# Appendix — Chemical Manufacturers Ass'n v. U. S. Environmental Protection Agency

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385009_0087%3A2

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Appendix
- **Published:** January 1, 1982
- **Citation:** 459 U.S. 879

## Text

ak

-

INDEX TO APPENDIX

inion of the Court in Natural Resources Defense Coun-
cil, Inc. v. EPA, Nos. 80-1607, et al. (D.C. Cir., March
RR SIS CR SR, Dgeeaie Le ee A-1

Order of the Court Denying Motion to Dismiss in Natural
Resources Defense Council, Inc. v. EPA, Nos. 80-1607,

et al. (D.C. Cir., March 2, 1982) ................. A-16
List of Petitioners’ Parent Companies, Sub-
oe ag Affiliates Pursuant to Supreme Court Rule

Een tn cRsGE COOKS ob bed GO eREeenda EW s «on 60s A-17

A-l

United States Court of Appeals

FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT

No. 80-1607
NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL, INC., PETITIONER
Vv.

U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY and
ANNE M. GORSUCH, ADMINISTRATOR,
U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, RESPONDENTS

CHEMICAL MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION,
AMERICAN IRON & STEEL INSTITUTE,
EDISON ELECTRIC INSTITUTE, ET AL., INTERVENORS

And Consolidated Cases Nos. 80-1660, 80-1723, 80-1733,
80-1740, 80-1741, 80-1809, 20-1821, 80-1837, 80-1875,
80-1881, 80-1889, 80-1909, 80-1914, 80-1915, 80-1923,
80-1924, 80-1927, 80-1928, 80-1929, 80-1931, 80-1932,
80-1934, 80-1955, 80-1966, 80-1970, 80-1975, 80-1978,
80-1984, 80-1987, 80-1989, 80-1999, 80-2002, 80-2004,
80-2007, 80-2114, 80-2279, 80-2521, 81-1569, 81-1570,
81-1571, 81-1572, 81-1573, 81-1574, 81-1575, 81-1576,
81-1577, 81-1578, 81-1579, 81-1708, 81-1709, 81-1746,
81-1747, 81-1748, 81-1749, and 81-1750

On Motion to Dismiss

A-2
Argued December 15, 1981
Decided March 2, 1982

Gene W. Lafitte, with whom J. Berry St. John, Jr.,
George J. Domas, and Robert E. Holden were on the
brief, for petitioners American Iron and Steel Institute,
et al.

Alan W. Eckert, Acting Senior Litigator, Office of Gen-
eral Counsel, Environmental Protection Agency, with
whom Anthony Liotta, Acting Assistant Attorney Gen-
eral, Donald W. Stever, Chief, Environmental Defense
Section, and Elizabeth Stein and David T. Buente, Jr.,
Attorneys, Environmental Defense Section, were on the
brief, for respondent.

Ronald J. Wilson was on the brief for petitioner Nat-
ural Resources Defense Council, Inc.

Before BAZELON, Senior Circuit Judge, and MIKVA and
GINSBURG, Circuit Judges.

Opinion for the Court filed by Circuit Judge GINSBURG.

GINsBuURG, Circuit Judge: These consolidated cases in-
volve numerous challenges to Consolidated Permit Regu-
lations (CPR’s)' issued by the Environmental Protection
Agency (EPA). Industry petitioners? contend that in-
itial jurisdiction to review the National Pollutant Dis-

140 C.F.R. pts. 122-125 (1981).

as “industry petitioners” or simply “industry.” The Natural

A-3

charge Elimination System (NPDES) portion of the
CPR’s does not reside in this court (or any other court
of appeals).* They have moved to dismiss all petitions
for review‘ insofar as the petitions challenge NPDES-
related CPR’s. The parties have fully briefed and argued
the motion to dismiss. We hold that section 509(b) (1)
(E) of the Clean Water Act (CWA), 33 U.S.C. § 1369
(b) (1) (E) (1976), vests initial authority to review the
challenged regulations in the courts of appeals. We there-
fore deny the motion to dismiss.

I.

