# Respondents Brief — Brown v. Glines

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385006_0046%3A5

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Respondents Brief
- **Published:** January 1, 1980
- **Citation:** 444 U.S. 348

## Text

“as Supreme Court, U.S.
i FILED }

JUL 20 1979 |

}
IN THE [MICHAEL RODAK,IR., CLERK

Supreme Court of the United aa
OCTOBER TERM, 1978

No. 78-1006

HAROLD R. BROWN,
SECRETARY OF DEFENSE, ET AL.,
Petitioners,
Vv.

ALBERT EDWARD GLINES,
Respondent.

On Writ Of Certiorari To The United States Court
of Appeals For The Ninth Circuit

BRIEF FOR THE RESPONDENT

DAVID M. COBIN
Hamline University
- School of

1536 Hewitt Avenue

St. Paul, Minnesota 55104

(612) 641-2143

(Court appointed Counsel
for Respondent)

Of Counsel:

Melvin K. Dayley

Dayley and Blumin

6330 Telegraph Avenue
Oakland, California 94609
(415) 653-8800,

PRESS OF BYRON S. ADAMS PRINTING, INC., WASHINGTON, D.C.

Page
EE ES) 1
SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT ...............05. 3
ARGUMENT:
I. The Court of Appeals was correct in

Il.

finding that the challenged regulations
violated 10 U.S.C. $1034 .............

A. The Court of Appeals was correct in
finding that the protections afforded
armed forces personnel by 10 U.S.C.
$1034 include communication by peti-

B. The Court of Appeals was correct in
finding that regulations placing a
prior restraint on all petitioning on
military bases were not necessary to
the security of the United States....

If this Court finds that the challenged
regulations violated 10 U.S.C. 1034, the

lower courts’ rulings in favor of respon-
dent should be affirmed ..............

A. The action taken against respondent
was based upon petitions directed to
members of Congress as well as a peti-
tion to the Secretary of Defense. ... .

B. Protections afforded armed forces
personnel for communication to
members of Congress should be held
to include communication directed

21

22

22

Page

additionally to the Secretary of
SR Ssh ha Rw eho yevieev ales

III. The Court of Appeals was correct in
finding that regulations requiring com-
mand approval prior to circulation of
petitions on a military base violate the
First Amendment...................

A. The Court’s decision in Greer v.
Spock is not dispositive of the
issues in this case ................

B. Taking the important governmental
interests served by the challenged
regulations into account, the Court of
Appeals was correct in finding that
the application of a prior restraint on
all petitioning on military bases was
substantially overboard...........

1. The significance of the prior
approval requirement as a prior
restraint..... eae ed oak ae ee

a) Dissemination delayed may
prove tantamount to dissem-
ination denied..............

b) Censors uncontrolled by courts
tend to deny publication to
material protected by the First
Amendment ...............

2. Applying the analysis employed in
Nebraska Press Association v.

27

29

29

35

35

36

iii
Page

b) The availability of other mea-
sures to mitigate the harm
Ee 47

c) The effectiveness of the prior
command approval require-
ment in protecting the military
DU Sauaiys bas 66 enedas 55

rj ae ig age Bb Wee 57
Se RS cc Sis oak be Awake UAC SOAS OO 60

: CITATIONS

CASES:
Abbott Labs v. Portland Retail Druggists, 425
Se RR ek eee Lee Wie oa acecn ne ook 9, 29

Allen v. Monger, 404 F. Supp. 1081 (N.D. Cal.
1975), 583 F.2d 438 (9th Cir. 1978), petition
for cert. pending sub. nom. Brown v. Allen,

ee Te Pee ree passim
Bantam Books v. Sullivan, 372 U.S. 58 (1970)... 49
Broadrick v. Oklahoma, 413, U.S. 601 (1973) .... 50

Carlson v. Schlesinger, 364 F. Supp. 626 (D.D.C.
1973), rev'd on other grounds, 511 F.2d 1327

EA Ri RU EMN A ake 6 aioe es OS Ve Wee a as 39
Carlson v. Schlesinger, 511 F.2d 1327 (D.C. Cir.
EME EN a padiaie Delve spas ee kers 21, 39, 45, 57

Chenoweth v. Van Arsdall, Mis. No. 73-1
(USCMA Mar. 13, 1973), 1 Mil. L. Rptr. 2098
Ey TSRMESNAL SAS Bap ih Peek NOSE eI yee 57

