# LIZZIE W . AND ALBERT'L .-CALLOWAY, Petitioners v .

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/agency%3Atax-court%3A19813138fe7bfe7f

## Record

- **Collection:** Agency decision
- **Document type:** Agency decision

## Text

LIZZIE W . AND ALBERT'L .-CALLOWAY, Petitioners v .
COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE, Responden t

Docket No . . 8438-07 .

Filed July 8, 2010 .

In August .2001 P entered into an agreement with
Derivium whereby P-transferred 990 shares`-of IBM common
stock to Derivium in exchange for $93,586 .23 . The
terms of the agreement ;characterized the transaction a s
a .loanof 90 percent of the . value of the IBM stoc k
pledged as collat'eral. . The purported loan wa s

nonrecourse and prohibited P from making any interes t
or-principal payments-during the .3-year term "of th e
purported loan . The terms of the agreement allowe d
Derivium `to .%sell the .stock ; .which it did immediatel y
upon receipt . At maturity P had the option of either
paying the balance due, and having- anu equivalent' amoun t
of IBM stock returned to him, renewing the purported
loan for an`additional ;term, or satisfying the "loan"
by surrendering-any right to receive IBM-stock . At
maturity in August 2004 the balance due was°$4'0, 924 .57
more than the then value of the IBM stock . P . .elected .
to satisfy his purported ba r
to receive IBM stock . P was not required to and,di d

SERVED

JUL - 8 2010

.not-make any payments toward either principal o r
interest on the purported loan .
1.
Held : The transaction between P and Deriviu m
in August 2,001 was a sale . P transferred all th e
benefits and burdens of . ownership of the stock t o
Derivium for $93,586 .23 with no obligation to repa y
that'amount
2.
Held , further , the transaction was no t
analogous to the securities lending arrangement in Rev .
Rut . 57-451, 1957-2 C .B . 295, nor-was it equivalent t o
a securities lending arrangement under sec . 1058, ,
I .R .C .
3.
Held , further , Ps are liable for an additio n
to tax under sec . 6651(a)(1), I .R .C ., for the lat e
filing of their 2001 Federal income tax return .
4 .
Held , further , Ps are liable for the accuracyrelated penalty pursuant to sec .` 6662, I .R .C .

Brian G .

Isaacson , . for petitioners . .

Daniel J .

Parent ,

RUWE, Jude :

for respondent .

Respondent determined a $30,911 deficiency ,

$6,583 addition t o tax under section 6651 .(a)(1)' for failure t o
timely file,

.and a

$6,182 .20-,accuracy-related penalty unde r

section 66621 .(a)-,i n
tax . The issue s we must : . decide are : . (1)b Whether `a transaction
in which Albert

Calloway (petitioner.) .t'ransferred 990 share s

of International Business Machines Corp°. .( .IBM) common stock t o
Der ..ivium Capital, L .L .C .' .(Derivium),

in-exchange for $93, 586 .2 3

was a sale or'a loan ; . (2) whether the transaction qualifies as

a

'All'section references are to the Internal Revenue Code as
amended,"and Rule references are to the Tax Court Rules of
Practice and Procedure .

secur.ities .l .endi-ng .arrangement ;'(3) whether-petitioners ..are .
.
liable for an addition to tax°under .section 6651(a)`(l). .fo r
failure to timely . firle ; and '(4) .whether' .petitioners are liabl e
for an :accuracy-related penalty pursuant to-,,section 6662(a )
FINDINGS OF FAC T

Some of'-the -facts- .have been `stipulated and are so found .
The stipulated facts ;and-.the-attached exhibits are-incorporate d
herein by .this reference .

.At the

the petition was" .filed ,

petitioners-'resided in Georgia .
After petitioner graduated from college in 1964, he began a
successful career with IBM . While employed at IBM petitione r
purchased shares of IBM stock .
During 2001 petitioner's financial adviser ,
introduced him to Derivium and its 90-percent-stock-loa n
program .2

Under that pro gramDerivium would .purport to lend 9 0

percent of-the^-value of securities pledged to Derivium" a
New York Stoc k
Exchange or":the'eNational Association of,,Securitie s
Dealers/Financial Industry` .Regulatory Authority' . Charle s

.
.
"borrow " , . ..
The use of the terms " l o an " " collateral "" ,
"hedge", andy "maturity" with all . -related terms ,throughout
this Opinion is merely for convenience in describing what
petitioners -contend the, transaction represents . .
2

On or about August

6,

200 .1, . Deriviumu sent . to, petitioner . a

document entitled "Master Agreement to Provide-Fi-nancing'an d
. Custodial Services ."-(master agreement)with attached "Schedul e
D, Disclosure Acknowledgement and .Broker/Bank Indemnification "
(schedule D) . The master agreement provides, in .pertinent part :
This Agreement ;is made for the,purposeof_`engagin g
* * * [Derivium] to provide ,or arrange financing(s) an d
to . provide. custodial .- servicesto * * * [petitioner]
with respect to certain properties and assets
("Properties") :to be pledged . as secu rity, the detail s
of which financing and-Properties are to be set out in
loan term, sheets . and attached hereto as .Schedule(s) .- A
("Schedule(s) A
" )

The . schedule D to be executed in connection with .the maste r
agreement states that the transaction was to "Provide Financin g
and-Custodial Services entered into between Deriviu m

* * *p
[ etitioner]
'• f edu
,h
aragrap" P
o hsc
l e D, relating to th e
pledge of securities, provides, in pertinent part :
[Petitioner] understands that by transferrin g
securities as,,collateral .to-* *m* .[Der.ivium] and unde r
the terms of the * * * [master agreement], * *" *

[petitioner]-,gives .* * * [Derivium] the right, withou t
notice to * * *.,,[petitioner], to transfer, pledge ,
repledge, hypothecate, rehypothecate,_ lend','° shortsell ,
and/or sell outright some or all of the securities
during the period covered by the - .loan .
[Petitioner] understands that * * * [Derivium]has th e
right to receive and retain the 'benefit`s from any -suc h
transactions and that * * * [petitioner] is not
`entitled to these benefits during the term of a loan .
* * * [Emphasis added . ]
Derivium also sent to petitioner a=•document entitled
"Schedule A-1, Property Description and , Loan Terms" (schedule,A-

1), which sets forth the essential terms°of•the transaction .
Schedule A-l provides :
This Schedule A* * * , dated A u g ust 6th, 2001, is
executed in connection with the Master Agreement to
Provide Financing and Custodial Services entered into
between Derivium * * * and [petitioner] `* * * o n
8/6/01 .
1 .- ::Property.
Description : "

•990 shares of International
Business Machines Corporation .
(IBM) .

.$105,444 .90 ( as of: 8/6/01,
$106 .51 . per share) .
-3 .

at

Anticipated :
Loan Amount :

10 .500, compounded annually,
accruing until and due at
maturity .

All Dividends will be received as
:cash payments against interest due . ,
with the balance of interest owed
to accrue until maturity date .
3 years,' starting from the
.date on which final loan
proceeds are delivered on th e

loan transaction .

Margin a.

Requirements :

None.,-beyond initial collateral .

10 c, Non-Callable :

11 . . . .Non_Recourse : Non-recourse to borrower ,
recourse against the
collateral only .
The loan°may,bem .r.enewed .or
refinanced at .borrower's
request for an additional
term, on the maturity date,
within :*-* * [Derivium's]
,prevailing conditions and
terms for loans at the time o f
renewal or refinancing . On
the renewal .or~refinancingo f
any loan for which-90o of the
.collateral value at maturity
does not,equal°or exceed th e
payoff amount, there will be a
.renewal fee, which will be
calculated as a percentage o f
the balance due at maturity o f
this loan . The''percentag e
will vary according to'the
market capitalization of the
securities at the time of the
renewal or refinancing, a s
follows : Large,Caps~;at 4 .5%,
.Mid Caps at .5 .50, Small Caps
at 6 .5% .

Upon receipt of securities an d
.establishment-of * °* *'
[ Derivium' s ] hedging
transactions .
Before entering into the agreement with Derivium, petitione r
reviewed a memorandum dated December 12, 1998', from Robert J .
Nagy , . who claimed to be a certified public accountant, to Mr .

