# Calton, Allen Fitzgerald

> Texas Supreme Court · August 26, 2015

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/cases/4056183

## Case

- **Court:** Texas Supreme Court
- **Decided:** August 26, 2015
- **Precedential status:** Published
- **Opinion:** Opinion
- **Cited by:** 0 later opinions in the Frix Law Library

## Citator (automated)

- No negative treatment found by the automated citator. That is not the same as a confirmation that the case is good law; read the citing cases.
- Full citator and citing cases: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/cases/4056183

## Opinion text

This document contains s
pages that are of poor quality
at the time of Imaging.

RECEIVED IN
COURT OF CRiMINAL APPEALS

AUG 2 6 2015
A~Aoos\a, C'er~

.!\. \\ -tl\. "f'' CC{_t.\o(\ 4-\ \:t1'c~0
~~\eJ ~~
J ~0 'f IV\ 3S \ Y
6~"'\ ;-r.)(- t l{ 0 s-
~(f)~
C\') A\\ e.tl '' ~" C~l \u11 :#- \ \ ). 3 ~ 8D
& \·, \-e.s. ~:-\-
3 D(oo vM ~s l~
(1~\- ;\)(. 11{05

C:lJ *\)e. s~{\\eJ'
L ~-YV\ ;Jx. . I i..p IOS'\\~~ 0 0
0 • ~-- \

\a-'o\~ -t>·f Co~\~ .. (\
~ I ~g\\
""·~~'/-.. b.\- A-c~
0
0

\\ b.\-t:t~eA\ b.\- ~us\~ ~\c\;of\
0 . p.Y
.... 0' J ~. t{

0 • f' l-\
:3[ Ac SU/V'\-0\\ 0-/\~ ~r;~1 o d
0 ~ eC-\ ~ ~- n~ ~\ 0/\6 Otf'c\ o-\ Q-Mf ev0 o
cr ' p.7
\_g) ~\W"\dooJ'~ b{ Q~1 M fUr f"V\tY\~~ ~e.\)\ eW
t=Ds C{\' M-1 Act { L~ rvt etA- \.v' ..s "'
- f· ~

Cc) Qe;\c;,\-o_r \-\ct,'b A \L\sh-\- \ o A~u\G1u'el\*
P-e- u::>('6 ol\ Ae~.eq\ ~..cz)nj ri\~6 " a ., - P" ll

m An ~~\~V\~~ ~-\tA\-~H'( Q/l~ ILt.ih A~rQ_~
A La.~~ w c;UU 'II ... t: '~·
~4A\~ \J g~~ !o'1~ J ~~ d-SS C\e~.~-(.~~
L J4~ 0> '~-\-l \7~s) Cor1j ~( oul~;~) ., r;- .,

~as(\-e.~ '\) s~ ~ 1d.. lwJ,~ 4~1.{ l:\ex A~Q.SCl/\AA~l\i() \9~) L - p .7
(S~V..QJ' \) L.Vt'nj b

~\'(' ~ 'V ~e. ~-o.\e_ p \-k~..t~~
L\~·\- \) \)-\--] \1tJJ) ( ur1'j e.o~\~~) Cl 0 G c. • f·~
'
~-e~·\;o(\ ~.r (.A)s-,-\-'bf M~ ~ ~j T ab\..L o{- A-t\'\....oN\-le-1 ~. \\J
f>Ci 3 eJ

S\Gl\-e. -e~ (~\ Cw-,~ "Jl!o -~-..v-~~ \').S: L"7\e)(Gv~,A(>~.\qf7J o ~\Cf
~e...le..o~-.~ \),~\-Me\ C..\V"'Y- lt.l, Sw3d Co/3 C\e~,CJ'-'""'-A..fp,JooW"' ,~J1
~t:.

0o'o'o~ vl..OJ.A~ \.\:1 S.G\: ~3 S Ll'1ttJJ c; t:-1 c , ~-_.l\
\)oVL~\cw ~ c_~'-'G-o((\\C!_ 11.2.._ u.~- lS.J (l9
G-~Vt{( ~r& Cor-'\> '-' £v(ns ""63oJ-vv~ 6 3 s S"'
t. \-ci-- ..APP· C-or<> c..(~ UN-1~\-\. l q ~ J. )Cor[~ Q roLQ.Qdt_'~) ..
(:s..(, \0("\ v .::c-t\~ (\ ~\ s. 1> .$1 \...{. ~- i?._ ( l£t 5 CoJ 0 0
0

G-f'D~ \J G,..-ou\~ l o;).. .(IA.)-:z,~ 1}\Ll,tJllto CI~~-C\v.Afp.
'ffi.s' NOf'~ l 910 1 f\ v~ n't ) c ·7
l-\a.0~~ 'J t.M\k ~ J~ 31~ uS. :1_ I I C\1~J,. . . p, J]
(o ~ ~ \) rt>t.r2L~~) o cY (, ..
\ a 'o\e 0\ ~~~\i-e ~
C q ~ .e...s pa g....e.l
\4-u-{)Q/)6-ez_ \J ~-\~ I ~~ S\.1))_ ~ "6).$"" (Te'f-_ Cs v~ J\-fp 19~0) or • (J· l 7
.s \-M Cf..... ~t 1-\-t \\ \J Q ~-f'\-\e ~I S"W~ 1.. '1-1. \ ("!C't.. es; 1"1.-Ai{J 197'~) • e~3
c. l~ o.f- r'"' ~I.e~ , \.e "-::s-b h n J V/1 S :r1 sw.;, ~ 11..1 &"' CTe i..A'(Jp (o.rp~J
~~\1 ~.r-fC.r .2.oU:J
(_,0 n'~ ~ \0~ ~ 0,3 ) ., •· o ao .,_ ., -- e)~ 1 .).If?.]

L ~S ~ cd--e._ v IJ lllcwo\ ( "& \.5 s.v J, ~ \ "i 7 CT~ . f-W{J . 1-kl..{ ~.J.dl
L I !(~ () IJ\- J I t:t q I I {\A) p-et J 0
0

IV\ttr'i Of"\ v L.oc.\(.~~-\- 1\l{ S-v...J~cb. .J._Jtp C\~i-.1 w~ -r' q
p (\' ~ ~ !-p~"\1 }Q ?)"' ___L 0-"> J<>j. 1/l 'I~0 e >?

01 d Cso()c ·~
.J .; "v..\V) ·1- ;hl_) & s £ t \"CV' s \ ~ ' JO \)~ ,)_L ~ 0'0 a'1-;

L; d I' ,) (QcY>r' CD? M ~~ i-~l) 0 h 0 \ fe""'-f ~ r J 0 ] ~ j_~ v_::::r:::-

J I I d- ~ :? [.~L b\ "' __l_) );h ~
Ci). ~ 'f\"' s 0)~ > ~ \) b \A), (\ JQV~~
-\-~~ b~9 1_so,O) ~fC'0 S"O)L. \'f!-0 l\ 1~~-J
1
QJ & '"\h2.bJ ·1'1-N·f\.'?'i-a-_.4

_5 (' d - p .:? = 0 CL~b') ~ #2,' cs.) rr OJ~ " pco-e) f>S'fJ · s·n ~--e 5 Yu~ ~~ f'. ~·~ S' /
r-c J , -=
o o ... ( OV~~Q b~J r:oor rJJV· w.,ry"f.a_L) b L 't' ~f~f~" ~? f\ )\t7cno--d

-~ ,J · p C' ' \ J'lll~mQ.)~ F'.l...JO·J ( ~6bt ()_~~ Vo) · ~ov· r-?~)
fr,O) t''e ()-)fb")9:,. -\-:> -\:~(0 ) 0 '!'1·~~"'~ 1--rl ~~ f'\o ~7 )~1))70 d\'~~~

I'C' c) J " fJ-;;- 'i b I ~?.J.:.J d) L. 'f '{0'"\...f'l L. L -:) ~- 1 O""'S IJ 0 ~v3 ~ vrn~ () C\ ) J0.~~

b ·d ·" (U~ 1dJv v--lJ)J.;JbL.t'c ~ r~rh c_d"p1ZJoW f\ -z_(f(\d'~~ )'U) ~ ~\~
s-o~l?d
so-So-")

S'd ~~0~ J0 ?'\'\ 1?__L.
;

#
I
f>4f~

::r' A ~ Lt..\JU'-J i-y_s. £-ervl . .:.:Cf"\L .?-:H Sw3'd.- J 3 l (\~;.... \ or.--.e 2- ~ve~~M ~1\:.J 1L LC. v V\11. 4 fe€ ;;. q L{ J w 1 ~ (, "b (

CT~i-. A~(>.;:,£+ ~•j+ ') '-k~...t~l"\ .?--00~) " t7 .., - ... - P· 1:2

..::::Ct~-· ~ \Jl~ MJ ~ .::Ii)c_ \ CTej.._.Af~ So.-. ~ i\) 1 9'19_\ , . ~7

R~QJ'a{ Gn.!~~\1orv;A A~~

r r-- \7
I

l\

£e.lv--al ~~1 ;Gc\e.i &16 ~eJ

·;J_ ~ u .s.~c · !\ -JQJ"__s q \i on .. ~ -J i ~"" ...Jai J h-u-\- OA.2. -\-{ f'l'-.('

\ (\ a\\ ~,1>\:,a\.~;\\\~ w ,¥v\_ -~ ~ Q~~).Q..S.S,IOJ \n Ct ~ ~\5.\.s '~ 4\~k J. MW'W ~'-1)
(A.us..e JJch C"'t'{] l(o~ ... ((("e~t 'N2_~nJ'S ~'n fu_ i.Vl ~~·t.llJ o\ ~1·Q be..8QI)
C>._f\.\-1-ol.{ CV\6. C-Dq .~~s:e__
~~-\,\a.~ ~\n ~ s v..l-Qf'e e.o, ~eA.\\ OJl( t(\ 0ct\- use ., .:r"' \)DJ'-hu,j \ar -\iQ
\~o!'-\-
'{)+-· ~ \S. ~-h·i)() ~ C)-~~
~~---s. ft~ \v-f'~._s .2_,{6) 1-. \ n -~ "f{Jt>r-\ 0 \- \\-u ~-R\.-\.;D() ~~ wrv\· 0-\- /V\(111 d.c-\MA.C ( ~ V'e_ -

Ct ~\if 0011-\ ~ "e-\.v-re J. -\-o CfJ Af{)QA ~ J-
Ej.l,,b,~ '' D'l -e '1-cJrr-\- '6-G-
c..ovf'\- ~oc:kr'~s (}QLDI"'~ ~r')~\ct\ 0-MUL J\) o ()/S""J/U \J'clv.-Q l{ p. . lo?
L..,~~ ~-~) CW' ct.-\- ~.(e. Of\ s-1 o- bl{ ~ \t-\Ql Of\~ tht/~\-:1
b~~ CV\~ ~-\-of"\ {)le ~ r.'\\Y\· ~~,.\~+u~~~tt. p__Q\Jt;IJ__p.J'()-G-

Q.e~~ifl ~~ \.0\'\-\ ~ ~ ev,~_s PCtJ~ I bt-cl ~
(
t·

COJ..lse ~~. o~L\ll!o~ .. Cct\Aon wct ~ Co~A3\ ~1. o~~~ -\ouJ\~ -~ ~b)~c;~ 'C)\~-~.
q.\te- ~ ~~Of'\S \-tv-Q__ GA ~ o. ~'-t ~sed F~IVI(X?o \.s A-\ t r ~~
CCtN\.uN c...o~rc\;o() .. u..e_ Cct\~ -..J ~\-~ .;).()os vv L .;l.!J'\ J..lo?.,;
.AJ·\). ~?-- oY- J-.1 't -(.\L \. \e-J... A~~· ~M--\.Oo\'~ AYO\J; ll 1 J-O\JS"J ~t- w~-
~ '~n.) CA:)o\- ~-Q~-~~na\-e c\ ~' (>v\o\L~'41l(o~- A ~X~"~-\--\c\l.l\ Cou.r+..s ~'Y;- ~ o{l-(1 ct_,\-. ~tff.Q.S {-C{ ., On £4 -15- (~ C q \k) ~--e cQ.-t\~ ~ e.'-' l ~--VI~-
~C\--\ U)f\~·r ~~ ~a.:\ ~- 5.~;11~ I\'\C\6Q q ~q..(.v; ol M,U(.' CA\.\-:-f'\ c..of\CVf\:\~ ~ ,~\.WMt.( D.\- \'he_ {f.C..Of~.S CCt\~ hq~ -\i-~~
OA ~ ~,\~s-('l'\"1 ~p.QA\ ~ct\- w ue. f'\e...l)_s --r-L> Nb Aual/ «t a\.st'n-s C IaJvts \·n ~ ~ -\-o ~Q --\- ~c..\- ~ cc\- c.~ d--u n "'- r ~ ~o s ~ '--l.

~c, ~ Q./\. A '-ov.tQ_ o-\- ~Q.. L.J:r)~ o\'~QS' en\-Q.red. a~oJn~\ ~~f'V) ~ S-€--e
e~~~\o\.\-.s \.\I 11 01\ ~ "'.I L, 0 r ~..s.. ~o'IV\ -~ Co\){'\-\- o\- Cr\ ('J'
G-cw ~a-~ 1\t"\ h-1U-e.H ICY\ 0v1J ~ fltv\ . .Ccl,d-
\ Q..J ~~:>vJ 4\\ so Knt~vJS CN'e.. ~ e\wM\- ~ ~ LM·~li.Vtrll_j o~(.u ~..Q. ...
~\ ~ ~Ct\ ~ ~c...or~5. wQ.J'e. M!J.~ovy -+or ~- ~\fed-1~ ,.~aJ r
Cv\d '""Qcuv,(\g~( Of>-rctl \QS~L~.·\icYl o~ ~~a{ .No. o;?.-Ol/ -.l.-2'6 - ( (L
,\)-
'S\ot~~€1\\- ()~ Fd r-~ • ..u..e_ £Jl~,loi\s l'Qt' , ,,~u t l'sl' 0/\d n\1' con*tr .-
(vv1·n ~~ ~~ ~~lnk~ A~ A~rQ_\\c:J::.Q CoU/\J-Q~ of\ Cct\~"s
b~~~\\- CV\~ ~svJoJ'~~~ Cal~ Ct t.o~ ~ ~-\or1et Y\Af'.A\f.or~ woS
~oin._s ~ -h\..e... (3¥1 CCiJfon S
1
~hoi~ A-\-~~~ -h·~ G:tt~ t'f')~~~d
c

~~ A\w~ b't ~ .Wov.~h ,., ~o~.s /e-tkrJ ~~+ Cqt-1-ttl wets
l'Vl
r e.1VJtS~n~ .&o"(Y"\~ -\-roJ\~cr( pt_s -.\i,a* he_ beh~ w~ ntrt c\nciLt-
~e~ ~n Y\--e._ ~ro0kr'r P--e,c.u('d ~,u, wa.l ~ ba.s1s. of rvv'"'. ·;~
A\\-o'~ 'bt\e..-f , UL.. £,c:~~b(~~ j'U''' Ba~ry A\hJ~s A(~c\cwA Dfp!VI-
J)~ ev\ pet~.Q.'S ]S a/\~3~ l

(__"'3) ...L\~ b.Q..{.'oj ~ u-\ ol"\ ~c..Q. obu-t ~ON11V\.e~ ~u,r6~ tvv-. A~~rJ.
Go(\\-uckd 'fV\S'~ ~~·,n~ c~c\)\-~ l'v\ce\-W 0*- ~ O "'-ad ~-et\c\.in_g a+~-
~rN._ • S-e.Q_ e )C...~;b~ t '' \-V 1 £~fa. cvr'd E")(\xi\,\. \ U'' , ~ Uf rq.
1 11

l ~) ~~1\\~ ~\~ ~~ ~~\)ecA\ ~\ z \1hof"\ ~ r ~ r (\ a ~ M a.v~~J fa ?t So f)~
~···.
,(

(_sj Mf"'. c;~,\)Q.r ~('....Jcif'6-e~ Catk q ~!.-£ o.Q--\WL Pr-e.~Ql h~a.NA,,~
ce_c..o{' ~~ on 5-c?..-l.l..~JRJL £".J~w--e ·-\-f'c.v\.H..dp\-j ~ were pe-t>?~ \y f'e ~ ~J te J
t.etl~ CV\·~ -\?or -G~lJQJ ·+o MqJ0l. r eqJ()I)aloly i·n~U-f'ri e1 Cl'~t)Lt~
6"--l
~. e*.~-\ o~~ \eU) r~ ., ~~. Ex~~(,\ r vvr• -f!of' c. (t_C.t3, Hlno( 11

or~ tt"\ Uu..tr.e AJQ, 1.;1-tl '-P(O~ -dJ J.. q.pat ~ ~ qt- pqp-i 3~- ({()

(·7J C9n 't-..11.{,-1~.. L4l~ ~._u~e~ ~~Sc.Oul~ a D.4vltvl~ fe\kr ~'t Gli'-
-\t~-e~ Mcvt'l lalae( ~7()1~ ore 1 CJu~ ~ r WiJ. ~(e ~ ~\J4JM~ p~q{ h.Q~V'/~ f'C:-
c..-oS'~_s \ 0 -\1-e. .Af~:e \l cJ::o Cou-.M As A. SVffl ~A- +o -\1--e.. record
o" Afreo \ ~" App~a( .AJ\1 , OJ..- o lf -:L.J_ z - c.(\_. f_.e.e__ ~h ,~l +'( X''
~r Cctl~'s 04vlcvtd f-e~.\{r--l-oJ~ev~ ~Jl-t~11.e/' crf07!1'( q4-pape_.s 41-'

A_() v-) /t:.rv.wS. QJ-e. \'e\-UJO'i:\- +o -1'4_ UA.w \..r 1/l.f 0 fC-vt t-e_ '
·g

~:S\.\M~ OA6 ~~"'\-y

~ ~\0 SQ.. ~c-oLe..- ~I eq~"' ~ CPVa
ha~ c....o~\~QJ'ed ~ ~\_s co~. oICilQ.Il~f\g.i €.0~ tko~h
~ . ~ ro S.Sl.. ~\ ~ r~ ~ l.eQ ~;,r) gs ~atle~ -\-o -9u Ik, c.p "i' ly w l 4\c\ ~the_
· a.~\\ leq~W\_\) f Q .Le..Q ..:r;, ('12__T CU.C l o.r'
.;Qe-e~\s q,?-7 rwJ.·~ 4ll-O CT~ (99p. \:\-.oy_~£1~·\- \)1~-\- '] \99( 1 or1_g ~ro~ Ju~\4a.( et.-.e\tha0 CtS 6q'.Jt'rRAfy -h\~d-.:r A a-\ ..ll{7~ (c.~'nf
l"')'\)a&~ q .15 .s ....:>J.J C{\- 1:t \ i Cn:l\M ~ \).. s \.0 ~ ~ q:\· 70 't ~.r-e~lte PaJ'~-
1\ u.s ~ \q 9 sv0 J d. Ct. t-- (Q~\Q, I
_x_, .{:4 c._.-\ CY'-0~\- \( (')\)-t- eJ'~n.g oq~~\ )( ~in ~ pL{b\ic re. '-'?.r J CVJd
~.s CV"e- A.-O\ ~ '--t .r ~.{-t lo\..p -h:> d. ~ v ll II th ( ~I 3
.1 w:>-d.. ID1 1\f'+ .-h::> \'-e-~~urJL
~ s.-e_. O...QLu..l'a ~ LCU\~ ~ ~ e.C~l\1heo '-'>t~u\ ~
e~ul-\\e o-G ~\~cre.~bn or ..)u~g""~\ .. :r\-~we. \~ ~ d\iM€A\: ~ ~ eovJ{ 0~ Cd-
1

(\1\A·Aa( ho.s. ~~itr\'oed. ~ f'-.\\n\~\v'·ta\ Ctct~l '-.1 Mo.A{~ Ca'i'1 J w;,·~ ~'13 1 ~q9 (Te~. C..rt."'\ A{Jp. 19"3&-J .. ~c-e\lef -r~\tt
~ \- ~ 11 U~c.S' CV\ ~ 1 n ~\.s\i f\_g \.t.l~ \,a~t.Q ~ "6\~p~\-o·\alL // J4c..V1-\i-,~ ; :\-~
Meh\.-i ~ ' 1 ~~oflc\ d\~Q~ .:r~ aA:- '¥. (7 .·-o-~.u L.VJ~QJ'k (\fl1·vtti~q( Ac+/
0

c \-to.J" \esu\ t \~ 'n\ ,e. 1 v1\fe.wt~\ , ~ \~ ~-\-\ ,, c.lQa.f'~ -ire 11 o'-' ts \ e\A ~~- -e#).I"G('~ o{ ~\~(JetlW)
Q(' 0\..A~j fV'\.QA\ ...-,...X d ot\- 'C,'1 "yvJ"-\1nQF --VN_ tiC~ ~\- b.JL ' ~v~1\;u--e..~ C..ONl-
1

MAA6~c\ ~6 ~-'V ~\CM\f\ ~ ~€~cri~~~ ~ W ~- \eu.J QS .\-u \o.e. ~~~ ..1 ~...0..1-b CJ4.S"" 1 CJ~9 er~.Cr,'IV\4-rf-19'1.:l,),t1'nQ11ra--roc.k
\ s ~~ "' ~ \-er' ~ \ \\
,\ ~-\t.~ i ~ c\ VI~ ~Lv .W-t e ~ lNl~ \ ev.t.-t\ce~ by . )
t ~ . .L.e..e j ~ e~ ~\ C..w'r'i. 1?-CQSw.l., ~ I.)$' 1 1·1_~ CTe-J...Cf\'"" Afp- 19"6 7.J
C 0ul'lu.Q d. •'n -\U- )owe/'
C...OvJ'\-~. \-hwe.v-if ~v-.t.-~ UtA~~ (' ,~\rtt ~ 1()U~\dQ-\ ()/\~ s~~~
Af~a~ o.re a\- s\a¥-e. ~-~-eJ\\- Aec.eQ'~~ Ceill.s fur -\1-.e. e'j.SZJ'tt:-e- o~ 1'1n1~
c..-ovJ'\\ os\ ~{"'at _)W'\.\~~c.~dl o \. ~ U:>vJ't oC- \ct_s\- ('('.i()J'.\- ~.l~ ~ V
W\ \ ~ ;)..~ Jvv.;) 6 .5\.S (\e i-. \q 3 riJ/ p.._~Q.Urat'Y-. v &""cwJ (p).. "t .l;wJ.. 6 'J.77,.10 ~ CS"-#)
c.. \ r 1q ~t)J ( C) V-L ~ rult ~1 C.GA 'o~ 6!2At e d b·-1 ~ J '-t\oi\-cvr\1a ~ (4~CIJ1 ~\-;on '()G
~ A(>~\\~ {)\OLHi 1 flld.M~f)g 0/\ e~LH..I\\)'-Q. C\.~ M_ ~\ ~ cui.J..f'€ o.C ~ LovJ'·\f"\ ~f" W ;_~ {,p(or i ~..peo 9 (T-£t.

c \\.l . A r f. g-eawvo ~- \- t'i J \.{ , /t.i:) v.:r 1\ ) . A l-\ivouf~ fW'. s&;,, f~ is (\ c w .
\ e.\-he J · A c....:...A{'-\- Ro.f or..\tr ~ ~ctS r~.1 if~'~~ 6 or \ ~ n-u Lon J..if" iUv"f loy.e ~
'\ " ~ ct\ ~Oft\ Gul'+y \.-, q ~ ~e.. c...on-\1 uJ l1j ~ ~ -\-o r ( ~aVe .s ~ \: ~ .Q. ,
(1 '-'t