Cox v. New Hampshire, 312 U.S. 569(1941)..... 47

iv

Page

Eastern Air Lines v. CAB, 354 F.2d 507 (D.C. Cir.
TOGRD . bc ss osc d.o0b 56S ee ate eeee ies 27
Easton v. City of Tulsa, 415 U.S. 697 (1974)..... 23

Edwards v. South Carolina, 372 U.S. 229
(ROG: 5). kn eves Coa Orie eeaares 52
Eisenstadt v. Baird, 405 U.S. 438 (1972)........ 23

Fleischmann Construction Co. v. United States,
270 U.S. 840 (199G). . cc ic vieclccctccscievs 28
Greer v. Spock, 424 U.S. 828 (1976)......... passim

Huff v. Secretary of the Navy, 413 F. Supp. 863
(D.D.C. 1976) 575 F.2d 907 (D.C. Cir. 1978),
cert. granted sub. nom. Brown v. Huff, No.
i EE Pe ey es PT err i passim

Montana Pow:.- Co. v. Federal Power Com-
mission, 445 F.2d 739 (D.C. Cir. 1971) cert.

den. 400 U.S. 1013 (1971). ................ 27
Nebraska Press Association v. Stuart, 427 U.S.
GOR ROT: i's wee vias Rice caeeesueeaees passim
New York Times Co. v. United States, 403 U.S.
TES (IGT 8 ice Vee sea ea ee ees 21
Parker v. Levy, 417 U.S. 733 (1974).... 35,50, 51, 53
Philbrook v. Glodgett, 421 U.S. 707 (1975)...... 28
Steck v. Connally, 199 F. Supp. 104 (D.D.C.
BOGE a ick Na cee eon eee 34
Street v. New York, 394 U.S. 576 (1969) .... 3,22, 23
Thomas v. Collins, 323 U.S. 516 (1945)....... 17,18
Thornhill v. Alabama, 310 U.S. 88 (1940) ....... 51

Tygrett v. Washington, 543 F.2d 840 (D.C. Cir.
976: oan Fe Sdekee van gs SRR ee 2 23

Page
United Mine Workers v. Illinois State Bar
Association, 389 U.S. 217 (1967)........... 18
United States v. Cruikshank, 92 U.S. 545
a a Sita giaie ai, a aaa ve eam wb u'achle'e Ae 17,18
United States Donner, 497 F.2d 184 (7th Cir.
1974) cert. den., 419 U.S. 1047 (1974) ....... 23
United States v. Gray, 20 USCMA 63, 42 CMR
ID hide! Gd 6. athe 00-070 64 AO LD oles 33
United States v. Schmidt, 16 USCMA 57, 36
UE RMEEINE ov k'b band dceeeketvcebs 33, 47
Waters v. Peterson, 495 F.2d 91 (D.C. Cir.
ee re eh a ee ce al ie ace es 4 bb bcp 23
Whitney v. California, 274 U.S. 357 (1927) ...... 43
Yancy v. Commonwealth, 135 Ky. 207, 122 S.W.
NES bs SUN wkd, bee heal weak Cae aes 19

Yates v. United States, 354 U.S. 298 (1959) . 3, 22, 26

CONSTITUTION, TREATY, STATUTES AND
REGULATIONS:

United States Constitution, First Amend-

Sahih td wile d ip a vik Neo 8 0 B08 8 8 passim
IN 6 54°55. \0'oco-o°0 a awe ove vivrache o's © 28
hid a Ss Gra hvala Hale Kb ole > oeee 8s pe 48
10 UBC. $016 mse cei cece cen ncenn 47
IEE iia. oon ok evn wo abba wa wriee paints 48
Se a5 a oy 3.0.00 5-60.80 ER 4,0 OAs 48
PP NE ns os be bes ec dba bh ouleee's passim
DTM Mieco k So) kee Cavaeeees 28

Page
Department of Defense Directive 1325.6 III G
PR ee Odie Sed we ke Awd Sob wks WE 10
Navy Regulation Article 1248................ 7,9
TREATISES AND ARTICLES:
Blackstone, Commentaries (Oxford, 1765) (Phil-
| i c open the
channels of communication between members of the
armed services and members of Congress, and the
historical importance of petitioning all suggest that
Congress would not have chosen to exclude petitions
from the communication protected in $1034.

army—America’s traditional weapon against dictatorship
and oppression—the right of Armed Forces personnel to
communicate freely with members of Congress is of the
utmost importance. It will be recalled that the Congress
endeavored to preserve this right inviolate by a new provi-
sion ... [referring to what is now 10 U.S.C. §1034).

