# Amicus Brief — Train v. Colorado Public Interest Research Group, Inc.

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385003_0325%3A09

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Amicus Brief
- **Published:** January 1, 1976
- **Citation:** 426 U.S. 1

## Text

>

MOTION FILED

SEP 24 1375
No. 74-1270

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

October Term, 1975

Russell Train, Administrator of the Environmental

Protection Agency, et. al., Petitioners

Colorado Public Interest Research Group, Inc.,

et. al., Respondents

ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES COURT

OF APPEALS FOR THE TENTH CIRCUIT

BRIEF AMICUS CURIAE OF PROFESSOR MICHAEL S. BARAM ,
DR. ERIC PETRASKE, AND THE BOSTON UNIVERSITY

ENVIRONMENTAL LAW SOCIETY.

No. 74-1270

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

October Term, 1975

Russell Train, Administrator of the Environ-

mental Protection Agency, et. al., Petitioners

vs.

Colorado Public Interest Research Group, Inc.,

et. al., Respondents

ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES

COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE TENTH CIRCUIT

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE BRIEF AMICUS CURILAE

No. 74-1270

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

October Term, 1975

Russell Train, Administrator of the Environmental
Protection Agency, et. al., Petitioners

Vv.

Colorado Public Interest Research Group, Inc.,

et. al., Respondents

ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES COURT

OF APPEALS FOR THE TENTH CIRCUIT

BRIEF AMICUS CURILAE OF PROFESSOR MICHAEL S. BAR/M,
DR. ERIC PETRASKE, AND THE BOSTON UNIVERSITY

ENVIRONMENTAL LAW SOCIETY

INDEX

Interest of the Amicus
Summary of Argument ..... +. +6 «© «© «© « «

Argument:

I. AUTHORITY TO SET STANDARDS FOR THE CON-
CENTRATION OF RADLOACTLVE MATERIALS IN
THE GENERAL ENVIRONMENT WAS TRANS FERRED
FROM THE AEC TO THE EPA IN 1970, AND
THIS TRANSFER PROVIDES EPA WLTH THE
AUTHORITY TO DETERMINE EFFLUENT DIS-
CHARGE LIMITATLONS FOR THE SOURCES OF
RADLOACTLVE MATERLALS LN THE GENERAL
ENVIRONMENT, WHICH SOURCES INCLUDE NRC
LICENSEES .. »= cee eee eveeec ce ce

IL. EPA AUTHORITY TO DETERMINE EFFLUENT
DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS FOR THE SOURCES
OF RADLOACTIVE MATERIALS IN THE
GENERAL ENVIRONMENT, INCLUDING NRC
LICENSEES, IS CONSISTENT WITH THE
FEDERAL WATER POLLUTLON CONTROL ACT
AMENDMENTS OF 1972, AND WITH THE
FEDERAL PREEMPTLON OF STATE REGULA-
TION OF RADIOACTIVE EFFLUENT DISCHARGES
FROM NUCLEAR POWER FACILITIES . .. . . 18

GEpOnemeem «ec co tee ees eee eb 6 6 eC

CITATIONS

Cases:
Northern States Power Co. v. Minnesota, 447 F. 2d

1143, affirmed, 405 U.S. 1035 6,24

Statutes, executive orders, and regulations:
Atomic Energy Act ot 1954, 68 Stat. 919 et. seq.
as amended, 42 U.S.C. 2011 et. seq.
42 U.S.C. 2021 (b) 23
Clean Air Act Amendment of 1970, 84 Stat. 1676,
42 U.S.C. 1857
42 U.S.C. 1857 c-5 23
42 U.S.C. 1857 c-5 (a)(2)(E) 1970 16
Energy Reorganization Act of 1974, Pub. L. 93-436
88 Stat. 1233-1254 9
Federal Water Pollution Control Act, 62 Stat.
1155, as amended by the Federal Water
Pollution Control Act Amendment of 1972,
86 Stat. 816, et. seq., 33 U.S.C. (Supp. III)
1251 et. seq.:
Sec. 101(a)(1), 1251(a) (1) 19

Sec. 101(a)(2), 1251(a) (2) 19

Sec.

Sec.

Sec.

Sec.

Sec.

Sec.

Sec.

Sec.

Sec.

Sec.

Sec.

Sec.

49 U.S.C.

Reorganization Plan No.

