# Brief for the CIO as Amicus Curiae — Peters v. Hobby

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA04386408_0129%3A13

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Brief for the CIO as Amicus Curiae
- **Published:** January 1, 1954
- **Citation:** 348 U.S. 882

## Text

en on
Office -Suorer-2 Court, U. S.
FiiLBD

JAN 171955

HAROLD B. WILLEY, Clerk

LIBRARY |
SUPREME COURT. U.S.

IN THE
Supreme Court of the Anited States

| OcToBer Term, 1954

No. 376

Joun P. Perers, Petitioner,
v.
Oveta Cup Hossy, et al.

| BRIEF FOR THE
CONGRESS OF INDUSTRIAL ORGANIZATIONS
AS AMICUS CURIAE —

Artruur J. GoipBerc
General Counsel
1001 Connecticut Avenue, N. W.
Washington 6, D. C.

Tuomas E. Harris
Associate General Counsel
718 Jackson Place, N. W..
Washington 6, D. C.

Joszeru L. Raun, Jr.
Washington Counsel, UAW-CIO
1631 K Street, N. W.
Washington 6, D. C.

>.

INDEX

PACE
The Interest of the Congress of Industrial Organizations |
Argument 3
I]. Federal Loyalty-Security Programs | 6
A. The Current “Employees” Security Program” for Civil-
ian Employees of ‘The Federal Government 8
1. Genesis of the Present Program ‘
a. The Truman administration loyalty program 8
b. Summary dismissal statutes and “security” 10

c. Merger of the Truman administration loyalty and
summary dismissal (security) programs ok ee

2. Establishment of the“Employees’ Security Program” 12
3. The Finding of Guilt Under the Present Program... 13

4. The Distinction between Applicants and Employees 17

B. Security Programs for Military Personnel seacdacitan ts: ee
C. Defense Contractors’ Personnel Clearance . ies ee

D. Proposed Extensions of Loyalty-Security Programs to
Other Industrial Facilities - sacle ekosan 21
E. Atomic Energy Commission. _ Saasemaee a
F. one "st pee Te. OD

G. International Organizations Employees’ Loyalty Pro-
gram 27
II. State and Local Action 30
Conclusion LER piace eaet col PME anaes 39

Appendix—Personnel Security Programs of the Federal Gov-
ernment .

CITATIONS

PAGE
Cases:
Adler v. Board of Education, 342 U.S. 485 32
— Communications Association v. Doud, 339 U.S. 382 oe
Bailey vy. Richardson, 341 U.S. 918 —.. _— 5,7
Barsky v. Board of Regents, 347 U.S. 442 38
Fitzgerald vy. City of Philadelphia No. 6212, September Term
1952, Pennsylvania Pleas Court 38
Garner v. Board of Public Workers of Los duasles, 341 U S. 716 31
Gerende vy. Board of Supervisors, 341 U.S. 56... 31

Parker vy. Lester, 112 F. Supp. 433, 443-444 (N.D. Calif., 1953) 23
United States v. Gray, 207 F, 2d 237, 241-242 (C.A. 9th, 1953) 23
United States v. Marcus Singer, Criminal No. 1150-54, United

States District Court for the District of Columbia... ss 33
Vane mele y, are, 296 we fC
Wieman v. Undegraff, 344 U.S. 183... ; ..3, 14, 20, 21
Statutes:

(Federal!)

Act of 1942, 56 Stat. 1053... sasees 1
Act of August 26, 1950—64 Stat. 476, 5 U SC. $22. . 10, 11, 12
Civil Service Act of 1883, 22 Stat. 403 .. 9
Hatch Act—53 Stat. 1148, 5 U.S.C. $113), 1939 ‘Amendment,

i cag EE REI AES ORE AE ALS RA TE ARG NRE 8, 9, 10
Internal Security Act a 1950, Title I, 64 Stat. 987. nema = ean eee 23
ne
50 U.S.C. $782(7) Scealins tacnahnesenanniasacinscadniertSepnchwhanmiguia >. ee
dE a
Magnuson Act —.....- ieotadatecapiaasnteidcceneecadendiiddaestnnioe * Oe
R. S. $1753, § U.S.C. $631 NRE EAL AN NS SOE * |
| SEES ST
United States Code Annotated:
a I ccs siteccneecencmnncivensnenpecscinciiiinpaicsscens OM
(State)
Alabama: Code of Alabama, T.52, s. 433 (6a) — wien 35
California: Deering’s California Code, Government T., para.
1028, 1953 - eae : —
Connecticut: Rule 17, Rules ‘and Regulations ‘and ‘Related
Statutes for State Classified Service... nesses cia
Florida: Florida Statutes Annotated, Ch. 876. jleieaaai ae
Georgia: Georgia Code Annotated, Ch. 89, ss. 311- 316. ideas Oe

Indiana: Burns Indiana Statutes 10-5202...

PAGE

Louisiana: Louisiana Revised Statutes, Ch. 14, ss. 358-365 32
Maryland: Flack’s Annotated Code of Maryland, 1951, Article

85A, (Ober Law of Mary!and) - 31
Mississippi: Mississippi Code Annotated, ss 4064- 01 et seq... 32
New Hampshire: New Hampshire Laws, Ch. 180 1953 _ 32
New York: New York Laws 1949, C. 360, (Feinberg Law) 32
65 McKinney’s Consolidated Laws of New York $§1101-1108

(1954 Cum, Supp.) - aocanccncoe ae
Ohio: Anderson’s Ohio Revised Code, ss. -143- 272 ae
Pennsylvania: Purdon’s Pennsylvania Loyalty Oath. Statute . =
Pennsylvania Statutes Annotated, T.65, Ch. 11 822
Texas: Vernon’s Annotated Statutes, Article 6252, 5.7... 35
Article 4542a, s.9_. ses. 37
Washington: Washington Revieed Code, Ch. 981 on) ae
Miscellaneous:

Bontecou, The Federal Loyalty-Security Program, Cornell Press,

1953 - waES nis , 9. 3G, it, {2
Brown and Fassett, tele Tests tee ddeiisson to the Bar, 20

University of Chicago Law Review. ell 37
Byse, A Report on the Pennsylvania ley alty Act, 101 U niversity

of Pennsylvania Law Review 480, 1953. Sem as 35, 36
gE SS EE ROE ONT
Congressional Record:

100 Cong. Rec. 14116 ~ btilienbaata darshan aeaiomasinaichas: in
this evaluation are never discussed in the regulations. Presum-
ably they are similar to the standards prescribed for the de-
cision to suspend.

The civilian agencies make no further provision for the ap-
plicant about whom there is derogatory information; he is
not processed under the regulations. Presumably the Security
Office evaluation of an applicant is given to the employing of-
fice, with a recommendation. There is no requirement that
the applicant ever be informed why he was turned down. Non-
sensitive appointments are made subject to subsequent in-
vestigation; hence, the applicant will usually have become an
employee before the investigation is made. He is thus af-
forded the procedural rights granted to an employee in his
probational period. The applicant for a sensitive position will
in all likelihood still be an applicant when investigation is com-
pleted.

13 The security officer in the State Department, known as the Admin-
istrator, holds 1 peculiar position. The Bureau of Security and Consular
Affairs was created by Congress. Responsibility for personnel was later
added to this Bureau. The personnel office was recently removed from
the Bureau, but Mr. McLeod remains in control of security, of the Pass-
port Division and of other offices.

19

The State Department specifies that the Office of Security
may conduct or request further investigation, or may develop
the information in hand by interview or written interroga-
tories. The Department of Health, Education and Welfare
has similar provisiéns for inquiry. The regulations of the
other agencies are silent on this point and the frequency of use
of these pre-hearing devices has not been ascertained. Po-
tentially, interview or interrogatory at this stage can do away
with a need for further processing of a simple case and save
both the government and the employee expense, effort and
embarrassment. Potentially, too, it can be a form of threat,
an indication to the employee that charges are forthcoming
and that quick resignation would be in order. The value of
the device depenus not on its intrinsic merits but on the atti-
tude of the department which utilizes it.

The Personnel Officer, under the Sample Regulations, for-
wards his evaluation and the file to whatever official the agency
head has delegated his authority under the Act to suspend
employees.

Suspension

The decision to suspend is the responsibility of a high ad-
ministrative officer, not a security official. It is a rare admin-
istrator who would have the time for complete review of all
files; the recommendation of the Personnel Security Officer
must carry great weight. The Post Office and the Treasury
departments ailow some scope for decision to be made formally,
as well as informally, by the Security office. The Post Office
regulations require the Personnel Security Officer to forward
the report and evaluation “if he deems suspension advisable”
which by negative inference means he may close the case if he
feels suspension unnecessary. This implication is further sup-
ported by a later section which specificaily says that in his
decision he is to be guided by the same standards which the
suspending authority uses.

The Treasury Department explicitly puts the power to order
suspension jointly in a Security Officer and a Legal! Officer, who
evaluate the reports. They decide what action, if any, shall be
taken. If they consider suspension or reassignment appropri-

20

ate, they notify the head of the bureau who must follow their
decision.’ If they wish, they may call the bureau chief into
consultation and abide by the majority decision.

In the Justice, Post Office and Treasury departments, sus-
pension is formally ordered by the heads of component bu-
reaus. The State and Health departments and the Veterans’
Administration restrict this power to the head of the agency.

If the officer decides it is not necessary to suspend the em-
ployee, a written determination to that effect must be placed
in the files.5 The Sample regulations state that if there are
“ameliorating circumstances” which are neither defined nor
illustrated, and if the Security Officer approves, the employee
may be transferred temporarily to a position where his pres-
ence would be consistent with national security. The regula-
tions of the Veterans Administration adopt this provision in
the words of the Sample. The Post Office, Justice and Health
departments have no equivalent sections. The State Depart-
ment includes, in a general warning against using the security
program to the exclusion of other procedures, a statement
that “interim action’? should be used to “the fullest possible
extent.” This could authorize temporary change of position
though there is no other mention of it. Since all positions in
State are considered sensitive, the practicability of such a
transfer can be doubted.

The Treasury treats reassignment as an interim measure
open to the Personnel Security Officer and the Legal Officer.
An employee who has been reassigned will then receive the

14The Treasury regulations state that one of four actions may be
taken, to
1. Retain the employee in his present position.
2. Suspend.
3. Transfer temporarily.
4. To find that continued employment is not clearly consistent
with national security.

The fourth item is not a true alternative. If it is found that con-
tinued employment is not clearly consistent with national security, a
further decision to suspend or transfer temporarily must be made. It
is possible that if this fourth item is found, further investigation will be
made before the second or third alternative is followed.

15 This requirement may put pressure on the official to suspend. He
may fear that he would be criticized if a future investigation should
unearth his failure to suspend.

In the Post Office, whatever the decision, the file is returned to the
custody of the Personne] Security Officer.

21

same notice which an employee of his status would receive if
suspended. He may answer in writing and in affidavits. If,
considering these documents, the Security Officer and the Legal
Officer agree that the case may be closed favorably to the em-
ployee, they make this recommendation to the Secretary. If
a favorable decision is not made, the Security Officer wil! order
the head of the bureau to suspend the employee. The case is
then treated like any other suspension case.

In deciding whether suspension is necessary in the inter-
ests of secur ty, the officer should consider, among other things,
the seriousness of the information received, the possible access
to classified materia! which the individual might have in his
position, and the opportunity to do harm which that position
affoi js. The regulations make no attempt to prescribe respec-
tive weight to these elements or to indicate what other con-
siderations might enter the decision.

Disposition Without Hearing

All employees do not have the same rights under Public
Law 733. The United States citizen, serving under a per-
manent or indefinite appointment and past the period of pro-
bation, is entitled to an agency hearing; other employees
are not.

The probational employee, the alien, the employee hired for
a limited period, will be given, within ‘‘a reasonable time”
after suspension, notice in writing of the suspension. Such
notice is generally given in the name of the administrative
officer having power to suspend, but some agencies have the
Security Officer or some lesser official send it.

