# Motion to Affirm — Lester C. Newton Trucking Co. v. United States

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385001_0985%3A3

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Motion to Affirm
- **Published:** January 1, 1967
- **Citation:** 389 U.S. 30

## Text

BS : it ? eo ca Re | n
’ » we aoe . 5

sued OLS 129 sinha bs3i sh ¥ nk Asateare) olin’ t TonosteV.

¥ nan ge apie cbocriiits 88 qque.t :
LEY why wy A pyre sea hits BSE ; ee AMOK NPS

3 IN eS Rabat f ¥ ft
e = eee SR Soares Ree Beng, meee? RNS ae t o

‘ Neo eee snce age Pd denon, bokuw'd-er sho Vi .
. an *-« yr sy we, Bass Page )

: ht “WM ROE ye Qatar vv wo Hoganwr’t aii eo ;
§ wee anna nanan: ae plies .

Mersy ae ec 5s

eee n ne eee TONNES see BRO pee)
; fiscernatigh Bh *“OFTATIONS*. J wolestiv D goby toh.
Cases: “HEC OT SOL atiave Nosed oy, OY Sgnbtnd dois’ ~ :
\ Alton-R. ere United tikes, $19 OS. npsille CI0 gg

er sAccalbn - Wad, Fnb:y Dwdved Badter; BBS wae |
Sete IRI sie ot epee neetietintneinin ince anliaesietsbalemalinee nee as | 7,8
Battoylis'y. Ube Bika 3 OS! 198 9 = 4
- Ohesapeake-- Motor --Lines;--Ine--Cotarhor
ita? Appiiatie 8 ADDO. BT ATT

; z Refrigerated Traneportation, fe v United
a . "ae TS. 86 7A: “ee okay
A

g ae *

.

Qh BI io: al: aie sor :

pywnt, dueretact oad. f 8 oR eibroltol OB
Phe areyey AMT > LEO ANY : yo aus OER IG atiarit

ifhh Deot gadcetey ated tone Baia) Lagerlo Be, 685 srt

"Lawn. ison eae Conus, cael

+ tad

~~

BY to mytamotky fig HK rr Legge davilloage, PORE, eh
| Owes frais Ce Oe Blot. ae
© 0) oe es Qonaiommeate Codaasbiaron, (6) TOS goitone
ate 7 cat aah! pbs $3 i deogests Id Od 4 6. Ed TOS he fai}
OW’ appa ‘pi ‘tite vir rn baker bbee ‘ro
3 oe otto f betes 1 8 Apel !

”
i;

-*

Bier TS ilacchey 1 Bote

: wey tt fy

fica s

u t of m8 st r
f 4 AES, fit Eas te fers tt 8

a fics ede Oe

~

By SRR ‘.
= Rh 20, oitmabiemory anf mo “4
opias, Snood. ea ns)

ty te "2 i

ry « a.
of meter garter eciiaM,

. Mathes a

sh 7 * ; , vee oe ? % .
‘ \ Sek f
Soe en fe@tt. AAAS : ° ; ae
26); Ke ucking C , ;
“ 2B}ea . Rinwten Zrucbing 0. Common Carrier
Y EN te Oh te De q ° 7% ae ’ :
3% > y . “ = e

- MF P 7 of. ee ara ‘ +

S > ; , “ + . , : 5 *4 y. % ;

™ Se ~ > 5

ur

“ht wi

! W?vappalont opal for an extension of its
SomyeRAROP and necessity under

Section V7 (a) tithe, Interstate Commerce Act, (49

U.8.0. aio) to trataport the identical commodities

pe yi a determination that these three
; commodities were ineladadcin the; terms of its existing

mgr
So EAS eee

mantiete - eee iy

eK * igh oe onion

fa . sa : Me Lae 3 a yan (6) e a bs ;
oc cert |
ecornttse: ey; paiventn

foobir,
annus ene seomnacombrtteeberrn (WB. App.
60). ‘In jits subsequent ‘Mepor>on reconsideration, the

Coininission ‘vonchided that; ‘applying the’ stafidards «
established in Willis. Shaw;*-appellant Waw in? fast
entitled 'to: broader suamaeunamramedae