$OL, 1311

19

3O1l(b) (1) (ec), 1311(b) (1) (ce) 1972 16

303, 1313

304 (b) (1) (B), 1314(b) (1) (B)
304 (b) (2) (B) , 1314(b) (2) (B)
306(a)(1), 1316(a) (1)

306(b), 1316(b)

307, 1317
4O1, 1341
402, 1342

404, 1344

502(6), 1362(6)

1431

3 of 170, 84 Stat,

2086 35. seq., 5 U.S.C. App., pp. 609

et. seq.

19

20,23
20,23
18,20,23

7,18,20,21

21

23

20

17

7,18,21

17

5,6,10

Sec. 2(b), 84 Stat. 2088, 5. U.S.C,

App., P-

610

ij

Code of Federal Regulations:
Title 10.

Sec. 50. 34a(a) 27

Congressional Material:

119 Cong. Rec. H-11749 - H-11750 (daily ed.,

December 19, 1973 12

|

Miscellaneous:

36 Fed. Reg. 11113 13
40 Fed. Reg. 19439 13,24
40 Fed. Reg. 23420 13,24

INTEREST OF THE AMICUS

This brict amicus is presented on behall of
Michael S. Baram, Eric W. Petraske, and the
Environmental Law Society of Boston University
School of Law, who have substantial personal in-
terests in environmental health and the protec-

tion of the environment.

Michael S. Baram, attorney for the Environmen-
tal Law Society, is an Associate Professor at
the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. He
is Vice Chairman of the American Bar Assoc ia-
tion's Committee on Environmental Law (General
Practice Section), Chairman of the American Bar
Association's Committee on Technology Assess-
ment, member of two committees of the National
Academy of Sciences (including the Committee on
Biological Effects of Loni.ing Radiation), and
special advisor to a Committee of the National
Academy of Engineering. He is a Lecturer in Law

at Boston University School of Law, and counsel

2.

to the law tirm of Bracken and Selig.

The Environmental Law Society of Boston Univer-
sity School of Law is an organization of stu-
dents with expertise in environment -

al regulation and energy programs. Dr. Eric
Petraske, a member, holds a doctorate in nuclear
physics, has held post-doctoral and faculty
appointments in this field, and is now a third-
year law student at Boston University School of
Law. He has worked closely with Professor Baram

on various studies relating to nuclear power.

Messrs. Baram and Petraske have conducted sub-
stantial research on standard-setting and other
aspects of regulating ionizing radiation from
nuclear power sources. They have developed ex-
pertise on the several regulatory approaches em-
ployed to control ionizing radiation; on the
authority of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission

(NRC), the Environmental Protection Agency (SPA),

ates Sh a *

3.

and the States; and on the analytical methods
employed by these authorities for standard-

setting and other decision-making.

This expert knowledge has enabled them and the
Boston University Environmental Law Society to
become aware of serious deficiencies in the dis-
cussion of this case as it has progressed
through the lower courts. Therefore, this

brief has a single purpose: to focus on these
specific defects and to bring necessary analy-
sis to the attention of the Court. The results
of this analysis support the Respondent's posi-

tion in this case.

At stake in this case are: (1) important public
interests in environmental health and the qua-
lity of ecosystems, for present and future gen-
erations; (2) the allocation of regulatory
authority suitable to the nature of the radia-

tion control problem and in harmony with the

4.

legislative framework provided by Congress; and
(3) development of appropriate government regu-

lations for the optimal use of nuclear power.

SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT

Petitioners argue that the combination of legis-
lative history and existing regulation of radio-
active effluent discharges from nuclear power
plants is sufficient to sustain the present re-
gulatory practices of the Nuclear Regulatory
Commission (NRC) and the Environmental Protec-
tion Agency (EPA). Present regulatory prac-
tices have in essence created an exception to
the Federal Water Pollution Control Act (FWPCA)
for the regulation of radioactive effluent dis-
charges trom nuclear power plants. Under the
exception, NRC determines Limitations on such
discharges and incorporates such Limitations in

the conditions it imposes on its licensees.

5.

Petitioners’ argument fails to address (a) the
scope of current EPA regulatory authority and
its implications for NRC regulation of licensee
discharges; and (b) the relationship between
standards or limitations for radioactive mate-
rials in the general environment as promulgated
by EPA, and discharge Limitations imposed on

nuclear power plant licensees by the NRC.

