# Eric v. Warnquist v. State Tax Assessor

> Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · January 29, 2019 · 201 A.3d 602

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/cases/4362651

## Case

- **Full name:** Eric v. WARNQUIST Et Al. v. STATE TAX ASSESSOR
- **Court:** Supreme Judicial Court of Maine
- **Decided:** January 29, 2019
- **Citations:** 201 A.3d 602; 2019 ME 19
- **Precedential status:** Published
- **Opinion:** Opinion by Humphrey
- **Judges:** Saufley, Alexander, Mead, Gorman, Jabar, Hjelm, Humphrey
- **Cited by:** 6 later opinions in the Frix Law Library

## Citator (automated)

- No negative treatment found by the automated citator. That is not the same as a confirmation that the case is good law; read the citing cases.
- Full citator and citing cases: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/cases/4362651

## How later opinions describe it (automated extraction)

- stating the standard of review when, in a Rule 80C proceeding, the court considered the propriety of a tax assessment decision of MRS de novo pursuant 36 M.R.S § 151-D(10)(I) (2018)

## Opinion text

MAINE	SUPREME	JUDICIAL	COURT Reporter	of	Decisions
Decision: 2019	ME	19
Docket: Yor-18-115
Argued: November	6,	2018
Decided: January	29,	2019

Panel: SAUFLEY,	C.J.,	and	ALEXANDER,	MEAD,	GORMAN,	JABAR,	HJELM,	and	HUMPHREY,	JJ.

ERIC	V.	WARNQUIST	et	al.

v.

STATE	TAX	ASSESSOR

HUMPHREY,	J.

[¶1] Eric V. Warnquist and Rosamond C. Warnquist appeal from a

summary	judgment	entered	by	the	Superior	Court	(York	County,	O’Neil,	J.)	in

favor	of	the	State	Tax	Assessor	(the	Assessor)	on	the	Warnquists’	appeal	from

the	assessment	of	tax	on	certain	foreign	income. See	M.R.	Civ.	P.	80C;	5	M.R.S.

§	11001	(2017).

[¶2] The	Warnquists	claim	that	the	court	misinterpreted	and	misapplied

36	M.R.S.	§	5217-A	(2017)	regarding	the	income	tax	credit	available	to	them	for

income taxes paid to a foreign jurisdiction. They also challenge the court’s

determination that the penalties and interest assessed against them for the

2012 and 2013 tax years were appropriate. See 36 M.R.S. §§ 186, 187-B(7)

(2017). We	affirm	the	court’s	judgment.
2

I. BACKGROUND

[¶3] The	following	facts	are	drawn	from	the	properly	formed	portions	of

the parties’ statements of material facts and their stipulated exhibits. See

BCN	Telecom,	Inc.	v.	State	Tax	Assessor,	2016	ME	165,	¶	3,	151	A.3d	497.

[¶4] The	Warnquists	are	residents	of	Cape	Neddick,	Maine,	and	own	two

rental	properties	in	the	county	of	Rogaland,	in	the	country	of	Norway. One	of

the	properties	is	a	single-family	home	and	the	other	is	an	industrial	complex.

In	2013,	the	home	was	taken	by	“expropriation,”	the	Norwegian	equivalent	of

eminent	domain. The	Warnquists	paid	income	taxes	to	Rogaland	on	the	rental

income from both properties and on the income from the expropriation—

$208,860	in	2012	and	$238,374	in	2013. The	Rogaland	taxes	were	based	on

the	Warnquists’	gross	income	and	did	not	include	any	deductions	for	expenses

related	to	the	properties.

[¶5] On their 2012 and 2013 federal tax returns, the Warnquists

reported	their	Norwegian	income,	as	well	as	income	from	interest,	dividends,

and pensions sourced in Maine, and deducted from this income certain

expenses	allowed	by	the	federal	tax	code,	including	expenses	associated	with

the properties, to establish their federal adjusted gross income (AGI).
3

The	Warnquists then imported their federal AGI to their Maine tax returns.

