# United States v. Warshak

> Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit · December 14, 2010 · 631 F.3d 266

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/cases/181032

## Case

- **Full name:** UNITED STATES of America, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. Steven WARSHAK (08-3997/4085; 09-3176); Harriet Warshak (08-3997/4087/4429); TCI Media, Inc. (08-3997/4212), Defendants-Appellants
- **Court:** Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit
- **Decided:** December 14, 2010
- **Citations:** 631 F.3d 266; 2010 U.S. App. LEXIS 25415; 2010 WL 5071766
- **Precedential status:** Published
- **Opinion:** Opinion
- **Judges:** Keith, Boggs, McKeague
- **Cited by:** 345 later opinions in the Frix Law Library

## Citator (automated)

- No negative treatment found by the automated citator. That is not the same as a confirmation that the case is good law; read the citing cases.
- Full citator and citing cases: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/cases/181032

## How later opinions describe it (automated extraction)

- holding Rule 704(b) was violated by expert testimony that the business dealings of defendant’s company were commingled with his personal dealings with the “intent to conceal” and that certain cash transactions were “designed to conceal”; the former spoke directly to the defend…
- holding that "a subscriber enjoys a reasonable expectation of privacy in the contents of emails 'that are stored with, or sent or received through, a commercial ISP' " and neither the ability nor the right of a third-party intermediary to access the *753contents of a communica…
- holding that “the government did not engage in any conduct indicating that it performed its Brady obligations in bad faith” and “there [was] no indication that the government deliberately concealed any exculpatory evidence in the information it turned over to the defense”
- finding that although an expert witness’s testimony as to a defendant’s intent was error, the error was harmless because of the large amount of evidence against the defendant and the government’s clarification that it was not seeking evidence of the defendant’s intent
- finding argument that the government could not seize the proceeds from legitimate transactions without merit because “[a]ny money generated through these potentially legitimate sales . . . resulted ‘directly or indirectly’ from a conspiracy to commit fraud”

## Opinion text

RECOMMENDED FOR FULL-TEXT PUBLICATION
Pursuant to Sixth Circuit Rule 206
File Name: 10a0377p.06

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT
_________________

X
Plaintiff-Appellee, -
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
-
-
-
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/
v.
,
4212/4429; 09-3176
>
-
STEVEN WARSHAK (08-3997/4085; 09-3176); -
-
-
HARRIET WARSHAK (08-3997/4087/4429);
TCI MEDIA, INC. (08-3997/4212), -
Defendants-Appellants. -
-
N
Appeal from the United States District Court
for the Southern District of Ohio at Cincinnati.
Nos. 06-00111; 06-00111-001; 06-00111-2; 06-00111-7
S. Arthur Spiegel, District Judge.
Argued: June 16, 2010
Decided and Filed: December 14, 2010
Before: KEITH, BOGGS, and McKEAGUE, Circuit Judges.

_________________

COUNSEL
ARGUED: Martin S. Pinales, STRAUSS & TROY, Cincinnati, Ohio, Martin G.
Weinberg, Boston, Massachusetts, for Appellants. Benjamin C. Glassman, ASSISTANT
UNITED STATES ATTORNEY, Cincinnati, Ohio, for Appellee. ON BRIEF: Martin
S. Pinales, Candace Crouse, STRAUSS & TROY, Cincinnati, Ohio, Martin G.
Weinberg, Boston, Massachusetts, Robert M. Goldstein, Boston, Massachusetts, for
Appellants. Anne L. Porter, ASSISTANT UNITED STATES ATTORNEY, Cincinnati,
Ohio, for Appellee. Kevin S. Bankston, ELECTRONIC FRONTIER FOUNDATION,
San Francisco, California, for Amici Curiae.
BOGGS, J., delivered the opinion of the court, in which McKEAGUE, J., joined.
KEITH, J. (pp. 94–98), delivered a separate opinion concurring in the result.

1
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 2
09-3176

_________________

OPINION
_________________

BOGGS, Circuit Judge. Berkeley Premium Nutraceuticals, Inc., was an
incredibly profitable company that served as the distributor of Enzyte, an herbal
supplement purported to enhance male sexual performance. In this appeal, defendants
Steven Warshak (“Warshak”), Harriet Warshak (“Harriet”), and TCI Media, Inc.
(“TCI”), challenge their convictions stemming from a massive scheme to defraud
Berkeley’s customers. Warshak and Harriet also challenge their sentences, as well as
two forfeiture judgments.

Given the volume and complexity of the issues presented, we provide the
following summary of our holdings:

(1) Warshak enjoyed a reasonable expectation of privacy in his emails vis-a-vis
NuVox, his Internet Service Provider. See Katz v. United States, 389 U.S. 347 (1967).
Thus, government agents violated his Fourth Amendment rights by compelling NuVox
to turn over the emails without first obtaining a warrant based on probable cause.
However, because the agents relied in good faith on provisions of the Stored
Communications Act, the exclusionary rule does not apply in this instance. See Illinois
v. Krull, 480 U.S. 340 (1987).
(2) The district court did not err in refusing to hold a full-fledged hearing under
Kastigar v. United States, 406 U.S. 441 (1972), when determining whether government
agents had improperly used privileged materials seized during a valid search of
Berkeley’s headquarters. Kastigar does not apply with full force outside the context of
compelled testimony. See United States v. Squillacote, 221 F.3d 542 (4th Cir. 2000).
(3) The district court did not abuse its discretion by failing to order the
government to provide discovery in a different format, as Federal Rule of Criminal
Procedure 16 is silent on the issue of the form that discovery must take. Moreover, the
government did not duck its obligations under Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1963),
by providing the defendants with massive quantities of discovery. See United States v.
Skilling, 554 F.3d 529 (5th Cir. 2009), vacated in part on other grounds, 130 S. Ct. 2896
(2010). Finally, the district court did not err in refusing to grant the defendants a
continuance so that they could continue examining the discovery materials turned over
by the government.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 3
09-3176

(4) The district court did not err in refusing to grant Warshak a new trial based
on an alleged Brady violation, as the purportedly exculpatory material did not rise to the
level of materiality. See Kyles v. Whitley, 514 U.S. 419 (1995).
(5) The district court did not err in refusing to grant the defendants a new trial on
the basis of prosecutorial misconduct. Though the prosecution did make a number of
improper remarks during its rebuttal argument, the remarks were not flagrant. See
United States v. Carter, 236 F.3d 777 (6th Cir. 2001).
(6) The evidence was sufficient to support Warshak’s and Harriet’s respective
convictions for conspiracy to commit mail, wire, and bank fraud, in violation of
18 U.S.C. § 1349. See Jackson v. Virginia, 443 U.S. 307 (1979). Those convictions are
therefore sustained.
(7) The evidence was sufficient to support Warshak’s convictions for mail fraud,
in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1341. Those convictions are therefore sustained.
(8) The evidence was sufficient to support Warshak’s and Harriet’s respective
convictions for bank fraud, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1344. Furthermore, the district
court did not err in instructing the jury that, under certain circumstances, the government
may prove specific intent to defraud a bank by showing specific intent to defraud a third
party. See United States v. Reaume, 338 F.3d 577 (6th Cir. 2003). Those convictions
are therefore sustained.
(9) The evidence was sufficient to support Warshak’s conviction for conspiracy
to commit access-device fraud, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1029. That conviction is
sustained.
(10) The evidence was sufficient to support Warshak’s and TCI’s respective
convictions for money laundering, in violation of 18 U.S.C. §§ 1956, 1957. Those
convictions are affirmed. By contrast, the evidence was insufficient to support Harriet’s
money-laundering convictions. Those convictions are therefore reversed.
(11) The evidence was sufficient to support Warshak’s conviction for conspiracy
to obstruct an FTC proceeding, in violation of 18 U.S.C. §§ 371, 1505. As a
consequence, that conviction is sustained.
(12) The district court did not err in refusing to order the government to reveal
whether or not it had conducted any additional surreptitious searches of Warshak’s
emails or communications. The discovery afforded by Federal Rule of Criminal
Procedure 16 is limited to the evidence referred to in its express provisions, United
States v. Presser, 844 F.2d 1275, 1285 (6th Cir. 1988), and those provisions do not
encompass the information sought by the defendants.
(13) The district court failed to provide an adequate explanation of its
determination that the defendants should be held accountable for $411 million in losses.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 4
09-3176

See Fed. R. Crim. P. 32(i)(3)(B); United States v. White, 492 F.3d 380, 415 (6th Cir.
2007). We therefore vacate Warshak’s sentence and remand.
(14) The district court did not abuse its discretion in refusing to admit certain
evidence during the forfeiture phase of the trial. Furthermore, the evidence was
sufficient to support the proceeds-money and money-laundering forfeiture judgments
against Warshak. In addition, the evidence was sufficient to support the proceeds-money
forfeiture judgment against Harriet, but it was insufficient to support the money-
laundering forfeiture judgment against her. Therefore, the proceeds-money forfeiture
judgment is affirmed with respect to both Warshak and Harriet, and the money-
laundering money judgment is affirmed with respect to Warshak, but reversed with
respect to Harriet.

I. STATEMENT OF THE FACTS

A. Factual Background

In 2001, Steven Warshak (“Warshak”) owned and operated a number of small
businesses in the Cincinnati area. One of his businesses was TCI Media, Inc. (“TCI”),
which sold advertisements in sporting venues. Warshak also owned a handful of
companies that offered a modest line of so-called “nutraceuticals,” or herbal
supplements.1 While the companies bore different names and sold different products,
they appear to have been run as a single business, and they were later aggregated to form
Berkeley Premium Nutraceuticals, Inc. (“Berkeley”).2 In Berkeley’s early days, the
company’s workforce was relatively minute; the company employed approximately 12
to 15 people, nearly all of whom were Warshak’s friends and family. Among them was
his mother, Harriet Warshak (“Harriet”), who processed credit-card payments.

As the company grew, Warshak brought on additional employees to facilitate
expansion, but he remained extremely “hands-on” with respect to the company’s
operations. In 2001, he hired James Teegarden, who eventually became Berkeley’s

1
The companies also sold a product called Keflex, which supposedly masked traces of drugs in
one’s urine.
2
These companies were called Lifekey, Inc. (formed May 9, 2001); Boland Naturals, Inc. (formed
May 7, 2002); Warner Health Care, Inc. (formed August 19, 2002); and Wagner Nutraceuticals, Inc.
(formed July 9, 2004). For the sake of simplicity, these entities will typically be referred to as Berkeley,
even in cases where Berkeley was not yet in existence.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 5
09-3176

Chief Operating Officer. Warshak also hired Shelley Kinmon to oversee the company’s
sales, later elevating her to the role of Vice-President. In 2002, Sue and Greg Cossman,
Warshak’s sister and brother-in-law, joined the company. Sue worked in Customer
Care, where she dealt with customer complaints. Greg came in as the President of the
company and thereafter functioned in various other capacities. That year also saw the
hiring of Sam Grote, who was brought on board to work in the marketing department.

To sell its products, Berkeley took orders over the phone, but it also made sales
through the mail and over the Internet. Customers purchased products with their credit
cards, and their credit-card numbers were entered into a database along with other
information. During sales calls, representatives would read from sales scripts,3 which
listed the major points to cover during the transaction. Shelley Kinmon testified that
Warshak had the final word on the content of the scripts. Often, the scripts would
include a description of the desired product, as well as language intended to persuade
more pliant customers to make additional purchases.

In the latter half of 2001, Berkeley launched Enzyte, its flagship product. At the
time of its launch, Enzyte was purported to increase the size of a man’s erection. The
product proved tremendously popular, and business rose sharply. By 2004, demand for
Berkeley’s products had grown so dramatically that the company employed 1500 people,
and the call center remained open throughout the night, taking orders at breakneck
speed. Berkeley’s line of supplements also expanded, ballooning from approximately
four products to around thirteen. By year’s end, Berkeley’s annual sales topped out at
around $250 million, largely on the strength of Enzyte.

1. Advertising

The popularity of Enzyte appears to have been due in large part to Berkeley’s
aggressive advertising campaigns. The vast majority of the advertising—approximately
98%—was conducted through television spots. Around 2004, network television was

3
Sales scripts were not employed at first.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 6
09-3176

saturated with Enzyte advertisements featuring a character called “Smilin’ Bob,” whose
trademark exaggerated smile was presumably the result of Enzyte’s efficacy. The
“Smilin’ Bob” commercials were rife with innuendo and implied that users of Enzyte
would become the envy of the neighborhood.