The central argument of this brief amicus

curiae is: (1) that Reorganization Plan No. 3
of 1970, (5 U.S.C. App., p. 609 et seq.),
transterred to EPA the authority to set stan-
dards for the protection of the general environ-
ment and the individuals therein from tonizing
radiation; (2) that this EPA authority neces-
sarily requires EPA to determine the Limitations
to be imposed on the sources of radioactive
effluent discharge inte the general environment;
(3) that EPA determination of discharge lLimita-

tions to be imposed on the sources of radio-

active ettluent discharges is consistent with
and supported by the provisions of the Federal
Water Pollution Control Act Amendments of 1972,
(33 U.S.C. (Supp. LIL) 1251 et seq.),for the case
of nuclear facilities licensed by the NRC; and
finally, (4) that this shift of regulatory
authority is consistent with the doctrine of
federal preemption as it has been enunciated
for the regulation of radioactive effluent dis-

charges from nuclear power facilities in

Northern States Power Co. v. Minnesota, 447

F. 2d 1143, (C.A. 8), aff'd, 405 U.S. 1035.

Reorganization Plan No. 3 of 1970 (84 Stat.
2086 et seq., 5 U.S.C. App., pp. 609 et seq.)
provides EPA with the sole authority to set
general environmental standards and thereby the
authority to determine discharge levels for the
radioactive effluent from nuclear power plants;

and the Federal Water Pollution Control Act

Amendments of 1972 (FWPCA) provide EPA with dis-
charge limitation, permit and enforcement
authority over point sources of pollutants. The
FWPCA defines "pollutant" to include "... radio-
active materials ... discharged into water"
(Sec. 502 (6) 33 U.S.C. (Supp. LIL) 1362), with-
out qualification. The FWPCA further prescribes
that national "standards of performance", de-

fined as standards "... for the control of the

" shall be esta-

discharge of pollutants ...
blished by EPA for various point sources, and
includes "steam electric power plants" (33
U.S.C. (Supp. IIL) 1316 (b)) in its list of
point sources. The FWPCA is therefore consis-
tent with the Reorganization Plan; and provides
EPA with explicit procedures for setting dis-
charge levels for radioactive effluents, for

applying the discharge Limitations to specific

nuclear facilities through a permit program,

8.

and for enforcing the permit conditions in
keeping with a specific timetable for implemen-

ting discharge control technologies.

Since the FWPCA does not explicitly amend the
Atomic Energy Act of 1954 and subsequent amend-
ments, and since EPA must produce a federal re-
gulatory program for the control of radioactive
effluent discharges which reconciles the two
acts, federal preemption is not an issue at

this time. EPA's subsequent development of

such regulatory program may or may not raise the
federal preemption issue, as the FWPCA affords
EPA several options for implementing a discharge
control program applicable to radioactive mate-
rials, some of which options would not necces-
sarily raise a federal preemption issue nor ob-
struct the further development of nuclear power.
Accordingly, we urge the Court to defer further

consideration of federal preemption until an

appropriate case is presented, subsequent to
the promulgation of such EPA regulatory pro-

gram.

Finally, we argue that Respondents’ position

is consistent with the several environmental
statutes that concentrate regulatory authority
over both general environmental levels of
pollutants and related discharge levels from
sources of the pollutants in EPA; and that such
concentration of authority in EPA is consistent
with efficient administration, and with the
continued development of nuclear power sources
under the authority of the Atomic Energy Act of

1954 and the Energy Reorganization Act of 1974,

88 Stat. 1233-1254.

10.

ARGUMENT

I. AUTHORITY TO SET STANDARDS FOR THE CONCEN-
TRATION OF RADLOACTIVE MATERIALS IN THE
GENERAL ENVIRONMENT WAS TRANSFERRED FROM
THE AEC TO THE EPA IN 1970, AND THIS TRANS-
FER PROVIDES EPA WITH THE AUTHORITY TO
DETERMINE EFFLUENT DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS
FOR THE SOURCES OF RADIOACTIVE MATERIALS IN
THE GENERAL ENVIRONMENT, WHICH SOURCES

INCLUDE NRC LICENSEES.

Reorganization Plan No. 3 of 1970, (5 U.S.C.
App., p. 609 et seq.), was promulgated to esta-
blish the Environmental Protection Agency, and
to concentrate in this new agency various func-
tions for protecting the environment which had
been fragmented among other federal agencies.