Cathcart regarding the ;~"Tax Aspects of'First Security Capital' s
90%-Stock Loan" that was requested by Mr . Cathcart . In-th e
.memorandum Mr . Nagy describes a potential client as,one who owns

publicly traded stock with a low basis,. which if sold would
result in significant gain to the .client . Mr . Nagy describes, th e
primary issue as,whether the 90-percent-stock-loan transaction i s
-a sale or a loan and opines that, although there is no "absolut e
assurances that-the desired tax treatment will be achieved" ,
there is a "solid basis for the .position that these transaction s
are, in-fact, loans ." -Petitioner relied on .Mr . .Nagy's memorandum .
to Mr Cathcart-in deciding whether, to enter into the, agreement
Petitioner-testified that a loan versus a sale transaction made
economic sense to him because the loan proceeds given to him were
90 percent of the value of the IBM stock .whereas if he had,sold
the stock he would have had to pay 20 percent for taxes .
Petitioner decided to'enter into the-90=percent-stock-loan
program (transaction) withDerivium . Petitioner signed the
master agreement, the schedule' D, and the schedule °A-1 on Augus t

8, 2001 . Charles D ._Cathcart, as president of-Derivium, signe d
the master . agreement and the schedule A-1 .-on-August 10, 2001 .
On or about August 9, .2001, petitioner instructed-Brian-J .
Washington of First Union Securities, Inc ., .to transfer 990
shares of IBM common stock (IBM stock or collateral)-to Morgan
Keegan &Co .- (Morgan Keegan) and to credit .Derivium's account .
On August 16, 2001, Morgan Keegan credited Derivium's account ,
with the IBM stock transferred from petitioner` : The followin g
day August 17', 2001, De'rivium sold ,the 990 sharers of IBM stock

held in its Morgan Keegan account for $1 0 3,984 .65 (i .e . $105 .035
per share of IBM . common stock) The . netproceeds from Derivium's
sale-of the IBM -stock were '°$1 .03, .918 .18 ('i . e .•,
$3 .47 . "S .E .C . Fee" and a $63 ``Comm'ission") .

$103' 984 . 65 minus a

On August 22, : 2001 ,

.the net :proceeds from the sale of the'IBM stock :settled into
Derivium's,Morgan Keegan account .
On or about August 17, 2001,' Derivium'-s'operations offic e
sent`to ;petit'i .oner two, documents . .. The .,first document, entitled
Valuation,Confirmation",`'indicates that Derivium-, .had receive d
the IBM stock into its . Morgan Keegan account valued a t
$104, 692 .50 (at a "Price per, .,."Share for Valuation' : of $105 .75) .
Thus, Derivium .projected .the amount . it-would lend to petitioner
as $94,223 .25 . The second document,' "Activity
Confirmation", however, indicates that"as . of August 17,` 2 .001 ,
Derivium had "hedged" .the,=IBM stock fora "hedged value "
$103,984 .70 .3 On the basis-of-the "hedged :' value Derivium
determined petitioner's actual "loan" amount as`$93,586 .23'(i .e .,
90-percent of $103,'9.84 .70) Thus, the "l'oan'' amount was no t
determined : until after .Derivium sold the IBM stock- .

'Derivium's Morgan Keegan account statement reflects a sale
price . of $103, 984`` .'65 , for the 990 . shares of IBM common stock . The
difference , between Derivium's,"hedged . value" of $103,984 .70 and
the',$103,984 65 reported oh-Derivium's Morgan Keegan account
statement . appears to be due to rounding . The Morgan .Keegan
statement reports the share price at the time of sale-at
$105 .035,, whereas Derivium's"Ac .tivity ..,,Confirmation" report
indicates the share price at the'time the' shares were "hedged" at
$105 .03505 .

On August . 21, ..200 .1, Deriv.ium sent . to petitioner. : alette r
informing him that . the .,proceeds' .of the loan were -sent :to hi m

according to :the' ..wire,,transfer instructionshe had provided a fe w
days earlier .-'On thatsame date, a .$93,586 .23 wire transfer wa s
received and, .credited to petitioner's `account at IBM `Southeas t
Employees . Federal Credit Union .
During the term of .--the"loan" Derivium`provided petitioner
with quarterly and .yearend account statements . 'The quarterly
acco.unt .statements reported "end-of-quarter. collateral value"'. and
dividends ,,such that it appeared that .Derivium stil-1 held the IBM
stock (i . e .-, Derivium . appears to have , reported the value of the
.collateral .on the .basis of the'fai .r .market value of the IBM stock
.at, the end of each calendar quarter . rather than . the $103,984 :65
of sale proceeds, and further . reported dividends on the IBM
stock, which it credited against'-the interest accrued'during .the
quarter,! as, if it continued, to hold all .990 shares of IBM 'stock)
Petitioner neither . received a- Form 1099-DIV, . Dividends and=
Distributions, .nor included any,IBM dividend income"-from th e
.alleged dividends ;paid on- ;,the IBM 'stock on petitioners" 2001 ,
2002, 2003, or 2004 Federal income tax return, .
.

.In a,letter dated . July 8, 2004, Derivium informed petitione r

that . the loan "will mature on August 21, 2004" and thatth e
"total . principal and interest that will be .due ,

$124,429 .09"

and payable o n

informed,

petitioner that,

as . -of July 8 ;'_2004 .,' the .value of °'990 shares o f

IBM stock . was .,$83, 318 .40 . .

.Derivium also 'reiterated td-petitione r

that, .: pursuant to, the :terms and-conditions of the maste r
agreement,'he was entitledgto`elect,one of the,, . foll o_wing thre e
options ~-at -maturity : (1) "Pay the Matur` ity Amount and Recove r
Your Collateral" ; ( 2) "Renew or Refinance 'thee, Transaction for"a n
;Additional Term" ; or -(3)w"Surrender . . Your` Collateral"' .
On July` '27, 2004, petitioner responded to, Derivium' . s July 8 ,
2004, letter,` stating°tha .t
my/our,collateral-uin satisfaction. ; of ;my/..our entire 'deb t
obligation" ; i e .-, petitioner relinquished the right ..to acquir e
the .IBM stock valued ' at $ 83, 326 . 324 and' never` made any payment s
of principalor interest on the $124,250 .'89•balance due on th e
"loan" . .
On: : September, ,
notifying `him that the loan matured on :Augusts -21, . 2004 ;°" and ,tha t
the .balance' due was '$40,''924 :-.57 more . than the value-of the= IB M
stock eon_ the .maturity , date . _ The partie's stipulate that the pric e
per share of, IBM stock .was $105'..03 on =August `17'1,` 2001, an d
approximately $84 .16 . on July 8, :2004 . .

4The Sept. . . 8 ;'`2004, letter indicates that >the 'dollateral ,
the IBM stock, was valued at $83,`326 .32, "using the average of the ,
closing' prices, as reported by'the Wall Street Journal ,' .for th e
ten trading days-prior-to the maturity date ."

On :Febru .ary 11,

2004 ,

petitioners

filed their 2001==join t

Federal income tax return .. Petitioners £did . :not'report the `
$93,586 : .23-received from Derivium,in exchangeefor'the .IBM`stoc k
on their 2001Federal income taxreturn, .nor di d
.termination of the transaction with Derivium'on,their' '200 4

:Federal-- income tax return .
Petitioner'_s 'cost basis in` 'the 990 shares of -IBM stock wa s
$21,171 .

The .primary issue is whether the transaction, iri whic h
petitioner transferred his.; IBM -stock -to Derivium" and " received
$93, 586 . .23.,

was a "sale ' or 'a 'loan . Surprisingly, this case

presents an

'issue -, of . first impres'sion in

Nevertheless,

this

'Court=. 6 '

there. . are many cases that provide-us with guiding :

to . the' .transaction 'as `a loan ; however, "Federa l

.SLn .the notice of deficiency -respondent ' s .determination .was
made using . a cost basis of $10, 399' for petitioner' s 990 shares o f
IBM stock .

6There,are now other cases pending . in :the Tax Court- ,
involving Derivium-transact :.ions . We understand . that-from 1998 . to
•2002 Derivium engaged in approximately 1,700 : similar transaction s
involving approximately $1 billion .
Derivium Capital L .L .C . v .
United States Trustee, . 97 .AFTR 2d 2006-258.2, .at 2006-2583 . to
2 .006-2584 .(S .D .N .Y . 2006) . . The Government estimated the tota l
tax loss associated,with Deriviums scheme to,be .;approximately
$235 million . Complaint, U nited States v . Cathcart , No . 07-476 2
(N .D . Cal . filed Sept . 17, 2007) .

- 12 ,
concerned,with the . economic substance, of the transaction under
scrutiny and .not,the ,form by which it is^masked .

United States

v . .Heller , 866 F .2d 1336 ; 1341 . (11th Cir . 1989,) ; ; see also
Commissioner y .Court Holding Co .,

24 `- U .S . 331,'334 (1-945) ("Th e

incidence of taxation depends .-upon the substance of .,
transaction .

To permit the true nature of .-,a . transactio n

to be disguised-by mere formalisms,, which exist solely to,alter
tax liabilities, would . seriously impair the effectiv e
administration of the tax policies of-,Congress .") ;
Helverina , 293 U . S .

465 ., w470

(1935)

Gregory v .

(finding the economic

substance of a transaction to rbe . ,controll,ing- and stating :, "To
hold, otherwise would be to exalt- .artifice above reality and to
deprive the . :statutory provision} .in question of . all serious
purpose " )
Whether the Transaction Was a Sale of IBM Stock

.

"The term `sale' 'is .,given .i,ts ordinary meaning for Federal
income tax purposes and is :=generally defined as .a transfer of
property- for money or a promise to pay money .," . , Grodt & McKay
Realty ; Inc .

V.