In addition to the television commercials, however, there were also
advertisements in other media, such as print and radio. In 2001, just after Enzyte’s
premiere, advertisements appeared in a number of men’s interest magazines. At
Warshak’s direction, those advertisements cited a 2001 independent customer study,
which purported to show that, over a three-month period, 100 English-speaking men
who took Enzyte experienced a 12 to 31% increase in the size of their penises. The 2001
study was also referenced in radio advertisements and appeared on the company’s
website, as well as in brochures and sales calls. James Teegarden later testified that the
survey was bogus. He stated that, prior to the appearance of the advertisements,
Warshak instructed him to create a spreadsheet and to fill it with fabricated data.
Teegarden testified that he plucked the numbers out of the air and generated the
spreadsheet over a twenty-four hour period.

A number of advertisements also indicated that Enzyte boasted a 96% customer
satisfaction rating. Teegarden testified that that statistic, too, was totally spurious.
Before the claim began showing up in Berkeley’s literature, Warshak had asked him to
harvest 500 names from the customer database and to “mark an ‘X’ by either satisfied
or very satisfied on say 475 of those.” As for the remaining 25, Teegarden “was to put
not satisfied.” Thereafter, the customer-satisfaction statistic cropped up in Berkeley’s
print advertisements and in the “sales pitches, brochures, [and on the] Internet.”

Finally, numerous print and radio advertisements boasted that Enzyte was the
brainchild of reputable doctors with impressive educational pedigrees. According to the
ads, “Enzyte was developed by Dr. Fredrick Thomkins, a physician with a biology
degree from Stanford and Dr. Michael Moore, a leading urologist from Harvard.” The
ads also stated that the doctors had collaborated for thirteen years in developing a
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 7
09-3176

supplement designed to “stretch and elongate.” In reality, the doctors were just as
fictitious as “Smilin’ Bob.” Investigators who contacted Stanford and Harvard learned
that neither man existed.

2. The Auto-Ship Program

The “life blood” of the business was its auto-ship program, which was instituted
in 2001, shortly before Enzyte hit the market.4 The auto-ship program was a continuity
or negative-option program, in which a customer would order a free trial of a product
and then continue to receive additional shipments of that product until he opted out.
Before each new continuity shipment arrived on the customer’s doorstep, a
corresponding charge would appear on his credit-card statement. The shipments and
charges would continue until the customer decided to withdraw from the program, which
required the customer to notify the company.

In the early days of the auto-ship program, customers who ordered products over
the phone were not told that they were being enrolled.5 From August 2001 to at least the
end of December 2002,6 customers were simply added to the program at the time of the
initial sale without any indication that they would be on the hook for additional charges.
Apparently, products were shipped with literature explaining the program, but no
authorization was sought in advance of the shipment. According to Teegarden, Warshak
explained that the auto-ship program was never mentioned because “nobody would sign
up.” If nobody signed up, “you couldn’t make revenue.”

This policy resulted in a substantial volume of complaints, both to Berkeley and
to outside organizations. In October 2002, the Better Business Bureau (“BBB”)
contacted Berkeley and indicated that more than 1,500 customers had called to voice

4
In an email, Warshak noted, “[W]e break even on everything else. [Auto-ship] is our profit. --
[I] cannot stress just how important it is that we get it right.”
5
Indeed, early sales scripts are entirely devoid of language indicating the existence of the auto-
ship program.
6
Shelley Kinmon testified that, with respect to Enzyte, there was no disclosure of the auto-ship
program in the sales scripts until September 23, 2003.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 8
09-3176

their consternation. Because of the complaints, Berkeley’s sales scripts and website
began to include some language disclosing the auto-ship program.7 A number of
internal emails indicate that sales representatives were required to read the disclosure
language and faced punishment if they failed to do so. To monitor the interactions
between representatives and customers, Berkeley installed a recording system for all
incoming calls.

However, as a number of Berkeley insiders testified, the compulsory disclosure
language was not always read, and it was designed not to work. Shelley Kinmon
testified that the disclosure of the continuity shipments was only made after the customer
had placed his order. In other words, the sales representative had already taken the
customer’s credit-card information when auto-ship was mentioned. Also, the disclosures
were deliberately made with haste, and they were placed after unrelated language that
was intended to divert or deaden the customer’s attention. In the case of Enzyte, sales
reps were instructed to lead into the disclosure language by stating that “the product is
not a contraceptive nor will it prevent or treat any sexually transmitted disease.”8
According to Teegarden, the thinking was that, “if we started off with a statement about
a contraceptive, something other than what it was, that people wouldn’t really listen to
what we were disclosing to them.”

7
The defendants also state that Berkeley hired “Venable [LLP], the most respected law firm in
the area of direct marketing, in April 2003, to review its scripts and reformulate its disclosures[.]” Reply
Br. at 6.
8
The disclosure portion of the September 23, 2003 sales script read, in full, as follows:
AFTER order is taken:
This product is not a contraceptive nor will it prevent any sexual disease. To let you
know that with your order you would be part of our established customer program [i.e.,
auto-ship]. approx. 10 days before your current supply runs out you would receive a
2 month supply for the price of $69.95 with free shipping and handling. There is no
obligation to remain on this program it is simple to discontinue, though it is a really
good deal. All the reorder info is written on the side of your bottle when you receive
your package, along with our phone number. So we will go ahead and process this
order and have it to you within the next 5-7 business days. Thank you, (customers [sic]
name), for your order today.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 9
09-3176

Moreover, disclosure of the auto-ship program was sometimes irrelevant. For
example, in November 2003, Berkeley hired a company called West to handle “sales
calls that were from . . . Avlimil or Enzyte advertisements.” During the calls, West’s
representatives asked customers if they wanted to be enrolled in the auto-ship program,
and over 80% of customers declined. When Warshak learned what was happening, he
issued instructions to “take those customers, even if they decline[d], even if they said no
to the Auto-Ship program, go ahead and put them on the Auto-Ship program.” A
subsequent email between Berkeley employees indicated that “all [West] customers,
whether they know it or not, are going on [auto-ship].” As a result, numerous telephone
orders resulted in unauthorized continuity shipments.

However, not all of Berkeley’s auto-ship issues related to the telephone. Many
Berkeley sales were the result of orders placed on the Internet, where disclosure of the
auto-ship program was inconsistent. In 2001, when Berkeley was in its infancy, the
company’s websites contained no indication that customers would be enrolled in the
program. Thereafter, disclosures were placed on the websites, but the disclosures would
“appear[], disappear[], and chang[e].” In 2003, for instance, disclosure language that
had been added to Berkeley’s Avlimil website was removed because sales had been
“drastically affected.” Additionally, the language that did appear was often confusing
and contained non sequiturs.

By July 2004, the complaints arising from Berkeley’s auto-ship program had not
slowed, so the President of the BBB reached out to Berkeley, sending a letter directly
to Warshak. The purpose of the letter was to express “serious concerns about the
number of complaints that [the BBB] had received.” The complaints “related to a single
issue, which was the [auto-ship] program.” According to the President of the BBB, the
organization “had asked on numerous occasions that [Berkeley] consider dropping [the
program], and got no positive response.”
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 10
09-3176

3. The Merchant Banks

In order for Berkeley’s business to operate, it was essential that the company be
able to accept credit cards as a form of payment.9 To process credit-card transactions,
Berkeley obtained lines of credit from several merchant banks. The relationships
between Berkeley and the merchant banks involved intermediaries known as credit-card
processors. Often, the processors had contractual agreements with the merchant banks,
and the processors were the ones who set up the credit-card processing arrangements
with Berkeley. Nonetheless, when Berkeley applied for a merchant account with a given
processor, the applications were passed along to the banks. Furthermore, either the
banks or the processors could terminate Berkeley’s merchant accounts.

In early 2002, Warshak’s merchant account at the Bank of Kentucky was
terminated for excessive “chargebacks.” A chargeback occurs when a customer calls the
credit card company directly and contests or disputes a charge. Merchant banks—and
credit-card processors—will generally not do business with merchants that experience
high volumes of chargebacks, as those merchants present a greater financial risk. In
determining whether a merchant is experiencing excessive chargebacks, the banks refer
to a figure known as the chargeback ratio, which is simply the percentage of transactions
in a given 30-day period that result in a chargeback. For example, if a company
conducts 100 credit-card transactions and one chargeback results, the company will have
a chargeback ratio of 1%. Typically, if a merchant experiences more than one
chargeback per hundred transactions, its chargeback ratio is deemed too high, resulting
in fines and, eventually, termination of its accounts, either by the merchant bank or the
credit-card processor.

Following the termination of the merchant account at the Bank of Kentucky, the
company applied for merchant accounts with a number of other banks. In some
instances, the applications, which often bore Harriet’s signature, falsely listed her as the

9
In the words of Greg Cossman, “without credit cards and the ability to charge them, there was
no business.”
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 11
09-3176

CEO and 100% owner of the company. In other instances, Warshak would complete the
applications in his own name but falsely claim that he had never had a merchant account
terminated. These prevarications were included in the applications because the prior
termination would likely diminish Berkeley’s chances of securing the services of other
processors.

Despite its history with the Bank of Kentucky, Berkeley was able to land (or
retain) merchant accounts with several processors. However, due to the auto-ship
program and an extremely onerous refund policy,10 Berkeley was repeatedly at risk of
crossing the critical 1% chargeback threshold.11 At company meetings, the chargeback
ratio was a frequent topic of discussion, as was the possibility that Berkeley’s accounts
would be terminated. To prevent that from happening, a number of strategies were
devised to artificially inflate the number of sales transactions and thus the denominator
of the chargeback ratio, reducing that crucial ratio. One strategy was called
“double-dinging.” That practice involved splitting a single transaction into two, thereby
driving up the number of transactions and diminishing the chargeback ratio. A
double-ding might entail carving a $59.95 charge into a $54.95 charge for the product
itself and a $5.00 charge for shipping. Warshak directed that virtually all sales be
double-dinged, and by 2003, triple-dinging was initiated.

Another way the company depressed the chargeback ratio was to make numerous
charges to Warshak’s personal credit cards. At Warshak’s behest, Berkeley employees
would ring up $1.00 charges on each of his credit cards until their limits were reached.

10
Apparently, Berkeley’s policy with respect to refunds was to “make it as difficult as possible.”
At one point, Enzyte customers seeking a refund were told they needed to obtain a notarized document
indicating that they had experienced “no size increase.” The admittedly ingenious idea behind the policy
was that nobody “would actually go and have anything notarized that said that they had a small penis.”
In 2002, “there was really no refund policy. It was: Sorry, you got it, you keep it, and we’ll cancel you
off of future shipments.” The defendants contend that this policy changed over time, suggesting that
everyone who was entitled to a refund got a refund. However, there was language on the Enzyte website
as late as 2006 indicating that “there are no refunds for orders once shipped.”
11
As Teegarden explained, the auto-ship program created a “problem because individuals, when
they didn’t know that they were getting charged, those individuals would try to call back in. They would
try to get a credit back on their credit cards. They either had a hard time getting through to us, or we would
deny them credit. And then they would have to go to their credit card companies and request a chargeback.
That, in turn, increased our chargeback rate.”
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 12
09-3176

Apparently, the thinking was that this torrent of additional transactions would dilute the
number of chargebacks and keep the ratio under 1%. The same thinking led the
company to charge and then refund the credit cards of randomly selected customers. The
charges were made without authorization, and if anyone complained about the odd
activity on his card, he was told that it was the result of a computer glitch. Through the
use of these techniques and others, the company was able to stave off termination of its
merchant-bank accounts.

B. Procedural History

In September 2006, a grand jury sitting in the Southern District of Ohio returned
a 112-count indictment charging Warshak, Harriet, TCI, and several others with various
crimes related to Berkeley’s business. Warshak was charged with conspiracy to commit
mail, wire, and bank fraud (Count 1); mail fraud (Counts 2-13); making false statements
to banks (Counts 14, 16-22, 24-26, 28); bank fraud (Counts 15, 23, 27); conspiracy to
commit and attempt to commit access-device fraud (Count 29); conspiracy to commit
money laundering (Count 34); money laundering (Counts 32-98, 102-106, 108);
conspiracy to commit misbranding (Count 109); misbranding (Count 110); and, lastly,
conspiracy to obstruct a Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) proceeding (Count 112).
Harriet was charged with conspiracy to commit mail, wire, and bank fraud (Count 1);
bank fraud (Count 27); making false statements to a bank (Count 28); conspiracy to
commit money laundering (Counts 30-31); and money laundering (Counts 99-101, 107).
TCI was charged with money laundering (Counts 57-58, 60-73, 79, 83, 91-93).