36	M.R.S.	§	5102(1-C)(A)	(2017).

[¶6] To	avoid	what	they	viewed	as	double	taxation	on	the	income	from

the properties, the Warnquists claimed a tax credit on their 2012 and 2013

Maine	returns,	pursuant	to	36	M.R.S.	§	5217-A,	for	the	full	amount	of	the	income

taxes they paid to Rogaland, which was based on the gross income from the

properties. For	each	tax	year,	the	Warnquists	used	a	“Worksheet	for	Credit	for

Income Tax Paid to Other Jurisdiction,” issued by Maine Revenue Services

(MRS),	to	calculate	the	section 5217-A	credit. Instructions	on	the	worksheet

guide	taxpayers	through	each	step	of	the	credit	calculation. Because	the	credit

the Warnquists claimed in both years exceeded the amount of their Maine

income	tax	obligations,	they	paid	no	Maine	income	taxes.

[¶7] In	2014,	the	Assessor1	audited	the	Warnquists’	2012	and	2013	tax

returns. The	Assessor	increased	the	Warnquists’	standard	deduction	for	2012,

but also determined that the Warnquists had claimed a larger credit than is

allowed under section 5127-A because they overstated the income that was

1 The	Assessor	is	the	executive	director	of	MRS. See	Leadership,	Dep’t	of	Admin.	&	Fin.	Servs.,

https://www1.maine.gov/dafs/about/leadership	(last	visited	Jan.	23,	2019);	see	also	Dep’t	of	Admin.
& Fin. Servs., Bureau of the Budget, Maine State Government Annual Report 2017-2018 (2018),
https://www.maine.gov/budget/sites/maine.gov.budget/files/inline-files/2018%20Annual%20Re
port_1.pdf.
4

taxed	by	both	Rogaland	and	the	State	of	Maine.2 The	Assessor	calculated	the

portion	of	the	Warnquists’	Rogaland	income	that	was	subject	to	tax	in	Maine

and,	based	on	that	calculation,	adjusted	the	Warnquists’	section	5217-A	credits

for	both	tax	years	and	issued	assessments	for	tax,	interest,	and	penalties.

[¶8] After receiving notice of the recalculations, adjusted credits, and

assessments from the Assessor, together with an explanation of how to

properly	calculate	the	section	5127-A	credit,3	the	Warnquists	timely	petitioned

the	Assessor	for	reconsideration	of	its	decision	pursuant	to	36	M.R.S.	§	151(1)

(2017). The	Assessor	denied	the	petition.

[¶9] The Warnquists then appealed to the Board of Tax Appeals (the

Board). 36	M.R.S.	§	151(2)(F)(1)	(2017). The	Board	reduced	the	tax	assessed

for	2012	by	$66	because	the	Warnquists	understated	their	allowable	standard

deduction, but otherwise upheld the assessments in a decision dated

July	21,	2016. The	Warnquists	sought	reconsideration	of	the	Board’s	decision;

2 In	Maine,	income	is	taxed	after	deductions	for	expenses	(net	income),	while	in	Norway,	income

is	taxed	without	any	deductions	(gross	income). See	36	M.R.S.	§§	5121,	5142	(2017).
3 This	was	not	the	first	time	the	Assessor	explained	to	the	Warnquists	how	to	calculate	the	section

5217-A credit. The Assessor imposed	substantial	understatement penalties on the Warnquists	in
2008,	2009,	2010,	and	2011	for	similar	section	5217-A	miscalculations	and	issued	letters	explaining
how	to	properly	assess	the	credits	they	were	entitled	to	in	these	years.
5

the	Board	denied	that	request	on	August	18,	2016. See	4	C.M.R.	18	674	100-9

§	305(1),	(2)	(2017).

[¶10] On October 18, 2016, the Warnquists filed a petition for review

pursuant	to	M.R.	Civ.	P.	80C	and	5	M.R.S.	§	11001	requesting	that	the	Superior

Court grant them relief from the tax, penalties, and interest imposed against

them.4 36 M.R.S. § 151-D(10)(I) (2017). They argued that under section

5217-A,	they	were	entitled	to	a	credit	for	all	of	the	taxes	paid	to	Norway—even

though	that	credit	was	greater	than	the	amount	of	taxes	otherwise	due	to	Maine

on that same income—and further asserted that the court should abate the

penalties and interest assessed against them pursuant to 36 M.R.S. §§ 186,

187-B(7). In	response,	the	Assessor	filed	a	motion	for	summary	judgment	on

September	19,	2017.

