# Appendix — Nader v. Allegheny Airlines, Inc.

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385003_1086%3A2

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Appendix
- **Published:** January 1, 1976
- **Citation:** 426 U.S. 290

## Text

_ Supreme Court, U. & )

fb. FILED

j
JOINT APPENDIX I AN_9 1976

MICHAEL RODAK, JR., CLERK

IN THE

Supreme Court of the Hnited States

OCTOBER TERM, 1975

No. 75-455

RALPH NADER,

Petitioner,

ALLEGHENY AIRLINES, INC.,

Respondent.

ON A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR
THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT

EE
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI FILED SEPTEMBER 22, 1975
CERTIORARI GRANTED NOVEMBER 11, 1975

(i)
INDEX TO JOINT APPENDIX

Note: The relevant orders and opinions of the United States
District Court for the District of Columbia in Civil Action
No. 1346-72 and the United States Court of Appeals for
the District of Columbia Circuit in No. 73-2243 are set

forth in the appendices to the Petition for Certiorari and
are not reprinted here.

ITEM Page
COMPLAINT FOR COMPENSATORY AND PUNITIVE
Ee ee ae
nn + «2 us « k ae & 6) 8) 4. e08°ece & ” OF
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES — District Court. . . . 10
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES — Court of Appeals .. 14
EXCERPTS FROM TRANSCRIPT OF TRIAL ..... = 16
DEPOSITION OF LESLIE O. BARNES (Pl. Exh. 24) . . 116
DOCUMENTARY EXHIBITS AT TRIAL ..... . . 138
Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 4 — Allegheny Memorandum... . 138
Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 5 — Allegheny Memorandum... . 139
Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 6 — Allegheny Passenger Service
Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 14 — Correspondence re:
ee

Q. What time did you arrive at the gate? A. About
10 after 10:00. My watch is usually a minute or a minute
and 2 half fast, but it was 10 after 10:00, I would say.
Depa time was the flight scheduled to leave? A. At

Q. Was the plane still there when you arrived? A Oh
yes, —

Q. What happened when you arrived at the gate? A.
There were people milling around in front of the ticket
lift desk, “ppodly nie. and the person in front of me was
a person ad known, John Koskinen, who w
to Senator Ribicoff. ee

van What happened when you presented the ticket to the
at py Fs When I presented the ticket to the agent

agent in ;
«ng indicated that there was no more room on the

Q. Do you remember exactly what the agent said? A.
He said, in so many words, there is no more room. The
ror tell him you had a reservation? A. I did.

Q. What did you tell the agent about the nature of
your trip? A. I told him that I had to make an no
speech in downtown Hartford, and it was very umpo

the plane.
Tae him if : would check to see if there were any
stand-by’s on the plane, because it has been my experi-
ence that stand-by’s are given secondary priority.

Q. Did he tell you whether there were any stand-by’s
or not? A. He indicated simply that the plane was full.
He had constantly repeated that phrase, and that he could

ing about it.
ais y nine. 8 him to do anything else to help get you
on board? A. Yes, I asked him if he would send his
representative or go to the plane—they were milling back
and forth at the [20] time—and ask if anybody on the
plane would desire to volunteer to take a later plane be-
cause of the urgency of the trip.

By Mr. Robertson:

her there were
. When you asked the agent to see whet

a volunteers on board who might take a later flight,
sir, so [21] that you could make your engagement, what
did he say to you then? A. He said he was sorry, but

he couldn’t do anything about that.
Q. Did he refuse to seek any volunteers? A. Yes, by

irtue of his statement.
ie Q. And at this time was the plane still at the gate?

A. Yes.

. t did you do then? A. Then I went to the
BAe et Bie to that I asked him what else could
be done, in effect, as other people were asking him, in
the same situation. He said he would possibly see; that
there might be another connection that could be made.

21

Q. What was the other connection that he told you
about? A. He said there might be another connection
via Philadelphia to Hartford, but that it was a close
scheduling problem.

Q. Did he say how close it wast A. I don’t recollect
exactly, other than it occurred to me that sometime in
that two- or three-minute span of frantic exchanges, and
so forth, there was indicated a ten-minute connection time,
if the plane from Washington landed as scheduled in
Philadelphia.

Q. Did he say whether or not he could assure that the
connection in Philadelphia would definitely be made? A.
No, he did not say he could assure it at all.

Q. Did he say he could not assure it? [22] A. He said
he could not assure it, in so many words. ;

Q. Do you recall what time this proposed connecting
flight was supposed to arrive in Hartford if it did make
the connection? A. At 12:15.

Q. That is the best of your recollection? possibility of making a connection via rope
phia, he told you that if the connection were made, it on
put you in Hartford about 55 minutes after your Flight 2
was scheduled to arrive, didn’t he? that.

Isn’t it accurate that compensation applies to broader
circumstances than just an intentional overbooking? A.
It applies to all cases of denied boarding.

Q. Which may be because in certain cases of an equip-
ment substitution? A. If I am not mistaken, I believe

61

that a substitution of i i
equipment is an excepti
“? ao compensation rule. petirsaphies
. That exception is set forth i
! in th i
forth in that rule, Part 250. ean arena
Q. Or an unintentional error
that someone may have
—_ , yo tingeere 4 or mistakenly confirming a ntsc
” ‘ .
a r whatever reason the denied boarding may

Q) . A. I l l p
, °

Q. But that would be one of ,
A. Pardon? e of the circumstances, right?

Q. That would be one of the circumstances in whieh
[138] denied-boarding compensation could be paid
suant to this tariff, right? A. That is correct eee
Q. So the fact that a tariff exists that relates to a va-
riety of circumstances under which you are going to get
some compensation, that tariff does not tell the caeetine
that there is an intentional overbooking practice in th
airlines, does it, sir? A. It does not. :

Q. Okay.

The Court: Now, let me ask you a question:

You said a moment ago, at the time you were with the
board, all of the members of the ATA who intentional]
sold more tickets than they had seats did not inform the
public. Wasn’t that your testimony? ;

The Witness: That is correct.

The Court: Is that still true today?

The Witness: I don’t know. I believe it is

The Court: All right. )

The Witness: This was the proposal, Your Honor, in
EDR-95, to require them to inform the public

The Court: You believe this is true today

The Witness: I believe it is true today.

. The Court: Could I rely on that as a fact?

The Witness: I think you can, Your Honor

[139] The Court: All right,

By Mr. Robertson:

Q. You are an expert on the existing tariffs, right? A.
On tariffs which are filed today?

Q. Yes. Yes. A. I am an expert on the law of tariffs
and on the particular tariffs as they existed when I was
with the board, but in my duties within the Air Transport
Association I have not worked with individual carrier

tariffs.
Q. Well, let me ask you about an industry-wide tariff.

A. Okay.

Q. What is CAB Tariff 142? A. That sounds like a
rules tariff. Isn’t that the passenger rules tariff?

Q. That is my understanding. A. Yes.

Q. Are you familiar with Rule 66 in that tariff? A. Not
by number. If you give me something other than the num-
ber, I may be.

Q. Well, have you ever heard of a conditional reserva-
tion? A. Yes, indeed, I have.

Q. Well, when was this put into effect? A. This is a
proposal of Eastern Airlines. I believe the year was—it
was within the last two years, was it not?

[140] Was it approved by the CAB? A. Yes, it was.

Q. And what was the basis of the CAB’s approval of
this tariff. A. I don’t know.

Q. Are all tariffs approved by the CAB A. Well, the
use of the word—I have to give a little narrative explana-
tion.

Q. Fine. Go ahead. A. We use the word ‘‘approved’’
rather loosely. What actually happens is that the carriers
are required to file a tariff thirty days, at a minimum, in
advance of the proposed effective date.

If the board does nothing to that tariff during that 30-
day waiting period, it goes into effect.

Now, then, we call that: the board has approved it.
Actually, in certain cases it may not even have looked at

it or have analyzed it at all.
The Court: In those situations it would de where there

was no objection?

The Witness: Absolutel i
: y. If the jecti
board must look at a tariff. —— ne
Pen Court: But, generally, if a tariff does not go into
e ~ without objection during the 30-day period after it
“4 ee ror “~ because somebody objected and, there-
. e the board’s attenti it; isn’t th
ns dre 1on to it; isn’t that the
: The Witness: It works that way most times, Your Honor
a the board ’s staff in the Rates Division, at least while
- there, did a fairly careful job of screening tariffs
on their own motion and bringing problems to the atten-

tion of the board, e .
siolate, d, even though there were no public com-

The Court: I see. All right.
By Mr. Robertson:

Q. But you do not know whether
’ er they are sti i
“- or not? A. (No response) J =
. Do you know? A. Well, si
: , Since the same ulti

ol works there who did when I was there T err
Say they do on that basis. Becau is 1
ne Pr Alert se that was his idea of

Q. But, in reality, an airline co

» In reality, ai uld file any sort of pro-

posed rule in its tariffs, and, unless it was challenged
eg by the staff or by another party, it would go into
e ect, is that right? A. If nobody challenged it, it would
go into effect. That is correct. )

Q. ot A. By “‘nobody.”’ I mean including the board.
. Q. Now, this conditional reservation that was introduced
y Eastern Airlines, what did this provide for? [142]
“‘. can tell you in general terms.

. Well, tell me as much as i
’ you know ab

much as I know about it. some ae aS
; Q. Yes. A. And I must say that I got most of this
rom newspaper readings and trade press readings my-

self, since I am not personal] pa
} —- - y familiar with, ’
worked with, individual carrier tariffs. a

Mr. Roberson: Just a minute. Your Honor, I object
this. I think we are going further afield. The stan in
this case is not whether there is some other supplementary
way to attack or ameliorate the no-show = _

The question is whether or not the board has bann
i the board has not banned it. 7
ay fact that they let Eastern Airlines experiment
for a short time on some kind of conditional reservation
i in this case.
have no probative value in t
“ court, in other words, with all — ase ag
i ll, althoug e
court would not sit here and say, we —
have overbooking, this cour de
pig eh gle ditional reservation
because you can have some con :
pa which would have some effect on no-shows, there
ilies anybody that doesn’t have the spn
i oa
i is violating the law, and I am going to
ay ip Athos because this airline or that airline has
° it. . . . . .
18) hat is the very point of primary jurisdiction. a
the fact that there are other approaches or supplemen a
approaches, which is what conditional reservation was, 1S
J . .
fore, irrelevant in this case.
"he here the evidence is undisputed that the a
has not banned overbooking, the airlines overbooking
a tes opted for requiring the airlines to tender
deferred-boarding compensation to rend pment pas-
id, ‘‘You must never ;
senger. They have not said, a a
They have said, ‘‘If you do, you m
dusted beneiien compensation, and you must advise =
of their rights at the time about denied-boarding compe
sation, and you must file a list of your oversales every
' with the board.” |
—*} pecs have not said, ‘‘You can’t do any —.
And, therefore, I think we are chasing —— a = pam
ing } yhether or not there
hen we are looking into whe |
an things that would help with respect to the oversale

problem.

The Court: What do you say to that?

Mr. Robertson: Well, Your Honor, we are investigating
what the CAB has done, I think, precisely, and that is
what I am trying to ask this witness.

Furthermore, as I understand the contention of the
defendant Allegheny, it is that they concede that the CAB
has [144] urged the carriers to do everything feasible,
everything in their power, to eliminate overbooking.

I think that is in the opinion that has been introduced
into the record here, and I think that is just what I am
trying to explore with this witness.

The Court: How long will this take?

Mr. Robertson: Another five minutes on this, Your
Honor. This is a very important point, though, what op-
tions are available and what options are now available to
the carrier and whether this is really an economic neces-
sity or whethe it is something less desirable.

The Court: All right. Well, I am inclined to agree with
Mr. Roberson, but I will try to keep an open mind and
give it such weight as the court feels it is entitled to re-
ceive, in view of the issues in the case and in view of the
fact that the court is sitting without a jury.

Mr. Robertson: Well, I understand, Your Honor, that
the defendant is arguing that this practice of selling more
seats than they have available on a flight is an economic
necessity, and I intend to show that it is not.

The Court: All right. You may proceed.

[145] By Mr. Robertson:

Q. It is a fact, is it not, that least three other carriers
besides Eastern have now instituted the conditional reser-
vation tariff? A. I do not know.

Q. Do you know, or are you aware of the fact that the
conditional reservation has now been extended for an
additional two years until 1975? A. I do not.

66
Q. You did not know that? A. No.

[150] By Mr. Robertson:

i i ights an economic
_In what respect is overselling flig
B45 for an airline? A. May I have the question read

back?

The Witness: Well, overselling flights is not an cconounie
necessity. You used the word ‘‘overselling”’ and not over-
booking’. I assume you are using that distinction in-
tentionally. a

By Mr. Robertson: Pile af
[151] 0. I am not aware of a distinction. A. Well, an
overbooking relates to the practice in the reservation sys-
tem of placing—of accepting more reservations than you
have seats in inventory. .
But if the system works at all, there are very few, if any,

ge question related to oversales and not to over-
ary a there are no oversales, as distinguished from
overbooking, is because the overbooking process takes into
consideration the fact, No. 1, that, unfortunately, many
members of the public make multiple reservations, ae
the intention of using only one of several reservations, an
ering to cancel the others.

— 1 am cancellations come at the last hour, and no
more requests for reservations or few would come —
that period. But if you had turned away previous requests,
you would have no manner of retrieving them. as

So, ideally, overbooking should result in very few.
relation to the universe that you are working with, very few
oversales.

And your question was related to oversales.