Before trial, numerous motions were filed. First, Warshak moved to exclude
thousands of emails that the government obtained from his Internet Service Providers.
That motion was denied. Warshak also moved to bar the government from using any
evidence “derived through improper access to privileged attorney-client
communications.” Appellant’s Br. at 42. Following a “Kastigar-like” evidentiary
hearing at which governmental inspectors testified that they did not make use of any
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 13
09-3176

privileged materials, the district court denied the motion. In addition, the defendants
requested a continuance, which was denied.

Over fifteen months later, in January 2008, the case proceeded to trial.
Approximately six weeks later, the trial ended and the defendants were convicted of the
majority of the charges. Warshak was acquitted of Counts 14-22, 24-26, and 28, which
charged him with making false statements to banks, and he was also acquitted of Counts
109-110, which charged him with misbranding offenses. Harriet was acquitted of Count
28, which alleged that she made false statements to a bank. She was convicted on
Counts 27, 30-31, 99-101, and 107.

As soon as the trial was over, a forfeiture hearing was held, during which the jury
heard additional evidence. At the hearing, the defendants attempted to introduce certain
evidence that many of Berkeley’s sales were legitimate, but the district court ruled that
the evidence was irrelevant. When the hearing concluded, the jury found that the
government had established the requisite nexus between certain assets and the crimes of
both fraud and money laundering.

On August 27, 2008, the defendants were sentenced. Warshak received a
sentence of 25 years of imprisonment. He was also ordered to pay a fine of $93,000 and
a special assessment of $9,300. In addition, he was ordered to surrender $459,540,000
in proceeds-money-judgment forfeiture and $44,876,781.68 in money-laundering-
judgment forfeiture. Harriet was sentenced to 24 months of imprisonment, ordered to
pay a special assessment of $800, and held jointly and severally liable for the forfeiture
judgments. TCI was sentenced to five years of probation and ordered to pay a fine of
$160,000 and a special assessment of $6,400.

Following a series of unsuccessful post-trial motions, the defendants timely
appealed.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 14
09-3176

II. ANALYSIS

A. The Search & Seizure of Warshak’s Emails

Warshak argues that the government’s warrantless, ex parte seizure of
approximately 27,000 of his private emails constituted a violation of the Fourth
Amendment’s prohibition on unreasonable searches and seizures.12 The government
counters that, even if government agents violated the Fourth Amendment in obtaining
the emails, they relied in good faith on the Stored Communications Act (“SCA”),
18 U.S.C. §§ 2701 et seq., a statute that allows the government to obtain certain
electronic communications without procuring a warrant. The government also argues
that any hypothetical Fourth Amendment violation was harmless. We find that the
government did violate Warshak’s Fourth Amendment rights by compelling his Internet
Service Provider (“ISP”) to turn over the contents of his emails. However, we agree that
agents relied on the SCA in good faith, and therefore hold that reversal is unwarranted.13

1. The Stored Communications Act

The Stored Communications Act (“SCA”), 18 U.S.C. §§ 2701 et seq., “permits
a ‘governmental entity’ to compel a service provider to disclose the contents of
[electronic] communications in certain circumstances.” Warshak II, 532 F.3d at 523.
As this court explained in Warshak II:

12
This is not the first time Warshak has raised this argument. In Warshak v. United States, 490
F.3d 455 (6th Cir. 2007) (“Warshak I”), a panel of this court determined that Warshak did indeed have a
privacy interest in the contents of his emails. That decision was vacated on ripeness grounds. See
Warshak v. United States, 532 F.3d 521 (6th Cir. 2008) (en banc) (“Warshak II”). In the present case,
Warshak’s claim is ripe for review.
13
Though we may surely do so, we decline to limit our inquiry to the issue of good-faith reliance.
See Pearson v. Callahan, 129 S. Ct. 808, 818 (2009). If every court confronted with a novel Fourth
Amendment question were to skip directly to good faith, the government would be given carte blanche
to violate constitutionally protected privacy rights, provided, of course, that a statute supposedly permits
them to do so. The doctrine of good-faith reliance should not be a perpetual shield against the
consequences of constitutional violations. In other words, if the exclusionary rule is to have any bite,
courts must, from time to time, decide whether statutorily sanctioned conduct oversteps constitutional
boundaries. See id. at 816 (noting that repeated avoidance of constitutional questions leads to
“constitutional stagnation” (citing Saucier v. Katz, 533 U.S. 194, 201 (2001))).
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 15
09-3176

Three relevant definitions bear on the meaning of the
compelled-disclosure provisions of the Act. “[E]lectronic communication
service[s]” permit “users . . . to send or receive wire or electronic
communications,” [18 U.S.C.] § 2510(15), a definition that covers basic
e-mail services, see Patricia L. Bellia et al., Cyberlaw: Problems of
Policy and Jurisprudence in the Information Age 584 (2d ed. 2004).
“[E]lectronic storage” is “any temporary, intermediate storage of a wire
or electronic communication . . . and . . . any storage of such
communication by an electronic communication service for purposes of
backup protection of such communication.” 18 U.S.C. § 2510(17).
“[R]emote computing service[s]” provide “computer storage or
processing services” to customers, id. § 2711(2), and are designed for
longer-term storage, see Orin S. Kerr, A User’s Guide to the Stored
Communications Act, and a Legislator’s Guide to Amending It, 72 Geo.
Wash. L. Rev. 1208, 1216 (2004).
The compelled-disclosure provisions give different levels of privacy
protection based on whether the e-mail is held with an electronic
communication service or a remote computing service and based on how
long the e-mail has been in electronic storage. The government may
obtain the contents of e-mails that are “in electronic storage” with an
electronic communication service for 180 days or less “only pursuant to
a warrant.” 18 U.S.C. § 2703(a). The government has three options for
obtaining communications stored with a remote computing service and
communications that have been in electronic storage with an electronic
service provider for more than 180 days: (1) obtain a warrant; (2) use an
administrative subpoena; or (3) obtain a court order under § 2703(d). Id.
§ 2703(a), (b).

532 F.3d at 523-24 (some alterations in original).

2. Factual Background

Email was a critical form of communication among Berkeley personnel. As a
consequence, Warshak had a number of email accounts with various ISPs, including an
account with NuVox Communications. In October 2004, the government formally
requested that NuVox prospectively preserve the contents of any emails to or from
Warshak’s email account. The request was made pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 2703(f) and
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 16
09-3176

it instructed NuVox to preserve all future messages.14 NuVox acceded to the
government’s request and began preserving copies of Warshak’s incoming and outgoing
emails—copies that would not have existed absent the prospective preservation request.
Per the government’s instructions, Warshak was not informed that his messages were
being archived.

In January 2005, the government obtained a subpoena under § 2703(b) and
compelled NuVox to turn over the emails that it had begun preserving the previous year.
In May 2005, the government served NuVox with an ex parte court order under
§ 2703(d) that required NuVox to surrender any additional email messages in Warshak’s
account. In all, the government compelled NuVox to reveal the contents of
approximately 27,000 emails. Warshak did not receive notice of either the subpoena or
the order until May 2006.

3. The Fourth Amendment

The Fourth Amendment provides that “[t]he right of the people to be secure in
their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures,
shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause . . . .” U.S.
CONST. amend. IV. The fundamental purpose of the Fourth Amendment “is to safeguard
the privacy and security of individuals against arbitrary invasions by government
officials.” Camara v. Mun. Ct., 387 U.S. 523, 528 (1967); see Skinner v. Ry. Labor
Execs.’Ass’n, 489 U.S. 602, 613-14 (1989) (“The [Fourth] Amendment guarantees the
privacy, dignity, and security of persons against certain arbitrary and invasive acts by
officers of the Government or those acting at their direction.”).

Not all government actions are invasive enough to implicate the Fourth
Amendment. “The Fourth Amendment’s protections hinge on the occurrence of a
‘search,’ a legal term of art whose history is riddled with complexity.” Widgren v.

14
Warshak appears to have accessed emails from his NuVox account via POP, or “Post Office
Protocol.” When POP is utilized, emails are downloaded to the user’s personal computer and generally
deleted from the ISP’s server.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 17
09-3176

Maple Grove Twp., 429 F.3d 575, 578 (6th Cir. 2005). A “search” occurs when the
government infringes upon “an expectation of privacy that society is prepared to
consider reasonable.” United States v. Jacobsen, 466 U.S. 109, 113 (1984). This
standard breaks down into two discrete inquiries: “first, has the [target of the
investigation] manifested a subjective expectation of privacy in the object of the
challenged search? Second, is society willing to recognize that expectation as
reasonable?” California v. Ciraolo, 476 U.S. 207, 211 (1986) (citing Smith v. Maryland,
442 U.S. 735, 740 (1979)).

Turning first to the subjective component of the test, we find that Warshak
plainly manifested an expectation that his emails would be shielded from outside
scrutiny. As he notes in his brief, his “entire business and personal life was contained
within the . . . emails seized.” Appellant’s Br. at 39-40. Given the often sensitive and
sometimes damning substance of his emails,15 we think it highly unlikely that Warshak
expected them to be made public, for people seldom unfurl their dirty laundry in plain
view. See, e.g., United States v. Maxwell, 45 M.J. 406, 417 (C.A.A.F. 1996) (“[T]he
tenor and content of e-mail conversations between appellant and his correspondent,
‘Launchboy,’ reveal a[n] . . . expectation that the conversations were private.”).
Therefore, we conclude that Warshak had a subjective expectation of privacy in the
contents of his emails.

The next question is whether society is prepared to recognize that expectation as
reasonable. See Smith, 442 U.S. at 740. This question is one of grave import and
enduring consequence, given the prominent role that email has assumed in modern
communication. Cf. Katz, 389 U.S. at 352 (suggesting that the Constitution must be
read to account for “the vital role that the public telephone has come to play in private
communication”). Since the advent of email, the telephone call and the letter have
waned in importance, and an explosion of Internet-based communication has taken
place. People are now able to send sensitive and intimate information, instantaneously,

15
In a number of the NuVox emails, Warshak discussed the creation of trusts for his children, as
well as the possibility that his financial dealings would mislead FTC investigators.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 18
09-3176

to friends, family, and colleagues half a world away. Lovers exchange sweet nothings,
and businessmen swap ambitious plans, all with the click of a mouse button. Commerce
has also taken hold in email. Online purchases are often documented in email accounts,
and email is frequently used to remind patients and clients of imminent appointments.
In short, “account” is an apt word for the conglomeration of stored messages that
comprises an email account, as it provides an account of its owner’s life. By obtaining
access to someone’s email, government agents gain the ability to peer deeply into his
activities. Much hinges, therefore, on whether the government is permitted to request
that a commercial ISP turn over the contents of a subscriber’s emails without triggering
the machinery of the Fourth Amendment.

In confronting this question, we take note of two bedrock principles. First, the
very fact that information is being passed through a communications network is a
paramount Fourth Amendment consideration. See ibid.; United States v. U. S. Dist.
Court, 407 U.S. 297, 313 (1972) (“[T]he broad and unsuspected governmental incursions
into conversational privacy which electronic surveillance entails necessitate the
application of Fourth Amendment safeguards.”). Second, the Fourth Amendment must
keep pace with the inexorable march of technological progress, or its guarantees will
wither and perish. See Kyllo v. United States, 533 U.S. 27, 34 (2001) (noting that
evolving technology must not be permitted to “erode the privacy guaranteed by the
Fourth Amendment”); see also Orin S. Kerr, Applying the Fourth Amendment to the
Internet: A General Approach, 62 Stan. L. Rev. 1005, 1007 (2010) (arguing that “the
differences between the facts of physical space and the facts of the Internet require
courts to identify new Fourth Amendment distinctions to maintain the function of Fourth
Amendment rules in an online environment”).

With those principles in mind, we begin our analysis by considering the manner
in which the Fourth Amendment protects traditional forms of communication. In Katz,
the Supreme Court was asked to determine how the Fourth Amendment applied in the
context of the telephone. There, government agents had affixed an electronic listening
device to the exterior of a public phone booth, and had used the device to intercept and
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 19
09-3176

record several phone conversations. See 389 U.S. at 348. The Supreme Court held that
this constituted a search under the Fourth Amendment, see id. at 353, notwithstanding
the fact that the telephone company had the capacity to monitor and record the calls, see
Smith, 442 U.S. at 746-47 (Stewart, J., dissenting). In the eyes of the Court, the caller
was “surely entitled to assume that the words he utter[ed] into the mouthpiece w[ould]
not be broadcast to the world.” Katz, 389 U.S. at 352. The Court’s holding in Katz has
since come to stand for the broad proposition that, in many contexts, the government
infringes a reasonable expectation of privacy when it surreptitiously intercepts a
telephone call through electronic means. Smith, 442 U.S. at 746 (Stewart, J., dissenting)
(“[S]ince Katz, it has been abundantly clear that telephone conversations are fully
protected by the Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments.”).