Commissioner,

Commissioner v . Brown ,

77 T. . C .. 1221," 1237 (1981) (citin g

380 U . S . 563 , 570-571-( 1965 )) .

Since th e

economic substanceof a transaction, rather' than its form ,
controls for tax purposes, the key to Jdeciding whether th e
transaction was a sale or other disposition i s
whether the benefits and'burdens of ownership °of .the IBM stock

passed from petitioner to Derivium . Whether` .thebenefits an d
-burdens .of ownership have .passed fron one taxpayer,Fto anothe r
question -,of fact that is .'determined -from the -intention of th e
parties as established by. .the' written' . agreements read in-th e
light of the attendingfact .s,and ;circumstances

See, Arevalo v .

Commissioner , . .124 T'-C : 2,44,, .251-252 (2005)', affd I" 469 F .'3d 43 6
.(5th Cir .

2006 ) .

Factors the,cour,ts"have'cons'idered in makin g

this determination,include :

Whether legal title passes ; (2 )

how the parties treat the : transaction` ;

.( 3) whether' an equity' '

interest- .in the . property acquired ;' (4'.), whether the contrac t
create sta present obligation-on the' sellerato',' .ex'ecute and :delive r
deed and--a present obligation' on' ,the purchaser to 'make
payments ; (5) whether .•the' right of possession .is . vested in the
purchaser ; (`6 )

which -.part pays the .property taxes ; . °(7) which

.party bears the' ri°s k of :-loss or damage -to" the property ; `° and - (8 )
which party` receives the profits from=,the" operation =and 'sale 'o f
.the property . See id .

at 252 ; see also Grodt-&-McKay-Realty ,

Applying the above factors leads us to the conclusion tha t

On August 1 .6, 2001, petitioner transferred the . .IBM stock t o
Derivium's Morgan .Keegan account . . The master . . agreement provides

14 authorized-to sell .it without notice topetitioner_ .

..Deriviumn

immediately, sold .: the stock . Thus, legal' title to-the stock ;
passed to . Derivium in 200.when'
1
petitioner transferred the IBM
stock .pursuantto . .the terms of the master agreement . '
(2) . The, Parties' Treatment of the Transaction .
In the master agreement the parties" characterize th e
transaction as . a .loan- and characterize :the IBM -shares .as .
collateral ., However, on-,-August . 4-17,2001,, the `day after . "it
received the IBM stock, Derivium sold'it . Derivium did not
determine,the_value of the .so-called loan, to petitioner until
after it had determined the proceeds it would receive-from-th
. ,Although , petitioner, testified' that ;heesalofth,IBMck di d
,not know :Derivium had sold-the IBM stock and :that he believed
-Derivium was only =acting as a custodian . of . the' stock, petitioner
admitted'that-when. he signed the , agreement : he,knew,that he had
authorized Derivium to,sell_the stock .8 Petitioners,, did no t

7Legal title is one, . of several factors in our test . and . may
not be determinative in`every sintuation ; e .g ., :brokers holding
stock for the accounts of,cus,tomers or as security for .advances`
under highly regulated condition s . See' Provost V .# United States ,
269 U .S . 443 (1926) . Indeed, Congress .has provided that certain
types of security' lending arrangements do not'have to be
recognized as taxable transactions if they meet .*,the- .strict
requirements of sec . 1058 .' See infra pp .'27-32 :
BAt ;trial petitioner testified :
Q What responsibilities do you believ e
Derivium, let's call it DC, Derivium Capital,
your

report dividends paid : on - the, IBM -,stock yon wtheir }2001, 2002, 2003 ,
, .or.2004 Federal income tax return, and petitioner . . was .neve r
required to repay any of~_the,principal or interest on'-the "loan" .
Indeed, .even :though petitioners argue . that the ,` :sale of thei-r .
IBM stock- occurred . in 2004 , they failed to .report the "sale "
.their IBM shares on :their 20 .04 Federal,income tax-return ., They
also failed-to .alternatively report any relief of indebtednes s
,income from the transaction on,their,-200 4
petitioners did not treat this transactionin :`a manner
with their own characterization of-the transaction . {

.continue d
A u"They had a' responsibility of'-*prbtecting me
throughout that three- .year. period to ensure that th e
stock -was there` at the" completion of the-transaction .
f your IBM'rv .

A I would' not have received anything-,,because, they
had the right,, that-was something that I agreed to', bu t
they also had the responsibility as- a .custod .an, :to
return to' me the total' number' Hof 990 shares at' th e
completion of the .tran .saction .

- 16
(3)_ Equity Inherent ° in }the Stoc k

Derivium acquired all property interest s
,and the' next .dayiall of Derivium's interest inthe stock wa s
sold :

' .etitlo n er ;~retained no property - 'interest in the stock . .,

At

best : he had an option to 'purchase an equivalent number . ` of 'IB M
shares after 3 1years at Pa price equival ent `to $ 93, 586' . 23 plu s
."interest '' . :

The effectiveness : .of the option depended o n

Derivium's abilityto acquire and deliver the,requir-ed number o f
. .IBM 'shares in 2004 .
(4)

Obligation To Deliver and-Pa y

The master agreement obligates petitioner to transfer th e
r

IBM stock to Derivium and .Derivium to pay .90'percent of the fai r
market value of , the, stock . The amount,.Derivium had to pay wa s
determined-after Derivium sold the IBM stock .
(5)

Whether the Right of Possession Passed

Derivium obtained title to,'possession of,'

and complete .

control of _the IBM stock from petitioner . Derivium immediately ,
exercised those rights and sold the stock .
(6)

Payment of Property Taxe s

This factor is inapplicable under the facts of this„cas e

(7)

The Risk of, Loss or Damag e

Upon receipt of the $93,586 .23 from Derivium in 2001 ,
petitioner bore- . no risk 'of loss in the event' that,the .value o f
the IBM-stock decreased . Petitioner`was entitled'to .retain all

the . funds' transferred- .to him regardless of the 'performance of, th e
IBM stock=in the financial marketplace .
(8) ; Profits From; the P ropert y
The ,master -agreement :provides . : _
[Petitioner] gives,-* * . *, [Derivi .um] the right, withou t
notice to * * * [petitioner], to transfer, pledge ,
,repledge, hypothecate, rehypothecate,x . So there . was n.o . requirement, that you had to .
repay ;theloan ?
A There was `a choice . - ' I could' haven extended the
loan, I could have . relinquished the loan, .,but the loan- ,
was, upside down . There- was a debt of $40,00'0 . I chose
to . relinquish' the shares . That was in payment for the
loan becoming .a taxable event in 2004 .
As previously mentioned, petitioners failed to report a sale
of the IBM stock on their 2004 Federal income tax return .

- -18 IBM stock in 2004 . .

.The foregoing,factorsindicate that th e

transaction was a sale of IBM .stock in=:2001 . .
In the context of taxation,, .c'ourts have defined a loan a s
n agreement, either express or implied, 'whereby one perso n
advances money 'to :the other and the other, agrees " to'repay it upo n
..such terms as to`time and, rate of interest, .or withou't .interest ,
.as the parties may agree .'

Welch v . Commissioner ,'204- :F .3 d

1
1 228 ., 1230 (9th Cir . . .2000) .(quoting Commissionerrv . .Valley Morri s
1305 .F .2d610, 618 (9th Cir'.

.1962) affg .i T . C ., Memo . 1998-

121 ; see also Talmage v . Commissioner , T .C . .Memo . 2008-34 .' For a
transaction to be a bona fide loan the p arties must have actuall y
intended to establish a debtor-creditor relationship at the tim e
the'funds were advanced .

Fisher v . Commissioner , ; 54 T .C . 905 ,

909-910 •(1970) . " Whether a bona fide debtor- credito r
relationship ; exists is a question of fact to bedetermined upon a
consideration of all the pertinent facts in the"case ' Id :

at

909 . "For disbursements to constitute true loans'there must hav e
been,,at .-the time the funds were " transferred,' an unconditiona l
obligation on the part of the transferee'-to repay'the money, an d
an .unconditional intention on the part of the transferor, to .
secure repayment ."

Haag v . Commissioner , 88,T .C . . 604, 615-61 6

(1987), affd . . without published ' opinion855 F .'2d 855` (8th Cir .

1988) .

19-Courts have considered various factors-in determiningwhether-a transfer . constitutes genuine indebtedness . No one
factor is necessarily determinative, and the-fact-ors'considere d
do. not constitute an exclusive list . See,El-linaer v Unite d
States ,,470 F .3d 1325, . 1333=1334 . (11th°Cir . 2006) (listing a
nonexclusive list,of 13 factors) ;

Welch v . Commissioner ,

supra at-

123,0 .10 Often it comes'down-to a question of substance over for m
requiring . courts to `look beyond,the parties'- terminology'to th e
-substance and .economic realities'

BB&T Corp . v . United States ,

523 F .3d -461, 476, (4th Cir . 2008) (quoting Halle v'. Commissioner ,
83 F .3d 649, 655 (4th Cir . . 1996), revg .

Kinastowne L .P . v .

