

Before the
FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20554

In the Matter of

Enforcement of Prohibitions )
) MM Docket No. 89-494

Against Broadcast Indecency in _ )
'8 U.S.C. § 1464 )

REPORT OF THE COMMISSION
(Proceeding Terminated)

Adopted: July 12, 1990; Released: August 6, 1990

By the Commission: Commissioner Quello concurring and

issuing a Statement.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Subject Paragraph
I. Introduction : |
I]. Background 4
III. Discussion 10
A. Constitutional Standard 1]
B. Governmental! Interest 14
C. Operative Definitions 24
1. Definition of Indecency 24
2. Definition of Children 2&

Al8
D. Narrowly Tailored Means
1. Accessibility —to Children
2. Children’s Listening and Viewing Habits
a. Radio
b. Television
c. Supervision
d. Conclusions
E. Alternatives to 24-Hour Prohibition
. Time Channeling
. Ratings and Warning Devices
. Broadcast Technologies
F. Non-Broadcast Alternative Programming
Sources
C. Entorcement

2 Woo

IV. Conclusion

V. Ordering Clauses

Al9
I. INTRODUCTION

1. In this report we respond to a remand of the record
granted by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of
Columbia Circuit in Action for Children’s Television v. FCC
(ACT II).1/ In its remand order, the court directed the
Commission to conduct a “full and fair hearing” on the
constitutionality of a statutory provision2/ which requires the
Commission to prohibit the broadcast of indecent material 24
hours a day.3/ The court granted the remand in light of the
Supreme Court’s recent decision in Sable Communications of
California, Inc. v. FCC (Sable),4/ which held that
government may regulate indecent speech if the regulation
promotes a “compelling government interest and 1s
“narrowly tailored” to serve that interest. The Commission
accordingly issued a Notice of Inquiry (NOJ)S5/ to solicit

1 No. 88-1916 (D.C. Cir. Sept. 13. 1989)

2 The Commission's 1989 appropriations law states: “By January 31,
1989, the Federal Communications Commission shall promulgate
regulations in accordance with section 1464, title 18, United States Code,
to enforce the provisions of such section on a 24 hour per day basis.”
Making Appropriations for the Departments of Commerce, Justice, and
State, the Judiciary, and Related Agencies for the Fiscal Year Ending
September 30, 1989, and for Other Purposes. Pub. L. No.-100-459,§ 608,
102 Stat.-2186, 2228 1988).

3 Enforcement of the FCC regulation promulgating the 24-hour
prohibition, codified at 47 C.F.R. § 73.3999 (1989), was stayed pending
judicial review by the court in ACT II.

4 1098S. Ct. 2829 (1989).

S 4FCC Rcd 8358 (1989)

A20
public comment on issues relevant to analyzing the validity
of the 24-hour indecent broadcasting prohibition in view of
the Sable decision.6/

2. After careful consideration of the responses to our
inquiry, we conclude that a 24-hour prohibition on indecent
broadcasts comports with the constitutional standard the
Supreme Court enunciated in Sable for the regulation of
constitutionally protected speech. First, the Supreme Court
has expressly recognized the government's compelling
interest in protecting children from broadcast indecency, both
to facilitate parental supervision and to promote the well-
being of children who may be exposed to indecent material.
Moreover, the narrowness with which courts have interpreted
“obscenity” has commensurably broadened the range of
patently offensive material that could be deemed “indecent”
if broadcast, rendering the government interest 1n protecting
children even more compelling. Second, the record in this
proceeding reveals that no alternative to a 24-hour
prohibition on indecent broadcasts would effectively serve
this government interest. The best available evidence
indicates that there is a reasonable risk that significant
numbers of children ages 17 and under listen to radio and
View television at all times of day and night. Neither time
channeling nor ratings and warning devices permit effective

© We received over 92.500 formal and informal responses to our NOI
Almost 88,000 informal letters supported a 24-hour prohibition. while
approximately 4.500 letters opposed it. Formal commenters are listed in
Appendix A, and the informal comments have been placed in the docket
tile. American Family Association et al. (AFA) filed its reply comments
ine day late. In the interest of assembling a full and complete record. and
the lack of prejudice resulting to any party, we wall accept those

Comments

A2l
parental control over these activities, and technologies that
may permit control are not currently available. On the other
hand, indecent material similar to that broadcast is readily
available on other media over which parents can exercise
control. Accordingly, we conclude that the compelling
government interest in protecting children from indecent
broadcasts would not be promoted effectively by any means
more narrowly tailored than a 24-hour prohibition.

3. We recognize, however, that there may be
instances in which children are not in the broadcast audience
al a given time of day in a given market. We theretore have
decided to modify our enforcement procedures to permit
stations accused of airing indecent materia! to demonstrate
that children in fact are not present in the broadcast audience
in their market at the time the alleged indecent program was
aired. We believe that, as thus enforced, the 24-hour
prohibition against broadcast indecency clearly meets the
narrowly tailored criteria applied by the Supreme Court in
Sable.

Il. BACKGROUND

4. This proceeding addresses Section 1464 of the
Criminal Code, 18 U.S C. § 1464 (1988), first enacted by the
Radio Act of 1927, reenacted by the Communications Act ot
1934, and later codified in the Criminal Code. Throughout-
this period-of more-than 60 years, Section 1464 and Its
identical predecessor provisions have prohibited the
broadcast of indecent language. Since 1934, the Commission
has been authorized by the Communications Act to entorce
Section 1464's provisions by, among other things, assessing

forfeitures for its violation.7/

5. In 1978, the Supreme Court affirmed the
Commission’s enforcement of Section 1464’s prohibition on
indecent broadcasting, including the Commission’s definition
of indecent language.8 F.C.C. v. Pacifica Foundation
(Pacifica), 438 U.S. 726 (1978); See also, Action for
Children’s Television v. F.C.C., 852 F.2d 1332, 1339 (D.C.
Cir. 1988) (ACT 1). In Pacifica, the Court also reaff irmed its
holding in Ginsberg v. New York 9/“that the government’s
interest in the ‘ well-being of its youth’ and in supporting
‘parents’ claim to authority in their own household’ justified
regulation of otherwise protected expression.” The Court
found that these concerns, along with the broadcast media’s
uniquely pervasive presence and unique access to
children )justified special treatment of the broadcast of
indecent material. Id. at 748-749.

6. In ACT I, the D.C. Circuit Court affirmed the
Commission’s action in one case involving the daytime

7 See 47 U.S.C. § 312(4)(6) and (b). S03 (b)(1)(D) (1988).

S The Commission ‘s detinition of indecent language remains “language
that describes in terms-patently offensive as measured by contemporary
community standards for the broadcast medium, sexual or excretory
activities or organs.” Pacifica Foundation, 56 FCC 2d 94, at 9&. 100
(1975). In our Reconsideration Order we explained that we separately
consider the nature of the material involved and the time of broadcast
because — the me of broadcast Is pertinent to whether the broadcast 1s
actionable, rather than to whether it 1s indecent. See 3 FCC Red 930, 936
n.6 (1987); ACT I] at 1338 n.8.

Y 390 U.S. 629 ( 1968). In Ginsberg, the Court upheld a state statute
that prohibited the sale to minors (17 and under) of sexual material
deemed by the legislature to be obscene as to children

A23
broadcast of indecent material, but remanded for further
explanation two cther cases involving broadcasts aired after
10 p.m. In the two cases remanded, the court found that the
Commission had not adequately justified its narrowing the
“safe harbor” during which indecent material could be
broadcast from the hours of 10 p.m. - 6 a.m. to midnight 6
a.m. The court also rejected the Commission’s suggestion
that channeling decisions could be made on a case-by-case
basis, finding that such an approach could have a chilling
effect on broadcasters’ exercise of their First Amendment
rights . Thus, the court directed the Commission to afford
broadcasters clear notice of reasonably determined times at
which indecent material safely may be aired.

7. Shortly after the ACT I decision, Congress directed
the Commission to enforce the broadcast indecency
provisions of Section 1464 on a 24-hour basis. 10)

response, the Commission promulgated the rule which now \
at issue in this case.11/ A number of petitioners challeng
the rule, and on January 23, 1989, the D.C. Circuit in A

stayed its implementation pending judicial review

8. Before briefing and oral argument had occurred on
the merits of the 24-hour prohibition, the Supreme Court, in
its Sable decision, addressed the extent to which the
government may regulate indecent telephone messages. After
noting that indecent speech is protected by the First
Amendment, the Supreme Court neverthe!*ss affirmed that

10 Seen. 2. supra

11 47 CFR § 73.3999 ( 1989) . See Order in Enforcement of

Prohibitions Against Broadcasting Obscenity and Indecency in 18 J =
1464, 4 FCC Red 457 (1988)

a a areca areca thar ricer race rie

A24
“[t]he government may, however, regulate the content of
constitutionally protected speech in order to promote a
compelling interest if it chooses the least restrictive means to
further the articulated interest.” Sable, 109 S. Ct. at 2836.
Restating the point later in its opinion, the Court described
the relevant constitutional standard as requiring that the
means chosen by the government be “carefully tailored” or
“narrowly tailored” to achieve the regulatory ends. Id. at
2839.

Y. The Supreme Court in Sable distinguished the
telephone medium from the broadcast medium, noting that
“unlike an unexpected outburst on a radio broadcast, the
message received by one who places a call to a dial-a-porn
service IS NOL SO Invasive Or surprising that it prevents an
unwilling listener from avoiding exposure to it.” 109 S. Ct. at
2537. Also, in a concurring opinion, Justice Scalia suggested
that indecent broadcasts could be prohibited if data
demonstrate “the infeasibility of alternate means to provide . .

adequate protection of minors.” Id. at 2840 (Scalia, J..

concurring).
Il]. DISCUSSION

10. As noted above, based on the record in this
proceeding and the Court’s decision in Sable, we believe that
the Commission's enforcement of a 24-hour prohibition on
indecent broadcast programming comports with the First
\mendment. Using the “compelling interest/narrowly
tailored” standard set forth in Sable, we conclude that a 24-
hour prohibition is the most narrowly tailored means of
effectively promoung the government s compelling interest -
In protecting-children from broadcast indecency because
there is a reasonable risk that a significant number of children

rein the broadcast audience at all times of day and night. In

A25
addition, we find that: (1) “children” are appropriately defined
as minors 17 and under; (2) the government has a compelling

interest in regulating children’s access to indecent broadcast
material, as the courts and Congress consistently have found;
(3) our definition of indecency Is not vague or overbroad and
in fact, repeatedly has been upheld by the courts; (4) other
alternatives for protecting children, such as ratings, warning
devices, or lock-out mechanisms would be ineffective; (5)
because the risk of exposure to children exists even in the late
evening and early morning hours, a time channeling approach
would not protect children from indecent broadcast materials;
and (6) adults have alternative sources of indecent materials
In order to tailor our enforcement of the 24-hour prohibition
on indecent broadcasting as narrowly as possible, however,

in actual cases of alleged indecent broadcasting stations will

be permitted to demonstrate that children were not tn fact

present in the broadcast audience for the market at the time

the programming at issue aired
A. Constitutional Standard

11. Several parties argue that the constitutional!
the indecency prohibition should be judged under the time
place and manner standard, rather than the more rigorou
compelling interest/narrowly tailored standard applied |
Supreme Court in Sable.12/ However, based upon tt
Supreme Court's having applied the more demanding t
Sable, and similar views expressed |

ACT I that content-based restrictions are sustainal

“the regulation is a precisely drawn means of serving
compelling state interest,""13/ we
Mora 4 ATMA

Alb

apply the more rigorous standard.