The notice is accompanied by a list of reasons for the suspen-
sion.1® The regulations state these shall be as complete as
security considerations, including protection of confidential
sources, permit. This proviso has been broadly interpreted by
the various agencies so that not only the names of informants
but the details of the incidents involved may be concealed if it
is thought such information might allow identification.

Within thirty days, the employee may submit such state-

16 These are prepared in most units by the Security Office. In the
Treasury Department, they are the joint product of the Legal Officer
and the Security Officer.

22

ments in writing, affidavits or documents, as he wishes, to
refute or explain the reasons given him with the notice. These
papers are submitted to a Legal Officer, who may be specializ-
ing in Security work. The Post Office and the Veterans Ad-
. ministration route the reply through the Security Officer.

The Legal Officer or the Security Officer (both of them in
the Veterans Administration) consider the answer for “suf-
ficiency.” This term is not defined. The Treasury adds that
if the papers are deficient, the Legal Officer may allow cor-
rection.

The Personnel Security Officer and the Legal Officer review
the file and the reply, if any was made.’7 They make a joint
recommendation to the head of the department or agency, or
individual recommendations if they are not in agreement.
There is no provision in the regulations of civilian agencies
for further investigation cr inquiry at this stage.

The head of the agency is responsible for reviewing the file
and the recommendations made. The extent of the review
may vary with the size of the operation supervised, the nature
of its security problem, and the personalities of the officials
involved. Again, there is no mention of any independent ques-
tioning. The officer may make one of three decisions. If he
finds that the continued employment of the individual is
“clearly consistent’’ with the national security, he will reinstate
the employee and compensate him for loss of earnings during
this period. There is no provision for compensation for the
expenses of defense.!*

If he finds that continued employment in the present posi-
tion is inadvisable, but that another position exists which the
employee could fill without danger to security, he may trans-
fer him to this job. This is to be distinguished from the tem-

17 The Justice Department requires the Deputy Attorney General, the
legal officer in security cases, to consider also the employee’s personnel
file. This, coupled with the lack of any reference in the Justice regula-
tions to other civil] service procedures, might indicate that suitability
cases are processed under security regulations.

18 The costs of defense may be high. The employee should have an
attorney. He may have to get copies of various records and documents.
He may take depositions and get affidavits. All this may be expensive,
and especially burdensome to a man who is suspended without pay.
Many employees, it is said, resign rather than fight charges, for financial
reasons.

23

porary reassignment pending administrative action which ‘s in
lieu of suspensicn. Permanent reassignment is at least a the-
oretical possibility in all agencies. The regulations emphasize
that reassignment, rather than removal, should be used when-
ever possible. There is little evidence of any widespread use.

If there is no position available, or if for any other reason
continued employment is not consistent with the security
standard, the employee is separated from the department. He
receives written notice of this decision from the administrative
officer or the Security Officer. There is no appeal. Civil Serv-
ice regulations for appeal of dismissal exc'!ude security cases.

Charges Preceding a Hearing

The employee entitled to a hearing receives, within thirty
days after suspension (as distinguished from “a reasonable
time”) a written “statement of charges.” These, like the
“reasons” which other employees get, are required to be as
detailed as security allows.

The employee may answer in writing, in refutation of the
charges. His documents are sent to the Legal Officer or the
Personnel Security Officer, both of whom again consider them
for “sufficiency.’”’'® The Post Office adds that if the Security
Officer and the Legal Officer are agreed on a favorable recom-
mendation, a hearing may be by-passed and the recommenda-
tion to close the case made to the Postmaster General. The
Justice Department makes a similar provision.

The Post Office, State, Treasury and Justice departments
state that the employee must request a hearing. Other agen-
cies make no mention of this. They say, following the Sample,
that a hearing ‘‘shall be given” but presumably one must ask
before it will be given.

Hearing Boards

Hearing boards are composed of government employees,
picked from a panel to hear a particular case. Agencies nom-
inate their own employees to a roster compiled by the Civil

Service Commission and draw from that roster employees of
other units when a board is needed. This procedure is a prod-

19 The Veterans Administration omits any reference to “sufficiency”
at this stage.

24

uct of the regulations; neither the statute nor the Executive
Order mention it.

In the Sample Regulations, nominations to the roster in the
Washington area are made by the agency’s Security Officer.
Health and the Veterans Administration reserve this function
to the head of the agency. The chief of a field office outside
Washington nominates to regional rosters, according to the
Sample. Many regulations are silent on this. The Post Office
gives still another power to the Security Officer; he makes
these field nominations also. The Treasury has the field heads
submit nominations at the request of the Personnel Security
Officer, who makes the final choice.

Nominees are required to be men of responsibility, ‘““unques-
tioned integrity” and sound judgment. They have had full
field investigations and no unresolved derogatory information
exists against them. The Treasury adds that no nominee may
be a security officer or an investigator. All nominations rust
be found to be “clearly consistent” with national security.

At least three members are chosen from this panel. None is
employed in the agency conducting the hearing.2° None may
be acquainted with the employee. The military selection dif-
fers, as will be shown. Sample Regulations call for the head
of the agency to make the selections frum the panel. The State
Department gives this task to the Administrator, Bureau of
Security and Consular Affairs. The Treasury places the au-
thority in the Legal Officer.

Of the agencies sampled, only the Treasury gives the em-
dloyee the right to challenge a member of the board. The
employee has one peremptory challenge and an unlimited num-
ber of challenges for cause. Rulings on chailenge are made by
the Legal Office which, of course, chooses the board in the first
place.

A cautionary note should be sounded at this point. The
regulations speak of “The Security Officer” or “The Legal
Officer” or “The Head of the Agency” performing a function.

2°It was hoped that this arrangement would eliminate personal
prejudice and cut down fear of reprisal from the Security Officer. In
defense of the older system in which each agency had its own board,
it is argued that outside boards may have little knowledge of the prob-
lems of the agency where they are sitting, and that security decisions
should consider the position of the employee.

25

This memorandum follows the terminology of the regulations.
It is impossible to ascertain from the regulations the degree
of delegation of authority that prevails. It is equally impos-
sible to determine the extent to which an individual Security
Officer or Legal Officer follows through the successive steps in
a given case.

Conduct of the Hearing

The Security Officer usually prepares the case against the
employee. The regulations call for the presence of a Legai
Officer at the hearing but what he does and whom he repre-
sents there vary among the agencies. The Sample Regulations
make him the representative of the head of the department.
He aids the board in procedure and legal matters and advises
the employee of his rights—but only on the request of the lat-
ter. This last duty is not his in the Justice Department. The
Treasury gives him the responsibility of assuring that both
sides are fully protected. He is repeatedly warned that he is
not a prosecutor and is not to act like one. Equally often it is
stated that the hearing is a fact-finding procedure and not a
trial.

The hearing is opened by reading the charges and the an-
swer, if any was made. The regulations instruct the Board to
insure the employee full and fair consideration. Before or
after the charges are read, varying with the agency, the Board
informs the employee of his right to participate in the hear-
ing, to have counsel, to offer witnesses or other evidence, to
cross-examine any adversary witnesses who may appear at the
hearing, and generally anything else the Board thinks he may
need to know.

The general order of the hearing is controlled by the Board.
The employee is allowed to control the sequence of presenta-
tion of his evidence. Generally, the agency presents its case
first; this is mandatory under Justice rules and customary in
other agencies. The department case is presented by the Per-
sonnel Security Officer.

The agency need never present a case; in practice, it rarely
does. The hearing board has access to the case file and must
consider it in reaching its decision. The Board may hear ex
parte testimony of witnesses of whose existence the employee

26

may be unaware. It may consider any documentary evidence
in the case—petitions bearing the employee’s signature, books,
articles and treatises he has written, previous testimony, etc.
A staternent that such evidence has been considered is included
in the transcript, out the evidence itself is not. The agency
may rest on the case it has built in the files; the hearing will
be treated as an opportunity for the employee to defend him-
self and for the Board to examine and judge him.

After the agency has made its presentation, if any is
made, the employee presents his case. He may call witnesses.
He may present documents. He may testify in his own be-
half. He gives his case in the sequence he thinks will be most
effective.
~ All witnesses who 2ppear at the hearing testify under oath.
However, statements in the file need not be under oath and
the board may hear testimony in executive session with or
without oath. The Board may call witnesses, but it is not
bound by their testimony and may cross-examine them. Even
if the agency has subpoena power, it is seldom used.” There
is no provision for witnesses’ expenses.

Technical rules of evidence are not binding; the Board de-
cides what it considers relevant to the issue. Study of tran-
scripts of hearings will show that questioning often goes to
political and economic beliefs, and that anything the Board
feels has a bearing on the ultimate issue may be brought up
whether or not it was contained in the charges.

The hearings are held in closed sessions. The Board is re-
sponsible for seeing that the hearing is conducted so that no
confidentia! information is disclosed to unauthorized persons.
Such information includes not only classified matter but
sources of information or methods of investigation. In Justice
Department hearings, the Security Officer confronts the em-
ployee only with evidence which in his discretion will not be
inconsistent with ‘or in any way compromise” security. The
Board is bound by his advice in all security matters in the
hearing. He may preclude pursuing a line of questioning if it
might divulge information to the employee.

—s

2: Most exceptionally, a few witnesses called by the A.E.C. in the
Oppenheimer case were under subpoena.

27

A verbatim report is made of the hearing. he transcript
contains the preliminary papers and the testimony given at the
hearing. The Sample Regulations stated that a copy vu. the
transcript could be had by the employee at “a reasonable cost”
but this provision was followed only by the Veterans Adminis-
tration and the Post Office. Generally, the employee gets a
copy free.

Decision and Review

The Board makes its decision on the basis of the fliie and
the hearing.??. Certain guides; are given for considering the
evidence. The Board is to take into account any handicap the
employee may have had through inability to meet charges of
which he was not told or to cross-examine or cast doubt on the
credibility of witnesses whose names were not disclosed. The
Board is also told that if a witness, not a “confidential in-
formant,” is called and does not appear, this can be considered;
so may the fact that there can be no payment for expenses.**

The State Department regulations, as a genera! guide for all
security decisions, establish two presumptions: a former course
of behavior is presumed to continue until the opposite is clearly
shown, and any doubts are to be resolved against the employee.

The decision is accompanied by a statement of reasons. Both
are submitted to the head of tne department or agency. They
are advisory only.

The Sample Regulations provided that the employee receive
a copy of the board decision (though not of the reasons). The
regulations of the Health Department omit this provision;
the regulations of the Post Office, Treasury and Justice Depart-
ments specifically provide against it. The State Department
does give the worker a notice of the decision. The Vet-
erans Administration gives the employee a statement of the
decision and further (within security restrictions) a state-
ment of the basic reasons for the decision. The Veterans Ad-

22The Justice Department provides that if the emplovee fails to
appear at the scheduled hearing, the Board will consider the case on
the record.

23 “Confidential informant” is never defined. It is not limited to FBI
undercover agents or similarly situated persons but may include anyone
who does not wish to be identified to the employee.

28

ministration does not elaborate on what this statement in-
cludes and how far beyond a general conclusion it would go.

The entire file, including the hearing record and the opin-
ion of the Board, is forwarded to the head of the agency. (The
Treasury Department sends the file though to the Security Of-
ficer and the Legal Officer for another review and recom-
mendation) ; he is supposed to review the entire case. There is
no provision for appeal by the employee nor for further in-
vestigation at this stage. A written decision is then made, to
reinstate, to transfer or to remove, and the employee is noti-
fied of this decision. The regulations do not indicate whether
th- ~gency head in fact delegates his review.**

There is no central review board, as there was under the
Loyaity Program. The Civil Service Commission is required
under the Executive Order to make a continuing study of the
manner in which the program is being operated, to look for
deficiencies in security protection and any tendency to deny
employees their rights. It is to report at least semi-annually
to the National Security Council, with recommendations for
revision or legislation. It also furnishes information about
any department deficiencies to the head of the department im-
mediately, for such correction as he might make. A small
unit in the Commission has been established for this function.
A central security investigations index is also maintained by
the Civil Service Commission.