Commissioner , T . .C . Memo . 1994-630) . Our-analysisof"the factors
relevant to this- case , leads to the .conclusion that even thoug h
the documents prepared by Derivium use the term "loan", the
transaction -lacked, the characteristics of a true loan .
The transaction was structured so that petitioner could
receive 90 percent of the value of his IBM stock . Petitioner
would have no personal liability t

''For example the,-nonexclusive-list of factors enumerated in
Welch v . Commissioner , 204- :F .3d 1228, 1230 •(-9th Cir . 2000), are :
(1) Whether the promise to repay is evidenced . by a' note or othe r
instrument; (2) whether interest was charged ; (3) whether a fixed
schedule for repayments-wasµestablished ;'(4-) . whether collateral
was given to secure payment ; (5) whether repayments were made ;
.(6) whether,the borrower had a reasonable prospect of repaying
the loan and whether the lender had sufficient funds to advanc e
the-loan ; and (7) whether the parties conducted themselves as i f
the transaction were a-loan .

- 20 Derivium, .,.and .it=would have made no .sense to do-so unless th e
valueof the stock had substantially appreciated' .E : Petitione r
.transferred-ownership of the .stock toDerivium,who. received al l
rights, and . privileges , of ownership - arid : was ~- free to ' sell 'th e
stock : sDerivium did . immediatelysell the stockand immediatel y
passed,90 . percent ,of the , proceeds

to petitioner' .

. The only right

petitioner retained regarding-shares .o-f,IBM stock-was an . option ,
exercisable ,'3 years later, in .2004 'to require Deriviu.m t
.acquire 990- shares of,-IBM stock , and .deliver them'to h.im. in 2004 . .
Petitioner' s . right to . exercise . this option in 2004 °was . `wholl y

contractual because he had already transferred all of`the z
incidents°of ownership to Derivium,,which had immediately ; sol d
the ... 990, shares . 11 See, ' Provost v . United States , 269 U . S 443 :
(1926) .x ; Petitio-ner engaged in,,the'-transaction because he though t
that the "loan" characterization would allow . him to r ealize 90 .

Z

k

11In some instances Deriviumi's clients have requested th e
return of stock . The parties stipulated that Derivium'- :s failur e
to" return .the' stock has r esulted in a number of lawsuits ; e .g . ,
The Lee Family Trust v . Derivium Capital L .L .C . , U .S . Distric t
Court, District of South Carolina , Robert G . Sabelhaus v .
Derivium Capital , U .S . District Court, District of Sout h
Caroli na, The Ha mmond Family 1994, L ..P -v . Diversi fied Design ,
.U .S . District Court, District of'South Carolina, Newton Famil y
L .L .C . v. . .DeriviumCapital ,~U .S . District Court, District o f
Wyoming,, WCN/GAN Partners, Ltd . ,v .',Charles_Cathcart .U S
.District Court,-'District .of-Wyoming, Derivium Capital L .L .C . v .
General Holdings Inc . . , U .S .,District Court, District of South .'
Carolina, Grayson . v . Cathcart , U .S~. District .. Court,` District of
South Carolina . On Sept .,1,1-2005, Derivium filed a-ch . 1 1
bankruptcy : petition, and on Nov . 4, 2005,-the .case wa .s~converted .
to ch . 7 and-venue was moved to South Carolina .

21
,percent of the value, of the . stock, whereas a ."sale " would hav e
netted only 80 percent .of the.stock's value after payment of ta x
on the , gain After the transfer petitioners-,did-not conduc t
themselves as if ; the transaction was a ,loan . Petitioners did not .
report-dividends earned on the 990 shares of,IBM stock on their
Federal income tax returns . When petitioners decided :not'to, ,
"repay the ;loan" in 2004, they did not ..report a sale ,of the stoc k
on their .2004, Federal :income tax return and, 'failed to~ report an y
discharge_of, requisite . false'-'-or -fraudulent
statements concerning 'the tax benefits of-'
participation ."
Unit ed States v . Raymond, 228 F .3d
804, 811 (7 h C r . 200.0) "Congress designed"'sectio n
.670-0 , as-a- `penalty provision specifically directe d
toward promoters of . abusive' tax shelters ' and other ,
abusive tax avoidance schemes .,'':' : United ..States .v .
White , .769 F .2d 511, 515 ( .8th-"Cir . . 1985) (emphasis i n
original )

In,, an order dated -September 22, 200 .9', the -distric t
court granted in 'part and denied-.Lin,..par.t,`-Defendants '
motions . for, ,summary Judgment'- The :court found that the
undisputed evidence revealed'-that4 : as part of-th e
.loan transactio n
. :in question ; : ' .legal` title of a
customer'-s securities . transfers to Derivium USA-,(for
example) during-the purported loan term in question,
which vests possession of the shares in Derivium' s
hands for the duration ., of at'he``purported loan- term ; tha t
the customer must- 'transfer 100% . of .al°l shares o f
.securities to Derivium USA, and- that-once-transferred ,
_Derivium USA `sells, those- shares "'on the -tiopen' market, an d
that once 'sold ., .Derivium USA .rtransfers 90 0 Hof that sale .
amount` to the . customer as the, "'loan"'. amount, keepin g
10% in Derivium USA's hands ; :-that during the term'-o f
the loan,-the Master -Loan Agreement-provides : tha t
Derivium USA has the .. 'right to y receive ' all -benefits tha t
come from disposition of-the .customer's securities, an d
that the customer is not entitl:ed .to these benefits . ;
that the customer, is furthermore prohibited fro m
repaying . the-- loam amount prior .to maturity and'- is no t
required =to pay any 'i ;riterest"'before the oan`maturi,t y
date ;S and '-that', at the- end of the purported loan term ,
the ° custom er .is.-not, required- to repay' the amount= of the
Goan (but-merely " allowed to do so - as one option at th e
(continued . .

s (' .,. continued )
'loan' s maturity date )°: and can exercise the -option :t o
walk= away from the , loan :entirely at 'the maturity dat e
'without repaying the principl-e ; and thus,Yca n
conceivably walk away ,from the transaction : withou t
paying interest .r at ;a11 on the loan .
4The, following .factual' findings%arex .taken_;
di:rect'y from . Judge . , Hamilton '.-s' Order , dated .
September Docket No . . 333 .
Thedistr:ict court concluded that arialysiso
, _,
these and other : undisputed ;: facts pursuant` to ;either th e
benefits/burdens ' approach' outlined in Gr.odt & McKay
Realty , Inc .- :v. . Commissioner of Internal Re4drid6,
T . C 1221, 1236 . (Tax " Court 19 ;81 ),, or 'the approach . I '
outlined in Welch v . Comm r, 204 F .'3d 12281230 '(9t h
Cir 2000), compelled the conclusion that th e
transactions in question constituted sales o f
securities, rather than bona fide Than transactions .
See e .'a ": Grodt -, 77 T . C .- .'at : 1236-37 (applying°multifactor :.test to determine point at which : the burdens and
benef its the pertinent 'facts-an d
'circumstances

. H.igbee v .

C ommissioner ,

supra at

44'8 ; sec . .

1 . 6664-4 ;(b)- (l ) -," . Income Tax Reg s
As previously noted, petitioners'.did .not .report their annua l
dividends from their .IBM .stockwhic h were, under their version o f
the transaction, credited yearly against their interest du e
Derivium .- -A .payment of'the dividends by, IBM, under their versio n
of the$,transaction,- would have created_ :taxable .income, to them .
Further, in 20 .04 they , did not~ .report the sale-of their :-IBM stoc k
an y gain . from that transaction,"~ nor,,did they report any relie f
=indebtedness ih:come .`These .-:failures were inconsistent wit h

some circumstarice.s,

a taxpayer may avoid liabilit y
showing reasonable relianc e

competent . professional , adviser` .-

Tigers Eve' Trading ;:; _L .. L . C .

v . Commissioner ,` T .C . Memo . .2009-121
Boyle , .. supra at 250-251 .,, and Freytag v`.. Commissioner , ,89 T . C
849,- 888

(Fl987)," affd' . 904

U . S . 868. ( .1991))

F 2d 10.11 (5th'_ Cir . . 1990), affd . 501

. .For relianc e on professional advice: to excus e
the accuracy-related penalty, the . taxpayer mus t

show that 'the . professional had fthe :requisi'te' expertise, as .- wel l
as knowledge of the pertinent' . facts, to-provide informed advic e
`See' David~'v . Commissioner , ;43 F ."3 d

789-790 .(2d , Cir'. 1995;), affg .°- :on'-`a short ' sale ; 'and petitioner ' was' i n
position of-the securit-ies,-lender who :lends his stock` to mak e
that de l

ive ry possible .,,

It

i's-

e nbugh ',f or me' th at petitioner 'gav e

Derivium' the ri .ght, ;and "authority to"° sell ''the ''IBM -common . .stock in,
question ,for. its -own -account-, which- . Derivium ^in `fact did . 3

Th e

nonrecourse nature of,petitioner'sa-obligation"to`repay Derivium ,
almost every `other -factor considered by the` majority- t o

the point

-Petit oner dis p osed-of the -stock i n- 2001 . '

2Professor _Raskolnikov builds' his ,analysis .; on xa. seminal .
discussion of the fundamental difference between tax ownership of
fungible and,, . .nonfungibleassets by now„ Professor Edward
Kleinbard . See Kleinbar d
., "Risky and Riskles .s Positions i n
Securities 71 Taxes 783,-,(1993) .,.
3Apparently, . .Judge Ho^Lme's and ; I ,differ on whether .petitioner
disposed'of his stock on Aug'. 16, 2001, when Morgan Keegan
creditedDerivium's account . with the IBM . stock petitioner
transferred, or'on the .next day, .; Aug .17, 2001, when Derivium
sold that stock . Although I_,have--no authority-addressing that
point, '1 think that, consistent .with~ Provost v . United States ,
269 U, .S . . 443 (1926), petitioner disposed-,of the , IBM .-stock 1 on-th
e
1
prior date ; i .e ., thedate he gave Derivium both' the right an d
authority' to . sell the _ stock . , .:- .I . do_, not ,believe that applying ,a
similar rule ao transactions intended to be securitizations
, .,constitutes a-- change in ..the . law, as, Judge, Holmes : believes .
Holmes op . note 1 . In . any event,'-sec . 1058 establishes a .,broa d
'safe-harbor to shelter many securitizations .

