# Prologue — Bertera's Hopewell Foodland, Inc. v. Masters

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385001_1052%3A0

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Prologue
- **Published:** January 1, 1968
- **Citation:** 390 U.S. 597

## Text

stil a Set cae Offive-6 game Court, U.
a eo ee.

LIBRARY. ey ae erat Bs |
| FEB-20 1068

ee

Y .. SUPREME COURT: 'U. 5 a

| . s | es Ao Ca kek: DAViS, CLER’ a
b sae 8 \a IN THE wae i
ee ae ®
a SupremeCourt of the United States |
% Cy ae cine October Term, 1967, |
' +g ti} , * —_ ; . .
SA ee et ae | BERTERA'S HOPEWELL FOODLAND, ING, |
Oe 8 BR x TABLE OF CONTENTS. A
es pe Sek ae ST PAGE
. Opinions Belew .............. Benenorgucepesesscudes = an
Grounds fer Jurisdiction ........ sseiiahiacatin’s vihees ae.
Nature of Proceedings .......... en ep ccheesieces 2
Judgment Sought to be Reviewéd ......... a es
Statutory Jurisdiction ~....... eseneee acehysecbc - -§:
Cases Sustaining Jurisdiction ................ —
Pennsylyania Statute. and Constitutional Provision
Involved kénnwies biiceeenborascubaaenecessaee.. =
Questions Presented by tlie Appeal eieae bias 4 Cre Ee
_ Statement of the ME Cages uectksddkaccaevekiues eV &
Reasons Why Federal Questions Are Substantial . 9
: >. A. The Statute Is Vague ......... peeuews ipa 2 er
B. The Statute Is Discriminatory iskpakadene”
Conclusion ec acgbesecsqcaccnccsdedssaabbert? cascuk | oe

Appendix A—Opinion of Court of Sodus Pleas are
_Beaver County, Pennsylvania filed May 4, 1966 . 23 -

~~ Appendix B—Opinion of Court of Common Pleas of
Beaver County, Pennsylvania filed July 27, 1966 ... 49

_ Appendix C—Opinions of the Supreme Coyrt of Peiin- ae es
sylvania dated November 28, 1967 ........ euenes «61

. Appendix C-1—Opinion of the Court: ..... 2, - as 61—
Appendix C-2—Concurring Opinion, Bell, C. J. 92.

’ Appendix C-3—Concutring- Opinion, Roberts, z on:

_» Appendix C-4—Dissenting. Opinion, O’Brien, J... 104

: Appendix C- 5—Opinion Vacating’ wicates Cohen, z 111

Tass oF Cases.

” Arrigo v. Lincoln, 154 Neb. 537, 48 N. W. 2d 643

EE Wkanudere Cac acbbakehhGadethne bese iebesanke 22
Bantam Books, Ine. v. Sullivan, 372 U, 8. 58, 83 S..Ct.
631 = (etneanaueeke Mawnan weene ETT TT TTT TT 3°

ee ooo Sah Ses

duteo ttn:

he? wae rn: (1941) ee 12
\ Sarner v. Union Twp., rad N. J. Super. 523, 151 A. 2d
. 298 (1959) SUE RARE SAR RAN eb A eBeabihee conse 20
Standard Oil Co. y. ;. California v. Jolinsod, 316 U. S. 481, .
- 6258. Ct. 1168 (1942) 2.2.20. KCL EA RAOUOCERKE NOS 3.
- Terry Carpenter, Inc. v. “Wood, 177 Neb. 515, "129° |
ON. W. 2d 475 (1964) ...... Pa Bete w eee 21, 22
Two Guys from Harrison-Allentown, Inc. v. McGinley,
366. U. S. 582, 81 S. Ct. 1135 (1961) os... eee. .. 16
‘U. S.v. Cardiff, 344 U. S. 174 (1952) -...... ee
_ U.S. v. National ca Products Corp., 312, U. 8. 29 -
| (1963) . ideekhabs SRRCROLA AAS ahig b40% ohn Kei 11
Winters v. People of State of N. Y,, 333 U. R. 507, 68. -
' §. Ct. 665. GREED hiweececocwrcescscccede awedeas - 8

