# Smith v. Dept. of Rev.

> Oregon Tax Court · August 22, 2025

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/cases/11128221

## Case

- **Court:** Oregon Tax Court
- **Decided:** August 22, 2025
- **Precedential status:** Unpublished
- **Opinion:** Opinion
- **Judges:** Davis
- **Cited by:** 0 later opinions in the Frix Law Library

## Citator (automated)

- No negative treatment found by the automated citator. That is not the same as a confirmation that the case is good law; read the citing cases.
- Full citator and citing cases: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/cases/11128221

## How later opinions describe it (automated extraction)

- acknowledging Oregon follows provisions from the IRC but not requiring Oregon to be bound to federal tax decisions and issuance of refunds
- finding the state is not required to follow the federal government’s acceptance of plaintiff’s requested refund, nor is it bound by the federal government’s decision based on a taxpayer’s self-reported income

## Opinion text

IN THE OREGON TAX COURT
MAGISTRATE DIVISION
Income Tax

DANA M. SMITH, )
)
Plaintiff, ) TC-MD 250092R
)
v. )
)
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE, )
State of Oregon, )
)
Defendant. ) DECISION

Plaintiff appeals Defendant’s Notice of Assessment dated February 27, 2025, for the

2023 tax year. A remote trial was held on June 17, 2025, via WebEx. Plaintiff appeared and

testified on her own behalf. Mary L. Stewart, an auditor, appeared and testified on behalf of

Defendant. Plaintiff’s Exhibits 1 to 12 and Defendant’s Exhibits A to I were received into

evidence.

I. STATEMENT OF FACTS

In 2023, Plaintiff was employed by PacificSource in Springfield, Oregon and received

$50,106 in wages. (Def’s Ex G at 7; Ptf’s Ex 5 at 1.) PacificSource withheld $2,320 from her

wages for Oregon state income taxes. (Def’s Ex G at 9; Ptf’s Ex 5 at 3.)

Plaintiff self-prepared her 2023 federal income tax return and filed it on April 6, 2024.

(Def’s Ex F at 1; Def’s Ex D; Ptf’s Ex 2.) She filed a state tax return, Form OR-40-P, for part-

year residents, reporting her Oregon residency from January 1, 2023, to August 15, 2023. (Def’s

Ex D at 1; Ptf’s Ex 3 at 2.) Plaintiff’s federal return included Form 4852, which is designed to

replace or correct Form W-2, filed by employers to report wages and taxes withheld. (Def’s Ex

E at 14; Ptf’s Ex 2 at 4.) Plaintiff amended her Oregon return to exclude her kicker refund.

(Def’s Ex F at 5; Def’s Ex C at 9-10; Ptf’s Ex 3 at 1.)

DECISION TC-MD 250092R 1
Plaintiff testified she filed Form 4852 to correct the W-2 submitted by PacificSource and

to report zero income from wages. (See also Def’s Ex E at 14; Ptf’s Ex 2 at 4.) Plaintiff

reported zero wages because she did not “work in an occupation that would meet the definition

of an ‘Employee’ as defined in USC 3401(c) [and that] [a]ny payments made to me were purely

private in nature.” (Def’s Ex F at 2; Ptf’s Ex 9 at 1.)

On September 3, 2024, Defendant denied Plaintiff’s claimed refund of $2,300 and

adjusted her return to match the W-2 from PacificSource. (Def’s Ex G at 7-11; Ptf’s Ex 5 at 1-

5.) Defendant adjusted Plaintiff’s federal adjusted gross income to be $50,106 and computed the

Oregon income tax as $3,635, resulting in $87.46 tax due. (Def’s Ex G at 3; Ptf’s Ex 8 at 1.)

II. ANALYSIS

Plaintiff’s appeal raises three issues. First, whether Plaintiff’s 2023 wages are taxable in

Oregon. Second, whether Oregon is bound by the Internal Revenue Service’s (IRS) acceptance

of Plaintiff’s return and issuance of a refund. Third, whether Plaintiff’s appeal is frivolous. This

decision will address this state’s authority to tax Plaintiff’s wages and then address penalties for

filing a frivolous appeal.

A. Wages as Taxable Income

Plaintiff does not believe the wages she earned in 2023 were taxable in Oregon. Plaintiff

contends she did not earn income from “a public office, connected to trade or business, federal or

federally connected employment, investment, or any privileged or other taxable activities.”

(Def’s Ex F at 1; Ptf’s Ex 2 at 1.) She interprets the federal code to mean only wages from such

sources are taxable. For the reasons explained below, Plaintiff’s interpretation is incorrect.