Section 301(a) of the Clean Water Act, 33 U.S.C.
§1311(a) (1976), forbids anyone to discharge any pol-
lutant into navigable waters except pursuant to an
NPDES permit issued under CWA § 402, 33 U.S.C.
§ 1342 (1976 & Supp. III 1979). These permits list, for
a specific discharger, the types and amounts of pollutants
that may be discharged. Section 402 requires determina-

8 Our jurisdiction to review the non-NPDES aspects of the
CPR’s is conceded and, indeed, is exclusive. See NRDC v. EPA,
No. 80-1607, slip op. at 9 (D.C. Cir. Nov. 4, 1980) (per
curiam).

* Industry petitioners seek dismissal of their own petitions
for review as well as those filed by NRDC and others. Because
of uncertainty as to the appropriate forum for initial review
of the NPDES-related CPR’s, both NRDC and some of the
industry petitioners have sought to challenge these CPR’s by
filing complaints in district courts. See NRDC v. EPA, No.
80-1607, slip op. at 12 n.10 (D.C. Cir. Nov. 4, 1980) (per
curiam) (collecting cases). If we were to grant the motion to
dismiss, these district courts would have to decide if they had
general federal question jurisdiction to entertain the pending
complaints. See 28 U.S.C.A. § 1331 (West Cum. Supp. 1981) ;
see also E.I. du Pont de Nemours & Co. v. Train, 430 U.S.
112, 124-25 (1977) (regulations not initially reviewable in a
court of appeals under § 509(b) (1) (E) may be reviewed “only
in the District Court, if anywhere”). One district court has
already asserted that it has jurisdiction to review NPDES
regulations. American Petroleum Inst. v. Costle, No. 79-0858,
slip op. at 2 (W.D. La. July 27, 1981).

A-4

tion of the amounts listed in any given permit in com-
pliance with, inter alia, the requirements of sections 301
and 306, 33 U.S.C. §§1311, 1316 (1976 & Supp. III
1979). Those two sections, in turn, require the Adminis-
trator of EPA to establish by regulation effluent limita-
tions, based on pollution-control technology, for sources
of pollutants.*®

EPA promulgated a set of NPDES regulations in 1979.
These regulations do not set any numerical limitations on
pollutant discharge. Instead, they are a complex set of
procedures for issuing or denying NPDES permits. Sev-
eral parties, uncertain as to the appropriate federal
forum, sought review in both courts of appeals and dis-
trict courts. EPA repromulgated these regulations, with
slight substantive modifications, in 1980 as part of the
CPR’s.* Once again, challenges were filed in both federal
courts of appeals and federal district courts. These chal-
lenges involve both NPDES and non-NPDES aspects of
the CPR’s. Through a complex procedural history, all
court of appeals actions have been consolidated here.”

Industry contends that no statute vests initial jurisdic-
tion in courts of appeals, so a challenge to NPDES-related
CPR’s may be instituted only under the general federal
question jurisdiction of the district courts. Thus the in-
dustry petitioners have filed their motion to dismiss. EPA

5 The Administrator may also authorize any state to run an
NPDES program in lieu of the federal program. Standards
for the Administrator’s approval of a state-run program are
essentially identical to the standards that govern the federal
i toms CWA § 402(b), 33 U.S.C, § 1342(b) (1976 & Supp.

1 ;

*For a fuller discassion of the CPR’s, which govern five

separate EPA permit programs, see NRDC v. EPA, No. 80-
1607, slip op. at 8-11 (D.C. Cir. Nov. 4, 1980) (per curiam).

’ For a partial summary of this history, see NRDC v. EPA,
No. 80-1607 (D.C. Cir. Nov. 4, 1980) (per curiam).

A-5

opposes this motion, citing CWA § 509(b) (1), 33 U.S.C.
§ 1869(b) (1) (1976), which provides:

Review of the Administrator’s action... (E) in
approving or promulgating any effluent limitation or
other limitation under section 1311, 1312, or 131([6]
of this title . . . may be had by any interested person
ae ee oe ee Oe

tates....

EPA contends that this statutory section covers the
NPDES-related CPR’s.®

II.