Oversales, itself, is not an economic necessity. Oversales
is an economic detriment. It is unfortunate when it happens,

67

and I am sure the carriers feel that way, too. Because the
[152] carriers are penalized, and penalized severely, for
that oversale to the tune of 100 per cent of the face
amount of the ticket, in addition the value of the ticket.

If the carriers intentionally engage in overselling, they

would go bankrupt very shortly by the simple laws of
economics, sir.

Q. So, in other words, the amount of overbooking that
occurs is much greater than the amount of oversales that
result? A. My goodness, yes.

Q. So that in a given period of time, if they oversell a
quarter of a million people, in that same given period of
time they might have overbooked four or five times as many,

is that right? A. Yes. And that is ihe whole justification
for overbooking, because yon—

The Court: What is the difference again between an
“‘oversale’’ and an ‘‘overbooking’’?

The Witness: Your Honor, overbooking is a statistical
exercise in which you accept reservations. Let us say you
have 100 seats. Now, you may realize on the basis of your
past experience that in this particular market, if you have
100 reservations, only 70 of those passengers wil] show up.
I am giving you a typical example.

The Court: Yes.

The Witness: Well, in that case you would overbook
[153] that flight by perhaps 25 seats to take into account
the fact that 30 of those reservations are bad reservations
from the public’s point of view. They are not going to show

up for the flight, and they are not going to bother to cancel
the flight, or cancel the reservation.

The reason you do that, No. 1, is economically for your-
self; but, more importantly, from the board’s standpoint,
when I was there at least, we took into consideration the
fact you are accommodating these 25 people, to whom, if

you did not overbook, you would just say, ‘‘No, I am sorry.
We are full. You cannot make a reservation.”

They would sit home, and your plane would take off with
95 or 30 empty seats.

That is really, from the Civil Aeronautics standpoint, one
of the primary justification for overbooking. It is an accom-
modation of the public because of the careless habits of
other members of the public in holding seats which they will
not use.

But the oversale occurs in that unfortunate case where
either your statistical analysis is in error, but even by the
law of average sometimes things are a little higher and
sometimes things are lower.

There may be one or two passengers for particular flights
in rare instances who exceed the capacity of the airplane,
and that is when you have an oversale: when you must
deny a [154] passenger with a confirmed reservation a
seat on the aircraft.

The Court: If I have learned anything from this case,
I have learned that if you have to be at a meeting or have
to be at any one point or place in the country or the world,
where the airline is under the jurisdiction of the CAB, you
had better jolly well take a week in advance to get there, to
make sure you are going to make it.

The Witness: I am sorry, but I can’t agree with you,
Your Honor.

The Court: The remedy, it seems to me, if it is over-
booked or oversold, is set forth in the tariff, according to
your testimony.

The Witness: Yes, sir.

The Court: And that may be a wholly inadequate remedy.

The Witness: Well, the fact is that such a small per-
centage—

The Court: That does not go to the problem of the im-
portance of an individual being a certain place in point of
time.

Suppose I have to give a speech, as I do, in Ohio at the
end of this week and I do not get there because of over-
booking. The fact that the tariff provides me with a remedy

9
= wes plus 100 per cent of the face value of the ticket, or
atever it is, is not going to compensate me for my lack of
presence [155] at this meeting, or a number of others ©
that I have to go to next month.
er Witness : But if that particular carrier had not en-
~ — gg they may not have given you a
rvation in the first place. Y i y ;
reef ~ Ai ou might have stayed at
= Court: That is not in accord with what the Civil
eronautics Board approves as a matter of policy. Th
can still overbook. ee
ns Brey preronn I i for all three of these trips, still
’ e worth a darn wh
te: Mary sl en I get to the airport and
The Witness: I would suggest, Your Honor, that if you

are there within a reasonable ti
me bef
you would be accommodated. ore Might departure,

In most cases the way—

Pncad vey Well, the implication is left from the testi-

ntti A or = today that if you get there a half
e flight time—that i irli

in ee at is what the airlines normally

The Witness: Well, we would li
: ' k
an hour before flight time. .
[172] Q. What are the duties of a passenger service
representative, just briefly, with Allegheny? A. I would
be supervising the ticket counter and gate operations and
giving information to all the passengers that travel with
us, helping with children, and so forth.

Q. Were you on duty at Washington National Airport
on the 28th of April, 1972, when Flight 864 was supposed
to depart? A. Yes, I was, sir.

77

Q. What time was it scheduled to depart? A. 10:15 a.m.

Q. And what time were passengers allowed to start
boarding on that flight? A. Approximately 10:05 that
morning.

Q. How many passengers were boarded on it? A. 100.

Q. About how long did it take to board that 100 pas-
sengers? A. Five to ten minutes.

Q. What time had your gate area opened down there
posse a could begin checking in, as distinguished

rom actually getting on the plane? A. A i
7 peg p pproximately

Q. What did you say the flight capacity was of thi
ticular airplane?
Q. And what did you tell him? A. I advised him it
Beech 80.
"2 “And what is a Beech 80 plane? A. It is a commuter
ire aft, twin-engine turboprop.
1179] Q. It carrier how many passengers? A. Fifteen

~ if anything, did Mr. Nader say or do ——
you told him that this commuter aircraft was a Beech

id, ‘*C _”
‘a ‘A. At that time he started down the hall-

"(Q. Did you tender Mr. Nader this form that the airlines
are supposed to tender about the rights to denied-boarding
compensation in the event of an oversale? A. Yes, sir,
, © wll us about that. A. I gave wham a —
‘ - . e
t to the gate, and I advised im 0
mr He said, ‘‘That is all right. I already have yond
I still said, ‘‘You have to accept mine. You do not have
it, but you have to take it.””
a he tell you from what airline he had greed
had one of those denied-boarding compensation rights
cards? A. Yes, he said American Airlines. en
Q. Did he take the one from you! A. Yes, e did. ;
Q. What did he do with it? A. He put it in his pocket,

his coat pocket.

81

[180] Now, did Mr. Nader question you about whether
or not the commuter flight would be able to make the con-
nection to Philadelphia and get him to Hartford 55 min-
utes after the original flight, or did he cancel it after you
made the statement about the commuter aircraft? A. So
far as I remember, all he did Say was, ‘‘Cancel it.’’

Q. Before that, had you already explained about the
schedule in Philadelphia, the connection schedule? A.
Yes, I did.

The Court: Well, the implication of your testimony up
to this point is that, until the last question, when Mr. Na-
der was asked to meet you at Gate 16, he, in effect accepted

your proposition or offer to fly to Philadelphia and thence
to Hartford.

The Witness: That is correct, sir.

The Court: And he offered no objection to flying to
Philadelphia via this Beech 80 aircraft.

The Witness: I am sorry. Would you repeat that?

The Court: And he offered no objection to flying via the
Beech 80 aircraft.

The Witness: That is when he objected.
The Court: When?
The Witness: When he found out it would be a Beech 80.

[181] What time was this connecting flight scheduled to
arrive in Hartford, Connecticut? A. I think it was 12:10.

Q. Did Mr. Nader ask you, in substance, after you had
told him the plane was full, did he ask you to see if any-
body would volunteer to get off the plane and give up
their seat for him? A. Yes, he did.

Q. Did you agree to do that? A. N 0, I didn’t.

Q. Why not? A. The flight was already boarded and
ready to go, and [182] the selection is automatic once we
have 100 people on board.

Q. You are referring now to your Passenger Service
Manual, Mr. McDonald? A. Yes, sir.

Q. And that says that the last person to arrive is the
Yes, sir.

i bn aniienl under that policy to delay the
flight, trying to find out who would be least convenienced
or inconvenienced? A. No, I am not permitted to do that.

Q. Did you say anything to Mr. Nader about-—after
he had decided not to make the flight, about being able to
pick up the deferred-boarding compensation at the ticket
counter, if he wanted it? A. Yes, I did, sir.

e e eo e @ ® e @ - e
Cross-Examination
By Mr. Robertson:

Q. Mr. McDonald, what time, according to your testi-
mony, did the two other denied-boarding passengers ar-
dnl the gate, Mr. Koskinen and Mr. Pulzun? A. Ap-

imately 10:10.
*'Q. Not ‘0 12? [183]. A. Approximately somewhere

in that area?
Q. 10:10 A. 10:10, 10:12.

i tion was that the

[184] Q. Is it true that your recollec
two A. Lain arrived at about 10:05 or 10:10, when the
gate agent, the other agent at the gate, advised you ~
there were two extra passengers? A. I am not sure of
exact time, but that did happen. ;

Q. So you are not sure of the exact time? A. Not to
the second, no.

Q. Or to the five minutes? A. I could not be perfectly
sure, no.
"Q. Actually, Mr. Koskinen did arrive at the gate about
10:05, didn’t het A. Approximately.

Q. And Mr. Pulzun actually arrived at that gate about -

45 minutes to an hour ahead of time, didn’t he? A. That
i ssible.

y 6. In fact, wasn’t Pulzun one of the first ten or 11 people
who checked in? A. I don’t know.

Q. Well, wasn’t Pulzun actually allowed on the aircraft
and then put back off? [185] A. No, sir.

Q. You did not go out to the plane and make him get off?
A. I did not.

Q. And you do not know if anyone did? A. Nobody did.

Q. Are you aware that the company has gotten a state-
ment from Mr. Pulzun giving this account? A. No,
I am not.

Q. If he gave such a statement, would that be false?
A. I would believe it to be false.

Mr. Roberson: May it please the court, I don’t think he
ought to characterize what some other witness has given in
some self-serving statement.

The Court: Well, ask him whether it was the truth or not.

By Mr. Robertson:

Q. Was it the truth? A. To my knowledge, it was not.

Q. Are you still sure that Pulzun and Koskinen, as you
just testified, arrived about 10:10 to 10:12? A. At the
check-in position, yes.

Q. I thought you said that Pulzun may have arrived, it
was possible that he arrived, 45 minutes early? A. That
is possible.

Q. What time did Mr. Nader arrive? [186] A. Approx-
imately 10:15.

Q. You seem very exact about that? A. Yes, sir.

Q. How can you recall that so precisely? A. Because it
was right at the departure time. I try to be aware of the
time

Q. What was the scheduled departure time? A. 10:15.

Q. What time did the flight actually depart? A. Ap-
proximately 10:25.

Q. 10:25 a that,
mathe e flight is closed.’’ A. I could have said that,
Q. And you would have, if it h
' , ad be f
“ =o of a4 flight? A. Not uodorewarne wang gual
. Did you have a discussion with Mr. Nad
whether there were any stand-by’s on board? 1 Yan he
asked me if any stand-by’s had been boarded j
Q. What did you tell him? A. No, sir.
. oy you make a check? A. Yes, I did
' you have a discussion with hia about i
ak
mer iin gs - “ree to see whether marae might
r _to take a later flight, so that th
would not be disappointed? A. He asked me if I cous
= . se so he could get on the flight
. He asked you if
Pye = you would make an announcement?
: ave did you say? A. I said no.
Q. You were aware that there was som in hi
= bon that flight at this point? A. ee cal oe. -
. You were not aware that sncy
tha dies oho tee at there was any urgency? A.

Q. Do you recall having your deposition taken and giving

testimony und ; .
A. Yes, 4 - er oath on July 6, 1973, in this matter? [ 192]

_ And do you recall the following question:
baer you understand from him that there was some
about getting there?’
ae)’ do vou recall giving the following answer:
“ did. I did.’ A. That was after “ asked me to see
body else would get off the airplane.
Q. Ten't it true that Mr. Nader got to the gate in more
than ample time to make the flight, and if the flight had not
been overbooked, he would have been puton it? A. No, sir.
_ It is not true? A. It is not true.

; And your testimony is that the flight did not leave

il 10:25 A. Exactly. ante
"6, That gave him ten minutes? A. I am saying if the
flight were leaving as scheduled he would not have got-
ten on. ;

i in’t i had gotten
. I am asking you: Isin’t it true that if he
“ls that day, based upon when he did get there that day,
if the flight had not been overbooked, he would have been
mmodated? A. It is possible.
“0. It is true, isn’t it? [193] A. It could have gone
either way depending on how fast the computer was send-
ing out the weight and balance tare sheet.

Q. Why did you refuse to check whether any passengers
might help out the situation, considering the circumstances,
the fact that the problem had been induced by overbooking?
A. By my Passenger Service Manual, or Allegheny 8 man-
ual, it is automatic. I am not to delay the flight any fur-
ther, looking for somebody who may possibly be lesser in-

ienced.
Q. Well how long would it have taken? A. Not very

er Not more than 30 or 40 seconds, would it? A. Iam

ot sure.
7 Q. Well, you are pretty sure, are you not? A. Consider-
ing the airplane was about 100 yards away from the gate

I was.
"O. Well would it have taken you 20 seconds or 30 seconds

to walk to the airplane? A. I would say for the total time

of going out and making an announcement it would be one
minute,

Q. One minute, nowt A. Right.

Q. All right. A. And also coming back into the lounge.
Q. I am referring again to your deposition, on page 64.
Do you recall being asked the question: ‘‘And how long
would it [194] have taken to do this,’’ referring to making
the announcement and asking for a volunteer, and your
answer: ‘‘I am not sure. It would all depend on how easy
or how hard it would be for somebody to get up,

‘*Queston: Well, for example, would it have taken you
30 seconds to walk to the plane?

‘Answer: Approximately,

‘Question: And another 20 seconds to make the an-
nouncementf?

‘‘Answer: Not even that, 10 seconds.”’

