# Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

> Texas Attorney General Reports · July 2, 1958

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/cases/4136616

## Case

- **Court:** Texas Attorney General Reports
- **Decided:** July 2, 1958
- **Precedential status:** Published
- **Opinion:** Opinion
- **Judges:** Will Wilson
- **Cited by:** 0 later opinions in the Frix Law Library

## Citator (automated)

- No negative treatment found by the automated citator. That is not the same as a confirmation that the case is good law; read the citing cases.
- Full citator and citing cases: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/cases/4136616

## Opinion text

HE ,*TIJOHNEY GENEHAL

OIFTEXA~

February 10, 1958

Hon. William A. Harrison opinion NO. ~~-363
Commissioner of Insurance
International Life Building Re: Whether a company subject to
Austin, Texas the provisions of Subchapter
A of Chapter 5 of the Insur-
ance Code regulating rates
for motor vehicle cr automo-
bile insurance may declare
dividends to one class of in-
suredB.upon a different per-
centage basis from another
class of insure& under the
provisions of Article 5.08
and Article 5.09of the In-
Dear Sir: surance Code.

You have asked our opinion as follows:

"Articles 5.08and 5.09prohibit discrimination or
distinctions being made in the payment of dividends to
policyholders. Article 5.08 specifically Bays that 'no
insurer shall discriminate in any distributions of prof-
its between insured of a class, and no classes for dis-
tribution shall b,emade or established except on the ap-
proval of the Board'. We respectfully request your opin-
ion as to whether a company subject to the provisions of
Articles 5.08and 5.09may declare dividends to one class
of insured6 upon a different percentage basis from another
class of insureds, with the only significant difference
between the two classes being that one class has paid pre-
miums based upon a time period of six months and the other
has paid premiums based upon a time,period of twelve months
or longer?" (Emphasis added.)

The effect of the language that you have quoted from Article
5.08 of the Insurance Code as set out above is to vest the Insurance
Department with authority to approve or disapprove the creation of any
classes for distribution. It is the intent of the Legislature in en-
acting Articles 5.08and 5.09 of the Insurance Code to prevent cliscrimi-
nation in the payment of dividends to policyholders. In exercising the
authority vested in it, th&Board has full authority to determine wheth-
er or not the proposed classes for distribution are justifiable. There-
fore, it is for the Board to determine whether or not there is a significant
Hon. William A. Harrie&, page 2 (~~-363)

difference between the two classes as outlined in your letter SO as
to warrant approving them 88 separate classes for the payment of divi-
dends.

SUMMARY

It ia within the authority of the State Board
of Insurance to determine whether proposed.
claeee.9of insureda for.dividend purposes are
justifiable under Article 5.08 of the Insur-
ance Code.

Yours very truly,

WILL WILSON
Attorney General of Texas

-*
Fred B. Werkenthin
Assistant

FBW:l.m

APPROVED:

OPINION COMMITTEE:

Gee. P. Blackburn, Chairman

John H. Minton, Jr.
B. H. TiminS, Jr.
Marietta McGregor Payne

REVIEWED FOR THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
BY:
W. V. Geppert

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/cases/4136616. Public record. Not legal advice.