\ Bh Yes **
ooraplainit on . ak praanittati-

AMMO TER: RAUB, ce Ags heey a battish Bivt poiaeleraye’ y pe:
Bont MOTE phe’ enalidina% netiithatal . a ra
ne i at n>: fig, :

aie |

°
2

«
e 4

: phallic enibtalsic™ arin oempeds creat |
vot gyal’ eainveniones: and. oa PA as well as. their

1a tn Weipa tke Gloimalnaion's op

plication of those ‘standards in the instant case. . Ab
1: Determination of the operations: whieh a motor”

teatrier vany conduct. under a “grandfather” ‘clause, ,

‘grit fact} as-found by the Commission | (J.8.

fe pW 21-28; 68), that it ‘never intended * to authorize

cates were iisned.Tndeed, in’ Newton, Hatension of
Prosen Poods, 43 M.C.C. 787 (1944), ap-
‘Was’¢ranted *‘frogen’ food’? authority upon the
y that thé transportation’ of the three -

modities was nt authorized: by its exist-
~ieoimmodities” Luektificalen. “Having

i : sin 9 Tots oe)
Stk, Baste bse amet ota.
¥, Batted OE poy ¥. Suse , 386 (NAD. A! 7

9
: Unsted| States; uiprea, 955 TB» at 580-560 Phat
; ia simply not ithe casd Kure.» : PATS sf vi seal: TOUT ek

"7a Seecidn BBB) (6) of thé chips “
(49: Stat.’ 544-345), non-mancfactuted agritalteral-commoditis
ett aisha cha eee oeiean oe atl
we iain Interstate Cor 6 Con ¥. Da
2d 116 (C.A. 5}} ents Caines Comat y Blepotes
Trucking Co., Inc. 186, F. 24.400. ymimission
‘consistently held, however,’ thot 1084 eal
berties, and’ ‘végetablés’ were hot” h the ‘agricdltd:
modities exception, because-it eigen only + n bi :
items. To transport frozen fruits, berries, and ‘vege

Frac drgagptin dng sone Arma oe ) & carrier quires
to have a certificate ny thelng tek Sedna 4 3
however, two court de d that these vomimodities ‘were

within the Section 203(b) 5) (6) ‘exemption. Home Transfer & -
\ Storage Oo. v. United States, 141 ¥. Supp, 599° (W-D. Wash),
“~~ afined, 8590.9. 884; Prosen Food Fapress ¥. United States,
148 FB Supp. 399 (SD. ‘Tex.), affitined; $85 US. 6: sa meet
of the Transportation Act of 1988 '('72 Stat. 874), ‘Co
clatified ‘its intetition ‘with ‘respect to ‘the Regen Say
cultural commodities exception. Section 7(a) amenie
* 208(b) (8) ‘by adopting a revious Comihis
and fhon-exempt ties arid by.
the exemption frozen fruiti, berries, anil Veg bles. | ess thus
affirmed and upheld the Commissint’s fon panting terpret
-. . tidnt:' See "HL Rep. No, 1929, Sawa 24: Sess., pp. 15-17. to
| night sed to fh fo ot Ui

wes IOT

Nothing the 188 Actor it agli hoy res oni :

~~,
“

| wo
"tail addition i the, eotitt dhetew obacrved,’ appellant
_ “ln predaded by the language snd lngistativetistony of

Bectlah 20b),.of the 1988 Act thom relying. on that pro-
Saas : mere wf eenaneenatoaen

‘ t® ° . . : ‘ Se
Tei ns} CO tate
’ et >
” : y »"
‘sy : t :
;

se i ve

sofamodites

SP SE bse pone oe shel

>
> +3
Oe Seat
~

dd quiselaigsl wi 10 Jok BOCK old ni yashor

ee a a ee

ee ae
The judgment of ‘the district court. so ‘be Me
ae BE r Mai Sg
| Solicitor General, -
‘Dowarw F. Turner,
Assistant Attorney General.
: Howam E. Suarmd, 2 §

Wuium R. Weissman, eet
Rosert W. GINNANE, ” ae
General Counsel, -
Joun E. Favtx, -
_ Attorney, ;
Interstate Commerce Commission.
Avevst 1967.

a

5.0 Sovermmrer Peering Gere, 1907

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385001_0985%3A3. Public record. Not legal advice.