# Petitioners Reply Brief — Kazmann v. Environmental Protection Agency

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385002_1215%3A1

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Petitioners Reply Brief
- **Published:** January 1, 1989
- **Citation:** 490 U.S. 1082

## Text

ee

- ae
° | Siereme Sourt, U8,
S8-1693 Filey
| MAR 45.4989

' JOSEPH F. SPANIOL, JR,
NO. ; CLERK

IN THE
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

OCTOBER TERM 1989

RAPHAEL G. KAZMANN, P. E.
PETITIONER

VERSUS

THE UNITED STATES
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, ET AL.
RESPONDENT

PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT

JACK N. ROGERS
MICHAEL R. CONNELLY
ROGERS & CONNELLY
604 St. Ferdinand
Baton Rouge, LA
70802-6187
(504) 344-4369
Counsel for
Petitioner

rene

QUESTION PRESENTED

Whether Petitioner, as a citizen
acting in his capacity as a ratepayer
and/or taxpayer of a municipality, has
standing under the provisions of 33 USC
1365 and/or 5 USC 702 et seq. to sue the
Environmental Protection Agency in order
to set aside orders of the EPA imposed

on said municipality.

TABLE OF CONTENTS
Opinions Below... ccscsvccecsscensiveene 1
JurisG@iction. «ss ss és6es4e esa eee 2

Constitutional Provisions

Involved... CA 86) 5235 F 2d 1032...32

Hill vs. Tennessee Valley Authority
fewre Gm 6) S49 F 24 1064........ 18

International Federation of

Professional and Technical

Engineers vs. Williams
(1974 E D VA) 389 F Supp 287
Aff'd w/o opinion (CA 4 VA)
oe eck ce eee eerees 28

Loveladies Property Owners'
Association, Inc. vs. Raab
(US Dist Ct D NJ 1975)
Ce ES 18

Marathon Oil vs. Environmental
Protection Agency (1972 CA 9)
ee wee wenn nen 32

Motor Vehicle Manufacturers'
Association vs. State Farm
Mutual Insurance Co.
(US S Ct 1983) 463 US 29,
77 me Be 20 $43, 103 S Ct 2856:...32

National Association of Metal
Finishers vs. EPA (CA 3 1983)
(oi 2 Bis eer reer err eer 34

Public Citizen vs. Lockheed Aircraft
Corporation (1977) 184 App DC 133,
ae wr ee PO ge ee OR eS 30

Sierra Club vs. Hickel (1970 CA 9 Cal)
433 F 26 28 ALL’ a 405 US feta cas 30

U. S. CONSTITUTIONAL ARTICLES:

Article 3, Se@ctsaon 2 til seaweeds 3,19
Fourteenth Amendment.........-.---- 4
STATUTES:
5 uscS 702 (Administrative
PrOCeagure ACL) + ean nt Onmr11~+ M : T ++ +
oe ae Fok oe @ Ait, sO i ,
TANMIIAGIANA roa ~ | a + +
LOULSIdllid, ie I ac z A
abe Ser temt er © ne = > *
—/ & HY WY mAh — , 7 ~
= NAN o + + .
> TV WIA? 1m Y 7
VEnerTr a 44 1ViaqaualS 7 — a ¥Y -. A
a — he

United States Environmental Protection

N y T and nen ~
igency, Through Its Administrator,

n 1 he 5

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

MIDDLE DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA

RAPHAEL G. KAZMANN, P.E., ET AL.
VERSUS CIVIL ACTION NO. 87-1016-A
U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY,

ET AL.

RULINC ON MOTION TO DISMISS

This matter is before the court on
EPA's motion to dismiss for lack of
subject matter jurisdiction, res
judicata and failure to state a claim.
Plaintiff has filed an opposition.
There is no need for oral argument.

The salient issue presented by the
motion to dismiss is whether this suit
is barred under res judicata principles.
This lawsuit is plaintiff's second
attempt to thwart EPA's actions in
forcing the City of Baton Rouge and the
Parish of East Baton Rouge to comply

55

with the provisions of the Clean Water
Act concerning secondary sewerage
treatment. Plaintiff's first attempt to
enjoin EPA's actions was made in Raphael
Kazmann, P.E. v. United States
Environmental Protection Agency, et al.,
CA No. 87-210-A (of this court's
docket). That action was dismissed by
the court for lack of standing and
jurisdiction. See reported decision at
669 F.Supp. 144 (M.D.La. 1987). A
judgment of dismissal was entered on
September 17, 1987, which is now final
as plaintiff failed to appeal.

On November 20, 1987, plaintiff
instituted this action against the same
defendants asserting the same wrong
doing by epa.! In this case, however,
plaintiff has substituted the statutory
references to the Clean Water Act in his
complaint with references to the
Administrative Procedure Act, 5 U.S.C.

56

EE LLlLlLlLlLl ee

Section 702, et seq. Plaintiff argues
that by asserting the Administrative
Procedure Act in this lawsuit, he has
presented a new cause of action
precluding the application of res
judicata. The court cannot agree;
clearly the issue of standing was
litigated in the first action. Any
question as to the correctness of that
decision should have been raised by a
motion for post judgment relief or an
appeal.

Although a judgment of dismissal

predicated on standing is not an

'Tn his first suit, plaintiff sought to
enjoin EPA enforcing the provisions of
the Clean Water Act relating to
secondary treatment to and prohibit the
defendants from entering into a consent
decree until an administrative hearing
had been held by EPA. In this suit,
plaintiff essentially seeks to prohibit
the same conduct. Plaintiff erroneously
claims that a consent decree was entered
in late September of 1987. Clearly,
these allegations are incorrect as the
court has pending before it an
application for approval of a proposed
consent decree in CA No. 88-191-A.

57

adjudication on the merits, such a
judgment precludes further litigation on
those matters actually adjudged.
Insurance Corp. of Ireland, Ltd. v.
Compagnie des Bauzites, 465 U.S. 694,
102 S.Ct. 2099, 2104, n.9, 72 L.Ed. 492
(1982); Mann v. Sabella, No. 86-3336
(5th Cir. February 11, i988). See
Moore's Federal Practice, Paragraph
0.405[5]. Since the issues are
substantially identical, the prior
judgment constitutes a direct estoppel. ?
Consequently, plaintiff is precluded
from relitigating the same issues

herein.

—.

2In the prior suit, the court did not
limit plaintiff to the jurisdictional
allegations of his complaint. The
effect of the Administrative Procedure
Act was raised and argued therein,
although not expressly noted in the
court's written reasons.

58

Acccrdingly, defendant's motion to
dismiss is hereby GRANTED and this

action will be dismissed.

JOHN V. PARKER, CHIEF JUDGE
MIDDLE DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA

a9

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385002_1215%3A1. Public record. Not legal advice.