Do you recall that testimony? A. Yes, I do,

Mr. Roberson: May it please the court, he ought to finish
reading from that, because he stops——

The Court: Read the full question and the full answer,
and then ask him if those questions were asked and those
answers given,

Mr. Robertson: Well, Your Honor, the rest of it relates
to an objection that was raised by Mr. Roberson.

Mr. Roberson: No, it does not.

You asked a question. I made an objection. Then the wit-
ness made an answer, and I think it is all pertinent to this
about how long it would take to——

Mr. Robertson: Very well, Your Honor.

The Court: I just got done reading it, but the witness
has not heard it, so you had better ask him.

[195] Mr. Robertson; The question that I put to the wit-
ness originally had to do with how long it would take to
make an annoucement.

The next question that we get into is, if someone accepted,

it might take another three or four minutes to get them
off the plane,

An objection was interposed by Mr. Roberson. ‘*How
about getting their baggage out of the hold?

And I respond, ‘‘That is true.’’

And the answer of the witness: ‘‘That would be impos-
sible. I would not even try it. There are 200 pieces of lug-

gage in there.’’
By Mr. Robertson:

Q. Do you recall that testimony? A. Yes, I do.

Q. So your prior testimony was that it might take you
30 seconds to make the entire trip out to the plane and
make the announcement, is that rightt A. And another
30 seconds or so to get back inside the lounge!

Q. Yes. A. Right.

Q. Another 30 seconds? A. Right. .

Q. So you are counting roundtrip, sirt [196] A.
"' aa it would not be necessary to take the baggage
off of the plane if someone wanted to volunteer, would it?
A. By company manual, it ic We are not allowed to

rate a passenger from his baggage.

. Well, saan someone has checked in for a flight and,
as the result of an oversale, it develops that they are over-
booked and don’t board it, and their baggage has already
been put on the plane. The baggage is going to go, is it not,
Mr. McDonaldt A. We will ask the passenger whether
wants his age back or not. |
~- But th frequently goes ahead to the destina-
tion, does it not? A. Most likely because we can get the
passenger there very quickly.

Q. So, all that would have been required was to tell who-
ever might volunteer that, ‘‘Your baggage will be waiting
for you in Hartford when you get there’? A. Yes.

[197] Mr. Robertson: I am through with that line, Your

Honor.
The Court: All right.

The Court: All right. I will overrule the objection and
give it such weight as the court feels it is entitled to.

By Mr. Robertson:

Q. Now, what is a‘‘PNL”’ or a passenger name list? A.
A “PNL”’ is a passenger name list.

Q. Well, what is that? A. It is a computerized listing of
the names of the passengers holding confirmed space on
a flight.

Q. This is used as a check-in tool, is it not? A. Not
necessarily,

Q. It is not used as a check-in tool? A. It does not have
to be.

Q. But it is used as a check-in tool? A. It is at times
used as a check-in tool.

Q. For the gate, right? A. Correct?

Q. But usually it is not used, is that correct? A. It de-

pends on the time of day and which flight and how many
agents are involved in boarding a flight.
[198] Q. So it is a tool that is often overlooked if there
is a press of passengers? A. It is not overlooked. The
PNL will be there. It may not be used to mark off every
passenger’s name as he checks in right then and there, but
they will have to use that eventually, sir,

Q. And this list of confirmed reservations is accurate up
to the time it is printed out and taken up to the gate, is
that right? A. That is correct.

Q. Now, the PNL was not used to check in Flight 864,
was it? A. It was there.

Q. It was there, but it was not referred to or used as
a check-in tool, was it? A. I don’t remember.

Q. You do not remember? A. Correct.

® @ ° ° * * @ * ® e
Q. Now, if over 100 persons were holding reservations

for Flight 864, this would show up on the PNL, would it
not? A. Yes, sir.

[199] Q. What is a ‘‘PBI’’? Do you know what that is?

A. Yes, sir. It is a Passenger Boarding Information read-
out or print-out from a computer.

Q. And what does this information provide? A. It will
give the information of all the passengers holding space on
the flight that have not been ticketed, plus passengers that
need assistance, plus the in-bound connections from both
Allegheny and other airlines.

Q. Well, it does give you that total number of passengers
who were booked out of your station, does it not? A. Yes,
it would.

Q. It also gives the status of the space out of each sta-
tion; in other words, if a flight is overbooked out of a par-
ticular airport, it would show ‘‘OB,’’ would it not? A.
Yes, it would.

Q. So doesn’t this provide you with a tool to find out
in advance whether a flight is overbooked or not? A. Yes,
it does.

Q. And isn’t this information made available to Alle-
gheny at the gates? A. It has to be picked up by the agent
who is working the flight, or that agent will ask for
somebody to get one. It is not a required piece of ma-
terial used for each flight.

Q. But it is available, is it not? A. Itis available.

[200] Q. And there are other tools available of the same
nature, such as the PMB, right A. That is correct.

Q. Therefore, isn’t it true that if a flight is heavily over-
booked, the information is in the computer and it is avail-
able to the agents at the gatet A. “hat do you mean by
‘heavily overbooked’’?

Q. Well, if a flight will hold 100 passengers and there are
107 or 108 booked with confirmed reservations on the flight,
this information is in the computer, and it is available to
the agents at the gate, is that right? A. That is right.

Q. Are they not supposed to know in advance the status
of the flight? A. Not necessarily. If an agent works 15 or
20 flights a day, it is hard to keep up with each flight.

Q. So, as a matter of course, sometimes it is just not
done? A. Which one are you speaking about now?

91

The Court: What is not done?
By Mr. Robertson:

Q. That the agents sometimes do not ascertain what the
ang tenaration in advance of the flight? A. They
usually know how many people are booked
rd ; number of ways of doing it, fanart
1] Q. Now, how was 864 actually ch i
W, ked
“a7 on this date? A. In what oye . mse
. Well, what happened when a passen
ger presented
himself to board the flight? A. At 9:30, the Ane made
a check-in announcement and started taking tickets and
stamping boarding envelopes for all the passengers.
Q. All right. A. That started about 9:30.
Q. And where were the passengers told to go? A. To
"- rena inside the lounge or in the Gate 17 area
, e stand-by’s wer i '
ny dao y e put in the same area? A.
Q. Then the door was opened to the ai
rplane and every-
one was sent out at once at that ti
“on tw dvwne trl ime to board? A. All
PR Fone they segregated? A. They were advised at
arding announcement t i i i
hte naw Oo remain seated until their
+ Se if more than 100——
e Court: Pardon me, sir. May I interrupt?
= — Of course, Your Honor. c
e Court: I may have missed somethi i
0 ieailleonh taker ething that is very
understood you to say earlier, sir, that all
: , Sir, the peopl
ome ow — the ship, Flight 864, by the a Mr.
skinen and Mr. Pulzun and Mr. Nad i
firmed reservations. 3 —tspeetaraatoame
The Witness: That is correct.

The Court: Well, now, from the an
, swer to the questio
he just asked, I gather that that may not have ta so

and that some of the °
ia of these people were stand-by’s that got on

i the
Witness: No. When we check in the passengers,
aante passengers, we hold on to their tickets at the check-
in desk. unin

The Court: Certainly.

The Witness: And, as the passengers are going out the
door, all the boarding envelopes are checked.

The Court: you mean, once a stand-by gets on, he be-
comes a confirmed reservation, the same as somebody who
called up six weeks in advance! é,

The Witness: Not for this particular flight, no, sir. 7

The Court: Were there any stand-by’s on this Flig

8641
The Witness: No, sir.
: Okay.

- at a Honor, if I may refer you to one
of plaintiffs’ exhibits that has been admitted into a
[203] Plaintiffs’ Exhibit No. 5—I refer specifically to -
first paragraph—I think you will see a company ~
that demonstrates the true answer to your question abou
whether any stand-by’s were boarded on the flight.

Q. According to the company’s records, there was at
least one stand-by boarded on the fight 1 si » sats
Mr. Roberson: Well, then, I submit it 1s immaterial.
would take at least three to get to Mr. Nader. He was the
third oversale, and if there were a stand-by on there that
shouldn’t have been on there, then Mr. Koskinen was en-
titled to it, or Mr. Pulzun. It was not Mr. Nader. They

could not skip them, Your Honor. . eee
So unless there were three on there, this is immaterial,
and I don’t think counsel is going to make any tender that
there were three. . bea
The Court: Well, you are a little bit late in objecting,
Mr. Roberson.
Mr. Roberson: I make an objection to the relevancy. If
there were a single stand-by, we are wasting time with this

witness, because it would take at least three for it to make
any difference in the outcome of this law suit.
[204] The Court: All right. You ought to look at that ex-
hibit, Mr. Roberson.

Mr. Roberson: I have looked at it, and I still say it does
not make any difference.

The Court: All right. Next question.

By Mr. Robertson:

Q. Well, now, you could have lifted more than 100 tickets
marked ‘‘Confirmed’’ at the time the flight was being
checked in, is that right? A. That is possible.

Q. Yes. And in that case more than 100 people might then
have walked out to the airplane when the gate was opened,
right? A. That is possible.

Q. And in that case somebody would have had to be sent
back, right. A. Yes, sir.

Q. The person sent back would be the guy, very likely,
who the least effective in shouldering his way on to the air-
craft, rather than the guy who was last in checking in for
the flight, is that right? A. That would be possible. Also,
at the same time, we try to keep a record of who was last
to check in, in case that does happen.

[206] Q. Now, was the reservations list or the PNL or
any of these tools actually used to see if passengers really
had reservations for the flight when they presented them-
selves? A. Yes, it was.

Q. It was? A. That is correct.

Q. And you ascertained, based on that, that all of these
passengers had an actual reservation for the flight? A.
All of these passengers had okayed tickets showing [207]
that they were confirmed.

Q. Right. That is not my——_ A. Except for one passen-
ger who had an open ticket.

Q. And which passenger what that? A. I don’t know.
I am pretty sure it was a group of four, or a family, and

the agent working the flight checked with the PNL, and
name was there.
7 My question was not whether you looked at the ticket
to see if it were in an okayed status, but whether you ac-
tually referred to the reservations list or the weight list
to see whether a person had a valid reservation? A. In
this case she referred to the PNL, and the name was there.

Q. How do you know that? A. I asked her.

Q. When did you ask her? A. Not too long ago.

Q. So it was after your deposition was taken, is that cor-
rect? A. Right.

Q. Now, ea are passengers supposed to be selected for
denied boarding? A. At Washington the selection is auto-
a Washington the selection is automatic? A. Any
area where there is gate check-in.

[208] Q. Well, the manual that I assume you are refer-
ring to really says that where the oversale is not known
in advance, isn’t that correct? A. That is correct.

Q. But here you knew in advance, or you could have
known in advance? A. I didn’t know in advance.

Q. And no one could have known in advance this flight
was oversold? A. They could have, but nobody advised
of it.

a * The company knew, didn’t they? A. Not necessarily.

Q. Not necessarily? It was in their computer records,
was it not? A. This is true.

Q. But you did not use the procedures that are applicable
where the oversale is known is advance? A. It is phys-
ically impossible.

Q. You did not use them, did you? A. At that time?

Q. Right. A. I was very busy that morning.

Q. All right, but you did not use them, did yout A. I
did not use the check-in tool?

Q. Excuse me. You did not use the procedures set forth
[209] in the manual for cases where a flight is known to be
oversold in advance? A. That is correct, because I did
not know the flight was overbooked.

Q. But by checking with any of the status tools, with
any of the check-in tools, you could have seen the flight
was overbooked, couldn’t you A. That is correct.

Q. Do you ever use these procedures for denying board-
ing and selecting passengers where the flight is known to
be oversold in advance? A. Yes, I have.

Mr. Roberson: Now, just a minute. Your Honor, counsel
is using ‘‘overbooked’’ and ‘‘oversale’’ as if they are the
same thing, and I think that is confusing and tricks the
witness. He could not know that there was an oversale
until the 101st passenger showed up.

He could know it was overbooked, but he is slipping
that ‘‘oversale’’ in when he should be saying ‘‘over-
booked. ’’

The Court: Well——

Mr. Roberson: I think it is important, Your Honor.

The Court: I think the witness is an expert witness in
the nomenclature of the trade. I doubt if he has been
tricked here. 3

Mr. Roberson: I think that Mr. Robertson knows the
[210] difference between those, and I think he ought to
be precise in his questions.

The Court: Well, I would agree. Counsel, if you can,
limit your questions to one of the two subject matters,
when you ask the witness a question.

By Mr. Robertson:

Q. How are you instructed to handle the oversold pas-
sengers? A. I don’t understand your question.

Q. Well, what are your instructions for handling an
oversold passenger? A. Via the manval

Q. Whatever instructions you have. A. First of all, to
keep the passenger calm.

Q. To keep the passenger calm? A. Right. Very often
passengers will get quite upset. And then to listen to the
passenser, of course, if he has anything to say, and then
advise him what I can do to get him to his destination
as soon as possible.

Q. Are you instructed to advise him the reasons why

he has been denied boarding? A. I am not sure if the
1 states that or not.

mO. I would like to show you an exhibit, Mr. McDonald,

Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 6. That is the manual used by Alle-

gheny’s passenger service agents, including yourself?
[211] A. That is correct.

