# Petition — Air Line Employees Ass'n, International v. Evans

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385004_0112%3A1

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Petition
- **Published:** January 1, 1976
- **Citation:** 429 U.S. 929

## Text

Supreme Court, U. &

FILED by,
JUN 17 1976

in Tas MICHAEL RODAK

R., CLERK

Supreme Court of the United States

OcTOBER TERM, 1975.

No. @5-1826

AIR LINE EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION,

INTERNATIONAL,
Petitioner,
VS,
NELSON EVANS,
Respondent.

PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE
SUPREME COURT OF GEORGIA.

ADAIR, GOLDTHWAITE, STANFORD
AND DANIELS, P.A..,
600 Rhodes Haverty Building,
Atlanta, Georgia 30303,
404/522-5950,

and

WYATT JOHNSON,
Staff Vice President and
General Counsel, ALEA,
5600 South Central Avenue,
Chicago, Illinois 60638,
312/767-3333,
Attorneys for Air Line Employee
Association, International,

Gunthorp-Warren Printing Cornpany, Chicago e Financial 6-6565 A> 56

TABLE OF CONTENTS.

PAGE
Onleion BaleW 2... cc ccccccccccccccccscccscccsecs l
BED cp eccedeccvacececvcnscsecesueavessesn 2
CI TOS nc cctncccwesevceescesectsweens 2
ND ED ook 6.06 ces cocscncnsseseesceseeces 3
eee Serr rer: eee 3
RATE oo cc ctcecccsccssccccecsccesceesoeseees 6
SD occ kc cdcecedcecdendcccetansetecsceses 20
Agmemtt A nn cccccccvccccsccccccccesscoeeseses Al
Papen BD ow. cc ccccccccccncvccsccecceccecosecs A2
AUTHORITIES CITED.
Cases.

Alabaugh v. Baltimore and Ohio R. R. Co., 222 F.2d 861
SU ED bck Se ceheneneceecdeacnnens 13, 17, 18

Andrews v. Louisville and Nashville Railway Co., 406 U.S.
Bet GED

VS. 7” ;
. Civil Action

r File No. C-841
AIRLIFT INTERNATIONAL INC., AND

AIR LINE EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION
INTERNATIONAL.

ORDER.

The above defendants having brought before the Court
Motions to dismiss the plaintiff complaint, and the Court having
heard argument of counsel and citation of authorities, raising
subject matter jurisdiction and exhaustion of remedies, the Court
does hereby overrules and dismisses the said Motions of defend-
ants to the plaintiffs complaint.

So ordere | that Ist day of August.

JEPTHA C. TANKSLEY,
Judge, Superior Court, AJC.

APPENDIX B.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF GEORGIA.

Decided: April 7, 1976

30610. Arr LINE EMPLOYEES
ASSOCIATION INTERNATIONAL

vs.

EvANS (616)

GUNTER, Justice.

This is an interlocutory appeal, originally granted by this
court on the application of two applicant-defendants, from a
judgment that denied the defendants’ motion to dismiss the plain-
tiffs complaint. After this court had granted the interlocutory
appeal, one of the defendants, the employer of the plaintiff,
voluntarily dismissed its appeal, and, at the same time, the
plaintiff dismissed the employer as a party defendant in the trial
court. The result of these two dismissals is that the issues for
determination, as the appeal now stands, are between the plain-
tiff below, Evans, and the defendant below, the Union.

Since appellate jurisdiction was in this court when the inter-
locutory appeal was originally granted by this court, this court
has retained jurisdiction even though the two dismissals referred
to above have eliminated the equitable relief involved at the
time the interlocutory appeal was granted. Our Constitution pro-
vides: “It shail be competent for the Supreme Court to require
by certiorari or otherwise any case to be certified to the Supreme
Court from the Court of Appeals for review and determination
with the same power and authority as if the case had been

A3

carried by writ of error to the Supreme Court.” Ga. Code Ann.
sec. 2-3704.

Evans was an employee of the employer until November 19,
1974, when he was discharged by the employer at the direction
of the Union for his alleged failure to pay his initiation fee to
the Union.

On November 24, 1974, Evans filed his complaint against the
employer and the Union seeking injunctive relief, compensa-
tory damages, punitive damages, and attorneys’ fees. Both de-
fendants filed motions to dismiss the complaint for failure to
state a claim on the ground that Evans had failed to exhaust
his administrative remedies required by the Railway Labor
Act, 45 U.S.C. Sec. 151 et seq., and the collective bargaining
agreement between the employer and the Union.

The trial judge overruled both motions to dismiss, two inter-
locutory appeals followed, the employer was then dismissed as
a party in the trial court, the employer dismissed its interlocutory
appeal, and we now have for decision, as the sole remaining
issue in the case, whether the Union’s motion to dismiss the
complaint was properly denied by the trial judge.

As we view the case in its present posture, the only issues for
determination are between Evans and the Union. Evans con-
tends that he was ejected from membership in the Union with-
out cause, or that he was denied membership in the Union with-
out cause, and that the Union, without cause, directed his dis-
charge by his employer for non-compliance by Evans with the
terms of the collective bargaining contract between the Union
and the employer. The responsive pleadings of the Union denied
that Evans had ever been a member of the Union, admitted that
he had paid dues to the Union for the month of October, 1974,
and admitted that his employment with the employer had been
terminated at the direction and request of the Union.

We think this case is controlled by the principles enunciated in
Sheet Metal Workers International Association v. Carter, 133
Ga. App. 872, 212 SE2d 645 (1975).

A4

Also, see Brady v. Trans World Airlines, Inc., 401 F.2d 87,
cert. denied, International Association of Machinists v. Brady,
393 U.S. 1048 (1969). In that case an employce charged the
Union with hostile discrimination in refusing to accept tender of
the plaintiff's dues and in wrongfully having him discharged
from employment with TWA. The complaint further charged the
Union with discrimination and with misrepresenting the facts
pertaining to the plaintiff's alleged dues delinquency in a hear-
ing before a Railway Labor Act adjustment board, The Third
Circuit construed such allegations as a complaint primarily
against his bargaining agent rather than his employer. After
setting forth statutory authority and discussing the jurisdiction
of adjustment boards and of the courts, the Third Circuit stated:
“The jurisdiction of railway carrier adjustment boards has been
construed as encompassing disputes between employees and their
employers, but not disputes between employees and their bar-
guining representatives.” P. 92.

See also Deboles v. Trans World Airlines, Inc., 350 F. Supp.
1274 (1972), where it was held that the complaint set forth a
dispute primarily involving TWA employees and their Union
representatives, and that the Railway Labor Act had not pre-
empted jurisdiction from the state and federal courts.

We conclude in this case that the exhaustion of administra-
tive remedies by Evans, as contended by the Union, was not re-
quired, and Evans’ complaint was not subject to dismissal for
failure to state a claim.

Judgment affirmed. All the Justices concur.

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385004_0112%3A1. Public record. Not legal advice.