- 44
Without more, that would constitute
year .

See sec .

a realization even t

tha t

1001 ( a) . Petitioner correctly makes , no . clai m

that section 1058 .; saves . him from recognition of-Income . -Se e
Samueli-v . Commissioner , 132 T .C . 37, 49, (2009) .-(sectio n
1058 (b) .(3;),.," requires that the lender be able to .deman d
-return

the lent securities ) .

a

promp t

We need only determine whethe r

.the calculation,-of gain or loss mu-st remain open, await-iryg th e
determination-of+whether petitioner closed the transactio n i n
'2004 by- .acquiring IBM common stock from Derivium . thin k not .
Petitioner relies on Rev . Rul . 57-451, 1957 :- 2 C . B ;. „:295 ,
wh ich addresses whether a taxpayer holding stock receive d
-pursuant to the ;, exercise of a restricted stock option make s a
disqualifying disposition of that stock when he{"lends" th e

0 4t

roker in

stoc k

transaction that would qualify as a dispositio n

-under th e analysis of Provost v . United States ,- supra . :

Th e

ruling concludes9that whether there is a disqualifying
disposi`tion'turns"on whether, at the end of'the loan transaction ,
the taxpayer receives from the broker stock that would

qualif y

or nonrecognition of gain or loss under section 1036 .

Th e

pertinent fact s of the ruling are distinguishable-fro m 'the fact s
of this-case because, in consideration for - his stock ,

t

,taxpayer in-the ruling appears to have received nothing other '
than "the personal obligation, wholly contractual, of th e
`borrowing'-°custbmer to restore him, on 'demand,

t6
h economic

:position in .which he ,,,would -have been . as'-,owner ,ofl .the stock, had

the`,loan .'., ztransaction not been entered into .-' Rev ., .-Rul- . 57-451 ,
1957=2 .C .B . . at .297 . Perhaps the, Commi ssioner thought the' , ry
transaction, remained .open because . of-,the dis .tinct,s possibilit y

.:that, . .a;part .tf;rom ; the borrowing broker'- S, -contractual, obligation ,
the -taxpayer -would receive ; onl-y , stock that would---qualify any gai n
(or loss ). for ., nonrecognition-,under section 1036 .
United States , 602'- .,F .2d` 1341 ,

Cf

Starker v . ' .

1'35 :5, (,9th= .Cir . ,19,79)

(nonsimultaneous : transfer, quali-f .i .es as ;_,like-kind- exchang e ., .[e ] ven
if ,.the-- contr:ac t right- includes the,- possib ility of the taxpaye r
.receiving,somethin g other tha n ownership of like-kind pr,ope ,rty")' . ,
,The .. -ruling ;'may ,be o f limited significance for anothe r
reason-,, .. since

,addresse s

a . definition of. "disposition limite d

urposes,-., of determining whether, tthere-has been a : .di•spositio n
of stoc k received, pursuant . , to a-Fre,stricted,stock option .,,, The ,
rules governing restricted -- stock ;: options, were found tin' section.
.421 before its amendment by the Revenue Act of 1964, Pub- .
272, sec . 22101 . 78

L . 88 .-

Stat .. 63, and subsection (d)(4) thereof defined .

"disposition" as a sale , , exchange , gift, or transfer. of . lega l
title but not, among other things," an . exchange to which section
1036 .applies . .4 The ruling contains insufficient analysis for m e
to extend it beyond its unique circumstances .

4A similar, rule can now be found in sec . 424(c)(1)(3) .
Neither' rule mentions transfers of securities for which no -gai n
is recognized pursuant to sec . . '1058 .

- 46IT'agree` with respondent that petitioner realize d
di°sposition of the

IBM comm on

stock

in 2001 .

The

partie s

that the adjusted basis in the stock was .'$2l,`17 1
Resporident .ldetermined that petitioner ' s realized - gain,

in ' 2001 ,

wasp $.72 ; ,435`, ; because respondent allowed him to -deduct ' from th e
amount realized not only his adjusted basis but als6f$10,- 3
,,denominated in respondent's calculation as "cost'of sale '
Respondent further determined that petitioner must'recogn-iz e
long=term capital gain) in 2001 . I agree that ,
petiti"over must recognize his gain in 2001 . It seems t o
however,, thatthe "cost of sale", $10,399,probably represent s
costTofithe sale but the nondeductible value-$of"the optio n
that ` allowed' petitioner (if he wished) to buy 990" shares of -IB M
cominon stock from Derivium in 2004 for $124, 429 plus,'" perhaps ,

-WHERRY,' J ., agrees with this concurring op,ihi'on .

A7HOLMES , J : : ; concurring " i

Derivium` agreed to` what Calloway claims was a nonrecourse "loa n
secured? by his= stock .'- In exchange for money,- Callowa y
transferred .acontrol of the` stock to Deriviuin .

Derivium sold th e

stock on the open market . •The
apply .

Section 1 .10.0 .1-2 (a) ,(4) .(i) :, ',Income Tax Regs . provides

that "the , sal e

*

*

liability
Commissioner''v . Tufts", 461, U .S . 300, 308-0 9
Commissioner , ` '331 U . S . 1, 12=1' 3
realized includes 4any1`nonrecozrse liability secured' by the '
property sold . Calloway would- then have to-recognize the
difference

between- the - discharged debt (i .e ., the . amount of the

loan- .proceeds p1u one day's accrued iiiterest minus--hisbasis i n
the stock) "
That would be enough to-solve the
this- case ." The majority (admittedly a

behest)- :instead- goes ; off on a frolicand~detour through a n
inappropriate`multif.actor test,"oapplie s
ends . up reaching' an overly broad-holding with potentially harmfu l
effects-on other °areas -of law .

.,The ,key : mistake the-,majority-make s
ransactions as one . =,These'~-two` transactions

purported

- 48
loan'as .set .,forth in the Master Agreement and Derivium! s
secret sale of Calloway ' s stock to an unr elated party .
they characterization of the first transaction- ,the=or e_ tha t
Calloway actually knew about because he signed the .Maste r
:Agreement --that should . be our focus .

The subsequent sale,- thoug h

'it,'must .be analyzed for its own tax consequences,j,,should', -no t
affec t our : characterization of the purported loan-Accor d
v . Derivium Capital, LLC , No . 02AS05849 (Cal . Super . C t
12003),("While the immediate liquidation of the secu .rity_-may=hav e
many , untowardimpacts upon the parties to the transaction,, thos e
potential

impacts have no apparent relevance to,the„ .bona fid e

majority concludes that the initial tran sfer, of stoc k
sale without ever findin g
that Calloway knew that Derivium would sell the stock ; .
« ; collateraizing the loan . Its holding is that Derivium' s
to sell was a :sale . Collapsing Derivium's contractual'righ t
into the subsequent sale would be appropriate

if .'Callowa y

,was splintering one transaction into two for .no other purpos e
than . to .avoid ,. taxes--where the transactions were

otherwis e

interdependent, and focused toward a'particula r
Pierre v . Commissioner , T .C . Memo . 2010-10 6
step ' , transaction doctrine) ( citing Commissioner ,y .FaClar k
U'. S . .72,6, - 738,: . (198 9)) . But here, where Derivium,represented , to

that itvintended to .hold :the stock and never,-,tol d
them of, the quick sale, one cannot . say. that these transactions
were integrated . or .-interdependent, .
.IL .
-arrive at it .s-,,destination', ;, the, majority uses Grodt~, &
'McKay Realty, Inc . v . Commi ssioner , 77r T . C, . . 1221 (1981) .
Grodt & McKay. , we.:thad- to distinguish between a . sal'e and -a sham
involving- ,the purpor.ted, sale . !of cattle' . Ina this case,

:the :

parties aren't arguing , about whether there was a ,sale= or a -sham,
but about whether• there' was a sale . or, .a loan . If, we are going t o
compare apples .to oranges,,we could just as . easily use the tes t
for .: ddistinguishing a loan from :;compensation- in Haag .v' .
Commissioner ,' 88 T,; .C . 604 ; : . 616 n . .6,-(19.87 .) , affd .- withou t
published, opinion 855,; F 2d 855 . (8th Cir . 1.988 ), or the . test for
distinguishing a loan from stock redemption-in- Rogers-v .' Unite d
`281'F .3d 1108

(10th Cir . . 2002), 'but 'those tests, too ,

containT'irrelevant
a

essence of the distinction we need" to-'make in this case .