-G4cl~ ('(\ ~~~ c...as-t.s ~("\~\eRA hQ wa.s ~ c~.C,ua\ Louf't P-Df~~
S-e.L ~Jr\oJf VVf'l\ (V\Cv...( frD'{JV'ly
\~S.~ -..v"'-vt ~ e;..\~-\_s ct \Q.~Ci\ 'b"-f\r ·-\-o \>V"4..rl"\ er t"\..,'n\~\RJ.ic;(.
0t C \- , ~ Q._K {.~ b.e.. C\ ~ Q./V'k:VlU/V'\VV\- . 0V'I ~ evvt -0rvo~th e.s .. ~\-~ ~~~~ler ~reu Gh hii IV'-4h" \.vi ~r
~~~ --..J~Q./\ N.. \U~~e ~ -\-.o ~\.df\j -\-raA~c.r\p\-..s. C{\~·-\~~ \t\q\-qf' h4~ ~e-
1\1\~~e ~ '(V\J"' .. s~~~l u- \--o 6o .s--o.~ E-j_\·\\Li\- ~ \, ~~ Q/\c\ \' Y" J ~ f''1_ ....
·~v-e.\-ore. ~e. ~\~\ q{ ·\o «r~o.,re 1 C%'h~
6Qti.AoU
0/\ ~ ~~.t. ~ ~re\.1\·, q\ ha..~()j \-rOI\su\~\:5 C\~ 'et~~\-e..~ 0/'1 ~ ~e;vw,~e 6

b'-{ c e..\J.or J-~~ \s f\~ ~\i)\.),~~\on -\or ~a\ c.-onc.et(\~'n_j
ht J ?w -J o -\' J(Y"\ _)0-:! u('tttt"J b

J.I) [I ' U l'! "t. f bL t: ff C0 S' c1) t1) ~) f\. \)q-0"~ craf s\'V , c~/) ::t=.
0

"oVt>J .tJ{Yl f\ h9 "r akl'\\Q-v Wd''1 ~I?"\ '\' ~ 0'""1 .d) ~ ~Vd- ~ \f?~
DLA.,v--vJ,l}UCY') t'~lj.} b 1/}? -\Vd) fl\JO~ \'t>VW bv'-\c V "\J'"'OJ J
(bQOr ~\"""at,\ [-t~'.G \fiJ JJv·"""~l."J \l.~' L~~ \' r~ s 'hb't t:ro X"2W
1\ "') I' 7 I ) \ V?i Vlll-'q-1' ~_r s '\.JW .)o_]- s--~ 5~Y¥V
U~-l )) ) -1- l? "'tn ~ JO j) ~\f)) "~ \..v.c JJ- ~"1' o\ f u ,wo~ 1o StJCV"' "'\A:J
U~\~) t:jo~ \CJ ~ \~ \.,0~\J~ )~""\ -;JO JO{\':>~ ~v~
Ajf\, )t\f -tn'-11- :r~J\'J I? 9 pn>Jc}Q \..Jc \SJ \'a,~CV'~ JO-jP_!.fJ~ 'J\N tb'tt ovv J<>}- ~~vvo-.):r"'va ~
)IV .. td'\a--'> }nvlo~VIo\.A.-\ ...)or
~wo- ..:nnl~ ~uOJd-S ~ \(r-0J )l?~
J ~ b\ ~ -;}.JG.J ~ ""\),. ( O)C>OL. ·6~ · w 1-.Y) 'i--.,_L) }1 L h 1 [ L h ~ [' C"' S L ~ \
11 ,n,p \J'~\~~Q C'\ uo~'d~ tnr-) • ~\ -\;'17 ~ o-i..l'l"d..> ~Y\b~'? av
0}\-\ t'i l S"(rA!7o \ )o~~ :Jo h.tf\'~1ou~ a--u- ·-\V"YlOj ~ \\~oy
.J ~ b\ v
~ u.~ "'-\Ohr>WV)-\ d'v.\~ P'\l"\o ~~VD 1 OJ'O~..)b
~ ~h~ o~~~v-~v..J ~~~ '-->).~-.£15~ ~
) \ l?'SY1().) ),J'~\\ ~V(IS '.J\]J
\

'
OJ\.'"\,\AA.,-..~
\ e_\ Q...VD/\ \ \ S 0 rvq \--\.e ~ ~ c-o""' ~ ~o("' ~-.S ~ ·{,\\ ~ LovS'\- or avu., reu'~ M ~ \o~ Ie~\.er ~i r ec\ -\hJL
~~u4 \ LovJ'\: ~o~\.er \o ~\~OS'€ ,0P-\r~ CQq\ -\-o
atl ~~~('\c.t\ \\\1~0/\~, J~ Jv ..o.\~of"\ v Kr4.SV\
cv-\- ~-~ Qt>J' \\ e ~ 4o{V'\. f ~ -i'' n__g ~q \- \{·~ \-\.-\: .. ~. E u \ \i- ~ \} Lv. r'lct.. ~
S \-u:k..Q ~c:U creG\\-€d ~. Q...U_£\r\\ oC A.qqea( 1 (t fV"M~'i o\W .e~c.V\ ~ eCv,-
1
~ Otl\\ CL ~ c.J{' n ~ ~ ~ t·1vr -\-o ~\::,\ ~ n CV\ &~ ~J'-'~ d.\ ctt-h o'l on 11--e. ""'Vl r\ ~
o (. 'nh A~Q.Qa~\ - ..:::r:. ~ et-\ "fl\.{ l ~ Onei 0/l ~e.ea( o~ d_gVIt h a.1 ~ j ra-tkd
-\"ncz... ~ r~rcx.Q~~ CV'\-~ £1~'ut ~ 6.~ c,. ~~dQ/t-\
.s.~c..\1\. ct \l .(.aA\f' O(>-Qof'~\~ II \~ \\ ~ € ~Y ~eu.A ~ q \·' ~'ng­
t e ~~ (;' \\u.etl /r \J '"1 ~ .IC/\1.( t'r\jl h \!'I\ ~ ~~ ~ e_\~ec~ve~ (X'e S.S 'n\~
0-f~\\o.k.f a_r ~~\~
i.e.e. ~ ~~(\ \.} :r IIi(\·\>'~ 3.S \ \A.S, I~ ( \Gs-lcj (\~\6tQJ
Q

GA lA ~-j~\~ c-\~h.\ \-'0 ~e \rCV\.iCN~~~) '1 Co~~e ~_s.e '-l lM.tH J ~~J

·~~'t \...\,~ '--\1~ \ Y'-\\Q \.\~\.t>~ lQJ:8h\-\<> s~\~u-eA\ \c;-M!~p\) ·, \)r~ J
'-N et~\v:nj\-on ll1 u.~.'-\'1.( 1 L\ '7'-f'\~ %-vvu.~\r\ --\o \ol \r~lf,\~\-i . 1S \ u.1 C0\ \~ ~ -\h\~ h....o 1 ~)"j
~ e.~\e~ Of'\ ~ '' C...OrUh~~Of\u( 0 U~a/\W S 0~ .~~. ft<>U~S OJ\~ €.t '-- ~~c\\u" 'bo~ o \. ~ w··~ c...et.\ \ -\.o, ~( t>u.Jv,res ,-n c..d~ n4l -\ d ,A~
~\UA q\'!ow Au \ l\v-\~lb-..tS ~\~W1 c;q'n!Xlc;{
c e..\"'\\ 0\\&~\ f ~ ~e ~ ~ ~\!_s 5 '--tl. \-\- or \n f\ ()(.2./l U.. -=t" d. C1.-\- \I &/) ~ \ ~ • A'"' ··6.
~ l\v\~e ~ ~e-tA "~ Q.J€ (..CV\ ~. (\/10 e '(_ '--fGI \ J Ul\\~ '-'\..) hQJ€ ~ \-Z~ () ~
b..C. -\-c\C\\ Ct "'"'W"\ 3 e\s ~~.JU~~s o" ~ ~ ~6 o .(;. ~"~ ~ ~ec.~-~ J
oA- \q_ ~\~ \~ ~o b~~ \\,\ \~ ~o tM6~l..¥h4-\-; onc.t..es\ab{ilNtdr
ct \J M v-e ~ cl A Q~ \\ d:_f \ VJ\ e.-vv rr-u..s.-\ \o..t? ~\- +r-ee o {:.. lA/\ rea s o11 e 6
~,~\n"v\\1.)(\s ~cA C...CV\ Qf\~ \~~~~Q. orvtan~ -e.1_•-u:u{ ac..uu~~
L...ou..A-..s /1' •. ~ e, \\tV\~~ v,., \~ ~6-.s. ~- C:l(' ~ \1 )._ -~- 4-\ \{ '1 \o ~ .
l.\
(_ ~\~ (\ ~+vt \-o''-(
""- 4 ~ ~ J OV\ ~ c....om~ Of) cd g_.( ~VI-\ -\-o C., l.-Q"'f I~ \-e.

( ~ co~~ or\ ~~.ecd q\- S~ -e ~ i..e_ ct ~ W1 \1\ ~ j-0\.\ ~\\OJ\.-\- .. .u...t
A\orvo\ '-'~~ -ztl.h.....>·l.~ \3:1 1 1.1?-ILiO (~e-1-.. Cr\'CV\·Af~·l\Ct,~~ff\-e~q~ l~ QA i"'6\s~\ ~e~'~cvA \~~-h+l-e~~
-\--o ct {-\-e.€.. ~Q/\!>V"\Q\ \-c N.- ~ Y-e~ ot ~~,e~· ~\- w_. ex. QoJ'k
\ rcv\l\e.J' \ ~\ sw ~ 6 S$"£ 1 3.s-~ -S( (-:)e-'f..-Cr--\fV\-...A,-pf. .;>-o o.s") , A \.i o JJU.
c .\. \ -I \I {,-,.\.l "' (\ )\ ,, ( I\ '\. "' .....,...- 11
c jvh,\::7 \ 1"' .l \.X. I 'f- I ~ CV\ o \ I S ~ r"'. ·

~ J v-~ f ~ Co vJ'-\- h Cot~ l o "'.J k1~ · ~~-\- C4I.J...ul\ q .i
~ \1"\'~jVt-\ ~-\l W\t i....vt:U C...C().)\-r.kA-1 01 ~1~ ~-hPe ~ +o "*-t \aq.\ic
~\~ b ~ D/\ ct }...t1~~k cl.~ivlt..e. or Off~a\ 1 ~~ ~UL. ~a\.s ore_
IJ.::
:J·
Q·\J ~\a\:,\.e -C-oc- ~ ~ C \Ul \..o c~.S'r. S..a.z ~~\\-\- \J Ml ('~ C.o.ro\.ir'R YD4
u ·~ · ..1.1\..e, :>. 'l t ( V1lU (c....\-i()-1 ~\\in J.l V'f rq) . «o*" Gf2...Gt \ , .S_.e_Q_ M. ~ .er' "\J (_~~ \)~
C).-v\'A~ u L\,()q u.s. '~ 9. t \CZI\). ~ WM1 o-\--\-n ct.\ \e. e ch-\- '-..) Q ct \wsun '3. '6 ~ \...,( -S. ~A')$"" i (.,Ito c\ro\we ~ b'-( (,c-tfl-ion 11 \)-t ~
CV\~ o('~tJ h\.e.~ ~ \-c::r-t>7 ~n '> N..tU.:. ~atJns~l ~b e.\-\..e~\}-Q_ 0-('~e-\\~ 'e-01~ ~-Q £t1\-scw:l\- 0
If_

f'l\,\ (\ ~ -V' J~ ~ U -~ • Cv\• -"1 S). . ~ .S "'"'f ( ~
\,q 5. ~\~4 ~ ~\ \\ .\S UvJ' \-
ct (..C'·\~ "y l de.~~ M \-.1 ct CU \~ ~ ·~. ~ t.o\ ~ ~-\0i-1 MG1 jle l ~ ¥ ._.
'~LH~k \ ~AJ·\e.vJ .~'vv1n.l~I.1'-.U._ ~~~NS >'13 u.S. ct.-\ 3~ .e-, \"i,Cft- A-rM~V'('p-\- -\.i NU. ~-e ~ -\or Q/1
e \~c.\1~ ~ e ~ \..Q.. 00 0-f\'.eo \ p U-.e... ..f 4CU.L~ -\-o Gt -\(aAHr-~ et I
OU'-e .fi u""' \.1 (" oC oUH G.-1 ~-e. 4. 4o { p ru~
~~c~-:>f\ c_\ou..ue~ b ~ ~ \l..iih A~-~QA\- .. ~ e:u,·\+J '1.1otU.5,
q\ \.{01- bl{. Ev·V\ t {t ~- o~ \>rocHS. Q.r\~ Cfct. 1 G-d~·"" 1 S~-l'ct (ho\'~\\r\~ ~c-r\· 3cvun~e.A L, ~~ o ~l.U. ~ {'0,....
Ce.S.S ~(...{*l n~-\- ~ \\M~~ --\-h~ o~~~w~ b~ s\er~~f'~ ('_('e_q\-edclkee_.\-
G.f~-tal \ n ct. re.-e.. ~'-\- -S\\e~e~ ~\,
\1\vvt c.. Lu1 \J c.ovJ'\ 'C> + Aef€ols ~ Y\tv'.Atforc\ J ~t.t 1J ~qii'Q_ Cte{ ~the
t>~~-o Nl~~ ~- ~\ q \ r--e (...Q (' ~ I -tiun--cuJ!t, r e.s.eo..rdA f1..e. (Q.v.) I ~ ~lr
e~sfL. J 4dj' ~~ t ~€/\\-t~.~~ CVJWVIVt.\-.s 1'4.Cf-\- fVtcM.f 6-€. C(J \.)allW -)-0 t) -.)01 .fo3' v(l"t·~r~ d)

U() .' -~ V"vQ ·0"1k ·t Q ~' h~ d_j
~v \G6 9 # .s' J ~- ·w\..J
7 ·'f.~_, ) ~ \~,.' _s t~ f"G->J oq -\'·n'-'v '--''\\1-:7")
}b lJj_ "'Jaj+hW ~JhcG)O f;-.ro~ 1/P/1 CQJ !l?~ )OoOcJy )l?V ~..VV~V) -)"Q
}-lfY'OJ ~ hjlbl\~ • of- ~I -\-0 · Yn ')l_~{\\.r (\ V~j \..:>~ Oo-y ~1Yd- G
-. lJ>v '· ·()J'O ~ ~'~0-.\: )-\d\~J)nMJ.-t ~~ -1n~ 1 ~f\ \~~] ~ VV') ~
lrft1lfl- o.r tdJJ)fVOJ-t \'?~~-~ ""lt)~O~ !lJCJ v """)(__ 'C -)"l?
. f.L // )P11Jtb \l::>VyrtCP 1~JO'vV ~ fe1\\.o<>Jd ().J'f'!"""'" 1 -ysnvv
)~)~(o7!1?\N CL..\..,·...1 ),J'O r~~nav· !""l.ft7nd~J::J S' \/Y\'vV
- ~V;n-u 11 .0'1} }1/l)JI~ jlJ~.~J? {) clU~j C'Q)& h.9 ~Vj15"jJOJ )oV(l~~l-tS"V c>-::>
· -;r-r cY"l1+ J"\f? s ssnojd ~ ji'~Jo v v r b r -1 o ·sn b OJ tr r-1-\ 11?)0 \._/(ILfJ~J~ )t7nbo ~ j){PO..Jd ern,:;- -~ J Q
~fVVWO~ d"iJ- ~ICY\ ;-vQ.3'-"0J tf}'yv.,) 5'\l?d""aJo dV\YjY->"0~ V't \']"~y) S"qJ"Y"l~~J
-QJd Jo~ ot tiiJf~~ ."'0 'Slvo~ ~"Z>f \W~!.J-::> S'~\,t.ooJ~ r-'01
0"-i)- 'J I

~rjX."(Q"Cto·r0/5t '1fV)~ J'u~o )t>"l-1.yvrw~~tu'OJ O"'f\~~ rVI
b' {'-' ~ o S'ao-)1/0J\on~ 1vow ~~ '1.J..n\ ~
(l:O)J;:, 1) ~->' f 1 rs r. ')' n 'rL ~ .. -\V1 ~ :v Jo ..!0)\ ovv v ro y~~ -\;\'S~
~V0-tP:::>u dVf-FO V )w\h?~ VO\~'v..>.'f )"0\J().~~ll-rucYJ u~o-~ 'J'O ~~ VO
j-)o~~ '~ 1 ~~1'='") vo \~JD v-o }Jl?'-'\l'~W \'VD \""?) o--yv. vpJato}Ql(') "trvJ~ ~ ~vo ""~\'J VN1n_J . ~"" n Df C4-fk!l~
o ,~c.\ A-~-{1«2~ \ '-NuS. cw\: ~~~l'f {q;\r' C\/l~ ~- reJL«l ~lt)J a{!-
~~ o ~ Cc...ti\-on .S e-<>"'~'G\-\l>f"\ b'-t ~ A{'(Lellakp G~-\-·'a/\q\)u~ Pc-ec..kM>.s A Lu~.5. ~-i'J-tU'OAdfor 0-e(iALR.
~~h r'V1W1~~ r\Jn-ut e~4~-\-o.~\..Q_ ('~~t-tl! i-.~UO/lQ {_s.
Cv\

~ar~Q\"( L.&A\olle-d- \., ~ e"tu...i\ot.~ 6>r1nwol~i ..SJte. ::r" r-e '-'~ifj ~~J . .i -u0.1. f
It~'-· .l.l\ ~v..:>3.} 51 I, !J ( t:\e 'J.. \1V Co~_g q>~-~~) j 0 . \\J ..::!:A~ ~nW~nj
l o't ~wJ~ Ct \ \o.)..()J .
_x ~ ~ ', f\i \-~-\- t:..CA.U2
C. Gt\ +vZs ~ e,\~ \\11 b n'n .g -~ "'-"\evtd CM«J
\ el\ e~ c....v as. ~v-.Q.. ~ L't.\M.s J, t ~ ~ ct/~ h cb\-c:u\n \7 ~\,-e:{ Q 11
·\n)\) llw.\v\i Cv\~ ~~ \-\-~\ot_tq~ Lur~~--G: a.c:A ~ \-o (\-c) ~I c~t,~ *h6~.s ti' evt -e)C'-{I:::t ~
I'

0 v()'6eAt ~ 'QJU'~-f'r"'' ~ Ol'-£ ~tnt­
SW1et\ cc..-\- " 6 ~~ \ (\\)\)\~~ o.r-e.. .SW\.fl.tlv-e CV'\iu.t\Cc/' ~u~.\o a~.)ure ~ct\-a r-e-
~\a\-or ~\\\ 1\-o\- ~re.rN~.\-wQ~ ~~'t ~r e t--\-fctD("'~,~ar."Z Y 1 l cri ~.eA\ec;\ -f-oe *ol\v.J'e. +-o 5~ .)~.\\--t~1l~\\. \\i~ N_ wou\~ ""4~ ~ ~~ted rQ.\ie.-\:- ~~ -\-c \~ -\'t.AG:t:\
1-\olo~\. l-VI'~QJ'
A J ~ 1~ '] 1 UJD ( \e-J.. . App .-re-t.-
c.r~c. .1..~) Co\ &\Of!,- Cf'\ lr. Is r i ~ t..·b· • 8 u\- Cll!t {;> n
\t u..s. ~~~ Ct ~\ \'\Q '{>\c CJV'l·~ \~c;t~-\t\ C rs
io
~\aM~ 0 '-"\\~ab\L e\"'1 ~ ._._.__'1'-vv,_g MwJ0.lie(:. IYl -hit- here1\n
Ct.\- qa.~ 11..' J-
ro '\> """r
"11"'-s ,;;_ 'i-Jl. !\Is o ~ ~~~.., \) \D>f\Q.S 9:n F:~ l
. 3 '!. ~ 1 3 '(,&""-~(? (Y-11-, C ~ I'i"1_0 (. eJ~ ~
r n:. t>e c.orJ-,-1-uf..t R·o ex\ ~w\,,m ~ c.au.J
A\~.""'j' (,., ( Q. \"' X-o \ \-,. ,., \(twu> n s '• oct. '-\- 11 · \) ~\ .\ ~ -\-- ~ku-Q.
.S"'-'VW\ \"- '-"""1::~-\: :c..ov.r\ ~rli\"g ,fM\ . j>r€.-kt«(
(l_Q_ c...-vr- ~ ~- C!;V\tfu ~ {-_ro~ Q- ~\c..~ f S \)I. rec-\: Aq~.e..a \ CVt ~ ~JQ.
o ""'-lr\-e <> ~ c...::.Je.
.--e "-"" t<>" e 1;\eev-lf' d Q\"-y alo~ &>e.s ""* '3 ):il--Qr€kre -11Ml c.,.uA- low Gl~ ~-
I

L.t;Wl
\, e~ ~ """""~s. .jlh ~ ¥ '"k«l .\ _ (lsz_~ Q"" ~e-._-\-

"-"
1

~r ~r '0 ~ fVI""' ~~s ;}. Dnf .l. ~
I

'-'.:> ""\- fkhoiQ. (V)q~in\ ~\.f{7-fJ'€~Q./\~-h~0 +o-\tt.e

~e~\.e , W'nV1 ~- S.t1-J(I{e_r oUeq.o-1\~ ~J-e_( -+hcJ. -\102.--
'i ec..c0·~ ~ ~~~ ~4~ ~() a~~fi~.~-~-rf'\e~e~ 4-e
re.et~o~\alr CCUL~Ud as~. -\-('VI~ o{-~ IV1c.r+i-V' .~r'rvl\n.g -G.t-u./\1"\
a... S'-'..)D\f\ e~~ Uif' o\- ~~ Co\AJ\~ ., ..l.Q..e_ Exktlo, (- \' \-\ l'
fV\.J'. , 1 ..t vp rc.. 1
.S~-\- W ~-\ Of\ ~ ~\a*-e Oft-~ \C1G+.S 'D ~~\i (..Q{f,_IL.j
e K\- b-e 0 '-tJh~·e6· b'1 c\-e(l ~f"\·L~l dt~­
(.o\ltf""(_ ;. ~ e ~ Q. \ l ~J Y. \ ~J .J \.\ W-\-~-\\ ~d kc _..(:c " ~lolL J e {~by
~D~ \)W~ l!l ctSJ~~ ~-~1 ~3h-\- ~~ ~""- ~J~t-h~} ~ ~{
b e.LA.u. ~ 'C>~· ~. ~.e...\l o S-e....e_ ~ j !U" .i \J QA.(.OI\.(C E "\v-~r~~..e ~ c_r/l c.
·t,l/1.. h.D.l~ (~(~() C..\-e-1-.. \'1~0 i ~ ~ ::r'"'~lortg toq sw3~ q-\- Co:).O/
.I"' r-e. '(3,q_\,.\l, )-oJw~JA ~\as- 1'\il . C.Tei-..-~. ~~~~~~ ::t.d)a)UNJ rro-
CJ...Q.-~'n~). ~ ~~"Jw.i~olo\Q_ ..Ccu(V"\ 1'\-.e.. ~\~ {lV'f,'C:l~ -H--e_ ~\q-\-<>r t'n
"'o-o )( \ CY\€ // .s Uuj' ~\ IV\ tv! ~0\f\US ~ \( ef . A f('r -o 't-(\111. tiXQ ~ ~ 2 1/ ~ yeoJ'
-W~ '{'ll.N{)6 .i \nee.. Lt- t J- U .. u.l.\L.lt\ \ i ~ 6.~ Cal~ f"'to1~6 a WfY
~ &\e.~ S.~\ct.t'n.t ""~M ~\~~
01\h.o,}Qf'.

c_~.c..G. a ~cJns\ '-(>Cia\.y Q.S Ct 1 h'O!'\hCV\. ~ ~1'\.QrvA-I'l~
~~ fY\~ ~ ~Q ~QI'j\)~ ~~ ~Q.\CAA.(*\0/V\ uW't -~ Coull{ .
oCI e q 6A'(')_g • '\.hw e.uQf' I o\JQ('q/11 ~ re c.IDrd
ti\ -\he_ \n.i~~ C.qifL -s~ Cl ~\\vn ~ CA 14-o"' ~}.n_j -\o J~\o s ~~ ~- ()Ct\:\v." 6'-i. ~l-.SC\1\(2_ o\-- -\--n.~te\r ~-G- .
~ re·h\,'o() 7::k- VIW'Je-,hc.)/\ ...~~ I UJ.e.. wll( r e.v('e....:J CV\~ (....01\J\W -\i.e
/h..9/'f\i G-t kv..s~~ ~10vl"'-\ ~n ~\~ tv\Cvl'~~~ fr()(.Q]~Vlj' LC4l~
h 4~ ~~..on CY' ~ e'L{->\~""t ~ ~e. reQ~oJI {o, ~ ~~s lvl {~\it1 1l-Jl t~lvr
G/\ ~ ~ 6~ Ll ). t { ].._ yeo.r ~ -e \~ . ~ f..e.Q ~V\2 Mev, ~OV\A.{ ~. (1\ ~· tVt-
.S\CI\ \-- (...0)~. ~\JA \)f'€J«:\-~ a.. c..N'OilleJ
~d -\'\L {'eq·\ \)oJ'~eS \h ,_'"~-£\- +os~ bX~~. o..-, U/\':4lul)alc,{~ ~e \{
·\o'i ~\ -ht1 h at u e!'.\1 nJ h \J " j hts 0'"\~ \rwM r-e.N(-\, llJ +-a \~ 6-e~~\ L.r ~~J 0/\8
(V'-O~J ~ \. ~ LoVJ""'-\- ~ f\t\ CA/l~bV\A-(J. O...~.lie{ ..\"'h\~ ~t S k-1 ~ Gvll~ t -
~~c.v\~ ~re~a( h eon~
c . KI\-\J '-"" .S. o.r-e.. ~\1 \ e.W e/1 cQ -\-u Vu..« LQ A.J-u '
'\ \

o"'b'-t1l\o% . . S ~~ ~c.oJ"~-S. 5 h..o\..(\d be-h\ed o.s. ct S'->{)~l~k( rer~ W,
.S ~·,.1(.u ~ or~v'A\o ~ : M
)Q]) "'?Jl?"V fd}JO"r) 1 ~ ~ 1O)L ·~_J_) \/tks('("'YJ' -yj I -tY ~V)Y\ (}tJ '(_VI l~'h
1 rtAJY)tr r~ ~ d F~ ~ s::. .t. 't, o0) L ')'\1 ·..)G f \-'~· o-")
JCl:3 Vtt.~tt-~
?J'i-t ~ \rf) ~~ ~~~ CN\"
yr;r, -d~ ~ """"~ vcr-ICJ-J(} _s:. v_,
I¥~ f~ \.Lf) ~ --Y~ r·d-\~ v 1' (2!2.. fC\ \ --=tF Uot\ ~ »~'' VO\ \'d ,J' -yvo ~J"l:>'Jl? -)0 :7 n \Yt5'-Vo~nv -~\'
01~ 1-vovvM~~\ y to tvowcf~n\'b -jo 01~ _) o-" b '1 -Tl? 't\-- +=
~ l
~rJ?}d -J'l ~Yl?vod~~.vn ~r J.,~OJ?>'-1 7JY1() ·):0~-

/\'
CSINIB02/CINIB02 TEXAS DEPARTMENT OF CRIMINAL JUBTICE 08/18/15
ST55/LS00069 IN-FORMA-PAUPERIS DATA 09 ~ rZtG : ~:ii
TDCJ#: 01123880 SID#: 03437930 LOCATION: STILES INDIGENT DTE: 03/26/15
NAME: CALTON,ALLEN FITZGERALD BEGINNING PERIOD: 02/01/15
PREVIOUS TDCJ NUMBERS: 00484586
CURRENT BAL.: 0.00 TOT HOLD AMT: 0.00 3MTH TOT DEP: 0.00
6MTH DEP: 153.57 6MTH AUG BAL.: 28.84 GMTH AUG DEP: 25.60
MONTH HIGHEST BALANCE TOTAL DEPOSITS MONTH HIGHEBT BALANCE TOTAL DEPOSITB
07/15 0.03 0.00 04/15 ill. 2-3 0.00
06/15 0.03 0.00 03/15 137.36
05/15 0. 13 0.00 02/15 142.71 153.57
PROCESS DATE HOLD AMOUNT HOLD DESCRIPTION

STATE OF TEX MOUI\ITY):{F _j_e.J~_G_y~()Y)
9
ON THIS THE ..!Jl DAY OF\::f¥§TIS.-t:=~;·r~ I CERTIFY THAT THIS DOCUMENT IS A TRUE,
COMPLETE,AND UNALTERED COPV MADE BY ME OF INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THE
COMPUTER DAT~IBASE REGARDING THE OFFENDER' S ACCOI,J!iT. NP S I G:
PF1-HEL.P PF3-END ENTER NEXT TDCJ NUIYIBER: U~~Q_(JOR SID NUIYIBER: -------·---------·

STEPHANIE LUTE
Notary Public, State of Texas
My Commission Expires
03/03/2018

Notary without Bond

RECEIVED IN
COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS

AUG 2 6 2015

Abel Acosta! Clerk

r-

/
l
C\Qr 'i}

()_Q : =c: "' ('(2_ A'\ (" \ \- Q{ ~ 6-o..u.t_j

C:}.) \4\0-M'~ A.\-.(:,~\~ .Ap(l01'~··~ Xf"'\.J~f'OM 0{:---·~ l.I,Jrtt ~f ~ ~

._,:- ·, \JJ Q..Q_\ct~\cJrJn_J 'T4~~~ c.(.,'--l_D-€\~4/\ r..ul4~ ~~ (lo,U ef
CP/) t""VJ.\vv/) 'for u "!~ \ U \-1 LL ~ Acc..u~~ ( (\ r Met-. }. ~j Pe -\,\, J"
(gt) ~~.\.o('J ~q-h~A ~(\~(~~ ~revt.oy.J ~lt\~JS
C\~t-o( ~ ·~ pl( l.o rri e,j \ \:{

Ql\~ f\ en ~ 1 ~~ Uf'.\. h--e J. evv6 ~~ ,_ eA ,o ~- ~ ~ ~o::;tp
\c~-\- ~~ Ac..L.i:>W\-\ J~~ ~ ft"k~ Orlj-1\t 1 \ \ ~ ~f\ \€. weJt if!_ -h XLe__ J ~ ( -e 6 Ceut ~ c:t6~\..K? ,
AtJ o f,\Q_ M.cJ' 'l -~ 4-Lt. fJ 4~J § {' -e.crci-1 CV7,ci C{J r~.- ..ft..(_
~ JZ. (\ ~ b.U'· J-o -€_4~ ~ ~- PQ ~ ~~~ ~-\w- (\ ik_ I

--fct~ (jJ tt.~ Qs- b et vk_ ~ ~ ~ 11-P . J . A .-J, t ~ C\' lJ 0
--€/\ clo J . ~ '"T2. \ -Por I~ C1 v-e -to -hIe
~..e Acvoi"V"\~~l· "j {)-€\1~d) hr Lui 'D-\-~.t +orej4 \f1j 1
1..>-)QJ -hr-.'A ~C!.SJ
rvtav\e ~ ~ ~~ Jvt,dtif l90~ OojvJ\)nd Dr. Ar\i'llsh:Yt;Tx../"6'~
--c) lA ~ ~JL Lovt\ ~ .J ~uJf\S L{ ol e0 - Ke ~'?tl\~ J \. ; F+ C!Jif.~ ;T~-~~ 19\...

~ ~cJ' \-e ~ M q,l t t\n
Q/'\- Li o L LV. ~~ ~\tvtuQ ~ ~, F~ \.A.)ur~ 0-x. '~''c,
0./\ ~ - \ ' - { ~ ' ,.. (\ (\
~\
\f r (I+-:~ •
L( lA.)I..A.JIJJ'-.
oC
c_ ('I "M) fla'l Af p-eed (Ieol'\
A'::::. f.=oil ovJ.S :
_:r:._
u) ~\Jro\ IJ (?{1)~~'".1 ~ (l)J..Q. I i' )I) 61 j Q..,~ I jV\ wrt« !i't 1/( a. d ~J
('/Q Ct ·cu ~_) +-a Q Lo Qcc. r'\1\et ~ ; ~ N_ M_ Ct.. ~ a d ~' .\-1 Jr\ 4 ( u pi'e J'
\)vvt~ ~ \4 \-v r c...v-o u \. 6.-- have_ .+-o M·t u J ~c, I ~4'~ a ·f.
h.i\ .} ~ ~ L- C1 \, ul\ .-f-o ( M. 4~ 0 r ~:-ef re ~~ I u n 4o w rd-~- J. o (""\ ()/\ l(
Go'{) I eJ.
l2) ~\c,.;;nJ _s-o ...,~ .kte-> pl.).)e~ c,JuW~.k.,( r/.1)(
-\-0 ~ .1 M~ 1~ cv, 6 s "'~ , Dv..e +v s v c)-1 « d0'fl re Jlf d. ..! ~
~M ~oir1..J '-"'~uJ hI 1 rr-R~~\ f'~ ;-1"'--!lol9(p 0/\ ~-1~-1~.

