# American Bristle & Hair Drawing Co. v. United States

> Court of Customs and Patent Appeals · April 27, 1972 · 458 F.2d 524

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/cases/6823992

## Case

- **Full name:** American Bristle & Hair Drawing Co., Keer Meurer & Co. v. United States
- **Court:** Court of Customs and Patent Appeals
- **Decided:** April 27, 1972
- **Citations:** 458 F.2d 524; 59 C.C.P.A. 104; 1972 CCPA LEXIS 342
- **Precedential status:** Published
- **Opinion:** Opinion of the court by Lane
- **Judges:** Almond, Baldwin, Lane, Rich, Woeley
- **Cited by:** 7 later opinions in the Frix Law Library

## Citator (automated)

- No negative treatment found by the automated citator. That is not the same as a confirmation that the case is good law; read the citing cases.
- Full citator and citing cases: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/cases/6823992

## Opinion text

Lane, Judge.
This is an appeal from the judgment of the Customs Court, 65 Cust. Ct. 147 , C.D. 4070 (1970), upholding the district director’s classification of the imported merchandise, 'involved as “brown processed hoghair,” as bristles under item 186.30 of the Tariff 'Schedules of the United States (TSUS) with duty at the rate of 1‡ per lb. and rejecting appellants’ claim of free entry as hog hair under item 186.55 TSUS. We reverse.
The statutory provisions here at issue read as follows:
186.30 Bristles, crude, or processed in any way for use in brushes or other articles_ 1 H»
There are no statistics on the domestic consumption of -these animal hairs; the aggregate consumption is estimated to be between 60 million and 75 million pounds annually. The bulk of consumption in terms of quantity and value, consists of cattle and hog body hair. Next in importance are bristles and horsehair. * * *
In sum, we feel that tbe Customs Court gave too much weight to the change in tariff treatment of bristles. There is nothing in the tariff history before us that demonstrates any intention to change the tariff treatment of hog hair from that which prevailed for many years or to alter the distinction between hog hair and bristles, whether crude or advanced.
The Customs Court concluded that appellants had failed to show a viable distinction between bristles of any description and the importations at bar and would seem to have been influenced by the failure of the record to reveal a specific definition of “bristles” that would be determinative of the present controversy. We agree that it is difficult to extract such a definition from the evidence and testimony of record. When counsel advanced published definitions, they were either rejected *109 or qualified by the witnesses. The witnesses did agree that Exhibits 2 and A unlike Exhibit 1, were bristles. Otherwise, the most that can be gleaned from this aspect of the testimony is that hogs are a source of bristles as well as hog hair, that lengths of two inches or longer are generally characteristic of bristles, that bristles tend to be more coarse and stiff than hog hair, that bristles cost considerably more than hog hair, and that bristles are predominantly used in brushes whereas hog hair is not so used.
However convenient a precise definition might be, its absence is not conclusive of whether appellants have shown that the importations comprised hog hair rather than bristle. We find the evidence persuasive that the importations were known by those in both the hog hair and bristle trades as hog hair and not as bristle and were used as hog hair and not as bristle. The merchandise should have been classified under item 186.55 TSUS and given duty-free treatment as claimed by appellants, and the decision of the Customs Court overruling the protest is in error. We accordingly reverse the decision and judgment of the Customs Court.
Worley, O. /., took no part in the decision of this case.
1 The flag end is split into two or more filaments.
2 The butt end is that which is opposite the flag end of the fiber or bristle.

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/cases/6823992. Public record. Not legal advice.