In accordance with a presidential directive of 1948, all rec-
ords and files are to be kept fully confidential to preserve in-
formational sources and t» protect the employee. A subpoena
or other demand from a source other than the executive
branch is to be “respectfully declined” and referred to the
office of the President. Access to FBI raw files is given neither
to other executive agencies nor to the legislature.

Eligibility for Reappointment

Public Law 733 said that termination “shall not affect the
right . . . to seek or accept employment in any other depart-
ment or agcuncy of the government” provided that the Civil
Service Commission determine that the employee was eligible.

24 The Veterans Administration provides that the Administrator give,
with the notice, the basic reasons for the conclusion reached.

29

Since the law originally covered only selected agencies, such
reappointment was more of a possibility than it is now. The
Executive Order shifted the emphasis and added a require-
ment. The employee will not be appointed in the same or an-
other agency unless the Civii Service determines eligibility
and unless the head of the appointing agency finds that such
employment is consistent with the national security.

Il. MILITARY DEPARTMENTS

The military departments of the government operate three
security programs, one for civilian personnel, one for military
personnel and one fer industrial facilities and their personnel.
These programs are not based on the same authority. They
do not cover the same areas nor deal with the same problems.
Yet, they are alike in spirit, in standards and in procedure.

CIVILIAN PERSONNEL

The program for civilian personnel operates under Public
Law 733 and Executive Orde: 10450. In 1953, the Defense
departments employed 1,148,745 out of a total Federal Gov-
ernment employment of 2,302,932.744

The Defense Department issued a genera! directive and the
constituent departments issued regulations governing their
own forces. The regulations are highly detailed. They pre-
scribe administrative steps far more elaborately than civilian
agency regulatious do. Military channels are carefully pre-
served. Nonetheiess, the programs are basically the same as
those under which civilian agencies operate and only the dif-
ferences need be emphasized.

Criteria
The Defense Directive criteria include all those of Executive
Order 10450 but add these refinements:

“8. Participation in the activities of an organization es-
tablished as a front for an organization referred to
in subparagraph 5 above [subversive organizations |
when his personal views were sympathetic to the
subversive purposes of such organization.

“9. Participation in the activities of an organization with

24a The Defense Department includes the departments of the Army,
Navy and Air Force and the Office of the Secretary of Defense.

10.

“Eee

“12.

13.

“14,

15.

“16

wy |

30

knowledge that it had been infiltrated by members of
subversive groups under circumstances indicating
that the individual was a part of or sympathetic to
the infiltrating element or sympathetic to its pur-
poses.

Participation in the activities of an organization, re-
ferred to in subparagraph 5 above, in a capacity
where he should reasonably have had knowledge of
the subversive aims or purposes of the organization.
Sympathetic interest in totalitarian, Fascist, Com-
munist, or similar subversive movements.
Sympathetic association with a member or members
of an organization referred to in subparagraph 5
above.

(Ordinarily this will not include chance or occasional
meetings, nor contacts limited to normal business or
official relations. )

Currently maintaining a close continuing association
with a person who has engaged in activities or asso-
ciation; of the type referred to in subparagraphs 2
through 11 above. A close continuing association
may be deemed to exist if the individual lives at the
same premises as, frequently visits, or frequently
communicates with such person.

Close continuing association of the type described in
subparagraph 13 above, even though later separated
by distance, if the circumstances indicate that re-
newal of the association is probable.

The presence of a spouse, parent, brother, sister or
offspring in a nation whose interests may be inimical
to the interests of the United States or in satellites
or occupied areas of such a nation, under circum-
stances permitting coercion or pressure to be brought
on the individual through such relatives.

Willful violation or disregard of security regulations.

Acts of a reckless, irresponsible or wanton nature
which indicates such poor judgment and instability
as to suggest that the individual might disclose se-
curity information to unauthorized persons or other-
wise assist such persons, whether deliberately or
inadvertently, in activities inimical to the security
of the United States.”

Items (8) to (14) may be considered as an elaboration of
paragraph (5) of Executive Order 10450, sec. 8, or perhaps
they create independent grounds for rvjection. (15) is the

31

classic example of 1(v), the pressure risk. Making it a sepa-
rate category may divorce it from the limitation of (1) that it
be weighed according to the position of the employee. (17) can
be encompassed in i(i), but the separate expansion may in-
dicate some special import to the Defense Department. (16)
merely makes a separate class of what was a phrase of (6)
in the Executive Order.

The directive recognizes that because of this enumeration
and elaboration on the basic criteria, all the classes are not of
the same “seriousness.” The regulations of the military de-
partments do not follow these criteria precisely, but the varia-
tions are unimportant.

The departments do not limit subversive groups to those on
the Attorney General’s list. That list is set forth in the loyalty
certificate for military personnel and the similar certificate of
non-affiliation for civilian personnel; but the employee is ap-
parently expected to disclose any subversive affiliation, whether
or not the organization is on the list. Failure to disclose mem-
bership is itself grounds for charges. The list is posted con-
spicuously at all military establishments.

The regulations, furthermore, specifically indicate that non-
listed organizations may be considered, though the Air Force
notes that the Attorney General has advised that “mere”
membership, affiliation or association with an organization
not designated by him should not be considered relevant un-
less the department obtains and makes available to the adjudi-
sator the Attorney General’s views on the organization. There
S no indication, however, that other departments follow this
idvice. The Navy permits the citing of organizations men-
jioned by other government agencies if there is information
ivailable sufficient to evaluate it.

The military regulations all refer to the Attorney General’s
itatement that membership in an organization is only one
actor to be considered. The Navy and the Air Force counsel
he adjudicator to consider the employee’s reasons for join-
ng the group and his knowledge of its purposes.

The Defense directive quite clearly states that these regu-
ations should be limited to true security cases. Maximum use
5 to be made of normal civil service removal when security is

32

not a consideration and the procedure is adequate and appro-
priate. This is repeated by the constituent units. However,
both the Army and the Navy indicate the reverse implications
of this provision. If the information is not of a status to sus-
tain civil service action, it will be processed under security
regulations. The Navy adds that action may be taken through
suitability procedures even if the security decision was favor-
able.

Categories of Sensitive Positions.

The Defense directive distinguishes three types of position,
two sensitive and one non-sensitive. The definition of “sensi-
tive” is not changed. However, a separate category is estab-
lished, consisting of those responsible for war plans and pol-
icies, for over-all defense programs, and certain other censi-
tive positions. The Army calls this top sensitive classifica-
tion “‘sensitive-critical’’ and includes in addition to those men-
tioned all having access to Top Secret classified matter, all
grades above GS-14, and all members of screening and appeals
boards. The Navy includes in top sensitive all having access
to any classified matter. The bottom sensitive group consists
of all other positions which are designated sensitive.

The Air Force has three sensitive levels—the war plan level,
a second level including those with access to Top Secret,
cryptographic or security clearance material, and a third level
which includes those having access to Secret or Confidential
matter, those training personnel, and those in public relations.
Included also in this lowest level are those working in areas
which contain classified matter (but who are without author-
ized access to it), and who have a real opportunity to commit
sabotage or espionage.

It was brought out in hearings of the Senate Committee on
Armed Services, July 15, 1954, that some incumbent em-
ployees and all applicants for Army employment are now re-
quired to execute a certificate of non-affiliation with certain
organizations. Incumbents in sensitive positions must sign. If
they refuse or invoke the Fifth Amendment, they are deemed
a security risk. Applicants for any position not exempted from
investigation must fill out this form. If they refuse or invoke

33

the Fifth Amendment, they are denied employment. If they
complete the forms and the information given raises a security
question, appointment will not be made prior to a national
agency check.

Investigations

Investigation in the military departments, as in civilian ones,
starts from the personnel forms and varies in intensity with
the sensitivity of the position filled and the nature of the in-
formation developed. Non-sensitive appointments are, as in
civil agencies, made subject to agency check and written in-
quiry. The Army excepts appointments under six months and
aliens employed overseas. The Air Force regulations require
only a check of employees references and local agencies for
temporary or seasonal employees under three months. If
derogatory information is developed in any of these cases, the
investigation is extended.

The top sensitive appointments are made only after the
completion of what the defense departments call a “back-
ground” investigation, which is approximately the equivalent
of a full-field investigation.» An emergency appointment may
be made but at least a satisfactory national agency check
must first be completed. A national agency check is required
before appointment to other sensitive jobs and the appointment
is subject to the satisfactory completion of the background in-
vestigation. In emergency, the position may be filled by one
on whom no check has been made. The Air Force regulations
are substantially similar but a lot more intricate.

Incumbents of sensitive positions are subject to full field in-
vestigation but may continue to occupy their positions pend-
ing completion. The Air Force requires only a national agency
check for the lowest sensitive group of incumbents. The Army
allows past investigation to suffice for present clearance if it
meets the present requirements. Of course, under the Ex-
ecutive Order, cases previously investigated are re-adjudicated
by the present standard. The Defense departments operated

——_

25 A neighborhood investigation is not generally made except to prove
or disprove derogatory information developed in other ways.

A great emphasis is placed in background investigation on citizenship
Status and on foreign travel and connections.

34

both loyalty and security programs during the Truman admin-
istration so that this provision should have little practical
effect.

The Directive is silent on procedure; it refers the depart-
ments to Public Law 733. As the regulations were developed,
each department uses three levels of boards, a security screen-
ing board at a pre-charge stage, a hearing board, as required
by the statute, and a review board, which affords the employee
an appeal after hearing, a development peculiar to the military
departments.

Disposition of Applicants

The civilian agencies, it will be remembered, have no formai-
ized procedure by which an applicant can appeal. The situa-
tion under the armed forces regulations is more difficult to
ascertain and the practice is not uniform.

The Army is silent on this point. There are detailed direc-
tions for handling the files after a determination has been
made, but no hint of what happens before. The Navy provides
that all cases in which an FBI full field investigative report is
received are referred to the activity Screening Board. This
would include all cases in which derogatory information deal-
ing with subversion was developed. A Screening Board may
request furthe.’ investigation, an interview, etc. These pow-
ers are given to the Board in all cases; hence, they are avail-
able when the Board handles an application. The Board
makes a recommendation to the head of the activity who makes
the final decision. There is no appeal from this decision.

The Air Force states that the appropriate military Com-
mand on receiving the investigative report may decide that
the applicant should not be appointed. If, notwithstanding
the presence of derogatory information, he feels the appoint-
ment should be made, he may do so if it is to a non-sensitive
position. If the position is sensitive, the case must be proc-
essed. Whatever the determination, all reports of derogatory
information are forwarded to the Central Security Board, with
a statement of the action taken. The Security Board reviews
all cases, may issue interrogatories, have investigation made,
etc. It may in its discretion grant a hearing to the applicant.

35

Evaluation of Reports—Army

Derogatory reports come to the installation or command of
the Army. A decision is made whether to continue employ-
ment. Additional investigation may be made. Suspension
occurs at this point only if security warrants it. The file is
forwarded to major command headquarters, within three days
if the employee has been suspended. The major command
makes a determination and a recommendation and forwards
to the command echelon or G-2, depending on the position of
the command. The head of the service of the Army having
command will review, make recommendations, and forward
to G-2.%6

G-2 will then review. It may make further investigation,
issue interrogatories, return the case to the major command
for an interview with the employee, or recommend suspension
or revocation of clearance, if this has not already been accom-
plished. If the decision is to end employment, the case is sent
to the Screening Board which is in the Office of the Secretary
of the Army. A recommendation and rationale accompany
the file and if the recommendation is adverse, a suggested list
of charges is included. The Board reviews the case and makes
a recommendation to the Secretary. It, too, may prepare inter-
rogatories, direct an interview or further investigate. If the
recommendation is favorable, G-2 may concur. If it dissents
a detailed rationale for non-concurrence is required. If the
recommendation is unfavorable and approved by the Secretary,
the Board draws up the charges.