Grodt &

McKay is , just the wrong test for analyzing ' this " transaction, . ,

borrow from tests that may b`e,-otherwise inapplicable,if .we

Memo .

1998 -121, for

- 50 -

example a,set s out the defining characteristics,of :
seven Ifa'ctors that courts have considered ,

none o f which woul d

'have to .'be dismissed as inapplicable to this case .
A good test should also reflect the nature of the,propert y
involved to;.determine the relevant factors, the 'proper "weight fo r
factor,' and whether any additional factors-would' .:be :useful .
'See, e :~g . - Torres v . Commissioner , 88 T .C . 702, 721-22 . (198 7
20.03 -7 2003 - 1 C .B . 363 .

The majority starts=down-th e

;right 'paths by ,excluding payment of property taxes' as' a
ownership'°( recognizing its inapplicability tos€bck) ,
7,,but then it stops short, not analyzing th e
significant` :differences between the fungible an d
property'at'issue in this case and the nonfungible ;. .an d tangibl e
~property":;at issue in Grodt & McKay .' One would think

"
Judge Halpern does recognize this important difference, an d
(following some quite persuasive commentators ) urges "1us .to'adop t
"control' :' as .tne essential attribute of determining thew,ta x
ownership of`securities . See Halpern op . p .'43 . In ,' ;host al l
tax .contexts, the concept of control as the touchstone'of,,
ownershipseems much better than the ever-pliable multifacto r'
tests : that dominate .the field . I also agree with . him that i t
Of fers ,i" much better path in explaining the casela w',''at least '
before today's result . But it does not adequately-distinguish ,
as I"explain below,"between secured interests in stock "an d
outright . transfers of ownership . Maybe it makes sens .e,to,, _
'obliterate 'this distinction, and treat all secured interests in

securities as,sales if there's been an effective change i n
control over them, but that big a change is one for th e
legislative branch, not us, to make . In the meantime , we,should
do our b es .t°, to come up with a way to distinguish secured ' loan s
from~sales even when modern conditions make the distinctio n
2
(continued .

tha t
iskn't,, See,,:; e . g ,

United : -Natl . . Corp .° . v .

Commissione r , 33 B .T .A .

790 ( .1935) : (findingp-_ .a4 100-percent loam on the, value.,-ofstock ,
characterized ;by-the'participants as a
sale, was 'in fact a loan). ; ~Fisher V,. ¢Commissi_oner ,

a loan) .

The Gr.o :d.t- &- McKay ;tes, might :be helpful . i141 the majority .
adapted I

o match the actual- facts:,of-,this . case =.instead_, .o=f° 3

applying, it without consideration ofr how, shares of .. stock d
rfrom ; .livest :ock rvand " how3 dist hgu skiing , a loan 5;from a` sale-, i
different from .d stinguishing -a, sale .from : aM:s"ham .

. ..Consider: :

Title - and, Possession ?.„ The 'clumsiness , of ., using . Grodt & . McKa y
most stri~ki,ngr,in its -,-focus and' possession .

Thes e

factors ,don't 'jibe well, tw th .'the way stock isY actually: held .
far-,=back- as 190.8, e in, .Richardson , v .,.° Shaw ,t'•the' Supreme Cour t
realized that a shareholder :could retain ownership without titl e
r 'possession when a, .broker purchased and held the shares for th e

shareholder' s . account :
[ I ] n' no just sense can the broker be held t o be they .
owner of. the' shares 7of stock which he purchases anVd '
carries - for his ' c'ustomer . * .

.. continued )
1(
sometimes hard- ; to - figure out` .

- 52 *
* * * Upon settlement of the account * * * [the broker ]
receives the securities . In this case the broker . `
:,assumed 'to pledge the stocks * * * because by the .°terms
of the contract * * * he obtained the right from th e
customer: to pledge the securities upon general'lo`ans,'
andinlike manner he secured the privilege of sellin g
,Vwhe.n necessary for his protection .
365, 377-78 (1908) .
Stock ownership today is even farther removed from =tangibleproperty concepts like title and possession owing to the rapi d
evolution, of the indirect holding system . The official`!'titl e
holder of°,most publicly traded securities, and . possessor ;
nphysical ;-stock certificates, is Cede . & Co . --"thenominee
,used`. by . ,The Depository Trust Company ("DTC") , a limited` purpos e
trust : company organized under New York law for the ;purpos e
acting, as-, a depository to hold securities for . the benefi t
pa-rticipants, some 600 or so broker-dealers and banks ." "
art . & (•1 .994 )y -(prefatory note ) .

The U . C . C .' s drafter s

that somewhere between sixty and eighty percent : of 'publicl y

ZThe American Law Institute and the National Conference o f
Comm issioners on Uniform State Laws have often had to revisit : th e
;problems caused by the rapid changes in the securities"industry .
Their` most recent revision of Article 8 was "to eliminat e
uncertainties by providing a modern legal struc .turefor`•curren t
securities holding practices," U .C .C . art . 8 (1994 .)a(prefatory
note), and "to eliminate the uncertainty and confusion that5,.
results from attempting to apply common law possession concept s
to ,modern securities holding practices ."
Id .' sec . ^ 8-106 ' cmt . .*7 .
It would be wise for courts in other areas of Taw`= to acknowledge
these parallel efforts to accomm odate changes - in,the r'e'al world .

T

- .5 3
yoiu u hold;
carry or.£maintain in or tor any of my margin or short Account s
* *', * ,without retaining in your possession or under, your,-,contro l

;for delivery the same amount of similar securities ,, or : othe r
property. The value of the securities and other property tha t
you,maypledge, repledge, hypothecate or re-hypothecate mayb e
greater than the amount I owe you ." TD Ameritrade, .,Clien t
r,Agreement ;,;http ://www .tdameritrade .com/forms/AMTD182 .pdf ; se e
also Pershing, Credit Advance Margin Agreement, .
.https // www .uvest . c o' m/pdf / Margino20Accounto20A.greement =..pof ; .Zecc o
Trading ; Margin Application , https :// www .zecco . com/forms /marginapplication/ DownloadForm .aspx .

55
party . .'.- See-id .

sec .- .9 -207),`cmt 6, Otxample) ,x'(2000) .

This, makes

secured-lending collat6ralized by securities look. very similar t o
a sale if :.r measured= by title and possession =

. .;

S'e'e, e . g .

id .-

sec .

8-106 . :cmt" . ti4
Obligation : to Deliver Deed . Perhaps the most striking, proo f
.of the inaptness"of ' Grodt"& McKay for this-,-case- is its' attention
to "whether' the_c&ntractt-C'.reates,a_present' .-obligationon th e
seller 'to execute and` deliver a deed` `and' a- present' obligation' on
the . purchaser, to "make payments .

Grodt''&' McKay , : 77 T .'C . at', 1237 .

The . majority construes ` this ° :to mean- an, obligation by Calloway ' t o
transfer scontrol~-of his stock'and -ofth e
` parties't,,agreement follows the guidelines in section l058 ;(b)4 :,the n
(continued ., .)

Opti=on-s -of, Chi . 3-Inc . , ' 143 F .3 d 8Q7,;,,. _818 -,(3d Cir . 19'98 )
(then-Circuit .Judge' Alito)
holding-=wha t

money nwa.s nonreco:urse . and `'Derivium` -had . the : authority to sell '
after . taking possession-, of the -stock ._ Given modern conditions i n

'which, a ` .lender' s .'authority - .toysellt stock -is routine and even
necessary ., the real : effect: of the holding would be to° treat al l
noncecour"se :' lending, against` .stock collateral as sale"s . The
majority, does:, not appear to . realiz e how startling`•,that , would

JV .
The Grodt :~& McKay- test ; = like-Fother- .transaction"tests,' als o
notes that , the intention-; of .,wthe parties 'governs the true natur e

6( :

. continued )

the Code says no, gain or loss need be recognized by-the stock .
owner at the time of the initial transfer . _'Sec'. 1058 ( a) Thi s
section,, generally is applied-to allow margin brokers to-engage i n
short ` sales without tax` coiisequences to the stock owners .

Section 1058 would mitigate-the effect of the majority' s
holding, if the right too sell was commonly limited to . short . .'s .ales
or other transa°dtions that fit'into the confines of section
1058(b) . But as, discussed above,, stock ; owners,: also customarily
give a secured lenderthe right to sell for the lender's ow n
protection--e .g .,,,to, cover margin calls, or repay a .loan in
,default . If a secured lender sells the underlying stock'for on e
of}these. reasons, then any. obligation to_return.identica l
securities is typically replaced with an obligation to apply th e
proceeds, of the csale „to the outstandin
debt- - .See, e .g ., . U . C_ C .
t
s ec :`9 =207
(c) (2) p
(2000),
he. transaction
This rips
he
from, th e

protection of ,section . 1'058,

see ff sec .

1058 (b) .(1) , and renders the

initial transfer'-taxable` under the ' m' ajo-rity'- s analysi s

64 of a transaction .