Letters receive similar protection. See Jacobsen, 466 U.S. at 114 (“Letters and
other sealed packages are in the general class of effects in which the public at large has
a legitimate expectation of privacy[.]”); Ex Parte Jackson, 96 U.S. 727, 733 (1877).
While a letter is in the mail, the police may not intercept it and examine its contents
unless they first obtain a warrant based on probable cause. Ibid. This is true despite the
fact that sealed letters are handed over to perhaps dozens of mail carriers, any one of
whom could tear open the thin paper envelopes that separate the private words from the
world outside. Put another way, trusting a letter to an intermediary does not necessarily
defeat a reasonable expectation that the letter will remain private. See Katz, 389 U.S.
at 351 (“[W]hat [a person] seeks to preserve as private, even in an area accessible to the
public, may be constitutionally protected.”).

Given the fundamental similarities between email and traditional forms of
communication, it would defy common sense to afford emails lesser Fourth Amendment
protection. See Patricia L. Bellia & Susan Freiwald, Fourth Amendment Protection for
Stored E-Mail, 2008 U. Chi. Legal F. 121, 135 (2008) (recognizing the need to
“eliminate the strangely disparate treatment of mailed and telephonic communications
on the one hand and electronic communications on the other”); City of Ontario v. Quon,
130 S. Ct. 2619, 2631 (2010) (implying that “a search of [an individual’s] personal e-
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 20
09-3176

mail account” would be just as intrusive as “a wiretap on his home phone line”); United
States v. Forrester, 512 F.3d 500, 511 (9th Cir. 2008) (holding that “[t]he privacy
interests in [mail and email] are identical”). Email is the technological scion of tangible
mail, and it plays an indispensable part in the Information Age. Over the last decade,
email has become “so pervasive that some persons may consider [it] to be [an] essential
means or necessary instrument[] for self-expression, even self-identification.” Quon,
130 S. Ct. at 2630. It follows that email requires strong protection under the Fourth
Amendment; otherwise, the Fourth Amendment would prove an ineffective guardian of
private communication, an essential purpose it has long been recognized to serve. See
U.S. Dist. Court, 407 U.S. at 313; United States v. Waller, 581 F.2d 585, 587 (6th Cir.
1978) (noting the Fourth Amendment’s role in protecting “private communications”).
As some forms of communication begin to diminish, the Fourth Amendment must
recognize and protect nascent ones that arise. See Warshak I, 490 F.3d at 473 (“It goes
without saying that like the telephone earlier in our history, e-mail is an ever-increasing
mode of private communication, and protecting shared communications through this
medium is as important to Fourth Amendment principles today as protecting telephone
conversations has been in the past.”).

If we accept that an email is analogous to a letter or a phone call, it is manifest
that agents of the government cannot compel a commercial ISP to turn over the contents
of an email without triggering the Fourth Amendment. An ISP is the intermediary that
makes email communication possible. Emails must pass through an ISP’s servers to
reach their intended recipient. Thus, the ISP is the functional equivalent of a post office
or a telephone company. As we have discussed above, the police may not storm the post
office and intercept a letter, and they are likewise forbidden from using the phone system
to make a clandestine recording of a telephone call—unless they get a warrant, that is.
See Jacobsen, 466 U.S. at 114; Katz, 389 U.S. at 353. It only stands to reason that, if
government agents compel an ISP to surrender the contents of a subscriber’s emails,
those agents have thereby conducted a Fourth Amendment search, which necessitates
compliance with the warrant requirement absent some exception.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 21
09-3176

In Warshak I, the government argued that this conclusion was improper, pointing
to the fact that NuVox contractually reserved the right to access Warshak’s emails for
certain purposes. While we acknowledge that a subscriber agreement might, in some
cases, be sweeping enough to defeat a reasonable expectation of privacy in the contents
of an email account, see Warshak I, 490 F.3d at 473; Warshak II, 532 F.3d at 526-27, we
doubt that will be the case in most situations, and it is certainly not the case here.

As an initial matter, it must be observed that the mere ability of a third-party
intermediary to access the contents of a communication cannot be sufficient to
extinguish a reasonable expectation of privacy. In Katz, the Supreme Court found it
reasonable to expect privacy during a telephone call despite the ability of an operator to
listen in. See Smith, 442 U.S. at 746-47 (Stewart, J., dissenting). Similarly, the ability
of a rogue mail handler to rip open a letter does not make it unreasonable to assume that
sealed mail will remain private on its journey across the country. Therefore, the threat
or possibility of access is not decisive when it comes to the reasonableness of an
expectation of privacy.

Nor is the right of access. As the Electronic Frontier Foundation points out in
its amicus brief, at the time Katz was decided, telephone companies had a right to
monitor calls in certain situations. Specifically, telephone companies could listen in
when reasonably necessary to “protect themselves and their properties against the
improper and illegal use of their facilities.” Bubis v. United States, 384 F.2d 643, 648
(9th Cir. 1967). In this case, the NuVox subscriber agreement tracks that language,
indicating that “NuVox may access and use individual Subscriber information in the
operation of the Service and as necessary to protect the Service.” Acceptable Use
Policy, available at http://business.windstream.com/Legal/acceptableUse.htm (last
visited Aug. 12, 2010). Thus, under Katz, the degree of access granted to NuVox does
not diminish the reasonableness of Warshak’s trust in the privacy of his emails.16

16
We note that the access granted to NuVox was also temporally limited, as Warshak’s email
account was configured to delete his emails from NuVox’s servers as soon as he opened them on his
personal computer. See Appellant’s Br. at 28 (“NuVox did not even save copies of account holders’
received emails once they had been opened and downloaded to the account holders’ computers[.]”).
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 22
09-3176

Our conclusion finds additional support in the application of Fourth Amendment
doctrine to rented space. Hotel guests, for example, have a reasonable expectation of
privacy in their rooms. See United States v. Allen, 106 F.3d 695, 699 (6th Cir. 1997).
This is so even though maids routinely enter hotel rooms to replace the towels and tidy
the furniture. Similarly, tenants have a legitimate expectation of privacy in their
apartments. See United States v. Washington, 573 F.3d 279, 284 (6th Cir. 2009). That
expectation persists, regardless of the incursions of handymen to fix leaky faucets.
Consequently, we are convinced that some degree of routine access is hardly dispositive
with respect to the privacy question.

Again, however, we are unwilling to hold that a subscriber agreement will never
be broad enough to snuff out a reasonable expectation of privacy. As the panel noted
in Warshak I, if the ISP expresses an intention to “audit, inspect, and monitor” its
subscriber’s emails, that might be enough to render an expectation of privacy
unreasonable. See 490 F.3d at 472-73 (quoting United States v. Simons, 206 F.3d 392,
398 (4th Cir. 2000)). But where, as here, there is no such statement, the ISP’s “control
over the [emails] and ability to access them under certain limited circumstances will not
be enough to overcome an expectation of privacy.” Id. at 473.

We recognize that our conclusion may be attacked in light of the Supreme
Court’s decision in United States v. Miller, 425 U.S. 435 (1976). In Miller, the Supreme
Court held that a bank depositor does not have a reasonable expectation of privacy in the
contents of bank records, checks, and deposit slips. Id. at 442. The Court’s holding in
Miller was based on the fact that bank documents, “including financial statements and
deposit slips, contain only information voluntarily conveyed to the banks and exposed
to their employees in the ordinary course of business.” Ibid. The Court noted,

The depositor takes the risk, in revealing his affairs to another, that the
information will be conveyed by that person to the Government. . . .[T]he
Fourth Amendment does not prohibit the obtaining of information
revealed to a third party and conveyed by him to Government authorities,
even if the information is revealed on the assumption that it will be used
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 23
09-3176

only for a limited purpose and the confidence placed in the third party
will not be betrayed.

Id. at 443 (citations omitted).

But Miller is distinguishable. First, Miller involved simple business records, as
opposed to the potentially unlimited variety of “confidential communications” at issue
here. See ibid. Second, the bank depositor in Miller conveyed information to the bank
so that the bank could put the information to use “in the ordinary course of business.”
Ibid. By contrast, Warshak received his emails through NuVox. NuVox was an
intermediary, not the intended recipient of the emails. See Bellia & Freiwald, Stored E-
Mail, 2008 U. Chi. Legal F. at 165 (“[W]e view the best analogy for this scenario as the
cases in which a third party carries, transports, or stores property for another. In these
cases, as in the stored e-mail case, the customer grants access to the ISP because it is
essential to the customer’s interests.”). Thus, Miller is not controlling.

Accordingly, we hold that a subscriber enjoys a reasonable expectation of
privacy in the contents of emails “that are stored with, or sent or received through, a
commercial ISP.” Warshak I, 490 F.3d at 473; see Forrester, 512 F.3d at 511
(suggesting that “[t]he contents [of email messages] may deserve Fourth Amendment
protection”). The government may not compel a commercial ISP to turn over the
contents of a subscriber’s emails without first obtaining a warrant based on probable
cause. Therefore, because they did not obtain a warrant, the government agents violated
the Fourth Amendment when they obtained the contents of Warshak’s emails.
Moreover, to the extent that the SCA purports to permit the government to obtain such
emails warrantlessly, the SCA is unconstitutional.

4. Good-Faith Reliance

Even though the government’s search of Warshak’s emails violated the Fourth
Amendment, the emails are not subject to the exclusionary remedy if the officers relied
in good faith on the SCA to obtain them. See Krull, 480 U.S. at 349-50. In Krull, the
Supreme Court noted that the exclusionary rule’s purpose of deterring law enforcement
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 24
09-3176

officers from engaging in unconstitutional conduct would not be furthered by holding
officers accountable for mistakes of the legislature. Ibid. Thus, even if a statute is later
found to be unconstitutional, an officer “cannot be expected to question the judgment of
the legislature.” Ibid. However, an officer cannot “be said to have acted in good-faith
reliance upon a statute if its provisions are such that a reasonable officer should have
known that the statute was unconstitutional.” Id. at 355.

Naturally, Warshak argues that the provisions of the SCA at issue in this case
were plainly unconstitutional. He argues that any reasonable law enforcement officer
would have understood that a warrant based on probable cause would be required to
compel the production of private emails. In making this argument, he leans heavily on
Warshak I, which opined that the SCA permits agents to engage in searches “that clearly
do not comport with the Fourth Amendment.” 490 F.3d at 477.

However, we disagree that the SCA is so conspicuously unconstitutional as to
preclude good-faith reliance. As we noted in Warshak II, “[t]he Stored Communications
Act has been in existence since 1986 and to our knowledge has not been the subject of
any successful Fourth Amendment challenges, in any context, whether to § 2703(d) or
to any other provision.” 532 F.3d at 531. Furthermore, given the complicated thicket
of issues that we were required to navigate when passing on the constitutionality of the
SCA, it was not plain or obvious that the SCA was unconstitutional, and it was therefore
reasonable for the government to rely upon the SCA in seeking to obtain the contents of
Warshak’s emails.17

But the good-faith reliance inquiry does not end with the facial validity of the
statute at issue. In Krull, the Supreme Court hinted that the good-faith exception does
not apply if the government acted “outside the scope of the statute” on which it
purported to rely. 480 U.S. at 360 n.17. It should be noted that this portion of the Krull
Court’s opinion was merely dicta, and it appears that we have yet to pass on the

17
Of course, after today’s decision, the good-faith calculus has changed, and a reasonable officer
may no longer assume that the Constitution permits warrantless searches of private emails.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 25
09-3176

question. However, it seems evident that an officer’s failure to adhere to the boundaries
of a given statute should preclude him from relying upon it in the face of a constitutional
challenge.18 Once the officer steps outside the scope of an unconstitutional statute, the
mistake is no longer the legislature’s, but the officer’s. See ibid. (“In that context, the
relevant actors are not legislators or magistrates, but police officers who concededly are
engaged in the often competitive enterprise of ferreting out crime.” (citation and internal
quotation marks omitted)). Therefore, use of the exclusionary rule is once again
efficacious in deterring officers from engaging in conduct that violates the Constitution.
Ibid.

Warshak argues that the government violated several provisions of the SCA and
should therefore be precluded from arguing good-faith reliance. First, Warshak argues
that the government violated the SCA’s notice provisions. Under § 2703(b)(1)(B), the
government must provide notice to an account holder if it seeks to compel the disclosure
of his emails through either a § 2703(b) subpoena or a § 2703(d) order. However,
§ 2705 permits the government to delay notification in certain situations. The initial
period of delay is 90 days, but the government may seek to extend that period in 90-day
increments. In this case, the government issued both a § 2703(b) subpoena and a
§ 2703(d) order to NuVox, seeking disclosure of Warshak’s emails. At the time, the
government made the requisite showing that notice should be delayed. However, the
government did not seek to renew the period of delay. In all, the government failed to
inform Warshak of either the subpoena or the order for over a year.

