# Brandon, Stephen Gerard

> Texas Supreme Court · January 9, 2015

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/cases/4038252

## Case

- **Court:** Texas Supreme Court
- **Decided:** January 9, 2015
- **Precedential status:** Published
- **Opinion:** Opinion
- **Cited by:** 0 later opinions in the Frix Law Library

## Citator (automated)

- No negative treatment found by the automated citator. That is not the same as a confirmation that the case is good law; read the citing cases.
- Full citator and citing cases: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/cases/4038252

## Opinion text

r '·,:Pi·,
. . .
~l/ 4-tt-()?r
. •.

5T£P~l£~··~fl~NDO~ \? !3Sg?J35 . .

. - ffiA~ w. ·sr/L£.S U:Ni'l
3000 F (Y'/' ~ ~ llf : . . . · This document contains some
i)£AlJII\IID .. \ .-r-1 -rc" 11_5 77'70 ~ pages that are of poor qualii.y
' '' •~ • I 1=-NT tj -J at the time of imaging.

To~ f:_L£R_r_\ 1£ ~t4s Coo~::r· o-f (!.Jii mii\\AL AflfJ£J4~
P.ol ~o~ t:13o%, CAPtrlJL 5114-nDtJ
AusTi.rM, T'k'kll:S ..18 7(1 . ,.

. R£~ STATE of Tt=.V\S v. STERH£~ ~~N~O~
....~+hJ:SC. _No •.· D 5 c_~ ll {£;7 ..

D£AR- Si(L/ IYlAo+UVl£; .
·E_f..ic_LDsE-b is Tit6 DIU"csiNAL AI\\D
o 1\\£ ~o flY o.f2 Pc.1iri oNE1,.J CouMrY I r~ M.S

{k, PLAi"~ri ££5 6itlr;sii\\AL {tpp. a~ Wk1r a·.P D1AM0 ttmus
iD Tfl-1£ Ho~ R.A/6/.£ Jub~ Df' SaiD C. o u/l,'I ;
ChNJ£..S NOW, Yr6P+16rJ fJJRArJODf\L R£LA1()12-.
Pe.D ££ iN 11-l£ Pr&.>o\16-STYL£1J --AtJd Nurr1b6f£o
, c...Jtc);6 of b(C..IiorJ A,Jn~:A.L£S THis ()~_i&iNAL- APP.
J!otL Ll) ~I of fY1 A-~ 0 AIVHlS . f1 /L fY1o-rtD ~ /tJ e_ ~ i SCtY~G/l}( \
Pualw ltf6 ~DJ~ 11+6 .{2/JLLCJliJ/tJ~;
J:_,
jj, r: of1
L. R..im(~~L- Sus-rielS At\1D (.s -APP£A RiN& P~to scs, wm
C.ftN b6 Lot:.ATE:n A--( fYlARJL lAJ, Sti L£5 UtJit; :3o&;o (fYI
2 5/Lf 8bAOIV1orJ'i: T~- 777Ds-, s&-ree-soN Co,
I
} I