Evaluation—Air Force

The Air Force procedure is similar. Reports are transmitted
to the Commander through the Director of Special Investiga-
tions, who also forwards a copy to the Central Security Board.
He may recommend to the latter that the employee be sus-
pended before sending the file to the installation.

The Commander makes his determination. If it is to retain,
he so states with reasons. He may suspend. However, interim
action, such as a change or a restriction of duty, is preferred.

26 At any time before a letter of charges is issued, the commander
may end suspension. Only the Secretary of the Army may authorize
payments for the suspension period.

36

Before suspending, “to avoid unwarranted or premature sus-
pensions” and to “ensure the orderly processing of cases’’ the
Commander must contact the Executive Secretary, Civilian
Personnel Security Program, at Headquarters in Washington.
If the employee is suspended, he receives a copy of the regu-
lations and is told he will get charges or instructions from the
Board. At the time he is suspended, the Executive Secretary
must be notified, a description of the position occupied for-
warded, and a statement made why interim action is not suffi-
cient to safeguard security. Whatever action is taken, the
file is forwarded, with the recommendation, to Special Investi-
gations at Washington. It must contain information as to
whether it is practicable to reassign the worker to another,
non-sensitive position on a permanent basis.

The Director submits this file with his recommendations to
the Central Security Board, with a summary of facts.27 The
Board reviews the case, making investigation or interrogation
as needed. It may recommend favorable finding, further in-
vestigation, processing to removal or other administrative
proceedings.

The Board may direct suspension or it may restore a sus-
pended employee to duty. It is required to take into considera-
tion not only the usual security needs but “the fact that an
unwarranted or premature suspension may result in needless
effort or embarrassment on the part of the employee or the
Air Force.” If it decides adversely to the worker, it will pre-
pare charges and a notice informing him of his rights. Nor-
mally, suspension occurs at this time.

Evaluation—Navy

The Army and Air Force have central screening boards
which act as a check over the Commander’s decision. The
Navy puts greater power in the hands of the Commander. A
screening board is appointed by the head of each activity and
handles only the cases of that activity.2* In small activities
the Commander may dispense with the board.

27 This Board has at least three members. One is from the Inspector
General's office, one from Personnel, and one from Judge Advocate or
the General Counsel's office.

28 This is composed of three employees of the activity. Preferably,
two should be civilians.

37

The board, if one exists, reviews all cases in which a full
fieid report is received and 2ll cases formerly adjudicated
under 9835. It may direct further investigation. It may re-
quest advice on the reliability of confidential informants from
the FBI. To clarify minor points prior to recommendation,
the employee, if he so desires, may be given written interroga-
tories. These are not to be used to confront the individual
with seriously derogatory information. The Board may inter-
view any local personnel, including the employee. It makes
a recommendation to the activity head but he makes the deci-
sion. However, if he disagrees with the board, he must in-
clude his rationale in the file.

Disposition Without Hearing

The Navy states that an appointee, defined as an employee
who has not completed twelve months of government service,
may be separated administratively. Administrative separa-
tion is not defined; it would presumably have to meet the re-
quirements of Public Law 733, however. An “incumbent” who
is an employee past probation period is furnished with charges.

The Army gives in a six-line paragraph the procedure ap-
plicable to the employee not entitled to a hearing. Cases of
appointments of under a year are not ordinarily processed
through security regulations. Their contracts are simply not
renewed and no reference is made to security in the termina-
tion. The undefined status of the Navy appointee has been
indicated.

The Air Force is as brief as the Army on these cases. How-
ever, it allows all employees and even applicants hearings at
the discretion of the Central Security Board. The regulations
suggest that a hearing should normally be granted.

Hearings; Boards

If a hearing is requested, a board is convened. The Army
provides that the Executive Secretary of the hearing board
will schedule a hearing even if no request is made and the
employee will be notified of the time and place. The Navy
provides that if no reply is made, the head of the activity will

38

consider the case, no presumption being made against the em
ployee for failure to respond. This would seem a formal step
the Commander has just decided to suspend and no new in
formation has arisen. If there is a reply, but nu hearing i
requested, the head will consider the case. He may, in his dis
cretion, schedule a hearing, again with no presumptions draw
if the employee fails to appear. The Air Force forwards th
file, with or without answer, through the Review Board if n
hearing is requested.

If an Army employee requests a hearing, the Executiv:
Secretary of the hearing board will review the file. If hi
opinion is favorable, an advisory panel of the Board will b
named. If it concurs, it may meet formally in executive ses
sion and submit a recommendation to the Office of the Secre
tary, Administrative Assistant. The employee will be give
no notice of this nearing unless he should happen to inquire

By an agreement approved by the Department of Justice
the military departments supply each other with hearing boar
personnel. In the Washington area, an official roster is kep
by the Defense Department. In continental United State:
and the territories, the boards are also drawn from the othe:
military departments. Overseas, and in isolated areas any
where, boards are taken from the employees of the installatior
and may therefore be composed of members of the same de
partment as the employee being heard. Board members are
chosen from the highest ranking personnel available.

The boards are composed of military and civilian personnel
A majority must be civilian. The Army and Navy provide fo.
an Executive Secretary of the Hearing Board who is in charge
of all administrative details of the hearing. The Executive
Secretary is a civilian employee, appointed by the Commander

The composition of the Board will vary from case to case but
the Secretary is permanent. The regulations require that, ii
possible, he be someone who was connected with the old loyalty
security program. He must meet the background investigatior
qualifications of the Board but not the grade requirements
The Executive Secretary in the Army selects the Board for the

39

hearing. In the Navy, he does the same in the name oi the
activity head.”*

Each member of the Board studies the file prior to the hear-
ing. The Air Force warns them that this is only one side of
the case and judgment must be reserved. The Naval Board
may consult with Intelligence on the reliability of confidential
informants and the method by which information. is obtained.
They must be informed of the nature of each organization
which may figure in the case.

Conduct of Hearings

The departments provide for a Legal Advisor to aid the
Board in examination and in procedure. The Air Force pro-
vides that if the employee appears without counsel the Legal
Advisor is to inform him of his rights and aid him in points
of procedure. This does not relieve the Board of its duty to
advise. The Navy states also that if the government has an
attorney handling the case, he may “xamine in aid of the
Board. The Army has an optional JAG representative and a
Security Advisor to the Board. The latter may question only
through the Board.

In most essentials, the hearings do not vary from civilian
agency hearings. ‘The regulations are a good deal more de-
tailed, however. Instruction is given in how to weigh evidence,
what to consider, etc.*° The boards are warned in general

2° The Executive Secretary maintains liaison with the Civil Service
Commission and the other military establishments in the area to ensure
that a panel is currently available. He takes care of travel orders for
the members of the board, transmits invitations to witness. s, arranges
the physical and temporal details of the hearing, gets clerical aid to
the Board, makes sure files don’t go astray, sends them along to the next
stage, etc.

In the Air Force, the Board sets the time and place for hearing.

30 The Navy instructs that documentary evidence is accepted as
reliable unless the employee furnishes clear proof to the contrary. A
denial raises a question of credibility.

In evaluating a witness’ testimony, the Board is to consider how well
he knew the employee, that their relation was, when he knew him, and
any motive he might have for testifying.

The demeanor of the employee, his evasiveness or cooperation, the
consistency of his current answers with past representations are fac-
tors. Misrepresentation is itself grounds for dismissal.

The Air Force cautions that derogatory information is to be weighed
by recency, relative seriousness, the attendant circumstances, the rele-
vancy to the charges, the supporting independent information, whether
it was given under oath, and the opportunity the employee had to rebut.

40

to protect confidential sources and are specifically told not to
ask questions which might reveal information. They are also
warned away from irrelevant questioning and constitutional
arguments.

It is standard practice in the military departments to send
an invitation to all witnesses who have given adverse informa-
tion and who have not indicated that their identity was to be
kept confidential. A witness may testify at the hearing or in
private before the Board. He is asked if his statement or his
name may be given to the employee. If he does not appear,
his testimony may still be used, but his non-appearance should
be weighed. There is the usual provision about taking into
account the employee’s handicap by non-disclosure.

Decision, Review and Appeal

The Board then makes a finding, a decision in writing and a
memorandum of reasons. The Air Force regulations require
a finding to each allegation and an analysis of the information
and the reason for the finding. The Air Force further pro-
vides that the Board may advise reassignment if there is a
suitable vacancy and the Commander appreves.

The file is forwarded to Washington for post-hearing review
and appeal procedure. The Army and Air Force Boards review
all cases; the Navy Board considers appeals and other cases
on its own motion. The employee may file briefs or papers
when the decision of either board is adverse. All review boards
consider additional written evidence and briefs.

The review boards make a recommendation to the Secre-
tary, who makes the decision. A favorable decision acts as a
clearance for the employee to have access to classified informa-
tion on a need-to-know basis. The provisions for lost pay, the
prohibition against rehiring, the reports to the Civil Service
Commission, the confidential nature of the files, are covered
sketchily, but the provisions of the Executive Order apply.*'
The Navy Department will on inquiry about an employee sep-

81If the employee resigns while charges are being processed, his
records will bear this notation.

The Army provides that once the employee is suspended and charges
have been made, separation under other procedures, such as reduction
in force, is held in abeyance,

41

arated for security reasons state only that he was separated
for unsuitability.

MILITARY PERSONNEL

Security programs for military personnel have been in
operation for more than six years. In 1948, a joint memoran-
dum of the departments forbade the enlistment or appoint-
ment into the armed forces, without the approval of the de-
partment, of one who “admits” or is otherwise believed to have
engaged in disloyal or subversive activities. In 1949, another
memorandum ordered that inductees who refused to execute
loyalty oaths and others suspected of subversion were to be
denied access to classified material and to be kept on duty
under surveillance. A system of discharging security risks
developed, with no statutory authorization other than the gen-
eral disciplinary powers of the armed forces.

The public was informed of some of the mechanics of the
system at the hearings of the Senate Committee on Armed
Service to revise the Doctor Draft law, March and April of
1954. The Department of Defense then issued a public memo-
randum. Pursuant to this, the military departments released
revised regulations in 1954.

Criteria
The criteria adopted by Defense for military personnel are
substantially the same as the criteria applied to civilians,*?

32 The Defense Department criteria are:

“a. Commission of any act of sabotage, espionage, treason or
sedition, or attempts thereat or preparation therefor, or con-
spiring with or aiding or abetting another to commit or at-
tempt to commit any act of sabotage, espionage, treason, or
sedition.

b. Establishing or continuing a sympathetic association with a
saboteur, spy, traitor, seditionist, anarchist, or revolutionist,
or with an espionage or other secret agent or representative
of a foreign nation, or any representative of a foreign nation
whose interests are inimical to the interests of the United
States, or with any person who advocates the use of force
or violence to overthrow the Government of the United States
or the alteration of the form of Government of the United
States by unconstitutional means.

c. Advocacy of use of force or violence to overthrow the Gov-
ernment of the United States, or of the alteration of the form
of Government of the United States by unconstitutional
means.