12. It is well established that the First Amendment
does not protect obscene speech, and that therefore the
government has broad authority to regulate commerce in
obscenity without reference to First Amendment principles
Sable, 109.S. Ct. at 2835; Paris Adult Theatre Iv. Slaton, 413
U.S. 49, 69 (1973): Roth v. United States, 354 U.S. 476, 481
(1957). In contrast, as the Supreme Court observed in Sable,
“[sJexual expression which is indecent but not obscene ts
protected by the First Amendment... .” 109.S. Ct. at 2836.
See also Pacifica, 438 U.S. at 743 (Stevens, J.), 756 (Powell,
J.). Nonetheless, the Supreme Court has indicated that it will
uphold governmental regulation of indecent speech if the
regulation meets the constitutional standards that the Court

has articulated.

13. In Sable. the Court set forth the constitutional
standard that governs restricuions on protected speech: the
government may “regulate the content of constitutionally
protected speech tn order to promote 4 compelling interest if
it chooses the least restrictive means to further the articulated
interest.” LOO S. Ct. at 2836. The Court also stated that the
means chosen by the government must be “carefully tailored”
or “narrowly tailored” to achieve the regulatory ends. Id. at
2836, 2839. While the standard has been expressed with

Is) ACT Jat 1343 n 18. quoting Consolidated Edison Co. vy. Public
Service Comm'n, 447 U.S. $30. 540 (1980)

ee eeeeeeaeEeEeEYEEGEeEee

A27

somewhat different wording, 14/ we understand it to require
essentially, a Showing that the regulation or statute serves a
compelling governmental interest and is nagrowly tailored to
serve that interest. This standard is substantially more
rigorous than the time, place and manner test applied to
content-neutral regulation of speech, 15/ which requires only
that the regulation be a reasonable means of serving “a
significant governmental interest” and that it leave “ample
alternative channels for communication.” Consolidated
Edison Co. of New York v. Public Service Commission of
New York, 447 U.S. at 535. See also Clark v. Community for
Creative Nonviolence, 468 U.S. 2%, 293 (19%4): Regan v
Time, Inc., 46% U.S. 641, 64% (1984)

B. Governmental! Interest!

14. In effectuating our statutory mandate Ir p!
concern has been and remains the protection of children fron
\ { | [ ) (; f
j ty ar WIV GU! A j
( ). Consolidate Ed ( {N
Commission of New York ym
a precisely drawn mcal f -TVING a %
>) iumodcr¢g Cytiz f i ge
1980) (law a | }
intrusi ), Corr vAA )

1]
IpcilINnyY §
} )
i JCatit [ A ‘ r . [
+> 1YA ¢
r j r
i ~ i x
_ } ‘
nd”) Bank
. ] 7
’ \ *
i v
»>€ \

A28

exposure to indecent materials. See 134 Cong. Rec. $9912
(daily ed. July 26, 1988) (statement of Senator Helms);
Reconsideration Order, 3 FCC Red 930, 931 (1987), aff'd in
relevant part sub nom. ACT I, 852 F.2d at 1340; Pacifica
Foundation, 56 FCC 2d at 97, recon. denied, 59 FCC 2d 892
(1976), rev'd, Pacifica Foundation v. F.C.C., 556 F.2d 9
(D.C. Cir. 1977); rev’d, Pacifica, 438 U.S. 726. In both
Pacifica and Sable the Supreme Court recognized the
government's interest in assisting parental supervision of
their children and, generally, in protecting the wellbeing of
youth, citing Ginsberg v. New York, 390 U.S. 629, 639
(1968). Sable, 109 S. Ct. at 2836; Pacifica, 438 U.S. at 749-
750. In the NOI, we solicited comment on-whether a 24-hour
prohibition of broadcast indecency advances this interest. We
also noted that courts have recognized an alternative
governmental interest in protecting the public’s right to be
tree from indecent material in the privacy of their homes, and
sought comment on this point.

15. Although parties generally agree that the
government has an interest 1n protecting minors from
indecent broadcasts, they differ on the scope of that interest.
Some parties maintain that the government’s sole legitimate
interest 1s to facilitate parental supervision, and not to
substitute governmental for parental supervision. 16/ In
contrast, Morality in Media (MIM) argues that a 24-hour
prohibition on broadcast indecency advances an independent

16 Capital Cites, ABC (ABC) Comments at 28: Pacifica Foundation ct al
(Pacifica) Comments at 32: P.E.N. American Center et al. (PEN)
Conffnents at 9: Cohn and Marks (C&M) Comments at 20; and
Comments submitied Jointly by a number of broadcasters and
organizations, including the National Association of Broadcasters. CBS
Inc... Action for Children’s Television, and the American Civil- Liberties

Umon etal (hereinatter- collectively referred to as “Broadcasters” ) at

~4

A29
governmental interest in the well-being of minors,17/ and that
the Pacifica decision can be read to establish an “indecent for
all (including adults) standard, and not merely an “indecent
for children” standard. 18/ On the other hand, Broadcasters
argue that there is no legitimate interest in protecting adults
from indecency, as adults have a right to receive
constitutionally protected indecent material.19/ Several!
commenters argue that a 24-hour prohibition also advances a
governmental interest in protecting the public’s right to be
free from indecent material in the privacy of their homes.20/
Cohn and Marks (C&M) disagrees, arguing that adults,
unlike children, are capable of receiving the “first blow”
from constitutionally protected indecent speech without
undue damage.2]

16. It is well established that protecting children from
exposure to indecent material is a compelling governmenta!
interest. See e.g., Sable. 109 S. Ct. at 2836; New York v.
Ferber, 458 U.S. 747, 756-57 (1982): Ginsberg v. New
York, 390 U.S. 629, 639-40 (1968): Carlin Communications,
Inc. v. FCC, 749 F.2d 113, 121 (2d Cir. 1984). Two related
rationales underlie this interest. First, as the Court explained

in Ginsberg and reiterated in Pacifica, see 438 U.S. at 749-
17 MIM Reply Comments at 15-16

18 MIM Comments at 4-5

19 Broadcasters Comments at 5-6

MIM Comments at 12-14; AFA Comments at 2-7: Salem Rep!:

Comments at 49-53

21 C&M Comments at 19 n.28 C&M’s reference to absorbing the “first
blow” derives from Pacifica, 438 U.S. at 749: “To say that one may avoid

750, “parents’ claim to authority in their own household to

(Footenote Continuted)

A30

direct the rearing of their children is basic in the structure of
our society,” and parents are “entitled to the support of laws
designed to aid discharge of that responsibility.” 390 U.S. at
639. Thus, the regulation of broadcast indecency ts intended
“to facilitate parental supervision of children’s listening.”
ACT 1, 852 F.2d at 1343. In addition, the Supreme Court has
expressly stated that “a State's interest in ‘safeguarding the
physical and psychological well-being of a minor’ is
‘compelling.”’ New York v. Ferber, 458 U.S. at 756-57.
quoting Globe Newspaper Co. v. Superior Court, 457 U.S.
596, 607 (1982). As stated by the Court in Ginsberg, “[t}he
State also has an independent interest in the well-being of its
vouth.” 390 U.S. at 640. The Court quoted with approval
from People v. Kahan, 15 N.Y.2d 311, 312, 206 N.E.2d 333,
334 (C.A.N.Y. 1965) (Fuld, J.. concurring), which dealt with
the sale of sexually explicit material to children:

While the supervision of children’s reading
may best be left to their parents, the
knowledge that parental control or guidance
cannot always be provided and society s
transcendent interest in protecting the welfare
of children justify reasonable regulation of the
sale of material to them. It is, therefore,
altogether fitting and proper for a state to
include in a statute designed to regulate the
sale of pornography to children special
standards, broader than those embodied tn
legislation aimed at controlling dissemination

(Footenote Continued) ;

further offense by turning off the radio when he hears indecent language
is like saving that the remedy for an assault is to run away after the firs!
blow.” Sce also n.29 intra

A3]

of such material to adults.

390 U.S. at 640. See also Prince v. Massachusetts, 321 U.S.
158, 165 (1944) (state interest in protecting “the welfare of
children” and preventing abuses that might prevent their
“growth into free and independent well-developed men and
citizens”).22/ These two related purposes, supporting
parental supervision and promoting the well-being of youth,
support the enforcement of narrowly drawn measures to
restrict children’s access to indecent materials.