Grodt & McKay , 77 T .C . at 1237 ;, seeMals o

Welch , 204 F . 2d at 1230 ;

United Natl .,

33 B .T .A . at-"7. 94";,i Fi'sher ,

440 ., Intent is seen by courts "as evidencedby the "
written agreements read in light of the attending fact s
circumstances

Grodt & McKay , 77 T .C . at 1237 (citatio n

omitted) . If the test is stated that generally, no one can '
disagree .

:But in addition to the problems caused 'by .' :this4 tes t

this : case, . the majority does not analyze the effect of . deception . ..
We are confronted here with one party who was not .;being'ho.nes t
.,withthe ;other about its intentions . (The Commissioner admit s
generally that Derivium told its customers that it intended,to '
hold,.thestock and hedge against the upside risk via a.,proprietary trading strategy . Reqs . for Admis . 264, 276 .)ra „
Despite the importance of intent in these tests, the majorit y
doesn't address what effect deception has on .the characterizatio n
of .th'e 'transaction .
eception`should have been considered at a minimum under the t
Grodt & McKay factor regarding the parties' treatment of th e
'transaction, but the majority merely notes that the, parties '
treatment was inconsistent with a loan because uallow a

that he knew he had authorized Derivium to sell his,stock
knowledge, however, is not inconsistent with a nonrecours e ,;loan .
secured by fungible collateral--such a provision is,standard
brokerage .and custodian account agreements where stock"secures a

See - supra` note-4` . The majority fails to mention tha t
' .Calloway. testified .that ." he .•"did,not know Derivium had sold the "
quarterly' lies that it stil l
-held the collateral 'and credited .the amount of-dividends'paid t o
reduceCalloway's ;interest oblig=ation : That, too,=however, wa s
part of the .'-conduct of{ the partie s
The majority` Simi{larly notes that, Calloway was never
required- to . .-repay- any principal 'or interest, but this also is .,
consistent wi'th the : loan terms-'!-payment at the 'end .

n onrecourse loan with a'ba`lloo n

.' We have = recognized' . parties' rights t o

structure loans`Eas they se e

fit, : even allowing- for- zero interest .

' Welch -, 2-04 ,"F`.3d& at 1 .230 ' (quoting' Commissioner-,v". Valley Morri's
Plan , 305 F .2d 610, 618 (9th% Cir . :1962), revg . 33 T .C . 572 (1959 )
and Morris Plan Co . v . Commissioner, 33 T .C . 720 (1960)) ; se e
also . Robinson, -- supra , at 9 ;-(°"Nonrecourse loans created by contrac t
can -take whatever :' formmeets `the' needs of-the parties") And w e
note that- .`even''if the' . taxpayer" does not pay interest during th e
loan term, upon satisfaction of the, debt"the full amount of `th e
part of th e
v
Tufts , 4 61~ U .S .-at, -;308-.09 :, , Crane - 331 U S ' :: at 12-13= and section
1 .1001-2,(a), Income T'ax •Regs .- Accord' Allan v . Commissioner ; 86
T .C . 655, 666-67 `(1986), affd .856 F .2d 1169 (8th Cir . 1988) .
.There for,e,'ythe taxpayer pays taxes o.n . .d_fscharged inter=est,,so it

66 Finally, the majority notes that the parties did' .not .-treat
gas ,a ;loan because the exact loan amount was not ` fixed .unti l
afte r Derivium determined the proceeds it would receive from :
This factor should not impute knowledgek .t o
-Calloway that Derivium was selling the stock, however ., because it
was consistent with the terms of the agreement . Schedule .A-l, ,
Property Description and Loan Terms, stated that the total loa n
amount. . would be "90% of the market value on closing" .a,ndMclosing
was,to take place "upon receipt of securities and establishmentof * . * * [Derivium's] hedging transactions ." This isno
different from a home equity line of credit whose preciselimit
depends on an appraisal and subsequent loan-to-value calculat .ion'.
VI .

. Even . if . we didn't want to accept Calloway' s deal ash a-_loanomits face, we should at least use a more sensible=multifacto r
test-here . -Taking the factors from Welch and the old BTA=cases '
would yield a different result :
Existence of Promissory Note .' While there is no ;promissory .
note, the "Master Agreement to Provide Financing and, Custodia l
,Services" .bears the markings of a loan agreement .

'Welch v . Commissioner , 204 F .3d 1228,

1230

The ;,;recitals '

(9th Cir . 2000 )

(existence of debt instrument), affg . T .C . Memo . 1998=121Fishe r
v . Commissioner , 30 B .T .A . 433, 440 (1934) (contents of debt
instrument) .

67 in . .the contract,- :use -loan , languages , 'speci'fying. : "This Agreemen t
is made *

t'o prov;id e

custodial service s
properties, : and ; assets

or

arrange :f inancing (s) and to provid e

;[petitioner ] ., with 'respect'..-to certai n
:
be~'T;pledged . as security . The .

services .promised ; in Section- 1, include

•"

[p]roviding` or arranging .

financing by ._ way of . one or, more lo ans ",and "[h]'olding l cash, .
securities, or=other, -liquidh assiet. s

*

;indicating initial-. treatment, ,as ;a- .loan .

*. as collateral,",-action s
Section 9 binds th e

parties and, their-,assigns .',i Schedule A-1 . lists . theinterest rate ,

maturity_ date,. ., a d other terms°x of'iathew loan . ,T This documen t
therefore . acts : at least=formally as a- debt: instrument .
Observing Formalities, .of¢Loan .8' ..:The, .parties' ; continuin g
course . of deal-ing also ., supp.orts . a 'finding that they intended' to
create a ioan',because .they followed-° through with the loa
. Derivium, .senlt-,Ca1-lowayx,,quarterly account statement
nformalites
s
.showing the ; : amount of, interest accrued, _,the loan, .,-balance, .. the "
maturity-,date,,: and- they. pro_j ected balance at maturity . Those ,
statements show that Derivium actually-did add interest to th e
loan,balance•., The quarter :Ly.. statements and the end-of-quarter
loan balance ; reflect interest - accruing at th e'", :agreed -'rate .'
Derivium ; even sent Calloway .-a '"notice that the 4~loan term was '

8 See United` :Natl . Co± .p ." v . Commissioner,
(1..935) .

33 B .T .A . 790, 794

68 :rending,°and inquired as to what Calloway intended,to`do .
responded that he intended to surrender his collateral :
c Interest Payments or Loan Repayment .9 It's certainly . true "
that'Derivium' s loans were structured to provide for a'bal'loon

.

payment .° ., :But we have seen loans without interim interest :
payments before . At one time, lenders tried to getaway fro m
paying income tax on interest income by giving "original- -issue .
discounts" instead of charging interest . Lenders would extenda a
supposedly interest-free $95 loan, for example, but then require :
the borrower to :repay $100 at the end of the term . ' See' Traveler s
Ins . Co v . United States , 25 Cl . Ct . 141, 143 (1992 )
caught on and enacted section 1281(a), which imputes interest:
.income to`holders of original-issue-discount securities ,
demonstrating that interest can accrue without actual payment :
dur ng .the loan term and without turning the loan into•=a sal e
See,'also~ United States v . Midland-Ross Corp . , 381 U .S 54 ,

66(1965) . A loan isn't even required to bear any interes t
all if the .parties agree .

Welch , 204 F .3d at 1230 (citation s

omitted) . The Commissioner may have a stronger point if
terms of . .,.thepurported loan called for interest payment s
Calloway. didn't pay . But nonpayment of interest according towthe
terms of the agreement is unpersuasive .

9Welch , 204 F. .3d at 1230-31 .

.yar d
.Duty : to RepayCommissioner ; says' Deri.vium'"s transactions weren't loans becaus e
the customers had the right to walk away . But'Calloway didn' t
have the right to :walk' away- `:scot ..,free-=he had t .o sur-render hi s
discussed above ,

loan .

.the duty'to`repay and reasonabl e

See. supra . .pt .' . IV .-A . ~ .' Nonrecourse ' loans ' have satisfie d

these . tests if, atthe beginning's ofa the ''loan, it makes economi c
sens e 'for :the .borrower"t
Sufficient Funds- to ;: Make -Loan,.,11 Our cases also tell -u s
that if -a"lender'doesn't have sufficient funds to make the loa n
at hand, .then the t ransaction 'i s-more ` like a sale

Welch,-20 4

scam got going, ` Deriviumrv had ,sufficient funds on hand until the .
whole thing collapsed .

The record is'''clear that Derivium sen t

Calloway fund's'-before, it `received" they proceeds from the' IB M
stock, so the -'loan-I could not" have been "funded by the sale . -- Se e
majority op . ' : p . 9'- ("On August 2l-`-- ;2,00l, Derivium sent, t o
petitioner aletter ' 'info'rming him that ` the proceeds of the loa n
were sent to him
transfer

10Id

was

received

On that same date, a $93,586 .23 wir e
and

credited

to

petitioner's

United Nati . , 33 B .T .A . at 79 .6 .