42

except that they omit “sympathetic interest” in subversive
movements (short of membership). The suitability criteria
are included; but it is directed that they be processed under
non-security procedures if not combined with security cri-

d. Membership in, or affiliation or sympathetic association with,
any foreign or domestic organization, association, movement,
group, or combination of persons which is totalitarian, Fascist,
Communist, or subversive, or which has adopted or shows a
policy of advocating or approving the commission of acts of
force or violence to deny other persons their rights, under
the Constitution of the United States, or which seeks to alter
the form of Government of the United States by unconstitu-
tional means. (An organization, movement. or group officially
designated by The Attorney General of the United States to
be totalitarian, Fascist, Communist, or subversive, to advocate
or approve forcible or violent denial of Constitutional rights,
or to seek alteration of the form of Government of the United
States by unconstitutional means, shall be presumed to be of
a character thus designated until the contrary be established.)

e. Performing or attempting to perform his duties, or other-
wise acting, so as to serve the interest of another government
in preference to the interests of the United States.

f. Failure or refusal to sign loyalty certificate DD Form 98;
pleading protection o1 the Fifth Amendment or of Article 31,
Uniform Code of Military Justice, in refusing to completely
answer questions contained in DD Forms 98, 390, or 398;
pleading protection of the Fifth Amendment or of Article 31,
Uniform Code of Military Justice, or otherwise failing or
refusing to answer any pertinent question propounded in the
course of an official investigation, interrogation, or examina-
tion, conducted for the purpose of ascertaining the existence
or extent, or both, of conduct of the nature described in a
through e above, and g through m below.

g. Participation in the activities of an organization as a front
for an organization referred to in d above, when his personal
views were sympathetic to the subversive purposes of such
organization.

h. Participation in the activities of an organization with knowl-
edge that it had been infiltrated by members of subversive
groups under circumstances indicating that the individual
was a part of, or sympathetic to, the infiltrating element or
sympathetic to its purposes.

i. Participation in the activities of an organization referred
to in d above, in a capacity where he shculd reasonably have
had knowledge of the subversive aims or purposes of the
organization.

j. Sympathetic association with a member or members of an
organization referred to in d above.

k. Currently maintaining a close continuing association with
a person who has engaged in activities or associations of the
type referred to in a through i above. A close continuing
association may be considered to exist if the individual lives
at the same address as, frequently visits, or frequently com-
municates with such perscn.

43

teria.** The Defense Department regards violation of security
regulations as a matter of discipline rather than of security
and includes it in this second category. The constituent de-
partments made no departures from these criteria.

Volunteers

The Defense directive states that no one reasonably believed
to have engaged in any of the listed activities at any time may
be appointed or enlisted in the armed forces without the ap-
proval of the secretary of the department. A volunteer fills
out the standard loyalty certificate (DD 98) to which is at-
tached a list of the organizations on the Attorney General’s
compilation. In addition to general questioning about sub-
versive activities, the certificate requires one to indicate the
extent of his participation in any named organization, includ-
ing not only membership but attending meetings or social
patherings which the organization sponsored. If the form is
not completed, the aprtication is denied. If from the form or
otherwise, there is reason to believe the applicant is ineligible

—

1. Close continuing association of the type described in k above,
even though later separated by distance, if the circumstances
indicate that renewal of the association is probable.

m. Any facts, other than as set forth in 2 below, which furnish
reason to believe that the individual may be subjecte. to
eoercicn, influence, or pressure which may cause him to act
contrary to the best interests of national security. Among
matters which should be considered in this category would
be the presence of a spouse, parent, brother, sister, or off-
spring in a nation, a satellite thereof, or an occupied area
thereof, whose interests are inimical] to the interests of the
United States

Category (2). which is normatiy processed under other regulations.

a. Willful violation or disregard of security regulations.

b. Intentional unauthorized disclosure to any person of classified
information, or of other information disclosure of which is
prohibited by law.

c. Any deliberate misrepresentation, falsification, or omission
of material fact.

d. Any criminal, infamous, dishonest, immoral] or notoriously
disgraceful conduct, habitual use of intoxicants to excess,
drug addiction, or sexual perversion.

e. All other behavior, activities, or associations which tend to
show that the member is not reliable or trustworthy.”

33 The Defense directive states that the security regulations are an
idministrative procedure which does not preclude trial by court-martial
when appropriate or separation on non-security grounds.

The Air Force requires the Commander, when recommending suspen-
‘ion, to state that other action w.is considered and found inappropriate.

Ad

under the criteria, the case will be forwarded to a designated
personnel or security officer for processing. There is no appeal.
The volunteer serviceman has a position like that of the appli-
cant for civilian employment.

Reserve officers going on active duty must also complete the
form. If the entries made give rise to a security question, and
he is a volunteer, the army will treat him like other volunteers;
if he is involuntarily recalled, his case will be processed through
the channels to be described below. The Air Force processes
both types of reservists through regular procedures.

The N ivy will make an interim assignment and an investiga-
tion. It may put the suspect reservist in active duty, court-
martial him when appropriate, or release him. If the disclo-
sure or refusal was made with intent to avoid duty, the Navy
may retain him on restricted activities and subject him to dis-
cipline for this act under the Uniform Code of Military Jus-
tice.**

Conscripts

The conscript and the drafted doctor raise major new prob-
lems. Civilian personnel and volunteers, it will be recalled,
are retained only if retention is “clearly consistent” with na-
tional security. There is, however, some danger of draft-
dodging. The military fear that a person subject to call may
refuse to execute the certificate or fabricate derogatory infor-
mation to avoid service. Hence the milder standard applied
to the inductee, which reverses the emphasis of the civilian
standard: the conscript will be retained unless there is suffi-
cient derogatory information to require discharge. The other
novel element in this situation is that the conscript’s involve-
ment with a security program is involuntary.

Inductees are now required to complete the loyalty certifi-
cate before entering the service. A known Communist or sub-
versive will not be inducted. If the inductee refuses to execute
the certificate or reveals significant derogatory information,
he is accepted and, pending investigation, is retained in the
lowest enlisied pay grade in a non-sensitive position. There

84 A national agency check is now made of al) officer candidates and
reservists considered for recall.

45

can, however, be no permanent assignment to such restricted
duties without adjudication under these regulations.

If the inductee refused to execute the certificate and if inves-
tigation and processing reveal that retention is inconsistent
with national security, he will be discharged with an undesira-
ble discharge. If there is derogatory information insufficient
to require discharge, he will be retained in service under con-
trolled conditions and the ultimate discharge will be based on
the service he has rendered.

If investigation shows that retention is inadvisable hut no
information is developed which the individual did not reveal
on his questionnaire, he will be given a discharge commen-
surate with the services rendered. If there is less serious
derogatory information, he will be retained in whatever as-
signment is appropriate, and the discharge will be based on
behavior in service.

A slight variation is involved in the special draft of doctors
and dentists. Those who fail or refuse to meet the security
standards are denied 2 commission. They are referred to
selective service for induction as enlisted personnel. An inves-
tigation and a determination will be made within ninety days
if possible and in every case within six monihs. If the indi-
vidual is held a security risk, he will be released with a dis-
charge so stating, unless the fact causing this determination
is beyond his control. If no risk is involved, he will be offered
his commission if otherwise qualified. If there is doubt, he will
be retained in enlisted status and used in his professional ca-
pacity under security restrictions.

_ Types of Discharge; Retention in Contro'led Duties

It has hitherto been the policy of the armed forces that
discharge should reflect only the quality of behavior in the
service. There are five classes of discharge, for other than
physical or mental reasons: honorable, general,**> undesirable,
bad conduct, and dishonorable. The honorable, the general

35 The general discharge is given for the same reasons as an honora-
ble discharge. The conduct is satisfactory but not sufficient for an
honorable discharge.

The genera] discharge may also be granted when separation is for
inaptitude and unsuitability.

46

and the undesii able are administrative discharges; only a
court-martial can give a bad conduct or dishonorable discharge.
A regular officer, with over three years’ service, can be given
a discharge under other than honorable conditions only by
sentence of a court-martial. Doubt as to retention is to be
resolved against the serviceman; doubt as to the type of dis-
charge is to be resolved in his favor.

All officers and warrant officers are deemed to hold sensitive
positions by virtue of their commission, regardless of their
assignment. Non-commissioned officers are generally consid-
ered sensitive. Any position which requires access to classified
information is of course sensitive. Hence, the serviceman who
is retained in controlled conditions because there is derogatory
information insufficient to warrant discharge is likely to be
held to the lowest level of military life.

Investigation and Evaluation

Investigations for the Army are conducted by Army staff
and instituted at the major command level for military person-
nel. When a report is made on information raising security
implications, the commander makes a recommendation to the
major command and takes any action necessary to protect
security in the meanwhile. At this point, the commander will
also institute what is known as “flagging” procedure. AI offi-
cial personnel files are marked to show that action is being
taken by intelligence personnel which would preclude favorable
action or change without the prior approval of the Depart-
ment.**

When investigation is completed, a recommendation will be
made to the major command. The case may be closed favor-
ably by the major command. If an unfavorable determina-
tion is made, the recommendation is forwarded to the Secur-
ity Division of G-2.

G-2 may direct an interview or further investigation; inter-
rogatories to the serviceman are frequently issued by G-2. The
case may be closed favorably or recommendation may be made
for removal or restriction procedures. The case is then sent
to a screening board of field officers. This board, too, can

86 The Air Force has a similar practice.

47

recommend further investigation, court martial, elimination,
discharge under other regulations, or retention in controlled
duties. A favorable recommendation is sent to the Review
Board. If a recommendation to discharge or hold in controlled
duties is made, a Letter of Allegations is prepared and deliv-
ered. The parallel to the stages of civilian personnel proce-
dure is clear—the command, the major command, the board at
the department level.*’

In the Air Force, derogatory information coming to the
Commander is sent on for investigation, interim action being
taken if needed. On receipt of the investigative report, the
Commander makes a determination. He may close the case,
if the decision is favorable, or he may recommend removal.

All cases, including those of inductees and applicants, are
reviewed by the Director of Special Investigations and then
by the Military Personnel Security Committee.** The Com-
mittee may interrogate or request further investigation. It
then makes its recommendation. If favorable, the case is
closed. If not, a notice and a statement of reasons is deliv-
ered. Here, too, the channels parallel the civilian personnel
process.

The Navy channels are more difficult to follow. Initial
processing of all cases, including applicants, may be by the
Chief of Naval Personnel or a Bureau or Headquarters Secur-
ity Board. The Board is composed of three or more officers
who “variously function as initial, intermediate, or final ad-
ministrative processing bodies, and as intermediate and final
review boards.” It makes a recommendation to the Chief of
Personnel who in turn makes the decision.

If the determination is adverse, the Chief will obtain from
Intelligence a narrative statement of fact as disclosed by the
investigation; written interrogatories are drafted to allow the
individual to explain or refute the charges of the narrative.

87 The Defense directive and the regulations warn that action to warn
suspects must be avoided. Before processing under these regulations
Intelligence must be consulted. If processing would endanger another
current investigation, the serviceman wil] be retained for the time.

88 This is composed of three officers, a colonel and two lieutenant-
colonels. One is from Judge Advocate, one from Provost Marshal, and
the third from Personnel.

48

Charges and Hearing

When charges are delivered, the serviceman has the option
to retire (if he is eligible) or to apply for a discharge; but he
must agree to accept an undesirable discharge. The final
nature of the discharge is in the discretion of the service; it
may be under honorable conditions; it may not. The Navy
allows a statement to be submitted showing why a higher dis-
charge should be granted.

Alternatively, the serviceman may answer the charges in
writing and request a hearing before a board. The period for
answering is short, not more than fifteen days. The Navy is
strict in granting extensions, the Air Force, liberal.**

Army and Air Force field boards are composed of field
grade officers, all senior in temporary and permanent rank to
the serviceman. The Navy requires only that they all be
officers. If the defendant is in the reserves, the Army requires
one, and the Air Force and Navy a majority, of the Board,
to be reserve. If the defendant is a woman, a woman officer
sits, but (in the Air Force) only in an advisory, non-voting
capacity.

The serviceman is furnished military counsel if he desires.
He may have civilian counsel, at his own expense. The Board
will aid in procuring witnesses, if he needs assistance. The
atmosphere is nonetheless more adversary than at a civilian
hearing. The order of presentation is more rigid and like a
trial; the Navy specifically grants opening, rebuttal and clos-
ing to the recorder who presents the department’s case. In
most other respects, the civilian and military hearings are the
same.