- 17. Despite the fact that protecting children from
exposure to indecent material is recognized as a compelling
governmental interest, some parties, including P.E.N.
American Center et al. (PEN) and Broadcasters, argue that
there is no proof that exposure to indecent broadcasts harms
children. Broadcasters submit a study that concludes that few
studies have been performed regarding harm resulting from
indecency and that there ts little evidence of harm to

22 There seems to have been some understandable confusion in the past
as to the extent to which we relied on both of these two purposes —
Supporting parental supervision and promoting the well-being of youth
in serving the compelling interest of protecting children. Compare, e.g.,
Reconsideration Order, 3 FCC Red at 930 3, with 3 FCC Red 931 911.
The court in ACT I understood the Commission's position as based solely
On its interest in supporting parental authority. ACT I, 852 F.2d at 1343
However, the Supreme Court in various cases, including Ginsberg,
Pacifica, and Sable. has recognized a broader governmental interest in
protecting children which goes beyond merely supporting parenta!
supervision, and Congress specifically referenced this broader interest in
directing the adoption of the 24-hour prohibition on broadcast indecency
See 134 Cong. Rec. $9912 (daily ed. July 26, 1988) (statement of Sen.
Helms). We take this occasion to state that, consistent with Congress’
direction, the broader view more accurately reflects what we seek to

accomplish — specifically, to support parental supervision and to

Promote generally the well-being of youth

A32
children.23/ On the other hand, Salem Communications
Corporation (Salem) and American Family Association et al.
(AFA) submit studies to support their argument that exposure
to indecent broadcasting has the potential to harm children.
For example, AFA submitted findings from a clinical
psychologist who concludes that children are harmed by
pornography.24/

18. The debate over harm to children is not at issue
here. Irrespective of the continuing social science debate, the
courts have recognized Congress’ authority, derived from the
governmental interest in protecting its youth, to regulate
access by children to indecent material. As a legal matter, it
is well established that exposure of children to such material
may be harmful, even if that effect has not been completely
proven scientifically. See Pacifica, 438 U.S. at 757-58
(Powell, J., concurring); Ginsberg, 390 U.S. at 641-43. In
proscribing the diss~emination of indecent material to
minors, Congress has considered testimony that cites its
harmful effects and has responded not only with the statute
and mandate before us in this particular case, but also with
the passage of other statutes that limit the availability of
indecent material to minors.25/ For example, Congress has

23 Broadcasters Comments at Appendix A.

24 AFA Reply Comments at Appendix 2. In defining pornography,
Victor B. Cline, author of the study, noted that “something could be

regarded as ‘pornographic’ but still not be legally obscene.” Id. at 1.

25 See Telephone Decency Act of 1987, Hearing Before the
Subcommittee on Telecommunications and Finance of the U.S. House of
Representatives Committee on Energy and Commerce, 100th Cong., Ist
Sess. (Serial No. 100-99, Sept. 30, 1987) at pp. 22-26, 27, 63-64, 96-97;
Cable-Porn and Dial-A-Porn Control] Act, Hearing Before the

(Footenote Continued)

A33

acted to protect minors from indecent telephone messages,26/
and the Supreme Court in Sable fully recognized Congress'
authority to do so (although it held that Congress in that case
had not sufficiently tailored its effot to serve this interest).
See 109 S.Ct. at 2839. Similarly, in 1984, Congress required
cable operators to make available to their customers a device
to enable them to control reception of indecnt programming
to protect minors from inadvertant access. See 47 U.S.C.
§544(d)(2)(A). More broadly, the Supreme Court has up-
held, in the face of a First Amendment challenge, a congres-
sional statute which protects the public, and particularly
children, from unwanted mail which the recipient considers
offensively lewd. See 39 U.S.C. §§3008 and 3010 (1988);
Rowan v. Post Office Department, 397 U.S. 728 (1970).
These statutes evidence findings by Congress that children
deserve protection from harm that indecent material may
inflict. It is significant that the 24-hour prohibition specifi-
cally mandated by the Congress, and although Congress is
not the ultimate interpreter of the Constitution, its findings
and purposes are due deference as those of co-equal branch
of government charged with providing for the general wel-
fare of the United States. See Metro Broadcasting v. F.C.C.,
No. 89-453, 58 U.S.L.W. 5053, 5061 (U.S. June 27, 1990).

19. Our concern with the harm to children caused by
exposure to indecent broadcast material 1s particularly strong

(Footenoted Continued)
Subcommittee on Criminal Law of the United States Senate Committee
on the Judiciary, 99th Cong., Ist Sess. (July 31, 1985, Serial No. J-99-46)

at pp. 103, 135-38

26 See Pub. L. 98-214, 97 Stat. 1469 (1983), amended by Pub. L. 100
297, 102 Stat. 424 (1988): further amended by Pub. L. 101-166, 103 Stat.
1159, 1192-1194 (1989)

A34

given the range of materials that could be included in the
"indecent" programming category (and thus conceivably
could be broadcast between 8 p.m. and 6 a.m., given the
Current restrictions On our enforcement authority). As Justice
Scalia noted in his Sable concurrence, "the more narrow the
understanding of what is ‘obscene,’ and hence the more
pornographic what is embraced within the residual category
of ‘indecency,’ the more reasonable it becomes to insist upon
greater assurance of insulation from minors.” Sable, 109 S.

2839 (Scalia, J., concurring).

20. It thus is significant that the courts have applied a
very narrow definition of obscenity in ruling on pornographic
films, holding that movies containing graphic depictions o1
sex acts, such as “Deep Throat” and “Debbie Does Dallas,”
are not legally obscene.27/ We recognize that these cases
have not involved the broadcast media and that most
broadcasters are likely to exercise restraint and not air such
movies unedited. Our own enforcement actions demonstrate,
however, that some broadcasters have been willing to ait
patently offensive, sexually explicit material that would seem
to tread close to the obscenity line.28

21. The broad range of sexually-oriented material that
has been or could be considered indecent or “protected
speech” — but not obscene speech — accordingly heightens
our concerns for preventing harm to children. Specifically
we find that Justice Scaulia’s statement in Sable is extremely
relevant in the broadcast indecency context. It has become

sore reasonable .... to Insist upon greater assurance of
insulation from minors” in light of the extremely

26 Examples of the patently offensive indecent material broadcas!

ome Stauions-are included in-Appendix B

A35
pornographic nature of what may be encompassed within the
category of broadcast indecency.

22. Although the Commission has focused on the
government’s interest in protecting children as a basis for
regulating broadcast indecency, preserving the privacy of the
home provides an alternative basis for upholding the
constitutionality of the 24-hour prohibition. In Pacifica, the
SupremeCourt’s first stated rationale for sustaining the
Commission's decision was the right of all members of the
public to be free of indecent material in the privacy of their
homes. The Court Pound that “the broadcast media
haveestablished a uniquely pervasive presence in the lives of
all Americans. Patently offensive, indecent material
presented over the airwaves confronts the citizen, not only in
public, but also in the privacy of the home, where the
individual's right to be left alone plainly outweighs the First
Amendment rights of an intruder.” 438 U.S. 726, 748, citing
Rowan v. Post Office Dept., 397 U.S. 728 (1970); Id. at 759-
60 (Powell, J., concurring in Sable, the Supreme Court again
referred to this residential privacy interest, noting the
“unique” attributes of broadcasting, 1.¢., that it “can intrude
on the privacy of the home without prior warning as to
program content.” 109 S. Ct. at 2837.30

29 In his concurrence, Justice Powell noted that “broadcasting unlike
most other forms of communication — comes directly into the home, the
one place where people ordinarily have~the right not to-be assaulted by
uninvited and offensive sights and sounds Although the First
Amendment may require unwilling adults to absorb the first blow of
offensive but protected speech when they are in public before they turn
away,...a different order of values obtains in the home.” 438 U.S. at

759 (Powell, J.. concurring in part) (citauion omitted)

30 The Court has recognized the government's substantial interest in

protecting the privacy of the home in non-broadcast contexts as well. See,

(Footenote Continued)

A36

23. The government’s interest in preserving the
privacy of the home reinforces its interest in protecting
children. As D.C. Circuit Judge Leventhal noted in his
dissenting opinion in Pacifica, “[w]ith the pervasiveness of
TV-radio and its reach into the home the choice made by
broadcasters precludes an effective choice by the family.
Because of the unique interest in home life, especia~lly
strong in homes where children are being raised, it is bootless
to quote from cases that reflect a more permissive attitude to
speech in public streets and places, without attention to the
difference. ... The reality of broadcasting’s special access to
the home con~joins with the passivity of TV-radio reception
— a mere click, without current purchase.” 556 F.2d at 33
(Leventhal, J., dissenting). While the record demonstrates
that a 24-hour prohibition on broadcast indecency is needed
to advance our primary interest in controlling children’s
access to indecent materials, it also supports this alternative
residential privacy interest, particularly the evidence
concerning the pervasiveness of the broadcast media, the
prevalence of random tuning and remote control devices, and
the ineffectiveness of prior warnings. See infra at pp. 17-18

and 34-35.

(Footenote Continued)
e.g. Frisby v. Schultz. 487 U.S. 474, 484 (1988) (upholding 4 narrowly-
tailored ban on picketing a specific residence and stating that “we have
repeatedly held that individuals are not required to welcome unwanted
speech into their own homes and that the government may protect this
freedom”); Carey v. Brown. 447 U.S. 455, 471 (1980) (“The State's
interest in protecting the well-being. tranquility and privacy of the home
is Certainly of the highest order in a free and civilized society’). Bolger \
Youngs Drug Products Corp.. 463 U.S. 60. 77-78 (1983) (Rehnquist, J
on~curring) (“We have often recognized that individuals have a
legitimate ‘right to be left, alone’ in the privacy of the home the one
place where people ordinarily have the right not to be assaulted by

uninvited and offensive sights and sounds”)

A37
C. Operative Definitions

1. Definition of Indecency

24. In carrying out its statutory responsibility to
enforce Section 1464, the Commission consistently has
defined indecency as “language that describes, in terms
patently offensive as measured by contemporary communi‘y
standards for the broadcast medium, sexual or excretory
activities Or organs.” Pacifica Foundation, 56 FCC 2d at 98,
100 (1975), aff'd, F.C.C. v Pacifica Foundation, 438 U.S.
726 (1978); Reconsideration Order, 3 FCC Rcd at 930 42
(1987), rev'd on other grounds, ACT I, 852 F.2d at 1338-
39.31/ We continue to believe that this definition is
sufficiently narrow to continue to pass muster
under the First Amendment. Indeed; we note that the U.S.
Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit, relying upon the
Supreme Court's opinion in Pacifica, explicitly affirmed this
definition recently in ACT I, 852 F.2d at 1340

25. Many commenters agree that the Commission’s
generic definition of indecency retains its validity because it
is sufficiently narrow and has survived Supreme Court
scrutiny.32/ Others, however, claim that the definition is
unconstitutionally vague,33/ and that the vagueness could

31 Our initial definition of indecency included the language “when there
's a reasonable risk that children may be in the audience.” Pacifica, 56
FCC 2d at 98. Starting with our 1987 decisions, however, we have treated
the nature of the material involved and the presence of children in the
audience as separate issues because the question whether there is a
reasonable risk of children in the audience 1s “more pertinent to

whether a broadcast is ‘actionable’ under 18 U.S.C. § 1464 than to
whether it 1s indecent.” Reconsideration Order, 3 FCC Red at 936.6

See Supra, n.&

32 See, e.g... MIM Reply Comments at 22-25.-Salem Reply Comments
§ p

t 10-21: and AFA Reply Comments at 3-7

A38
suppress broadcast material with serious literary, artistic,
social, and cultural value, as well as discussions on a range of
subjects.34/ Several parties argue that the Commission
should adopt a rule that defers to the reasonable, good faith
~judgments of licensees.35/ Finally, Broadcasters argue that
a licensee should have a right to a trial de novo whenever the
Commission applies the definition to specific
circumstances.36

26. We do not believe that application of our
definition of indecency will lead to unconstitutional
censor.ship. We have emphasized that “subject matter alone
does not render material indecent. Only when that matter is
presented in a manner that is patently offens ive will it be
considered indecent.” Reconsideration Order, 3 FCC Red at
932 (emphasis in original).37/

27. Furthermore, we will continue to give weight to
reasonable licensee judgments when deciding to impose
sanctions in specific cases. We cannot, however, abrogate our
statutory duty to enforce Section 1464 by deferring
absolutely to broadcasters’ judgments. See ACT [ at 1340)

> ie!