Section 509(b) (1) (E) authorizes the courts of appeals
to review the promulgation of “any effluent limitation or
other limitation under [CWA § 301, 302, or 306,] section
1311, 1312, or 131[6] of this title.” “Effluent limitation”
is defined in CWA §502(11), 33 U.S.C. § 1362(11)
(1976), as “any restriction established by a State or the
Administrator on quantities, rates, and concentrations of
. . « constituents which are discharged . . . , including
schedules of compliance.” At first glance, one might read
subsection E to confine this court’s review to EPA’s
establishment of numerical limitations on pollutant dis-
charges.’ Two aspects of the statutory language itself,
however, indicate that the provision has a wider range:
(1) subsection E authorizes review of an “other limita-
tion,” not just an effluent limitation; and (2) section
502(11) defines “effluent limitation” as “any restriction”

* EPA also asserts that we have initial review authority
under 33 U.S.C. § 1869(b) (1) (D) (1976) and under the doc-
trine of ancillary jurisdiction. Because we find § 509(b) (1) (E)
a sufficient basis for our authority to review the NPDES-
related CPR’s, we express no opinion on EPA’s other argu-
ments.

*Cf. Montgomery Envtl. Coalition v. Costle, 646 F.2d 568,
574 (D.C. Cir. 1980) (“{E]fluent limitations are technical
specifications of the quantities of various polluting substances
that a permittee may lawfully discharge.”’).

A-6

on the amounts of pollutants discharged, not just a num-
erical restriction.

The phrase “effluent limitation or other limitation” in
section 509(b) (1) (E)" has in fact been interpreted to
include more than numerical limitations. In NRDC v.
EPA, No. 79-1639 (D.C. Cir. May 7, 1981), we addressed
a challenge to regulations governing applications for vari-
ances from the limitations imposed on municipal sewage
plants. Those regulations set no numerical limitatione;
instead they establish “criteria and standards to be ap-
plied by EPA in acting on . . . requests for modifications
to the secondary treatment requirements.” 40 C.F.R.
§ 125.56 (1981). We rejected a challenge to our juris-
diction because “[a]s a practical matter [the regulations]
restrict the discharge of sewage by limiting the avail-
ability of a variance to a class of applicants which does
not include all coastal municipalities.” Slip op. at 12.

In VEPCO v. Costle, 566 F.2d 446 (4th Cir. 1977),
the challenge was to standards regulating the construc-
tion and design of cooling water intake structures. The
court agreed that these standards were not effluent limita-

“This phrase also appears in § 505, 38 U.S.C. § 1365

A-7

tions because they were “concerned with structures... ,
not with discharges.” Id. at 449. Nonetheless, the court
held the standards reviewable as an “other limitation”:
“([T)he . . . regulations here do refer to information
that must be considered in determining the type of in-
take structures that individual point sources may employ,
and, by that token, they are iimitations.” Jd. at 450.

One court, however, has adopted the position industry
urges here. In American Iron & Steel Institute (AISI) v.
EPA, 543 F.2d 521 (3d Cir. 1976), the court held that
it had no jurisdiction to review EPA’s “net /gross” regu-
lation, which states when a permittee may receive a
“credit” for pollutants in its intake water, and a revised
version of which is contained in section 122.63(g) and
(h) of the CPR’s. The court held that the net/gross
regulation was not an effluent limitation because it merely
Sgn the policy and procedures to be followed

in connection with applications for permits.” 543 F.2d
at 526.

We believe the approach taken in NRDC and VEPCO
is sounder than that taken in AJS/. First, of course,
NRDC is binding precedent in this circuit, and in NRDC
we specifically rejected the reasoning of AISI. NRDC,
slip op. at 13. Second, the A/JS/ court. «unlike the Fourth
Cireuit in VEPCO, did not consider ..e possibility that
something that was not an “effluent limitation” could none-
theless be an “effluent limitation or other limitation.” “
Third, the AISI court seemed more concerned with the
timing of judicial review than with identification of the

™ Because § 509(b) (1) (E) provides for our review of both
effluent limitations and other limitations, we see no need to
determine that the CPR’s are one or the other. It suffices that
RR fg ry Re ee Fry: Compare
NRDC v. EPA, No. 79-1639, slip op. at 14 (D.C. Cir. May 7,
1981) (“effluent limitations”). with VEPCO v. Costle, 566
F.2d 446, 449-50 (4th Cir. 1977) (“other limitation”).