[¶11] On	March	7,	2018,	the	Superior	Court	(York,	O’Neil,	J.)	granted	the

Assessor’s motion for summary judgment, upholding the tax, penalties, and

interest assessed against the Warnquists. The court held that there was no

4 Because a determination by the Assessor or the Board is not considered “an adjudicatory

proceeding	within	the	meaning	of	that	term	in	the	Maine	Administrative	Procedure	Act,”	the	Superior
Court	reviews	the	assessment	of	taxes	de	novo. 36	M.R.S.	§§	151(2)(D),	151-D(10)(I)(4)	(2017);	see
also	BCN	Telecom,	Inc.	v.	State	Tax	Assessor,	2016	ME	165,	¶	2,	151	A.3d	497. “The	court	shall	make
its	own	determination	as	to	all	questions	of	fact	or	law,	regardless	of	whether	the	questions	of	fact	or
law were raised before the division within the bureau making the original determination [the
Assessor]	or	before	the	board.” 36	M.R.S.	§	151-D(10)(I).
6

genuine issue of material fact pursuant to M.R. Civ. P. 56(c) and interpreted

section	5217-A	to	limit	the	credit	available	to	a	taxpayer	to	an	amount	no	larger

“in relation to the total amount of taxes owed than the proportion that the

taxpayer’s adjusted gross income from the foreign jurisdiction bears to the

taxpayer’s entire Maine adjusted gross income.” After noting that the

Warnquists had not been “double taxed,” the court held that the Warnquists

had failed to establish reasonable cause for a waiver or abatement of the

assessed	penalties	and	failed	to	satisfy	the	court	that	they	were	entitled	to	an

abatement of the assessed interest. See 36 M.R.S. §§ 186, 187-B(7). The

Warnquists	then	timely	appealed. See	M.R.	App.	P.	2B(c).

II. DISCUSSION

[¶12] In considering an appeal from a summary judgment, we review

de	novo	whether	there	was	no	genuine	issue	of	material	fact	and	whether	either

party	was	entitled	to	judgment	as	a	matter	of	law. See	M.R.	Civ.	P.	56(c);	Blue

Yonder,	LLC	v.	State	Tax	Assessor,	2011	ME	49,	¶	7,	17	A.3d	667. Because,	in	an

appeal	from	the	Maine	Board	of	Tax	Appeals,	the	Superior	Court	is	authorized

to	rule	on	legal	matters	de	novo,	see	36	M.R.S.	§	151-D(10)(I),	we	review	the

court’s	interpretation	of	the	law	directly	and	do not	defer	to	the	interpretive

ruling of the Assessor or the Board. See Blue Yonder, 2011 ME 49, ¶¶ 6-7,
7

17	A.3d	667;	see	also	BCN	Telecom,	2016	ME	165,	¶	2,	151	A.3d	497. On	appeal,

the Warnquists challenge the Superior Court’s interpretation of 36 M.R.S.

§	5217-A and its denial of their request to abate the penalties and interest

assessed	against	them.

A. Section	5217-A

[¶13] The Warnquists contend that section 5217-A permits them to

claim	a	credit	against	their	Maine	income	tax	obligation	for	all	of	the	income	tax

they	paid	to	Rogaland. The	Assessor	argues	that	section	5217-A	allows	a	credit

only for the tax the Warnquists paid to Rogaland on income that is taxed by

both	Maine	and	Rogaland.

[¶14] We review de novo the Warnquists’ challenge to the court’s

interpretation	of	section	5217-A. See	Sears,	Roebuck	&	Co.	v.	State	Tax	Assessor,

2012	ME	110,	¶	8,	52	A.3d	941. Section	5217-A	provides:

A resident individual is allowed a credit against the tax
otherwise due under this Part . . . for the amount of income tax
imposed	on	that	individual	for	the	taxable	year	by	.	.	.	any	political
subdivision	of	a	foreign	country	that	is	analogous	to	a	state	of	the
United	States	with	respect	to	income	subject	to	tax	under	this	Part
that is derived from sources in that taxing jurisdiction. In
determining whether income is derived from sources in another
jurisdiction, the assessor may not employ the law of the other
jurisdiction but shall assume that a statute equivalent to section
5142	applies	in	that	jurisdiction. The	credit,	for	any	of	the	specified
taxing jurisdictions, may not exceed the proportion of the tax
otherwise due under this Part, excluding the tax imposed by
8

section 5203-C, that the amount of the taxpayer’s Maine adjusted
gross	income	derived	from	sources	in	that	taxing	jurisdiction	bears
to	the	taxpayer’s	entire	Maine	adjusted	gross	income	.	.	.	.