[212] Are you instructed to advise the passengers what
happened and the reason for the oversale? A. I don’t
“ean right. A. I could not give you verbatim on that.
You have a copy of the manual there. That is a year
old now, and it is changed quite often.
Q. Are you advised to tell the passenger that an in-
tentional overbooking may have caused his oversale? A.
I usually would advise the passenger that there has been
a mistake; exactly what it is, I don’t know, unless, of
course, it is an equipment substitution, or something like
“. You would not advise him that an intentional over-
booking policy may have caused his distress? A. No, I
’t think I would.
“~~ boy that is because you do not think it is good
publicity for the company, do you? A. That is true. :
The Court: Is that the reason you did not do it in this

instance?
The Witness: I was not sure of the reason for it at

that time.
[213] By Mr. Robertson:

i t that
. Well, you did mark on the forms and the repor
m. filed the reason for the oversale being overbooking,
did you not? A. Yes, I did. That was the most obvious
reason, but I still was not sure. )
Q. Now, this is the last short series of questions. Con-
cerning this trip to Philadelphia with the possible con-

nection to Hartford, was this a legal connection in Phila-
delphiat A. No. Company-wise, it was not a legal con-
nection.

Q. It was an illegal connection, was it not? A. That
is correct.

Q. Was there some risk that the connection might be
missed? A. There would have been some risk.

Q. Did you guarantee that it would be made? A. No.

Q. Did you tell him it would be close? A. Yes, I did.

Q. And even if the connection had been made, the
second flight was not scheduled to arrive at Bradley Field
until almost an hour after the first flight, is that right?
A. Approximately 55 minutes.

[214] Q. All right. And you gave a report in writing
about this denial of boarding to someone in the company?
A. Just the required denied-boarding form.

Q. You did make a report? A. Yes, I did,

Q. Mr. Nader did not tell you at any time that the
type of aircraft that was offered to him had anything
to do with his decision, did het A. No, he did not.

Q. And, in fact, you had informed him of these verious
other features and problems with the alternative trans-
portation—— A. I advised him I would have somebody
meet him because it would be a close connection.

[215] Q. Was the flight actually held up in Philadelphia
for the connecting passengers? A. It did not have to be.

Redirect Examination
By Mr. Roberson:

Q. Does your company require you to board anyone
that has an okayed, ticket, everyone that has an okayed
ticket for a flight? A. Yes; if the ticket is written cor-
rectly, regardless of any other information, the passen-
ger is to be boarded.

Q. If it has an ‘‘okay’’ on the ticket, then you down
there board him, is that correct? A. That is correct.

Q. And that was the situation on this flight: that you
boarded the first 100? A. That is correct, sir.

oe @ e @ @ * eo * @ °°
[216] Recross-Examination
By Mr. Robertson:

Q. Is this program of checking in anyone with a con-
firmed okay showing on their ticket, is this set forth in
the tariffs? A. It is in the company policy manual, yes.

Q. Is it in the same section on denied-boarding priori-
ties that we have been taking about? A. I am not sure.
I don’t think so,

Q. You don’t think it ist A. It would be in a different
section.

Q. All right. A. There is a general section for pas-
senger check-in.

Q. But the section that is submitted to the CAB con-
cerning denied-boarding procedures, this is not contained
in that section? A. I don’t know,

Q. Thank you.

eo ® e@ eo @ oe ° e @ °
(Witness excused)

The Court: Now, we will return here when, Madam
[217] Clerk?

The Clerk: September 10th.

The Court: And you will produce your other witness
on that date?

Mr. Robertson: Yes, Your Honor.

Mr. Roberson: Your Honor, I have one witness here
from Pittsburg, because I understood Your Honor wanted
to finish the case today. So I brought him down from
Pittsburg.

He will not take very long.

The Court: How long is not very long?

Mr. Roberson: Maybe counsel will stipulate that he
will testify to what I have said at page 7 of my brief,
which is only about ten lines. That is on page 7. The
witness is John H. Jenkins.

The Court: Wait a minute.

Mr. Roberson: I don’t think there is any dispute that
that is—about any of that in there.

The Court: All right.

Mr. Roberson: Of course, if we can stipulate to that,
it is quicker than having him in here,

The Court: Let me read it.

Have you got that, Mr. Robertson?

Mr. Robertson: Yes.

The Court: Will you stipulate, if he were called. he
would so testify?
[218] Mr. Robertson: Yes, I would.

The Court: All right. The court will be in recess, so
far as this case is concerned, until Monday, September
10th, at 2:00 p.m., at which time the further witnesses for

either side will be presented that either side wishes to
testify.

* e ° o . . ° e e e
Excerpt From Transcript
September 10, 1973
° ° ° e . . ° e e e
[8] John Koskinen
° o °° @ @ . e e e e

Direct Examination
By Mr. Robertson:

Q. State your name and residence for the record, please.
A. My name is John Koskinen. My residence is in the
District of Columbia.

100

[9] Q. In 1972, April, what was your employment! A.
I was administrative assistant for Senator Ribicoff of
Connecticut.

Q. And your duties in that job? A. As his adminis-
trative assistant, I was responsible for the operations
of his staff, both in Washington and in Connecticut.

Q. And on April 28, 1972, do you recall having a con-
firmed reservation for Allegheny Flight 864 to Hartford
from Washington? A. Yes, I did.

Q. Were you ticketed in advance for this flight? A.
Yes, I was.

Q. And what exactly happened when you arrived at
the gate [10] to check in for this flight? What time was
it, first of allt A. I arrived approximately eight to ten
minutes in advance of the departure time at the gate with
my ticket. There was no one standing in front of me
that I can recall. I approached the agent, handed him my
ticket. He stated that there was—there was a pause, and
then he stated that they had a bit of a problem. He made
a call on his receiver and told me—all of this took place
in a matter of seconds—that there was not a seat on the
plane.

When I asked him how that could be since I had a
ticket, he said that they had overbooked.

At that point in time, as I was beginning to explain
to him that I had a meeting for the Senator in Con-
necticut, a voice over my shoulder said, ‘‘You think you
have a problem.’’ I turned around, and Mr, Nader was
right behind me.

Q. And you knew Mr. Nader personally? . e

[30] The Court: And the size of the group that appeared
there was not affected one way or the other by Mr. Nader’s

presence, or lack of presence?

107

The Witness: Very much so, Your Honor. It was affected
by his lack of presence.

The Court: Let me ask you this question, sir:

How could it have been affected when they did not know
that Mr. Nader was not going to be able to arrive?

The Witness: Well, when I said 1000, the 1000 people
who showed up were there before we even were under
way with the rally.

t stood up and announced that Mr. Nader was not
going to be tehre, and the crowd evaporated, to a large
extent. From that point on it was all downhill.

But I think the important thing to remember is this:

The purpose of the rally from our point of view was
to raise some money. From the time Mr. Nader—we
learned that he could not show up, this purpose was frus-
trated, because we did not go ahead with the fund-raising.

Tn other words, we did not have people selling buttons
and bumper stickers. We did not have anyone making a
pitch for money, because we felt people would have thought,
after the big build-up, that we were asking them to come
down [31] to this Plaza using Mr. Nader as a drawing
card, and then not having him there, and then saying,
‘‘Hey, how about giving us some money for this rate
case.”’

So we just decided not to do it, and the crowd was
not there to do it with anyway, by the time the rally
actually started.

[32] Q. Let me ask you how you specifically knew what
flight—whether you specifically knew what flight Mr. Nader
was to arrive on. A. Oh, sure.

Q. And how did you know that? A. Well, I knew it
because I, No. 1, had checked with the lady who does his
travel, who does his arranging. Secondly, I called the
airline, as I have done in several instances, by just calling
and saying, ‘‘I would like to confirm that Mr. Nader has
a reservation on this flight.’’ I just do that to be sure
he is booked on a particular flight.

108

Q. You called the airline and asked whether Mr. Nader
had a confirmed reservation? A. That is right.

Q. What did they tell you, when you called? A. They
said yes. I had done that before, and this time they said
yes, as they always had.

Q. Did you rely on this knowledge that was conveyed
to you in making the plans for the rally? A. Well, of
course. He was the attraction, and we leafleted very, very
heavily. That was the other thing that I may have failed
to mention. We leafleted all the insurance [33] companies
and other places where you would naturally draw people
from for an event of this kind at noontime.

Q. Okay. Were you aware of, or did Allegheny inform
you of, their intentional overbooking practice? A. No.

Q. Did you know that this particular flight had been

overbooked? A. No.

. But if you had known in advance, were there other
Pte you Rte have done to save the rally? A. Other
things that would have gotten Mr. Nader there?

. Yes. A. Yes. oe

4 ace, specifically? A. Well, the point is, I think, is
that I felt there was nothing we could do to save the rally
at that time. I assume that we could have gotten another
flight, or attempted to get another flight. ;

[34] Q. An earlier flight? A. An earlier flight, yes.
Q. Or some other means of transportation? A. Yes.
s.

“— Would you have done things that way, had you

known of the risk? A. Yes.

Q. And then you learned that Mr. Nader was not on
the flight. By what means did you learn that? A. By
“tat what did you do then? A. Well, I dispatched
the person who was then my administrative aide to Boston.
Immediately after finding out that he was not going to be
on that flight, then a short time after that, a matter of

Te

—,

moments, finding out that he was going to be on a flight
to Boston, we sent Mr. Chapman off to fetch him. Then,
I began preparing very quickly some remarks to make
before the rally was really under way.

[42] Cross-Examination
By Mr. Roberson:

[50] Q. When do you say you made the arrangements
with Mr. Nader to speak at the rally in Hartford? A.
The arrangements were made with Mr. Nader’s repre-
sentative sometime around the end of the week prior to
the arrangements for the rally for his appearance at the
rally, sometime around the end of the week prior to his
appearance.

Q. The rally was scheduled for April 28th. Would ‘‘some-
time around the end of the week’’ mean the previous
Saturday? [51] A. I think it was probably Thursday or
Friday. That is my recollection.

Q. Now, you remember having your deposition taken in
this case in November of 1972, and being asked questions
when you were under oath about this case? A. Oh, yes.

Mr. Roberson: Page 6, Your Honor.

The Court: All right.

By Mr. Roberson:

Q. ‘‘Question: Do you have any documentation that
would make you positive as to when that was done?’’ This
is talking about your call to Mr. Nader’s representative.
A. Yes.

Q. ‘‘Answer: No, I don’t. I do know that it was late
in the week, prior, probably a Saturday.’’

That question was asked you, and that is the way you
answered it; isn’t that sot A. Yes, I suppose.

Q. And when was it that you arranged with the Mayor
and the City Council President to speak at this electric

110

utility protest rally? A. Again, I think it was right after
I confirmed that Ralph would be able to do the rally that
we began finalizing it with the Mayor, late in that week
prior, around the 20th, the 21st.

® € e » @ e ° @ a ®

[52] Q. If Friday were the 28th and you first learned
that Nader said he was going to be able to speak on the
previous Saturday, it was after Saturday that you arranged
with these people, was it, or had you taken it up with
them beforehand? A. Oh, we had taken up with them
beforehand the possibility of doing this, certainly.

Q. And you had flyers printed up and distributed by
your people advertising this rally, didn’t you? A. Yes.

Q. When did you have those mimeographed, or however
you had them produced? A. As I recall, again, early in
the week of the week that the rally took place.

Q. Was the rally scheduled for 12:15 to start? A. I
think we originally talked about noon, and then we thought
that maybe we had better give people a chance to get down
from Hartford Fire and Aetna and places like that, which
is quite a walk.

[53] Q. Mr. Moffett, would you answer my question? I
asked you if you transmitted to Mr. Nader the information
that the rally was to start at 12:15. Now, is the answer
to that, that you did transmit it, or you did not? A. The
answer is I am not sure.

Q. I show you what has been introduced into evidence
as Exhibits F and G. Are these copies of the two flyers
that your group distributed during the week before the
rally? A. Yes.

Q. Both of them call this a ratepayers’ rally, do they
not? A. Sure.

Q. They do not say it is a fund-raising rally, do they?
A. No.

—_

111

[55] How leng had you planned for this rally t
A. Roughly, 50 minutes. cadets

Q. And that would have taken it from 12:15, according
[56] to those flyers, to five minutes after 1:00, wouldn’t
it? A. That is right.

Q. So if Mr. Nader had arrived at Hartford on a flight
arriving there at 12:15, he would have gotten to Consti-
tution Plaza before the rally was planned to break up,
wouldn’t he? A. No.

Q. Referring to page 37 of your deposition, did I ask
you this question, and did you answer this way:

‘‘Question: Had Mr. Nader arrived at Wartford by
12 :15, at the airport, he could have gotten into the Con-
stitution Plaza meeting before it broke up, couldn’t he?

‘*Answer: Well, not much before it broke up. You see
we lost the crowd at that point.’’

Was that question asked you, and did you answer that
way, sir? A. Yes. .

Q. And although your rally had been planned to go to
1:05, in fact, it broke up about 12:45, isn’t that right? A.
That is right.

Q. Now, had you known that Mr. Nader was going to
try to make a connecting flight, you could have put that
rally in a holding pattern, and Mr. Nader could have
spoken at the end of it, could he not? A. No.