The Reorganization Plan provides, in part:

ll.

"Sec. 2 (a) There are hereby
transferred to the Administrator:

(6) The functions of the AEC under
the AEC Act of 1954, as amended, ad-
ministered through its Division of
Radiation Protection Standards, to
the extent that such functions of the
Commission consist of establishing
generally applicable environmental
standards for the protection of the
general environment from radioactive
material. As used herein, standards
mean limits on radiation exposures or
levels, or concentrations or quanti-
ties of radioactive material, in the
general environment outside the
boundaries of locations under the
control of persons possessing or
using radioactive material."

(5 U.S.C. App., p. 610)

EPA has done little with this authority since
1970, and in 1973, it was advised by the Direc-
tor of the Office of Management and Budget to
confine its radiation regulation to the general
environment. In a memorandum from the Director
of the Office of Management and Budget, Roy L.
Ash, to the EPA Administrator, Russell Train,
dated December 7, 1973, the following directive

was contained and accepted by EPA:

12.

"...this memorandum is to advise you
that the decision is that the AEC
should proceed with its plans for
issuing uranium fuel cycle standards,
taking into account the comments re-
ceived from all sources, including
EPA: that EPA should discontinue its
preparations for issuing, now or in
the future, any standards for types
of facilities; and that EPA should
continue, under its current authority,
to have responsibility for setting
standards for the total amount of
radiation in the general environment
from all facilities combined in the
uranium fuel cycle, i.e. an ambient
standard which would have to reflect
AEC's findings as to the practica-
bility of emission controls..."
(attached to court of appeals brief
of Arkansas et. al., pp. 35-36.
Accord, 119 Cong. Rec. H11749-H11750)
(daily ed. December 19, 1973)

EPA has followed this interpretation of its
functions, and in 1975, proposed regulations for
limiting the levels of radioactivity in the
general environment, and for limiting human,
non-occupational exposures. Environmental

Protection Agency, "Proposed Standards: Radia-

tion Protection for Nuclear Power Operations,"

i3.

40 Fed. Reg. 23420 (May 29, 1975)

The NRC has, since 1970, continued to indepen-
dently promulgate "guidances" for limiting such
radioactive effluents from nuclear power facili-
ties. Such discharge limitations were in "in-
terim" form for four and one-half years, as AEC
"Proposed" Appendix I. 36 Fed. Reg. 11113
(June 9, 1971). Final Appendix I has been pro-
posed on May 5, 1975by NRC. (40 Fed. Reg. 19439).
Such guidances have essentially served as dis-
charge control regulations on NRC licensees, and
have been used to restrict radioactive dis-
charges since 1970. The NRC has employed cost-
benefit analysis and the "As Low As Is Readily
Achievable" principle (previously, "As Low As
Practicable") in determining the numerical dis-
charge limitations contained in the guidances,
but has not employed EPA general environmental

standards as a framework for setting its dis-

14.

charge limitations, since such standards have
not been available, and are only now in pro-
posed form. 40 Fed. Reg. 23420, (May 29,

1975)-

There is a necessary relationship between dis-
charge levels and general environmental levels.
In order to achieve and maintain general en-
vironmental levels, including levels of human,
non-occupational exposure, appropriate dis-
charge levels for each source have to be esta-
blished. Since general environmental features
differ in different regions (e.g. coastal re-
gions, high-altitude regions, etc.); since the
number otf operating sources of radioactive dis-
charges in each region changes over time; and
since monitoring of actual concentrations may
indiccte that prior theoretical calculations as
to future concentrations were invalid; the dis-

charge levels for each facility in a region have

15.

to be determined before operation and then reviewed
and altered on the basis of operating experience and
monitoring, as necessary to ensure that the general

environmental levels will be met and maintained.

Therefore, discharge levels for each facility
operating in a region logically have to be esta-
blished and continually reviewed in light of these
other circumstances, to ensure that general environ-
mental standards will be achieved and maintained.
However, the NRC has promulgated only generic dis-
charge Limitations in Appendix I applicable to all

licensees, irrespective of these other circumstances.