Conceding that it violated the notice provisions, the government argues that such
violations are irrelevant to the issue of whether it reasonably relied on the SCA in
obtaining the contents of Warshak’s emails. We agree. As the government notes, the
violations occurred after the emails had been obtained. Thus, the mistakes at issue had

18
At least one court has translated this inquiry into the context of qualified immunity. In Roska
ex rel. Roska v. Sneddon, 437 F.3d 964 (10th Cir. 2006), the Tenth Circuit considered whether an officer’s
alleged reliance on a state statute rendered his conduct objectively reasonable. The court held that, in
determining whether such reliance had occurred, one fact to consider was “whether the official in fact
complied with the statute.” Id. at 971.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 26
09-3176

no bearing on the constitutional violations. Because the exclusionary rule was designed
to deter constitutional violations, we decline to invoke it in this situation.

But Warshak does not hang his hat exclusively on the government’s violations
of the SCA’s notice provisions. He also argues that the government exceeded its
authority under another SCA provision—§ 2703(f)—by requesting NuVox to engage in
prospective preservation of his future emails.19 Under § 2703(f), “[a] provider of wire
or electronic communication services or a remote computing service, upon the request
of a governmental entity, shall take all necessary steps to preserve records and other
evidence in its possession pending the issuance of a court order or other process.”
18 U.S.C. § 2703(f) (emphasis added). Warshak argues that this statute permits only
retrospective preservation—in other words, preservation of emails already in existence.
He notes that the Department of Justice (“DOJ”) generally agrees with his construction
of the statute, pointing to the DOJ’s own computer-surveillance manual, which states:
“[Section] 2703(f) letters should not be used prospectively to order providers to preserve
records not yet created. If agents want providers to record information about future
electronic communications, they should comply with the [Wiretap Act and the Pen/Trap
statute].”20

Ultimately, however, this statutory violation, whether it occurred or not,21 is
irrelevant to the issue of good-faith reliance. The question here is whether the
government relied in good faith on § 2703(b) and § 2703(d) to obtain copies of

19
It appears that, below, Warshak argued that the preservation request was itself a violation of
the Fourth Amendment. He does not renew that argument on appeal, and it is therefore waived. See
Robinson v. Jones, 142 F.3d 905, 906 (6th Cir. 1998) (“Issues which were raised in the district court, yet
not raised on appeal, are considered abandoned and not reviewable on appeal.”).
20
Warshak also argues that the government’s § 2703(f) request for prospective preservation of
his emails was a violation of the Wiretap Act. However, the government does not plead reliance on the
Wiretap Act to justify its actions. Thus, this argument is immaterial.
21
Some courts and commentators have suggested that § 2703(f) applies only retroactively. See,
e.g., Deirdre K. Mulligan, Reasonable Expectations in Electronic Communications: A Critical Perspective
on the Electronic Communications Privacy Act, 72 Geo. Wash. L. Rev. 1557, 1565 (2004) (“The Wiretap
Act and Pen Register statute regulate prospective surveillance of Internet communications
(communications “in transit”), and the SCA governs retrospective surveillance (stored communications).”).
However, the language of the statute, on its face, does not compel this reading.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 27
09-3176

Warshak’s emails. True, the government might not have been able to gain access to the
emails without the prospective preservation request, as it was NuVox’s practice to delete
all emails once they were downloaded to the account holder’s computer. Thus, in a
sense, the government’s use of § 2703(f) was a but-for cause of the constitutional
violation. But the actual violation at issue was obtaining the emails, and the government
did not rely on § 2703(f) specifically to do that. Instead, the government relied on
§ 2703(b) and § 2703(d). The proper inquiry, therefore, is whether the government
violated either of those provisions, and the preservation request is of no consequence to
that inquiry.

Warshak’s next argument is that the government violated § 2703(d) by failing
to provide any particularized factual basis when seeking an order for disclosure. Under
§ 2703(d), such an order “shall issue only if the governmental entity offers specific and
articulable facts showing that there are reasonable grounds to believe that the contents
of a wire or electronic communication . . . are relevant and material to an ongoing
criminal investigation.”

To the extent that he is arguing that the government’s application was
insufficient, Warshak is wrong. The government’s application indicated that it was
“investigating a complex, large-scale mail and wire fraud operation based in Cincinnati,
Ohio.” The application also indicated that “interviews of current and former employees
of the target company suggest that electronic mail is a vital communication tool that has
been used to perpetuate the fraudulent conduct.” Additionally, the application observed
that “various sources [have verified] that NuVox provides electronic communications
services to certain individual(s) [under] investigation.” In light of these statements, it
is clear that the application was, in fact, supported by specific and articulable facts,
especially given the diminished standard that applies to § 2703(d) applications. See
United States v. Perrine, 518 F.3d 1196, 1202 (10th Cir. 2008) (noting that “the ‘specific
and articulable facts’ standard derives from the Supreme Court’s decision in Terry”);
Warshak I, 490 F.3d at 463 (“The parties agree that the standard of proof for a court
order—‘specific and articulable facts showing that there are reasonable grounds to
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 28
09-3176

believe that the contents . . . or records . . . are relevant and material to an ongoing
criminal investigation’—falls short of probable cause.”).

Finally, Warshak argues that a finding of good-faith reliance is improper because
the government presented the magistrate with an erroneous definition of the term
“electronic storage.” As noted above, if an email is in electronic storage for less than
180 days, the government may not compel its disclosure without a warrant. 18 U.S.C.
§ 2703(a). In applying for the subpoena and the order that eventually resulted in the
disclosure of Warshak’s NuVox emails, the government suggested to the magistrate that
an email is not in electronic storage if it has already been “accessed, viewed, or
downloaded.” Warshak argues that this definition of electronic storage does not comport
with the Ninth Circuit’s decision in Theofel v. Farey-Jones, 359 F.3d 1066, 1071 (9th
Cir. 2004), which held that “prior access is irrelevant to whether the [emails] at issue
were in electronic storage.” Warshak further argues that, because the government failed
to mention the Ninth Circuit’s definition, it “usurped the court’s function to determine
whether an email . . . [is] in ‘electronic storage[.]’” Appellant’s Br. at 38.

As an initial matter, it is manifest that the decisions of the Ninth Circuit are not
binding on courts in this circuit. It therefore cannot be said that the government
somehow violated § 2703 by failing to cite an out-of-circuit decision that it thought to
be wrongly decided. Incidentally, the government is not alone in thinking that the Ninth
Circuit’s definition of electronic storage is incorrect. One commentator has noted that
“Theofel is quite implausible and hard to square with the statutory test.” Kerr, A User’s
Guide to the Stored Communications Act, 72 Geo. Wash. L. Rev. at 1217; see also
United States v. Weaver, 636 F. Supp. 2d 769, 773 (C.D. Ill. 2009) (“Previously opened
emails stored by Microsoft for Hotmail users are not in electronic storage, and the
Government can obtain copies of such emails using a trial subpoena.”).

Furthermore, it does a disservice to the magistrate judge to suggest that the
government usurped the role of the court. The government’s application did include a
proposed definition of the term “electronic storage.” That does not mean, however, that
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 29
09-3176

the magistrate judge unhesitatingly received that definition, and, as the government
notes, the magistrate “presumably [had] the opportunity to consider and review relevant
precedent.” Appellee’s Br. at 117.

Consequently, we find that, although the government violated the Fourth
Amendment, the exclusionary rule does not apply, as the government relied in good faith
on § 2703(b) and § 2703(d) to access the contents of Warshak’s emails.22

B. The Kastigar-Like Hearing

1. Background

During the government’s investigation of Berkeley, case agents came into
possession of myriad documents that were ostensibly subject to the attorney-client
privilege. Many of the documents were obtained during a March 16, 2005 search of
Berkeley’s headquarters, in which agents copied the contents of over 90 computers.
Other documents were procured earlier through the subpoena and court order issued to
NuVox, which granted investigators access to the contents of Warshak’s email accounts.
In all, case agents had access to approximately “60,000 email communications from or
to attorneys representing Berkeley and Warshak, communications facially and
presumptively protected by the attorney-client privilege.” Appellant’s Br. at 41.

On July 5, 2007, Warshak filed a “motion to bar the government from using the
evidence obtained in violation of the defendants’ attorney-client and work product
privileges and to dismiss the indictment since privileged material was used to secure it.”
United States v. Warshak, No. 1:06-CR-00111, 2007 WL 3306603, at *1 (S.D. Ohio
Nov. 5, 2007). In the motion, the defendants requested that the district court hold a
hearing “in the framework of Kastigar v. United States, 406 U.S. 441 (1972), at which

22
In addition, we note that the Fourth Amendment violation was likely harmless. See United
States v. Carnes, 309 F.3d 950, 963 (6th Cir. 2002) (noting that a Fourth Amendment violation does not
warrant reversal if the violation was harmless). The NuVox emails did not play a role in obtaining the
search warrant that produced the overwhelming majority of the evidence in this case. In addition, only
three of the emails were introduced at trial, and they were largely cumulative of the testimony of William
Bertemes, Warshak’s accountant. See Bradley v. Cowan, 561 F.2d 1213, 1217 (6th Cir. 1977) (noting that
the impact of “purely cumulative” evidence is often minimal).
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 30
09-3176

the government would bear the burden of establishing that its case was untainted by
attorney-client and work product privileged materials.” Warshak, 2007 WL 3306603,
at *1. To an extent, the district court granted the motion, setting a “Kastigar-like”
hearing with the “narrow purpose of eliciting the sworn testimony of government agents
as to their handling of evidence.” Ibid. In ordering the hearing, the district court “found
that [the] [d]efendants had raised enough of a question about the amount of time U.S.
Postal Inspector Alejandro Almaguer (‘Almaguer’) possessed privileged data, as well
as the government’s methodology in screening data for privileged information, to merit
a response.” Ibid.

The hearing was held on September 27 and 28, 2007. During the hearing, “the
government proffered evidence and the testimony of Almaguer, the [d]efendants were
afforded [an] opportunity to cross-examine Almaguer and examine other agents on
direct, and the parties argued their respective positions concerning the propriety of the
government action in this case.” Ibid. In addition, the defendants called Peter
Horstmann, an expert witness “who used software to analyze the electronic documents
the government produced to [the] [d]efendants.” Ibid.

After the hearing, the district court held that the government had satisfied its
burden, stating as follows:

The [c]ourt’s original concerns that triggered the grant of the
“Kastigar-like” evidentiary hearing were rooted in the amount of time
that Almaguer allegedly had access to privileged materials, and in the
fact the government had proffered no sworn statements backing its
contention that it did not use privileged materials to obtain witness
proffers. The government has completely allayed the [c]ourt’s concerns.
The United States has met its burden to demonstrate its agents have acted
properly and that its case is untainted by privileged information.

Id. at *8.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 31
09-3176

2. The Adequacy of the Government’s Presentation

Warshak argues that the Kastigar-like hearing was inadequate. More precisely,
he argues that the district court failed to “hold[] the government to the burden prescribed
by Kastigar and subsequent cases applying it.” Appellant’s Br. at 48. He complains that
the district court “simply accepted the government’s blanket denials that it used
privileged materials in preparing its case against defendants, and shifted the burden to
[him] to show that privileged materials contributed to the return of the indictment.” Ibid.
(internal citations omitted). In short, he argues that the district court improperly
loosened the stringent demands of Kastigar.

In Kastigar, the Supreme Court held that when a witness is compelled to give
incriminating testimony under a grant of statutory immunity and is thereafter prosecuted
for any matter related to the compelled testimony, the government must shoulder the
“heavy burden of proving that all of the evidence it proposes to use was derived from
legitimate independent sources.” 406 U.S. at 461-62; see also United States v. Turner,
936 F.2d 221, 224 (6th Cir. 1991). “This burden of proof . . . is not limited to a negation
of taint; rather, it imposes on the prosecution the affirmative duty to prove that the
evidence it proposes to use is derived from a legitimate source wholly independent of
the compelled testimony.” Kastigar, 406 U.S. at 460.