97 Cong. Rec. A4977 (1951).

a. —— —— —_

Vi. PROMOTION POTENTIAL
' 1S NOT DEMONSTRATE A CAPABAITY FOR PROMOTION AT HS 2. PERFORMING WELL IN PRESENT GAADE §=—SHOULO BF CONTIO.

fet (ms ERED (OR PROMOTION ALONG WITH CONTEMPOR AEIES Gad
3. OEMONSTAATES CAPABNITIES FOR INCREASTO BESPONSIMITY 4 QUISTANOING GROWTH POTENTIAL 4510 ON OF MOMSTRATEO

ONSIOLE FOR ADVANCEMENT ANEAD OF CONTEMPORARIES 5) PERFORMANCE «PROMOTE WELL AMEAD OF CONTEMPORARIES Eo

Vi. COMMINIS FACTS AND SPECIFIC ACHIEVEINTS: Captain Glines clearly is the most

tent navigator within my flight, and probably the most competent within the
ent group. My observations of him during several MAC support missions makes me
completely confident of his exceptionally high level of skills, knowledge, and
judgment. He has been among the most active, if not the most active, participant in
the Reserve Program. His flying time during the past 12 months was approximately
800 hours. He has flown all available Flying Training Periods, has made himself
available for MAC support missions on an almost unlimited basis and has performed a
number of "fill in" administrative duties for the squadron when needed. His work ha
been uniformly excellent. His mobilization potential is of the highest. STRENGTHS:
In addition to the highly superior navigational campetence described above, Captain
Glines is an officer possessing superior leadership potential. He is highly
intelligent, dependable, and thoroughly considerate of the needs of others. Further,
Captain Glines has the courage, as well as the ability and initiative, to assume
responsibility where appropriate. SUGGESTED ASSIGNMENTS: Captain Glines is
currently awaiting reassignment to the 349th MAG. After his requalification in the
new aircraft I would anticipate he should progress rapidly to instructor and flight
examiner. SELF IMPROVEMENT EFFORTS: Captain Glines is currently taking a
correspondence course in Evaluation of Financial Reports, a graduate level course
given by the University of California. He has applied for entrance to the graduate
school of Economics at UC. OTHER COMMENTS: Captain Glines' transfer will be a loss
keenly felt by this unit. His performance has been outstanding. Captain Glines has
used his personal and professional capabilities to actively promote equal opportunity
programs. Captain Glines is @ student studying for his Masters Degree.

7

Vill, REPORTING OFFICIAL

HAGE SNABE ATEN VIAN AND SROAR Lf | a en

™ AOE, AFSN SSAN. AND DRGAMNIZATION $1GMa!

JOHN M COHAN, Major Flight Commander KA. MV & -
$64-38-S683FV, 314th TASq - ; welll J t
McClellan AFB. Calif (AFRES) Sr_Navigator i 1 7 July Te

BY INDORSING OFFICIAL

I have observed the performance of Captain Glines and concur with the remarks and
ratings of the reporting official.

p ik ‘.
MAME. GRADE Ass S546 460 ORGANIZATION ovry nme Moma! iy a
CHESTER W ANDERS, Lt Colonel uadron Commander “i ‘ ?
317-14-7S511FV, 314th TAS