, i.,Dj_, ftnPG LLEO i .S YYI(I\li--
Sra..i PeL, ~or di'rA-Tur£ \ R£L~Wt2..... wouw H--A\16 tR.Ee.i£JBJ
f\\o-rt'L£ fJILbVY'l ll-fb ~Duif cfJ ~1Ylir.J4-G ~ fl(JG(f-t_S •
I[,
t,. Re:seoND6NL
~~ ~£.s(Jof'lD~N" ZfoHf\\ D. KiNAR...o, iN h~s C!..APAC(f'(
A~ CJ£s-rr2.ic.:r C-L£(LJ( o..P Gs!H-\J6S71>,j C:ou~-ry', TE. 'X-.14~
AM A-- Nlc'uiif£LJAL Du-r 1mtnGd)iA-16LV Tl?Af'Jsmil ~ro
IHE- ~otJR.r nf C.aJmctJA-l A-11P~14U5 a_ &J PV D-P
'T#£ r'\'lon'ol\) -Poa- Disco~Gl.Y, AI\\Y tl-tJSw££.5 -A'Lt-tJ,
aND a_ c..£rri-P ~· t.A-T£ /(_fSc_i ,,· 1\.) e:s- 11-16 bAr£ LJ fJo tJ
W~iCA IU:I+I .fJitJrH'N& w~S f{JM6 [{J /fiG CO~Vt'ai!J&
~ouR.J ,~t:-cicJGc; Tl-tf.l-1 'THc.i£ AIL6 l\)D isst.J6S To
b6 ~£~oL~ED .. SottN D~ K.~A~i tJisTILiCT c_LEJR-IC-,
asALv£5Tl>tJ C.oui\JTY Mf\'1 bi:S S6f2. 'J6D ftl bfls fJLAc_£
D-f- hus i 1\lE.SS A-11H6 3 u~TJ'c£ C£ NI£/L. toDD 5 ?r~t- Sr,
ST£. LfODli GAL-\18rz>rJ '\ l6Y.il·S 775s-/"
.nr,
~. VioLttriorJ o£ Ame;J £. ll~o? o·f TH6 L6"klltS
Cooh D£ C.JdRE
.2vol T!-\£ Re/3Po~o61\J{ \1 IDLAT£D Ar2:rieL6 t {,o?
S£e--riorJ 3(I\l
+oa_ DlsCD\1a..,Y\ tu\lY f*'!LJ£lS ~·LEo, A-ND a e£il11 .-:
_Q{c.Ar£ RWn·N~ rH£ Di4/!5 tJPof'J uJH-ictf 1#11-1
..P.t'Nb~tJG- WA~ tYJAD£: ro THb CDuRr a/ Cf_iiYit.NI+L
APO~PcL.S ~AND TlrAT St.JCJ+ fC£CDtlJS Pre.£
Q~ui~D by ·me Gourtl Df tt itJS imPo::£:1) tJ fJotJ
h~ ro bLf 1 f-4£. '[t£YJ4.~ C,o~~ o-f' ~ tLiv'YI iN AL P2.D ~ ffi t.Jt.b ~~
.:Lu cot0i-r~NA-L LHJD LDrYimo.J c.o LJILT£~ Y tJ-(1
1\NY LU~--rr£rJ R.t:.SPoN563 Tb h;s co~fC.ESPof.J D£tJ~E­
&N D. R.mu£~1.
~,DS t!Jr~Jriu£.. ll.D7 5£Grft>N 3Lc.) C!..L£AR-LY S TFI-TES ·
m~ Ll iP ·rt-~£'c.o~\\lc:n'ruG (}_f)u~-r 1'.J£ci 7/Jn-r nes
T~E dtt2£. tJD ~ L)u\- JS'S \)£.~.h TJ.I-6 C.t.EIJ K .s Uti Ll_
1rYJm£Di ttr£' Y UANS mir T?J TH6 too~ tJ {J
L:LvV1;~M- f+PPa:t~ a.. CLJP'r' nf--rHG fYlo~io~ \
~>t~t? A-tJ.SuJ6t5. f~·l£.t:l. A~n a... ~EdtfJi e:_£+r6 Rccili NG-
'TH-6 DAr£ OPDN W~~ 1lJitl fi~JniNt.s wA-S fiJI+fJ£ 9

fa.~lurus D.{l~ffG C..ouiGI m AU wi-rlktJ Tlf&
OLLLD~D d.O DAVS ~f+,- -rHis L;TI-~ffriotJ iN ·
L'::.oDD .fJa.;-rH ~t43 Su bstAtJ-r't4-LLY f1R.G'Jai 1£~
aMD o