While Kastigar is clearly concerned with the use of testimony obtained despite
an assertion of the Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination, this court has
suggested that Kastigar concerns may arise in the context of other privileges, such as the
privilege accorded to attorney-client communications. Specifically, this court has
hinted, in dicta, that “the leaking of privileged materials to investigators would raise the
spectre of Kastigar-like evidentiary hearings.” In re Grand Jury Subpoenas, 454 F.3d
511, 517 (6th Cir. 2006). However, no other appellate court appears to have joined us
in suggesting that Kastigar is implicated whenever investigators come into possession
of materials subject to the attorney-client privilege.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 32
09-3176

One circuit, the Fourth, has engaged in a fairly lengthy analysis of Kastigar’s
applicability in the arena of non-constitutional privileges. In United States v.
Squillacote, 221 F.3d 542 (4th Cir. 2000), the Fourth Circuit was faced with a scenario
in which government investigators had legally conducted electronic surveillance on
several defendants pursuant to the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act.23 During the
surveillance, the agents heard and recorded a number of conversations between one of
the defendants and her psychotherapists. Subsequently, the defendants “moved to
suppress any evidence derived from the privileged communications,” arguing that “they
were entitled to a hearing to vindicate the principles set forth by the Supreme Court in
[Kastigar].” Id. at 558. Ultimately, the court determined that Kastigar was “simply . . .
not applicable.” Ibid.

In so holding, the Squillacote court began by conceding that the conversations
at issue, which the government had obtained during surveillance, were privileged.
According to the court, “[t]he question, then, [was] whether the mere existence of this
privileged information br[ought] to bear the full weight of Kastigar.” Id. at 559. The
court held that it did not, finding that “a Kastigar analysis is not triggered by the
existence of evidence protected by a privilege, but instead by the government’s effort to
compel a witness to testify over the witness’s claim of privilege.” Ibid. (emphasis
added). However, the court also opined “that Kastigar-like protections may be required
in cases involving testimony compelled over the assertion of a non-constitutional
privilege.” Ibid. Nonetheless, in concluding its analysis, the court reiterated that
“because the government’s right to compel testimony in the face of a claim of privilege
is the issue at the heart of Kastigar, its protections do not apply in cases where there is
privileged evidence, but no compelled testimony.” Id. at 560. We agree, and hold that,
absent compelled testimony, the full protections of Kastigar are inapplicable.

23
That is to say, the federal agents had established probable cause to believe that the targets of
the surveillance were a foreign power or agents of a foreign power. Squillacote, 221 F.3d at 554; see 50
U.S.C. § 1804(a).
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 33
09-3176

As further justification for its holding in Squillacote, the Fourth Circuit observed
that “suppression of any evidence derived from the privileged conversations would be
[im]proper in this case, given that the privilege is a testimonial or evidentiary one, and
not constitutionally-based.” Ibid. In making this assertion, the court observed that, as
of the year 2000, no court had applied the fruit-of-the-poisonous-tree doctrine to
derivative evidence obtained as a result of improper access to materials covered by a
non-constitutional privilege. Ibid. (quoting United States v. Marashi, 913 F.2d 724, 731
n.11 (9th Cir. 1990)); see also Nickel v. Hannigan, 97 F.3d 403, 409 (10th Cir. 1996)
(“[W]e decline to apply the ‘fruit of the poisonous tree’ doctrine to the possible breach
of attorney-client privilege in this case.”). We have found no subsequent authority
indicating that such derivative evidence is subject to suppression, and we agree that it
is unwise to extend the fruit-of-the-poisonous-tree doctrine beyond the context of
constitutional violations. See Trammel v. United States, 445 U.S. 40, 51 (1980)
(indicating that testimonial privileges must be balanced against “the need for probative
evidence in the administration of criminal justice”).

In the present case, the privileged materials were not obtained from Warshak as
a result of compelled testimony. Instead, they were garnered pursuant to a subpoena, a
court order, and a search warrant, much like the psychotherapist-patient conversations
at issue in Squillacote. Thus, because the documents were not the product of compelled
testimony, a full Kastigar hearing was not required. Moreover, there is no indication
that the government made any direct use of the privileged communications, either at trial
or before the grand jury. Consequently, given the fact that evidence derived from a
violation of the attorney-client privilege is not fruit of the poisonous tree, Warshak’s
argument withers.

C. Volume & Format of Discovery

The volume of discovery in the present case was prodigious. Indeed, the
government turned over millions of pages of discovery, but that discovery appears to
have come from relatively few sources. Most of the discovery came from Berkeley
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 34
09-3176

itself, when, in March 2005, inspectors executed a search warrant and “imaged” (i.e.,
copied) the electronic contents of the company’s computers and servers. After the
search, the computers and servers remained on Berkeley’s premises, except for several
laptops, which were taken offsite and returned two days later. All told, the electronic
evidence originating at Berkeley filled three “tera-drives” and numbered 17 million
pages. In addition to the electronic evidence, agents seized approximately 506,000
pages of hard-copy documents, all of which the defendants were eventually permitted
to copy. On top of the evidence obtained at Berkeley, discovery included 275 discs of
material gathered by the grand jury and 13 discs of potential trial exhibits compiled by
the government.

The defendants make three arguments with respect to the immense volume of
discovery in this case. First, they argue that the district court abused its discretion and
violated their right to a fair trial by allowing the government to turn over stupendous
quantities of evidence in a disorganized and unsearchable format. Next, they argue that
the government was improperly permitted to “abdicate” its Brady obligations by
producing gargantuan “haystacks” of discovery that swallowed any “needles” of
exculpatory information. Appellant’s Br. at 52. Finally, the defendants argue that the
district court erroneously denied a 90-day continuance, which was requested to enable
the defendants to continue sifting through the mountains of discovery furnished by the
government. Ultimately, none of these arguments is persuasive.24

1. The Manner in Which the Government Produced Discovery

The defendants’ first argument is that the district court erroneously permitted the
government to produce titanic amounts of electronic discovery in formats that were
simultaneously disorganized and unsearchable. Specifically, the defendants assert that
the electronic images of the Berkeley computers and the discs of potential trial exhibits

24
In making their discovery-related arguments, the defendants contend that the alleged errors
should be evaluated collectively. That is, the defendants contend that the alleged mistakes combined to
result in a violation of due process and the right to a fair trial. However, the aggregate impact of these
supposed evils does not rise to the level of a constitutional violation.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 35
09-3176

were difficult to search. The defendants further contend that the government’s failure
to supplement the discovery materials with indices was prejudicial to the preparation of
an adequate defense.25 In making this argument, the defendants lean heavily on Federal
Rule of Civil Procedure 34(b)(2)(E)(i), which requires a party to “produce [discovery
materials] as they are kept in the usual course of business or [to] organize and label them
to correspond to the categories in the request.” The defendants acknowledge that there
is no corresponding provision in Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 16, which governs
criminal discovery, but they argue that due process mandates enforcement of the civil
rule in the criminal context.

A district court’s decision on a discovery matter is reviewed for abuse of
discretion. United States v. Gray, 521 F.3d 514, 529 (6th Cir. 2008) (citing United
States v. $174,206.00 in U.S. Currency, 320 F.3d 658, 663 (6th Cir. 2003)); see United
States v. Maples, 60 F.3d 244, 246 (6th Cir. 1995) (“It is well settled that a district court
has considerable discretion under Rule 16 . . . .”).

As an initial matter, it must be noted that the defendants cite scant authority
suggesting that a district court must order the government to produce electronic
discovery in a particular fashion.26 Furthermore, it bears noting that Federal Rule of
Criminal Procedure 16, which governs discovery in criminal cases, is entirely silent on
the issue of the form that discovery must take; it contains no indication that documents
must be organized or indexed. Thus, if we are to find that the district court abused its
discretion, we must do so despite a pronounced dearth of precedent suggesting that the
district court was wrong.

25
The defendants concede that “[t]he government provided indices to some of the hard-copy
discovery.” Appellant’s Br. at 52 n.16.
26
In suggesting that criminal discovery must comply with Rule 34(b), the defendants point to a
single case, namely, United States v. O’Keefe, 537 F. Supp. 2d 14 (D.D.C. 2008). There, the district court
looked to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 34(b) in assessing the form in which the government should
produce documents. Id. at 19. However, the O’Keefe court admitted that, “[i]n criminal cases, there is
unfortunately no rule to which the courts can look for guidance in determining whether the production of
documents by the government has been in a form or format that is appropriate.” Id. at 18-19.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 36
09-3176

There are a number of factors that counsel against such a finding. First, the
overwhelming majority of the discovery at issue was taken directly from Berkeley’s
computers, which means the defendants had ready access to that information. It also
means that the defendants had access to the documents “as they [were] kept in the usual
course of business.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 34(b)(2)(E)(i). Thus, any difficulty that the
defendants had in accessing the copies is arguably immaterial.27

Furthermore, there is reason to believe that the defendants were experiencing
little difficulty in accessing the contents of the electronic discovery. Though the
defendants claim that they were provided with data that had been rendered in
unsearchable formats, they were citing discovery material to the district court in their
motions, leading the district court to observe that the “[d]efendants’ motion[s]
demonstrate[d] [that] they [were] capably navigating discovery.” Additionally, at the
Kastigar-like hearing held before the district court, an expert witness who testified for
the defense indicated that, with the use of certain software, he could perform “very quick
and thorough” searches of the electronic discovery. Consequently, it does not appear
that the discovery materials were nearly as unsearchable as the defense purports.

Lastly, it should be observed that the government did provide the defense with
something of a guide to the electronic discovery. In response to the defense’s discovery
request, the government furnished the defendants with “a detailed room-by-room
inventory of all items seized from the company, including a listing of the various
computers that were imaged.” Appellee’s Br. at 127. That listing surely offered the
defendants some aid in identifying and marshaling the documents relevant to the
litigation. Accordingly, we decline to hold that the district court abused its discretion
in failing to order the government to produce discovery in a different form.

27
Moreover, any disorganization in the documents was likely attributable to the defendants
themselves. It cannot be that the government is necessarily responsible for curing the disarray that they
inherited.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 37
09-3176

2. The Abdication of Brady

The defendants next argue that the government shrugged off its obligations under
Brady by simply handing over millions of pages of evidence and forcing the defense to
find any exculpatory information contained therein. In essence, the defendants contend
that the government was obliged to sift fastidiously through the evidence—the vast
majority of which came from Berkeley itself—in an attempt to locate anything favorable
to the defense. This argument comes up empty.

In United States v. Skilling, 554 F.3d 529 (5th Cir. 2009), vacated in part on
other grounds, 130 S. Ct. 2896 (2010), the Fifth Circuit confronted and rejected a nearly
identical argument. There, disgraced Enron CEO Jeffrey K. Skilling advanced the
following contentions:

Skilling . . . asserts that the government’s use of an open file failed to
satisfy its Brady obligation to disclose material evidence. Skilling
contends that the government’s open file, which consisted of several
hundred million pages of documents, “resulted in the effective
concealment of a huge quantity of exculpatory evidence.” As the
government never directed Skilling to a single Brady document
contained in the open file, Skilling argues that the government
suppressed evidence in violation of Brady.

Id. at 576.

In dismissing Skilling’s argument, the Fifth Circuit noted that, “[a]s a general
rule, the government is under no duty to direct a defendant to exculpatory evidence
within a larger mass of disclosed evidence.” Ibid. (citing United States v. Mulderig, 120
F.3d 534, 541 (5th Cir. 1997)). However, the Skilling court added a caveat:

We do not hold that the use of a voluminous open file can never violate
Brady. For instance, evidence that the government “padded” an open file
with pointless or superfluous information to frustrate a defendant’s
review of the file might raise serious Brady issues. Creating a
voluminous file that is unduly onerous to access might raise similar
concerns. And it should go without saying that the government may not
hide Brady material of which it is actually aware in a huge open file in
the hope that the defendant will never find it. These scenarios would
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 38
09-3176

indicate that the government was acting in bad faith in performing its
obligations under Brady.

Id. at 577.

Here, the government did not engage in any conduct indicating that it performed
its Brady obligations in bad faith. First, there is no proof that the government larded its
production with entirely irrelevant documents.28 Furthermore, it cannot be said that the
government made access to the documents unduly onerous. While access to the
documents may have been somewhat hampered due to the format in which they were
transferred, the district court noted that the defendants’ motion practice “demonstrate[d]
they [were] capably navigating the discovery, which primarily all came from [the]
[d]efendants in the first place.”29 Finally, there is no indication that the government
deliberately concealed any exculpatory evidence in the information it turned over to the
defense.30 Consequently, the government has not “abdicated” its duties under Brady.