3a

McClellan AFB, Calif (AFRES) Command Pilot {| 1 10 July 72
oro + ee
rd

17 Jur We
2ciA8 72D
LAST MAME FURST Maw POOLE FETE AR artn/ stan activa Outs Geaot
Glines, Albert E 552-52-9680FV NONEAD
(CHECK APPROPRIATE SLOCK AND COMPLETE AS APPLICABLE)
SUPPLEMENTAL SHEET TO RATING FORM wHiCH 0 LETTER OF EVALUATION COVERING THE FOLLOWING
COVERS THE FOLLOWING PERIOD OF REPORT PERIOD OF OBSERVATION
io Teau vaow Teau
30 Sep 71 31 May 72 |
Precede comments by eppropriete dete, 1.6. seetion continustion, indorsement continuation, additionel indorse-
went, ete. Follow comments by the euthentication te inchude: meme, grade, AFSN. orgenssetion, duty tithe, date
ond signature.
ADDITIONAL INDORSEMENT
Concur. The evaluation of this officer accurately portrays his performance
and abilities. My contacts with him have impressed me with his potential.
oy t. Ay mee
A FORSYTHE, Colonel, 541-14-3967FV, 940th Tactical Airlift Group, Commander,
Jul 72
L,
MMCROFILMED = $ AUG ‘72
ar oetrak 778 fervious COrtiow @ Is foew ek Of UttO wk mA SUPPL CENT AL sucet 10 af FORMS 77,

707, 909, 910. 911 AND U75

OFTEe THis O47E PREVIOUS FOI TI Ges @Hi, Of OO N0K :
cos anmpanhoomal tel Galt eam

. ul -
“| arr , =
Petes Pie =
Glines, Albert E.

MTA (feee ane

4a

dO 42 seretells

feo 1079

1

La CU ee
301 MASq (Assoc) (AFRES)
Travis AFB CA 94535

— ee
Navigates aircrart to accamplish cargo airlift and other assimed missions.
Plans the navigational phase of each mission and insures that all navigational
equipment is inspected and prerlichted.
and maintains flight logs and records.

Thee aa
552-52 -9660 FV NOMEAD
+ s680 Bales oot 7, eee OF etroet
Naviga lL feeas ‘un =
El a oF her , o Batam foe etPcer
199 CRO
PRESERT OUTY
parse 1545. SQUADRON NAVIGATOR C-141.

Performs minor in-flight maintenance

RATING FACTORS (Conerder Row thee officer se perferesme on Rew sod )

+ NOM FOCE OF CUTIES

-

geterse

MOD GAPS Oe =} mom
“ue

Hum Damts 10. 9" OF

“so

yar beac roar &
mr

owt
~~ ouases o-

i. efomte Ge mer
waves oF wrk 108

crceuaeet sron cece or ms
ees OF ws 108

3

gecenreenes LmOr OS Tamora
on y res
Ad

oO

> PCR Om~NCE OF CUTIES

O

Bete of anti ty OF
ome OFfte fers fo meter
900 HG eheters

er eromeanct EET) Ar

“ee Ae a OtmeTE

Dat re eee Quail
w0es 48E vhey Dat Sractoer

oz)

Peomucis veer x waste
wo Qari ty oF mers

Cx)

“A WOrteS

Gaile e690 Dati te oe
“e ane cutanae syeumren

oO

L_denevte

veserective

Cy

oescerte
: CEFECT) VENESS IN SDR ING OF OTHERS
wr yoeeeecy tet os 2Ome vee ety mae os woe seus t arty oR ots ere PT OPE | HORE Om wemONY BF tm * LCCeT A
hl kl coosceare oe Ath eeG Oe OF veote women © ecumsranct). omnes 4 whey GOOD "tee ite *
O oes womet Scr ivkey OCMNTES mameOn®
wore Ld ~ CJ
Le —
‘ See
orrts etee noe "= png bt TORR y EMME TORTERT OF ND TOSTES & wha OF LOE - ab us ares soetes at
" mrtearied One. stare ” etyrantiere! ony eae tow s accarns OF mETOATENE amO ACCEPT: a]
Poms erty ” ar tori etseens: ornare OF OC SPONS era i ty
2 1,——_ oe Cx] Cc)
pS os 2v0ctuen?
RE Samy ane oe nese teen ru ta

Sumo Ou? wi tase ~n
teeoes

wit =6 om ta
Creuetiae OF fac toes

Cid

Ane 06) Weiwer®
CONS OCOS O44 Facroes to
eee AC OUATE OCS ONS

Cx)

nn a alacte ng tte ar
‘ fre
wuts ore aa

=

e acartagicity

-— ——

Team fe e+ ~~
we Le = ote en
’

Pr re taut ‘st Se ruat ome

eiersmnenc TH ONT nae
oF 1S Ofer e Mean

be ~ ' =u ees sretss
tad styeteame

onet ater
tet veore
moe rr pr tuatiens

eo —— t
“

tot cmon prem “ne
'