R£LAIDIL p~y~ J!DL Ak\ lJiJ)£{L
d~L?.£L:(')il& ~~~D~~£tJI·TD IR..ANSmil ~DPV
cl-rtt£ fYloTi o ~ AL t isc_c~~v \ ANL,\ Ruu:: 3Lf., -PiLES THi~ n1lT//l)tJ 1

..Port. DIS~oV£.f?_V, PuR-SuA-i\ll1b IH6 F£rJ6UrL eat.£~
c..~m(t\\A- L. ·Pwt!lS~u~\ Ruu=: 1Lo L£) .
.:c"
ftPPuL-ANI ·((E.D.u£5'/S Iff£ CDo~
C,ol\1s'fQ_O£S
1
At'fJu,CAN1' S t~Prt:rfvL PL£A-Dit0J C:r
/_j B£ {)_fl. L.LY l A!Lr IS £~WLfJimJl. 'r A- hll'J
m(T;G;-A-Ti Nb- £ \ltt£:Nc£ \ 'l.flm- Is I f\J T#E. Possc:Sie>tJ
~ "T+t£. idALv£~r-:J Cou~ 1iu.b£~£~ ND~ oNLY bcr fYllrriorJ
..{)oL D~s.c..n\J£/LY, bLJI PrLSo bY L£~L 1D TH6 +/oN.
SuDfs£ !JJAv~£ fYlA-u.iA, Assr. ]);gr~c;r ftlllJlA16Y
L~((p_~ Df2.D5N~, -As W£LL 1t-s A L£7'7E. L Tb
A-T lit£ -rim£ t is-r,· CL£R.K. ,:fA-.SDr-J mo !P -r+t£: STtrr£ lD P~\lin£ ·A-ND d ,'scwsG ·-r~l..s
£u..uLPAIDL~ £\Jt~Et.JC£ '1D IH6 dsi£NdAJ.J'11 Rfirf!EL
~vc=>-rt:.b o~ ~~ w+ti[i_.J+ q's suPPDR::I£'0 bY /Hb
.fJD Lw w b~ (h C,Ptc;£ LAw : t:_ r·-r( ~ & " 12" \;f.[: a S:r4v=:: c
"'' &.r:s, £tf_, 105 s.~'f. 33 75, ALSo 5££ {)NiTc2\ Sr14Tt=:S'
I .. \ •

\1. Hf'"'"')D
{\ {) S, '-~ w
I) I ~ It.-.-,.
/1 t
I
- I J3 qJ.. \ K0 rs \L l!)d lrl £ lj
---

1/:l s.·e;r: i55~ ALSO ClcC;.lJ'o J, I ). s, ., Cf:l s.ct.

703, [H£ -fttc-r-rl:lffl TH-l3 £~iDE.Nc£ is IH£
~ur~ n/1-rtt£ S·riJ:TE TD di~cl oSE £XC.A)t-PV+TCJ!LV

£ui~£JJ~ i~ ALSo SoUJPofDtJ \1. uJtt,~rreV, c18' F3d
433{5-rt-\. ~~~. iqq4-\, dE-f'GA)D~NI\:; fuNtsAm£tJ"It+L-
R..il:9t-\-rS of Do£ PfLDcbSS LVEAP.E VtDLAIE~ bY klot\1-
dic..w N
bf TttE LAw PDE~GrJT£b iN l+tis rYJOitDN,
APPu.c..A-NI ~~ R.Ulo6sTiN& AN £\JiC~6NTA((_'\J6JtT£lJ
issl)a, fY1Prr£Q.i14L ·ro 11-l£ L£&AL;.,y tJ{J
APPu· c.A /'\)'"( s co~(·f\J£m£tJC:

~£t; PE~T:Pu u_t/ Sob mr·rr£ D 1

.Jt:qw,.v~
SrGPfi/EJ'~ f!J!U\1\1 ~DvJ t PRD s~
Tbc::r- it~ 1.35_s
mDI"icrJ fbL D i~~D\l£.LC(, WAQ, m~/ L£ D TD [#1:6
CouiL'I o·f ~~v11irJAL A PP6f+L:5 bv U.S. (i'R..sr
CLASS rYl 1/\t L" t3..L/d ~gSGJ 'fl> fJr 8£ L fl C.DS-IA--'
PrTi o rJ
I\ 5T£P.t-t£~ (j~N~o rJ, lbc.:J-:J:l: /35~ 33.5'~
b£iN~ p~~f:~L'( lNC..Pc~R..AI£'D 1~ 'f-11-E: fYJII-R.K
W, s.,.-i u::s uf'ltT nf2 '14-1£ l£'£il-~ D£..Alw:rm£tJ-I
af ~.J!.irvt;NAL su~-ric£- lNS7~irt..JT/of\JA-L Di\liSrl){.J
t~ .:1 £if'£.tl.S6~ C.,o O~'T ~t:L)LP?lTDLV £\Ji~£i\JCE 10 -rHE of£/CNC!AI-Jf, f?.Jr!ff£/L
R£Do£ST£b Dtf(, l(Jo-;-; u.J-t-J.(·ef-1- ,·s suPPZJR-T£lJ bY IH£
.foLUJ(..D~ ~ b c.. A, r.ti, ;o5 S.d. 3375, ALSo~££ tJN;T£l\ St-ArC:S'
' ..._.\
'
.. ·. \ 'j:~
'
.C0 pu1
' >.
.'·/ I•

. I,: ~I '

IA_htfrl£ Y ' ~ r
.

OitJ S. c:r. ~~3q1. \ 1\t(t r:S ~.
'

v. ArA12RS
.
t
~,..,...f:

.J 15' s. C;r. 1555"; ALSO Clr-C..,-lJ-0 J. I ). s, I Q;L s. c-r.
. .
7&;3, I H£ fAcll+ltr THiS £vtD£Nc£ 1s IIi£
turtJ
.'
Df iH£ SII41E TD d/c;;.c_LDSE £XC.--tJt-Pt41CJI2_V

£u(.i:J£.f\\c£ is I~L-So SuiPPo~T~i~ b~ IH£ IE:YJ4s
LD b£.. c_ R_j m. PRo~ ~ tt-r: ~ DL I I NoTt: I I ..
11 r:.
T ~ LJ s )
Iff£ ; (V'l P£fl c_ ~iNC~
pD uJ£_Jt._ D -P l+fE
£y: ~-- u Lf-J 4 T!J i)_ V £ ~ 1-D£.. J'JC._£ T f-1 ~ / {1 fJ f Ll. C. A~~ / S {2_£_- .
' . .

\
DtJ£Sii.Nb-: {_!J_ i-r,·I\J&, 44JiLSDJ \l._lUtftrtt:Y. I d~. r 3d.
.•
i LJ.3 3 f 51" c_; R-. ,q 9'+ \ , cl d£AJ D f\ Nr 's, fUN M mcr.J It+ L-
;,
·'

d i c..w s. Ll ll£ 0 f £ ~ it£1\.) C£.:. 'ft.(~~ ; 1\ I P£ AL H£ D Ti-l£
Qt: L;A.f!)i L,.Tl' AV\lD Ctt£.D 1. ilJi u·!V o-P A K£ Y IAJ i TJJ£SS,

w ouu"J 1-\ Av£ loltA LL-y' C..-t-\ t\ N C:s- £ D T+1£ o Uicorn£
6~ -rH£ ti'LiAL. 1 l-l£l.£ .foR£ iN THis iN srHrJ/ C.l'-ls£ ,
CL .f'a IAJ 1'1 L iA.J A5 1\Jo-i (( cc..i E. v6 ['" b () E:. TO
I IL
T{t£ o ru£S fYlA'/t:,Q_,·f4L To 11-f£ L£. Gs·A Lr,IY rJ t) I

~\ PPL.i c A /\\IS c.o~f.)r'f\J£vn£AJI:

~£.SPt:cTfuu_l(' S~Jbf\t11.11£D,
.4~d~~
STf-P1·-(£N () fi...f-\1\J i\ovJ I Pea s~
Tr:.tT~ iD ~ /35X'X 3~
I I-_, 1

CoPy

1

d..D I Lf, CA._ I ~U£ AND c_D R..~£c_I CD PY ti-P C\ PPLi ct.JIUT~
mI D f. Cl tJ fa fL l\ i 'S r o \l£L r'
1 iA~ rv1 A ,. L£ iJ TO 7-+I~
(A_)

LOURS o-f c(L,·((i;f\JA L A PP6ALS bv LJ' S. (/12.sl
c LA)S m AI. L I {'JrJe_.c:_c;c-,~c/ TO A8£ L (-/ CDSI.fr'

o'l /
P,o, bo'i.. I.J..2DR, (!_14P/-rD'- 5Tt41tol\..l i 4 uST;N,
J£'1-.43 '78 7 I I.

[\£ C LA() ATioN_
I-, sTi P.J-1£ t-J 8r2..A f'-~ ~o"" /t:Jc:J.Jt 135 ~ 253 5',
I

b£t.NCs Pe_c~£-l('s~LY' iNC-A~£/2.itr£b i~ ,--If£ rY]ItQK
lJJ, S1"i L£5 uf'lil rJ2 ~+-1£ /£Y..J4 s D£..1-JA~mt.:tJ-1
() . _,- >-.'. ' . \
o-\ ~Q.( rYit NAL :.fLJ ~-r/c_£. -- _j_f'JSi/Ti..JTJ.() tJ A L LJ I J isr l)I\J

I~ ..1 r;__ff- £/(_ £f"1 uN T-l+r_S
.E t...J-t~ r!iT.s
At\\~

Af.Pib Av .~r~
.('"'·.,, ., .l>t..
~ !:~~~-- ,,

-- --~- ------- -- -- ~--------- ---------- ··- ----· ·--·- ------- ----. ·--------- -------------- --- ----- ----- -- -- --· -~ --- --------------- ------·· .. --- ----- . ---

------ ·-------------- -----------~------ ---------------------------------·------------- ------------------------- --- ----- - ----
• -·-·-· . . ..

n
·······-·-··--···-·- -·····-- .... ··-·····-······ --······· -··-·--·-····--··-····· ····-·· ...
.
-- ·-··-·-··· -·· ·- .... .. . .,.. ·······- .. .. . . -- .. ...... . - -
-
- -. - - -
.
- - -- --

- -_-:_- _ _~-·-:·: ·.:·: -~·::·._::~::•.-.:::::~~·-~-·-·~:R~;: :_·:·-____··: .• ~-·:::·.·.:.·_·::.·.
·~-·-··· :. ·~- • ~~··-··-· :.·---~····· - _-__:: -~-;J;;;;;;;_;;:/'"tiS:di~i.-
----- . --. --- ---·---- .... ---- ····-- --------- ····------------------ ···------------ ----------------·--·-· ····-·--------·-·-······-- -----· -------- -------· ··--·-·· ------ ---- ··-··· ___________ .. --------- .. _:______ . -

·~-· : • -=--~=:·:=•=•~---~·.:. ·==~=-==-=::=-~- ·:::=--==-:·:::·. (;/La/~:~= : :·: : :
_·::::.:•~:;BrwnzliiiL~:liii:t1iJiliiiZE~~IJM
·--------·--·-··--·--~-~--~---~---~----~---&11!!!§:_ .?J-~fn
---- . -uU{J~~J)AL_-~-*~---······· -··--·········-
·-- ·····--··-··-··-~----·--····---------·-..----···--·-----·-··-··-·-----·-------·····---··-·----····----·-······-············ ········-····--·. ·-·······-·-· •......... ···-··-·····--·-··