See. e.g.. Broadcasters Comments at 35-30; PEN Comments at | 1-
16: Post- Newsweek Stanons (Post) Comments at 1-2: ABC Comments at
19-21: C&M Comments at 7-16: and Cox Comments at 9-15

34. PEN Comments at 16-20; Pacifica Comments at 13-20: Post
Comments at 2-5: and KDVS Comments at ]i-14

35 Broadcasters Comments at 40: ABC Comments at 36-41: and
> i= ie i.

Arizona Board of Regents ct al. (Joint Parties) Comments at 22-2

36 Kroadcasters Comments at 44
37 We also note that the courts already have determined that our
definition of indecencs 1S not unconstitutionally vague. See ACT | a

133-1339 ?

A39

n.14. Finally, in response to the suggestion by Broadcasters
that a trial de novo be available, we note that under the
procedure we have utilized for indecency enforcement
actions, issuance of notices of apparent liability, a trial de
novo 1s in fact available to any station that challenges the
Commission's determination by not paying its forfeiture. See
47 U.S.C. § 504.

2. Definition of Children

28. We find that for the purpose of enforcing Section
1464,38/ children ages 17 and under constitute the category
of persons that should be defined as “children.” This
conclusion 1s supported by the legislative history of the
Statutory 24-hour prohibition against indecent broadcasts,
Supreme Court decisions addressing the regulation of othe:
sexually explicit indecent materials, and other statutes

governing the availability of indecent materiais to childre

29. In the NOI. we noted that our 1987 enforcement
rulings indicated that children 17 and under should be
protected from indecent broadcast. and sought
comment on whether we should continue to so define
children. Arguing generally tha! including all minors would
be consistent with state laws protecting minors from other
sexually explicit speech, some parties agree that “childre
Should include persons 17 years o!d and under.39, However

Opposing parties argue that even though states may protect

38 Sec n 1464 Wi
far } Q f
7 € 1$ Ww) e
tee 1464
ao gy AFA Comm s 5 (
>

A40

children from obscenity, they do not protect children from
indecency,40/ and that in any event there is no evidence that
exposure to indecent speech harms children.41/

30. Defining children to be protected from indecent
broadcasts as those 17 years old and under is consistent with
the legislative history of the statutory provision requiring the
Commission to enforce Section 1464 twenty four hours a
day. That history reveals that the statute's author intended to
encompass children 12 to 17, as well as those under 12,
within the class of persons to be protected by the 24-hour
prohibition.42/ Since the statutory provision originated as an
amendment introduced on the Senate floor, no committee
reports exist for reference. The author’s explanation,
delivered immediately before the measure was adopted,
therefore must be accorded substantial weight in interpreting
the provision.43/

31. In addition, defining children as those 17 and

40 See Broadcasters Comments at 26-29. See also Cox Enterprises (Cox)
Comments at 26-28 and PEN Comments at 20-23.

41 Broadcasters Comments at 13-17 and Appendix A: Broadcasters
Reply Comments at 10-12; Pacifica Comments at at 30-31; and ABC
Comments at 23-28.

42 In enacting the 24-hour prohibition, Senator Helms, the author of the
legislation. relicd upon data regarding children 12 to 17 in arguing tor
enactment of the prohibition and. therefore. intended for it to apply to this
age category. 134 Cong. Rec. $9912 (daily ed. July 26, 1988) (statement
of Sen. Helms).

43 See North Haven Board of Education v. Bell, 456 U.S. 512, 526-527
(1952); Steiner v. Mitchell. 350 U.S. 247, 254 (1956) (remarks of
legislaulon’s sponsor 1s an authoritative guide lo statute’s construction and
deserves to be accorded substantial weight). See also National Woodwork
Manufacturers Association v. NLRB, 386 U.S. 612. 640 (1967) ("It is the
sponsors that we look to when the meaning of the statutory words ts in

doubt.”’)

Ad]

under is consistent with other laws regulating the availability
of sexually explicit indecent materials to children. One such
Statute is the “dial-a-porn” prohibition, 47 U.S.C.A. §
223(b)(3) (Supp. 1990), enacted in 1989, which prohibits
indecent telephone communications to persons under the age
of 18. This provision is strong evidence that Congress has
found that persons 17 and under should be protected from
indecent materials. In addition, contrary to the comments
cited above, the NOI at Appendix A lists statutes from 48
States that penalize persons for disseminating to minors
materials that are sexually explicit, and not necessarily
obscene by adult standards. Most of these state laws protect
children ages 17 and under.

32. The government’s interest in protecting children
17 and under from exposure to indecent materials also has
been recognized by the courts. For example, when discussing
an earlier version of the “dial-a-porn” statute, the Supreme
Court in Sable explicitly recognized the government's
"compelling interest in preventing minors from being
exposed to indecent telephone messages,” and tacitly
approved Congress’ decision to apply the statute to children
ages 17 and under. 109 S. Ct. at 2839. Similarly, in Ginsberg,
390 U.S. at 631, and Bethel Schoo! District No. 403 v.
Fraser, 478 U.S. 675, the Supreme Court found a compelling
governmental interest in controlling the availability of
indecent matter to persons in the 12-17 age group. These
precedents make clear that the government has a legitimate
interest In protecting persons 17 and under from exposure to

indecent broadcast materials.

33. We recognize that the court in ACT I criticized
the Commission for not clearly defining “children” for
purposes of applying Section 1464 and for failing to justify
its application to the 12-17 age group.44/ In this report we

A42

Clarify that all children 17 and under will be included in the
protected age group. We find sufficient justification for
adopting this definition in analogous federal and state
statutes, Supreme Court precedent, and in the legislative
history of the 24-hour statutory prohibition against indecent
broadcasts. Accordingly, for purposes of protecting children
from exposure to indecent broadcast materials, we will!
consider “children” to be persons age 17 and under.

44 The Court in ACT I noted that the Commission in 4 1976 legislative
proposal had recommended that the regulation of broadcast indecency be
directed to protecting children under 12. See 852 F.2d at 1342, citing 122
Cong. Rec. at 33,367 0.119. At the time, we made this recommendation
for two reasons. First. we proposed that broadcasters could defend agains!
an indecency complaint by showing that they had made efforts to
minimize the risk of exposure to children. Including 18-year olds in the
definition of children, we feared. would deprive broadcasters of this
defense because of the difficulties inherent in effectively shielding [s-
vear olds from indecent programming. Sccond, we observed that ave 12
“is the accepted upper limit for children’s programming tn the andustry
and at the Commission. 122 Cong. Rec. at 33,367 0.119; see 122 Cong
Rec. at 33.364 (Sept 24, 1976).

However, now outside the confines of that debate and on further
cxamination. we conclude that the apprepriate “upper limit for children’s
programming” differs from the appropriate upper limit for protecting
children from exposure to indecent material. To the extent the public
interest requires broadcasters to offer age-specific or other special
programming for children, that interest subsides when the child reaches
an age, such as 12 years old. when general interest programming serves
his or her needs. In contrast, the wide usage of the age of 17 andl under in
other federal and state laws intended to protect children from access to
sexually explicit material demonstrates the general acceptance of the need
to protect children older than 12 from exposure to such material
Morcover, our recommendation to Congress in 1976 simply struck a
different balance between the need to protect children and the rihts of
adults to see or hear indecent matter from that struck by Congress in 1988
when it directed the Commission to enforce the prohibition on imdecent

broadcasting 24 hours a day

A43
D. Narrowly Tailored Means

1. Accessibility to Children

34. As did the Supreme Court in Pacifica, we find that
the broadcast medium is uniquely pervasive and accessible to
minors, and that these characteristics further justify prudent
regulation of indecent broadcast programs. The Supreme
Court has recognized that “each medium of expression
presents special First Amendment problems.” Pacifica, 438
U.S. at 748. Broadcasting has specific characteristics that
support regulation of indecency that would not necessarily be
permissible if applied to other media. In particular, for
purposes of regulating indecent broadcasting, the Court has
noted “that broadcasting is ‘uniquely pervasive,’ can intrude
on the privacy of the home without prior warning as to
program content, and is ‘uniquely accessible to children,
even those too young to read.” Sable, 109 S. Ct. at 2837,
quoting Pacifica, 438 U.S. at 748-49.45

35. Notably, the Supreme Court in Sable
distinguished indecent telephone services trom broadcasting,
observing that the caller to a “dial-a-porn” service must “take
affirmative steps to receive the communication,” 109 S. Ct. at
2837. In contrast, “[bJecause the vroadcast audience is
constantly tuning in and out, prior warnings Cannot
completely protect the listener or viewer from unexpected
program content.” Pacifica, 438 U.S. at 745. Thus, “[p}lacing
a telephone call is not the same as turning on a radio and
being taken by surprise by an indecent message.” 109 S. Ct

45 Similarly. in enacting the 24-hour prohibition on broadcast indecency
the statute s author expressed concern repardiny the NCIrVaASIVENESS ane

}
accessibility of the broadcast medium. 134 Cong. Rec $9912 (daily ed

July 26, 1988) (statement of Sen. Heln

A44
at 2837.