~~~-F''~-
~ (\ J9 1, a&'"'~ --~..~ "+ "~-- ~ lrJ> Ocly "1' ""'~i'"J~ v >;-s~""\Ulll

)oo"l/(} -1-o "~-,~~0~ aJ 110 ·c: -s \ \)\Jv ·-~~
t, (\o ~ -'1-~j_-j-g. 1-s-~.L--w.~""Jc> f\ .0'\k ~I ,N I' 1'~'.,'1~3 'o ~r'r>~\V (8

·~ J~~'OD o-s QJ o o )t>
l.J~~'JD ~~llqJbjo-' cr"c~o o~ u~ j\~fhvJ ou~vord-J~.J \..V'O :r: (t)
4 ~+);>w 0'-tK J Q \l}\-n4 -~ fu,~cr P~ )to ~o)~ hm\~~
j-Q htlb~d ~ ~:vn J'o~r ~vo ~S ·0'\K 0-...\ "':Y~~d} -vv"J
-:r:: tJVU rl )?~ o~- q ~ ··-J o )a \oQ'-') -fJ ~ \rlQ ~~-\- · ~'-''0-C'll \ ....r0 t"' v.P()
) -J q. I
-L \-b'1t: r~r· V-;)\.J~P'~\rf} ~ 1 Q1~l'e,\\~ l.fo.t\\:J),,~,, VO\\v· \f)

'~~vovv 7 0 -t'~ ..>~ uo~'\'7J& ,~ 'JG \'J·o~~r V::t: ~~b~~1•o ~
? ~VAn ry -\Vo\NYY)~;"JJV )~~l?\~"t\

rvroJ 0-y )bV\jhN \ - . ) J
._j~b\0\l
-J-0
~VV'~ -~ u-r-
Vcrt)b'J VI~\\ Vo nv ~ vx
~ Q (Y '()S'Y'I"O J

·'~
_,
I rH-o I J --atD ~ --)..." ""=- --~. ,~ vW c> v r, """~ "flv ':><>-'?'\a-U
.'
01tk <>t -\"'\""\ ~ \l.C1 \ >:. J "'1" Vl>\\''1' s--•uv 1\~\.' vf' s \ l 'J ~
~

-:l ~VV (}-M~ b SX 1
,\l " t;i''"'\"-3 >o \'~"''1\'V' (C11)
b -oS -o~ -\-~
I

) t \1""d.f"' ~"""' C-\ Ol ~Jb j
\;1- '!."> I £ Jo'l.."' - 9,.\ -1l\N f ~if) \'I' ';>-\ -) 0. S-t: 1)!:m d -0 .m1 1-? ~ 01 ~ Q!Vd RJ,)

- o-J u~ (_Q·b-\ {A ~d-\~ ~JO ~vo ~ -10 ~o' \Y'C"y) uo; I ~-J11_j.
JQ fd V )'~ U 10 I V\A")r frOJQ...v.iuJ }~OJ \}? \ J_}_ ·-J- 0 fl -c 0 ! l7 0 -\-~JO) '1.? ~ ()
"hO.cn ::poJJOJ ~~vo -) fl~.JO'":) ~-~ --r\ Q 5':r }1 ~\~C\~"~3 ~-Y.? ~1f'P~V (L,.)

~oJl?c) 'tl? i.vvl0~ (t-£ )CYV~! LO)'& p~,Q..\'\ f~Lt'SLCJ
\ O(Y ~ \ 0 \~_L.J'O:::j ~J\ t) s-.::r: Jj I\ t'C)')")(~ ~r;? ~l"'frJ~V (OJ)

s-[ ra31?o -\1? j~c>v- f1l. ~-a ·~~~,.~
''h.;J...L }0 \~.d-__L w'~~...ro-~ 4'\-\ s::r: uJ~\ -\''·"~~~3 "lv.:> ~\r-e~ Co\f)y o~e_
o0 ~u ~-"'\ -\1-e_ u. ~.Go vf'T I)C A~p.e.cds fl' (~ c 1 ~Q~O~
~i~ ~:-t- 0" vt b f-Q.( .AQJ' d ~\--lo/1 -ro o,·.srnt'sr f=or Lo.U..L of
Gvt

~ '--v\oj~~ 1V\ ou\ W ~v'J'-\~ ~-\c\;tn A-t~~' i--. cu\- Pu:S'.e___s 16-19,

Q~J ,A\-\u.chQ ~ OS E> u ~ ~
'
CtCeJ ,_A \-·\c.. W.-~ ~s E > .2/\ ~· '~--- AA-· 6' o.f~s :2. t c.t 0 ,

(j j) A-\-.\-et ckt ~ Ol..J &k, 6 t 1\ 0 1r 1 ~ o.. --\-('J-Q 0/v ~ (\red- ~1 Dt:-
t CQ)

~ ~ ai\A &\- ~- .s~,~,lv-l1 ~~ -ro ~ lo)M1\-~ 0-.tJ~a-)J_Q_ 'l o~~ott\ _
yv-.o-h v-1 10 Oti ~"vii~ ~wJi..tV"\ -\-o cJ-t~ \q o~- 11-e. Tc-i--L;'vi\ p{tlc_ ~~ ~~l e_r
•
jLdqJ-or_J A~-(. ~Q..tl611 To iJ\& 0t-l ~ ~ ur .s \.w..-t{-·+n
~~w 1'-\ t.t. ~~ \~os C\'JH OrCic-hlQ. CZA~ Q.QMe~'t e.s L.oJ~ Pyyl?A~j''i...
Cv\- pC\~fL 3D
- .,, l(

llq) A\-\ovhe-~ &'-Jo'\ \ 0 \5> a. \-r~ 0/\~ G-Dfr-e.-ct C-0{>W'V.s. GA\~C£.t.\1bn 6~ ~~ ~0/l~ ~jh\- TV App.ea( Af(J.QAdj X
~-\- Qu._S~ 3(

(~oj A~a~~ ~i E-t-\..\ 'b \\: ~ ~~ \~ a.. \-,lM? CVld Go rreG\ (_;v~'f
b~ A\\€.1\ H ~·' Ccd·\-vrl A> D\;(R. ~pea\ A('~e.., t1 ~ 01+- ~Qje J 2
(_~\j A~\-~~~ QS Ex~;~l~ ,.,Stt \s o._·\-n}.~- Q/vct c..oriecl-lPf'(
o ~ /V-Dt, .,,.., He> r T ~ \Up o r4-u'~ fLe-c..o; 6 &1 ~ At'~ }.CUJ; t a€
~c.~lt ~ 10 \'"[ ~ LotM.u>l a. 6 tupoi'\V>J ilQ.wn~ Ap(lll1/i, 1 '~- a\- f·:JJ

( ~ :1-J A ~CtcN l ~~ £J-.~(~\~ \~:1" "t~ ct:\-r:u..e CV\~ (...().rf(.c.Jc Gb~l( (r\- or~
A-(>Qo~'.(\~~ Goi.V\~··\ t=Os ~ ...AcfpQa( 0/\d D"~ ~r LoW\-'\- (le_poJWr
s.\- ~· ~~{ \\ QJ -w ~t e.p~ ~'Or\.v~ 6l.cuvu ~ 3~
(:lJ) A\\c.~~ ~ e~ ~~ lo~ \: \lu_: t-& o. ·\r lA.Q Cv\6 co rreG\ ~PY 0-\--
A~~\\a:k.f LoLV\J-eJ . ga.rr1 A\-tvri'~ ,_;.J{..;~~v.)r) O{Jf1~~ cA~are-f 35 Cl//d3h

(2l\) A-\-~ c~e ~ Ct ~ E)(\,\, 1;-r\- '.., Vu \ s. q_ \-,lJ\.Q 0/\ d co r r-c c\ ~'f(y o-C
'·
Lt-tW\1> A~\-€.1\''ftt (evli-tYl ~ -S\-~ S ~~1\V' do.::bc\ s- 2-IJ
AfpLq~))( Ot\- @ag~ 3 7 ·

~\ql,.u \"'-_~ A\.(., ~C ,-t Afpe-1 f1 x.. .::r,..,d ~ 'I( fJ a.~ \ \) t:>{' \} j
'
I

c~s) A\\c. c.M.e~ C-tS £'k ""'\~\\ ~w \( .\ ~ q \- ('~ Cv\~ (.;o t f'e-Gt ~~ 't 6~ ~
"'f\(\et\ o V[ D.f
E ~\"'.\,,-L'\ ~
{)S ~!'I"\ ~~ \ ~~rN2.~\\c Gt.Q\wn \)..e\.ti\)t ~~ A~~'~i¥.. aA-- fa.~ 4~
0- ~) A-\-\-~~~ 4~ E,J,\ b\t \\ 2'' :Ls 4 ·tcv--Q.. Cvld c...o rrec.k Go~'-( -o-f
'""-Ho..r~ p4 S~ q 0 ~ ~\a\ G:,W'\~ rn """'"""!""""' 1=1~6, In ~J
1 oC tc.c\1
C...Onc\u.!JQf"') 0·\:-·· L~ Q/\J 0\'~ ·1="JI.e~ 0/l 1-1-67 tn . C-1.\1- 6a7CQl~ -D'8\.f1i ~"6 ._A O-(Jp1V1hi-.. ec/-\- ~fe.. l!JS

~ L1) -~\-9 vhe.~. ~ E: Y-k~\o~l ~\'AI\ 2L.& ct \-rv-JL Q/\d e-c\{'{'cl U:>f('t ~
(4

e V...~ ~a~ e.- ~0 o\-. \r' l!t \ C..O\JJ't' s ~~.fW'l &VV'-, ~(l)d.'""' ~ -l -t> \. ~c~ I
1

G-onc.h.(~l dl o~ ~ Cv1c\ oc-W. ~de~ o.n 1-9-'6 7 in c-e~er~c.e..
-\-o c.o1~_f ~-e-\J\un . ~~"" C..O\':-t
() ..(.. M~~o-v...u. GVCd -h ~~\ U Ct \J fY\~~) ti~ \-o -1~ ev--e k~~ (( U' I Cf 0 '6
o o .3 w!n>~ Cc · J ~c:'4~~" j1x_.l ep o l.:l · J ~u~ g..e__ Lot..t.l ~ ~-\- UJILS
Y o I w . $-e--\ Krqp &~ 1 ~ t v Jf1/\ 1-r>Z ~~ 19c., 1 CVi ~ o'~-t~:J c.*
C\QJ' \L- ~mcd WI)~ i f t-l() 1 w- G-tl\ ~C\P ..)-\- · 1 +i:. ~~ -;T'>~..7{of9~
Dr'\ ~-\ after the time to per-
being recorded; showing: · · · fect the appeal has 'expti-~d~fil~! the uih.ranscribec1
notes or the original recording of the proceeding with
(1) the numbdr and style oflhe case before the the trial court clerk. The tr!al court 'Clerk need not
court;'· · •·· retain the' notes beyohd 15'years' of their filing date.
(2) llie name cif each person speaking; . Eff. Sept. l~ 1997.: ·i ; · · ·~, .
(3)0the event be1rig recorded such as the voir
Rule 14; ' Recording arid
dire, the opening ·statement, direct and cross-exami-
nations, and ~b.ench c.onferencei:J; B~~·adc'kstip.g. ·court
(4) each exhibjt offered, admitted, or excluded; Proceedings
· (5) tl:le time ()fday of each event; and Notes and Comments :
(6)'' the .ina'ex riumbe~ on the recording device ,Comment to ;1997 .change: lfhis is former: Rule
showing whereieach event is recorded; 2~.· The ru~~ ~re~tten _;mcj now; allows recor~­
iiig arid broadcasting' 6f court proceedfugs at the
(c) iiftet: ~ proce~ding ends, file\vith the elerk the discretion· of the court and subject tO the stated
origin_all?gi / ,, . . .: . : ·_ . . guidelines; ; ,,
(d) have the original recording stored to' ensure 14.1. Recordipg and Broadcasting Permitted
that itis; presery~d
.·
~nd is accessible; arid ' . '·
- ··:. · ' " ' . . \•·.
.An .appellate ·court rriay •permit. courtroom proce'ed-
(e) enstir~ that r:o one gains access to the original ings to be broadc,ast, televised, recorded, or.· photo-
recording witlioutthe court's Written order. . graphed in accordance with this rule.
Eff. Sept. b,199f" ' .,; . . , .. . ' . : Ef(,
.... ,.
_Sept.l,l997,
. . ..
13.3._ :.Pr.iorities'of Reporters.· _ 14.2. Procedure
Th!( ,@kl. ~burt. n\ust help ensu,re that the. vishing to .. broudcact, televise, rec-
work priorities. The reporter's duties ;elating to ord, or photograph a court proceeding must file
... -- -------·------- ------------·-- -·-----------------

~ui~'-'34. A,:}:ipeli~te. :Re~ord . (10) any request. f9r preparation of the
reoo~; ' ··
34.1. Contents (11) in civil cases, a certified bill of costs ·
The appellate record consists of the clerk~s recqrd ing the cost of preparing the clerk~s record,
and, if necessary to the appeal, the reporter's record. ·credits for payments made; ,
Even if more than one notice of appeal is filed, there · (12) in criminal cases-tl;le trial court's ce.J;tltJca·tioi-
should be only one appellate record in a case. of the defendant's right of appeal under l~ul.e
Eff. Sept. 1, i997. . .
and · .··· ..
34.2. Agreed Record (13) subject to (b), any filing that a party
By written stipulation filed with the trial court nates to have included in the fecorcf ·
clerk, the .parties may. agree on .the contents of the (b) Request for Additi~nal Items.
appellate record. An agreed record will be presumed , (1) Ti~e for Request. · At any time before
to contain all evidence and filings relevant to the clerk's' record. is prepared,. any party may. file.
appeal. To request m~tter to be included in the ..·the trial court clerk a written designation ·_snE~ci1Fvit1efore the
the· parties cannot'agree, the trial 'court must~n any
time for perfecting the appeal, the appelia~t mu~t
party's motion or at the appellate court's request-
determine what constitutes an accurate cop;y of· the request in writing that the official reporter prepare
missing citefu and order it tci be included' in the clerk's the reporter's' 'record. The request must designate
the exhibits to be included. A request to the- court
record or a supplement.
reporter-but not,_ the court recorder~must ·also
·'(f) Original Documents. If the trial court deter- designate the portions of the proceedings to be
iliiries that original docum:~rits fii~d with the t;ial included.
cbrti~t cl¢'rk should be inspected by the _appellatec'ohrt (2) Filing. The appellant must file a copy of the
or sent't_q that CO\lrt in lieu of COpies, the trla] court . request\vitn the trial court clerk. ; .. ·.
' mu~t. make. a!l order for the safekeeping, tl~ansporta­
.:(3) Failure '£6 )illieiy Request.. .An app~ilate
tion, and return of those original documents .. -The
court must not refuse to file a reporter's record or a
order . must list the original document;:; and ,briefly
supplemental r~porter's record because of a failure
descl:ibe thepl. Ail. the documentS must be. arra~ged to tim~ly reques(if . . '
i'n their listed sequence and bouild fiTrr!ly tog~ther.
On any_ party's motion or
its own initiative, the, appel- ,,(c);fa:;;tial Reporter's Record.
late court rnay direct the trial court cJerk to ~elld it - - (1)' Effect on· Appellate Points or Issues~ · If the
any original document. . . . . ' appellant requests a partial'reporter's record, the
(g) Additional Copies of Clerk:s Record in Crimi- appellant must include in the request a statement of
nal. C:ases. In a criminal case, the Clerk's record must ; the points ·or issues ·to be presented on appeal and
be .made in duplicate, and in a case in which the death Win then be limiU:!d to those points or issues.
penalty was assessed, in trip!i6ate. The· trial court .- · ·' (2) Other PaAies May Designate Additions. Any
clerk must retain the copy or copies for. the parties to othe~ party may'. designate . additional exhibits .and
use. with the court's permission. ._, portions of the testiino_ny to be included in the
reporter's record. _ ··
(h) Clerk May Consult With Parties. The clerk
may consult with the parties concerning· the contents · (3) Costs; Requesting Unnecessary Matter~ Adc
. ditions requested by another party must be included
6f the clerk's record.
Eff. Sept. 1,.1997. Amended by Supreme Court Dec. 23, 2002,. eff.
in the reporter's record at the appellant's cost But
J a?: 1, 209~· if-, the trial court finds that all or part of the ·
Notes and Comments -·· designated additions are unnecessary to the appeal,
th~;trial court may order the other party to pay the
· Comment to 2002 change: Rule 34.5(a). is costs for the preparation of the· unnecessary add,i-
amended to require that the record in a criminal
case include the certification of defendant's right of tions~ ··· This paragraph- does not affect the appellate
appeal; see Rule 25.2(d). Rule 34.5(c) is amended court's power to tax costs differently.
to .make clear that an appellate court may order · '·• (4) Presumptions. _The appellate court must pre-
- the;. trial court to make._ such , a certification for
inclusion in a supplemental _clerk's record.
sume that the partiaJ reporter's record· designated
34.6.... lteporter's Record
the
bY parties constitutes ·the entire record for
· pdrposes \:if revieWing the stated points or issues.
(a) • Contents. This presumption applies even if the statement· in-
(1)_ ·Stenographic Recording. ·u the proceedings cludes· a point• or' issue complaining of the legal or
were. stenographically recorded, the reporter's rec- factual ·insufficiency of the evidence to ·support a
ord consists of the court reporter's transcription of · specifi~ factual finding identified in that point';or
so much of the proceedings, ~nd any of the exhibits, 'issue.
that the parties to the appeal designate. (5) Criminal Cases. In a: criminal case,' if the
(2) Electronic Recording. · If the ··proceedings · '~tateriient contains a point complaining that the
were- electronically recorded;- the reporter's record evidence is insufficient to support a finding of guilt,
consists of certitied copies of all ·tapes or other the reeunlmut;L iHdude all the evidence admitted at
audio-stor~ge devices on which the proceedings the trial on the issue of guilt or innocence and
were recorded, any of the exhibit,s that the parties punishment.
. --- ------·· ---