(emphasis	added).5

[¶15] “In	interpreting	a	tax	statute,	we	look	first	to	its	plain	meaning	to

give	effect	to	the	Legislature’s	intent.” State	Tax	Assessor	v.	MCI	Commc’s.	Servs.,

2017	ME	119,	¶	7,	164	A.3d	952. When	a	tax	statute	provides	a	credit,	it	must

be narrowly construed. Goggin v. State Tax Assessor, 2018 ME 111, ¶ 14,

191	A.3d 341; see also Foster v. State Tax Assessor, 1998 ME 205, ¶ 8,

716	A.2d	1012	(it	is	well	settled	that	“taxation	is	the	rule	and	tax	exemption	is

the exception”). The taxpayer seeking the credit “must show that it is

unmistakably	within	the	spirit	and	intent	of	the	statute.” DaimlerChrysler	Servs.,

N. Am., LLC v. State Tax Assessor, 2003 ME 27, ¶ 7, 817 A.2d 862 (quotation

marks	omitted);	see	also	36	M.R.S.	§	151-D(10)(I)	(“The	burden	of	proof	is	on

taxpayer.”).

5
Title 36 M.R.S. § 5142, which deals with computation of taxable income of nonresident
individuals,	provides	in	relevant	part:

1.	General. The	Maine	adjusted	gross	income	of	a	nonresident	individual	derived
from	or	connected	with	sources	in	this	State	is	the	sum	of	the	following	amounts:

A.	The	net	amount	of	items	of	income,	gain,	loss,	and	deduction	entering	into
the nonresident individual's federal adjusted gross income that are derived
from	or	connected	with	sources	in	this	State	.	.	.	.
9

[¶16] Because	the	section	5217-A	credit	reduces	a	resident	individual

taxpayer’s Maine income tax obligation, we first determine what that tax

obligation	is. The	process	begins	with	an	identification	of	the	taxpayer’s	Maine

taxable	net	income,	which	is	the	person’s	reported	federal	AGI	adjusted	by	any

modifications, deductions, and exemptions required or allowed under Maine

law. See 36 M.R.S. §§ 5121, 5122 (2017). The taxpayer’s Maine income tax

obligation	is	then	calculated	based	on	that	taxable	net	income. 36	M.R.S.	§	5121.

Next, Maine law authorizes several credits against the taxable net income,6

including	a	credit	for	income	taxes	paid	to	another	jurisdiction—the	credit	at

issue	in	this	case. 36	M.R.S.	§	5217-A. The	result	of	these	calculations	is	the

individual’s	Maine	income	tax	obligation.

[¶17] Section 5217-A is complicated, but not ambiguous. The plain

language	of	the	statute	makes	clear	(1)	who	is	eligible	to	receive	the	tax	credit,

(2)	what	income	forms	the	basis	of	the	credit,	and	(3)	at	what	amount	the	credit

is	capped.

[¶18] A Maine resident taxpayer is eligible for a credit under section

5217-A if the taxpayer paid income tax to a qualified foreign jurisdiction for

6 “A	tax	credit	reduces	tax	liability	in	contrast	to	a	deduction[,]	which	reduces	income	subject	to

tax.” Tax	Credit,	West's	Tax	Law	Dictionary	§	T330,	Westlaw	(March	2018).
10

income	“derived	from	sources	in	that	taxing	jurisdiction.” A	qualified	foreign

jurisdiction includes “a political subdivision of a foreign country that is

analogous	to	a	state	of	the	United	States.” 36	M.R.S.	§	5217-A. In	this	case,	the

qualified	foreign	jurisdiction	is	Rogaland,	Norway,	as	neither	party	disputes.