36. The Sable decision strongly suggests that a 24-
hour broadcast indecency prohibition is constitutional if it is
the most narrowly tailored means of protecting children from
exposure to indecent materials. The reversal of the dial-a-
porn prohibition in Sable restec 1ot on the failure to channel
such communication, but on the government's failure to
show that a complete prohibition on indecent dial-a-porn was
necessary to meet the government’s interest in protecting
children from the indecent material. The emphasis the Court
placed on the inadequacy of the record in Sable thus supports
a conclusion that a total prohibition on indecency would be
upheld if the record demonstrates that no alternative would
effectively serve the compelling interest at stake.

37. The record in this proceeding confirms the genera!
pervasiveness and accessibility of broadcasts to children. TV,
available in virtually every household, is viewed an average
of 26 hours per week by children ages 2 to 17 years old.46
Between 25% and almost 50% of children have a TV set for
their personal use.47/ Radio is even more pervasive, with
each household having an average of over five radios Over
99% of children age 12 to 17 listen to radio at least once a
week.48/ Moreover, as described in detail infra. children do

16 NO] al 836]

$7 Id. Additional data submitted by AFA illustrates the pervasive nature

of television, using the Chicago television market as an example. Chicago
has S VHF and 3 UHF TV stations. of which most broadcast at least 2¢
hours a dav, 7 davs a week. As a result. for over 80% of all hour

week. day or night. there are at | tS different programs ru ic
simultaneously. In a typical 168 hour broadcast week. there are

rs of programs broadcast. AFA Comments at 4

A45

not just have general access to the broadcast media, but they
in fact tune in to their radio and television sets without

meaningful supervision at all times of the day and night.
Children’s Listening and Viewing Habits

38. The record indicates that there are children in the
radio and television audience at all hours of the day and
night. The data further shows that a significant number of
these children are not subject to active parental supervision,

even during the late evening and early morning hours

39. The data submitted in response to the NO]

; ; te th re » oi | ry ur +} . i. . rye ; '
Indicat¢ lal tnere af§re children in th adit itenin¥’v aAUCGICNCE
t yi; TIN ? 1“) t} r LV Praoe f nears rnree-qg arter ,¢
dali times OF GdV. WILD dN daVCrave I nearly (hree-qualicls oO!
1) ]
million widren iistening t } t \ Inignt and
Y r ( Y 4s | con ae \
Vnicn indecent Male | Hd ) OwW
eaSOndD!) ISK U Signi m I
‘+ IT
> | | ( |
r\ ( il UU j
, hh ,
I Mi
, Te
c | s¢ Ca nai I ] |
is\ | } f (

aaa...

A46

41. The NOI indicated that the national listening
audience for children ages 12-17 between midnight and 6
a.m. peaked at 1,471,000 between 12:00 and 12:15 a.m..
decreased gradually to a low of 309,000 between 3:45 and
4:00 a.m., and then increased to 1,429,000 between 5:45 and
6:00 a.m. The average quarter-hour audience for the entire
six hour block of midnight to 6 a.m. was 716,000 children
ages 12-17. The average one dav cume (the estimated
number of different persons who listen to radio for a
minimum of five minutes within a specified time frame) for

> &S

between midnight and 6 a.m. was 3,533,000 children ages

+

|}2-17. That 1s, during any given midnight to 6:00 a.m. time
frame on any given day, 3,533,000 different children aves
!2-17 in the United States listened to the radio for at least
five minutes. The weekly cume for listening between
midnight and 6 a.m. was 10,896,000 children ages 12-17
These listeners constituted 10 to 12 percent of the post
midnight total listening audience and this proportion was
generally consistent for davtime listening as well.50/. We
requested comment on these data and asked commenters to
submit any other data or studies regarding listening habits of

children and adults

42. Commenters supporting the 24-hour prohibition
submit that children ages 12-17 make up a substantial portion
of the radio audience. MIM submits radio listening data for

hidren ages 12-17 tor New York, Chicago and Los Angeles
collected by Arbitron for the summer of 1989.51/ MIM

OmbDines the data tor the three markets and makes a national!

jection Of post-midmight listening by children ages 12-17

Is remarkably close to the nattonal data presented in th

A47

NOI.52/ MIM estimates that from 12 to 1:00 a.m. the average

quarter hour audience for this age group nationally 1s

1,334,557, which is very close to the Commission's estimate
of 1,429,000 for 12 to 12:15 a.m. MIM’s estimated low in

listening among children ages 12-17 occurs at 4-S a.m. with

220.067 in the audience, whereas the Commission estimated

309.000 in the audience from 3:45 to 4:00 a.m

43. Bonneville International Corporation (Bonneville)

reviewed data on audiences for several of its radio stations

that it classifies as having “some ‘en appeal,” and found that

children ages 12-17 are in the audience post-midnight

Bonneville also reviewed data for non-Bonneville stations in

’

markets in which Bonneville has stations and. similarly,

found stations with greater post-midnight listening by

children aAvCS ] J | tnan an\ (f OTaNnNic VTi up
Salem submits a Bakersfield, ¢ study showings
that 28% of children as

between midnivht and ¢
Broadcasters (NRB)
fampa showing lary

to radio at all times of tn

14. Broadcasters Claim U 1ud Ce for ¢
programming that the Commissi reviewing as (OF
deemed to De) Indecen ny t
Gallup survey of N y K Lit

NQO|

Ads
ages 6-11 commissioned by Infinity Broadcasting indicating
that in 99.6% of households surveved, no children in that age
group listen to the Howard Stern morning radio show.56/ In
the sole household that reported a child listening to that
show, it was reported that the child was supervised by an
adult.57/ MIM responds that although Broadcasters assert
that few children ages 6 to 11 listen to the Howard Stern
show, there are older children in the audience. As reported in
Arbitron’s Summer 1989 “Radio Market Report” for New
York, only 5 of the 48 stations listed for the New York
market have a greater audience of children ages 12-17 than
WXRK-FM Monday through Friday, 7-8 a.m., when a
portion of the Howard Stern show is broadcast. MIM further
states that Arbitron reports an estimated 10,600 children ages
(2-17 listened to the Stern show for at least 5 minutes during
any quarter hour from 7-8 a.m. Monday through Friday in the
summer of 1989.58

45. Other commenters opposing the 24-hour
prohibition dispute the Commission’s initial findings and
submit radio listening data in support of their position.
KDVS-FM (KDVS) urges that channeling be used to
enhance parental responsibility, and states that Arbitron and
other radio surveys suggest that the number of young
children in the audience during school hours ts only between
3 and 5% of the potential audience of children ages 12-17.
This group comprises only 1-4 of the total audience during

S6 Mr. Stern’s morning radio show was the subject of one of the
Commussion’s 1987 indecency decisions. See Infinity Broadcasung Corp
of Pennsylvania, 2 FCC Red 2705 (1987)

57 Broadcasters Comments at 260.65, cing a poll by the Gallup
Organizauion, WXRK Radio. Special Listenership Study (Dec. 1984)

Ss MIM Reply Comments at 20

A49

these broadcast hours. Both of these figures are far lower
than even those seen in the 11 p.m.-midnight sampling, and
approximate the post-midnight sampling. KDVS claims that
these statistics suggest two appropriate times for channeling
— during the school day and the late evening hours. KDVS
also states that the same survey (Arbitron Fall 1983) reported
that, during Monday through Friday, 7 p.m. to midnight, only
10% of the total audience of children ages 12-17 listened to
radio outside the home at those hours. Therefore, argues
KDVS, most of the children in the radio audience would be
subject to adult supervision.59/

46. KDVS also states that children ages 12-17 make
up only 10% of a very small midnight to 6 a.m. listening
audience. KDVS maintains that nationally, only about 3.5%
of children ages 12-17 are present in any quarter hour post-
midnight time frame for all stations. KDVS estimates that if
this age group comprises 10% of the population, then the
3.5% of all children ages 12-17 listening to radio post-
midnight represents only 0.35% of the entire population.60/
Finally, KDVS states that the Commission, in the NOI, did
not identify estimates of the sampling error or relative
standard error involved in the ratings.61/

47. Pacifica Foundation et al. (Pacifica) also claims
that listening statistics regarding children ages 12-17 are
flawed in their application. Pacitica states that the
Commission gives the impression that a significant number
of children in this age group listen to radio generally.

S9 KDVS Comments at 7-9
60 KDVS Reply Comments at 3-4

Hl Id. at $-6

, ==

ee

ASO
Pacifica, like KDVS, claims that the percentage of children
ages 12-17 of the total listening population (the largest
possible representation of these data) does not reflect the
percentage of these children in the actual total population.
Pacifica states that the 12-1 7year old listening population
Should be divided by the total population to obtain a more
realistic representation of this group's listening.

48. Pacifica further observes that such data do not
retlect children’s listening to public radio stations. Pacifica
relies on data trom Arbitron, Spring 1989, to conclude that
children ages 12-17 listening to public radio stations account
for a mere 0.2% share of this group’s listening to radio and
no [OQ] share of total radio listening. Only 1.5% of the
population of children ages 12-17 tuned into public radio for
S minutes during an average weck from this survey.62
Broadcasters also refer to the minimal audience of children
aves 12-17 that National Public Radio (NPR) attracts.
Broadcasters submit that, according to the Arbitron National
Report (Spring 1989), member stations carrving NPR
programming have no measurable audience in this age group

; Coil

from 6 to 10 a.m. and 6 p.m. to 6 4.m.63

49. The submitted data confirm our initial
determination that there are a significant number of children
in the listening audience at all times of day and night. MIM,
Salem and NRB have submitted data illustrating that the
listening patterns of children ages 12-17 are similar to those
described in the NOI.64/ which indicated that the percentage
of children in this age group listening to radio during all time

Pacifica Comments at 23-25 and Attachment 4

NO} at 836] and Append. Ks. Tables 3 and 4

AS1
frames was higher than the percentage of adults age 18 and
over listening to radio.65/ These 12 to 17 year olds represent
over 10% of the 6.9 million total average quarter-hour
listening audience from midnight to 6 a.m.66/ Although
KDVS maintains that there are few children ages 12-17 in the
listening audience during the day, even low numbers of
children (KDVS’ submission indicates that 1-4% of the total!
audience is children ages 12-17) confirm that there are

significant numbers of children listening to radio during
school hours. Similarly, although KDVS maintains that 12 to
17 year olds listening between midnight and 6 a.m. during
any quarter hour make up only 0.35% of the total population,
this figure represents 3.5% of all children in this age group in
the U.S... or 716.000 children ages 12-17.67

b. Television

SO. Our initial data. and data supplied by se

commenters. validate the Commission oncerns regarding
bo | i > . 4 oO “Ne: af] | ty r mm? >t ' ;
cnildren S Viewing, especially late nignt viewing, ol
television. These data demonstrate that there 1s a reason
risk that a significant number of children are present in the

nationwide television viewing audience at al! time

S1. The NOI stated that. ba 1On rating
NO] Anne {iy RR
N rega KDVS
sampling ¢
| Comn
i) A

AS2
children are in the television audience throughout the day.
Unlike radio, there are no reported data reflecting television
viewing by age between 2:00 and 6:00 a.m. That which is
available, however, demonstrates that children, particularly
those ages 12-17, remain in the viewing audience throughout
the last reported time period ending at 2:00 a.m. The data
also indicate that between 3% (for ages 2 to 5) and 8% (for
ages 12-17) of children’s weekly viewing occurs between
11:00 p.m. and 1:00 a.m. The NOI also analyzed Arbitron
data depicting the percentage of persons by age group that
watch TV from 6:00 p.m. to 1:45 a.m. in four selected
markets. These data show that percentage-wise, aS many
children ages 12-17 as adults watch television during the late
evening hours, and that a higher percentage of 12 to 17 vear
olds than adults may watch television during these hours in
some markets during the summer months.68/ We requested
comment on these data and solicited additional studies or
data regarding children’s viewing.