Q. Who spoke first at the rally? [57] A. I did.

Q. And you spoke about five minutes? A. Roughly.
Maybe a little more. Roughly five minutes.

Q. And when did the Mayor speak; was he next? A
Yes, he was.

Q. About how long did he talk? A. Oh, I don’t
I think he talked—it is hard to recall, but dab sae
minutes.

Q. And about how long did Carbone talk? A. Carbone
no talked, oh, ten minutes or so.

. So you got your 30 minutes of s i i
isn’t that right? A. Thirty? vo

112

Q. Yourself, five; Carbone, ten; and the Mayor, 15?
A. Yes, sir.

Q. And had Mr. Nader arrived down at Constitution
Plaza by 12:45, he would have had 20 minutes to talk,
wouldn’t hef Allegheny Passenger Service Manual] ¢-99 Page 2

‘ April 1, 1972

OVERSALE
Was the oversale caused by Offer the same services as r
OVERSALE ; substitution of equipment? cancellation of a rence
oe . boarding station due to Con-
| : i. ——
An oversale is a passenger who holes confirmed ticket for a Erodtabis conditions.

flisht, and who checks in for the flight (this means eppearing
"e at our local ticket lift point before scheduled departure time),
but who cannot be accomodated on that flight because of in-

sufficient seats or seats being blocked. Give every oversold Is there a flight or
passenger a copy of “Notice to Passenger Denied Boarding”, flights on AL * other Rebook passengers:
Fora SS-112. - airlines that is planned Retrieve passenger PNR

to arrive at the passen-
ger's ultimate destina-
—_ yoy eo peces not
ater than ours after -
the flight(s) on which - ered Bg or pee
confirmed space was held nterru at is be

(4 hours for flights to P —

Adjust space as required

t is the oversold assenser's choice to accept or reject J
I Pp ? j using PACER procedures.

alternate transportation; unless it is on a Certificated Air
Carricr of Public Convenience issued by the CAB. If a
passenger accents and uses alternate transportation, such as
air taxis, limousine, cabs, rental cars, etc. and the alternate
C transportation is planned to arrive at the passenger's desti-
nation within 2 hours of his scheduled arrival (4% hours for
Canada) do not pay D.B.C. a. oer

- reissue ticket using PR-5
Rule 380 if travel 4 to

: OPE te be on two or more airlines.

See Next Page.

The term stop-over means a ccliberate interruption of a
passenger's trip which is scheduled to exceed~four hours at
a point between the place of departure and destination. A
‘passenger traveling Williamsport to St. Louis with a connec-
tion in Pittsburgh is oversold, It is Allegheny's responsi-
bility to get the passenger to STL, not PIT, within 2 hours
of the original scheduled arrival time to avoid paying D.B.C.
C If unable to get to STL, D.B.C. is paid. IPT-PIT.

When rerouting an oversold passenger to another airport within
the same metropolitan erca it is the passenger's choice to
accept or reject the rerouting. A passenger is oversold with
a destination of O'Hare. Alternate transportetion to Midwey
arrives within 2 hours of his scheculed arrival. If the over-
sold passenger eccents and uses the alternate transportation,
do not pay D.B.C. ;

If a pascenger is “oversold” the cost of the services you
provide him aust not exceed the value of the refund of his
ticket and the D.B.C. due hin.

Airline enployees and their cligible fanily nembers traveling
Reduced Rate (Industry Discount) are not eligible for D.B.C.
payments. ;

) , .
CF cher 0.0. ; ie een ie é

142

——

6-99 “sre 3
October 1, 1970

— 143

6-99 Page 4
Yecember 10, 1970

_

’
OVERSALE (CONT'D)

Is there chartered surface transpor-

tation (bus, limo, taxi, car rental)

that /

‘/- is acceptable and is planned to

| arrive at the passenger's destina-
tion or stopover point rot later
than 2 hours after the flight(s) on
which confirmed space was held? (4%
hours for flights to and from

. Canada.)

- charges less than the combination
of boarding involuntary refund plus
denied boarding compensation?

Is there an Air Taxi acceptable to the

passenger that

- meets the requirements in 6-75.

- is planned to arrive at the

‘ passenger's destination or stopover
point not later than 2 hours after
the flight(s) on which confirmed
space was held. (4% hours for flights
to and from Canada.)

- charges less than the combination of
involuntary refund plus Denied
Boarding Compensation.

Offer to pay Denied Boarding Compen-
sation, and offer the same services
as for Cancellation of a Passenger's
Boarding Station or Deplaning Station
due to Uncontrollable Conditions.

Charter transporta-
tion.

Use A-6 as authori-
zation.

Lift passenger's
flight coupon, attach
to Found Ticket,
Form A-26, describing

why ticket was lifted.

Send to Revenue
Accounting in next
Sales Report.

DO NOT PAY PASSENGER
DENIED BOARDING
COMPENSA7T ION.

HOW TO COMPUTE THE AMOUNT AND PAY THE DENIED BOARDING COMPENSATION

1.

Determine the value of the flight coupon. This value is
the point-to-point fare without tax from the oversold
boarding point to the destination shown on the flight
coupon less any discount applicable to the coupon.

If the value of the

._ flight coupon is Pey the Customer

$25.00 or less ------------------ $25.00
More than $25.00 woe ennnn------- Full value of coupon an

not more than $200.00.

d

Prepare A-79, Refund Draft, for the amount of the compensa~-

tion and make these special entries:

—

eri Numbe

From oversold boarding point
to destination shown on

flight coupon

a

—a— | C] mvownrar os 27,3 2
—_—s y

?

>

¢

"OS" and amount of

compensation

a 2Ho
es — ~
Flight Number and Date pats Le] 2-72 — AP3
as REASON g
N Note: All Allegheny Comauter Airlines pay Denied Boarding
Compensation to oversold passengers. ‘
eer po ol “— i ee oe wd
Se i RSS ay

, i’

PASSE CR SERVICE MANUAL

et
. 0 9 Se Apne 144
ee

6-99 Page S$
October 1, 1976

- If GTR is form of payment of . Lex
passenger's ticxet, mak
Refund Draft payable to “Treasurer of the u.s.” Seeae
passenger's name, "GTR}'" and have passerger sign in the

” ”
— boz of the Refund Draft. Do not cash Draft for

- The passenger must receive the D.B.C. pcyment on th.

and place of the oversale. If the rath on. wee alternsie:

transportation departs before the Draft can be pre ered

you have 24 hours to mail this to the passenger. . :

HOTE: If passenger is a standby on a flight

that is scheduled to recch his destination
within the 2-hour time Limit, do not pay
D.B.C,. immediately. Advise passenger to
return for D.B.C. payment if he is not
eleared on the standdy flight.

_, 4, Stamp back of Refund Draft with "Release of Liability" stone

S. Give the Draft to the passenger.

- The passenger may ask you to cash the Draft. “If so,

ask pas e i
— to endorse draft. Include in next bank

C 6. For additional information, see Rules Tariff, Rule 380.

: . ane 740s

owe torverves&

145 cu-ceee aumee
6-100 Paze 1
March 10, 1971

-

OVERSALES

An oversale is a passenger who holds confirmed ticket

for a flight, and who checks in for the flight (this

means appearing at our local ticket lift point before
scheduled departure time), but who cannot be accommocated
on that flight because of insufficient seats or seats
being blocked. Give every oversold passenger Form SS-112.

Oversales are usually the result of:

~- Reservations or travel agencies unintentionally
confirming passengers on waitlisted flights.

- Ticket agents issuing tickets without verifying
reservation status. |

- Stations clearing standbys for a flight and over-
booking downline waitlisted stetions.

- Aircraft weight limitations caused by high fuel
loads or restricted take-off weights.

- Substitution of equipment.

Use the following procedures to:
- clear overbooked flights.

- handle oversales when they occur.

—— eee
e oc ee —_— ewe re mee ———— ome

WER SERVICE ty
ELLA 148 PASSC.SGER SERVICE MANUAL

6-100 Pace 4
August 15, 1979

ee ALLSG?..:NY

catstitn ents a? te

149 PASS..AGER SERVICE MANUAL

6-100 Page 5
February 10, 1972

.

Handling the Oversold Passenger

Try to separate the oversold passenger from other
passengers; be patient, courteous, and tactful.
Listen consideratecly; let the passenger talk.

Apologize for the inconvenience and } interruption to
his travel arrangements.

Explain the reason for the oversale

- Caused by an unintentional error made in confirn-
ing reservations for the flight. This type of error
is infrequent; and unfortunately, impossible to
‘rectify at this time. An oversale report is imnedi-
ately submitted to our Central Reservations office,
who investigates and follows up with the erring office
which would be a travel agent, other smsttne, or
one of our own offices.

- Or, equipment substitution. (Explain in as much
detail as possible.)

- Or, weight restriction. (Explain in as much
detail as possible.) :

Remove the passenger's baggage from the flight.

Give oversold passenger copy of "Notice to Passengers i
Denied Boarding,” Form SS-112.

There are meny services which can be offered to the
oversold passenger. These services are found in
Section 6-99.

You must also offer Denied Boarding Compensation (DBC)
to oversold passengers meeting certain conditions. See
Section 6-99. -

REPORTING AND INVESTIGATING OVERSALES

Who

Oversold Station

’ Customer Service
Manager

1.

Ss.

Complete an original and 3 copies of
the Oversale Report Form SS-113 for

each oversold passenger whether DBC

is paid or not.

Call Central Res Control in PIT CRO,
Ext. 271 or 262, and report the
oversale.

Retrieve a hard copy of the oversold
passenger's PNR and PNR history using
your 1977 agent set.

Attach the copy of PNR and PNR history

to the Customer Relations copy of SS-119.

Give report to your Customer Service
Manager.

If no contact with the passenger at
the time of the oversale:

THEN

call each oversold passenger unless
you are positive he/she is satisfied
with the explanation and alternate
service provided. In either case,
enter a brief summary on the back of
the SS-119 and sign it.

Examples:

Passenger very irate. VIP. CSM
called passenger at home, explained
circumstances and apologized.
Passenger very understanding.

(signed) C.S.M.

continued... —-

= 4

awe ~ . Mle. ‘ty
ai

6-100 Page 6

February 10, 197?

—

REPORTING AND INVESTIGATING OVERSALES CCONT'D)

Who

Customer Service
Manager

> me.

Submit completed SS-119's no later then

oversale occurs.

Does Whet

Examples: (cont'd)

Passenger was G.I. Couldn't care

less about delay. Happy with

$25.00.
(signed) C.S.M.

“PSR Smith handled passenger. Pas-
senger satisfied with alternate

transportation.
' (signed) C.S.M.
Distribute SS-1193:

C

Original - Director of Reservations.
Copy #1 - Director of Customer .
Relations with copies

. Of PNR and PNR

attached.

Copy #2 --Station file.

history

Copy #3 - Your Regional Director.

72 houre after tha

PASSENGL? SERVICE MANUAL

¢ 6-100 Page 7
March 10, 1971

=2sar€ BEPORT _$S-119
a FLIGHT FO- TIGHT DATE
oe (Last) waren) mS.
, MISS C—J
DdaeSs (Street) — (City) (State) — (Zip Code)
=LEPRONE (City) — (Nuaber)

RST FLiGai Sec™

oh ew

— ke

TCKET KO. [DATE AND PLACE OF ISSUE
" rare FaovIe.>

cost

iSPOSLTION OF CONTINUING/RETURS SPACE

‘USE OF OVERSALE

AMOUNT OF DBC PaAlD

“STRISCTION: ORIGINAL - DIRECTOR, RESERVATIONS
COPY 1 - DIRECTOR, CUSTOMER RELATIONS
COPY 2 = STATION FILE

152

PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT 14—CORRESPONDENCE RE OVERSALES

{Letter to Allegheny]
May 2, 1969
The President
Allegheny Airlines, Inc.
Washington National Airport
Washington, D.C. 20001

Dear Sir:

I was scheduled with a confirmed reservation out of Wash-
ington National on your flight No. 864 last Tuesday morn-
ing, April 29, at 10:30 A.M. A vice president of our com-
pany and general counsel was scheduled out together with
me on the same flight. We arrived at the airport and
checked in at your main ticket counter upstairs in the
main lobby at about 9:45 A.M. We were accepted on
your flight No. 864, our bags checked, and we were told
that the flight would leave from Gate No. 7 — gate time
was noted to be 10:10 A.M.

We lingered around the main lobby for a short period of
time, then proceeded on to Gate No. 7 arriving there about
10:15 A.M. We walked by the desk at the gate into the
waiting room without being challenged by anyone although
two attendants were at the desk at the time. We sat down
in the waiting room and were advised by one of the attend-
ants via the speaker system that Flight No. 864 was de-
layed and would now depart at 10:50 A.M.

We left the waiting room, walked down the hall and back,
and reentered the waiting room — again not being chal-
lenged by either attendant. The flight had not been called
at 10:45 so my associate went to the desk at the gate

to inquire about the flight. He was asked for his ticket
and called to me that I needed to present my ticket.

153

When I presented my ticket, quite a bit of confusion took
place. I was finally told that due to an error by the com-
puter the flight had been over sold. I was not allowed to
board the flight, but I was told that I would be scheduled
on a later flight that was to leave two hours later.

My associate and I were on a very tight schedule. We had
a very important appointment scheduled at Springfield,
Massachusetts, an appointment that was to iast all after-
noon. We had another appointment scheduled in Hart-
ford, Connecticut the next morning that would carry un-
til our departure time at 3:05 P.M. Wednesday for our re-
turn trip to Harlingen. Needless to say we were severely
inconvenienced by the delay.

I was escorted back to the main lobby by your Mr. Henry
Rouson. There I was offered a check in the amount of
$29.60 for my inconvenience — that being the one-way
fare from Washington to Bradley Field. Mr. Rouson asked
me to endorse the check and he would pay me in cash, at
the same time calling my attention to the wording that I
would endorse. My endorsement would free Allegheny
from further liability. I refused to endorse the check —
thus ending our conversation.

I might add that I continued on to Bradley field, arriving
for my appointment 3% hours late. I would also like for you
to know that I was treatea at all times with courtesy and
respect by Mr. Rouson and the rest of the personnel, for
which I am grateful.