*e

> Use OF etsquerts

Teen ee)
or Mmomeres

eMES FENOTES om 8 BeOtKe
Vat SAC TORY waneee

TONNER ES OF UheRe BOUT ene
rotons

CPPRC TT OERT OFC aml Hes
Vee ed OF OC rT OF me
(wPeOrtO POOCT OR OES

ana ®
et

(=~) fon)

Cae) Ce]

=
"
beeps
en not ~ ae
om Mee ow
O ertreaerrrnt)

te a0 O88 FE PRE SS ON

~~

CSE SESE OME TO EB.
weres Ot0d Cr tem

Loe | tee |

Sa =e thy Sen me ey eer ooo its
Ca) Can | Ce c= Se

“whan Quen Tits Comerdes Boo thee altrcer eeete a

ie iy were wee as Hone Ti Re eee
— Lees * | Sears . Sate one y= “tes
: ae tee A teh hel

force standeré

Sa err ey
+e eNge8 ere
tone

oc

~ Bink

ee ee

emieit C

” pees GRADE OFFICER EFFECTIVENESS REPCRI
-

5a

009

OVER-ALL EVALUATION (Compere thie ef ficer ONLY wrth officers af the seme grade )

yr
em tie fee
fener tech reee

@ecr0 se PPT es
oe tee
ease

Ba oy) Oe ioe el

+ BOLD HOT OLarrSTeATE & CAPsOrL TTY FOR PRGEOT ION At tere Teme

D Obwowsteetes CamemicrThts fom om “

~emnes oe or vd aety
COPS OLE FOR FO vem tein! atau OF Frm

es 1 plaromene e114 9 Petstet yenoe | tama D OF Casinr are ow
‘oe Oe eee

© GIT TeRDreG Lert bs fy die eet Ge Germ fretee
x PERT em PRR ITE ELK BwE AO OF COM TiN Mami tS

FACTS AND SPECIFIC ACHIEVE ENTS:
his time and talent to the Air Force Reserve progran s

Comat ns

Capt Glines has made sinificant contributions of
ince joining the 933 MAGp

(Assoc) (AFRES). Capt Glines has attended the C-141 navigator training course at
Altus AFB, Oklahora, where he distinguished himself by graduating second in his
class. Capt Glines has also received a recormendation for a checkride in the
minimum am 1t of time. He has devoted 45 days of his time to Active Duty during
the past three months and has flown several overwater training missions during that
period. He has the additional duties of Squadron Cormunications Security Officer
and Plans Officer. In this capacity, he has developed a communications security
briefing to be conducted at his monthly unit training assemblies. He hes also
contributed significantly to the development of his unit's operations plans.
Because of his potential, Capt Glines has been selected to attend the C-5 navigator

training course at Altus AFB, Oklahom.

His participation in the Air Force Peserve

has been excellent and he has accumulated the maximum allowable number of additional

flying training periods. STREIGTHS:

and has a cooperative attituce.

Cant Glines is an energetic, zealous officer
Ne is easy to get along with and gets along well

with others. He has excellent potential and is a dedicated officer. SUGGESTED
ASSIGNMENTS: Capt Glines should be upzraded to line navigator as socn as possible
and is recommended for attendance at the C-5 navigator training school. OTTER
COMMENTS: Capt Glines is athletically inclined and in this regard, enjoys coacning
a softball team. His civilian occupation is that of automobile salesman.

vit.

REPORTING OFFICIAL

45-32-8157 FIB12 MASq (Assoc)
Travis AFB, CA (AFFES)

i CT a ee ee) Bate The T ae SA
FRANK L. JACKSON, Major, USAFR | Squadron Navigator Front Joe en
af80 Bat ne care

Senior Mav

3 April 1973

ACVICW BY IMOORSING OFFICIAL

I concur with the comments and ratings of the reporting official. Capt Clires is
energetic ard possesses a strong desire to do an exceptional job for the Peserve
program. Due to his rapid prccression and fine attitude, I have selected him for
conversion to the C-5 Associate Reserve squadron,