Since the legislative history on control responsibility
for radioactive effluent discharges from nuclear

power plants, as presented by the parties in this case,
is inconclusive as to Congressional intent, the central
issue before this Court is the appropriate allocation

of authority between the two agencies, consistent

16.

with the scope of authority provided by

Congress.

it is clear that general environmental standards
govern discharge standards under existing legis-
lation for air pollution (42 U.S.C. 1857 c-5(a 2)
(E)1970) and water pollution (33 U.S.C. (Supp. III)
1311 (b)(1)(e)1972) control. Therefore, EPA's
primacy on radiation regulation matters is evi-
dent, although unsupported by its activities to
date. This primacy can only be effectively rea-
lized through EPA regulation of discharges as

well as of general environmental levels, the
Respondent's position. Interagency agreement

can, of course, be reached to ensure that NRC
expertise is available for EPA use in determining
discharge limitations on a facility-specific

basis.

17.

In determining the appropriate allocation of
authority between the two agencies, the Court
should be guided by consistent Congressional
determination that authority for both discharge
and general environmental (ambient) controls
should be concentrated in EPA for pollution con-
trol purposes. Congress has provided for few
exceptions to this single-agency approach to
pollution control, and only by means of explicit
and detailed provisions in its major pollution
control enactments: e.g. (1) aircraft noise
emission (discharge) control by the Federal
Aviation Administration (49 U.S.C. 1431), general
(ambient) noise level control by state and local
authorities; (2) dredge spoil disposal by EPA
and the Corps of Engineers in a cooperative re-

gulatory program (33 U.S.C. (Supp. IIL) 1344).

18.

IT. EPA AUTHORITY TO DETERMINE EFFLUENT DIS-
CHARGE LIMITATIONS FOR THE SOURCES OF RADIOAC-
TIVE MATERIALS IN THE GENERAL, ENVIRONMENT, IN-
CLUDING NRC LICENSEES, IS CONSISTS Nt WITH THE
FEDERAL WATER POLLUTLON CONTROL ACT AMENDMENTS
OF 1972, AND WITH THE FEDERAL PREEMPTLON OF
STATE REGULATION OF RADIOACTIVE EFFLUENT

DISCHARGES FROM NUCLEAR POWER FACLLITIES.

The Federal Water Pollution Control Act Amend-
ments of 1972 (FWPCA) provide EPA with discharge
limitation, permit and enforcement authority over
point sources of pollutants. The FWPCA defines
"pollutant" as including "... radioactive materials
..discharged into water," (Sec. 502(6), 33 U.S.C.
(Supp. Lil) 1362) without qualification, The FWPCA
further preseribes that national “standards of
performance," defined as standards "...for the
control of the discharge of pollutants..." (33
U.S.C. (Supp. ILL) 1316(a)(1)) shall be established
by EPA for various point sources, and includes
"steam electric powerplants" (33 U.S.C. (Supp. III)

1316(b)) in its list of point sources.

wee eee

19.

The provisions of the FWPCA most relevant to EPA
determination and application of discharge li-
mitations on the radioactive effluents of nuctiear
power plants include the following:

1. Water quality standards to be established by
the states subject to EPA approval, (33 U.S.C.
(Supp. TIL) 1313) and subject to the overall
objectives of the act to have (a) water quality
on a national scale sufficient to protect fish,
shellfish, wildlife and recreation by 1983 (33
U.S.C. (Supp. LIL) 1251(a)(2)); and (b) water
quality on a national scale undisturbed by pol-
luting discharges from potnt-sources by 1985.

33 U.S.C (Supp. TIL) 1251(a) (1).
2. Effluent Limitations for existing point
sources (33 U.S.C. (Supp. IIT) 1311) (discharge
standards) to be developed by EPA as necessary
to achieve and maintain the relevant water qua-
lity standards and 1983 and 1985 goals, noted
above. Implementation of such Limitations is

tion Discharge Elimination System (NPDES), wherein

20.

discharge permits must be secured by the polluter
and enforced by EPA and the states. (33 U.S.C.
(Supp. TIL) 1342). Further, the NPDES program
and the conditions ot the permits must be based
on Congressionally-prescribed criteria: by 1977,
employment of the "best practicable control
technology" (BPT) for each of the industrial
categories of dischargers; (33 U.S.C. (Supp. ITT)
1314(b)(1)(B)) by 1983, employment of the “best
available control technology" (BAT). (33 U.S.C.
1314(b)(2)(B)). An industrial point source ca-
tegory, designated "steam electric power
plants" has been established for purposes of
implementing the NPDES program (33 U.S.C. (Supp.
111) 1316(a), 10 €FR40 ) and covers nuclear power
facilities.