A-8

forum for review; thus the court may have blended

actions to be reviewed in courts of appeals rather than
district courts.“ In short, the issue as it is presented

2 See, e.g., 543 F.2d at 528 (declining to consider net/gross
regulation “at this stage” and “in the absence of a full and
comprehensive record”); id. at 529 (“The issue of district

% AISI was cited in support of our decision in Diamond
Shamrock Corp. v. Costle, 580 F.2d 670, 674 (D.C. Cir. 1978),

that a net/gross regulation was not ripe for review. The
parties have not yet briefed the issue of the ripeness of the
CPR’s, and we do today hold that any of them are ripe

not
for review. We hold only that this court has authority

196-97 (1980) (per curiam) ; E.I. du Pont de Nemours & Co
v. Train, 430 U.S. 112, 127 n.18 (1977); VEPCO v. Costle,
566 F.2d 446, 447 (4th Cir. 1977)

in a court of appeals. Compare CWA § 509(b) (1) (six
specified categories of actions under CWA) with. e.¢., Clean
Air Act §307(b)(1), 42 U.S.C. $7607(b)(1) (Supp. Ill
1979) (eight specific categories and “any other nationally
applicable regulations promulgated, or final action taken”).
Industry petitioners argue that if the CPR’s are reviewable
directly in a court of appeals, virtually any action
reviewable, thus contravening the

|
i

|
|

ag8
It
Hi
3
Hi
iH
ttl

|
|
.

A-9

SETHE PHM PHN Be
TEN BE ; Woe fi dichal att
itt iil bhi Ee
rigtifes PSeny eet Thy
files ceil tie tee i:
5 i sail pithy tH!
Hi aeaks aga 33 :

Thums Long Beach Company
West Shore Pipe Line Company
Wolverine Pipe Line Company "

STANDARD OIL COMPANY (INDIANA)
Subsidiaries and Affiliates

TEXACO INC.
Subsidiaries and Affiliates

New Zealand Refining Company Limited, The
South Africa Oil Refinery (Proprietary) Ltd.
Batangas Land Company Inc.

Changi Airport Fuel Hydrant Installation Pte. Lid.
Ndola Oil Storage Company Limited

Central African Petroleum Refineries (Private) Ltd.
East African Oil Refineries Limited

H. C. Sleigh Limited

Societe Malgache de Raffinage

Societe Reunionnaise d'Entroposage (S.R.E.)
Cia. Refinadora Petrolera Santo Domingo Inc.
Deutsche Transalpine Ollejtung GmbH

A-52

Forenade Syenska Oljeimportorers AB

Frevlig A.G.

Gas Natural Colombiana S.A.

Ghana Bunkering Services Limited

Iranian Oil Participants Limited

Iranian Oil Services (Holdings) Limited

Irish Refining Company Limited

Maghreb Gaz S.A.

Mainline Pipelines Limited

Miland Ariport Refueling Services, S.p.A. (MARS)
Mitsui- Texaco Chemicals Co., Ltd.

Montreal Pipe Line Company Limited

N.V. Rotterdam Rijn Pijpleiding Maatschappij
Oberheinische Mineralolwerke G.m.b.H.

Pars Investment Corporation

Pipelines of Puerto Rico, Inc., The

Raffinerie du Sud-Quest S.A.

Refinery Services Company S.A.

Rheem del Eduador C.A.

Rhein-Mein Rohrleitungstransportgesellschaft m.b.H.

Societa Italiana per |’Oleodotto Transalpino S.p.A.

Societa per Azioni Raffineria Padana Olii Minerali
(SARPOM)

Societe Africaine de Raffinage S.A. (SAR)

Societe Anonyme de la Raffinereie des Antilles (SARA)

Societe D’Entreposage de Bobo-Dioulasso

Societe Camerounaise d’Entreposage (SCE)

Societe Dakaroise d’Entreposage S.A. (SDE)

Societe d’Entreposage de San Pedro S.A. (SESP)

£ ciete d’Entreposage Petrolier au Burundi S.A.R.L.
(SEP-BURUNDI)

Societe De ManutentionDes Carburants Aviation Dakar
Yoff (SMACADY)

Societe Gabonaise de Raffinage (SOGARA)

A-53

Societe Gabonaise d’Entreposage du Produits Petroliers
S.A. (STEPP)

Societe Togalaise d’Entreposage S.A. (STE)

Svensk Petroleum Forvaltning Aktiebolag

Tankanglage AG Ruemlang (TAR)

Texaco Mexicana, S.A.

Transalpine Finance Holdings S.A.

Transalpine Olleitung in Osterreich GmbH

Trinidad Asphalt Holdings Limited

Trinidad Northern Areas Limited

Trintovac Developments Limited

Refineria Texaco de Honduras, S.A.