3. The Denial of a Continuance

On December 28, 2007, the defendants requested a 90-day continuance, which
would have pushed the commencement of the trial from January 8, 2008 to April 8,
2008. In making the request, the defendants contended that they had been afforded
insufficient opportunity to review the evidence, stating: “[i]t is as if the government has
pointed the defendants to the Earth’s oceans, saying ‘there is your discovery.’” The
district court declined to grant the request, noting that “[c]ounsel for [the] [d]efendants

28
The defendants contest this point, noting that the government admitted it did not review
everything that it turned over to the defense. However, the fact that the government did not know whether
the documents were relevant does not establish that the government intentionally produced irrelevant
discovery. Nor is there any indication that the government was willfully blind as to the pertinence of the
materials that it was handing over.
29
As the government points out, the defendants’ ability to peruse the electronic discovery was
admitted by the defendants’ expert witness at the Kastigar-like hearing. Specifically, the witness testified
that he was able to sift through the discovery using software called Concordance, which “does a very quick
and thorough search . . . and tells you how many hits you have, and then tells you how many documents
there are associated with that search.”
30
“If there is something exculpatory still in the [discovery that was produced], we must
assume—as there is no compelling evidence to the contrary—that the government does not know about
it either.” Skilling, 554 F.3d at 577.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 39
09-3176

outnumber counsel for the government, and have all been working on this case for a
substantial amount of time.”31 The defendants now argue that the district court’s denial
of their request for a continuance was error.

The district court’s denial of a motion for a continuance is reviewed for abuse of
discretion. United States v. Crossley, 224 F.3d 847, 854 (6th Cir. 2000). “Denial
amounts to a constitutional violation only if there is an unreasoning and arbitrary
‘insistence upon expeditiousness in the face of a justifiable request for delay.’ To
demonstrate reversible error, the defendant must show that the denial resulted in actual
prejudice to his defense.” United States v. Gallo, 763 F.2d 1504, 1523 (6th Cir. 1985)
(quoting United States v. Mitchell, 744 F.2d 701, 704 (9th Cir. 1984)). “The defendant
demonstrates ‘actual prejudice’ by showing that a continuance would have made relevant
witnesses available or added something to the defense.” United States v. King, 127 F.3d
483, 487 (6th Cir. 1997); see also United States v. Faulkner, 538 F.2d 724, 729 (6th Cir.
1976) (“No absolute rule can be articulated as to the minimum amount of time required
for an adequate preparation for trial of a criminal case.”).

The defendants argue that they were prejudiced in two ways. First, they argue
that “their counsel could not satisfy their constitutional obligation to review all the
evidence in the government’s possession, custody, or control.”32 Appellant’s Br. at 60.
In making this argument, they allege that “the entirety of the government’s 360,000
pages of trial exhibits . . . were largely disclosed on November 29, 2007, only six weeks
before trial.” Id. at 59. Second, the defendants argue that “[t]he defense simply did not
have sufficient time to locate and then utilize material and exculpatory evidence that was
hidden within the millions of pages of discovery.” Id. at 60.

These arguments lead nowhere. With respect to the first, it must be noted that
more than a year elapsed between the time the indictment was handed down and the time

31
The district court also observed that “[t]rial was originally scheduled for November 13, 2007,
and the [c]ourt continued it for other reasons than any purported evidentiary problems.”
32
The defendants’ attorneys submitted sworn affidavits to this effect, though they point to no
authority establishing a “constitutional obligation” to review all evidence in the government’s possession.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 40
09-3176

the trial began, affording the defendants ample opportunity to construct a defense.33
Additionally, the discovery time line does not indicate that the defendants were short-
changed with respect to preparation time. The bulk of the documents in question were
in the company’s possession as early as April 2005.34 Furthermore, the entirety of the
discovery material in the case was in the defendants’ hands by June 2007, more than six
months in advance of the trial. While the government did not provide the defense with
thirteen discs of potential trial exhibits until November 29, 2007—approximately six
weeks before trial was to begin—those exhibits were ostensibly culled from the
discovery material that the government had already provided.35 It is true that this case
involved millions of pages of documents, but there is no dispute that the defendants were
given months to comb through the bulk of them. As a result, it cannot be said that the
district court’s unwillingness to postpone the trial was the product of an undue insistence
on haste.

The defendants’ second argument—that they were not given enough time to mine
exculpatory evidence from the mountains of discovery dumped at their feet—similarly
fails. As an initial matter, it should be noted that this argument assumes that exculpatory
evidence exists. In the absence of such evidence, the lack of time to look for it would
be harmless. In other words, it would not be prejudicial if the defendants were denied
the chance to excavate in a mine that contained no ore. On that score, the most the
defendants can say is that they “fervently believe[] . . . that with sufficient time they
would unearth the necessary volume of emails to counter the government’s accusations.”
Appellant’s Brief at 60. Consequently, the defendants have failed to demonstrate that

33
The defendants were indicted in September 2006, and trial commenced in January 2008.
34
As mentioned earlier, most of the discovery in this case was obtained from Berkeley computers,
which were imaged during the March 2005 search of Berkeley’s headquarters. Aside from several laptops
which were seized and returned, Berkeley remained in possession of all the imaged computers once the
physical search was done. Thus, Berkeley’s claim that it had too little time to review the contents of the
computers rings hollow.
35
Allegedly, two of those discs were corrupted and could not be opened until approximately a
week before the trial began. However, that does not change the analysis. Though the defendants were
given relatively little time to review the trial exhibits, they were nonetheless given a significant period of
time in which to review the discovery materials and prepare their defense.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 41
09-3176

the denial of a continuance worked any prejudice with respect to their ability to glean
exculpatory evidence.36

D. Warshak’s New Trial Motion: Brady

The next issue is whether the district court erred in denying Warshak’s motion
for a new trial, which was based on the assertion that the government had suppressed
exculpatory evidence in violation of Brady. “This court reviews [the] denial of a motion
for new trial based on Brady violations under an abuse of discretion standard.” United
States v. Graham, 484 F.3d 413, 416 (6th Cir. 2007) (citing United States v. Jones,
399 F.3d 640, 647 (6th Cir. 2005)). “However, the district court’s determination as to
the existence of a Brady violation is reviewed de novo.” Id. at 416-17 (citing United
States v. Miller, 161 F.3d 977, 987 (6th Cir. 1998)).

“To establish a violation of Brady, the [defendant] has the burden of establishing
that the prosecutor suppressed evidence; that such evidence was favorable to the defense;
and that the suppressed evidence was material.” Carter v. Bell, 218 F.3d 581, 601 (6th
Cir. 2000). “[E]vidence is material only if there is a reasonable probability that, had the
evidence been disclosed to the defense, the result of the proceeding would have been
different. A ‘reasonable probability’ is a probability sufficient to undermine confidence
in the outcome.” United States v. Bagley, 473 U.S. 667, 682 (1985); see also Kyles v.
Whitley, 514 U.S. 419, 434 (1995) (holding that the “touchstone of materiality is a
‘reasonable probability’ of a different result”). “Moreover, in determining whether
undisclosed evidence is material, the suppressed evidence is considered collectively,
rather than item-by-item, to determine if the ‘reasonable probability’ test is met.”
Schledwitz v. United States, 169 F.3d 1003, 1012 (6th Cir. 1999).

In this case, the information alleged to constitute Brady material was discovered
post-trial while Warshak was defending himself in a civil action involving the FTC.

36
Furthermore, any emails that the defendants might have found were continuously in their
possession from the time of the indictment to the time of the trial. Thus, the defendants had more than a
year to turn up anything exculpatory.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 42
09-3176

During that litigation, Warshak deposed Sue and Greg Cossman, his sister and brother-
in-law, whom the government had interviewed extensively in the run-up to Warshak’s
criminal trial.37 In their depositions, the Cossmans spoke favorably of Berkeley and
testified that government investigators were pushing a particular version of the facts. In
addition to the depositions, Warshak’s involvement in the FTC litigation led to the
discovery of (1) several recordings of Berkeley sales calls during which disclosure of the
auto-ship program was made and (2) several printouts of Berkeley’s website on which
disclosure of the auto-ship program could be seen. Warshak argues that this evidence
was exculpatory and should have been turned over prior to trial.

However, Warshak’s argument fails because the evidence at issue was not
“material” for Brady purposes. First of all, with respect to Sue Cossman’s deposition
testimony, it must be noted that, as Warshak’s sister and a participant in the Berkeley
fraud, she had plenty of incentive to stretch the truth in Warshak’s favor. Furthermore,
many of the favorable things she said in her deposition were echoed in the statements
of trial witnesses, who stated that they did not realize what they were doing was wrong.
Thus, the cumulative nature of her deposition testimony cuts against a finding of
materiality. See Spence v. Johnson, 80 F.3d 989, 995 (5th Cir. 1996) (“[W]hen the
undisclosed evidence is merely cumulative of other evidence, no Brady violation
occurs.”). Finally, her testimony would not have undermined confidence in the finding
of fraud, as numerous witnesses and scores of emails confirmed that Berkeley executives
were engaging in deliberately deceitful practices. See Jones, 399 F.3d at 648 (“Given
the overwhelming evidence of guilt, a new trial under Brady was inappropriate.”).

Greg Cossman’s deposition testimony is likewise immaterial. Critically, Greg
Cossman took the stand at Warshak’s trial, at which time he actually made most of the
favorable remarks that later appeared in his post-trial deposition.38 For example,

37
Sue Cossman did not testify at Warshak’s trial. Greg Cossman did, however.
38
For the same reason, we conclude that the information in Greg Cossman’s deposition was not
suppressed.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 43
09-3176

Cossman testified at trial that, “while [he] was participating at Berkeley, [he] had no
suspicion of participating in a conspiracy doing anything that was criminal.” Also,
Cossman apparently testified that the government’s investigators were “calculating,
ruthless, relentless and intimidating.” In light of these statements, Greg Cossman’s post-
trial deposition testimony adds nothing new to the mix, and it therefore does not
constitute Brady material.

Nor can it be said that the tapes and printouts meet the materiality requirement.
Though the recorded calls do contain disclosure of the auto-ship program, that fact is not
particularly helpful to Warshak’s case, given the testimony that the disclosures were
designed to be ineffective. Similarly, the appearance of the disclosure on the company
website at a given instant in time is also unhelpful; there was testimony that the
disclosure on the website appeared, shifted, and disappeared like water in the vision of
a desert traveler. As a consequence, these materials do not generate a “reasonable
probability” of a different result.39 Kyles, 514 U.S. at 434. Accordingly, the district
court did not err in finding that Warshak failed to demonstrate a Brady violation.

E. Prosecutorial Misconduct

The defendants also argue that a new trial is warranted in light of “serious
improprieties in the government’s rebuttal argument.” Appellant’s Br. at 69.
Specifically, the defendants assert that the following acts constitute reversible
misconduct:

The government’s attorney vouched for the “honesty and integrity” of the
prosecution team.
The government’s attorney expressed his personal opinion with respect
to the guilt of the defendants, describing the defendants as “weak” and
“self-aggrandiz[ing].”

39
The calls and website printouts clearly fail to satisfy the suppression requirement as well.
There was testimony in the record that Berkeley taped all of its calls, meaning Warshak had access to the
calls long before the government disclosed the tapes. Furthermore, with respect to the website printouts,
it must be noted that they came from Berkeley’s website. Anything on Berkeley’s website should have
been known to Berkeley’s owner.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 44
09-3176

The government’s attorney described his personal life, relating anecdotes
about his time in the JAG Corps and his association with a military
celebrity.
The government “suggested to the jury that the fact that the grand jury
had found probable cause . . . was evidence of . . . guilt.” Appellant’s Br.
at 72.
The government improperly asserted that the defendants’ guilt was
supported by evidence that had not been presented during trial.
The government impermissibly argued that the guilty pleas of
coconspirators were evidence of a conspiracy.
The government employed rebuttal “to give a second principal closing
argument.”

Appellant’s Br. at 74.40

In determining whether a prosecutor’s remarks and conduct merit a new trial,41
this court utilizes a two-part test. Cristini v. McKee, 526 F.3d 888, 899 (6th Cir. 2008)
(citing Girts v. Yanai, 501 F.3d 743, 758-59 (6th Cir. 2007)). First, we must determine
“whether the prosecutor’s conduct and remarks were improper.” United States v. Carter,
236 F.3d 777, 783 (6th Cir. 2001) (citing United States v. Carroll, 26 F.3d 1380, 1387
(6th Cir. 1994)). Second, if the conduct and remarks were improper, “the court must
. . . consider and weigh four factors in determining whether the impropriety was flagrant
and thus warrants reversal.” Ibid. The four factors are: “(1) whether the conduct and
remarks of the prosecutor tended to mislead the jury or prejudice the defendant;
(2) whether the conduct or remarks were isolated or extensive; (3) whether the remarks
were deliberately or accidentally made; and (4) whether the evidence against the
defendant was strong.” Ibid. Additionally, “[w]hen considering challenges to a
prosecutor’s statements at trial, we examine those statements within the context of the

40
The defense did not immediately object to any of these acts, although it did request a curative
instruction after the argument, objecting to the first four sets of remarks made by the prosecutor.
41
“Whether statements made by a prosecutor amount to misconduct and whether such statements
render a trial fundamentally unfair are mixed questions of law and fact, which we review de novo.” United
States v. Carson, 560 F.3d 566, 574 (6th Cir. 2009) (citing United States v. Francis, 170 F.3d 546, 549 (6th
Cir. 1999)).
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 45
09-3176

[entire] trial to determine whether they were prejudicial error.” Cristini, 526 F.3d at 899
(citing Girts, 501 F.3d at 759).