S2. The United States Catholic Conference (USCC)
submits results of a radio listening and television viewing
survey of almost 8100 children attending Catholic diocesan
schools (5,726 age 12 and under and 2,346 age 13-18). The
USCC survey indicated that children 12 and under watch an
average Of 3.5 hours of television per day, mostly trom 3-9
p.m. Monday through Friday, and an average of 6 hours per
day on the weekend, mostly from 8-11 a.m. and 7-11 p.m.
USCC also reported that children age 13-18 watch an average
of 3.5 hours per day, mostly from 4-11 p.m. Monday through
Friday, and an average of 6 hours per day on the weekend,
mostly from 7-9 a.m. and 2-11 p.m.69/ USCC concludes that
6S NOI at &362 and Appendix C
69 USCC Comments at S. We note that USCC admis that the results ef

its survey are not conclusive, and that it was unable to receive a tull

responseto is survey. fd. at S-6

AS3
if a reasonably clear distinction between times when children
are and are not in the audience can be discerned, then time of
day restrictions for the broadcast of indecent material could
be established.

53. KDVS takes issue with the Commission's graphic
representation of Arbitron television viewing data for the
four markets that appear in Appendix C of the NOI. It asserts
that the post-10:30 p.m. periods are measured in fifteen-
minute intervals, whereas pre-10:30 p.m. time periods are
measured in thirty-minute intervals, thus depicting the rate of
audience decline after 10:30 p.m. as slower than it is in
reality. KDVS further states that the Commission has implied
incorrectly that the proportion of age groups represented on
the charts is indicative that each group ts similar in size.70/

54. Several commenters have filed evidence
indicating that children comprise a significant portion of the
late night audience. Salem and NRB submit data showing
that, in five metropolitan areas, the number of children in the
viewing audience late at night is substantial.71/ For example,
in the Washington, D.C. market, for July 1989, seven percent
of children ages 12-17 and four percent of children ages 2-11]
are in the viewing audience from 1:45 to 2:00 a.m., Monday
through Friday. Salem averages the data for the five markets
and projects the national television audience for various post
11:00 p.m. time frames. For the 1:45-2:00 a.m. period, Salem
projects that, nationally, 4.8% of children ages 12-17 watch
television. This translates to over 970,000 12 to 17 year olds

70 KVDS Reply Comments at 4

71 Salem Reply Comment at Exhibit 2 and NRB Reply Comments at
Exhibit 1, citing data trom Arbitron Television Market Report for the five

markets for July 1YSY

AS4

in the television audience at that hour.72/

55. These data and our initial data confirm our belief
that there is a reasonable risk that significant numbers of
children are watching television at all times, including late at
night. USCC’s suggestion that distinctions can be made as to
when children are or are not in the viewing audience is
unpersuasive. Its survey indicates only that children watch
TV mostly in certain time frames, but these time frames are
not all-inclusive of children’s viewing. In addition, we note
that 66.9% of U.S. television households have videotape
recorders (VCRs).73/ Through VCRs, children can record
late night programming for viewing during daytime, thus
obtaining access to programs even if they are not in the
audience when the programs are initially aired.

56. KDVS° arguments regarding the data presented in
the NOI also are unpersuasive. Depicting audience in 15
minute intervals as Opposed to 30 minute intervals trom
10:30 p.m. to 1:45 a.m. achieves a greater level of accuracy
in the measurement of late night TV audiences. Using 30
minute increments does not alter the percentage of each age
group that is watching TV at those times. We agree with
KVDS that the rate of decline for all audience segments 1s
relatively steep late at night. This does not change the
evidence indicating that children remain in the viewing
audience late at might: With regard to KDVS’ contention that
the Commission implied that each age group tn the four
markets chested in Appendix C of the NOI is similar in size,
such an implication was not made. The NOI states that the

P2) Saiem multiphes the 20.254.000 total population of 12 to 17 vear

olds cited inthe NOJ by ¢ S to arrive at 972.192 children in this age

range. Salem Reply Com ents at 65

1999) Nichsen Report on Television at |

ASS
percentage of cach demographic group is represented on the
chart. While the percentages of each group are, in some
cases, equal, the actual numbers of each group are not.
Nevertheless, there appears to be a reasonable risk that
significant numbers of children are in the television viewing
audience at all times.

c. Supervision

57. As previously noted, the government has a clearly
established compelling interest in protecting children from
exposure to indecent broadcast materials, both to facilitate
parental supervision of their children and to generally
promote the well-being of youth. In order to complie a record
with respect to supporting parental supervision, the NOI
requested comment on parents’ ability to supervise children’s
listening and viewing, whether parents in fact supervise
listening and viewing. and whether parents are concerned
about their children’s exposure to indecent broadcasts. Our
preliminary finding was that there 1s significant unsupervised
television viewing by children on a daily basis. In addition,
while there are fewer data available to measure unsupervised
radio listening among children, we preliminarily concluded
that, because of the number of radios per household, a
significant number of-children have the opportunity for and
actually engage in, unsupervised listening.74/ Our review of
the record in this proceeding contirms the validity of these
preliminary findings, and demonstrates that unsupervised
children are watching and listening to television and radio at

all times of day and night

58. Broadcasters dispute the NOIT's assumption that in

order to supervise their children, parents must Co-view Or CO-

74. NOI at 8363

AS6
listen with them or have specific knowledge of their viewing
or listening. Broadcasters argue that as long as parents or
other adults are present, they have the opportunity to
supervise their children’s viewing and listening. Broadcasters
maintain that examining the presence of adults as the key to
whether children are subject to adult supervision is analogous
to the methods used by courts to examine the regulation of
indecent material by cable and telephone. Rather than
examining the actual use of technical devices to block
reception of indecent material transmitted by cable or
telephone, or examining parental supervision, Broadcasters
State that courts instead analyze the opportunity to use these
methods to block reception.

59. Broadcasters commissioned a survey of 1,000
homes with children 17 and under to determine opportunities
for parental and adult supervision. According to the survey,
over 88% of children were under parental supervision and
YS were under adult supervision between the hours of 8:00
p.m. and 6:00 a.m. During the 10:00 p.m. to 6:00 a.m. period,
over 93% of children were under parental supervision and
99°, were under adult supervision. Between midnight and
6:00 a.m., over 98“ of children were under parental
supervision and 99% were under adult supervision. 75
Broadcasters Claim these data demonstrate that parents or
other adults have the opportunity to supervise their children’s
Viewing and listening during these hours.

60. MIM disputes Broadcasters’ study, arguing that
under the “opportunity for supervision” theory advanced by
Broadcasters, the study equates presence with supervision,
assumes that a child will not watch television or listen to the

radio after his or her bedume, and assumes that supervision

AS7

by anyone over the age of 18 is the equivalent of parental
supervision. 76/ AFA argues that even if a child is in the
presence of an adult, that adult may not supervise a child as a
parent would.77/ Even when parents are home, AFA argues,
there is limited parent-child co-viewing of television. AFA
submits the results of a 1989 study of co-viewing habits of
parents and children that concludes that parents generally do
not view family series with their children. The study found
that, on average, parents and second graders co-viewed 5.6
prime time and 1.96 syndicated series in the last year. Parents
and sixth graders co-viewed 7.2] prime time and 2.05
syndicated series, while parents and tenth graders co-viewed
7.63 prime time and 2.8 syndicated series. The study
determined that for all series and for prime time series only,
the mean co-viewing frequency was between something less
than “just a few times this year” and “have watched
[together], but not in the last year.” 78/ The authors of this
study claim that “parents co-view with children, particularly
when their viewing preferences coincide, and that co-viewing
is associated with generally positive parental! attitudes toward
television and specific beliefs in encouragement for children
learning from television. [The data] do not, however, suggest
that co-viewing 1s very much mouvated by an active
determination to mediate children’s television
experiences. 79/ On the other hand, USCC submits a survey
of over 8,000 parochial school students showing that 81% of
the respondents ages 12 and under, and 70% between the
ages Of 13 and 18, watch television with an adult at night

76 MIM Reply Comments at 18-149
77 AFA Reply Comments at &

78 AFA Comments at 38-39

79 Id atn he

ASS

The study also shows that 72% of the respondents ages 12
and under, and 90% between the ages of 13 and 18,
sometimes or almost never listen to radio with an adult. S80/

61. The record before us demonstrates that the
pervasiveness and accessibility of television and radio,
coupled with the lack of effective parental control
mechanisms, discussed infra, make effective parental
supervision exceedingly difficult if not impossible for the
average parent. We-noted in the NOI that 63% of television
households have more than one television set, and of the
ninety-nine percent of households with radios, each
household has, on average, over five.81/ The number of
televisions and radios in households can easily prevent a
parent from actively supervising a child's viewing and
listening habits. In a household with more than one
television, a child may watch a program without parental
knowledge. VCRs permit a child to tape a television program
for later viewing without parental knowledge. The ability to
listen to radio without parental knowledge is even greater,
given the number of radios in the average household, their
portability, and the widespread use of headphones.