Crk

a Cat NS ee eee ye vray 2, called Ga |Ge) Ge Et Ge |e

. COL TING ami tty ar UMM EME SS Ow

(OCR qeeer ed ten wi tere me ee ee Th On te w Sftshe ome OES | ero rr
“tem sees ‘ 1 oo feet POLLED Teh ete Cte Perks 0888 (tome “_* oe “es to
© @) re ‘ We ome MA vate
eo. wee we DL este wees x ie 1 | [on wae
C= C= | C= CeCe) [Ce Ce Ce Ce
WW. MILITARY QUALITICS (corecwer te © officer wants aie Pavee stamdaras +

wr UT a er ee I wee Tete one re ee |
F00E THO GURY Or te Hrd ate Oe POOL! 1 Oem =) * LOO PON 0 Oat ny eter eS ~
eter FerOreQt ere tt am oes -
o

ereecr) anes are renee

AF sng A 77a uavovens enr¥eus ° wat oeun isa SUPPLEMENTAL SHEET TO AF FORMS 77, O — (| Cc Ce) ot ~~
mn ere 18 Ganaysres oni me-nafe§ 707, 909, 910, 911 MnO ne a ane mrp
EXHIBIT D-1

ar Ege ee ee ee ee

8a 9a

%3

‘. Ovte-al cY Oe (Coopers thie officer OMLY @rth efficore he seme grade) 2 itf8 LAST MAME FURST ame mr OORE FIT IAL

active Outy Gaaoe

s3an
WEE Glines, Albert £. \' 552-52-9680FV NONEAD

Craeaeee syseseegeriee (CHECK APPROPRIATE BLOCK AND COMPLETE 4S APPLICABLE)

ees >|

tonne feet ame

SUPPLEMENTAL SHEET TO RATING FORM WHICH LETTER OF EVALUATION COVERING THE FOLLOWING
Ce ot. bog Ct). Co (Co eae COVERS THE FOLLOWING PERIOD OF REPORT PERIOD OF OBSERVATION

nares. Pron Ot ow avtnece CPPECT IVE ted COMPETENT weer font CACC ORAELT) Qurstanoing = ry 7} rer

YI PROMOTION POTENTIAL 26 Feb 73 29 Jw 73 |

s. muee noe ectamnvenne 0 casemscen ven cocmproen av ture cumm, fj] * SPSS, mccturgsusiahene © Sonim C7 cosertcT™PCien’ octets ty ene suthenestavion's sorta "han graces AvShy vgunievion, day shel dot

eleneture.
memareems Gtaituter atts Ss tenons eR ee ee 1.
OT ADDITIONAL INDORSEMENT: I concur. Capt Glines in addition to flying has made

FACTS AMD SPECIFIC ACHIEVIZENTS: Capt Glines has performed his duties in an ' himself available for additional duties during the unit training assemblies.
exceptionally fine manner throurhout the period of this report. His participation I personally assigned him several projects in the Navigator Section and he
ami perforrance in all scheduled unit training assemblies have been especially oy rg ber ae oe te and with dispatch. Recommend Capt Glines enroll
noteworthy. lis effective use of materiel and perscnne] while serving as Manuals % Air Comman tarf College by correspondence in order to better utilize his
Control Officer demonstrated his great efficiency and success while working with administrative and managerial abilities.

others. Capt Glines has proven to be a canpetent and professional navigator.

The examiner on his recent C-141 initial evaluation had many favorable comments Ei es > b

on his performance. In order to broaden his technical knowledge, he also accumu- Lyra ve tat,

lated the maximum number of additicnal flying training periods. Because of his : EDMOND F. COONEY, JR., f‘9/jor, USAFR, 508-34-1945FV, 301 MASq (Assoc), Squadron
proven abilities, he has been selected to transition to the highly sophisticated Navigator, 20 August 1

C-5A aircraft end entered training on 30 July 1973. He has expressed a high degree
of enthusiasm for this essimment and will undoubtedly be an asset to the 301 MAS.
STRENGTHS: Capt Glines is a conscientious officer who will see e project through

aDDITIONAL INDORSEMENT: Capt Glines has d trated ded
to its comiction. He has excellent potential and gets along well with others. 4 " ph soa pe oi eoreecly sage ate