Decision and Review

The Board then makes a finding, in detail, with an opinion.
It recommends what action is to be taken, advising as to reten-
tion or discharge and the type of discharge. The Army, with
the problem of the inductees, adds the alternative of retention
in controlled condition. The Air Force allows the lowest grades

89 The Navy will grant extension only for serious illness or for unique
evidence and other extraordinary circumstances.

49

of airmen to be retained and assigned to non-sensitive posi-
tions.*®

The convening authority in the Navy may review the rec-
ord and return the case to the board for revision or clarifica-
tion. He may not direct new findings. He then transmits the
file to the Chief of Personnel who sends it for further review
to a Bureau or Headquarters Security Board. Final decision
is usually made by the Chief. However, he may forward it to
the Secretary of the Navy to determine, with or without a fur-
ther review by a Department of the Navy Security Board.
This Board is to be consulted only when there is dispute
among members of other boards and/or other authorities.

The Army and Air Force inform the serviceman that he
may further appeal his case by brief, arguments and addi-
tional evidence. The Review Boards may request further in-
formation and may call the defendant to appear. The .irmy
Review Board then directs action. The Air Force has a legal
review by the Judge Advocate General and a decision by the
Secretary. If the decision is favorable to the serviceman, he
is cleared for the position and for the access to classified mate-
rial it requires. Clearance is for the job involved and not
merely for retention in service.

If the decision is to discharge the serviceman, the discharge
is based on the gravity of the reasonably substantiated deroga-
tory information, whatever the character of the services ren-
dered. If the serviceman is a conscript who revealed fully
derogatory information on the loyalty certificate he will re-
ceive a discharge based on the service rendered. Doubt as to
the nature of the discharge is to be resolved in favor of dis-
charge under honorable conditions.

In each department, there is a Board of Review of Dis-
charge and Dismissals and a Board of Correction of Military
Records. Neither operates under the Uniform Code of Mil-
itary Justice nor under the security regulations. They are,
however, available for security cases. The boards of dis-
charge review are composed of civilian officials chosen by the

+

40 Indefinite assignment to these controlled positions needs the ap-
proval of the Secretary. It cannot be extended beyond the current
term of enlistment. The serviceman may not re-enlist without depart-
ment permission.

50

Secretary of the constituent departments. They meet at
Washington, unless otherwise designated. They do not re-
view courts martial. They handle administrative discharges,
on appeal or on their own motion. An appellant may appear
in person or by counsel. The boards cannot revoke a dis-
charge, but they can amend its nature.

When any proceedings—dismissal or rejection—are taken
under these regulations, the Civil Service Commission and the
Federal Bureau of Investigation are notified. Thus, future
employment in government or defense is unlikely. There are
the usual provisions for secrecy of files.4! The Defense De-
partment gives no access even to other departments with se-
curity programs without the prior approval of the appropriate
secretary.

The separated serviceman is not allowed to re-enlist without
the approval of the Secretary of the department. If his dis-
charge is an undesirable one, he will be limited in the benefits
which, as an ex-serviceman, he would otherwise receive.

DEFENSE CONTRACTORS PERSONNEL CLEARANCE

The military departments operate a third security program,
this one affecting nearly three miilion private employees. All
industrial facilities utilizing classified information must be
cleared through the contracting department.

Since 1950, about 20,000 plants and 500,000 employees have
been cleared for Top Secret, Secret and some Confidential in-
formation. In addition, about two million employees have been
granted access to Confidential material. The size of the pro-
gram may be judged by the estimated 200 facilities and 4,000
employees cleared monthly. Six hundred and eighty-eight
persons have been denied clearance in a four-year period up to
July 15, 1954.*4

Each plant seeking a government contract utilizing classified

41 The military departments classify as confidential all personnel
security records and documents of a disciplinary nature, disclosure of
which could be prejudicial to discipline and morale.

Information will be released only on a determination that the request
is based on a legitimate interest and the release will not prejudice the
public good.

41a Statement of Secretary of Defense Wilson before the Senate Armed
Services Committee, July 15, 1954.

51

matter must have its physical set-up and its important person-
nel approved. A foreign owned, controlled or “influenced’”’
company is not eligible for clearance. An inspection is made
of the premises. Investigation is made of officers, directors
and the key employees who will have access to classified mat-
ter for preparing bids. A facility denied clearance on physical
elements has no appeal. A denial because of personnel may
be appealed to the Appeals Division of the Board. A security
agreement is made part of the contract.

Investigation

Personnel are cleared according to the category of informa-
tion they will need to receive. Since investigation is ordinarily
not begun prior to employment by the facility, an interim
clearance is granted. Clearance is made by the military de-
partment having security cognizance of the facility, or by the
management for the lowest level of security information (Con-
fidential).

For Top Secret, a background investigation is required. For
Secret information, an American citizen needs a_ national
agency check; an alien must have a background check.

Officers, directors and key employees requiring access to
Confidential information are given an agency check. Aliens
must have a background investigation.

All other citizens with access only to Confidential material at
the facility are cleared by management in the absence of de-
rogatory information. Many facilities have therefore had to
establish investigative staffs of their own or utilize detectives
and credit agencies. A review is made of personnel records.
Checks are usually made at credit bureaus and police files,
verification made of past employment and the like. FBI in-
formation is not available directly but it may come through
the military department.

Denial of security clearance need not mean dismissal from
the company. The military department by its contracts re-
quires only that the employee be kept from classified material
and from areas where classified production is carried on. But
dismissal may often follow for a variety of reasons.

52

Evaluation

If the military department thinks clearance should be de-
nied or revoked, the case is forwarded to a Screening Division
of the Industrial Personnel Security Board. There are three
Boards in the United States. The Eastern is under the ad-
ministration of the Army, the Central of the Air Force, and
the Western of the Navy. The appropriate commander ap-
points an Executive Secretary, a Security Advisor and a Legal
Advisor to aid the boards. The boards are authorized to
convene at any military establishment in the area. Each
Board has a Screening and an Appeal Division.

A company may not revoke a clearance once granted,
though it is free te transfer cr dismiss the employee on its own
initiative, subject to its obligations under collective bargaining
or other contracts. Any derogatory information must be sub-
mitted to the security office of the military department in
charge of the facility. The military department may revoke
clearances in exceptional cases but it must forward the case im-
mediately to the Screening Division with an explanation of the
action.

The Screening Division (three members) reviews the case.
If the determination is unanimously favorable, clearance is
granted. If not, in collaboration with a Security Advisor and
a Legal Advisor, a notice of denial or revocation and the rea-
sons for the action are prepared. This, and a copy of the
regulations, are sent to the contractor or employee, as the case
may be. He may answer, within ten days, in writing and under
oath. :

The file is then considered, with any answer given. Again
unanimity is required to clear. If it is not attained, the clear-
ance is denied or revoked. The employee (or the contractor,
if the clearance for the whole facility is in question) may then
appeal to the Appeals Division, in writing or at an administra-
tive hearing.

Hearings

The Appeals Division (also three-man) must include at least
one attorney and one civilian and the Chairman must be a
civilian. Hearings are conducted like the hearings the military

33

departments conduct for civilian employees. Decision is by
majority vote and includes a finding as to each allegation.
Decision is subject to no review, but the Appeals Division may
reconsider the case on its own motion, or on appeal from
either side.

The criteria are the same as those in the defense directive
for civilian personnel. With respect to paragraph (1) (suit-
ability criteria) the qualifying phrase “the relation of the
employment to the national security” is missing. Since all
these cases deal with classified matter, all the positions in-
volved are “sensitive” by definition. Hence, the change is
probably without significance.

Though the directive does not provide for review, apparently
the military department concerned can effectively intervene.
The Navy recently suspended the clearance of Dr. E. U. Con-
don and returned the case to the Industrial Review Board for
“reconsideration” (N.Y. Times, Oct. 22, 1954).

iil, ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION

The military department clearance of defense facilities and
personnel rests largely on its contracting power. The Atomic
Energy Commission program rests on specific statutory au-
thority as well as contractual control. It uses exactly the
same procedure for its own personnel and that of its contrac-
tors. Since the inception of the atomic energy development
program, the Commission’s work has been done largely
through contracts with private companies.

The Act authorizes the Commission to make arrangements
for research, to contract for special nuclear materials to be
produced with government facilities, and to license commercial
and medical research and development of atomic energy. The
person with whom such arrangements are made must agree to
permit no one access to “restricted data” without investigation
of his “character, associations, and loyalty’. “Restricted
data” is the equivalent of “classified information”. All AEC
employees must have similar clearance. The President may
direct that investigation be made by the FBI of some or all
groups of employees or contractors, and the Commission may
certify specific positions of particular sensitivitv to be handled

54

by the FBI. If a Civil Service Commission investigation de-
velops data reflecting on loyalty, the CSC refers the file to the
FBI for full field investigation.

The AEC received the authority, in 1954 amendments to
the Act, to establish the standards for the investigation and to
specify the scope and extent of investigation to be made. It
will be based on the location of the work and its nature, and
the importance which the restricted data to which access is
granted has for the national security. Previously, a full back-
ground investigation had to be made for everyone with ac-
cess to any level of restricted data.

The standard in the present regulations, dating from 1948,
is phrased in terms of danger to the common defense or se-
curity. The precaution is included that weight must be given
to favorable information. A balance is to be made of the pos-
sible risk the person represents and the cost to the program of
not having his services.

Criteria

The criteria are in two categories. Information in Category
(A) creates a presumption of security risk. Category (B) is
composed of derogatory information “where the extent of ac-
tivities, the attitude, or conviction of the individual” must be
weighed in determining whether a presumption of security
risk exists.

The Criteria include:

“(A) Reasonable grounds to believe that the individual or
his spouse has

“1. Committed or attempted to commit or aided or
abetted another who committed or attempted to
commit any act of sabotage, espionage, treason, or
sedition.

“2. Established an association with espionage agents of a
foreign nation; with individuals reliably reported
as suspected of espionage; with representatives of
foreign nations whose interests may be inimical to
the interests of the United States. (Ordinarily this
would not include chance or casual meetings; nor
contacts limited to normal business or official re-
lations. )

“3. Held membership in or joined any organization

v Yap,

a)

be totalitarian, Fascist, Communist, subversive, or
as having adopted a policy of advocating or approv-
ing the commission of acts of force or violence to
deny others their rights under the Constitution of
the United States, or as seeking to alier the form
of government of the United States by unconstitu-
tional means, provided the individual did not with-
draw from such membership when the organiza-
tion was so identified, or otherwise establish his re-
jection of its subversive aims; or, prior to the dec-
laration by the Attorney General, participated in
the activities of such an organization in a capacity
where he should reasonably have had knowledge as
to the subversive aims or purposes of the organiza-
tion.

“4. Publicly or privately advocated revolution by force
or violence to alter the constitutional form of Gov-
ernment of the United States.”

(A) Also includes cases where the individual has

“5S. Deliberately omitted significant information from
or falsified a Personnel Security Questionnaire or
_ Personal History Statement. In miany cases, it
‘may be fair to conclude that such omission or falsi-
fication was deliberate if the information omitted
or misrepresented is unfavorable to the individual.

“6. Violated or disregarded security regulations to a
degree which would endanger the common defense
or security.

“7. Been adjudged insane, been legally committed to an
insane asylum, or treated for serious mental or
neurological disorder, without evidence of cure.

“8. Been convicted of felonies indicating habitual crim-
inal tendencies.

“9. Been, or who is, addicted to the use of alcohol or
drugs habitually and to excess, without adequate
evidence of rehabilitation.”

Category (EB) includes those cases where the individual or
the spouse has
“1. Sympathetic interest in totalitarian, fascist, com-
munist or other subversive political ideologies.

“2. A sympathetic association established with mem-
bers of the Communist Party; or with leading mem-
bers of any organization set forth in _Category A,

Wa 0 weno % «h-- (7 cairn Mes th's ei] wot in

36

clude chance or casual meetings, nor contacts lim-
ited to normal business or with official relations.)

“3. Identification with an organization established as a
front for otherwise subversive groups or interests
when the personal views of the individual. are sym-
pathetic to or coincide with subversive ‘lines’.