Texaco Agro-Industrial (Nigeria) Limited

Quimica Industrial “FIDES” Ss. A.

Texaco Canada Inc.

Public Fuel Transmission Systems Limited

Great Eastern Oil & Import Co. Limited, The

Texaco Norway A/S

Deutsche Texaco Aktiengesellschaft

Texaco Portugal Prospeccaoe Producao, S.A.R.L.

Texaco North Sea Norway A/S

Texaco Gabon

Texaco Togo

Zaire-Texaco S.A.R.L.

Texaco Nigeria Limited

Texaco-Cities Service Pipe Line Company

Tadlagaz S.A.

American Overseas Petroleum Limited

Bunkerservice Brunsbuttel G.m.b.H.

Societe Ivoirienne De Futs et D'Emballages
(SOGUILUBE) (See Texaco Africa Lid.)

Caltex Petroleum Corporation

Australian Lubricating Oil Refinery Limited

Phoenicia Oil Company S.A.L.

Botany Bay Tanker Company (Australia) Pty. Limited

Sydney Metropolitan Pipeline Pty. Limited

Koa Oil Company, Limited

A-54

Mediterranean Refining Company

Nippon Petroleum Refining Company, Ltd.

Tokyo Tanker Company, Limited

Caltex Deutschland G.m.b.H.

Caltex Mediterranean Limited

Condea Chemie G.m.b.H.

Federated Pipe Lines Lid.

Flexibox G.m.b.H.

LPG de Panama, S.A.

Pembroke Capital Company Inc.

P.T. Caltex Pacific Indonesia

Pev ogas, S.A.

Texaco Maroc

Societe Ivoirienne D’ Avitaillements Portuaires (S.1.A.P.)

Societe Ivoirienne D’Entrepasage De Produits Petroliers
(S.LE.P.P.)

Badger Pipe Line Company

Bayonne Industries, Inc.

Canyon Reef Carriers, Inc.

Colonial Pipeline Company

Coltexo Corporation

Dixie Pipeline Company

Explorer Pipeline Company

Felix Oil Company

Kaw Pipe Line Company

Laurel Pipe Line Company

LOCAP Inc.

LOOP Inc.

Olympic Pipe Line Company

Portland Pipe Line Corporation

Texas-New Mexico Pipe Line Company

THUMS Long Beach Company

West Shore Pipe Line Company

Wolverine Pipe Line Company

Wyco Pipe Line Company

Aircraft Fuel Supply B.V.

Airport Refueling Services S.p.A.

Aktiebolaget Svensk Petroleumlagring

A-55

United Kingdom Oil Pipelines Limited
Unterflur Betankungsanlage A.G. (UBAG)
West Australian Natural Gas Pty. Limited
Zaire Services des Entreprises Petrolieres (Zaire S.E.P.)
Aktiebol Dj ist

Association Petroliere Belge

Aviation Fueling Services, S.A.

Aviation Service Center

Compagnie Entreposage Communautaire
Singapore Refining Company Private Limited
Societe Belge de Transport Par Pipeline S.A.
Societe de Cabotage Petrolier S.A.

Societe du Pipeline Sud-European S.A.
Societe Nationale de Raffinage

Svensk Petroleumadministration AB

Total Centrafricaine de Gestion

Societe Agricole des Enterprises Petrolieres
Union des Raffineurs Belges

Svensk Petroleumlargring Tre Aktienbolag
Societe Cameranaise des Depots Petroleirs (SCDP)
TNPL

AK Chemie GmbH & Co. KG

Bergemann KG

Braunkohle-Benzin AG

Knoops & Muller Mineralolhandel GmbH
Karlsruhe-Stuttgart Rohrleitung GmbH
Bremer Mineralolhandel GmbH

Dannenberg & Co. Mineralolhandel GmbH
Mdina Weave Ltd.

W. Knierim & Co. Mineralolhaldel GmbH
Boske & Co. Mineralolhandel GmbH
HoeTex Beteiligungsgellschaft mbH
Bayonne Industries, Inc.

Canyon Reef Carriers, Inc.

Colonial Pipeline Company

Coltexo Corporation

Dixie Pipeline Company

Explorer Pipeline Company

A-56

Felix Oil Company

Kaw Pipe Line Company

Laurel Pipe Line Company

LOCAP Inc.