_ _ --~~--
· - ·-· · · · _________EiiL ~--~----~~- - · - n----A_/ A~/'_{'-;!
A#-~-y;tft:l-~i
----~----·--- __ - ···----··· - ---·-··-·- -
----·-· · ·- -·-·-· -. - -· · · · -·· -- . . · -----· --· . -·· ---·· . . - -· · ·- · --·-· ·--··--·-----·--·-· · ·
·--~------o----·

... . fovJd&_ CL C!fd ·- ......... -~ ~-

-·~- · _: · ~- -· -·~ ·-·~·- ~- ~- ·~- -~- ·~- ~-~ ~- -~- -· ·-~ ·-·~- · ---_-. ~-~·~-~- ~- ~ ·- ~-~-~~-------~~----·~-~-------~·~·----~~--····-·:.·:~·---~···--· : :.:.~-~- - - -·- - ·~-·- ~ - __ _:·-_-···-· ··::·:

·--- ·- ·- ···--···-·-·-···-- --·······- --- ---··--·------·--· .. ····-·-············--·-·-·--·· ···-·····--···-· --·--····-----·~ ··-··-···--·-· ·····-·-·--·-·--·--· ·-· .. - --····---·-··. ·--· ----- ----···-· ······ ··--·- ·-·

----------- ·-- ------ --- ---- -------· ------- -------------------- ··- ---- --·· --- ----- -. ·-- .. ···-- -· ---· ·- ·-··- -··-- -·- -- .
'
.. -------··

/
-------------'
c:-~-~--------
I

• _ _ _ _ _ _------=--::o~~~I!J~-L3-58:82~_s::_ _ _
-------·~w__,_~ ~----
--------~~_£m~~d---------
-------~~~~7~~----

·------------------------
Affidavit of Amaris Kinsey

I, Amaris Kinsey am above the age of 18, and of sound mind, do declare that the following information is
true and correct to the best of my knowledge.

I, Amaris Kinsey, have been assisting my uncle, Stephen Brandon, in trying to obtain a copy of the
private investigators report, for his case that was prepared by investigator, Donna Brown. Brown, was
the investigator who was appointed to his case by the 405th District Court of Galveston County. I have
spoken to Donna Brown, the investigator on the phone as well as Atty. Winston E. Cochran Dr., who was
representing Stephen Brandon at the time. Cochran showed the report to Stephen Brandon, but never
as promised gave a copy of the report to Stephen. I did in fact, speak to Investigator Brown, and she
claimed that she had moved her office from Dayton to Liberty, TX and lost her files and was not able to
deliver a copy of the requested report at this time . I have made several attempts since this time to
locate Donna Brown, or obtain the report from Atty. Cochran, but with no success.

This statement is true and correct to the best of my knowledge.

Respectfully,

Sworn before me this ~ay of __p-~'-~e~c___ 2014.
MvkhJ
Signature of Notary Public
Affidavit of Crystal Lucas

I, Crystal Lucas, am above the age of 18, and of sound mind, do declare that the following informatio-n is
true and correct to the best of my knowledge.

I, Crystal Lucas, have been assisting my brother, Stephen Brandon, in trying to obtain a copy of the
private investigators report, for his case that was prepared by investigator, Donna Brown. Brown, was
the investigator who was appointed to his case by the 405th District Court of Galveston County. I have
not personally spoken to Donna Brown, the investigator on the phone but have spoken to Attorney.
Winston E. Cochran Jr., who was representing Stephen Brandon at the time. Cochran showed the report
to Stephen Brandon, but never as promised gave a copy of the report to him. I have made several
attempts since this time to obtain the report from Attorney Cochran, but with no success. There is
exculpatory evidence within this report that is favorable to Stephen's defense.

This statement is true and correct to the best of my knowledge.

Signature of Notary Public
MAURICE ROSS
Notary Public, State of New York
. No. 01R06276894
Oualif1ed in Onondaga C t
Comm· . E ounr
ISSIOn Xpires 02125120~

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/cases/4038252. Public record. Not legal advice.