Yours very truly,

HYGEIA DAIRY COMPANY

JHA:1d
By: Jas. H, Alexander

cc: Mr. R. Ames
Customer Relations

154

{Letter from Allegheny]

CLOSED No. 59-47
May 08, 1969
Mr. James Alexander
Box 751
Harlingen, Texas

Dear Mr. Alexander:

Mr. Barnes has asked me to reply to your letter cf May
02. May I extend a sincere apology for the incorvenience
incurred,

We appreciate your taking the time to advise us of the cir-
cumstances related to your travel with us on April 29. A
copy of your correspondence is being forwarded to our
Vice-President of Customer Service for review in an effort
te prevent recurrence.

Please accept the enclosed check for $29.60. This is paid
to you because of our failure to accommodate you to
your ticketed destination within two hours of your ori-
ginally scheduled arrival time.

May I also add that it is a pleasure to relay your appre-
ciative comments on our service to all concerned.

Thank you for allowing our review. We look forward to

the opportunity to welcome you aboard many times in
the future.

Sincerely,
RSA:ck rc — es
Enclosure irector, Customer Relations
cc L.O. Barnes

bec: P.D. Brennan—For your information. Thank you.

bec: R.W. Bussen—Credit DBC for $29.60 per ticket no.
033-482-647-079. Thank you.

155

{Letter to Allegheny]
THE DEPUTY POSTMASTER GENERAL
Washington, D.C. 20260

June 11, 1969
Dear Mr. Barnes,

It is disturbing to me, to say the least, that I have had no
explanation as yet from you as to the exceptionally poor
service and treatment which my wife and I experienced with
your company at the Hartford/Springfield Airpozt. This

lack of any response is especially aggravating since the inci-
dent was called to your company’s attention on June 2,
1969, by Mr. Batrus, my Executive Assistant, in direct phone
contact with your Vice President, Mr. Brennan.

After having been confirmed and ticketed in advance for re-
turn to Washington on your flight 931, Sunday, June 1,
1969, and having again confirmed by phone to your station
at Hartford at 8:00a.m. on the day of departure, I was told
on arrival a half-hour before flight time that no seats were
available for me and my wife.

It was very important that I return to Washington at that
time, and despite my plea for assistance in arranging trans-
portation, even by charter if necessary, I received no coopera-
tion whatsoever. In fact, I received only abrupt and discour-
teous disregard of my request by your personnel, and was
put to the added inconvenience of having to arrange myself
for a charter flight at a cost to me of $330.00.

I felt you should know this since I obviously must be con-
cerned with the general quality of performance of certificated
air carriers.

Sincerely,
Mr. Leslie O. Barnes /s/ E. T. Klassen
President, Allegheny Airlines E. T. Klassen

Hangar 12, Washington National Airport
Washington, D.C. 30001

156

[Letter from Allegheny]
October 17, 1969

Mr. F. E. Batrus

Executive Assistant to the
Deputy Postmaster General

Office of the Deputy Postmaster
General

Washington, D.C. 20260

Dear Mr. Batrus:

I first want to apologize for the inconvenience Mr. and
Mrs. Klassen were exposed to when they attempted to
travel with us on June Ist.

I have attached our customer relations adjustment check
in the amount of $301 to cover their additional expenses.

I sincerely trust they their future travels with us will be
most pleasant and should they incur any difficulty I would
appreciate hearing from them.

Sincerely,

L. Thomas Ferguson
LTF:e

attach.
bec: R.S. Ames
W.L Meyers

157

[Letter from Allegheny]
September 16, 1969

Mr. John N. Hansson
12409 Braxfield Ct. No. 4
Rockville, Maryland 20852

Dear Mr. Hansson:

I am in receipt of a copy of your correspondence to East-
ern Airlines regarding your decision not to pay for the air
transportation provided by Allegheny between Hartford
and Washington.

This is indeed distressing since the airlines are prohibited
by law from providing free transport and must process for
collection. I am hopeful that this reply to you will not
require any action that may reflect upon your excellent
credit status.

The oversale at Hartford was indeed unplanned, and I wish
to assure you that Allegheny does not purposely oversell
any flight. As evidenced by our paying $660.00 for the
two Air Taxi Aircraft, our concern was to provide the air
service to your destination promptly even though the value
of all of the tickets for the passengers who were on the
Air Taxi Aircraft was only $228.75. As you may note, it
was indeed not only an expensive alternative service arrange-
ment but assumed in the recognition that on Labor Day
weekend alternate services were at a minimum.

I have determined that the first Air Taxi (N5844) arrived
at the Page Airways gate (here at National Airport) at 7:45
p.m. Your Air Taxi (N6996L), after the short delay to
service a switch, arrived at the Page Airways gate at 8:05
p.m.—or one hour and fifty-one minutes after flight 816.
It is also my understanding that the Passenger Service

158

Representative who served you at Hartford called you at

a later time at your home to again apologize for the serv-
ice failure to you and to your wife.

I have enclosed my Customer Relations check for $10.00
in reimbursement of the dinner you obviously missed due
to your delay of almost two hours.

Hopefully, previous experiences with our airline have estab-
lished that this was an exception to our usual efforts.

Certainly, your continued patronage is desired.

Sincerely,
R.S. Ames
Director—Customer Relations
RSA:kg
Enclosure

bec: EAL— I suggest a wait of 10 days and then a friend-
ly reminder “collection” note in the tone of
“we have received a copy of Allegheny’s reply
and knowing your check is enroute to us
wished to add our apology for the incident
experienced.”

Thank you.
bec: R.W. Bussen.

159

[Letter from Allegheny]
March 18, 1970

Mr. J. Henry Korson

Professor of Sociology

The Commonwealth of Massachusetts
University of Massachusetts

Amherst, Mass. 01002

Dear Mr. Korson:

This will acknowledge receipt of your letter of January 2.
May I extend my sincere apology for the inconvenience in-
curred and fer this unintentional delayed reply.

I can certainly understand your displeasure with us over this
matter and I agree that the oversale of this flight or any
other flight is not the kind of service our valued customers
deserve. Please be assured that each and every oversale is
investigated with corrective action instituted in an effort to
prevent recurrence,

I have thoroughly reviewed the reports submitted on this
matter by our managers at both Hartford and Providence.
The flight was actually oversold by six passengers. At the
last minute before departure, it was discovered that there
was still one empty seat and the first oversold passenger
was immediately boarded. After the flight departed, our
Passenger Service Representative discovered that a Marine
had failed to board the flight after checking-in for personal
reasons not known to us.

All oversold passengers were boarded on Flight 966 to Bal-
timore, and a limousine was provided to National Airport in
Washington. Since it did not arrive within the two hour
time limit as requir2d by Civil Aeronautics Board regulations
regarding oversales; denied boarding compensation was paid
to each oversold passenger involved.

160

Oversales are few when compared to the number of depar-
tures even though any of the thirty-eight major airlines and
more than 5,000 travel agencies (world-wide) can sell space
on Allegheny. However, through human or computer error
if we are not properly advised, our total number of commit-
ments do occasionally exceed our total number of seats
available.

According to our records your son’s tickets and those of a
Mr. LaBella were confirmed and issued by Eastern Airlines
at Charlotte, North Carolina. There were several other pas
sengers who also held confirmed tickets for this flight for
which we show no records.

While you are correct that Allegheny does provide the major-
ity of the flights serving Hartford, may I emphasize that AF
legheny is not the only carrier permitted by the Federal Avia
tion Administration and the Civil Aeronautics Board to oper-
ate this route.

Again, my sincere apology for the inconvenience incurred

by your son. I sincerely hope that your travels with us since
this time have been in evidence of our desire to properly
serve you.

Sincerely,
RSA: rce ALLEGHENY AIRLINES
ce Civil Aeronautics Board -S. Ames, Director
~Your file no. 70-158. Customer Relations
Thank you.

Senator Edward Kennedy
Senator Edward Brooke
Mr. Ralph Nader
Congressman Sylvio Conte
bec: L.T. Ferguson/J. Jenkins
E.I, Colodny P.D. Brennan

161

[Letter to Allegheny]

45 Westbrook Street
Hartford, Conn. 06106
March 1, 1970

Allegheny Airlines

Washington National Airport

Washington, D.C,

Dear Sirs,

I am writing with reference to an unfortunate experience
that I had while attempting connections via Allegheny Air-
lines from Bradley International and Washington National
on February 22nd. Having made reservations on flight 816
I had arranged connections from Washington to Charlottes-
ville, Virginia in accordance with the expected time of ar-
rival of flight 816,

As a result of what had appeared to be a situation of
just too many reserved tickets being sold for the flight,
there were at least ten other individuals along with myself
that were not allowed to make flight 816.

I am not in a habit of writing notes of complaint, but
I was surprised to have this happen to me while attempt-
ing connections with Allegheny. I do an extensive amount
of traveling by air and I must say on any of my previous
flights with your airline have been most enjoyable. It was
just that as a result of the difficulty that I experienced I
missed an important meeting and incurred additional expense
in having to extend my trip several days to accomplish my
duties,

Sincerely,

/s/ Demetrios Tsacoyeanes
Demetrios Tsacoyeanes

162

{Letter from Allegheny |}
TSACOYEANES Closed 30-250

- - - for bringing to our attention the experiences encoun-

tered on your recent trip between Hartford and Washington,
D.C,

May I extend my sincere apology for the inconvenience in-
curred as a result of this oversale. I have reviewed our
records regarding this matter and have determined that your
reservations were cancelled as a result of late check-in at the
ticket-lift position. Therefore, I am unable to forward any
denied boarding compensation.

I hope your future travels will again include Allegheny and
satisfaction with our services will warrant your continued
patronage.

Sincerely,

/s/ R.D. Meade
R.D. Meade, Supervisor

Customer Relations
3/23/70

163

[Letter to Allegheny]
Miss Rhoda Goldberg Mr. Richard Ames
620 2ist St. N.W. Director of Customer Relations
Rm 504 Allegheny Airlines, Inc.
Washington, D.C. 20006 Nationa! Airport
Washington, D.C. 20001

Dear Mr. Ames:

On Sunday Feb. 22, I arrived at Bradley Field (Hartford,
Conn.) at approximately 4:45 P.M. to catch Allegheny Flight
No. 816 leaving at 4:59 P.M. & arriving at 6 P.M. at National
Airport. I had purchased a round trip ticket at the Amer?
can Security Building at 21st & Pennsylvania Ave. N.W. on
Thurs. Feb. 19 — I had gone out of my way to do this just
so that I would encounter no difficulties in the course of
my travels . . . little did I know what was in store for me!
Upon arriving at the gate, a Mr. Rickey nonchalantly told
me he was sorry, but the flight was full, and since ! had not
been within the gate of the departing flight ten minutes prior
to take off (which I was!) he could not accommodate me at
all!! This information was not printed on the ticket in any
place whatsoever — I had specifically read it to see if there
were any directions I would have to follow since I already
held my ticket. .. It is only printed on the first page of
your schedule . . . No one had ever pointed this out to me,
and I had never at any time been made aware of this provi-
sion!! The next flight was 8:09 so I had to spend three
hours in the “‘pleasant’’ atmosphere of Bradley Field . . . it
was not a direct flight so it took two hours instead of one
... and I had to suffer the uncomfortable feeling I get from
not one, but two take offs and landings . . . . my luggage
was on the first flight, which did not add to a pleasant
mental state . .. and someone was awaiting me at National
who nearly panicked since I could not reach him... .

164

Mr. Ames, is this anyway, to run an airline??... I
would appreciate being reimbursed for my time and ag-
gravation, merely caused because your airline overbooked
a flight which I felt had assured me of passage... . I
do a great deal of travelling on Allegheny . . . . so before
I delve into the legal aspect of such a situation, I would
appreciate your reimbursing me for this flight.

Sincerely,

/s/ Rhoda Goldberg

[Letter from Allegheny]
GOLDBERG, RHODA Closed

- - - for writing and for your patience with us.

Enclosed is my customer relations check for $25 equal to
the denied boarding compensation payment.

I hope all other travels with us have been as desired and
without a similar inconvenience. We do indeed desire your
continued patronage.

Sincerely,

R.S. Ames, Director

Customer Relations
3/31/70

BCC: E.I. Colodny/P.D. Brennan — We had 107 for 100
passenger flight. We cancelled on 10 T/L to correct our
error, Per passenger, she arrived prior to 10 T/L.

165

[Letter from Allegheny]
May 1, 1970

Dr. Paul Weiner

Associate Professor of Economics
The University of Connecticut
Storrs, Connecticut 06268

Dear Dr. Weiner:

Thank you for providing me with a copy of your April
24 letter to the Federal Aviation Administration. Although
you will undoubtedly receive a response from that office,
I appreciate the opportunity to respond — especially in
view of the unfortunate circumstance which prompted you
to write,

First of all — I deeply regret the fact that you were de-
nied a seat on one of our March 19 flights to Washington.
At this writing I am not familiar with the circumstances
of that flight. In today’s computerized environment, this
should not have happened and we are probably more in-
terested in the cause than even you are,

Next, I am privileged to respond briefly to the ques-
tions posed in your letter:

(1) Northeast, American, Eastern, TWA and Alleg-
heny Airlines are all certificated to provide non-
stop service in the Hartford-Washington market.
For reasons with which I am not familiar, only
Eastern and Allegheny provide nonstop service;
the bulk of which is provided by Allegheny.