LOOP Inc.

Olymp'c Pipe Line Company

Portland Pipe Line Corporation
Texas-New Mexico Pipe Line Company
THUMS Long Beach Company

West Shore Pipe Line Company
Wolverine Pipe Line Company

Wyco Pipe Line Company

Aircraft Fuel Supply B.V.

Airport Refueling Services S.p.A.
Aktiebolaget Svensk Petroleumlagring
United Kingdom Oil Pipelines Limited
Unterflur Betankungsanlage A.G. (UBAG)
West Australian Natural Gas Pty. Limited
Zaire Services des Entreprises Petrolieres (Zaire S.E.P.)
Aktiebolaget Djurgardsberg

Wichmann Beteiligungsgesellschaft mbH
Caluplast Farbenfabriken Wichmann
Zerssen Mineralolhandel GmbH & Co. GmbH

UNION OIL COMPANY OF CALIFORNIA

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

A-57

Duachita Fertilizer Company, Inc.
P-M-S West, Inc.

Sanitation, Inc.
Sepulveda Oil and Gas Company
Southcap Pipe Line Company
Superior Deshler Co.

Union Oil Company of Canada, Ltd.
Unoco (Philippines), Inc.

Van Salt Water Disposal Company

Corporate Petitioners in Virginia Electric and Power Company, et al.
v. EPA, D.C. Cir. Nos. 81-1569 and 81-1572
ALABAMA POWER COMPANY
Parent
The Southern Company
Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Alabama Property Company
Southern Electric Generating Co.

ALLEGHENY POWER SYSTEM, INC.
Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Allegheny Power Service Corp.
Monongahela Power Co.
The Potomac Edison Co.

Allegheny Pittsburgh Coal Co.
West Penn Power Co.

West Virginia Power & Transmission Co.
West Penn West Virginia Water Power Co.

AMERICAN ELECTRIC POWER COMPANY, INC.
Subsidiaries and Affiliates
Appalachian Power Company

A-58

Cedar Coal Co.

Central Appalachian Coal Co.
Central Coal Co.

Central Operating Co.
Kanawha Valley Power Co.
Southern Appalachian Coal Co.
West Virginia Power Co.
Franklin Real Estate Co.
Indiana Franklin Realty, Inc.
Indiana & Michigan Electric Co.
Indiana & Michigan Power Co.
Castlegate Coal Co., Inc.
Kentucky Power Co.
Kingsport Power Co.

Ohio Power Co.
Southern Oil Coal Co.
Central Ohio Coal Co.
Windsor Power House Coal Co.
Twin Branch Railroad Co.
Beech Bottom Power Co.

Ohio Valley Electric Corp.

CAROLINA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY
Subsidiaries and Affiliates
Capitan Corporation
Carolinas-Virginia Nuclear Power Assn., Inc.

ye

A-59

CENTRAL AND SOUTH WEST SERVICES, INC.
Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Central Power and Light Company
Public Service Company of Oklahoma
Transok Pipe Line Co.

Ash Creek Mining Co.
Southwestern Electric Power Company
Southwest Arkansas Utilities Corp.
Arklahoma Corp.

West Texas Utility Company

CSR Services, Inc.

CENTRAL ILLINOIS PUBLIC SERVICE COMPANY
Subsidiaries and Affiliates

CINCINNATI GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY
Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Union Light, Heat and Power Co.
West Harrison Gas & Electric Co.
Miami Power Corp.

Lawrenceburg Gas Co.

Lawrenceburg Gas Transmission Corp.
Tri-State Improvement Co.

YGK, Inc.

CLEVELAND ELECTRIC ILLUMINATING
COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

A-60

COLUMBUS & SOUTHERN OHIO ELECTRIC CO.
Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Colomet, Inc.
Simco, Inc.

COMMONWEALTH EDISON COMPANY
Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Commonwealth Edison Co. of Indiana, Inc.
Illinois Maintenance Co.

72 West Adams Co.

Chicago & Illinois Midland Railway Co.
Medical Center Steam Co.

Nuclear Resources, Inc.

Cotter Corp.

Commonwealth Research Corp.

DETROIT EDISON COMPANY
Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Edison Illuminating Company

Midwest Energy Resources Company
Peninsular Electric Light Company

St. Clair Edison Company

Washtenaw Light & Power Company
Essex County Light & Power Co., Lid.