The flagrancy analysis does not necessarily end this court’s inquiry. But if the
improper statements were not flagrant, reversal of a conviction is warranted only if
“1) the proof of the defendant’s guilt is not overwhelming; 2) the defense objected to the
statements; and 3) the trial judge did not cure the impropriety through an admonishment
to the jury.” United States v. Galloway, 316 F.3d 624, 632 (6th Cir. 2003); see also
United States v. Cobleigh, 75 F.3d 242, 247 (6th Cir. 1996).

1. Were the Prosecutor’s Conduct and Remarks Improper?

The first step in the prosecutorial-misconduct analysis is to determine whether
the conduct and remarks at issue were improper. The first set of allegedly inappropriate
remarks related to the honesty and moral character of the prosecution team. Responding
to a number of comments made during closing arguments for the defendants, the
government’s attorney, Mr. Kadon, suggested that the defense had labeled the
prosecution team “abusive and horrible and evil people.” Kadon then stated:

First of all, I think the biggest thing you heard [during the defense’s
argument] was that this is a big conspiracy, that the conspirators are not
seated behind me; the conspirators are seated over there where I am. I
mean, I’m a conspirator, I guess; that Ms. Porter, Mr. Josephs, the federal
police that have been investigating this case, somehow the Postal
Inspection Service, Federal Bureau of Investigation, Food and Drug
Administration, the Department of Justice, the United States Attorney’s
Office and the Criminal Investigation Division of the Internal Revenue
Service all got together and conspired, that over the last several years all
we thought about every single day when we came to work was how we
were going to get these guys.

Kadon then suggested that he “hope[d] [the jury] d[id]n’t believe that,” and he went on
to argue that “it is kind of preposterous that we would all get together and lie to do this,
that this case is somehow worth everything—our reputations, our lives, our
families—just because convicting this guy or these people is so important to us.”
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 46
09-3176

The defendants contend that these remarks constitute improper prosecutorial
vouching, which typically “occurs when a prosecutor supports the credibility of a
witness by indicating a personal belief in the witness’s credibility[,] thereby placing the
prestige of the office of the United States Attorney behind that witness.” Francis, 170
F.3d at 550 (emphasis added). Here, however, Kadon did not vouch for the credibility
of a witness. Rather, he spoke to the likelihood that the government’s attorneys had
engaged in a monomaniacal witch-hunt. Furthermore, he did not overtly suggest that the
government’s attorneys were honest or morally superior. Instead, he suggested that the
prosecution team had no motive to lie. That said, we do think Kadon went a bit
overboard, and his remarks veered into dangerous territory.

The next allegedly improper remarks pertained to Kadon’s opinion of the
defendants. At one point, Kadon posed and then answered the following series of
rhetorical questions: “Do I believe that these people were weak, that they sought
self-aggrandizement, personal gain, and they sought it at the expense of other people,
consumers? And, in fact, it’s okay to lie to banks, because who cares about them
anyway? Do I believe that they believe that? Yes.”

These remarks were also inappropriate. As the defendants correctly note, “it is
improper for a prosecuting attorney in a criminal case to state his personal opinion
concerning . . . the guilt of a defendant.” United States v. Krebs, 788 F.2d 1166, 1176
(6th Cir. 1986) (quoting United States v. Daniels, 528 F.2d 705, 709 (6th Cir. 1976));
see also United States v. Bess, 593 F.2d 749, 755 (6th Cir. 1979) (“Implicit in an
assertion of personal belief that a defendant is guilty, is an implied statement that the
prosecutor, by virtue of his experience, knowledge and intellect, has concluded that the
jury must convict. The devastating impact of such ‘testimony’ should be apparent.”).
In this case, Kadon plainly voiced a personal belief regarding the guilt of the defendants.
While he did not directly state that he believed the defendants were guilty, he stated that,
in his mind, they were weak and sought wealth and notoriety at the expense, both literal
and figurative, of the consuming public. Thus, Kadon’s remarks were improper.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 47
09-3176

Next, we must consider Kadon’s statements about his time in the JAG Corps.
In the middle of his summation, Kadon remarked:

And, you know, when I was on active duty, I worked for a guy named
Gary Harrell, who—he was kind of a famous guy. If you have ever seen
the movie Black Hawk Down, he was in the movie Black Hawk Down.
He’s a Green Beret. And he would always tell me when we talked about
things—I was his JAG officer, but I don’t fly Black Hawks—he would
always say, you know, Karl, life is full of choices. You make your
choices and accept the consequences, about the things that we were doing
with respect to prosecuting the war on terror.

The defendants argue that the prosecutor’s remarks about his military service and
his quasi-famous colleague were improper. With respect to these remarks, the
government concedes impropriety, acknowledging that the remarks were entirely
irrelevant to the closing argument. We agree. The remarks served no purpose other than
to enhance Kadon’s stature in the eyes of the jury, and they were therefore inappropriate.
This conclusion is especially apparent when one considers the good guys/bad guys
dichotomy that the remarks create when paired with Kadon’s statements regarding the
“weakness” and cupidity of the defendants.

The fourth set of statements at issue touched on the relevance of the grand jury’s
decision to indict the defendants. Following his comments about his stint in the armed
forces, Kadon noted that all 112 counts in the indictment were “things that a grand jury
determined were probable cause, these people committed these crimes, that’s what that
means.” Sometime thereafter, Kadon returned to the mindset of the grand jury, stating
that “[t]he grand jury believed [the defendants] committed crimes.”

These remarks were plainly out of bounds. As this court stated in Bess, “it is
always improper for a prosecutor to suggest that a defendant is guilty merely because he
is being prosecuted or has been indicted.” 593 F.2d at 754; see United States v. Bowen,
500 F.2d 41, 42 (6th Cir. 1974) (holding that it was improper for a prosecutor to state
that an eyewitness identification “was good enough” when it was presented to the grand
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 48
09-3176

jury). Here, there is no question that Kadon invoked the grand jury’s probable-cause
determination when arguing for a finding of guilt. His remarks were therefore improper.

The fifth set of remarks at issue involved individuals who had filed complaints
but had not testified at trial.42 First, Kadon stated that, despite floods of complaints to
Berkeley and the BBB, the government had made a strategic decision not to “bring[] in
a million people or hundreds of thousands of people” to testify that Berkeley was
shipping them unwanted supplements. Then, Kadon remarked that thousands of callers
had unsuccessfully attempted to call Berkeley and that the government did not “have to
go and have everyone here say: I called; it was a problem.”

The defendants argue that these comments impermissibly “convey[ed] the
impression that evidence not presented to the jury, but known to the prosecutor,
support[ed] the charges against the defendant[s] and . . . thus jeopardize[d] the
defendant[s’] right to be tried solely on the basis of the evidence presented to the jury.”
Hodge v. Hurley, 426 F.3d 368, 378 (6th Cir. 2005). However, the defendants are
incorrect. The remarks in question merely alluded to evidence already before the jury,
namely, testimony that droves of customers had complained and that scores of others had
tried in vain to do the same. In suggesting that those witnesses could have testified, the
government was simply explaining their absence. As a result, these remarks were
permissible.

The penultimate allegation of prosecutorial impropriety stems from a remark
about the coconspirators who testified at trial.43 Specifically, Kadon stated: “And if you
believe that there was an agreement to put this on between the people here at the table,
the ones who were charged and the people that testified, they pled guilty to doing that,
that’s one part of the conspiratorial element right there, those people.”

42
It should be noted that because the defendants did not object to these statements below, they
are subjected to review for plain error. See Cristini, 526 F.3d at 901. Ultimately, however, the level of
review is irrelevant, as the remarks were not improper.
43
As with the previous set of remarks concerning potential witnesses, this comment did not spur
an objection at trial and is therefore subject to plain-error review.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 49
09-3176

This declaration was not improper. While it is true that a jury “may not . . .
consider the guilty plea of any [other] person as evidence of guilt on the part of the
defendant [standing trial],” United States v. Stavroff, 149 F.3d 478, 484 (6th Cir. 1998),
Kadon’s remark did not directly implore the jurors to consider the guilty pleas of the
defendants’ coconspirators. Instead, Kadon simply added an identifier as to whom the
charged defendants were shown to have conspired with—a number of other defendants
who had pleaded guilty. That portion of his statement did not lie at the core of the
message he was intending to convey, which was that the jurors should convict if they
found the existence of a conspiratorial agreement. Consequently, Kadon’s statement
should not be deemed inappropriate.44

Lastly, the defendants argue that Kadon engaged in improper conduct,
specifically by employing the government’s rebuttal argument as an impermissible
second attempt at a full-scale closing. The defendants contend that the government
deliberately limited its initial closing argument to a “45-minute long [sic] broad-brush
overview of its evidence, and withheld many of its most pointed arguments for rebuttal.”
Appellant’s Br. at 75.

However, the defendants’ argument fails. True, a number of cases suggest that
the government may not advance any new contentions on rebuttal. See, e.g., United
States v. Gleason, 616 F.2d 2, 26 (2d Cir. 1979) (indicating that prejudice might have
arisen if a rebuttal argument containing new assertions had not been followed by
surrebuttal). However, the defendants point to nothing in Kadon’s rebuttal argument that
was raised for the first time after their summation. Furthermore, to the extent that Kadon
made any new arguments in response to assertions made by the defense, those new
arguments were permissible. See United States v. Sarmiento, 744 F.2d 755, 765 (11th
Cir. 1984).

44
Even if it were deemed improper, the third of the four flagrancy factors—whether the remark
was deliberate or accidental—would militate against a finding that this remark was particularly pernicious.
Kadon’s statement was clearly a spontaneous aside that, in fact, interrupted the flow of the main point he
was trying to make.
Nos. 08-3997/4085/4087/4212/4429; United States v. Warshak, et al. Page 50
09-3176

2. The Four Flagrancy Factors

Having determined that a number of Kadon’s remarks were improper, we must
now proceed to the flagrancy analysis, which involves the application of the four factors
delineated above. None of the four factors is dispositive. Galloway, 316 F.3d at 632.
On balance, it appears that the prosecutor’s remarks, though improper, were not flagrant
enough to “render [the] trial fundamentally unfair.” Carson, 560 F.3d at 574.

a. Tendency to Mislead the Jury or Prejudice the Jury

The first factor requires us to consider whether the remarks in question were
misleading or prejudicial. Carter, 236 F.3d at 783. As an initial matter, it must be noted
that the defendants did not immediately object to any of the remarks. In some cases, the
defendants did not object at all. That cuts in favor of a finding that the remarks were not
particularly prejudicial, as anything significantly deleterious would presumably prompt
a swift objection from experienced defense counsel. See United States v. Trutenko, 490
F.2d 678, 680 (7th Cir. 1973) (“We are inclined to believe[,] however, that if the
comment were sufficiently prejudicial to warrant reversal, counsel who was present at
the time either would have objected forthwith or else would have requested the trial
judge to give a curative instruction.”).45

Setting aside the failure to lodge an immediate objection, it seems evident that
a number of the improper remarks would tend, in isolation, to prejudice the defendants.
The perceptions of the jury were surely impacted to some extent when the prosecutor
suggested that he believed the defendants to be weak, greedy, and capable of criminal
designs. See Bess, 593 F.2d at 755. Furthermore, it is plain that Kadon’s military
anecdote was likely to stir the patriotic fibers of at least several jurors, shifting their

45
As noted in footnote 40, the defense did request a curative instruction following the argument,
objecting to all of the remarks at issue, save those about additional evidence and the guilty pleas of co-
defendants. But the request for a curative instruction does not alter the analysis in any great respect. If
veteran trial counsel failed to interrupt the argument, then counsel must have been of the opinion that a
somewhat delayed curative instruction would suffice to extinguish any prejudice. This assertion finds
corroboration in the mystification of the trial judge, who was somewhat perplexed when the defendants
presented objections after Kadon had concluded his rebuttal and asked, “Why didn’t you object at the
time?

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/cases/181032. Public record. Not legal advice.