'~

RuJ~ 34.6 . ;} ..
: .- :~

(d) Supplementation. - If anything r~levant is bruit- court clerk must ·give all original exhibits to the
ted from the. reporter's record, the trial court, the reporter fm· use in• preparing the reporter's record;
appellate court, or any party may by letter direct the Unless ordered to;,include original exhibits in the
official court reporter to prepare, certify, :and file in reporter's record, the court repprter must return
the appellate court a supplemental repo:tter's record the original exhibits to the clerk after copying them
, containin~ the omitted iterns. Any supplemental re- for inclusion in. the Teporter's record, If someone
porter's recoFd is part ofthe appellate, record. other than the tryalcourt clerk possesses an original
(e) Inaccuracies in the Repmter:s Record. exhibit, either the trial court or the appellate court
may order that person to deliver the _exhibit to the
(1) Correction of Inaccuracies , by Agree~ent.
trial court clerk.
The .partiep may agree .to .correct a!!, ipaccuracy in '
the reporter's record, including an. exhibit, without (2) Use of Original Exhibits by Appell~te, Court.
the court reporter's recertification. . . If the trial court' det~rmines that original exhibits
. (2), yorrection of Inaccllracies by 'rpal Court. If
or
sh,oulq be inspeet~le pqrtion of (e)(2) referring to the text of the record ·is simpli~
fied without substantive. chaj1ge., · Sp.bp:J.ragraph
the reporter's record, or. the lost or ·destroy'ild _ex- (e)(3) incorporates· the procedu1'es 'speCifi(td in
hibit, is nec~ssary .to them by the time we go to trial in the case. 15:1i:ll 10 THE COURT: Most of these motions the
!5:14:34 11 MR. CALTON: Do you have an indication 15:11:31 11 law does not require written findings of facts and
15:11:15 12 of when that is going to be, Your Honor? J5:11:J9 12 conclusions of law. So I will mot be doing such.
ll:H:40 13 THE COURT: He is going to be back in 11:11:0 13 MR. CALTON: Thank you.
15:14:H 14 town about the first of August. 15:11:ll 14 But the ones that the law requires you
1l:1l:H 15 MR. CALTON: So you're indicating that 15:11:48 15 will --
!5:14:41 16 we are not probably going to go to trial by the first 15:11:49 16 THE COURT: I will.
11:14:48 17 of A.ugust? 11:11:11 17 MR. CALTON: -- address them that way?
15:21:!8 18 THE COURT: Probably not. 11:11:53 18 THE COURT: Yes, sir.
15:11:19 19 MR. CALTON: We are not going to trial 15:1l:5l 19 MR. CALTON: And, Your Honor, on the
tl:1~:sr 20 ne::t week? 11:11:16 20 motion for evidentiary hearing, in Frank's motion.
Ll:24:lt 21 THE COURT: I doubt it. We are still in 1.5:21:59 21 THE COURT: Uh-huh.
11:14:1! 22 pretrials. Unless you \vant to go to trial rlithout 15:17:5'1 22 11R. CA.LTON: That motion is going along
23 hearing the pretrials. ll:1a:o1 23 ~lith the suppression motion, and obviously the speedy
ll:1us 24 l1R. CP..LTON: No, sir. n:1s:o1 24 trial motion Hi th the testimony that 1ve' re hearing in
15:25:oo 25 THE COURT: Okay. '\ \\ 1( l.l:ls:o7 25 court, correct?
Connie Gilfeather, CSR e:~""' 'tn\ D Off· q\ ~.(p Connie Gilfeather, CSR
Ground Eleven: Records lost or destroyed that were necessary for appeal.
#.
97. Applicant presents no credible evidence that a court reporter w,as present and
recorded proceedings on January 8, 2004, January 16, 2004, February 12, 2004,
Col--~,..,~"
~ \..IUJ. UUJ.. J 'Jh
."-\..J'
")(\(\If
.L..tVV~,
.,,,-1
U.J.J.IIo..&. ~
r>,.;l 'Jh
A.L.t-'..I...J..l ~\J\J
4-1\.J,
'J(\(\1.'1 ; , th;c;,
1
.1...1.1 ._ ..... ..._._.
r~f~~l1--. q{- ~ctf-e_ ~
24
________,___

67. Applicant has failed to prove that the records he alleges were lost or destroyed
should have been a part of the record in this case.

68. Applicant has failed to prove that records from this case were lost or destroyed.

69. This Court recommends that Applicant's eleventh ground for relief be DENIED.

Ground Twelve: Conviction obtained with the use of an involuntarily submitted
statement.

70. Article 11.07 usually may not be used to litigate matters which should have been
raised on direct appeal. Ex parte Banks, 769 S.W.2d 539, 540 (Tex. Crim. App.
1989).

71. Claims found in the record will not be reviewed for the first time on writ of
habeas corpus. Ex parte Gardner, 959 S.W.2d 189, 199 (Tex. Crim. App.
1998)(op. on reh'g). The exceptions to these rules are (1) constitutional errors
when the law has changed after appeal and (2) claims for which additional
evidence is needed for factual development. See Ex parte Bravo, 702 S.W.2d
189, 193 (Tex. Crim. App. 1982); Ex parte Torres, 943 S.W.2d 469, 475 (Tex.
Crim. App. 1997).

72. Applicant presents no credible evidence that the law has changed since his appeal.

73. Applicant has failed to demonstrate that additional evidence was needed before
this claim could have been raised on direct appeal.

74. Applicant's involuntary statement claim should have presented on direct appeal
and is therefore may not be litigated now. See generally, Ex parte Banks, 769
S.W.2d 539, 540 (Tex. Crim. App. 1989).

75. This Court recorrunends that Applicant's twelfth ground for relief be DENIED.

Grounds Thirteen and Twenty-One: Received ineffective assistance of appellate counsel
during the thirty day time pen"odfor the .filing of a motion for new trial.

76. The standard of review for ineffective assistance of appellate counsel claims is the
Strickland v. Washington test and is the same as the standard for ineffective
assistance of trial counsel claims. Ex parte Jarrett, 891 S.W.2d 935, 944 (Tex .
. Crim. App. 1994), overruled on other grounds, Ex parte Wilson, 956 S.W.2d 25
(Tex. Crim. App. 1997).

77. The two-prong test enunciated in Strickland v. Washington applies to ineffective
assistance of counsel claims in non-capital cases. Hernandez v. State, 988 S.W.2d

E~\.,,,'~ \~ \1 G It 0--(>f~' ~ Ct \- ~ C(1-07·~, 1-- G-\ P~s.-e. (J
SUPREME COURT BUILDING, 201 WEST 14TH STREET, ROOM 106, AUSTIN, TEXAS :78701
--- WEBSITE:·WWW:CCA~COURTS~S-T-ATE~T-XcUS------------
Case: 13-11083 Document: 00512467364 Page: 1 Date Filed: 12/11/2013

IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT

No. 13-11083

In re: ALLEN FITZGERALD CALTON,

Movant

Motion for an order authorizing
the United States District Court for the Northern
District of Texas to consider
a successive 28 U.S.C. § 2254 application

Before HIGGINBOTHAM, DENNIS, and PRADO, Circuit Judges.
PER CURIAM:
Allen Fitzgerald Calton, Texas prisoner # 1123880, was convicted of
attempted murder and was sentenced to serve life in prison. Now, he moves
this court for authorization to file a successive 28 U.S.C. § 2254 habeas corpus
application raising claims pertaining to documents that were procured by him
after his direct appeal was adjudicated. He has not made a prima facie
showing that he will raise a claim grounded in either "a new rule of
constitutional law, made retroactive to cases on collateral review by the
Supreme Court, that was previously unavailable" or facts that "could not have
been discovered previously through the exercise of due diligence" and that, "if . ·
proven and viewed in light of the evidence as a whole, would be sufficient to
establish by clear and convincing evidence that, but for constitutional error, no
reasonable factfinder would have found [him] guilty of the underlying offense."

• •• ·-••••·•~-----~----~----~····-·"-- •-·--------.------·--•----• • • -· ·-·•·- "•• -v -•··-·----- •
Case: 13-11083 Document: 00512467364 Page: 2 Date Filed: 12/11/2013

No. 13-11083

See 28 U.S.C. § 2244(b)(2)(B) and (b)(3)(C). Consequently, he has not shown
that he should be permitted to proceed with a successive § 2254 application.
Insofar as Calton argUes that his proposed § 2254 application is not
successive, he is mistaken. Because he does not seek to challenge a new
judgment or proceeding, his case is materially distinguishable from those in
which applications second in time have been held not to be successive for§ 2244
purposes. See Magwood v. Patterson, 130 S. Ct. 2788, 2796 (2010}; In re Cain,
137 F.3d 234, 235 (5th Cir. 1998). Finally, Calton's argument that he should
be permitted to present his claims under 28 u.s.a. § 1651
. or in an independent .

action is likewise unavailing. See Henderson v. Office of Thrift Supervision,
135 F.3d 356, 360 (5th Cir. 1998).
IT IS ORDERED that Calton's motion for authorization is DENIED.

2

--- ~-- ·- -- --- ------ ~-- ---- . --- --- --- -~ ~- -- ~-. --~--------------··---···-··- ····--·····--
CAUSE NO. 067-270690-14

ALLEN F. CALTON, § IN THE DISTRICT COURT
Plaintiff, §
§
v. § OF TARRANT COUNTY, TEXAS
§
STEVE SCHILL~R et al., §
Defendants. § 67th JUDICIAL DISTRICT

DEFENDANT JUDGES ANSWER AND MOTION TO DISMISS FOR LACK OF
SUBJECT MATTER JURISDICTION

TO THE HONORABLE JUDGE OF SAID COURT:

COME NOW Defendant Judges Sharon Keller, Terrie Livingston, John Cayce, Bob Gill

and Louis Stums, by the Attorney General of Texas, and file Defendants' Answer and Motion to

Dismiss for Lack of Subject Matter Jurisdiction. In support thereof, Defendants respectfully

offer the following:

I.
NATURE OF CASE

That Defendant Keller is the Presiding Judge of the Court of Criminal Appeals.

Defendant Livingston is the Chief Justice of the Second Court of Appeals, and Justice Cayce is a
1
former justice on that court. Defendant Stums is the Presiding Judge of the 213 h District Court

and Defendant Gill is a former district court judge. Defendant Judges are sued in their official

capacity, (Complaint pages 2-3). Plaintiff is a convicted felon. He asserts that Defendant

Schiller failed to provide him with a complete record. Plaintiff's allegations against the

Defendant Judges are all based upon the fact that they are current or former judges that had some

contact with the underlying criminal case or the appeal of that case. Plaintiff's suit against

Defendant Judges are for actions taken by the judges while disposing of a case in which Plaintiff

-·· - -- ---~- ------ -~--------------- ------ ----·-·-------- ------. -~------ ~------------~--- - -------- -~--------~--·- --- -- --· .w- -
was a participant. Defendants are entitled to judicial immunity and sovereign immunity which

are absolute immunities from both suit and damages.

II.
ANSWER

Defendants deny generally the material allegations of Plaintiffs Petition. Moreover, this

Court lacks jurisdiction over this cause of action. Defendants are entitled to judicial and

sovereign immunity.

III.
MOTION TO DISMISS

Defendants are Entitled to Judicial and Sovereign Immunity.

Texas law is clear that ·~udges acting in their official judicial capacity have immunity

from liability and suit for judicial acts performed within, the scope of their jurisdiction."

Twilligear v. Carrell, 148 S.W.3d 502, 504 (Tex. App.- Houston [141h Dist. 2004, pet. denied),

citing, Dallas County v. Halsey, 87 S.W.3d 553, 554 (Tex. 2002). "This immunity extends to

actions that are done in error, maliciously, and even in excess of the judge's authority." !d.,

citing, Stump v. Sparkman, 435 U.S. 349, 356-57 (1978). The immunity is overcome "only for

actions that are: (I) non-judicial, i.e., not taken in the judge's official capacity; or (2) taken in the

complete absence of all jurisdiction." Id, citing, Mireles v. Waco, 502 U.S. 9 (1991 ). "Whether

an act is judicial (or non-judicial) for this purpose is determined by the nature of the act, i.e.,

whether it is a function normally performed by a judge, as contrasted from other administrative,

legislative, or executive acts that simply happen to be done by judges." !d., citing, Forrester v.

White, 484 U.S. 219 (1988). Under Texas law, "judicial acts include those performed by judges

in adjudicating, or otherwise exercising their judicial authority over, proceedings pending in their

courts." !d., citing, Mireles, 502 U.S. at 13.
-------------

In the instant action Plaintiff is suing Defendants for actions taken by the judges or their

court in Plaintiffs underlying criminal case. These are clearly actions taken by Defendants their

judicial and official capacities entitling them to both sovereign and judicial immunity. The

instant action is nothing more than a collateral attack on a prior judgment. This Court does not

have authority to sit as an appellate court in the underlying action. Under Texas law the Court of

Criminal Appeals is the final authority on criminal cases.

Plaintiff is seeking equitable relief. This is not available to him in this case. While

·~udicial immunity is not a bar to prospective injunctive relief, against a judicial officer acting in

a judicial capacity or to attorney's fees, for obtaining such relief," Twillinger, I48 S.W. 3d at

504, f.n. 8, citing, Pulliam v. Allen, 466 U.S. 522, 542-44 (1984)(emphasis original), Plaintiffs

pleadings reflect that Plaintiffs claim is not for prospective injunctive relief. Plaintiffs

complaints are for past conduct and his request for equitable relief is vague. The Texas Supreme

Court has made it clear that "a declaratory judgment is appropriate only if a justiciable

controversy exists as to the rights and status of the parties and the controversy will be resolved

by the declaration sought." Bonham State Bank v. Beadle, 907 S.W.2d 465, 467 (Tex. I995).

There is no controversy that could be resolved by the declaration sought.

Finally, the United States Supreme Court has made it clear that there are limitations on

the availability of equitable relief against a judge in his official capacity:

The limitations already imposed by the requirements for obtaining
equitable relief against any defendant - a showing of an
inadequate remedy at law and of a serious risk of irreparable harm,
severely curtail the rfsk that judges will be harassed and their
independence compromised.

Pulliam, I 04 S.Ct. at I 978. See also, Adams v. Mcllhany, 593 F. Supp. I 025, I 032 (N.D. Tex.

1984).

- -~---~ ------ .. ------------·----------·-
Plaintiff cannot make the required showing of an inadequate remedy at law. Plaintiff

cannot make the required showing of a serious risk of irreparable harm. Therefore, Plaintiff's

request for declaratory relief should also be dismissed with prejudice for lack of subject matter

jurisdiction.

ACCORDINGLY, Defendants respectfully pray Judgment ofthe Court.

Re~pectfully submitted,

GREG ABBOTT
Attorney General ofTexas

DANIEL T. HODGE
First Assistant Attorney General

DAVID C. MATT AX
Deputy Attorney General for Defense Litigation

KAREN D. MATLOCK
.Assistant Attorney General
Chief, Law Enforcement Defense Division

Is/ David A. Harris
DAVID A. HARRIS
Assistant Attorney General
Attorney-in-Charge
State Bar No. 09056800

P. 0. Box 12548, Capitol Station
Austin, Texas 78711
dav id.harris@texasattorneygeneral.gov
512.463.2080 I Fax 512.495.9139

ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANTS
~\
; \
067-270690-14

CAUSE NO. 067-270690-14

ALLEN F. CALTON, § IN THE DISTRICT COURT
Plaintiff, §
§
v. § OF TARRANT COUNTY, TEXAS
§
STEVE SCHILLER et al., §
Defendants. § 67 1h JUDICIAL DISTRICT

JUDGMENT

On this the J/~ay of ~ , 2014 came on to be heard the Motion to

Dismiss of Defendants Keller, Livingston, Cayce, Gill and Sturns. After reviewing the pleadings

on file herein, the Court is of the opinion that said Motion is well taken and should be granted.

IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED ADJUDGED AND DECREED THAT the Motion

to Dismiss of Defendants Keller, Livingston, Cayce,. Gill and Sturns be and is hereby

GRANTED.

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED ADJUDGED AND DECREED THAT Plaintiffs cause

of action be and is hereby dismissed with prejudice to the refiling of same in any, form.

IT IS FINALLY ORDERED ADJUDGED AND DECREED THAT any relief not

specifically granted be and is hereby denied, and that this is a final judgment.

JUDGE
b - - -- -·

::\. '") CAUSE NO. 153-270690-14
' \

ALLEN"F"CALTON § IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF
§
vs. § . TARRANT COUNTY, TEXAS
§
STEVE SCHILLER, ET AL. § 153RD JUDICIAL DISTRICT

DEFENDANT STEVE SCHILLER'S FIRST AMENDED ANSWER AND
MOTION TO DISMISS PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 14 OF THE
TEXAS CIVIL PRACTICE & REMEDIES CODE

TO THE HONORABLE JUDGE OF SAID COURT:

NOW COMES Defendant Steve Schiller, and files this, his Original Answer and

Motion to Dismiss pursuant to Chapter 14 of the Texas Civil Practice & Remedies Code.

I.
ORIGINAL ANSWER

A. GENERAL DENIAL

Defendant denies each and every, all and singular, the allegations contained in

Plaintiffs petition and any petition which Plaintiff may )lereafter file by way of

amendment or supplement, and demands strict proof thereof by a preponderance of the

credible evidence.

B. QUALIFIED IMMUNITY

Defendant possesses qualified immunity for the matters alleged in Plaintiffs

Complaint.

C. SOVEREIGN IMMUNITY

Defendant possesses sovereign immunity from suit and sovereign immunity from

liability for the matters alleged in Plaintiffs Complaint.

DEFENDANI' CRIMINAL DISTRICT ATTORNEY OF TARRANT COUNTY, TEXAS' FIRST AMENDED
ANSW'ER AND MOTION TO DISMISS PURSUANI' TO CHAPTER 14 OF THE TEXAS CIVIL PRACTICE
& REMEDIES CODE (Cause No. 153-270690-14; Calton v. Schiller)- PAGE 1

.. ----------·-··-· -- ·- -~ ------ ------------------------- ------------- -~-----------------------·--------- ----------- .. -- .
···-·--·--··-- -------·--·--------------

OFFICIAL IMMUNITY.

Defendant possesses official immunity from suit and official immunity from

liability for the matters alleged in Plaintiffs Complaint.

II.
MOTION TO DISMISS

A. FRIVOLOUS CLAIM

Suits brought by inmates m district court in which an affidavit or unsworn

declaration of inability to pay costs is filed are controlled by Chapter 14 of the Texas

Civil Practice and Remedies Code. Section 14.003 provides dismissal of a suit if the

court finds the claim is frivolous or malicious. 1

To determine whether a claim is frivolous or malicious, the court may consider

whether: (1) the claim's realistic chance of ultimate success is slight; (2) the claim has

no arguable basis in law or in fact; (3) it is clear that the party cannot prove facts in

support of the claim; or (4) the claim is substantially similar to a previous claim filed by

the inmate because the claim arises from the same operative facts. 2

B. CALTON'S CLAIM

Plaintiff Allen F. Calton was convicted of attempted murder and evading arrest in

2005 in the 213th Judicial District Court of Tarrant County. Calton is a prolific filer of

lawsuits in state and federal court.3 As stated by United States Magistrate Judge K.

Nicole Mitchell, and adopted by U.S. District Judge Michael H. Schneider, "Allen Calton

'TEX. Crv. PRAc. & REM. CODE ANN. §14.003(a)(2) (Vernon 2002).

2
TEX. Crv. PRAC. & REM. CODE ANN. §14.003(b) (Vernon 2002).

3 See Plaintiffs Declaration Confirming Previous Filings, filed February 20, 2014.

DEFENDANT CRIMINAL DISTRICT ATTORN)W OF TARRANT COUNTY, TEXAS' FIRST AMENDED
ANSWER AND MOTION TO DISMISS PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 14' OF THE TEXAS CIVIL PRACTICE
& REMEDIES CODE (Cause No. 153-270690-14; Calton v. Schiller)- PAGE 2

b _\_1__:_ l'y~-\----~-~:..'b____ ~±_---~-~1.~.---2.~--------·- -·-- . .
···-----------··- ·-· ---- ----·-·-----------E:'f./1:\:\ ..
Defendant Schiller is the former court reporter for the 213th District Court.

Calton sued Schiller alleging:

"pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 1983 for (1) ... failing to prepare and file a
complete and sufficient record on appeal ... (2) for delay in preparing
requested relevant records necessary for the effective, fair and meaningful
resolution of appeal, (3) for failing to ensure Calton had been provided a
complete, adequate and sufficient record on appeal, (4) for the
unconstitutional resolution of Calton's first appeal as a matter of right on
an incomplete and insufficient record in violation of Calton's right to
access to the courts and Calton's substantive and procedural due process
rights and equal protection rights as guaranteed by the First and
Fourteenth Amendments."

See Plaintiffs Fifth Amended Complaint under the Civil Rights Act 42 U.S.C. §

1983. Additionally, Calton alleges a negligence claim under Texas law against Schiller.

Calton alleges that Schiller's failure to prepare and file a complete and sufficient

record on appeal prevented his criminal conviction from being properly considered on

appeal.

C. "N0 BASIS IN LAW OR FACT"

1. § 1983 Claim

All of Calton's § 1983 claims against Schiller are barred by the doctrine found in

Heck v. Humphrey, 512 U.S. 477, 114 S.Ct. 2364, 129 L.Ed.2d 383 (1994). If Plaintiff

were to prevail on the claims brought in this suit it "would necessarily imply the

invalidity of his conviction." I d. at 487. Unless a conviction is overturned or invalidated

by a court with such authority, a claim that would implicitly invalidate the conviction is

not cognizable. The Supreme Court in Heck held:

DEFENDANT CRIMINAL DISTRICT ATTORNEY OF TARRANT COUNTY, TEXAS' FIRST AMENDED
· ANSWER AND MOTION TO DISMISS PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 14 OF THE TEXAS CIVIL PRACTICE
& REMEDIES CODE (Cause No. 153-270690-14; Calton v. Schiller)- PAGE 3

______________________________________€?d~Lb_ _Lt '_~N-~~---~--~--~---- _a.~~- __e_~J~- _d::I----~-----------------
-----------

[W]hen a sbite prisoner seeks damages in a § ig8;3--s-uit, the aisfricfcourf --
must consider whether a judgment in favor of the plaintiff would
necessarily imply the invalidity of his conviction or sentence; if it would,
the complaint must be dismissed unless the plaintiff can demonstrate that
the conviction or sentence has already been invalidated.