DUKE POWER COMPANY
Subsidiaries and Affiliates
Mill Power Supply Company
Crescent Land & Timber Corp.
Eastover Land Company
Eastover Mining Company
Wateree Power Co.

A-61

Catawba Mfg. & Elec. Power Co.

Western Cardina Power Co.

Caldwell Power Co.

Southern Power Co.

Greenville Gas & Electric Light & Power Co.

FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY
Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Fuel Supply Service, Inc.
Land Resources Investment Co.

GULF STATES UTILITIES COMPANY
Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Varibus Corporation

HOUSTON LIGHTING & POWER COMPANY
Parent

Houston Industries, Inc.

ILLINOIS POWER COMPANY
Subsidiaries and Affiliates
Electric Energy, Inc.

IOWA PUBLIC SERVICE COMPANY
Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Cimmred, Inc.

Energy Development Co.
Energy Reserves, Inc.
Centennial Coal, Inc.

A-62

MIDDLE SOUTH UTILITIES, INC.
Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Arkansas Power & Light Co.
Arkansas-Missouri Power Co.
Louisiana Power & Light Co.
Mississippi Power & Light Co.
New Orleans Public Service, Inc.

MINNESOTA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY
Subsidiaries and Affiliates
Superior Water, Light & Power Co.

Topeka Land Company
Energy Land, Inc.

MIONTAUP ELECTRIC COMPANY
Subsidiaries and Affiliates
Eastern Utilities Associates

NEW ENGLAND POWER COMPANY
Parent
New England Electric System

NIAGARA MOHAWK POWER CORPORATION
Subsidiaries and Affiliates
Beebee Isiand Corporation
Moreau Manufacturing Corp.

St. Lawrence Power Co.
The Indian River Co.

NORTHERN INDIANA PUBLIC SERVICE COMPANY
Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Shore Line Shops, Inc.
NIPSCO Exploration Co.
NIPSCO Fuel Co.

NORTHERN STATES POWER COMPANY (MINN.)
Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Cormorant Corporation
United Power and Land Co.
Northern States Power Co. (Wisc.)

Chippewa and Flambeau Improvement Co.

A-64

OHIO EDISON COMPANY
Subsidiaries and Affiliates
Pennsylvania Power Co.

OKLAHOMA GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY
Subsidiaries and Affiliates
Arklahoma Corporation

PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY
Subsidiaries and Affili

Alberta & Southern Gas Co., Ltd.
Natural Gas Corp. of California

Pacific Gas Transmission Co.

Pacific Transmission Supply Co.

Pacific Gas LNG Terminal Co.

saat
7

ow ee Om

A-65

ROCHESTER GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY
Subsidiaries and Affiliates
Canadea Power Corp.

SOUTH CAROLINA ELECTRIC & GAS COMPANY
Subsidiaries and Affiliates

THE SOUTHERN COMPANY
Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Alabama Power Co.

Alabama Property Co.
Georgia Power Co.

Gulf Power Co.

Southern Company Service, Inc.

TAMPA ELECTRIC COMPANY
Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Tampa Bay Industrial Corp.
Mid-South Towing Co.
Electro-Coal Transfer Corp.
Gulfcoast Transit Co.
Southern Marine Management Corp.
Cal-Glo Coal, Inc.

TEXAS UTILITIES COMPANY
Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Dallas Power & Light Co.
Texas Electric Service Co.

A-66

Old Ocean Fuel Co.

Texas Power & Light Co.
Texas Utilities Services, Inc.
Texas Utilities Fuel Co.
Texas Utilities Generating Co.

UNION ELECTRIC COMPANY
Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Missouri Power & Light Co.
Missouri Utilities Co.

VIRGINIA ELECTRIC AND POWER COMPANY
Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Laurel Run Mining Co.
Virginia Nuclear, Inc.

WISCONSIN ELECTRIC POWER COMPANY
Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Wisconsin Natural Gas Co.
Wisconsin Michigan Power Co.
Badger Service Co.

WISCONSIN POWER & LIGHT COMPANY
Subsidiaries and Affiliates

South Beloit Water, Gas & Electric Co.
Wisconsin Power & Light Nuclear Fuel, Inc.
NUFUS Resources, Inc.
Wisconsin River Power Co.

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385009_0087%3A2. Public record. Not legal advice.