62. We note, moreover, that parents’ control of
children’s television viewing and radio listening differs from
parental control of cable viewing and telephone calls.
Technical means are readily available to block children’s
access to indecent cable programs and indecent telephone
calls. Upon request, cable operators must provide a device
such as a “lock-box” or “parental key” that permits a

&0 USCC Comments at 5-6

Sl NOT at 836]

AS9Y

subscriber to restrict access to selected programming,82/ and
access codes and scrambling are among the methods which
can restrict children’s access to dial-a-porn services.83/ In
both instances, these methods can restrict access by children
whether or not parents are physically present and actively
supervise. In the case of television and radio, however, there
is no comparable means that is readily available upon which
parents may rely to prevent children from watching indecent
off-the-air broadcast television programs or listening to
indecent radio programs. Most television receivers do not
permit blocking of specific channels,84/ and channel
blocking devices are not available for radios. There is no
evidence in the record that a lock-box type of device is

82 Cable Communications Policy Act of 1984 § 624(d)(2), 47 U.S.C. §
5$44(d)(2).

83 See 47 U.S.C.A. § 223 as amended by Pub. L. 101-66, 103 Stat
1159, 1192-1194 (1989); Regulations Concerning Indecent
Communications by Telephone (Report and Order), FCC No. 90-230,
adopted June 14, 1990.

S4 In reply comments, Broadcasters submit a list compiled by the
Consumers Union of selected television models currently sold in the
United States. Broadcasters claim that over 120 models are equipped with
a channel blocking feature that prevents unauthorized access. to channels
Broadcasters Reply Comments n.14, Appendix 5. Virtually all of the
televisions on this list have at least a tweniy-inch screen and, Judging by
the list price, appear to be color televisions. Broadcasters provide no data
showing the market share held by these models. No commenters
submitted evidence as to whether channe! blocking devices for
attachment to existing television sets are available. Furthermore,
Broadcasters offer no information as to how channel blocking works,
particularly whether a channel blocking feature completely prevents
access to a particular channel or whether it may easily be circumvented
Moreover, most television sets used in homes today do not have any
blocking mechanism. Finally, no party has submitted evidence regarding
the feasibility of using televisions with channel blocking in this context

or of the market penetration of these televisions

A60)

available for attachment to televisions and radios to prevent
access to specific channels. Therefore, because parents
cannot rely on technical devices to prevent children from
viewing indecent programs, parents can effectively supervise
their children only by co-viewing or co-listening, or, at 4
minimum, by remaining actively aware of what their children
are watching at all times. As many concerned parents filing
comments in this proceeding emphasized, however, it is not
practical for parents to exercise this type of control. The letter
of Elizabeth Urquhart of Houston, Texas, addressed to
Commissioner Duggan, succinctly sums up the point made in
a large number of other letters submitted in this proceeding in
Stating that “[I]}t is not a matter of my responsibility to
monitor. A person (parent) would have to be super human to
monitor every program a child might watch in and out of our
home [sic]."85

63. We do not believe that Broadcasters’ study

SS Many letters submiticd in this proceeding emphasizcd the
impossibility of close supervision. Representative of these are th
toliowing five. Mrs. Barbara Gious of Warsaw.. Indiana, wrote: “} havc
two teenage boys who have their own walkmans and tape recorders

There 1s no way that | can know what they are listening to all the time.
Donald and Sandra Lee of Irving, Texas stated: “As working parents. our
children have access to television at umes when neither my husband nor
myself are available to screen their viewing. The radio ts available
everywhere they go and it 1s equally offensive... .” Yvonne Thomas of
Boonsboro, Maryland. a public school teacher, wrote “Many children live
alone with a television as both parents are working.” Another teacher,
Ann Davis of Shrewsbury. Pennsylvania, wrote: “I tuned in the radio
about 6 A.M. to see if any of the schools had been delaved [due to
inclement weather]. This was the station suggested at school to listen to. |
heard the most foul language and sexual innuendos I'd ever heard in
public I had to ask [my son] to leave the room saying that | would let
him know when the announcement was made.” Cheryl Maver of
Bronson, Michigan, reported: “As | was driving my four children to

school one morning, around 7.30, | was appalled at what | heard on a

radio Station iwo DJ's were being very crude~

A6l

demonstrates that parental presence alone can adequately
protect children from indecent broadcast programming.
Broadcasters’ data show that at no me during the day are all
children under parental supervision. Even during the period
of time from 1:00 a.m. to 6:00 a.m., the survey found that
1.2% of the children were neither with a parent nor asleep.86/
Since children are in the broadcast audience during this
period, it is not unlikely that some of these children could
watch indecent programming broadcast late at night. In
addition, although the survey asked parents if the child in
question was “in the presence of at least one parent,
stepparent, or legal guardian,” the term “presence” was
apparently undefined. A respondent may have answered that
the child was in the “presence” of a parent even if the child
was awake in another part of the home and the parent asleep.
Nor did the survey ask what parents were doing during the
hours that they were in the presence of children. Because
there 1s no technical means to prevent children from viewing
or listening to particular programs, supervision requires
parents either to co-view or co-listen, or to remain actively
aware of a child's viewing or listening at all times. As a
practical matter, mere “presence’ in the same house as a
child does not necessarily translate into supervision

64. Commenters have not disputed our estimates of
the amount of unsupervised television viewing by children.
Our analysis. based on a 1980 study of 817 American
households with children between the ages of 5 and 17,
estimated that the maximum amount of unsupervised
children’s daily viewing ranges from 212 to 222 minutes and

the minimum ranges from 40 to 54 minutes.87/ We also

56 Broadcasters Comments, Appendix (. Jab!

$7 NOI at 8363 and Appendix B. Tat

Aé2
estimated that among children in certain age groups the
maximum amount of unsupervised children’s daily viewing
could range from 357 to 375 minutes, if we assume that all of
a child’s viewing in two-television households occurs on a
separate set from the parents’.88/ The NOI also suggested
that the number of radios in households made a substantia!
amount of unsupervised radio listening by children likely.
The data submitted by the parties to this proceeding do not
refute these estimates. In any event, the record-demonstrates
that parents cannot always provide meaningful supervision,
even when they are present at home. Accordingly, we
conclude that there is a substantial amount of unsupervised
viewing and listening by children, and that as a practical!
matter; the pervasiveness and technology of broadcasting
serve to deny parents the means necessary to exercise
effective control over these activities.

d. Conclusions

65. The above evidence indicates that there Is a
reasonable risk that significant numbers of children are in the
audience for radio and television broadcasts at all umes of
the day and night. The number of children present, moreover,
clearly is more than “a few of the most enterprising and
disobedient young people.” Sable, 109 S. Ct. at 2838. For
example, evidence submitted by the commenters indicates
that, in all time frames measured, a higher percentage of al!
children between the ages of 12 and 17 listen to radio than
the percentage of all adults age 18 and over, even between
midnight and 6 a.m.89 Although some commenters claim

that }2 to 17 vear olds listening between midnight and 6 a.m
BA Id

KY MIM Comments at 42-62. Salem Reply Comments at Exhibrt |. NRE
Renly, Comments at Exhibit 2: sec also NOL at S36] and Appendix 1B

Table: sand 4

A63
during any quarter hour make up only 0.35% of the total!
population,90/ this figure represents a full 716,000 children
between the ages of 12 and 17.91/

66. Similarly, the record demonstrates that there ts a
reasonable risk that a significant number of children are in
the television audience throughout the broadcast day and
night. As previously noted, avaliable data show that children
particularly those between the ages of 12 and 17, are m the
viewing audience until the last time period reported for
television ratings. The data further show that as high a
percentage of children ages 12 to 17 as adults watch
television during the late evening hours. Indeed, for the |
to 2:00 a.m. ume period, one commenter has estimated tt
there are over 970,000 12 to 17 year olds in the televisior

+.

audience.92/ These figures, of course, do not take into
consideration the number of children who may be using
VCRs between midnight to 6 a.m. to record televisior
programs for viewing at a later time

67. The data further show that a significant
children in the broadcast audience are not subject t
parental supervision, even during the late evening and ea!
morning hours. Although Broadcasters have submitted
Study alleging that many children are under “parenta!
Supervision” at all umes of the broadcast day, the st
not establish that parents in fact acuvely Supervise |

“9 MIM Comments at 42-62: Salem Reply ¢
Reply Comments at Exhibit 2. see also NOI at 536) \

Tables 3 and 4

y KDVS Reply ( omments at 3 {

4) NOL at Appendia B. Tabk

Ao4
children’s viewing and listening of radio and television:
rather, it shows only that most children are usually in the
“presence” of an adult, an undefined term that leaves open
the possibility that children may be watching or listening to a
television or radio while their parents (or other adults) are in
other parts of the house or are asleep. The record, moreover,
indicates that children engage in unsupervised viewing and
listening throughout the day and night not because of a lack
of concern by parents, but because of the impracticality of
total supervision that derives from a combination of the
technology involved and the lack of available and eftective
parental control devices.

68. In sum, the evidence establishes that, given the
pervasiveness and accessibility of radio and television,
unsupervised children in pursuit of entertainment need be
neither “enterprising” nor “disobedient” to turn on a
television or radio, or to record a program on a VCR, al any
time of day or night. Accordingly, we conclude that there
exists a reasonable risk that a sufficient number of children
are in the broadcast audience at all times to warrant
narrowly-tailored government regulation of indecent
broadcasting aimed both at facilitating parental supervision
and promoting the well-being of youth. Such regulation is
particularly necessary since, as previously discussed, a wide
range of sexually explicit and patently offensive material
may be encompassed within the definition of “indecency.“93

E. Alternatives to 24-Hour Prohibition

69. The NOI solicited comment on alternatives to a
24-hour prohibition, including (1) channeling indecent
broadcasts to a time of dav when children most likely will not

+

93 See 1% 19-2]. supra

A65
be exposed to them; (2) using program rating codes or pre-
broadcast warnings to protect children; and (3) relying upon
broadcast technologies to limit children’s access. After
careful consideration of the record, we conclude that none of
these options can effectively advance our interest in
protecting children from indecency and, accordingly, that a
24-hour prohibition is the most narrowly tailored means of
serving this compelling government interest.