“4, Identification with an organization known to be
infiltrated with members of subversive groups when
there is also information as to other activities of
the individua! which establishes the probability that
he may be a part of or sympathetic to the infiltrat-
ing element, or when he has personal views which
are sympathetic to or coincide with subversive
‘lines’.

“5. Residence of the individual’s spouse, parent(s),
brother(s), sister(s) or offspring in a nation whose
interests may be inimical to the interests of the
United States, or in satellites or occupied areas
thereof, when the personal views or activities of the
individual subject to investigation are sympathetic
to or coincide with subversive ‘lines’ (to be evalu-
ated in the light of the risk that pressure applied
through such close relatives could force the in-
dividual to reveal sensitive information or perform
an act of sabotage).

“6. Close continuing association with individuals
(friends, relatives or other associates) who have
subversive interests and associations as defined in
any of the foregoing types of derogatory informa-
tion.

“7. Association where the individuals have enjoyed a
very close, continuing association such as is de-
scribed above for some period of time, and then have
been separated by distance; provided the circum-
stances indicate that a renewal of contact is prob-
able.”

(B) Also includes those cases where the individual has

“8. Conscientious objection to service in the Armed
Forces during time of war when such objections
cannot be clearly shown to be due to religious con-
victions.

“9. Manifest tendencies demonstrating unreliability or
inability to keep important matters confidential;
willful or gross carelessness in revealing or disclos-
ing to any unauthorized person restricted data or

Ath--- Ve ~-5SE nw eee “* mast e* wien 44a 4- Se +n

of

of the Atomic Energy Commission or of any other
Governmental agency; abuse of trust, dishonesty;
or homosexuality.”
The trier is not limited to the criteria and may examine any-
thing he thinks relevant.

It should be noted that for most of the criteria which have
loyalty connotations, either the individual or his spouse’s acts
may be considered. The criteria most closel:; resemble those
of the Defense Department for civilian employees; but they
may be characterized as more moderate and as evincing a
greater tolerance for deviation or experimentation in the past.
The presence of a relative abroad is of significance only when
the individual’s views are along subversive lines, and an eval-
uation is to be made of the chance that pressure could be suc-
cessful. Personal habits which might disqualify are more
carefully defined and limited.

The most important difference is to be found in the AEC
restriction of (3) to the Attorney General’s list. The individual
must have been and continued to be a member after the or-
ganiza‘ion was identified unless his participation before identi-
fication was made was such that he should have known of the
subversive nature of the group. “Sympathetic association” is
restricted to leading members of these organizations.

However, “front” and “infiltrated” organizations are not
limited to the Attorney General’s list. “Identification” would
seem to reauire, however, a deeper involvement than “par-
ticipation in the activities”.

Procedures ~

The Act provides that the Commission shail make adequate
provision for review of dismissals. Since 1948, incumbents
have been granted hearings and appeals and in 1950 these were
extended to applicants. The policy of the AEC is to give max-
imum opportunity for administrative review that is consistent
with national security.

The AEC has emphasized screening and informal procedures
to reduce the number of cases. This may result in applicants’
being cenied employment by the government or the contractor
on suitability grounds, without the protection of a hearing but

58

On receipt of derogatory information, if no grave security
question is raised, the local AEC officer may have an inter-
view for clarification. Clearance is not denied on the basis
of the interview.

The Manager of the Operations Office concerned will present
to the individual the notification letter with the adverse in-
formation. He must answer within ten days. A hearing will
be scheduled before a Personnel Security Board. Failure to
answer is a waiver of the board and all review proceedings.

The Board is chosen from local AEC and contractor em-
ployees, all having clearance. At least one must have some
knowledge of the field of work of the individual. There is a
right to challenge for cause, but the challenge is decided by the
Manager who appoints the board.

Witnesses may testify under oath or not. The failure of
the employee to testify may be considered by the board. The
allegations may be amended and an adjournment to answer
will be given. Added investigation may be requested. The
hearing, in other essentials, is like the hearings previously
described.

The recommendations, with the findings and a statement
of reasons, is submitted to the Manager. He reviews the file
and the effect which denial of clearance would have on the
atomic energy program.

If the recommendation is adverse, the employee is notified
and given the Manager’s findings. He is told of his right to
appeal to the Personnel Security Review Board and to submit
briefs. The Manager might make a favorable recommenda-
tion and the General Manager, for the Commission, might not
agree. Again, the individual is allowed to submit briefs to
the Review Board. The board reviews and makes recom-
mendations to the General Manager. The General Manager
makes the final determination for the Commission, which it-
self considers important cases.

IV. THE PORT SECURITY PROGRAM

The Coast Guard program for clearing maritime and dock
workers is probably the least known of all Federal govern-

A

As. Weil

39

million people. When fighting began in Korea, there was no
legal authority for any maritime personnel security measures.
The Coast Guard developed a voluntary plan with shipowners
and some unions to prevent access to American ships and
docts of anyone deemed a security risk. An appeal right
was contemplated but the program was never completed. An
interim procedure gave an appeal to a Coast Guard officer
from which appeal could be taken to a five-officer board in
Washington. This continued until the end of 1950 when the
current program went into effect.

The Magnuson Act, passed in 1950, provides that ‘“vwhen-
ever the President finds that the security of the United States
is endangered by reason of actual or threatened war... or
of subversive activities,” he may institute measures to “safe-
guard against destruction, loss or injury from sabotage or
other subversive acts, accidents . . .” the ships and ports of
the nation. The regulations were promulgated under this
Act and an Executive Order which authorized the Com-
mandant to prescribe identification papers for clearance.

Service on all vessels is restricted unless exempted by the
Commandant. Seamen are already required to have a Fed-
eral license; security validation is stamped on that. The sea-
man applies at a Coast Guard Marine Inspection Office for
clearance by the Commandant. A check is made against the
files of the FBI and the Office of Naval Intelligence; there is
no independent investigation. Clearance is denied if “the
applicant’s character and habits are such as to authorize the
belief that the presence of the person aboard vessels of the
United States would be inimical to the security of the United
States.”

Criteria

The criteria for determining if seamen are security risks
are that the individual, on all the evidence available,

“1. Has committed acts of treason or sedition, or has
engeged in acts of espionage or sabotage; has ac-
tively advocated or aided the commission of such
acts by others: or has knowingly associated with

60

“2. Is employed by, or subject to the influence of, a
foreign government under circumstances which may
jeopardize the security interests of the United
States.

“3. Has actively advocated or supported the overthrow
of the Government of the United States by the use
of force or violence.

“4. Has intentionally disclosed military information
classified confidential or higher without authority
and with reasonable knowledge or belief that ' may
be transmitted to a foreign government or 1}:"s in-
tentionally disclosed such information io 4:‘rsons
not authorized to receive it.

“5. Is or recently has been a member of, or affiliated,
or sympathetically associated with, any forei.sn, or
domestic organization, association, movement, croup,
or combination of persons (i) which is, or which
has been designated by the Attorney Gene: al as
being, totali ‘rian, fascist, communist or s 'bver-
sive, (ii) wich has adopted, or which has been
designated by the Attorney General as having
adopted, a policy of advocating or approving the
commission of acts of force or violence to deny other
persons their rights under the Constitution of the
United States, or (iii) which seeks, or which has
been designated by the Attorney General as seek-
ing, to alter the form of the Government of the
United States by unconstitutional means: Provided
That access may be granted, notwithstanding such
membership, affiliation or association, if it is dem-
onstrated, by more than a mere denial, that the
security interests of the United States will not there- —
b, De jeopardized.”

The criteria are essentially the same as those of Executive
Order 9835, the former Employees’ Loyalty Program. Ques-
tions arising under suitability criteria are dealt with through
the licensing procedure.

Access to designated waterfront facilities is also subject
t. clearance. The Commandant designates which facilities are
restricted. They are those where shipping and other activity
vital to military defense or military assistance are being car-
ried on, and where explosives or other dangerous cargo is
loaded. All major port areas have been so designated.

61

The Coast Guard issues a Port Security Card but other clear-
ance is accepted.*? An applicant must be sponsored by an
authorized official of the company or the union. There is no
provision for interim clearance.

A new criterion is added for dock workers,

“f. That such person is otherwise not a suitable and safe
person to have access to such waterfront facilities and
port and harbor areas, including vessels therein, by
reason of:

“1. Having been adjudged insane, having been legally
committed to an insane asylum, or treated for serious
mental or neurological disorder, without evidence of
cure.

“2. Having been convicted of any of the following fel-
onies, indicative of a criminal tendency potentially
dangerous to the security of such waterfront facili-
ties and port and harbor areas, including vessels
therein; arson, unlawful trafficking in drugs, espio-
nage, sabotage, or treason.

“3. Drunkenness on the job or addiction to the use of
narcotic drugs, without adequate evidence of rehabili-
tation.”

Procedures

If clearance is denied or revoked, the person is notified in
writing. He is told that he may appeal and what rights he
would have at the hearing. His appeal is to an Appeal Board
which is convened by the Commandant in one of the Coast
Guard Districts. The chairman represents the Coast Guard.

‘2 The Coast Guard Port Security Card is not required if the indi-
vidual holds:

1. Merchant Mariner's Document showing security clearance.
2. Armed Forces Identification Card.

3. Identification credentials issued by Federal law enforcement
and intelligence agencies to their officers and employees.

4. Identification credentials issued to public safety officials when
acting within the scope of their employment.

62

The two other members represent management and labor.
These are nominated to panels by the Secretary of Labor and
the Chairman makes his selection from the panel. The labor
member will if possible be of the same union as the worker.
If there is no one available with this qualificatio., one of the
public alternates will be chosen. They are usually attorneys
in the community. If practicable, at least one member of the
Board should be an attorney.

A bill of particulars is prepared by the Commandant and
furnished to the Chairman of the Board for transmission to
the appellant. He may answer within ten days and within
fifteen davs after the notice is received, the Appeal Board
will meet. Continuances are freely granted. The employee
is informed in advance who the members of the Board will be
and what their business or union affiliations are. He mzy
challenge for cause, with affidavit and an oral presentation.
In addition, he has two peremptory challenges, one directed
to the management representative and one for labor. The
appellant may decide if the replacement for the challenged
member will be from management or labor, as appropriate, or
from the public members of the panel.

The Coast Guard presents no evidence as a rule. The ap-
pellant may decide if hearings will be open or closed. The
regulations governing the hearing generally are like all reg-
ulations on hearings.

The Board may request further investigation. On the hear-
ing and the file, the Board makes a recommendation, with
its rationale. The Commandant may approve or reject the
decision or remand the case. An adverse decision may be
taken to a National Appeal Board which sits in Washington.
It, too, is a three-man board, composed of Coast Guard, man-
agement and labor. There is the same right to challenge. The
hearing provisions are the same. The appellant may appear,
have counsel, etc. The Commandant still makes the final de-
termination. Even if the clearance is eventually granted,
there is no provision for compensation for what may be an ex-
tended period of unemployment.

63

V. CIVIL SERVICE SEPARATION PROCEDURES IN
NON-SECURITY CASES

Competitive ard classified civil service are terms used in-
terchangeably by Civil Service regulations. The competitive
status is defined as one which permits promotion,** transfer,**
reassignment,** and reinstatement without competitive exam-
ination. Status is acquired by probational appointment after
competitive examination, by statute, or by other civil service
rules.

The applicant for civil service appointment takes either an
“assembled” or an “unassembled” examination. The assembled
examination is an examination in the conventional sense—
tests of skill, of intelligence, etc. The unassembled examina-
tion is not an examination at all. The applicant, in his ner-
sonal history sheet, lists his educational and experience quali-
fications. He is given an interview. These are evaluated
quantitatively and qualitatively and a rating is assigned.

The successful applicant is appointed to a position. The ap-
pointment may be temporary, for an indefinite period, or
permanent. A temporary appointment is for a stated period,
under one year. A temporary emergency appointment is for
a period less than a month and is made without examination.