1S COMPAR VAC & through a high level of participation. I concur with this evaluation and the
SUGGESTED ASSIGIMENTS: In eto to best —_ his eng maf Glines should recommendations of his reporting and indorsing officicls to upgrade as C-5
be upgraded to navigator imme iately upon his return from formal C-5A school. a ‘ onal ed
OTHER CQOMINTS: Capt Glines' devoted interest and outstanding abilities in the navigator cad inerense his profess CELL Ls 'Thvemgh eaEreppenrenss SuErees,
field of athletics have aided greatly in the high success of the local softball ~ 2
program where he volunteers his services as a eoneh - ranager. iy Rag Soe ; , A Lie AA
4 44 that of ' _ Capt Glines prerotes the Pua : , J os
See san eS Sas B.C. MEWS, Colonel, USWFR, $51-12-5762FV 349,11 1ft Wig (iss0c), (ARES),

Commanier, 2° .ugust 1973

vir. REPORTING OFFICIAL

CeCe ee SIT TRwT —=
CHARLES EGIZIANO, Capt, USAFR Squadron Navigator LO * 4 lie .
127-30-6610FV, 301 MASq (Assoc [OSE bas _
Travis AFB, CA (AFFES) | Senior Mav 1 20 august 1943

m. REVIE@ BY [MOORSING OFFICIAL

I concur with the above report. Capt Glines is an officer whose full potential
has not yet been realized. He should be an asset to the 301 MASq.

a ee mv veer

Seer -”
JOEL V. FALK, Capt, USAFR Squadron Navigator Stel leh
503-24 -5 303FY, 302 “ALG (Asse PTS “ae coy ’ ery} Peter dus CHT Om
Travis AFR, CA (AFT *) Navigator ‘| 1 20 August 1973 AF we @ 778 as vern warn ores paps gy SUPPLEMENTAL SHEET TO AF FORM

D-2 Tew a tome ou “p-3 707, 909, 910, 911) AND 475 7

lla

AFFIDAVIT OF ERIC A. SEITZ

STATE OF HAWAII )

) SS.
CITY AND COUNTY OF HONOLULU )

ERIC A. SEITZ, being first duly sworn on oath,
deposes and says:

1. I am an attorney admitted to practice before the
Supreme Court of the United States, before state
courts in California and Hawaii, and before numerous
federal courts for trial and appellate proceedings.

2. Currently I ar engaged in the private practice
of law with offices located at 681 South King Street,
Suite 200, Honolulu, Hawaii 96813.

3. Commencing in September, 1972, I represented
an individual named PATRICK CHENOWETH in
connection with his trial before a Navy court-martial
on charges alleging, in substance, acts of sabotage to
the aircraft carrier U.S.S. Ranger.

4. The court-martial proceedings in Mr. CHEN-
OWETH’s case occurred over a period of several
months at the United States Naval Base, Treasure
Island, California, terminating on or about June 5,
1973, by findings of the military court that he was.
not guilty of the specifications and charges on which
he was tried.

5. During the entire period of time, from his arrest
in July, 1972, until his acquittal in early June, 1973,
Mr. CHENOWETH was confined without bail at the
correctional facility on Treasure Island. A petition for
habeas corpus was filed in his behalf and ultimately

12a

reached the Supreme Court upon a petition for cer-
tiorari, resulting in the Order that is appended hereto
as Exhibit A.

/s/ E.A. Seitz

ERIC A. SEITZ -

Subscribed and sworn to
before me this 3rd day
of July, 1979.

/s/ Marilyn Joy Barbain
Notary Public, First
Judicial Circuit, State of Hawaii

My commission expires: 5/1/83

13a

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
OFFICE OF THE CLERK
WASHINGTON, D.C. 20543
October 9, 1973

Eric A. Seitz, Esq.
405 Capp Street
San Francisco, Calif. 94110

RE: CHENOWETH v. WARNER, SEC’Y of
NAVY, et al., 72-6812 =

Dear Sir:

The Court today entered the following order in the
above-entitled case:

The motion for leave to proceed in forma pauperis
and the petition for a writ of certiorari are granted.
The judgment is vacated and the case is remanded to
the United States District Court for the Northern
District of California with directions to dismiss the
case as moot.

Very truly yours, |
MICHAEL RODAK, JR., Clerk

By

/s/ HELEN TAYLOR
Helen Taylor, (Mrs.)
Assistant Clerk

AIRMAIL

RECEIVED OCT 30 1973

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385006_0046%3A5. Public record. Not legal advice.