3. New source performance standards (discharge
standards for future point sources) to be estab-
lished by EPA for nation-wide application, on the
basis of the "best available demonstrated control
technology" for designated industrial categories

and dischargers. 33 U.S.C. (Supp. III) 1316(a) .

21.

"Steam-electric power plants have been

so designated. (33 U.S.C. (Supp. ILI) 1316(b)).

4. Toxle effluent standarda for the discharge

of "those pollutants which after discharge and
upon contact with any organism, either directly
from the environment or indirectly by ingestion
through food chains, will cause death, disease,
behavioral abnormalities, cancer, genetic muta-
tions physiological malfunctions or physical
deformities, in such organisms or their offspring."
These are to be established by EPA for nation-wide

application (33 U.S.C. (Supp. LIT) 1317).

Kach of the foregoing is subject to prescribed

time frames. Further, the FWPCA defines the term
"pollutant" to include among other things, "radio-
active materials." (33 U.S.C. (Supp. TIL) 1362(b)).
The decision of the Circuit Court of Appeals in
this case relates to EPA responsibility for set-
ting discharge standards, and thereby calls for
EPA to set both effluent standards for existing
point sources (2 above) and new source performance

standards (3 above); or alternatively toxic

22.

effluent standards for radioactive materials
which would be applied to both existing and

new sources,

Radioactive materials of the types discharged in
the effluent from power plants readily qualify

as "pollutants" under FWPCA, and thereby qualify
for discharge regulation by EPA under the various

provisions outlined above.

Regulation on the basis of the toxic pollutants
section of the FWPCA, for example, could be
applied to all radioactive materials. The states
would not be able to require higher discharge
limitations on toxic, radioactive effluents in
light of the finding of federal preemption over
power plant radioactive effluent discharges in
the Northern States v. Minnesota decision, des-
pite the reallocation of authority to EPA for
controlling discharges. The possibility of
differing standards among the states wich conse-
quent disruption of the national development of
nuclear power would thereby be avoided; although

each state could eventually qualify for implement-

23.

ation and enforcement of the federal standards,
following arrangements with EPA under the FWPCA
(33 U.S.C. (Supp. III) 1341); 42 U.S.C. 1857C-5)
and the consent of the NRC under the provisions

of the Atomic Energy Act. 42 U.S.C. 2021(b).

Other alternatives for EPA in regulating such
discharges are provided by the FWPCA. For exam-~
ple, EPA can determine discharge limitations for
existing sources in keeping with its findings on
"best practicable" control technology (33 U.S.C.
(Supp. III), 1314 (b) (1) (B)) for implementation
by 1977 and “best available” control technology
33U.S.C. (Sup. ILD 1314(b) (2) (B) for implementation
by 1983. EPA can also determine discharge limi-
tations for new sources on the basis of "best
available demonstrated control technology." 33
U.S.C. (Supp. IIT) 1316(a)(1). EPA could in

such cases, employ the principle of "As Low As

Is Readily Achievable" (10 CFR 50. 34a(a) and

the methods of cost-benefit analysis, used by the
NRC, and arrive at discharge limitations similar

to those provided in NRC's Appendix I. 40 Fed.

24.
Reg. 19439, (May 5, 1975).

The foregoing analysis also indicates that dis-
charge control by EPA would not necessarily in-
terfere with the principle of federal preemption
over the radioactive effluent discharges of nu-
clear power plants, as such principle has been
articulated in the Northern States case. 447
F.2d 1143(C.A.8) aff'd, 405 U.S. 1035 . Discharge
control authority would remain with a federal
agency, and the issue of federal preemption is
therefore not raised by this case. Subsequent

to the formulation of EPA discharge Limitations
and the implementation of such Limitations in an
EPA program, the federal preemption issue may
arise in a controversy, and can be appropriately

dealt with at such time.

EPA authority to determine such discharge lLimi-

tations on nuclear power plant sources is there-

fore consistent with, and made capable of effective

implementation by, the several provisions of the
FWPCA, and does not, at this time, raise issues

of federal preemption.

25.

CONCLUSION

For the foregoing reasons, the judgment of the

court of appeals should be affirmed.

Respectfully submitted.

Michael S. Baram

Nha S baa

Attorney

September 1975

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385003_0325%3A09. Public record. Not legal advice.