(2) Competition invariably breeds efficiency, although
it doesn’t always improve costs. More impor-
tantly perhaps — particularly in a service com-

(3)

(4)

166

pany such as ours — competition tends to im-
prove personnel performance. Your observa-
tion suggests that you might have had an un-
satisfactory experience on Allegheny on another
occasion,

I am not certain that I understand your third
question. Airline accounting procedures require
conformance in all cases to the Civil Aeronau-
tics Board System of Accounts, Internally, for
tax purposes or other reasons, the ultimate re-
port may vary from the procedure. Deprecia-
tion is, of course, a major cost factor, and does
vary from one airline to another. For the most

part, the schedules used reflect a corporate judg-

ment as to the useful life of the equipment.
Generally speaking, jet aircraft are depreciated
over a 12-15 year span to a residual value of
15 per cent; propeller aircraft are usually 10
years or less, also to a 15 per cent residual.

I am not clear as to your last question. Spe-
cifically, I do not understand how high man-
agerial expenses could mask low earnings; I
would think the reverse would be true. I sug-
gest that an airline’s Breakeven Load Factor
(the percentage of seat occupancy required to
break even) would be a better criterion. In
other words, a higher-than-average breakeven
requirement might indicate the tendency you
appear to be seeking. In this connection, re-

167

I trust the foregoing will answer, in part, your ques-
tions. Again, | am most sorry that your experience (per-
haps your first) with Allegheny was an unpleasant one. I
trust your next flight with Allegheny will demonstrate
that your experience was, in fact, unusual.

Sincerely,

L. O. Barnes
LOB:jih
cc: Mr. John Dregge, Director
Office of Community & Congressional Relations
Civil Aeronautics Board

Mr. John Shaffer, Administrator
Federal Aviation Administration

bee: Mr. E.I. Colodny
Mr. L.T. Ferguson/Mr. R.S. Ames

[Letter from Allegheny]
January 11, 1971

Dr. Paul Weiner |
Associate Professor of Economics

Department of Economics
The University of Connecticut
Storrs, Connecticut 06268

Dear Dr. Weiner:

Thank you for your letter of December 30 concerning the
Denied Boarding Compensation paid you on March 19 at the
time of the oversale incident.

I believe the newspaper article enclosed with your letter
has a misleading headline which may cause some misunder-
standing. In the article itself, however, it does state, ““Fed-

gard Allegheny, Continental, Northwest and Na-
tional who are at or slightly below a 40 per-
cent requirement; the industry average is cur-
rently around 45 per cent, I believe.

168

eral regulations state that any passenger bumped despite
holding ‘confirmed reserve space’ is entitled to a refund plus
an equal penalty payment...” In your instance you were
rebooked on an Eastern flight to Baltimore plus a taxi to
Washington payment for which was via your original ticket
for the Allegheny flight. As you noted, the Denied Boarding
Compensation amount of $30 was also paid to you which
amount equalled the one way fare between Hartford and
Washington at that time. Had you decided to not make the
trip to Washington at all, then you would have been entitled
to a full refund on your ticket plus the Denied Boarding
Compensation.

We at Allegheny find oversales to be most distressing
for us as we know them to be for our passengers. In this
connection in August of 1970, Allegheny introduced a com-
puterized name and flight reservation system and this has
reduced the number of oversale incidents considerably.
Enclosed is a copy of our “Air Commuter” magazine de-
scribing this system starting on page 8.

Please be assured of our continuing efforts to offer the
best service possible to our passengers.

Sincerely,

L. O. Barnes
Encl.

bec: Mr. L.T. Ferguson/Mr. R.S. Ames

169

DEFENDANT’S EXHIBIT A b -3alO)

DON W. CROCKETT
ATTORNEY AT LAW
Suite 880
1700 Pennsylvania Avenue, N. W.
Washington, D. C. 20006
June 19, 1972

Mr. Edwin I. Colodny
Executive Vice President
Allegheny Airlines
Washington National Airport
Washington, D.C. 20001

Dear Mr. Colodny:

Enclosed herewith for your information is a copy of a complaint
resulting from the dishonoring of a reservation for Mr. Nader by your
company on April 28, 1972. The complaint fully sets forth the facts
surrounding the incident. We intend to file this complaint on Friday,
June 23, 1972.

We are also returning herewith your company's draft dated April 28,
1972 in the amount of $32.41 which we reject as a wholly inadequate
offer of settlement.

Recent CAB statistics reveal that the airline industry is apparently
unwilling to take the steps necessary to eliminate the oversales of their
flights, a problem which has plagued consumers for many years and
which remains a matter of serious public concern.

If you are interested in discussing the settlement of this matter
before the complaint is filed, please let me know before June 23, 1972.
We anticipate that any such settlement would include an assurance on
Allegheny's part that it would take immediate steps to eliminate
overbooking and oversales.

I have been delayed in moving to the above address and can be
reached at 1001 Connecticut Ave., Suite 800, Telephone: 628 7234.
———————
Sincerely,

Deu ld, Casbah

Don W. Crockett

cc Ralph Nader ae ae .
C.C.A.G. Gs

EyALt A

170

DEFENDANT’S EXHIBIT D — CAB NOTICE EDR-109
@ PTA Retro!

EDR-19

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
CIVIL AERONAUTICS BOARD
WASHINGTON, D. C.
Economic Regulations
Docket 1656;
Dated: Jarmary 10, 1967
PART 221 - CONSTRUCTION, PUBLICATION, FILING AND POSTING OF
TARIFFS OF AIR CARRIERS AND FOREIGN AIR CARRIERS

PART 250 - PRIORITY RULES, DENIED BOARDING COMPENSATION TARIFFS
AND REPORTS OF UNACCOMMODATED PASSENGERS

NOTICE OF PROPOSED RULE MAKING

Notice is hereby given that the Civil Aeronautics Board has under
consideration an amendment to Part 221 and a proposed new Part 250 of
the Economic Regulations. The new Part would require carriers to establish
and fiie with the Board priority rules for determining which passengers
holding confirmed reserved space shall be denied boarding on an oversold
flight. In addition, the amendment to Part 22] and the new Part 250 would
require carriers to file tariffs providing specified denied boarding compenss-
tion to such passengers. Finally, the new part would require carriers to [file
reports of unaccommodated passengers.

The principal features of the proposed amendment to Part 221 and
the new Part 250 are set forth in the Explanatory Statement, and the
proposed amendment and new part are set forth in the Proposed Rules. These
regulatious are proposed under the authority of sections 204(a), 403, 404,
and 411 of the Federal Aviation Act of 1958, as amended (72 Stat. 743,

758, 760, and 769; 49 U.S.C. 1324, 1373, 1374, and 1381), and section 3

Eyhtt D

..%... ¢

of the Administrative Procedure Act (80 Stat. 383; 5 U.S.C. 552).

Interested persons may participate in the proposed rule making
through submission of ten (10) copies of written data, views or
arguments pertaining thereto, addressed to the Docket Section, Civil
Aeronautics Board, Washington, D. C. 20428. All relevant matter in
communioations received on or before February 16, 1967, will be
considered by the Board before taking final action on the Proposed
Rules. Copies of such communications will be available for examination
by interested persons in the Docket Section of the Board, Room 710
Universal Building, 1825 Connecticut Avenue, N. W., Washington, D. C.,
upon receipt thereof.

By the Civil Aeronautics Board:

HAROLD R. SANDERSON
Secretary

(SEAL)

172

e EXPLANATORY —_

On October 12, 1965, the Board issued a notice of proposed whe
making, macs. ts consider a proposed new Part 250 providing for
notice and other requirements with respect to overbooked flights.

In addition, the notice advised that the Board has under consideration
certain amendments to Part 221, which would require carriers subject to
Part 250 to include ‘n their tariffs their criteria, practices and rules
for determining passerger priorities applicable to instances where
confirmed reservations exceed the capacity of the aircraft on a scheduled
flight. The notice afforded an opportunity to interested parties to
participate in the proposed rule making through submission of their views
or arguments.

The Air Transport Association of America (ATA) has consolidated and
submitted comments of 31 air carriers. In addition, supplemental comments
have been submitted by a number of carriers. The carriers unanimously
oppose the rule proposed in EDR-95, particularly the provisions of the new
Part 250 requiring notice to passengers of an overbooked condition. Upon
consideration of these objections, and of other factors hereinafter set
forth, the Board is hereby propesing alternative regulations to deal with

the pr oblem.

i/ Locket 10553; Part 221 - Construction, Publication, Filing and Posting
of Tariffs of Air Carriers and Foreign Air Carriers; Part 250 - Notice and Other
Requirements of Overdocked Flizhts.

2/ Alaska Ccastal-cllis Airlines, Northern Consolidated Airlines,
and Wien Alaska Airlines, jcintly; Czark Air Lines; Pan American World
Airways (supported by Yan American-Grace Airways); Trans Caribbean Airways;
Trans-Texas Airways; Trans World Airlines; and United Air Lines.

The Boerd has for some years been concerned with the problem of
oversales - the failure of air carriers to accommodate at flight departure
time passengers holding confirmed reserved tickets on the flight on the
ground that spece is not available. While the rumber of passengers
holding confirmed reserved space who are denied boarding is not large

relative to total enplanements, in absolute terms the number is substantial.

Thus, evidence submitted by the carriers in the Overbooking Practices of
Teupkline Carriers' Investigation, Docket 11683, and information received
thereafter, indicate that in each of the years 1963 and 1964 approximately
50,000 passengers with tickets for ccnfirmed reserved space vere denied
boarding on flights in domestic trunk «nd local service.

The oversales problem, therefore, is a severe one. It causes
distress, inconvenience and damage to passengers. It impairs the public

image of air carriers, casting doubt on the integrity of their reservations

practices. Clearly, it is incumbent on the Board and the carriers to do all

within their powers to eliminate oversalea_to the extent feasible.
The crux of the carriers' comments, as submitted by ATA, is that the
proposed notification rule (1) would be largely unworkable; (2) would

create anxiety and confusion on the part of the traveling public, severely

weakening public confidence in air carrier reservations Systems;

Y/ Birictiy speaking an oversale alsc occurs vhen a passenger is not

accommodated in the class of service for which he holds confirmed reserved
space, but is seated in a lower class of service ("downgraded") or a higher

class ("upgraded"). However, this type of oversale presents a far less
severe probdlen.

j

‘

/

eo 175 °

-i-

174 ra)

- 3 =
1. As indicated above, the primary thrust of EDR-95 was directed

toward the practice of carriers of deliberate or controlled overbooking.
This practice stems from the fact thet there is substantial reservations
turnover before flight departure time occasioned by changes in passengers’
plans and cancellation of their reservations. In addition, the practice is
=_——_— —_— = *

(3) would increace unnecessarily, and at an undue cost to the industry,
the already-heavy vorkload which must be handled within extremely narrow
tolerances: by airline reservations systems; (4) would cause the public to
make a great number of duplicative and protective reservations;

(5) would increase the already rapid turnover of reservations vithin
the last 12-24 hours before departure; and (5) would increase the
troublesome *ne-show" and late cancellation problems.

used to allow for multiple reservations made by some passengers and ‘or

"no-shows" - passengers who neglect to cancel reservations they do not intend
~~? }

to use. Reservations turnover can be projected and compensated for by booki

In light of carrier comment and other considerations, the Board in excess of the capacity of the aircraft to a predetermined extent. By
has tentatively determined not to finalise EDR-95. Rather, we propose carefully controlling overbooking in this manner on certain Page, sasetenf
to deal with the oversales problem by other means for the following resscns: can seduse a chance of aircraft departing wih empty seats. At the same ;
(1) the proposed notice requirement of EDR~95 would have necessiteted =, cue the carriers’ acceptance of reservations in excess of :
[nein chances in the reservations practices and systems of carriers, inventory, passengers are able to secure space on flights which can |
and the Board is not prepared to require such changes in a system vhich in fact accommodate them and are also benefited by being offered \
. has, on balance, worked reasonably well in the public interest; (2) various maximum flexibility in securing, cancelling and changing reservations
measures are available to the carriers to reduce the dimensions of the without charge or penalty. However, where carriers overestimate reservations
oversales problem by liuiting or curtailirg certain aspects of their turnover on a particular flight, overbooking can result in oversales and
reservations practices; (3) finally, the Board believes the oversales passengers holding confirmed reserved space are denied boarding. :
problem can be substantially redueed by the proposals herein to require | The carriers, however, contend that overbookings alone do not —
carriers (a) tc make prompt, effective and adequate compensation to . cause oversales nor are they even the chief cause of oversales. In
oversold passengers, (b) to eetablish priority rules for determining | “a support of this position ATA has submitted the results of special
| which passengers holding conflirmed reserved ‘space shall be denied f surveys conducted by four carriers as follows:

j
boarding on oversold flights, end (c) to file reports of unaccommodate f

passengers. Theae matters will next be discussed sestiatip.

@ 176 wo

Boarded # Overbookings OQversales

Carrier "A" (1 day) 45,000 os P
Carrier "B" (2 days) 22,000 323 n
Carrier °C* (5 days) 125 ,000 635 3
Carrier "0° (48 days) | $1,273 70 2

In the casesof Carriers "B" and "D", it is stated.none of the oversales vere
attributable to the overbookings and in the cases of "A" and "C" the overbookings
were only a contributing factor.
There is nothing in the substantial body of deta before the Board
which controverts the carriers' claim that overbooking is not the major
cause of oversales. Among other causes of oversales are reservations
practices such as "free-sale" and “block ticketing". In addition, oversales
are caused by such factors as (1) substitution of lower capacity aircraft because
of maintenance or other operational consideration; (2) errors ccamitted by
personnel of the carrier denying boarding to the passenger, by personnel
of other carriers, and by travel agency personnel; (3) breakdowns or defects
in commrication, computing and other equipment used in processing reservations.
It is also apparent that the notice requirement of EDR-95 would
not only have the effect of controlling the practice of deliberate over-
booking. The effect of the notice would be to seriously curtail the practice.
Thus, carriers would act overtesh if they were required to advise passengers
of their overbooked status twelve hours prior to flight time in view of the

© 17 «6©@

-6-

resultant confusion, alarm, bitterness and cancellation of reservations. In
this connection, it is to be noted that the table set forth above shows
that there vere « total of 1,728 overbookings and only 24 oversales or less
than .0140 percent of overbookings. Had the requirement proposed in EDR-95
been in effect, it is manifest that « very ciseable mmber of persons vould have
been needlessly alarmed by the notification of their overbooked status and that
reservations vould have been canceled on flights which actually could have
accommodate’ these passengers. Further, were the carrier prevented from
everbooking, large mumbers of passengers would be denied reservations on
flights vhich, because of reservations turnover and "no-shows," ous Gyert
with empty senate.