[¶19] In order to receive a credit for income tax paid to a qualified

foreign jurisdiction, the foreign income on which the tax was based must be

“subject to tax” in Maine. Section 5217-A assumes that the qualified foreign

jurisdiction	calculates	taxable	income	using	AGI	with	a	provision	analogous	to

36	M.R.S.	§	5142.7 If	a	qualified	foreign	jurisdiction	defines	taxable	income	in

some other manner, any taxpayer seeking a credit under section 5217-A for

taxes	paid	to	that	foreign	jurisdiction	must	recalculate	his	foreign	income	by

“adjusting”	that	income	for	any	deductions	or	expenses	provided	for	in	Maine

law. See	36	M.R.S.	§	5142. This	adjustment	ensures	that	the	credit	reflects	taxes

paid	only	on	the	portion	of	the	income	earned	in	the	foreign	jurisdiction	that

would be taxable if it had been earned in Maine. Section 5217-A does not

permit	taxpayers	to	claim	a	tax	credit	for	tax	paid	on	income	that	is	not	subject

to	taxation	in	the	State	of	Maine	(i.e.,	the	expenses	and	deductions	“removed”

7 Section	5217-A	provides,	“In	determining	whether	income	is	derived	from	sources	in	another

jurisdiction,	the	assessor	may	not	employ	the	law	of	the	other	jurisdiction	but	shall	instead	assume
that	a	statute	equivalent	to	section	5214	applies	in	that	jurisdiction.”
11

from	the	taxpayer’s	gross	income). In	essence,	taxpayers	seeking	tax	credits	for

income taxes paid to foreign jurisdictions that define taxable income as

something	other	than	adjusted	gross	income	must	calculate	their	“foreign	AGI”

before	they	can	properly	calculate	the	maximum	credit	available	to	them	under

section	5217-A.

[¶20] The maximum credit allowed under section 5217-A may not

exceed “the proportion of the tax otherwise due under this Part . . . that the

amount	of	the	taxpayer’s	Maine	adjusted	gross	income	derived	from	sources	in

that taxing jurisdiction bears to the taxpayer’s entire Maine adjusted gross

income.” The language is complicated, but the application is—for taxes—

relatively	simple	in	practice. First,	a	taxpayer	must	calculate	what	percentage

of	his	or	her	total Maine	AGI	is	derived from	sources in	the	qualified	foreign

jurisdiction. To explain how to perform the necessary calculations, MRS

provides taxpayers with a worksheet. The worksheet contains both

instructions	and	a	box	with	a	space	for	actual	calculations. At	line	one	of	the

box,	a	taxpayer	is	to	record	his	or	her	Maine	AGI,	which	includes	all	income—

foreign	and	in-state—reduced	by	any	applicable	deductions	and	modifications

provided	by	Maine	law. At	line	two,	the	taxpayer	records	the	income	earned	in

the	foreign	taxing	jurisdiction. The	instructions	accompanying	the	worksheet
12

make	clear	that,	in	recording	the	foreign	income,	the	taxpayer	must	record	the

foreign	AGI. The	instructions	state	that	the	income	included	in	line	two	“must

be determined in the same way that a Maine nonresident calculates

Maine-source income” and that “[i]ncome considered taxed by another

jurisdiction is income, after deductions, that is analogous to Maine adjusted

gross income (federal adjusted gross income plus or minus income

modifications).”8

[¶21] Lines	three	and	four	of	the	worksheet	guide	taxpayers	through	the

calculations necessary to determine the proportional cap on the credit for

foreign	income	tax	paid. The	resulting	percentage	is	the	maximum	percentage

of	the	taxpayer’s	overall	Maine	tax	liability	that	may	be	satisfied	using	a	section

5217-A	credit. For	example,	if	a	taxpayer’s	foreign	AGI	represents	seventy-five

percent	of	his	total	Maine	AGI,	he	may	claim	a	credit	under	this	section	in	an

amount up to seventy-five percent of his overall Maine tax liability, and no

more. In	its	entirety,	the	worksheet	reflects	the	complexities	of	section	5217-A,

but it does not contradict the statute, nor is it susceptible to multiple

interpretations.