1'We ch.,

204 F :3d'wat ` -1230

account

*

*

70 *

") ; majority op . p . 8 ("On August 22, 2001, the ne t

from , the sale of the IBM stock settled into Deriviumf s
Keegan . account .") .
Ratio of Price Paid to Property Value .12 Without ;.other-

evidence, ; if ,a lender lends full price for the purported- ,
collateral . it looks like a sale .

United Natl . Corp . , 33 B . .T .A .

at .797. . But . .. at what discount should the court infe r
parties intended a loan? In Fisher , the Board of Tax,Appeals' .
noted that ;a purchase for substantially less than-fair--market"

"

value may .allow the Court to rescind a sale from an oppressiv e
"lender",,,,but a small discount coupled with the right to t
repurchase "does not signify that a loan was intended .''. ;
B .T .A .at 441 . The discount in that case was not enough t o
.recharacterize the purported sale as a loan . This is admittedl y
a,-closerquest-ion, but when one of Derivium's customers :didn'
receive full price for his shares and doesn't ask us to .changethe formal characterization of the transaction, I think thi s
factoris consistent with intent to take out a loan, or~at,leas t
-insufficient to recharacterize the loan as a sale .

12 United Natl . , 33 B .T .A . at 797 ;

Fisher , 30 B .T .A>..-at 44 .1 .

71
Derivium' s Intent and Conduct . "

the various tests . in the-, casellaw requir e
But "intent" .,:is notexact :ly th e

.conduct of both .cparties

word what-we-think we should b e
parties . to a :deal is :,trying to,
prom ses,of a secret,hedgng_strategyand its continual flow o f
false

statements to tits customers, , suggest to any . reasonabl e

-observer`i

hindsight, that ., its intent' was- ..not to make eithe r

loan'or a sale , but a quick theft of 10 percent of the . stock' s
value .- taut L)erivium, s

to

a .C

other litigation . show .. a desir e

least publicly- represent their transactions as loans . .,

E . .g,,r Derivium Capital LLC v .--United States Trustee, 97 AFTR2 d
2006-2582 (S . ..D .N,.Y . 2006)~,(stating that-California court grante d
summary judgment motion declaring-transactions

were loans

that Derivium ; .intended,to file-~bankruptcy motion . to ge t
determination -that transactions were-loans, not sales) .

no doubt ..that . the facts of this . case , are ugly .
relied on a promoter in`entering the transaction ,
testified the transaction was tax motivated, and didn't repor t
consistently with his own characterization of the transaction b y

13Welch -

; 204, F .-2d _ at ; 1230 ; United Natl : , '33 B .T .A . at, 794 ;
.Fisher , x 30 B .T .A- . at 440 ; see .-also Grodt &= McKay Realty: ; Inc . 'v .
Commissioner , .77 T .C . 12211: 1237 ` :.( 19.81)- .,.

- 72 -

failing to recognize dividends paid on the co.llate.rth L
during the .loan term and the disposition of the stock as'a

sal e

fore the' amount of the accrued debt at the close of the mloani~ .A`:1
These .°facts ., while supporting the result in this case, may differ
significantly from cases where Derivium's customers .were_dupes
rather than, at least to some degree, in on the con . Never mind,,
says=,the majority, in both classes of case, the initial transfe r
of stock from a customer's account to Derivium's is asal e
tax :.purposes . 1 4
:But-to return to where I began, this case and all th e
°Derivium cases should be easy . If there was a bona fid e
. nonrecourse loan, followed by the sale of collateral , .. the ta x
rules are : clear . According to section 1 .1001-2(a)(4)

Income

Tax Regs . ., "the sale * * * of property that secures .=a nonrecours e
liability . discharges the transferor from the liability ." And .
when a nonrecourse liability is discharged by sale of collateral ,
the borrower must recognize income at that point--the amoun t
realized ' is .the amount of nonrecourse

liability discharged as a ,

"These worries are somewhat alleviated by the majority' s
appropriately narrow application of the penalties . In finding,
for the Commissioner on that issue, the majority relies
exclusively on Calloway's personal treatment of the transactio n
reliance on a promoter, and his failure to prove reasonabl e
reliance on other professionals .

the'.. sale.'5=k `Tufts , .461-U,. S . at 308 - 09

Crane , 331 U .S .

1986 -141 (treatin g
stamp collection=as sold : -b'y `taxpayer .1 in "year pawnbroaker sold i t
.
a S .-0 pposed to :year taxpayer` received 'money from pawnbroker )
first transaction then,,wdul-d°not be a recognition event fo r
Calloway'. but `Deriv um' s sale-=even its' secret sale= would .1 6

event s

flowing 'from,-t-he `result reached- by the majority .17

15The -timing of the recognition event would be .the same i f
the loan were' a recourse loan, but there are some differences in .
tax treatment, when a recour.se, loan is, satisfied by . ;the- sale o f
collateral for less than the debt amount . t In that case the stoc k
owner. would recognize gain or . 1oss of the sale . price less his
basis, plus cancellation-of-debt income in the amount of the .deb t
forg ven .; ;less the sale .p.rice .H See Gehl v . Commissioner , 10 .2,T C .
784, 789-90 (1994), affd . without published opinion 50 F .3d 12
(8th Ci'r . 1995) ;, sec . 1= . 1001-2,(a)-,,,,In-come, Tax Regs . ; ., Rev . Rul- .
90-16, 1990-1 C .B . 12 . The-cancellation-of-debt income woul d
potentiallyA be ; subj ect-.. .to- an, insolvency exclusion .
See sec .
108 (a ) (1) (B) .

noted above,,while . a,secured ,,party~holds securities, as betwee n
.the two the debtor is conside red the owner . of the securities .
U . C . sec- . a 9-20 .7 cmt< .. 6 -( Example ) ..- But .if . then securedy partysells the underlying securities "by virtue of the debtor's
consent or applicable legal rules" .then "the debtor normally
would retain no interest in the securit[ies] following th e
purchase [by a third party]-from the 'secured party .", . Id- sec .
9-314 cmt . 3 .

the'

17Because 'of a-'small amount of ` accrue d interest, 'from
time the loan was made. until the stock' was sold,'-Calloway woul d
actually- have a 'slightly higher deficiency if we - found hi s
transaction-:-to be 'a bona fide loan . The Commissioner hasn't mad e
'(continued : : .)

- 74 There are, finally, some potentially odd consequence-s,o'f ,
this- ;opinion . Consider first an easy variation--a simple, „
collateralized loan subject to the same standard

contract ,

language .-as in Derivium's forms . The stock stays in the lender', s
electronic equivalent of a desk drawer, the borrower-repays ,,th e
loan and regains control of the stock .

Does this becom e

on the, initial transfer? And a repurchase when the loan
-,,repaid ?
Or consider the example of subordination loans--stock s
transferred by an owner to a broker or dealer . The : transfero r
keep's his voting rights and dividends, but gives the transfere e
the'" right to 'sell the transferred stock and retain the`a proceeds .
(This sort of deal is beneficial to the transferor°because'he'
gets .'a .stream of payments equal to a percentage of the value ,
the'securities he's transferred . And it's beneficial .to th e
broker or dealer because such securities count - toward'his"` min'imu m
net-capital requirements .) Courts have always called these loans .
"rathe`r'than sales, despite the right of the transfere e
Cruttenden v . Commissioner , 644 F . 2d 1368, 1374-7 5

S"ee, ' e . g° ,

17( . .

.

continued )

any claim for this little bit of extra deficiency, so-he wouldn' t

get it ., See Baker v . Commissioner , T .C . Memo . 2008-247-(citin g
Estate_of_.Petschek v . Commissioner , 81 T .C . 260, 271;-72 ,(1983,),'
affd .P738=F .2d 67 (2d Cir . 1984), and Koufman v . Commissioner ,;69 ; .
T -Q ., _473, 475-76 (1977))

(9th Cir . 1981), affg . 70 T .C . 191

(1978) ;

Lorch v . Commissioner ,

605 F .2d 657, 660 (2.d Cir . 1979), affg . 70 T .C . 674 (1978 )
Or, perhaps especially, consider the increasingly comple x
financial instruments like re ;pos_andcustomized derivatives .

All .

of these alter'the "benefits and burdens" of ownership, but som e
that take on the form of sales are treated as loans . Kleinbard ,
supra at 798 & n .79 ("For tax purposes, repos traditionally hav e
been treated as secured loans of money ." (citing Rev . Rul . 79108, 1979-1 C .B . 75, Rev . Rul . 77-59, 1977-1 C .B . 196, and Rev .
Rul . 74-27, 1974-1 C .B . 24)) : ;

see also Neb . Dept . of Revenue v .

Loewenstein , 513 U .S . 123, 130-31 (1994) (finding repos are loan s
for . purposes of 31 U .S .C . section 3124(a)) . Must all now be
subject to the uncertainty of the

Grodt & McKay test ?

I respectfully concur in the result in this case

and eve n

the imposition of penalties (because Calloway did not respect hi s
own characterization of the transaction as a loan) . But unles s
future courts .treat,our analysis today as a limited-time ticke t
good only on Derivium cases, we may be creating more problem s
than we're solving .

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/agency%3Atax-court%3A19813138fe7bfe7f. Public record. Not legal advice.