I d.

In Vasquez v. Dunn, 2011 WL 5878428 (N.D. Tex. Sept. 8, 2011), the court held

that an inmate's suit against a court reporter should be dismissed pursuant to the Heck

doctrine. Inmate Vasquez sued the court reporter claiming that the court reporter's

negligence in preparing an "incomplete and inaccurate trial record" prevented fair

consideration of his appeal. I d. at *1. The U.S. District Court held that the "claim that

the court reporter prepared an inaccurate trial transcript, thereby interfering with his

right to appeal ... undermines the validity of his conviction." Id. at 2; see Penley v.

Collin County, Tex., 446 F.3d 572, 573 (5th Cir. 2006) (per curiam); see Mims v.

Anderson, 350 Fed. Appx. 351, 352 (11th Cir. 2009); see Holmes v. Garcia, 101 F.3d 697

(5th Cir. 1996) (unpublished per curiam). The inmate's suit was dismissed because the

relief he sought called his conviction into question.

Similar to the above opinions, Calton's conviction has not been reversed on direct

appeal, nor has it been called into question by a v.rrit of habeas corpus, and he cannot

maintain this civil action for damages which would necessarily undermine his

conviction.

2. State Claims

Calton also sues Schiller for negligence, breach of fiduciary duty and fraud.

Schiller as a government employee, however, is entitled to sovereign and official

immunity for acts allegedly committed in performance of his official duties. Cloud v.

McKinney, 228 S.W.3d 326, 335 (Tex. App.-Austin 2007, no pet.). Governmental
DEFENDANT CRIMINAL DISTRICT ATTORNEY OF TARRANT COUN"IY. TEXAS' FIRST AMENDED
ANSWER AND MOTION TO DISMISS PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 14 OF THE TEXAS CIVIL PRACTICE
& REMEDIES CODE (Cause No. 153-270690-14; Calton v. Schiller)- PAGE 4
___ . ________________ -· ___ _ _ _____£.~·h-ct.~_\:t_- ~'-.AJ-~'~----C¥{J-e4-~,_j... __Qu\___ p_«JL_J ~------
--------~-----·- -·--· ...

entities and their employees acting in their official capacity are immune from suits for

damages, unless there is an explicit waiver of that immunity. The only waiver of

immunity for a negligence cause of action is the Texas Tort Claims Act. To sufficiently

plead a cause of action within the Texas Tort Claims Act there must be an allegation of

bodily injury suffered through the use of a motor-driven vehicle or through the

condition or use of real or personal property. TEX. CIV. PRAC. & REM. CODE § 101.021.

Calton has made no allegation that fits within the limited waiver of the Texas Tort

Claims Act. There is not, therefore, any arguable basis in law or fact to suggest any

waiver of Schiller's official immunity for the state law claims pleaded by Calton.

PRAYER

WHEREFORE PREMISES CONSIDERED, Tarrant County, Texas, requests that

this suit be dismissed as provided herein. Or in the alternative, the Tarrant County,

Texas, prays that Plaintiff Allen F. Calton recover nothing by his suit and that Tarrant

County, Texas, recover costs of court. Tarrant County, Texas, further seeks any and all

such relief as it shows itself justly entitled.

Respectfully submitted,

SHAREN WILSON
CRIMINAL DISTRICT ATTORNEY
TARRANT COUNTY, TEXAS
Is/CHRISTOPHER W. PONDER
Assistant Criminal District Attorney
State Bar No. 24041705
Tim Curry Criminal Justice Center
401 West Belknap, gth Floor
Fort Worth, Texas 76196-0201
817-884-1233 I Telephone
817- 884-1675 I Facsimile
cwponder@tarrantcountytx.gov
ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT
STEVE SCHILLER
DEFENDANT CRIMINAL DISTRICT ATTORNEY OF TARRANT COUNIY, TEXAS' FIRST AMENDED
ANSWER AND MOTION TO DISMISS PURSUANT TO CHAJ'TER 14 OF THE TEXAS CIVIL PRACTICE
& REMEDIES CODE (Cause No. 153-270690-14; Calton v. Schiller)- PAGE 5

------······-------------·---------------·--------------G~\,"Tk\\-.)~N-~--~-e-'i-~-~-K---q{~--~fY"G.J-~-::-d.::S··--·-
CERTIFICATEOFSERVICK····

I certify that on the 26th day of January, 2015, a true and correct copy of the
above and foregoing was this served on the following in /compliance with applicable
rules:

Mr. Allen "F" Calton CM/RRR 7013 1090 oooo 0625 9535
TDCJ #01123880
Stiles Unit
3060 FM 3514
Beaumont, Texas 77705

js/CHRISTOPHER W. PONDER

DEFENDANT CRIMINAL DISTRICT ATTORNEY OJ wos guilty or nolo conlendcre and the punishn1ent uiu not exceed the punishment recommended by the prosecutor and
' " ' " " I " ' hv I he drfrnohnl- o dcfcndonl may :>ppc;J! only: (A) those malter.s tltat were raised by wnltcn motion filcu anu ru\cu on before
. ·-·---. r ~·" r. "''~A"'":' I /('Tl= Pflnr-,:niiRE 25.2(a)(2).
CASE NO.

THE STATE OF TEXAS § IN TEE 213th
§
vs. § DISTRICT COURT
~ ~-.Q) (J:_~
§
§ TARRANr COUNTY, TEXAS
~ .
NOTICE OF APPEAL

TO THE HONORABLE J1JDGE OF SAID COURT:

Comes now, ~ ~~ 0 ,.J__~ in the above styled

and numbered cause and gives this his Notice of Appeal to the Court of _ _ _ __

Appeals of Texas from. the judgments heretofore rendered against him in the

above-styled and nwnbe~d ca~.