Me Gap them, Cay suubbetto Gpatesd of Go Guastian of omiteiting \
Leeds to the conclusion that, vile it results in oversales, it also
contetinghgg to fleidbiiity ant frostan in covering, changing anf eqpusling
reservations. Thus, any rigid controls over overbooking, as now practiced,
would inevitably lead to restrictions on privileges which contribute greatly

——

to the convenience of air transportation, and have come to be relied
upon by the traveling public. In edition such controls would reduce load
factors, and the additional cost would ultimately have to be borne by the
traveling public.

In light of the above, it can be seen that the present reservations =
systems of the carriers in general benefit the traveling public. The

2

od “= 6

Board is not prepared, therefore, to require changes in these systems
without fully exploring other means by which the oversales problem may
be curbed. Moreover, the reservations practices of the carriers involve
detailed methods of doing business, personnel supervision, use of equip-
went, adaptation to technological change, oe. requiring a high degree
of management flexibility and freedom. Since these matters are within
the special province and competence of carrier management, it is desirable
that the Board attempt to minimize to the extent possible regulation of _
the details of the carriers' reservations systems. But by the same token,
it is incumbent on the carriers themselves to take effective steps to
curb oversales resulting from their reservations practices. Obviously,
if efforts by the carriers in this direction are inadequate, the Board
may be compelled to seguicte eemguastiens teus® tile ant.

2. In connection with the foregoing, there are two reservations
practices of carriers, in additior. to overbooking, which contribute to
oversales. First, are "free-sale” privileges, a reservations procedure
established by agreement whereby the participating carrier can sell
space on another carrier without any prior clearance or check of inventory
up to a specific time before departure. This procedure is particularly
used with respect to participating foreign carriers with offices located
outeide the United States. Second, are “block ticket" arrangements, by which
persons which are given the ticket stock of a carrier can validate tickets
which on their face purpert to confirm reservations when in fact such

reservations were not confirmed by the carrier.

"Free sale" and "block ticketing" no doubt reduce carrier reservations
costs and increase flexibility and facility of securing reservations for the
traveling public. Nevertheless, these practices not only contribute to
oversales but they in fact invite oversales. This is an ares over which
the carriers heve control, and the carriers have, in our judgment, a clear
duty to take steps to drastically reduce the opportunities for oversales
resulting from these practices. A recent resolution of ATC, is « measure
toward this end which could and should be advanced further.

Similar observations can be made concerning the problem of "no-shows,"
which one carrier assigns as "the real problem" with respect to oversales.
There may well be economic pressures on carriers to overbook in order to
compensate for no-shows, as well as for reservations turnover. However,
it is within the means of the carriers to reduce the number of no-shows
through reservation service charges. The Board has expressed its belief
in the desirability of reservation and no-show controls and previous

4/ On April 20-21, 1966, the Air Treffic Conference of America adopted
certain resolutions concerning Standard Interline Passenger Procedures to
be effective June 3, 1966. One of these resolutions provides that carrier _
members shall not enter into free sales agreements on flight segments opera-
ting within the Continental United States, "when the selling offices have
access to that Member's av@iiibility by means of local or toll free telephone
or manually maintained or computer stored availability." In addition the
resolution provides that free sale shall not be granted to travel agents.
(By Order E-24516, December 14, 1966, this resolution, and others designed
to strengthen the carriers' reservations procedures, were approved.) However,
the substantial number of free sale arrangements involving international
flights remains unaffected by the resolution.

3 180 +)

=

experiments with no-show penalty assessments have given graphic evidence
of their salutary effect on the problem. Hovever, no-show assessments
were abandoned by the carriers and have not been in effect since January 31,
1963. Aside from causing serious economic loss to the carriers, the
problem of no-shows results in substantial inconvenience to the travel-
ing public in being cenied reservations through the thoughtless action

' toore Oaecengers who book more space than they intend to use. The
carriers' failure to curb this practice is a matter of concern to the
Board, and they are urged to take corrective steps such as the establish-
ment of an appropriate reservations ou”

3. It is apparent from the foregoing that the present reservations
aystem of the carriers is designed to provide maximum benefits for the
traveling public and to reduce the carriers' reservations costs. However,
these ends are achieved at a price of substantial inconvenience and hard-
ship to those relatively few passengers who are oversold and denied board-
ing although holding confirmed reservations. Our present determination
not to attempt detailed control of reservations practices at this time is
premised upon the carriers’ effecting a substantial improvement in the
treatment of oversold passengers.

In our judgment, the compensation provided in carriers’ tariffs as
liquidated damages for failure to accommodate passengers with confirmed

S/ See Order F-20859.

G/ The imposition of « charge should not, however, result in a higher
fare level.

181

+

cinsid ont Gadd in tinnde” Data furnished by
eleven trunk carriers show that for the twelve months ending August 31,
1965, of the 37,184 passengers denied confirmed space, 22,182 were qualified
for denied boarding compensation, Of this total, 19,772 passengers actually

accepted such compensation and received an average of only $20.00 per
incident. Furthermore, we do not believe that the present denied boarding
tariff is completely equitable, as it is primarily limited to domestic

transportation.. ,

In view of the above, it seems clear that the compensation provided
in the tariff is inadequate to compensate passengers for the inconveniences

7 These amounts are as follows:

Value of first remaining flight
coupon for which space is con-

firmed on departed flight

Amount_of Compensation
Pull value of the first
se

SOk of the value of the first

182

eM ec

arising from oversales. We cannot directly attack such causes of over-

sales as substitution of equipment or errors of personnel of the carriers

or their travel agents. With respect to the reservations practices of the
carriers responsible for oversales, however, we conclude that these practices
must either be regulated by the Board or that the denied boarding passengers

be offered reassumtie compensation. In other words, wes shall permit the above-\

} .
| described reservations practices to continue without regulation on condition |

eee je
that the carriers file tariffs providing prompt, effective and adequate
2/

compensation to denied boarding passengers, as proposed herein.
The proposed rule will require denied boarding tariffs to be filed

by all carriers holding a certificate under section 01(d)(1) and (2)

of the Act authorizing the transportation of persons, except « helicopter
Operator, or a carrier conducting sutee- ies service cmtussveny
The rule will apply to flights or portions of flights originating or
terminating in the United States, its territories or possessions, but excludes
flights originating and terminating within Alaska. The required tariffs
will provide for compensation to eligible passengers at the rate of 200

percent of the value of the first remaining flight coupon with a $50.00

B/ With respect to human error, greater use of computerization offers ;
opportunities for its reduction. The Board is gratified to note the great
strides the industry has made and is making toward computerization of its reserva-
tions systems,

9/ Since comments on the supplementary proposal herein may govern
the disposition of the 12-hour notice requirement proposed in EDR-95,
we shall not withdraw the latter at this time.

The latter are excluded because oversales have not been a

problem with then.

183

-12-

minimum and a $200.00 maximum. The conditions under which passengers

are eligible for compensation are set forth in the rule. The compensation,
if accepted by a passenger, shall constitute liquidated damages for the
carrier's failure to provide him with confirmed reserved space. The
rule will require carriers to tender passengers eligible for denied
boarding compensation, om the date apd place the denied boarding occurs,
a draft for the appropriate amount of compensation with the reverse

aide of the draft containing a waiver from liability. The carrier

shall allow such passengers at least 30 days within which to endorse

and cash the draft.

Carrieng Will .be required to furnish passengers denied boarding
a written statement explaining the terms, conditions and limitations of
the denied boarding compensation.

- \. In addition to providing reasonable compensation to denied boarding
passengers, the prepoced rule will require carriere to cetehlish pricrity
rules for determining which passengers holding confirmed reserved space
hall be denied boarding on an oversold flight.
~ ap-95 required that the priority rules be stated with "particularity
and definiteness." The ATA and individual carrier comments interpret this
language as requiring "inflexible" priority rules. It is pointed out that
the carriers, individually, already have in their company manuals established
guidelines for company personnal responsible for the accommodation of
overbooked passengers. These guidelines, however, permit a degree of

184

flexibility in their application so that when it is necessary to deny
boarding to a passenger, it is possible to consider all passenger service
factors and thus choose the passenger who would be least inconvenienced by
such denial and for whom alternative reservations are available.

In view of these comments, the proposed rule will not require
inflexibility in the carriers’ priority rules. It will require that the

priority rules not result in unjust discrimination or undue or unreasonabl
assegaties or disadvantage to persons. Assuming that the "guidelines"

in company manuals do not have the latter results, it appears that the
carriers have substantially conformed to the requirements of the proposed
rule.

In addition, EDR-95 proposed to amend Part 221 of the Economic
Regulations by requiring carriers subject to Part 250 to file in their
tariffs the criteria, rules and practices for determining which passengers
with tickets for confirmed space on a specific scheduled flight are to be
boarded on aircraft not able to accommodate all passengers with tickets
for confirmed reserved space. The comment specifically addressed to the
amendment of Part 221 is that priority rules reflecting Mexibility are
not proper tariff material. We agree that the Nexibility required in
the priority rules would make them inappropriate as tariff material.

We shall, instead, require the carriers to file copies of their priority

/

rules with the Board. “

-

185 d
= -

5. Finally, the proposed rule will require carriers to file reports
regarding the number of unacconmodated passengers for specified markets,
quarterly, and for their respective systems, monthly. The latter will be
similar to reports submitted by carriers pursuant to Orders E-20659 and
£-21187. Carrier coments submitted by the ATA, as well as individual
carrier comments, have suggested the filing of such reports a: an
alternative to EDR-95. It has been the Board's experience in the
administration of Part 234 of the Economic Regulations concerning realistic
scheduling, that the reports required and the attendant publicity have
created powerful incentives to improved performance in hemes area. We
expect similar results through the reporting of unaccommodated passengers.

186
PROPOSED RULES
The Civil Aeronautics Board proposes to issue a new Part 250 (14 CFR 250)

follows:

PART 250 - PRIORITY RULES, DENIED BOARDING COMPENSATION TARIFFS
AND REPORTS OF UNACCOMMODATED PASSBIGERS

Sec,

250.1 Definitions.

250.2 Applicability.

250.3 Priority rules.

250.4 Filing of denied boarding compensation tariffs.

250.5 Amount of denied boarding compensation and exceptions.
250.6 Denied boarding compensation as liquidated damages.
250.7 Denied boarding compensation drafts.

250.8 Written explanation of denied boarding compensation,
250.9

Reports of unaccommodated passengers.
$250.1 Definitions.

For the purposes of this Pert?

"Carr‘er" means an air carrier, except a helicopter operator or an
air carrier conducting intra-Alaska service exclusively, holding a certificate
issued by the Board pursuant to section 401(d)(1) and (2) of the Act, author-
ising the transportation of persons.

"Confirmed reserved space" means space on a specific date and on a
specific flight and class of service of a carrier which has been requested
by @ passenger and which the carrier or its agent has verified, by appropriate

notation on the ticket, as being reserved for the accommodation of the passenger.

"Stopover" means a deliberate interruption of a journey by the passenger,
agreed to in advance by the carrier, at a point between the place of departure
and the place of destination,

"Value of the first remaining flight coupon" means the applicable one-way
fare, including any surcharge, less any applicable discount.

187

$250.2 Applicability.
This part applies to all carriers as defined in $250.1 and applies to

flights or portions of flights originating or terminating in the United States,
ite territories or possessions, but excludes flights originating and terminating
within the State of Alaska.

$250.3 Erhority miles |
Every carrier shell establish priority rules and criteria for determining

which passengers holding confirmed reserved space shall be Gentes boarding on an
oversold flight. Every carrier shall file with the Board two copies of such
rules and criteria, {neluding that portion of ite company manual instructing
employees on the order of boarding priorities in case of an oversold flight.
Such rules and criteria shall not make, give or cause any undue or unreasonable
preference or advantage to any particular person or subject any particular
person to any unjust discrimination or any undue or unreasonable prejudice or

disadvantage in any respect whatsoever.

$250.4 Eiling of denied boarding compensation tariffs.

Every carrier shall file tariffs providing compensation to a passenger
holding confirmed reserved space who presents himself for carriage at the
appropriate time and place, having complied fully with the carrier's require-
— as to ticketing, check-in and reconfirmation procedures and being
acceptable for transportation under’ the carrier's tariff, and the flight for-
which the passenger holds confirmed seservet space is unable to accommodate
the passenger and departs without his.

Note: See §221.36(a)(7), the tariff provision for filing denied
boarding compensation tariffs. '

188
-3-
5250.5 Amount of denied boarding compensation and exceptions.

The tariffs required by this part shall provide for compensation to
be paid a passenger holding confirmed reserv

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385003_1086%3A2. Public record. Not legal advice.