8 Moreover,	the	worksheet	specifically	cites	to	section	5142.
13

[¶22] In this case, the Warnquists miscalculated their section 5217-A

credit because they failed to account for the differences in the Maine and

Rogaland tax systems. When using the worksheet, they did not record their

income from the Rogaland properties according to the definition of AGI

provided	in	36	M.R.S.	§	5142.9 The	Warnquists’	failure	to	properly	account	for

the expenses attributable to the properties in the calculation of their foreign

AGI	resulted	in	a	credit	that	exceeded	their	Maine	tax	liability	on	the	income

derived from Rogaland and effectively shielded them from tax liability on

income	that	was	never	subject	to	tax	in	Rogaland—i.e.,	the	interest,	dividends,

and pensions they received while they were Maine residents and that was

included	in	their	Maine	AGI.

[¶23] The court recognized the Warnquists’ error and correctly

concluded	that	section	5217-A	may	not	be	used	to	shield	income	sourced	to	the

State of Maine using untaxed portions of foreign revenue. Allowing the

Warnquists	the	benefit	of	the	credits	they	claimed	would	result	in an	absurd

and illogical taxation scheme that the Legislature did not intend. See Eagle

9 As discussed above, see supra at ¶ 19, section 5217-A presumes that every foreign taxing

jurisdiction	has	a	provision	identical	to	section	5142	through	which	it	calculates	the	taxable	income
of	nonresidents	using	the	taxpayer’s	AGI. Therefore,	although	the	Warnquists	are	residents	of	Maine,
section 5142 is specifically applicable to their Norwegian income through section 5217-A. See
36	M.R.S.	§§	5142,	5217-A.
14

Rental,	Inc.	v.	State	Tax	Assessor,	2013	ME	48,	¶	11,	65	A.3d	1278. The	court

properly	upheld	the	decision	limiting	the	credit	available	under	section	5217-A

to	the	tax	that	otherwise	would	be	due	on	the	same	income	in	Maine,	calculated

after	deductions	for	expenses. See	36	M.R.S.	§§	5142,	5217-A.

B. Abatement	of	Penalties	and	Interest

[¶24] The Warnquists also argue that the Superior Court erred by

declining	to	waive	or	abate	the	penalties	and	interest	assessed	against	them	for

the 2012 and 2013 tax years. See 36 M.R.S. §§ 186, 187-B. We disagree.

Reviewing	the	record	before	us	de	novo,	we	can	identify	no	basis	on	which	to

abate or reduce the penalties and interest. See Victor Bravo Aviation, LLC v.

State	Tax	Assessor,	2011	ME	50,	¶	24,	17	A.3d	1237. The	Warnquists	have	failed

to	demonstrate	that	they	relied	on	erroneous	information	provided	to	them	by

MRS	or	that	there	is	substantial	authority	for	their	alternative	interpretation	of

section	5217-A. See	36	M.R.S.	§§	186,	187-B;	see	also	John	Swenson	Granite,	Inc.

v.	State	Tax	Assessor,	685	A.2d	425,	429	(Me.	1996). The	worksheets	that	the

Warnquists used to calculate their taxes accurately reflected the limits of

section	5217-A	by	clearly	defining	the	amount	of	the	foreign	income	tax	paid
15

for	which	taxpayers	may	a	receive	credit.10 Moreover,	this	is	not	the	first	time

the Warnquists miscalculated their credit under this section. They received

notice of their repeated errors and were given instructions by the Assessor

regarding the proper calculation of the credit in prior years. Therefore, the

Superior Court did not err in its decision to uphold in full the assessment of

penalties	and	interest	against	the	Warnquists. See	36	M.R.S.	§§	186,	187-B(7).

The	entry	is:

Judgment	affirmed.

Gregory J. Orso, Esq. (orally), Orso Law, P.A., York, for appellant Eric V. and
Rosamond	C.	Warnquist

Janet	T.	Mills,	Attorney	General,	and	Kimberly	L.	Patwardhan,	Asst.	Atty.	Gen.
(orally),	Office	of	the	Attorney	General,	Augusta,	for	appellee	State	Tax	Assessor

York	County	Superior	Court	docket	number	AP-2016-39
FOR	CLERK	REFERENCE	ONLY

10 Specifically,	the	worksheets	instructed	taxpayers	regarding	the	proportionality	language	of	the

statute	and	clearly	defined	the	foreign	income	tax	paid	for	which	a	taxpayer	may	receive	a	credit. See
supra	at	¶¶	20-21.

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/cases/4362651. Public record. Not legal advice.