J

~~~.
DEFENDANT

OR

~~c~
A()RNE,y FOR DEFENDANT

BAR CARD II - - - - - - - -
··-·-·---·~~----~-

TIIE STATE OF TEXAS §
§
§

~~&Jc~: TARRANT COIThlY, TEXAS

"NfOTION FOR FREE REroRTER'S RECORD th'ID
AFFIDA YITOF 1NABIT..ITYTO PAY FOR
COUNSEL Al'ID REPORTER'S RECORD

TO THE HONORABLE JUDGE OF SAID COL'"RT:
Comes now, CLlleA. ~l +'Ljf!._Y'c~.JJ C.CVl ~ , Appellant in the
above styled and numbered cause and submits this motion for a free Reporter's Record
for the appea,L pursuant to Tex. R. App. P. 20..2, stating that be/she is too poor to pay
for or otherwise obtain a Reporter's Record for the appeal or to give security there~or
either ill: whole or in part.
eW~tt ''Sl(- -~e~J., 'J._ ct-t f>-4.~ 33.
. ··- ---~---------~-- a
·---------- ---
THE STATE OF TEXAS § IN 1BE 213th

VS.
A-l\~
d .J.:~
!f«t.-\-zge-ra.l Q
I .
§
§
DISTRICf COURT _ _ ____
TARRANT COUNTY, TEXAS
~ •..

ORDER APPOJNTING COu"'NSEL FOR THE APPEAL
• AJ.'lD ;
ORDER FOR COt:.iRT REPORTER TO PREPARE REPORTER'S RECORD

On this day, it being Il:l4dc bo;r;n and appe!!.ring to the Court that the
Defendant is Vlithout counsel of his own selection to represent him herein., and that" he
is too poor to employ counsel, or give security therefor, to represent him herein and the
Defendant having requested that an attorney be appointed to represent him in the above
styled and numbered cause.
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED, ADJUDGED AL~ DECREED bv the
Courtthat &,,.~ df-A{ ' . ,
a. regulru:Jy licensed and pr cticmg attorney lS hereby appointed to represent the
Defendant as. his attorney, and said Attorney is hereby authorized to proceed to perform
the duties of the Attorney for the defendant in this cause.

to
And on this day, it appearing the Court that the Defendant in the above styled
and numbered cause, has given hisjber Notice of Appe.al to the Court of..,.._-----
Appeals of Texas. And it being made known that the Defendant herein has filed his/her
affidavit, stating the be/she is too poor to pay the Court Reporter for a Reporter's
Record for such appeal or give security therefor.
· The Court is of the opinion that t:fle Defendant is entitled to the relief as prayed
·I

j for.
...,, It is therefore the ORDER of this Court that the Official Co~ Reporter of this
~

...
'·
Court, S~ >J e,.., $ c.1_~ lle .r · .· , prepare and
.
.;
furnish a. Reporter's Record to be _used in perfecting the appeal in this cause.
!
:
\ ·.,
PRESIDING JUDGE

DATE SIG~"ED

'-----~~-'~-~
.... ,.--------
I

•
--~AFFIDAVtTOF BARRY J. ALFORD-
•
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ------------------

---- - -------FilE·o--
THDMAs A WILDER, DIST. CLERK
TARRANT COUNTY. TEXAS
Cause No. 213-007618-0843618-A
MAY 10 Z006
THE STATE OF TEXAS §

!~
TIME
§ BY
COUNTY OFTARRANT §

BEFORE ME, the undersigned authority, on this day personally appeared Barry J. Alford,
Affiant, known to me to be the person whose name is subscribed hereto, who; upon Affiant's oath
deposed and said: ·

"My name is Barry J. Alford and my address is 1319 Ballinger St.; Ft. Worth, Tarrant
County, Texas 76102. I am over eighteen years of age and capable ofmakingithis statement. I am
making this statement of my own free will and accord. No one has given or promised to give me
anything of value or benefit, to influence me in any way to make this statement. I voluntarily make
this statement in order that the interest of justice Will be served.

I was appointed to represent Allen Fitzgerald Calton (hereinafter referred to as "Applicant")
on or about May 21, 2004. On that same date, applicant was released from the Tarrant County jail.
Once I learned to where he had been transferred, I wrote him a Jetter informing him that I had been
appointed to represent him on appeal and, if he had any questions or comments concerning his
appeal, he could write me. In the meantime, I received the reporter's and clerk's records from the
appellate clerk. I spent numerous hours reading the records as well as many hours conducting legal
research regarding the points of error that I planned to raise in my brief.

It was not until just before I had filed my brief and sent applicant a copy that l was advised
by applicant in several letters that he was requesting some transcripts that he believed were not
included in the reporter's record which was the basis of my appellate brief. At no time in these
letters did applicant ever notify me that he wished to pursue a bearing on a motion for new trial. I
consulted with the trial court reporter, Mr. Steve Schiller concerning these nilssing records. He
informed me that the transcripts that applicant had inquired about were concerning bearings on
different cases and not the case for which I was appea1ing. I was never advised by applicant until
1received his post conviction application for writ of habeas corpus that be wished to pursue several
grounds for error, including ineffective assistance of counsel, a Brady claim and a claim for newly
discovered evidence.

As to his claim of ineffective assistance of counSel, since applicant had proceeded prose at
the trial for which I was appointed to represent him on appeal, a claim of ineffective assistance of
counsel would be a frivolous point of error since applicant waived his (J'h amendment right to counsel
prior to oial. In regard to applicant's other claims, the points of error raised in my appellate brief
were those that, after a careful reading of the record, were raised at trial by applicant and preserved
for appeal. Applicant never objected to tht points of error raised in my brief nor did he ever
communicate to me that be wished to raise any issues at a hearing on a motion for new trial prior to
filing his article 11.07 application for post cdnviction writ of habeas corpus. In fact, when the Court

521
E,(~,\ t \:- v LA'' ~.~'f.-. c.t_·\-
.·
f

• • --------1--------·-----

. of Appeals affirmed the.trial court~s judgment, I then filed-a-Petition·forDiscretioruuyReview mth·
the Court of Criminal Appeals in Austin on applicant's behalf. Applicant, on his own motion, asked
that the pending Petition for Discretionary Review be dismissed."

Barry J. A11i d, Affia

SWORNTOANDSUBSCRIB~~nf~.
)~ if
- OT Y PUBLIC F
TEXAS
TilE STATE OF
_J I
NAME PRlNTED k±tiO~ [.__, {dp ~-7JJ
COMMISSION EXPIRES 1D/.3) 'k:J
May 2, 2012

Dear Mr. Calton:

I am enclosing the four hearings that I took. These dates not only match up with my records, but the
Tarrant County Clerk has verified that these were the ones I took. My name was listed as the reporter
on the proceedings sheets in t.he clerk's file for these four hearings and no more.

Sincerely,

Steve Schiller
CAUSE NO. 12-4665-22

IN THE MATTER OF § BEFORE THE COURT REPORTERS
§
STEVE SCHILLER § CERTIFICATION BOARD

FINAL ORDER

The above styled and numbered matter came to be considered on the 12th day of October,
2012, before the Texas Court Reporters Certification Board (Board). The Respondent,
Steve Schiller (Respondent) appeared prose. The Board makes the following summary of
evidence, findings of fact, conclusions of law, and final order.

I.
Summary of Evidence

Tne Respondent has been a certified shorthand reporter since July 19, 1991. A complaint
was filed by Allen Calton (Complainant) against the Respondent alleging that the
Respondent failed to prepare transcripts for pre-trial hearings that were properJy requested
by the Complainant.

II.
Findings of Fact

1. The Respondent is a Certified Shorthand Reporter in the State of Texas, holding
certification number 4665 since July 19, 1991.

2. On or about March 22, 20 12, the Complainant filed a complaint against the
Respondent.

3. Notice and copy of the complaint, and notice of the time, date and place of the
hearing tc be held oa October 12, 2012, ·.vere timely sen.t to the Rcspoudei1t by
certified mail and first class mail to his address of record. The Respondent
received the notice and copy of the complaint. The Board received his response on
April 5, 2012.

4. The complaint alleges that, during the time the Respondent was a licensed certified
shorthand reporter, the Respondent failed to prepare transcripts for pre-trial
hearings that were properly requested by the Complainant.

5. Other alleged acts include failing to make reasonable inquiries about the extent of
the record.
- - ----------- -------------- - - - - - - ----- ---------~--- -----------------------·--·· ·-·---------·--·---·

The Respondent appeared at the hearing on October 12, 20 12 pro se.

7. At the hearing, the Board found the Respondent was in violation of the Rules
Governing Court Reporter Certification, Rule X(a)(4), and imposed a private
reprimand.

III.
Conclusions of Law

1. The Board has jurisdiction over the complaint filed by the Complainant against the
Respondent.

2. The Respondent received a copy of the complaint in accordance with section
52.027(b) ofthe Texas Government Code and Rule X(f)(1) ofthe Rules Governing
Court Reporter Certification.

3. Respondent received notice of the October 12, 2012, hearing in accordance vvith
section 52.028 of the Texas Government Code and X(i)(2) of the Rules Governing
Court Reporter Certification.

4. ' The Respondent's actions, as referenced in the above Findings of Fact, violate the
following:

Rules Governing Court Reporter Certification, Rule X(a)(4): Incompetence

FINAL ORDER

Based upon the evidence presented in Cause Number 12-4665-22, In the Matter of Steve
Schiller, the Texas Court Reporters Certification Board finds that the conduct of the
Respondent, Steve Schiller, violates the Rules Governing Court Reporter Certification,
Rule X(a)(4).

IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED by the Court Reporters
Certification Board, meeting in Austin, Texas on October 12, 2012, as follows:

That Steve Schiller is privately reprimanded.

This Final Order is adopted by the Texas Court Reporters Certification Board effective the
date of the Board Chair's signature, unless otherwise provided herein.
SIGNED this 7 day of Lh._ .....- '2012.

Ben Woodward, Chair
Texas Court Reporters Certification Board

£~~~b \\-- \'W t\ o.p~~~ 1 x c; ~ ~ ctfe_ Lfo
3
........ ·····-···· .. -- -:··:··::--·-···-·::.--- --7-::-:------~-----~~--

-"~J (_ UJ.). S:e /\J o. D~ '\.{. ~ I \o t
/-'\\M··~~ci~r
\ ~ "-.__q
lk>n I n.
"- i C'
'\l'\..Q. .() )5~"'' \_r. \
U0 u./' \:' FILED
THOMAS A WILDER, OIST. CLEF
V \ TARRANT COUI'ffi'. TEXAS
d-- \ s \l" ~u ~\u Q n'i-
·--rfv_s\-cvk o-C·\e_}-.QS. AUG 05 2u1!l
·-ra rr&t \- \J::.V/1,\•tt ·Ye-'LCi.i'
TtME-·- - - - - -
_OEPVT
~'a ~.e.- \~e~~CJ\A\ A\\ 0'\t\f''c Co.C~ ()~~ L e_\-\v' "Tb l\-r'v-.Q-----.~~~-\....,.d-t-\0"--
----r-o ~ \.Q__ ~ .s.\-o.r\W 0-,) \~ -~ se c_p~~ 6 0 '\ ~ \-n c~ D -t--\e '1-Cti' ~ 0J\. \ -
o .\- , ~ \)~.Q_o.\s. At~y An~ A H Qr e..\-,; o l l-\-ea.r-1'n ~ Qe u \ ~ Y0c1. AJ ct;:;
1

ts(\,()-vJ \...()~ \n i~ ~ 0 iS+c: \C-\- .f- l4{CQ/\'\- lPU/"tft" r ~Ct u--e Q(so ~('­
(___,\-QJ }L. D

L-0&-'clec\.. 0 '--"'AJSL Lo~..A.\i s\-u.M~- Ot -\1"-P_ 2U1h ~vt~\ oat Court AUf(0ol t.:D\)1..-f ~a" s,-\-_~ hQ_re_ \d~ \0 ·~ \,Qc(cer
o~ ~ -vr\~un c_Q_\\g ~Q.S. /\t:>-\- b.Qnef\'\-ffh.Q_ a---~~ we~ Ct. ~~1"j~e~ 5e.x\uK
+c Ofl-'"\ i}.)l--\ ~ v..:ho\- 'i QU.. f\.lU2.~ -\-o ~ \ s COJ r'-( OL.-t-\-- '--{ D LAJ (Y'.A,fl.~-i \-er'ra(

d-u~ Q/1~ -h\~ ~ (€(A)\~ \n ~ ~~.e.\t~ L-Dw+ aA~ i?~\Q,{ItJ
--Y1"o r
\ r--.;.__ . ....,
,L ,_.._L,,/'\
•'--'! i
t \ ""'-""'
.\---n
• ~
+t""o
• • '--Z
CJ..O(,IQ.Hc+n
\ \ -'J\,.Y
t..ov..rf\J_., S.-e.Q. e, Jo. \}t\lqa~2
J _:r-1~~\-
VY\ er.J\ s1 L.t..c. v Mu.Je.Q. .ACJt-{ s\-016 \o'¥,{1 0'-1,~ C\-e-f_. Arr-Lr ~ J)i-.\-\] ~l..(~~'l
,;~ ocq) ( CoLv"'~ /\ch'nJ ~-\- r~~ \'~C t»tJ~i),d"' VC>\\\1 -\VQ\~0 O)oJJ

lt\1 ft'Jl7)--} Q --\-~'1'>-\f' o..f'odoJd at ~"? 6'u~~ lf'lk rl? '1 ht:"''Odo') ~J?'1K
U} ya~o)J-.vu flduo-1 ov r~ JJ "-~o~ :i"b') ~ .Jd-jJO~ t-.MOJ
yr. )b~--~1')_£_ '1J_):I\." ~ -JG Jr\~o~ ~0 y&>~')J~ ~ ..Jo ~v-c-j
o-v' ··dJO r v.!) ~ OJ\'\-~ _) (}-') '7 ") no J, vt o~~y:o s~)'P"r-~ JVV.
(Q. ~b) i. .;>j_ ') ~l $ ~ 'f ~ J ~ t' 1 ~ .>-c "'},';)_\ 'b \~ )0") \ ' -:) ~)fiQ)(}-U -\VO bJV' f~Vr) )~o-J ~~~ ~ V\ ->a-y4 '\ \YIP\?
- ~'1J_t l. r a-t\- v ~ -t-1'01 r \ h x o-t"'lacyl7 ~ -~Q'\,) .rv 1 ..J?rfY?) ~ {Y'\ •( -1-''-.} C"""' o-v 1 , L b 1
~-V\ft~DrndJ van;'V\~ C\ d~\ro)b ux -JG.
~~I) ~S)~~tG t~OJ 011'-G g rJ00"cJ r~ww 7f'.l.k -~ p-u~~1--tr ·n d-'-1
/O':pif:~}Q Jn~Jc vo ~\, ~Ja~ i~ b -~uf> ~VV .. ~'d\\CD ~r.v.o~wvv
Jl,i7)rn-J +\(\'"len Jvp~ h~ \-t)_ t I'C -~ U\\-tJ'o-\ r \II X" o ) ~ l.JCI'f1'~ \}J'A \ O)S~\/d"
Of 1-vorn")a-\j ftl~C'(") no yl/0) ~J-PJO ..t.t\/6) ?VO V?~l/Yl~v:r:-J ~~ii!?UJ
JrnJJO) f'1noJ17)1 JO .puCV) a-on~ ~ ~ 8 t\ VV ·~rua; ·1-e_L ~ -T~)
_ .fl1 J hy JJChiJ.frrt=> ~ rv~ )l? ~ ~ n _Q \.-1)..- [ lC"' 0"1X -} 0 fU..M'\) Y':har I> f ~)'")~
' Qf ~ Cl..t ~o 11~ -.,o-r \1J d )-.,..,v -V>? ~ 0-t -~r~ wJ~vo-:> ~vo ~\rl)ts-v'
or~ -\~~-no), j-.::t::"' ?JOJ~ r~-Jo~ )~~)~h.y V ~V
t vY'OJ ~ \ V~Ov ~ ~' C o-~ u-ocv- J "') h o 0
S"?Jm dJ ?r~ 'd-)\1 "vv I ~\.fUOJI oMOoJ'-\K l..vQJ'J- ~fcr\TvvvQ Sl ~VOCVO\~_) 0~~1-vvQ :a- ::J:.)
,
:.. __
[ } "d"d? & _,.)? '"j. ' \ ~chlo j! '\l t \, "1~3 .
t 0- Q[o?\N d-A-f0 r4.a o)J~ ·~ fu~ ~-t
-~@J r()Jal~ JJ»?w\\V'"O)"\'hh \:h.'h\ !ooo 01'0)Q -S\O'L f\ oYil~O
)roL..J \~\.l"f1r Mr s~JYO\'"~rv YCJ1'b/ r\.~\c3'i>" ~ lC'}J ~.\lrt") ();MJ~1~ fJ~t'\ ~ ~·v:::> 0\S\O)L-
\'X-L' '1k~~rJ , l-"6v~,-av · 10n \n-J o-c}~ n _s:::l "ciO")L -r-,_L1 U)-yfu~\-~ I 0:--"~ ~-JIG ~it~jnf ~ \ 0
JpocJ.rO"-V
' vcr~cJ 1f'f=)l? 1,./c fl? o ...J
hvo h9 ~·!))n:Jo J b ~~·~ ~ ))\,en ti= J6\ 1o- \ ~\/l'J'.A/0 ~ S\ '1k -J o d

tarnal lK'OA flil/lo\rv\ a. r ~- ~ 0V -y-oJ,-, J r · v)- t - ) vo ~- 0-\-
-pof~Jtj Yoh r-rJ)-;;) .;)
1

b?;VO p~ o ;r9 -rr~ d-10'-\l._.. '"~")b )blfOt'~ ~ b Vv~JOJJO~ cr\- ~ Y"l ' \ '
)t>tfcr) b r-r~~·4 '5 oo ·~ vy')~ U\~ 5·o'D9'") ~~·
,.-·-{
. ---·-···-··-···-·- ·----:-_-;:-:--::--:.:-::.-.--.--·.-

a Complete items 1, 2, and 3. Also complete
item 4 if Restricted Delivery is desired.
II! Print your name and address on the reverse
so that we can return the card to you.
a Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece,
or on the front if space permits.
D. Is delivery address different from item 1? D Yes
1. Article Addressed to:
If YES, enter delivery address below: D No

~\e0e. ~~~\\v--
\ctO~ £)o_sUJ~ .0\~
3. Serv_9 Type
· A"\ \os\-on7T~ I Gul~· ~ertified Mail"
D Registered
~ Pr_!9rity Mail Express'"
bj..Keturn Receipt for Merchandise
D Insured Mail D Collect on
4. Restricted Delivery? (Extra Fee) D Yes
2. Article Number
(Transfer from setVice /abeQ

es Form 3811, July 2013 Domestic Return Receipt

;j
76. Applicant presents no credible evidence that there is newly discovered evidence
that establishes his innocence.

Grounds Six, Nineteen, and Twenty-Seven: Denied right to self-representation, denied
due process, and denied access to court on Febnwry 12, 2004 due to being unable to
prepare an argument while in jail.

77. Applicant presents no credible evidence to support his claim that the jail
improperly denied Applicant access to the law library.

78. Applicant was advised by the trial court regarding his right to represent himself.
See Calton v. State, 2005 WL 2082202, No. 02-04-228-CR, Slip Op. p. 5 (Tex.
App.- Fort Worth Nov. 17 2005, pet. withdrawn)(not designated for publication).

79. Applicant was advised by the trial court that the cases were "rather serious" and
that "there were disadvantages to representing himself." See Calton v. State, 2005
WL 2082202, No. 02-04-228-CR, Slip Op. p. 5. (Tex. App.- Fort ~orth Nov .. 17
2005, pet. withdrawn)(not designated for publication).

80. Applicant advised the trial court that he was "willing to take the risk" associated
with representing himself. See Calton v. State, 2005 WL 2082202, No. 02-04-
228-CR, Slip Op. p. 5 (Tex. App.- Fort Worth Nov. 17 2005, pet. withdrawn)(not
designated for publication).

81. The Second Court of Appeals found that Applicant "competently, knowingly,
intelligently, and voluntary" exercised his right to defend himself. See Calton v.
State, 2005 WL 2082202, No. 02-04-228-CR, Slip Op. p. 5 (Tex. App. _: Fort
Worth Nov. 17 2005, pet. withdrawn)(not designated for publication).

82. Prior to the February 12, 2004 pretrial hearing, the trial court had been litigating
Applicant's pretrial motions in several of his pending cases.

83. Prior to the February 12, 2004 pretrial hearing, the trial court had been litigating
Applicant's speedy trial claims for a period of weeks, in between other court
business.

84. At the other pretrial hearings on the speedy trial motion, Applicant was well-
versed in the law as well as the facts of his cases.

85. The trial court judge was liberal in allowing Applicant time and resources to
present his speedy trial claim.

86. When he appeared in the trial court for the February 12, 2004 pretrial hearing,
Applicant did not seek a continuance from the trial court in order to further
prepare for the hearing.

E 'l-~, b t\ tr L l( Co(>{l10 ~~ (_ ct \- f4J__e_ L{0
9
••
i

87. In all the time spent hearing Applicant's speedy trial claims, the trial court had not
heard any evidence or law that would have permitted Applicant a dismissal of his
cases.

88. Applicant presents no credible evidence to support his· claim that he was denied
his right to self-representation.

89. Applicant presents no· credible evidence to support his claim that he was denied
due process.

90. Applicant presents no credible evidence to support his claim that he was denied
access to the courts.

Grounds Seven, Eighteen, and Twenty-Three: Received ineffective assistance of counsel
during February 12, 2004 hearing, February 24, 2004 hearing, and at trial.

91. The trial court granted Applicant's request to proceed prose on May 9, 2003. See
Application; Exhibit 1,p.1, 17.

92. Applicant represented himself from May 9, 2003 until the conclusion of the trial.
See Criminal Docketing Statement.

Ground Nine: Denied a requested jury charge.

93. The Second Court of Appeals has already determined that the trial court properly
refused the requested jury charge on voluntary conduct. See Calton v. State, 2005
WL 2082202, No. 02-04-228-CR, Slip Op. 12 (Tex. App.- Fort Worth Nov. 17
2005, pet. withdrawn)(not designated for publication).

94. Applicant presents no credible evidence, or argument, that the judgment in this
case has been overturned.

95. Applicant presents no credible evidence, or argument, that applicable law has
changed and the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals has held that it should be
applied retroactively.

Ground Ten: Cumulative Error Doctrine.