Winters v. U.S., 333 U. S. 507, ee (1948) 12

_ Act of June-24, 1939, P. L.-872, as amended vy :
= - plemented by Section 699. 15, added, September 27,
1961, P. L. 1695, Sec. 1, Title 18, Purdon’s Pa. Stat.

t. See. 4699.15, p. 541 (1963 Ed.) . Pescgeeks we, o
‘Ret of. June 25, 1948, c. 646, 62 Stat. 929, Title, 28,
United States Code,, Section 1257 8) eeieiéacnmy Oe ?
a ; ear “Consrerunion. x nn ‘ol
| United States Constitution. ...... coe ik OES .8 28".
- Amendment XIV ............ “so wagp s0 sons ose y Up Ob OO
- Amendment XIV, Sec. 1 ..... 4 ERI RCR ehoseena 4.
A. i)
atti a ON, _ MISCELLANEOUS.
i i cicciciidaycnscvabsesacegeca Me
Vol. 82, C. J. S:, Statutes: ' - ae | :
Sec. 163, p. 277° ..... Sesens eases mecscsvesceces IT
We MM oad ccccccscessncnensct Bweceo ff
‘Sec. 1555, p. 263 ..... Diecitiee eh iain keto kkwks is 17 _—
, Ps pe . st ‘ . :
ope cat | Ae uae
‘ |
\ a

“
4 . *- * .
“-
J .
4 — j
* ‘ Ww
’ - . 4 es
: . .
ie ML + @ ‘ . ”
*
} e a
e .
Pay
* ‘ . =
’ . : a
j oo? .
jue,” s ’
, ee
. : .
. ° 4 ° .
- ‘0 by
av’ Pa . [ ©
a
see ~~
a . ’
4 er .
“ .
\ /
. ad ‘2
é ‘
- .
.
° . P .
oe g .
~ ° .
ary
‘ ”
, ’
a] . ‘
. ,
. S ‘. ’
‘ a mS q
7 ? s e
J
. se
; .
, e od ’
e . 4
” r }
. ‘
. ’
. .
”
, « .
P - ™ of
’ ¥ a
. ” .
. , ‘ a
. ’ 7 - Me .
. . ° =
» 4 « e 4
>
at a a
9 ‘ x
* . >
. . . bd
. v6
- .
. . & “*
°, a
-* e
‘ B-
‘* . 2? .
. e : J
.
. . &
. j .
®. , ’
* ‘* i »,

“
‘
‘\
”
sd .
’ .
.
° .
. -
.
23%
*
7@
. | od
oe «4 ‘
. ® *
¢ »
s , Cd
* . ;
ad ’
.
x -
.
” 7s
.
.
.
.
’
* e :
.
.
.
° al 3
a, e
-
é
.
+ "
.
,
.
-
ad .
1d *
ee
-* .
s°
se ’
° ‘
.
J .
e-
* oe
7.

_ INTHE

| Supreme Court of the United States

EET s on Term, 1967
' : oe BERTERA M's HOPEWELIPOODLAN D, INC.,
- te Pee . Aggetes, *
a ‘Vs. @ | a4 :

ROBERT J MASTERS, District Attofney of Bebive'l
_ County, J OHN A! KRZTON, Chief County .Detective
‘, of Beaver, County, LOUIS POLCE and STEVE ‘D.
-. MIHALIC; County Detectives of Beaver County. and —
other Municipal and State Law Enforcement _
all members of a class,. eee
: x? . o ‘Kaw, bites.

On ApprAL FROM THE Supreme Court or PENNSYLVANIA &”
=~

oo

JURISDICTIONAL STATEMENT

; The appellant appeals from the judgment of the.Supreme :
~ Court: of Pennsylvania entered on November 28, 1967,
_.affirming the decision of the Court of Common Pleas of

Beaver County, Pennsylvania, and appellant submits this .°
~ statement to show that the Supreme.Court-.of the United -

States has jurisdiction of the appeal. and meaty a . substantial

_question is presented. t

Opinions Below
The opinion of the Court @ Common Pleas of Beaver

ear is not officially Teported. A copy of this opinion

=) ‘ *

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385001_1052%3A0. Public record. Not legal advice.