1. Time Channeling

70. Time channeling would establish a specific time
period during which non-obscene, but indecent adult-oriented
programming could be aired. The feasibility of this
alternative depends on whether indecent broadcasts could be
channeled to hours when it is unlikely that children would be
in the audience. We conclude that, based on the data

indicating that there 1s 4 reasonable risk that children are
present in the viewing anqJistening audience at all times,
there is no time when the reasonable risk of children in the
audience is sufficiently low to make their exposure to

indecent programs unlikely. Accordingly, we conclude that it
would not be possible for broadcast stations, as a general
matter, to channel indecent material! to certain times of the
broadcast day without risk that a sigaificant number of
children will be watching or listening without meaningful

parental supervision

71. Broadcasters argue that channeling broadcasts to
times of day when parents have an opportunity to supervise
their children gives parents a meaningful opportunity to
prevent children’s access to indecent programs.94/ A 24-hour
prohibition, argue Broadcasters, places government in the

94 Broadcasters Comments at 21

EEE

A66

position of deciding what children should see and hear.95/
KDVS suggests that the Commission implement time
channeling during school days, when there is a reduced risk
that children would be in the broadcast audience.96/ Other
parties, however, note that a number of children are alone
during various times of the day.97/ In this regard, we note
that ACT | affirmed the Commission's regulation of a
daytime indecent broadcast.98/

72. Finally, AFA argues that the effectiveness of a
time channeling approach is diminished by the proliferation
of VCRs, claiming that an estimated seventy-five to eighty
percent of households with children have VCRs.99/ KD VS
counters AFA’s claim, arguing that most VCRs are
purchased by parents, frequently for the personal use of their
children, and that parents therefore must be aware of the
possibility that their children may use VCRs to tape
broadcast programming. l00

73. After further consideration of time channeling, we

96 KDVS Comments at 7-8. KDVS submits data from a 1983 Arbitron
survey of the San Francisco metropolitan area showing that teens
comprise one to four percent of the total television broadcast audience
duriny the day

97 AFA Comments at 36-37: Lynda Beams (Beams) Reply Comments
at 8-9 and Exhibit G:; Bonneville Comments at &

98 ACT I, 882 F.2d at 1341

99 AFA Comments at 29. See also Salem Reply Comments at 63. noic
#2. in which Salem cites a 1990 Nielsen study showing that over 14°. of
VCR taping ts done from 11:00 p.m. to 6:00 a.m.. and over 50% Ot VCR

recordings are made when the television is turned off

lOO KDVS Reply Comments at 6

A67

conclude that we cannot identify a time when the reasonable
risk of children in the audience is sufficiently low to make
their unsupervised viewing of indecent programs
unlikely.101/ We have determined that at all times there is a
reasonable risk that significant numbers of children are in the
broadcast audience for television and radio. The proliferation
of VCRs further undermines a channeling approach for
television, for, as AFA noted, a majority of households with
children have VCRs that children may operate to tape a
program. Clearly, many teens and even younger children
know how to use the recording and playback functions of a
VCR. As a result, delayed viewing on a VCR provides
children with access to programs broadcast at a time when
their live viewing is least likely.

74. Broadcasters’ argument that siations should be
permitted to channel indecent programming to times of day
when parents have an opportunity to supervise their children,
moreover, fails to address the impracticality of parents
Supervising their children’s listening and viewing 24 hours a
day.102/ The record in this case includes thousands of letters
from parents addressing this issue and convinces us that
parents who wish to exercise such supervision do not have
the tools or time available to do so because of the
pervasiveness of the broadcast media and the lack of
effective parental control devices.1U3/ Although
101 For this reason. we overrule the conclusion reached 1n the
Reconsideration Order, 3 FCC Red 930 (1987), that time channeling 1s an
effective means of controlling children’s access to indecent broadcasting.

102 Indeed, it appears that the most effective means for parents to
actively supervise their children’s listening and viewing activities Is to
remove all televisions and radios. This result not only is highly
impractical, but also would deprive families of the many benefits of the

broadcast media

103 See n.85, supra

A68

Broadcasters’ study attempts to show that opportunities for
parental supervision are extensive, it fails to demonstrate that
meaningful parental supervision is possible as a practical
matter.104/ Indeed, in view of the substantial amount of
unsupervised viewing and listening by children, the number
of children who are without parental supervision and the
factors interfering with parental ability to supervise
children’s viewing and listening effectively, we must
conclude that time channeling would be an ineffective means
of protecting children from broadcast indecency.

75. Several commenters also argue that, because the
Commission's definition of indecency and its indecency
enforcement policies are allegedly vague, unless a time
channeling approach 1s adopted in lieu of a 24-hour
prohibition, the threat of sanctions could deter some
broadcasters from presenting programs that are not actually
indecent.105/ C&M maintains that time channeling
recognizes the rights of broadcasters to transmit
constitutionally protected indecent speech and the rights of
listeners to receive indecent programming. 106/ This request
for a “safe harbor’ to present indecent programming reflect~
a belief that a broadcaster cannot determine with any degree
of certainty whether a specific program violates the
guidelines adopted in this proceeding. This is incorrect. Our
definition of indecency. read in conjunction with our
decisions in enforcement actions, provides licensees
sufficient guidance to decide whether a program would be
indecent.

104. See 98 57-64. supra
10S See Post Comments at 1-2: Cox Comments at 24-25

106 C&M Comments at 28-30

'

A69
2. Ratings and Warning Devices

76. Another alternative to a 24-hour prohibition of
broadcast indecency is the use of a voluntary industry ratings
code for television and radio broadcasts. The ratings, which
would be published in television and radio guides and
announced prior to each program, would alert the viewer or
listener to the content of the program. We conclude that
ratings and warnings would not effectively limit children’s
exposure to indecent programming, since this method would
require parents to actively supervise their children’s listening
and viewing at all hours and in all locations. The
effectiveness of ratings and warnings Is further reduced by
random tuning behavior known as “grazing,” in which
viewers use television remote control or radio scanning
devices to rapidly tune through the entire channel menu until
they find something interesting enough to hold their
attention.

77. The NOI requested comment regarding the use of
a Voluntary industry ratings code for television and radio
broadcasts. However, the NOI expressed doubt that ratings
and warnings would prevent minors from viewing or
listening to indecent programming because the broadcast
audience is constantly tuning in and out of programs, and
suggested that random tuning behavior may be even more
prevalent today than when Pacifica was decided in 1978.107/
The NOI suggested that children could be exposed to
different programming in rapid succession without warning
as to content either because they graze or because they are
co-viewing with others who are grazing. :
107) NOI at 8363 and n.44. The Pacifica Court noted, “Because the
broadcast audience 1s constantly tuning in and out, prior warnings cannot
completely protect the listener or viewer from unexpected program
content.” 438 US at 738

A70

78. Several commenters address the possible use of
ratings and warning devices. USCC and KDVS suggest that a
combined time channeling and ratings system could be
effective.108/ However, AFA and Salem surggest that ratings
require parental supervision in order to be effective.109/
Other commenters fear that an indecency warning could
attract children to a particular broadcast! 10/ or that a warning
could serve to “license” an indecent broadcast by warning the
viewer of content.111/ Several commenters also specifically
responded to the Commission’s discussion of grazing.
Broadcasters submits a study conducted by Arbitron and
NAB of 13,000 radio listeners aged 12 and over showing that
this group listened to an average of 2.99 radio stations per
week.112/ Broadcasters concludes that this study indicates
that neither adults nor children engage in significant random
tuning for radio. Pacifica claims that radio listeners.
especially those who listen to noncommercial radio stations,
do not engage in grazing.113/ On the other hand, others
contend that grazing is prevalent.1] 14,

79. We conclude that ratings and warnings would not
effectively limit children’s exposure to indecent

108 USCC Comments at 6: KDVS Comments at |
109 AFA Comments at 46; Salem Reply Comments at 72.

110 Beams Reply Comments at If!; Salem Reply Comments at 72: AFA

Comments at 46

111 MIM Reply Comments at 30)

112 Broadcasters Reply Comments at 9, n.17
113 Pacifica Comments at 21-23

114 AFA Comments at 44-46. 1.65; Salem Reply Comments at 72. 1 105:
MIM Reply Comments at 35-36.

A7]

programming. Currently there is no device which would
‘permit a parent to “lock out” programming. Unless it were
| practical for parents to supervise viewing at all times, a child
_may ignore a warning and view or listen to indecent
programming. Indeed, a warning may attract a child’s
attention and lead the child to view or listen to the program.
rhis is of particular concern because of the significant
amounts of unsupervised viewing and listening by children.
We also believe that grazing is sufficiently common to
reduce the effectiveness of ratings, even if a child is
supervised. Grazing and channel changing by either a parent
ora child may cause the viewer or listener to miss a content
-warning.115/ We believe the study cited by Broadcasters
indicating the average number of radio stations listened to per
week is not relevant in determining whether grazing occurs.
Grazing involves turning to a number of channels in a short
period of time, and such rapid switching may not be rejected
in ratings. Broadcasters do not state whether the study asked
listeners if they engaged in grazing to find those channels, or
it they ever engaged in grazing. Therefore, we conclude that
lack of parental supervision, coupled with the proclivity of
viewers and listeners to graze, would undermine the efficacy
of a system of ratings and warnings.

Wie oa

meting

3. Broadcast Technologies

80. The NOI requested comment on whether there are
feasible broadcast technologies that could restrict children’s
access to indecent broadcasts. We conclude that although
such technology may be feasible, no such technologies are
currently available to the public for this purpose.

115 We note that the broadcast in question in Pacifica was heard by a

man While driving with his young son, and that the parent apparently
missed the warning aired before the broadcast. Pacifica, 438 U.S. at 730.

A72

81. The NOI suggested that the FM or television aural
subcarrier could be used for the broadcast of audio
indecency. The subcarrier signal would be receivable only by
special decoders. Salem supports the NOI’s assessment that
subcarriers could be used to provide audio indecency — Salem
maintains that an FM station could install a subcarrier signal
generator at minimal expense, and that decoders for home
use Currently cost approximately $60, but could be expected
to fall in price if produced in large quantities.116/ John W.
Olivo, Jr., suggests use of a signal that would permit
electronic blocking of programs by home receivers. KDVS,
however, Suggests that alternative broadcast technologies
may not be financially feasible for many broadcasters,
particularly noncommercial stations. | 1 7/

82. As another alternative, NRB suggests that the
Commission permit the broadcast of scrambled indecent
material at anv hour.118/ Kennedy Broadcasting
(“Kennedy”) similarly suggests that low power television
(LPTV) stations be permitted to offer adult-oriented
programming if scrambled. NRB and Kennedy argue that the
decoder necessary to view scrambled programming would
protect children from indecent material in much the same
way as a Cable lock-box or parental ke

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385010_2113%3A2. Public record. Not legal advice.