96. . Applicant presents no authority that the accumulation of these alleged errors is
cognizable as an individual claim.

10
'•

Q) jQJ .J r~ """" !\l'i.O'lrr V'l ""\~" 01"1" '1\""S::.. !'u'{"~\fri-:1 1\ ~ '-)]';( '1~\5\l
V<> ~r'! o\>Q) dv.1)'\~""' ~ <>-\- 1WM-v~ C) r a-~"'\ ·~ ~ sen Q .) 0"\Y.-'i"' '--'0--
• o-J"~~ )(!'\~ al\ 'V(1'S. J\1\\ ~'\).- ~ \.JO":\) \('\JCY1 ~0'0 VV
C"" Q/V

I ~~""'\TO l~\ bJ <>--\ -nWJ.j()
~~b~~\J~ -np•"'J15'J\J\\ -\b~" y~scn~ ~0\\~ ·ff\JV\ 6'\J~v-~~\.ICYJ ~~CD~ ·

l.J1J0 hJMJ a...r- Jo-)\'."\P 'S ~ -y~
) ~?Vv ~(b \"-' J<>::J V't~'"'..S:. o~
., ~Vh~l?'d rYrr\o<> \J-..>0') ~\CV! \-Jar>~) ~vv P-'"'o" ~\ ~&!.:a ,\~('r. ~vy
.. )Y'fWl~wvv J-'1 "\''-'cY'I .J0-:3 ~~o~ ~ J-0 \-..IGG~~ u~ \'~~-:LJJ'V C\\~ ~~vJ
X" or):1) ~~\~vo- ~vo ~~)~)' ~Q.~ "'-\k u~ j~~"d) ~ '--'4? r \\)
. • S\l?U'\_o~~o 15'-\X ~q SO\~
-'-9) ~alSCY) ~,vo \.JO~ ~OSloCT\, QJ"' \J-fc}.IO"\
'C
\70\..l!~OJ )l-'Jq (}~(}"\)_." )G {)b 'J ·~ .J(>f:\C .~VV ~\i~-w ~\./y\~) -JC>. )\ o~
\-'1:>'1-\- rq~ r- ~vo lvn\S15~ -ae ~ )lN1fO -~ ~\N\ ~ UI..Xl~~ \~~~)V
y~~ '~'iK !\~~r~r yv-o~)o ~ ~vo \J~o\~ ~) V<>\)"':iJ ,, ~,, VO\\V

-Jd J\~1.) s-~ Vt?\.v f'v;~ ~ v:r:- J.v\ o\1 D1''0\J~ ~ h ~ S'v ~u ;o\ c"'~-3 \ ~ cv-o~ "))y- .,~b \()-d

S') O()~dy )b~~\.JJ
_)~l?\~
)0

-tv" OJ ~ VJ: 00-p '?"J , ~ ,, VO \\ V """00 v '""")""' .
-
, a ey -o~roo ")
-~
··~,,

(~ A\~u._)~ 'f\r\r. ~c.1\\\v ~Ct~ k'-".)oJ'~e6 ll..t,\qh:>r ~e0V'a\ \)a:te,S.
o-G- ~ re_\evaA\ ()r·eAdal \e-,-\·:{l-e,~ rQ..c..or~
~~ ('I .e...t..Q ~.s e.a L

(_-.Sj A,~~ v..~,~ ¥n\~ "'~ ·ev\~Qilc...e re~\v-e.d Oil which
t.f-IJ-IJ ...
'-...J &~ q vo'(>~ o{ &\e~ ~(j,\~\~~ CMswQ.J ~ (lt-\~rt c....o~ 1c.-t'nt
l'tr\o.ke Qjl!.lltl~-\- r.t\C-~c.L,if/v If\ h\.S Ccy.>qu.f...t O!J Ct J l;r-\-~~J
fLe ~o r-t .6 t- \4-i i r-e-\1.\i of) ~ r ~-\- ~{ t"la-,Jcv-u ~

A~QIVl~11... ~-\- kO CV\~U. Alr ~~dA -H~- Q~\cr\-c.r b..t~Cl/\ fr€-
Qo..yt.S
((~ns ~ VVC"'\\ t>f- \-\-a~Q~ 0:,~'6>U~ ~ot\- vvQ~ .(;I.e~ i (\ ~...S\-a:k.Q
\ ,za-l (J)..>J"'\- on (o-(o-1).. .~ C-..2.)J- 009(p1Cf- 6~~, \L~\01:\o\ 0 ev.V' f'€CQ\~~ Ct Cb~'t o~~\& 1-J..s.:t~ Aotlc.L
U/\\1\ ..S~~\o.u"' ~ol).._ .A~ L-Or\\.\f~~ 'b~ 9-Q.\q,~r~ f,Lt'nj ~t~ ~V-f- _
r \ -e.-vr~\a\_ M~5'~UM \n ~ ~'{lu~-\- 0~ W f'\\ JJo.. L''J-\.3-D'D9~\ E~q\~n~-S ~'-l.i\,.~\o\Q De\GIIof :r:; ~~~.:Y t'V\01160M{i pafLJv.f{D
~
Q.l\6. eo~~Ct-C\e~ ~ CouJl-\s CJI\ ~t..\-i~l.Q 6CCO.Sibns D ~~~
c..,\u--\L ~~(Q_. M.Q.t.(U'..S ~e.rQt>f"l ~b ~ Df! "6 -1-J'\ on 't-17-j)_, J-uL. £,l._\,lbt'\ ' 1£ h~.\-u q\-~Wd Q/\6 ( , ( l ( i ) r -
11

~0('ct.\.e6 -ro, CouJ~\- 0~ LC'(~rv:-\-;Ul clcr-\-ed- 9'{7-/J,
(q) ~ Co®\- t)~ u\'~"al A(J~ea\.s (Yb~-\ie~ (l.tlq,-\-or b·( A.Jo·\1Q d c:t-\-ed
0,.-J-S- \)... ~Y:\ "o ac-\ion v.J\)uv~ be ~~V'\ of\~\~ ~Df) R>r
fl...e.coni ' }, lli'ct\\ tl\ . Su- E .._L, •\.' ~ " f '' h~+<> a+¥; W d. 0/11.1 ,' n c..or f r«-kcJ
0

~ .r- .s &.i ~ .AJ1A--1 (_Q_ d. et-k~ c;- J ~-: r1 , ,._
(r o) · ~\cr\-o\ vJ c.t...Ot·J-. ~ s.\teA~~Q./t h,~ da}IVl~ \1\ Q/\. e~Cvr-\- h '6\o\--a}n \e..\\e~ '"tl~ q
f\. ~ Aq (>-e..cd D n Ct C...OfVi le,\-e.. \C. c..o \ ~ .. .tR...e. E'}( ~ ,l.:,t"\- hQre.\-a q 4---\-a 4-a d
\1 (,. '(

0/\ c\ '- 1\ c..o r ~o, 4 .\-e. d.- ~ r- C-O\'~ (J o 0 ~ e/l UL ~ -- /- I J.. ' 5 -'f.- e. 'J . cJ. ,(,; f
'' \\" \,.., ~ \,..o 4 i-\-4 J-uJ CV1 ~ Vl ~ ~tt\ (}...R,Lo\'~ .. Lu... £'ilt,ldt- "IH hQr€~- q-~-\-4n~ CnJ\-c-\c~ b-·~ \e-1-.qs G:,~ ~ ~(s
()..QCQ;\ ~~
G:,v.S'~
(t.L\ ~\v" ~ S'\- ~ ctk~ l d -ll-l ~ .

(\'{) ..A\-kf' P.qJ'\w C).J.re6 ~\~ de-(; d€ACAes ~ A~\'0\\ot:.e ~v..f'*-
6'-'2rv\e6, %\C\;~\.J Qe~nn ~r ~Jv~\'-\- ~ "'10/Jc.\~~ Of\ /-(7-13 .
.S-e..e.. ["')(~'~'-\ '"~'' h~-\-o a;\--\y~J CV16 t\nc...ofp~rq46 ~
...S Ctl\ ~ o r ~ J ~ ~ I -17- J3 .. ·~

(tsj On 1-~7-U w\-\-h A~d'~o~c:d el.lt6W1\-~~ ctt..-\\on of"\--Y!M.S: \.AJC"t\. -(h'\.s f"<>of"C{i-tJ. ..fo (' .Sa;J C...C\('e.. ~ fo 11'~ L.L -Cr-ofV\ fV\J. fiAJktel' S ,

(11J .A.\-\.v-- ~~\~n_g -0~J--t.-\--wo r~ \n ~ J~ CoW'+ ~\cf\.-or
,tr...o~~ Cr'\ +a~ ~~q\. LoW"\- () ~- ~ -1 J. .L.Q....Q_ ( \\1' I At~"tin .J.Jo, Lf ! \ 1-
C...\J -3['1;. ~-Q.\ct,~r- ~u.bJ~~~t~ hct~ ~J LOrtt dl.x~u-ed
Wv~\ ~f'-.e.)4f6\u_ C>n. '--V--\0-1 ~- So r~Jq\.or C..Uc-n 6 e'I...~.St
s\-~ r~eMes-

(\"E.J on /-ltt>-t3 4\ct--\-or..(;\. .e~ 011t>-¥ncif' );. .:t.lS~ Q~d, \n~ .\=Of'-\-
L.-0 ° 4 \ ~ f\ c-\- ~ ·-\-ct \.l:t!~
eM."{ c..c..\\cn Of\ -Vh \~ W0~-\ ~ ...Q_ ~ ~ A '.ovts....L o-G- \...0!'\t Ot'~Jt./'
Pre>llovt~ \'{ e:'we ~ . Lu E-L~to:-\ "':r.: 11 a..:\--\acN-6 a...-v6 t'l}ws~orq{_e; ~
l~ll (L~\cr\·-u~-S A(J(>.QA~·' Sv.f{JDr\
y.,_ \ctc..K ~ ~ 'fe:~{ Co~ 01d-fH-e-t GU>~
f.::!.? .s '-t Q.v\-tton o/'\ to ....31-L~ _ J:.R.e. C \ u If Ac+lon
AJ\), tf i 1 - cv ~~~.S ~
4'hA.S. Q.e~.\)ofl wets 6\~~~s-ed. As A0 Ab~s.e. at~w~rt ~ I J-L{-(3,

(;L \) ~\Q~(' +h,QA .{) \.e~ OvH)~ ~-\- \ n ~ ~~ 1(-·, .eh+lon 'f=Oc \..01;', \ o ~ tv\0/l c\QVV-{ s. O{'f~ ~ i 0 -\:
r~ ~.e_~, '~ CVl ~ .t.S.
(_;._;sj ~e\C{\ur-\'h-V1 sv-.t~ C~.A'~ ~ \qtJ -+u, \·n~Mch~ Lt~ {)vJ'..iV.G/t\ -\--a f ll~ l
().__e.,~ct~J 4.s in c.cv-C9f'q4d
\.(\ v~e. ~-\--rl..u-- o\0\s.Y t='o r ~ ~ ~ UJ qg ..S u bJ .JL L1.L ~·~~
0\.S~~se~ b~~JL ~M-U)tlC"~ ~-e~cv\. ~LAS·A-. S.e.e.. cl\lll Ac~~"
.N 0, L\ ~ \Y,- C \) .- ( 3 '( 0 ~ ~ r e( .e.JCM.,{- f r e-
-\--ri~ re-)Jf) ~~~ r\1 11-e.. J -\--d:e
o ,~ \.." c~ Cov.f' t- . ~\ct\-or r~ Af~ ~ i-- ~n ~v-r~or-\-o-G ~.S
~r ~r\\- 0.\- N\Cvl~S ,- ~-(' ~CoW'-\- Ct.afor~~ ~-\16n10 ,
(Je\,.\-)on
0 \S~SS ~.i ~\'( \-o ~\q-\-or~ (U.!~or1S-e- Q..-) 6 ~. ~uA~ c~ ~ l'aJ\-
1

\-t'n~ ~. ~en \"b \Y\.C{_f.JL o* Q..eA~·\-o\~ ~()n ~' ~\r 11 q{ ,
G1 ~) A5. ~s. e1-~~\~ ·\--('all o~ ~oylQl~(\g.r ~r~ LCt.tk hcd'
clr \lt...q ~~ ~ .S o vt..f h~ -~ ~- \o_t~* ~ ~ h\ ~ Q \,I lrtt ~ -5. l..V\. ~-v' . h.IJ C.AI! I fv--e_
C\~.)kces. '"T""b o~-\-A-r-e\n'ctl c-e(..Qr~ ~
~. o'--l-\- 6 €- -T\ CT'P- Ae~l.,. .:r-\- cqnA\:r\- \oJL \ ec.uur1al.oty ~nc..kta.e.J
-\"{Aa\-- (A.tA-on ~'LCU &\~t if\ ~~ ~ -s "":\-.s .- £-ipec,ic-.dJl \'n~ \LJh+
e~Vt.L~'.r ~\-\{Q\.e M-€1\\-al \\\M~-e.5- ,e~~il\1--t p!y~p\(. rvvL-
chc~on ('e_ ~\IV\ Q/\ 1 CV\ ~ ~ - e~Ce ~ -S. ~ e> f- v..., k ~ vrf/4 -f
~ ~r-e~s \on L.Jt ~ p.s~ ck-{1t -{2t..4--:\--lAle.S cvv~ ow 4 ('ElJLt.l t ~t- h\ ~ M -€~t-\-cc(
\llf"\Q~St.S.~ Y. -\-.,s
{L-~t\~ ~ \ r\ q '-.1 -~if'-(_ \ e \ q~('-._~ CV\i~ J e. ~ 4 \.e 6 ~~ . ~ ~ (l..,e_, \ ~ ~.r
~\)~s~ \ "'Gi ~ ~ ~-,\~ -\-o ~ ~~flj> \.:,y_\- s~\ -~ ~ ~ ~1 ~ Med.\--
c. C\:\\ of\.S. \ (\ Ct ~ .(V) Q f1...t. \~ ~r Cct.r\ "''C)\ t,\i g ~ h \ .\ clei.i\vti ct,\- q {q s. \- 0./\ '6
~,G\.ec\.\v--e.. rau 0/) ~ ~~-\-l~.s 0-0\ q~ q.t( .. ~{~ l.V\ ~ ~
l (\ -\-\ \..{ eA u.__ 0 t- .3-0D N\-J t) ~ ~- ll b 4~\n CV\ ~ I 0 MJ D { \-\.c; \ ~ ( I

(JJ LA/\~ \-vt~ e~~s\ ve.. ~ ~'-c.4\-1uf) r-e._gt('i\el\ . ~~ ctuo tnclM,t\..eJ
.-v--.e ~4 \lorl .S ~ ~ €\JV~t b-\-'hU' p ~Jktr a(g u
S u.~WJ. ~\o"fV'\ • ..::tn c...lu ~'1'\j ~ g ~ (S (()c.c\. ~ r-e Hw-e.. i ~'-ng ~~ m~ e...o.J'/
(}..Q..(..ur( ,\n-.& o n .-z.\.f s(l-etl.i C/v 6- ~~ ra.((1.e 4c. 6Q c.kQ.i ./~r tJ.J k,~ fle-

lccbs- \.s \>\'-v~cr\\o..e~ ct ~ ~,\1t."''G.l M ,\1)·~ q\\-v-t\.tt_g .'f'..Q.~\-c..ct-honS
~q\- q\so C..A.A.U.Q_, Cl t..0!\~-tc\ CV\16 s-ec\Gt4J ~ e.tCf}-e~j~ ~J q'ld..
IV'Q.~\c..C(,~cAi or-e \)\0 ~f' ~olul ;2.-o M~ 1 fV\ ec. \\ z}Ae Su M_g L i ~1'n 0 ,...
1
~("\ t toto ,Nt.~ f .A.fu\~~ \ ~·(\ Q [.1JO ('\"\ ~ c 0 \. ph.Q/1 ky- drWt-1~ .S o M.~ •.s...e. .Q__
£ )(,~ 1 \o l~'~o '( 'h~\-o Ot -\-\-c,WA 0/\~ \1\u:>r~vrq-kJ.. ~' ct \-(~. Q/\.6
Co cn\-y\- ~ctU .. w~i~
C..Oc\:~("cV\S edt ();(\e. 0 t- (J\~(\h(:( IJ rre.Jcri\oecl. ~ ~cq+l()fl-.f .
(3\) l..v\~ ~e M~f\~ ct\\-Qrt~j pr-e~cr\p-\i'o(l tN?6\-c't,\,VU .f\c\-cnty
~e.i c..o(\t..t~\on bvt\.C\\~o p4\ R~l~~r \'n..sudA Ct C'€\ct't.€d-i~
cvv~ ~~~~~ ~\-~. (l_eA~.J 0-Q\~-\,o,j \:>r-tu\\ \1\0p-v'ololL Md he
c c.. f11\~ \- ..(:.o tM..i r ~It 0./\ ~ 1 fVl ~ (\ -\-eu.\r1 q .\-rcu\n o {_ ~ '--'1 Itt-\- i ~ ~ +
~0-l~ i$' ~f\\L &\-r~jlt\-\- or~\n·)(. u~Ms OA ~ lor ·s .eQ.. Y- ~- \v.1 f> o -Q o~ ~ r\1on-V\.r,
0

(3>)J ·--('nus. QQ.\.~\ hC\~ ()(") ~ 0 W' ~ j-( ~ \ \~ -\-o ~ \00, U \-e ~ Ct l C{ S ~
~ \ ~\ a/\cL ·~ .{ c:-\ ~.Jf\V' _s --(:o \ "'-e.l~\f\.f ~~ h\1 S q k (

(3'-\j -(\-1\1 "'q__s \e..s~...tl\.e6 i'n. ~, \orea.~ 'b-e..\w e.QI\ -\1-.Q..-bhn~ (\~~ci
a\oQ~ \-t"\ ~.1~\~~ p.ecA ,

(:S S) whM Q-~.lct\or \.r-\e.~ ·to rrv\ ~ ~\\\~~.e. ~\~i o \-- ""'~s. ~~ c.ct-h ()(\~
~ f'\ ~ ~..i ~ \- o.JnrNl. \)a .s...e..s Ot ..l~.-~. ~~().'\.-\-\a\ r- \ " \ re\l·ton n-.Q.~vr\-io'l ~\l \oy_k!n 1=0.r
~~w -o

(:,.n. .1:-re ~ ~ "fre11e 6 5. -\.,.:k:p wh e)l \:> M a..vp:k.l eQ +:
o-\- h\~ ~ ~r-e~J nYl ~~tD)tr~ 0-f f Qr0 l'c...t
G\ ~A '# l· \ .1 3 ~ \1~ 1 ~af'l--e~ f\'\. CV\4Hl!l f
~e.~ O\- ~- ~~,\\tO::.(' S..e~"Q11 1 D\~cX A-V-\-v:N--y o{{;L.L 1 !..Jbl '-'.). d.e(~cf
f="~ \A).:)~~ (T-i_. t~\ 7,,\.o CV\ ~ ,Ow\.rt~ ~ ~ -~Mq~ lA.-l i \ ~ t.{O(
\..-0 · (1 e/\~ ~ 1
P\ Jv..so!'~ l }')(~ ~~ (Cf.t.p , 0./\ "&- \,l(j.- IS"'""'
e-·~e-~~ ort ~-L-g~lr ~~F.., ~
, Texas Courts Online- Court owiminal Appeals Page 1 of I

·TEXAS
COURT OF ·CRt
APPEALS
dicial Directory,
Courts
General Information
Loading
• CCA Home
·lfh Case# WR·65,590-14 -> Event: ACTION
CaseMail • Practice Before the Court
'GJir TAKEN Internal Operating Procedures [pdf] 1
Rules & Procedures I Forms I Issues I
Oral Argument Instructions I Opinion
Event Information: Archives I Hand Down Archives I IBAe
Event Type: ACT10N TAKEN Amendments Archives
• About the Court
Application for Writ of Habeas Corpus - Contact I ~ I Employment I
Description: 11.07 . Overview I Virtual Tour
Date: 7/25/2012
Disposition: Abuse of writ order previously entered Case Information
Opinion Written: • Hand Oown list

~ Hint: Click on the folder icon~ above for more case
(Orders, Opinions & Statements)
• Case Search
in formation. • Opinion Search
• Case Submission Schedules

Case Mail

• Track Cases or Released Opinions
· My Account I Case Tracking I Opinion
Tracking I Register I ~ I FAQs

Texas Appellate Courts

• The Supreme Court of Texas
• Court of Criminal Appeals
• Courts of Appeals [by District-City]
!-Houston I 2-Fort Worth I 3-Austin
4-Sao Antonio I 5-Dallas ! 6-Texarkana
7-Amarillo I 8-EI Paso I 9-Beaumont
10-Waco I 11-Eastland 1 12-Tyler
13-C~-·
By: _c_'---...,.·-..__."-7_.b -:+/_u_.._·_/_.;1_~
__,·~4-a_~_'-~, 6t-\~ \\ t-\ ' . fUJL Jo f..J
1

-------·- - - - - - - - - - - ------------------------
---------------
~-

PREPARE THE REQUESTED AFFIDAVIT AND FILE THE SAME WITH THE TRIAL COURT. AS WELL

AS A COPY WITH THE SECOND DISTRICT COURT OF APPEALS AND FORWARD COMPLAINANT A

COPY OF SAID REQUESTED AFFIDAVIT. ADDITIONALLY MR. SCHILLER NEEDS TO FILE THE

RECORDS THAT HE HAS LOCATED WITH THE SECOND DISTRICT COURT OF APPEALS. THE RE-

LEVANT THREE CAUSE NUMBERS ARE LISTED BELOW THAT ARE IN REFERENCE TO MY ATTEMPTED

MURDER ALLEGATION I WAS CONVICTED ON IN THE 213TH JUDICIAL COURT.

CALTON V STATE TRIAL CAUSE No. 0843168

EX PARTE ALLEN "F" CALTON WRIT No. C-213-009679-0843168-H

CALTON V STATE APPEAL No. 2-04-228-CR

I HAVE SPENT YEARS IN PRISON BECAUSE OF MR. SCHILLER'S MISCONDUCT AND I'M

STILL DOING TIME BECAUSE MR. SCHILLkR FAILS TO ACT REASONABLY. IF THERE IS NO
I
i
!
CONSEQUENCE A SEVERE CONSEQUENCE INj THIS PARTICULAR CASE. THEN THE C.R.C.B.
i
RULES AND REGULATIONS MEAN NOTHING-I WITHOUT CONSEQUENCES FOR RULE VIOLATIONS

YOU HAVE NOTHING. IT STARTS WITH coksEQUENCES.
I
THE FIRST STEP TO PREVENT THIS
J

TYPE OF INTENTIONAL EGREGIOUS RULE VIOLATOR
I LIKE MR. STEVE SCHILLER IS TO. LEVY
i
. I
A STIFF PUNISHMENT AS A DETERRENT TO PREVENT ANY FUTURE MISCONDUCT OF THIS

MAGNITUDE.

· RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED,

QJ9&A''V'' ~
. ALLEN "F" CALTON
I.

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT A TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE FOREGOING WAS CERTIFIED

MAIL RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED TO THE C.R.C.B., P.O. BOX 13131, AUSTIN, TX. 78711

C.M.R.R.R. #7010 0290 0000 9209 9279 AND FIRST CLASS MAIL TO STEVE SCHILLER,

401 w. BELKNAP ST. I FORT WORTH I 'l'EXAS 76196 ON --~..:::::::____:::U~L'~'lf----'{L.?-=--J{'---'-'d~0=--.:....1-(;J;;ll,,__
fl. 1)-J-_ /\
O!QQM \ t
E
ALLEN "F" CALTON
j/ ~ '--

.. - · - · - - - - - - · - - - · - - - - - - - - -
IN THE CRIMINAL DISTRICT.

213TH JUDICIAL COURT

TARRANT COUNTY, TEXAS

PRO SE DEFENDANT'S MOTION TO COMPEL COURT REPORTER STEVE SCHILLER TO FILE NUNC
PRO TUNC THE RECENTLY DISCOVERED PRETRIAL HEARINGS TRANSCRIPTS WITH THE SECOND
DISTRICT COURT OF APPEALS AND SUBMIT AN AFFIDAVIT TO THE APPELLATE COURT ALSO

TO THE HONORABLE JUDGE OF SJI..ID COURT:

NOW COMES PRO SE DEFENDANT ALLEN "F" CALTON AND FILES THIS HIS PRO SE MOTION

FOR AN ORDER ISSUED BY THIS COURT ORDERING OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER OF THE 213TH

JUDICIAL COURT AT THE TIME JUDGMENT WAS ENTERED AGAINST THE PRO SE DEFENDANT ON

MAY 20, 2004. TO FILE NUNC PRO TUNC THE RECENTLY DISCOVERED PRETRIAL HEARINGS

TRANSCRIPTS THAT vJERE TU.1ELY AND DILIGENTLY SOUGHT AND REQUESTED BY THE DEFENSE

WITH THE SECOND DISTRICT COURT OF APPEALS OF TEXAS AND FURTHER ORDER STEVE

SCHILLER TO SUBMIT AN AFFIDAVIT DETAILING AND EXPLAINING THAT THE REASON THE

I~R.O SE DEPENDANT' .S PIRST P..I'PEAL P..S OF RIGP.T ~·'JAS DECIDED ON Jl.l'! INCPJ\1PJ:.ETE RF.CORn -- --~•,

WAS SOLELY THE FAULT OF MR. SCHILLER DUE TO MR. SCHILLER MISLED, MISINFORMED AND

I-1ISREPRESENTED TO THE PRO SE DEFENDANT'S APPELLATE COUNSEL AT THE TIME BARRY

ALFORD. THE OMITTED RECORDS MR. ALFORD HAD CONSULTED WITH MR. SCHILLER ABOUT

miiCi-i wE.tEvent: ACTION • CCA Home
1:.:.::;, TAKEN CaseMail • Practice Before the Court
Internal Operating Procedures [odfl I
Rules & Procedures I Forms I Issues I
Event Information: Oral Argument Instructions I Opinion
Archives j Hand Down Archives I TRAP
Event Type: ACTION TAKEN Amendments Archives
Application for Writ of Habeas Corpus - • About the Court
Description: Contact I Judges I Employment I
11.07
Overview I Virtual Tour
Date: 5/15/2013 • Other Court Links
Disposition: Abuse of writ order previously entered Texas Criminal Justice Integrity Unit 1
Judicial and Court Personnel Training
Opinion Written: Fund - Grants

CtJ(.- It) f l
---------~--- -·---- - - - ---------------- --~---- -------------- -· ----- ·- -

httn://www_cca_courts.state.tx.us/ooinions/Eventlnfo.asp?EventiD=2525584 · 7/11/2013
TARRANT COUNTY

Thomas A. Wilder
District Clerk

DATE: Ju!y 11, 2013

NAME: ALTON F. CALTON

POST CONVICTION WRIT NUMBER: C-213-009849-0843168-1
·~.

RE: Request for Post Conviction Writ Information

Date Writ Filed: 2/27/2013

Date Transmitted To Court of Criminal Appeals: 4/4/2013

Other: PER THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS, THIS CASE WAS DISPOSED ON
5/15/2013 AS " ABUSE OF WRIT ORDER PREVIOUSLY ENTERED"

Sincerely,

Thomas A. Wilder
District Clerk
Tarrant County, Texas

Enc: Copy of request letter
--~!created By Pearl EMR- PH0512 CMCP Report DatefTime: 6/30/2015 02:09AM
Schema: TDCJ-

EMR Medication Print Pass
Active Medications From 0613012015 to 0710112015
STILES (ST)
ALLERGIES:
NO KNOWN ALLERGIES

BUPROPION HCL 75MG TABLET# RxiD:18433383
2 TABS ORAL TWICE DAILY FOR 30 DAYS. NF 244407-[INDEF] REFILLS: 6/11
RX DATE: 12/09/2014 08:09PM RUN START DATE: 06/07/2015 08:08PM RUN END DATE: 07/07/2015 08:08PM_
ORDERING FACILITY: STILES (ST) EXPIRATION DATE: 12/04/2015 08:08PM
ORDERING PROVIDER: NATHAN, PRADAN A M.D.
MEDICATION STATUS: ACTIVE ENTRY USER: NATHAN, PRADAN A M.D.

DiPHENHYDRAMINE 50MG CAPSULE Rx!D: 18433380
1 CAPS ORAL EVERY EVENING FOR 30 DAYS. REFILLS: 6 /11
RX DATE: 12/09/2014 08:09PM RUN START DATE: 06/07/2015 08:04PM RUN END DATE: 07/07/2015 08:04PM
ORDERING FACILITY: STILES (ST) EXPIRATION DATE: 12/04/2015 08:04PM
ORDERING PROVIDER: NATHAN, PRADAN A M.D.
MEDICATION STATUS: ACTIVE ENTRY U_SER: NATHAN, PRADAN A M.D.

HALOPERIDOL SMG TABLET RxiD:18433382
2 TABS ORAL EVERY EVENING FOR 30 DAYS. REFILLS: 6 /11
RX DATE: 12/09/2014 08:09PM RUN START DATE: 06/07/2015 08:05PM RUN END DATE: 07/07/2015 08:05PM
ORDERING FACILITY: STILES (ST) EXPIRATION DATE: 12/04/2015 08:05PM
ORDERING PROVIDER: NATHAN, PRADAN A M.D.
MEDICATION STATUS: ACTIVE ENTRY USER: NATHAN, PRADAN A M.D.

NORTRIPTYLINE HCL 50MG CAPSULE RxiD: 18279058
1 CAPS ORAL EVERY EVENING FOR 30 DAYS. REFILLS: 7 111·
RX DATE: 11/06/2014 05:21 PM RUN START DATE: 06/04/2015 05:19PM RUN END DATE: 07/04/2015 05:19PM
ORDERING FACILITY: MICHAEL (MI) EXPIRATION DATE: 11/01/2015 05:19PM
ORDERING PROVIDER: SCHAFER, VIRGINIA S NP
MEDICATION STATUS: ACTIVE ENTRY USER: SCHAFER, VIRGINIA S NP

IBUPROFEN 800MG TABLET Rx ID: 19412534
KOP 1 TABS ORAL TWICE DAILY FOR 30 DAYS. REFILLS: 0 /2
RX DATE: 06/24/2015 11:39 AM RUN START DATE: 06/24/2015 11:38 AM RUN END DATE: 07/24/2015 11:38 AM
ORDERING FACILITY: STILES (ST) EXPIRATION DATE: 09/22/2015 11:38 AM
ORDERING PROVIDER: BARBER, MARK A M.D.
MEDICATION STATUS: ACTIVE ENTRY USER: BARBER, MARK A M.D.

LISINOPRIL 40MG TABLET RxiD:18279061
KOP 1 TABS ORAL DAILY FOR 30 DAYS. REFILLS: 7 /11
RX DATE: 11/06/2014 05:21PM RUN START DATE: 06/04/2015 05:20PM RUN END DATE: 07/04/2015 05:20PM
ORDERING FACILITY: MICHAEL (MI) EXPIRATION DATE: 11/01/2015 05:20PM
ORDERING PROVIDER: SCHAFER, VIRGINIA S NP
MEDICATION STATUS: ACTIVE ENTRY USER: SCHAFER, VIRGINIA S NP

MECLIZINE 25MG TABLET Rx ID: 19412518
KOP 1 TABS ORAL TWICE DAILY FOR 30 DAYS. REFILLS: 0/2
RX DATE: 06/24/2015 11:39 AM RUN START DATE: 06/24/2015 11:38 AM RUN END DATE: 07/24/2015 11:38 AM
ORDERING FACILITY: STILES (ST) EXPIRATION DATE: 09/22/201511:38 AM
ORDERING PROVIDER: BARBER, MARK A M.D.
MEDICATION STATUS: ACTIVE ENTRY USER: BARBER, MARK A M.D.
Page 1 of 3
-~/CreatedBy Pearl EMR- PH0512 CMCP Report DatefTime: 6/30/2015 02:09AM
Schema: TDCJ

EMR Medication Print Pass
Active Medications From 0613012015 to 0710112015
STILES (ST)
ALLERGIES:
NO KNOWN ALLERGIES

PROPRANOLOL 10MG TABLET RxiD: 18279055
KOP 1 TABS ORAL TWICE DAILY FOR 30 DAYS. REFILLS: 7 /11
RX DATE: 11/06/2014 05:21 PM RUN START DATE: 06/04/2015 05:19PM RUN END DATE: 07/04/2015 05:19PM.
ORDERING FACILITY: MICHAEL {MI) EXPIRATION DATE: 11/01/2015 05:19PM
ORDERING PROVIDER: SCHAFER, VIRGINIA S NP
MEDICATION STATUS: ACTIVE ENTRY USER: SCHAFER, VIRGINIA S NP

RANITIDINE 150MG TABLET Rx ID: 18279063
KOP 1 TABS ORAL DAILY FOR 30 DAYS. REFILLS: 7 /11
RX DATE: 11/06/2014 05:21PM RUN START DATE: 06/04/2015 05:20PM RUN END DATE: 07/04/2015 05:20PM
ORDERING FACILITY: MICHAEL (MI) EXPIRATION DATE: 11/01/2015 05:20PM
ORDERING PROVIDER: SCHAFER, VIRGINIA S NP
MEDICATION STATUS: ACTIVE ENTRY USER: SCHAFER, VIRGINIA S N.P

Page 2 of 3

------------------··----------------------
CORRECTIONAL MANAGED CARE
OUTPATIENT MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES

Transfer to Inpatient Note

Patient Name: CALTON, ALLEN F TD0#:1123880 Date: 09/19/2008 09:54
Facility: BYRD
A e:40 Race: B Sex: Mc:.le