Permanent appointment was common prior to World War
II. During the war, most appointments were made for the
war period and no permanent competitive status was gained.
A similar provision was put into effect with the Korean War.“
Appointn...:t is generally made for an “indefinite” period. In-
definite appointees are not eligible for retirement benefits, on

‘3 Promotion—‘‘the advancement of an employee while continuously
employed to a higher classification act grade or to a higher grade within
the same agency—established pay schedule in which grades are assigned
or from a lower rate paid under a'‘thority other than the classification
act or vice versa or to a higher rate under a different agency-estab-
lished pay schedule or under a pay schedule in which no grades are
assigned.” 5 CFR 64.301.(10).

** Transfer—a change of position during continuous Federal service
without a break of one work day from one agency to another.

*5 Reassignment—a change without promotion or demotion from one
position to any other position, while serving continuously within the
same agency.

** Executive Order 10180, November 13, 1989. All future appoint-
ments were to be made non-permanent, with a few exceptions allowed
the agency to maintain its permanent strengih.

64

the whole. In reduction in force, the indefinite appointee is
separated from service before the permanent. Almost one-
third of all employees have indefinite appointments.

The permanent and the indefinite appointee serve a pro-
bation period of one year. The probationer has few rights
procedurally until the year is completed.

The President may add to, or remove positions from, the
classified service. If a position is removed, the incumbent is
no longer entitled to the srotection of the civil service pro-
cedure and may be separated at the will of the appointing
authority.

Positions in the executive department excepted from the
Civil Service are listed in three “schedules”, A, B and C.
Schedule A and B contain positions for which it is not prac-
ticable to hold competitive examinations. For jobs in Schedule
A, no test is required. For Schedule B, a non-competitive ex-
amination must be passed. Executive Order 10440, March
31, 1953, authorized a new schedule, C, for positions of a con-
fidential or policy-making nature. The Civil Service Com-
mission has been issuing a series of directives stating which
positions in each agency are included in this category. Many
of the positions listed were previously in Schedule A. About
8 percent of federal employment is in “excepted” categories.

An applicant may be denied examination or a candidate de-
nied appointment for cause. The Commission includes as cause:

1. Dismissal for delinquency or misconduct.

2. Physical or mental unfitness for the position.

3. Criminal, infamous, dishonest, immoral, or notoriously
disgraceful conduct.

4. Intentional false statements or deception or fraud in

examination or appointment.

Refusal to furnish testimony to the Commission.

Habitual excess drinking.

Reasonable doubt as to loyalty.

Any legal or other disqualification which makes him unfit.

OIA

These are also cause for separation if they develop o: are
discovered after the employee enters on duty. A person dis-
qualified for an examination may be denied another test for

65

a period up to three years. All appointments are made sub-
ject to investigation of character and fitness and the employee
may be removed within eighteen months of appointment if
the findings are adverse.

Removal for Cause

It is a popular belief that a person appointed to a civil service
position is almost impossible to remove. During a fifteen-month
period ending March, 1948, 21,304 Federal employees were
separated from employment for cause. Over half, however,
were “blue collar” workers, who were only about 27 percent
of personnel. Discharge was based largely on definite offenses
—drunkenness, absence, past convictions, etc.—and rarely on
general incompetency.

Contrary to the popular belief, there are few statutory re-
strictions on removal. The Lloyd-LaFollette Act, the basic
law in this field, stated that removal of a civil service employee
should be made “for such cause as will promote the efficiency
of such service.” Employees with status must be advised of
the reasons for the action and given an opportunity to answer.
The permanent or indefinite employee, past his probationary
or trial period, and the employee having a competitive status
but serving in an excepted position neither confidential nor
policy-determining, has the protection of these civil service
removal minima. The employee separated by order of the
Commission because his appointment was contrary to regula-
tion is not entitled to this procedure.

The Act does not define cause for separation. The Civil
Service regulations allow removal for the same reasons which
disqualify an applicant from examination or appointment.
Religion, marital status, race, national! origin or political belief,
other than acts forbidden by law, are not cause for discharge.
Removal based on any of these may be appealed to the Com-
mission.

A temporary employee may be separated on notice in writ-
ing from the appointing authority. The probationary worker
receives u notice in writing, giving the reasons for the dis-
charge and the effective date of separation. He has no oppor-
tunity to answer except in the discretion of the agency.

66

The permanent or indefinite appointee, past probation, re-
ceives a notice in writing of the adverse action proposed. With
the notice, he gets a list of charges, specific and detailed; but
the supporting evidence need not be included. The employee
need not be told who preferred the charges against him. How-
ever, the charges must be sufficiently factually detailed to allow
answer, and no discharge can be based on charges not given
the employee.

The worker is retained in an active duty status during this
period of administrative proceedings. If necessary to protect
government properiy, other employees or the public, he may
be temporarily assigned to other duties or placed on leave
without pay with his consent. In emergency, the department
may suspend, issue charges, and require the employee to an-
swer in a shorter period than is usually granted.

The employee must be given a reasonable time to answer
the charges. The agency must consider the answer and at
the earliest practicable date give the worker a written decision.
If the determination is adverse, he is notified of the reasons
for it and of the effective date of the adverse action. He is
not entitled to a trial or a hearing or to any examination of
witnesses, but these may be granted by the agency in its dis-
cretion.

The Act gives no review to the employee of the agency de-
cision. The Civil Service Commission will not investigate
unless it is shown that the required procedure was not followed
or that removal was made for a prohibited cause. The em-
ployee must request review within ten days of the effective
date of the action or the last decision of the employing agency
review system.*? His request must be detailed and under oath.
The supporting evidence for his claim must be set forth in his
request. A prima facie case for review must be made. The
Commission may recommend reinstatement but it has no power
to order it. The reinstated employee is compensated for any
earnings lost in the period of wrongful discharge. He is deemed
in service for this time except for accumulation of leave.

-_——-

47 Extension is granted only on a show of circumstances beyond the
control of the employee.

67

Veterans’ Preference
The veteran and certain relatives of deceased or disabled

- veterans are entitled to preferred treatment, not only in appoint-

ment to civil service position but in separation proceedings.
Almost half of all federal employees are in this status. The
“Preference Eligible’ serving under permanent or indefinite
appointment, past the probationary period, may not be re-
moved,**® suspended, for more than thirty days,*® furloughed
without pay, reduced in rank or compensation,” or debarred
from future appointment except for cause. The temporary or
probational worker is not covered by these provisions; nor is
the legislative or judicial employee; nor are most appointees
confirmed by the Senate. The preference employee must be ,
given thirty days advance written notice of the adverse action
contemplated.*! Where there is reasonable cause to believe
he is guilty of a crime, he receives only such notice as is rea-
sonable under the circumstances. The notice contains the
reasons for the proposed action. He has a reasonable time to
answer personally and in writing. His answer must be con-
sidered by the agency. If a decision is made adverse to him,
he is notified in writing of the determination and of his right
to appeal to the Civil Service Commission.*"?

The Commission does not consider appeals from loyalty
hearings since the abolition of the Review Board. It will not

4S Removal—-sey ‘ion from the service on charges of delinquency
or misconduct, 0: ...ause the employee's capacity is not sufficient to
justify his retention in the service.

‘9 Suspension—a temporary non-pay status and absence from duty
required by the appointing officer for disciplinary reasons or for other
reasons pending inquiry.

5° If a non-veteran is demoted, he is notified in writing of the reasons
for the action and of his right to appeal through whatever grievance
procedure the agency had adopted.

5! The notice states what action will be taken under the proceeding.
If on review the agency desires to take a more severe acticn, new
charges must be issued and a new review is required. If the penaliy
imposed is less severe than the action proposed in the notice, a new
proceeding is not necessary.

‘2 If the employee accepted a reduction in rank on pressure from the
agency, he has not waived his rights.

The agency must ascertain whether an employee is a preference eligible
and treat his ccse accordingly. It is not excused by ignorance of his
preferred state.

68

consider a case until the employee has exhausted any remedy
his agency may have.

Within ten days after the effective date of the adverse action,
or of the iast adverse decision of an agency appeal, the pref-
erence eligible may appeal to the Commission in writing. He
encloses the charges, the answer, the notice of adverse decision
and any added documentary evidence he wishes to submit. He
must include evidence of his preference status.

His documents are examined by the Chief, Appeals Exam-
ing Division, or by the Regional Director, if it is an appeal in
the field, to see if the employee comes within the scope of the
act. If. it is decided he does not, he is informed of his right
to request reconsideration and to submit evidence and argu-
ments in support of his claim. If the decision again goes
against him, he may appeal to the Commissioners on the point.

If he is within the Veterans’ Preference. Act, the case is
docketed for investigation and adjudication. Investigation will
be made as necessary. No pledge of confidence is made to
witnesses. Evidence is discussed by the investigator with the
administrative officer of the employing agency who made the
adverse action against the employee and with other officers of
the agency. They are requested to give their version of the
dispute. The employee is informed of any data the agency
may furnish and is allowed to insert his views on it. The
agency may then comment on his comments and he on theirs.

The Civil Service Commission reviews both on the merits
and the procedure. The employee may request a hearing. He
may appear at this personally or through representatives. The
agency also appears. Both sides may present evidence and
witnesses. Testimony is given under oath. There is no sub-
poena power. If a transcript is not directed by the hearing
examiner in charge, he summarizes his notes and the parties
may take exception to any claimed inaccuracies in the sum-
mary. “

The decision is made by the Chief, Appeals Examining Office,
or by the Regional Director, depending on the location of the
hearing. The determination includes an analysis of the evi-
dence, a finding, the reasons for the finding, and a recom-
mendation. The agency and the employee receive copies of

69

: the decision. If it is adverse, the employee is notified of his
_ further appeal rights.

Within seven days, an appeal may be made to the Board of

- Appeals and Review of the Commission. The Board reviews

Lobe. 3G!

the record. In its discretion, it may allow the parties to ap-
pear personally and argue but there is no right to further
hearing. Evidence which could have been previously sub-
mitted will not be considered. If new evidence appears, the
Board may remand the case to begin the procedure again or,
in exceptional cases and in its discretion, it may receive the

_ evidence. An appeal may be taken to the Commission, at the
_ Commission’s discretion, with a personal appearance or writ-
_ ten presentation. Under the Veterans Preference Act, the

7 agency must take such corrective action as the Commission,
_ at any of these appeal stages, recommends.

The Commission may examine the case of any separated

_ worker to determine whether he is eligible for future govern-
_Mment employ. Request must be made within six months of
_ Separation or within sixty days of the last adverse decision on
- appeal.

_ Fair Employment, Hatch Act

If the employee claims that he was or is being separated

- because of race, creed or national origin, he files a complaint

within three months of personnel action with the supervisor
_ of the Fair Employment Officer.** An attempt is made to settle
_ the dispute at the supervisory level when possible. If for some

reason this cannot be achieved, further complaint is made to

_ the Deputy Fair Employment Officer who investigates and in

turn attempts to adjust the grievance.

Unsettled complaints are taken to the Fair Employment
Officer who makes his attempt at adjustment. If he, too, fails,
the employee may be given a hearing. The Fair Employment
Officer after hearing makes findings of fact and a decision. If
the determination is unfavorable, further appeal is possible to
the head of the department or agency.

53 An appeal is gramixd the applicant denied appointment because of
race, creed or national origin. He files his complaint with the Fair
Employment Officer.

70

From the agency, appeal may be taken to a Fair Employ-
ment Board in the Civil Service Commission. The Board can
refuse to accept an appeal. If it takes the case, the employee
is usually accorded a hearing. If new evidence appears, the
case is remanded to the agency head for new ‘ctermination.

The Commission does not allow duplicate appeais under the
Fair Employment procedure and the Veterans Act. The Fair
Employment procedure is available to all employees.

Under the Hatch Act, Federal employees are limited in the
type of political activity in which they can participate. A
government worker who violates this limit may be removed
from his job and denied future government employ.

The employing agency and the Civil Service Commission
make a joint i

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA04386408_0129%3A13. Public record. Not legal advice.