Patient Lan ua e: ENGLISH Name of interpreter, if required: I
iviosi recent vitals from 04/23/2008: BP: 140 I 68 (Sitting) ; Wt: ; Height: 74 ln.; Pulse: 74 (Sitting) ; Resp: 18/ min; Temp: 98.2
(Oral) ·
Allergies: NO KNOWN ALLERGIES
Active Problems: *

Chronic Care:
Seizure Disorder- Ccc First Observed 05/26/2004 08:18AM
Hypertension (htn) - Ccc First Observed 11/27/2004 07:32AM

Not Specified:
Major Depressive Disorder, Recurrent, Severe With Psychotic Features First Observed 03/21/2006 01:04PM

Seen this date at (time): 19-SEP-2008 09:50
S: Offender found· to be in need of transfer to:
._x_ Crisis Management
Diagnostic and Evaluation
1
Other:

Reason for transfer: Patient reported that he can not get the thought of cutting his wrists out of his mind. He thinks he
might have been thinking too much aboct his life sentence and this has pushed him down a deep hole of depression.
"I just want to die."

0: Mental Status Exam
Oriented x _ 4_
Appearance:dishelveled
Behavior:aggitated
Speech: pressurred
Mood/affect: flat
Thought processes:WNL _
Thought content: Reports theme of fatalistic and hopeless thinking·· .·
Suicidal/homicidal ideations:Reports he can't get impulse to cut out of his head.
Cognition:wnl
Ir.sight and Judgment:WNK

A: Diagnostic Impression
Axis I:Major Depression-recurrent with psychotic features
Axis II:301.7

P: Transfer to _ _ _ _ _SKYVIEW_ _ __ facility by:
_x_ Van
Ambulance
Regular Transportation
1 of 2
- - - - - --------·-··-··-·-···---'-- ---·--···----------------·-·-···-----·----··---------------- ----
0361
CORRECTIONAL MANAGED CARE
OUTPATIENT MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES

Transfer to Inpatient Note

Patient Name: CALTON, ALLEN F TD0#:1123880 Date: 09/19/2008 09:54
Facility: BYRD
Other:

Physical exam completed.
_x_ Patient is medically cleared for transfer per orders of _ _ _ _DR. DAO._ _ _ _ __
Patient is not medically cleared for transfer.
Disposition:

Special precautions/comments: Potentially staff assaultive
Follow-up entry: While waiting for transport to Skyview the patient asked to go to the rest room and a minute, or so, later he
exited the bathroom dripping blood from both his wrists.
Nurses reported that wounds will require stitches to close the wounds.
Dr. DAO is currently treating wounds.

Procedures Ordered:
MH OP ASSESSMENT/EVALUATION
MH OP CRISIS MANAGEMENT REFERRAL: major depressive· disorder, recurrent, severe with
psychotic features

Electronically Signed by HALLMAN, SAMUEL MA, LPA, RP on 09/19/2008.
##And No Others## .

2of2
--·-- -- ---------------------·------ ·-------- ---------------
...

Correctional Managed Care
PRE-CRISIS MANAGEMENT HEALTH EVALUATION

tticnt Name: CALTON, ALLEN F TDC.J#: I 123880 Date: 09/19/2008 10:03 Facility: BYRD

~c: 40 Years Race: 8 Sex: Male
ost recent vitals from 04/23/2008: BP: 140 I 68 (Sitting) ; Wt: ; Height: 74 In.; Pulse: 74 (Sitting) ; Resp: 18 /min; Temp: 98.2 (Oral)
llergies: NO KNOWN ALLERGIES

Patient Language: ENGLISH Name of interpreter, if reg_!! ired: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __,

ffender is being transferred to Crisis Management due to: SUICIDE ATTEMPT

Jecial Diet: REGULAR
JHLES: _ _ __

PRE-SEG/LOCK-UP/UOF PHYSICAL EXAM
Chronic Conditions/Illnesses
No
Physical Observations
General Appearance
Clean
Skin
Turgor
Good
Lacerations
YES WHILE IN INFIRMARY OFFENDER WENT TO BATHROOM AND CAME OUT
/ITH BOTH WRIST CUT HAS RAZORBLADE IN HAND. SECURITY HERE. OFFENDER FOLLOWING
RDERS. LEFT WRIST HAS A 2" CUT RECEIVING 4 SUTURES. RT WRIST HAS 3 CUTS 1- 1"
ECEIVED 2 SUTURES 1- 1/2" RECEIVED 1 SUTURE 1 SUPERFICIAL CUT 1/2" LATERAL TO 1/2"
UT BANDAGED WITH TELFA 4X4 AND CO WRAP. SECURITY TAKING TO INTAKE FOR
RANSFER TO SV. . "
Contusions
No
Bruises
No
Respiratory
Dyspnea
No
Breath Sounds
Clear
Cough/Congestion
No
Cardiovascular
Rhythm
---· ·Regula-r----------- ----------------· .......
~ ·correctional Managed Care
PRE-CRISIS MANAGEMENT HEALTH EVALUATION

1ticnt Name: CAL TON, ALLEN F TDCJ#: 1123880 Date: 09/19/2008 10:03 Facility: BYRD
Edema
No
Chest Pain
No
Bleeding Tendencies
No
Gastrointestinal
Distention
No
Constipation
No
Diarrhea
No
Nausea
No
Vomiting
No
Abdominal Pain
No
Genitourinary
Flank Pain
No
Burning/Frequency Urination
No
Discharge
No
Gyn
Pregnant
Not Applicable
Menses
Not Applicable
Neurological
Headache
No
Dizziness
No
Speech
Normal
Pupils
Equal
Reactive
Left
-______Ri g________
ht --~--
--~-------------------------

Psychiatric
.;' 4
\

Correctional Managed Cai'e
PRE-CRISIS MANAGEMENT HEALTH EVALUATION

~tient Name: CALTON, ALLEN F TDCJ#: 1123880 Date: 09/19/2008 10:03 Facility: BYRD
Orientation
Person
Yes
Place
Yes
Time
Yes
Coherence Of Thought Processes
Organized
ILLOGICAL
Emotional State
DEPRESSED
Suicide Risk Assessment
Suicide Threat/ Attempt*** (Describe) CUT WRIST WHILE IN
IFIRMARY
Musculoskeletal Range Of Motion
Upper Extremities
Normal
Lower Extremities
Normal
Released To Security
Yes
Referred For Further Evaluation
Yes DR DAO FOR SUTURES
'AMOXiCILLIN 500MG PO BID X 7 DAYS
V/0 DR DAO/ 8 LOVE LVN

rvientai Health Services
Md: DR NGUYEN
TRANSPORT TO SV

fender was medically cleared by: DR DAO
fender is being transferred to Crisis Management per: DR K NGUYEN

nd this note via email to Mental Health staff on your facility.

All verbal/telephone orders must be Electronically Signed by LOVE, BE\'EFU Y D LV.N.
on 09:'1 CJ!200X.

4
·..

Correctional Managed Care-
PRE-CRISIS MANAGEMENT HEALTH EVALUATION
\

1ticnt Name: CALTON, ALLEN F TDC.J#: 1123880 Date: 09/19/2008 10:03 Facility: BYRD
Electronically Signed by KING. ELIZABETH L CCA on 09/19/2008.
Electronically· Signed by DAO, HUNC l'vl.D. on 09/19/20mL
Electronically Signed by NGU\TN. KINH V M.D. on 09/19/2008.
Electronically Signed by J'vHTC'HFL.L., VALERIE J CC.i\ on 09/22/2008.
Electronically Signed by B'{RD. REI3ECCA on 09/22/2008.
Electronically Signed by COOKSE'Y. JOANNA L CCA on 09/2.5/2008.
Eiectronicaiiy Signed by COOKSEY, JOA.. NNA. L CCA on 09/29/2008.
##And No Others##

...- - - - · - · · - - - - - - - ---------·-·
,f 4
c:\temp\108996294.tif pr·inted by rnivap. (Page 1 of 3)
.# Scanned by AVANT. CJI.THY R CC.i\ in facility SKYVIEW on :0/0''2008 i 2:13 z
......I\ CORRECTIONAL MANAGED CARE
' '-.. MEDICAL & MENTAL HEALTH TRANSFER SCREENING
PARTS Ill & IV

NAME: Calton, Allen F DOB: 10/02/1967 TDCJ: 11238.80
ALLERGIES: NO KNOWN ALLERGIES

Ill. Facility of Assignment Health Screening;
Date: ---2/rtf/o'd,
Time: 3D Facility: ')/(_1 t/1~ )
1/: 4
Transfer Information: .
Return From: 0 Specialty Clinic 0 Inpatient £If Inpatient MH/Crisis Mgmt.
~ Newly Assigned ?> rA
Current/History of treatment for HealtH Problem or Chronic Condition?
MEDICAL 0 DENTAL 0 MENTAL HEALTH 0 SUBSTANCE ABUSE ~ 1
If yes, describe: ft 5-rde.s, 1 k :S hl.cK.e.G Yrx"-ra. • a a e-n --ttf_e .j Ef:krJe{ cat!.e.-ru.~ a->1£ iO b(( G--f-..f!. ro.Y
u) ("I Sf- S ~j:;~e U: a a ,-eft_
~-es -\ r' plc-e.e_ ..fb(J) u)(C's,r· Sc~ ~:; ~.... ~'
~ Ly t sr;~.........__
I -
OFFENDER'S PRESENT ORIENTATION: /
What is today's date? ~t Time? .:Z,'3o
What place is this?=-'dl;:L!:l.ma:>a.l!..i.J--'(;...,._.,-Iiii~-----------­
Aiert .iD Not Alert 0
Oriented ilJ Not Oriented 0

SPEECH: riJ Fluent 0 Mumbling 0 Shouting D Refuses to Talk
0 Other_ _ _ _ _ _ _ __

BEHAVIOR: OAngry OCrying ~Cooperative OHappy 0 Other_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
DO YOU HAVE CURRENT THOUGHTS ABOUT SUICIDE? Yes 0 No Q
PREVIOUS SUiCIDE ATTEMPT? Yes tid No 0

SCREENER'S SIGNATURE: L.tLZtmrf; /Gt_)
--- ··- ..-........ ·--------------
IV. Review of Offend~r's Health Record
Date last PPD G( I CXR 0 : 1L thL
Date of last mammogram: $lt.4\, 1 ~e.e.-~;~~ Mci.J~ W\W~
p.QAttl~ o ~ ~!l.f'J~ ~'1.\-~ \,;,~toW ~r~ ~NL (J\j CPo-\.LQ 1\\AMbU'j
~e1v-\~ ~- -c~ct-\1~ ~c.b ~' e.c.clA o \ \4..\c-~.-\-or'.s ~E?>Ji:~'-tl -h\tlttJJ #>

£..J-e~6 Qf\ ~-\{?~!~ ~''~tl ~
Jl..es ~e.cAt-r I~ J~b~+·k ~I
~~fl·l~

lL·e~~-h~f1 Cor\~CM--\~j PrJUJl~t.U ~U/ljJ ~~ lofJ/
(_\) \c\n.\ ~s:vS'\-: u.~. D\S\-r\C\ Go'-0'\- DQ\\as Di\;\\).\tn ·.:-:s'V\~j.Q. ~id &nd. fo.Q..'1
~\~ D~ ~ IO-i'J-0:1 .
~'s~'hon :A Jw '1 ~\.V'\6 Aje.\t'U~ ~\cJo\t~ or"' o\\ UQ~M.S On .1-1~-05"
V\ Q~w'i. -h\a\ .. \~{~C\rLIJ..l-\- A~r~d J"'--'~_ji'V\{h-\- en 4- c..f-CJ(o ~r\\
0~ ~\o..f'Ol'\ ~-€1\ted on fu·J-6(Q '

bn~ n\~~-\- o-G 4-..t3-s.s.L\. \C{l Oo.oiS ~QJ su..Qd.
~ c \1\\~ b\M \J\ve~\i~~t:Jf) GA6 resu\u-hVJ ~~ ~ t \ ~ 0
0:> vS'-\ ; u. ~ . 0~\{\c.~ ~uf'-\- tt:>~-u~ 0(\) \ s ron -0c..t~J>-L~n fl7c_1)rtlk
~\\.e. Oc*.Q ! tO- 11-o:L._
0\S.~I:)S\~-()() ~ Case. ~\s(l'\H~5ed. pu('J~OI'"\ -\-o ~~\.l •.S.c. ~reus-e~ (f)

L..\_-l~-o3 -tor bt\C- "()~ S.ubJec-\- NtC..\4-o.r -:J"u3''-SJ.\c\icn ():') y-1\b-Qj'
~\o.-\.f'\t~~ $v\e.~ ~oS')ti\-~ E~h"g.QJ Dcv,~ ~~hoJ' ~ ;--rf'ct Ct.(_ ~1'-.SCI)
i

:s-~u'i w,m'o!lj"'\~ 1L\-.d\f',s.\\al\ 1CYl6 tvlcr\\ f...c-ew-M ~r d~t·Qj ht~ fV'1L-
dt\01 ;L~."'J~~ifl OAJ L~.~-'i+
Wo.S s \J..Q~ -C-or ~~.QAt·n~ (} l v\~~~ metd ou~s'~ (.,t ~ pres~ lQ 0/1 ~
l..e...-jo(
~ \ ~ ~o\\urP ll'\~i\-\ja-.\,fl_J +h \ s. "' t~fq-h 6(). 0-e.Q. At"'\~-Sq"} I c.Du e.(: ~owl-e .s
0/\~ cJtue.--C- s,~!) w V'-E' ..s~ ers: ~- ·S~lJdurl 0\-C=\ua.h 0~~ C)~..Qf' I
A~~M\5.

(_3) \r-\ a\ ~e__ No. 3'-\~- l q~(~( -cQ_j Cct{M \) ~Q.c.lleCl(~ AJ.e,{worK
' " G>..re_ D~ nc..v.)·, ~ ·CedU'D
Co~: 1'--t 3 \h .o d\-c,c\- ~v.r\ ;ra...rrM\ CoUII-lt 1"-:Jc...{~J.e.- UJoMo CK
Mle_ ~~ ·~ s-~ -o.s
0\SQI:)J~lhon :. 9 \OAn-\1-(.\ Nt>n-.S u.r~eJ +NL. Ac.-\,·of\ Cf\ H-7- 03

_9~uct-h\I'Q__ Foeti

~\c_M~\~ s~ \X-.~o.~OA 1 Drl.<>~ ,oc.~~\fCYI~Or,UJaJS~
~ \ ~-QAA{ (·(\~ \rv\~ fY'-Il ~k..a\. C.Cld"' e._ 0/\~ I'V\0.~·\m\-\on ~ o. 6CK-. tvt} IM.f S\1.-
J\-cJN~~ on .S-11.{-~:l '"' ~- IQn~Cov-A~~{ .-:rQS:. f.f..eq{~ 1\~L~:lK
\I'\ CC\1-e. '0~- DCA....>'~ (Q..W'o .......lY.S ..s~~ J~+o ~}('\.S -\hQ_ ~ luy-ef

o\.-~~if' ~~~\-_s.
C:..ow~ :_ u.S. \J\~\,:,c\ l.ovJ"\- Dcd'\Cl.~ D\\l\S\cn Co\ \-o0J Cb~(~~V/1-k..-
·~\\ ~- ~~~: \()- 11-05 'l
0\.s\)OS\~-vn ~\- fl .[- 01 F1 Hi-t Cir-
C..u.~ .\- A\-~t~~ D \.i\Wl5on ~ r
QC o\.)\~n_q ~\~(\\;\~ ,C{J~cv-:>1·~ C'C\2..01 C/1 t(-..'1.1-os- QAd -{!o~ ~.-fa1.1u.tf~
ML>n\\o- Q\oJn~\~ ~\\_Q ~\o.~(\.\1{~ wos ~u.~e~ ~ QS'(W\iy
-c"'"'\ CtAci Q\.~\v\~~( w~~ ~o\ ~\\-oc:--e~ 'b'-'"~ r-C{Lo\' \~ ~\~ Q~~.e~IO() OV1c1 Qlo;(\\,('~ ..rulare1_uu.¥y
Ci.\~Q~,~ JU\C\'\_e b'{lf\o_j~lhj 'o~~ W\1.\\_s w'l~ ~ b~G\cv.)\-e_s. du.Q..-\-o ba-ing~ ~lott.u- cn~}-orsv.­
p..Qr~\jor oG-~ t?\-'h1lr ~tWQA\:s ..slter1\~ Vul~a. . UJQ~ slJ'.-QJ -+c, b~1Q.f
(\ j ~~vi.\or ot- ~- o-rfr\U' ~e_J.Q.M-s I'
lS) "" z~\ ~~. ~ \ '--\f,06'-(;\J ---roJ- ·y r· J \- -
'-a, l-~' \) \
. -r-
f ().)\.l
C! -{ \ r- L
'-.lOu.-'\ \ 7
I

G:>~..A.0~: ~s. \)\~~-~~ ~v.s\ -~s\ V0oNiA D\\J\\\0(1 ·u""\.g.Q. ~\(i rN:-0/I...S
\=,k C)o:k.Q : \\-'-\,as
D\~Q\j\\\~f'): 0\s~~\ o~ a.t\ 't)-\tu.at ~Q~~ C.\cJMS ~~\-c\~~\ f

ar \s:\~ ~{\)·(¥"\ ~-ev-r~ 'n \ ~ \oac..k 0.1\ 2 · ?"t --()t.t_ .Q l w~-t,(~ _(~ 0. ~QJ\..\S~a ,-:r. ~tva\ I
Cvtb .S ~ \\o.~ -fo\' +.or u' ng c._c:U ~ 4-o \}.)~af ~ ~ o1 ():)0 Uol -\- &k{o.t),_ \-
d w lnj ~.-\n a\ ~cv\- occ.wr-e~ of\ S-f() '0 t\. -\-o s: -.2-o -6 L{ ~ 0\OA~ ~~ su..Qc\ a~,.
..{}GV's H.\~ ~~ hV't ~tit:t, o-. E 0 a.-ts I PJ'""To..v(o r cu~.Sf ~. cJt)Jc;tQ.f' ·/
~upI/¥\~ c.e.L2.i rn J-003 OVl 6 k;Di e.uJ
\r\a\ ~~(\'n\~ ~s. 3~nj +:oG\.e. ~l~ ~ ~\cttlA~ .. ~lCL{'n·h\-~ u.JQ:i
I
I'

\..J.AO-~\.e_ ~ ~\l{ f;,\.e_ ~ (\-o~ho" ~u...e~Sf!~~ca.4 ~
h'-t ~~e.. o ~~·Vh..

Co v.0\ ".u.S. D's\~~ Q,\1\~·,e:o 0;.A6ge.. AJM~ J(o-e.~ r' .

~\\~ ~ct\e. ~ I,J.:~ -o't

(.) \S~-o-" \ hofJ : ~ Ufl'\~ s~ e~ evJ'.h.-tO/l\ -\-c::, ..;2. ~ uS.c., i- l Cfl S (e) {.:>.j 1 :Z.~ U .\' ,(.
~- V1 \~ A c\0 0/)~ i J_ u.~. (. ~- \ Cf97 e Ccj On \[) --( -09
~ pV'a-\1~ f"a t.-\- 1

~\alA:\,\~ s~ ~ P('-~. L~~f\IP/\,r.. rYJi\hc.LL{JQ/'~~ ~r-ru\,~~-{hf'
d. e.Nt\ ~ \>\ o.,{ ()"\{- ~ ~\~( c.o.re 01t c\ M? ~\ «1h0') -tor Q\) er{ ~Q.-{\f\-C~A n~v--e_
Cc\1'"\·6,\-\tx'\ \n. ~~ oi& ~\c::JAr\-1~ ~ ~QI\~ 0-'\~ L.O\'' \\~ ~ ~ \o..t""--\1(~ St.te.c\
\.\.U.\'\.C.S.. ~~w~o.C!A( ~n-tfV\rW-e.\11 ~lbf 1 6wVl ~\oe..\'-\- w11\i~~f'
'(VJtJJ(o.y CAc\
€-S..\-Ot~h(\S ~ (->t>\\~ P"e'-l-€1\~n~ {>·~0-{c"\n\~...(c~~nj prescrike~~ ~n~
\)cU\~'v1\,(~ ·*'~ ~ s~ ~o.{y, @\G.t~h(t
-e -f. QV'-\ V\, 4 ·.ot::t- c.,v.-O\JL{() Cq,t\-vn u ~u1~re-kt\
GvJ"\: u~~. \Ju~,~ ~~~~~~\\.)·,~·,on -::r-V\6-~s~.La.ILe
~\ \~ 0 cet.o s - I -- 0 ~
·0 ..
~'s~\\\{)(\ ; o\S"Vli\\Sec1 r W"'-i'-'.0/\\ ~~'I, \.l..~.c. -\aJLJL ~ G(>~fo~r ·l ~ ~Mu.re.S -h \)revet\ ~ ~\n.}n('~ +«>A/\-Of Q...l\· ~ tL(.tt~iQ. L vV\.q Jv..e._ \-o~-e.t'.f' {oifure_
.-\-A ~('cu~~~"'-J \)\cJA\-t\\:- 9~su-t'~\-iol) eye~\o~!-ts,~\~n'-'~~.s~ .f\'\-OJ · ~ \cv\"\-1\E J~r-e.SS1 of\ -o.c\.\ca\-;on · \ n S ~~~Q/' ~~ ..(.C)c~ ·~ \ct{rt\1_f{:
s v-.Q.~ fi~ ~
~ ~v-- l~~OI\\s
/'

lC\) 'IC\al ~ A.Jb. 4'·D1-\Q.\\\\1\\\ oea~-\,V"\ Con~'( ~~n,p \)r.Q...ur~t,tS +'I Hnf-i' Pc.f.lL I e>{? :q
)t -}Q ~of~(} ) f'~'\ ~ ~ )"> J d Sui"""J ('J\JC'V V O~bJ'oO"-,. 0 'S'-J'l "\"\""' \ C
J

h ,JJ'aro"' vu 1'"" .j~ '-\'~"" \3 0\i~' n u.fi'..\ -""t a.\~""'" 7 ~"' s "l-11.\V\"") ~
Vt't~ Sf'\ 'I JC> lie) 'il Y\1"4 !I '""'~'I ~ ~'tr)'-\'A."' IJ .
J''1"' v,'tli"' ~ ~~ J "& lPrbw""''.l-: Jh.FVY1l. "QJ}~h~J~ ~l(V") ~~5\~~'t> -:V':-\ 1 S0 ~Jl 0
'rl- h ~ -e .,_ ~ C\J- '[;I ~ 0) ' OCY '()"1YN"} \" \ ~ (Qtj
>

. SJVO~"lr)d·f JO"r\:00"-J.f lJG 5lC'l'_~r SCI..~ :))ho)~
~ ~b Jlvvo_Q b ~ .f~ o-)to \~ ..fv\1 1 "o).Qw on-:J,}?I)+"Ii'] Q-jta-vtry" ~"t>\?-l ~S'o(J 01'~0 •-:>')'$' rn _:_1.:_1/ ~- W J.,:'YI
froj,Fnl/v'l VDfn() I I

I LR·p·J'vl (\It ~J:>,)~ ~5 j-() ~\vo ld - g_czc'7' n"'~ 'il" - -"'-;)-
\td JJ\?M · V\.1 ~(}J yvo Jov\XII)fJ-· '--\'S'~\ov_..:q )-vry~~V'-() ~r- j)LtU{VlQ r';;'S~o--> )\'1 ~vM- o

., y·i-.:> 4i O'jf>o~J )., 0 ~()-bJ-6 lA ~\:>.mJ' S'ui'M-t)?'-'..>QJ-J- -]Jl.\'V\l-'0 1b -\~C>"C>JO 0--T
SQVO $. bCN/ ~ t.S ~ GJ hOo 'O-ft OJ! J?T -\ )\bW't\1) '-\~)I nV():5Vf\ · -f7
~~ ~J'~qt\ Jdt·~\1~ )~~ ~0 JCrOQ._)-a O)A- V.l fu~\~a) ~ tJOO
~ (Q_~P~J~ 1,..~ICY:> "\~~~to~'-~ ~ (~J \t ...$'b\ ~. 0''S· D ~'C 0-t-

.
'VOY'IYJ"">Q

/
h~~ ~' 6~-9 ~f ~J ~ro!( ~\S (cw.Ji~t o/l l'l-\~-10 . Ql ~l~ hW'JV)-\-c ~\c:J~~ O.J\ 1..2~( ~-/ Q
d v--Q__ -\-o ~ la)A\t~~ ~..r ;·or lt\1 ~c:Ai'()J\ evt c\ ab0 far .ft lt. rtf a J r~ -€Uta~~ (Q q _
~ Q-{\1\ i \- c.~\: . -{.~hQ.-H11lf\ J WI k yl'\ ~ J ~k-t Sl)l[j' " ~I C.: n\) (( -f u-.QJ_ A~ CSaJ-
~ ~.r,J. -cr-. D...u.\ctc:::..... ~(' N'\'1 ILr'n ~ ---J1Ar&t~ o.C. bo~ ~ ~a//IVL alro oit t.:J-1~.-{ij
d, v--e_. \-a Q\a)~~~ ( ~ {'/ bf' ·\ thj>~ Df\a ~ ~~Vt\1 f{ .J' ~ ~ L. (t-l_OJ\f~e1\r)c.~ ev,d McLo1 ~rwrt-\,0J q..(qlr-e_ ~'~up\/-.
f\ ~ c. C!rS~ CV"l· 6 ~ r uvf)~S: cq~'n f CV> J- J o 0 ~ifc ytfiJ J 0~ uQ p1c.. h{tt{(
).JL g ~t Q~ .{ C>ll r :;l ..J..I- IJ ~ QI o)n-h f{ d'Wcl "6€Gi cer G\,'f\~ 4rJ\.tr~ fecU'-
O{)V'J (Y) ( J..-10-10 ~v.e_ k ~f1 C)f' ft tvS~ q/h.o!),
~ \ cJ C\\1 \\:- ..! ~ ~ .S.j-\- . Q....os.s CV\ ~ M ' f\-vOVQ/\ ~ vi.J \ln_J -e~(.Q.U tv---e-
-t-a \'L.e.-. o/\. ~v~. bV(. u...r1\(\f CV\ e -~ c.Q ~ \ ~ ~Wt:\- 'f'J~ ( 1~\Aht~ 'ouJrJA_g ol( o0-Q/"' a+ivb.tlllJ cl f€AtUd rr(\ ~
wQ.t
~CAl Q{~QA-\ ~v-.Q. -\-o ?n' OJ' 1tkfOl\iUf'\ ~ l~1 f\~(~ ~u.Q~ (V\. (_Jt~
D

OJ1d AJ. CL-e(l ~ (' c-e.~~ ~ \oJ"-\1{~ c ~J--'L. ~~ b~~J ~0 (-J-l(,
ot.J1--o.. \~~-t-t\-G h ~a ki\-t-{,(f- J u-Q_J. G-. w ..e_M\~ 0'\ ~-{1-l{ du-e
-\-o ~r\'u\' \\~~on .. ~\CMn\-t~ ~ u..st~ @.. ~ay'fh.ol\c\ ~' l.Q\'1-\-ia--r p(a!n.h({?- 0 ~q \s.Q
o.r~ '()~ Cr-t~~no ( "'C)...tJk.Q_~r -\'h~r ..(2M1we rrt Jed
hCA.N/-f\_J tl ~r~\\cy "" ~1ac.Q_-\-o ~.(€\lfVIT 1\1\~\al~ ~~~ 't).~CR-1krs WI~ repee!
~ u.~~\M Ot\-~-Q~S. v...:>\~ ~ ~\~Je._ {co'CV\ q .s~c.wrn_g r GS") UC)~b-JO)')d-(} l'i )}':\\) ~b \c)
JC?j- 'dl': 7}? .f?T> LJ}Q ~ P-J) L}vto] d 'Q/ _, 17- c I 0o y~{j )ofd-1 S'-J)li'l..\~\~ --}0>
o--.mJ" J'Vlho~~J-o(~vYD du,~S~ _JGJ rvo o-Jlo"J h.J-.o~]~~~n~ oS\OT
bJUt 1-Jcn J'1f hc:-y")W fv-0 · ~J)'"JLU flPt:)JqJ v~'i) ·~5 ~a-JtT\l' JQ,tJc\ JH!.fW4o e>\'4"'¥~.'\ j)!-J3 ])\.fV-:0) ~ a+
q.n p QI-SI-rJ vo QJjo wro\..j 1'~C'C\ -10 Pyt>d-J\1}\- Jur1row voj- ~'))1-\0 · ~
f vo JOjJ'O~ · y fO'O r- JJ ~·~h;> 10 · l/Q rIll"{~ r ·J,.,v w OJ ~ (Y) 1ucsvo Lf\h,.+ ; u\1v-r ~00 Y})\_\V(O \ Id "0 /- r 1-r:} u 0 t} DW"'l? \ 5 ~ ~ ~~ft'l >l~lud ]J.qlliro\~ 0-\- o-np Qt-b-t f vo t5SiO'J hrou~\~l_"J~~f d-S\l:>-J rv
JJ 1:\U?'O \ ~ Oi I j()') q yoJ ~ ~ S\) C1Q -? ~9 VOw\~\ Vf0-\0.0 J \> V"Q
ucr~~ r f-vo w f-rn s )-)l.\\J·~\C> " O'J-1:.-1: 1 vo -1:--n~~, ~ ':'"-'\
6-cut>o..t- }}l\U\"'ld Ju\,fQ/'nQJJc> ~vo ])~v~\ ~ Ji> ~)\bfiD~ _; ~ i7\ ~V1J(t '7 '9 o--n S"'
}}ltlfP=>I~ ..,uoq-oft~}l J9\,s 0/-711-1.1 vo y~-~~'.>-\f~.) )ln~~~ f~J'-\\)~\ c)
/V,ttJV'tfAD'\~'? J~lAf~)~)'1'-1J 1~J'~tr}'J\J. ~~S"' JJ~\~ VQ~Udt\~\ jQ_\~~ r

o-t-~? Ol-t'HI vo _j}~olo \~C'f'q o~'Ovv 5-f::>JJV(\--JG.j- tmvv
JJ.]qtoojd
-'fiJAJhcJ{S)~jo yvv ~~~·--\&")! )~ v-c,~~ ~~r- j)'-\~ro\ s-~~
-~ bVvJ~ u\' -~"\l--f\O?rs"·' ~h~'"' 1 ~~l~Y\ ~q ab~\.lJo--' ~~
(f)!:yn~J~ \h~l-~ -\-'Yl9_ (~\.1;,-S"dJd- Vl()JO~ S'b ~\? ~! ~ OU~-)
-~w"\rnr~\ s~d 9WJC1Lil--.JCrGW')n'&t' 0-\-- -\VOY\J"JY) \QA\rv~'~ ~-~~ ~ ~ ~ -.~~~ ()/)~ M · ~s s~ +o0 41 t.-1\-f ex CQs.I i v--e .forUL
On ~'\M bq ..Jt~ C. \-\-osds: lfY\c C\cvzqh&,f~J_cr~f'v.rd_
~ r ~c..PW'a,f\{~~ \) \ Cvt\rt~\ \.- \-u kll l h,1MJ t\f-61:\'t'f-:.Ji-.itf:~''~ f/~'~h{~' wQS
LAI)'~..iu\r ~·lJ7!Q,_f ~~~Vlh~t.
0 ~~ ~ .£\1\\C. ., c\Q_ wC{\d;,. \'\oJn\-1~ SV-{?~ J' u-e_ ~ {l..Cr\t.J ~f' ~Cd"tj> ~\~~w
~.C \-v~ .S\..t.\O ~ fL uXf.~e,h o.r, \-1-(( ctl~ ""Jh Pl Q)n-hf.f. IA)QJJ -h II .St.«C ,J..VV\~(\~s: ,Gs.\...0('{.3Y\\- 1 0/)6 ~rlll{-sh-tl~n for
· .1,., o.....r 8 M_j "'\<>-~ "-\-> ~ ~ {r.oiVI ~ .s1Lse6 OAO J u '.c.'~ al d ~ +<> ~wi ur I A-iJ>'lhil/1.•
(> \ wV~&~ .!: w. ~ G-. L.O ~~h \- {o, 61!Mf I~ e\a.t ~'h ~f n-Q ,l, Cd \ K d/1 ~ IV'/!J,oJi t7
Qf\ 'l.-).'h-ll J_~ \-o ~\'\-?.){\ \i\1Jcv\7Uf). ~\al. ~{~.J~~ ""Cf. ~.ojQf ~ Lil~~beJ::_

-foe' *''n6~J ~\cJn-tt\~ jvt\-kr E>~ ct -fa~d\.~dQ\I~cvl ~ctnfQ_ ~q-\-- ~
\o 0 ~ ~1'\ e-v..::> -\-o ~ {_ -e,,;r,k.Q O.li S. -( "1-·- Jl. cl_ ()...Q_ -\-o ~ f' i C.J' h \i ~ cc\1 Of) _

Q\~n~~ ~~6 (5.(\~~"~ ·~~ l.l-1cA-tVrJ ~lo.Jthf{ £VJ
~.e-ye /~a~ 0/llc\ ~"'~ ~\Co-t'"\,{{ a-t ~H a.s ha/lt\cu£Cn,p PlO-t~t\,tfitt~
\J~ ~ l(vv~ f\\CA/Ifl.stf' d ~ -\-o ~n'\>\ h\1~et~ .. ~\o.-t'v\·h~\. ~ued ~~'i.O ~
Q.DOS"'~ o.L c,,""-~n4t \J,;_.~\;LQ ~c--¥h.Ur ~lur--e \n \,o.vt'"g a_~u\\"U[ M plctLQ_
. -~ ~C'e.N~ Y'V\~\.ctl\~ \\l o\-~W.£ Lot~ ~ ~eak~ ...iu\c.\~£ o.~-\-s to(-\{,
~ 'o\a~-e_ -G.-(()~ Ct. ..s h.u".n\1.2 C'otL-o\', ~(O(V\ hV\.AJ)f1i acc..es..s: -k QJ \,c;WJA__g
~£A 2. ..-cx--. A.-ll o~ ~~!L ~.e..(Q.4..S\ ;-1 c..(')
' ' ~ "'
~.-~q JvO
~(' LA)Gf\\- ~ J
() \ f- C I. .D \ l)J'\ ~ \ .
0

~ f' ~)u"bnJL 'C/\ :J-d-0- 6Y
'Hk V(~ ~ M w,6.~ ~t,e.\- ·+a ~e~ Co cU' ~ ~J\~
~-\~~ ..&~\\\U' ~ ~\e.. Nw-rc \Jro\wt c..~ OJ\~ ~u ~hia~ heQI

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/cases/4056183. Public record. Not legal advice.