Gross income includes “undeniable accessions to wealth, clearly realized, and over which

the taxpayers have complete dominion.” Comm’r v. Glenshaw Glass Co., 348 US 426, 431, 75 S

DECISION TC-MD 250092R 2
Ct 473, 99 L Ed 483 (1955). It encompasses “compensation for services of whatever kind and in

whatever form paid.” Internal Revenue Code (IRC) § 61(a)(1). Yet Plaintiff claims her wages

were not taxable because she did not “work in an occupation that would meet the definition of an

‘Employee’ as defined in USC 340l(c).” (Def’s Ex F at 4; Ptf’s Ex 9 at 7.) That section provides

that the term “employee” “includes an officer, employee or elected official of the United States.”

(Emphasis added.) The language does not address how other employees’ wages are subject to

withholding or taxation. IRC section 7701(c) states that the use of the word “includes” “shall not

be deemed to exclude other things otherwise within the meaning of the term defined.” It does

not follow that the inclusion of certain types of employees in this section would necessarily

exclude others from taxation.

Plaintiff also claims any payments made to her “do not constitute any taxable income

under relevant Income Tax Law, specifically 3401(a) and 3121(a) of IRC Title 26.” (Def’s Ex F

at 4; Ptf’s Ex 9 at 7.) Both of these sections define “wages” as they pertain to their particular

chapters, and their irrelevance to Plaintiff’s argument has previously been explained by this

court. See Routledge v. Dep’t. of Rev., TC-MD 170396G, 2018 WL 3808557 (Or Tax M Div,

Aug. 6, 2018), aff’d as modified, 24 OTR 103 (2020) (rejecting an identical argument). IRC

section 3401(a) defines “wages” for purposes of chapter 24, pertaining to the duty of employers

to withhold income tax. IRC section 3121(a) defines “wages” for purposes of chapter 21,

pertaining to employment tax. These sections concern employer duties; neither pertains to the

issue at hand or supports Plaintiff’s reasoning.

Plaintiff’s argument concerning the classification of the “payer” of her wages is similar to

the one rejected by the court in Routledge v. Department of Revenue, 24 OTR 103 (2020).

There, plaintiff argued that the remuneration he received from his employer for his services was

DECISION TC-MD 250092R 3
not income for Oregon personal income tax purposes because the payer was not a public

employer. Id. at 105. The court cited to IRC section 3401(a)(11), which states “ ‘wages’ means

all remuneration * * * for services performed by an employee for his employer, * * * except that

such term shall not include remuneration paid * * * for services not in the course of the

employer’s trade or business * * *.” The court noted that “[u]under IRC section 7701(a)(26), the

term ‘trade or business’ ‘includes the performance of the functions of a public office.’ ” Id. at

106. The court goes on to explain that “the definition of ‘trade or business’ does not begin and

end with IRC section 7701(a)(26).” Id. at 107. The court again pointed to IRC section 7701(c),

which provides: “The terms ‘includes’ and ‘including’ when used in a definition contained in this

title shall not be deemed to exclude other things otherwise within the meaning of the term

defined.” The court concluded that IRC section 7701(c) “thus requires the court to include

within the meaning of a ‘trade or business’ an employer’s activities that are ‘otherwise’ within

the meaning of ‘trade or business.’ ” Id. at 107.

Plaintiff does not assert that PacificSource’s activities are outside the definition of a trade

or business in the ordinary meaning of the term, but rather her argument seems to be that the IRC

must be read narrowly to exclude private enterprise as a source of taxable wages. Here, as in

Routledge, Plaintiff is mistaken.

Plaintiff’s interpretation of IRC sections 3401(c) and 3121(a) as excluding private

employment is also contrary to established federal law. See Muhammad v. Commissioner, 121

TCM 1576, TC Memo 2021-77, 2021 WL 2665979 (US Tax Ct) (rejecting claim that only

federal employees are subject to income tax). A W-2 from an employer is sufficient evidence of

employee wages. See Hardy v. Comm’r, 181 F3d 1002, 1004-1005 (9th Cir 1999), aff’g TC

Memo 1997-97. Plaintiff earned $50,106 in wages, from an Oregon employer, while residing in

DECISION TC-MD 250092R 4
this state. Those wages are taxable under Oregon Revised Statutes (ORS) chapter 316 regardless

of the employer type.1

B. Oregon is Not Bound by IRS Determinations

Plaintiff asserts Oregon is mandated to conform to the definitions in the IRC under ORS

316.048. She argues that the IRS accepted her return reporting zero income and issued a refund,

thus Oregon should do the same.

ORS 316.048 was created by the legislature and enacted for the state to utilize the federal

tax code instead of having to reinvent and pass a separate state tax code. The statute does not

mandate the state to conform to the federal tax code, rather, it has simply adopted much of the

federal tax code for convenience. While Oregon’s tax laws incorporate federal definitions, the

department is not bound by the IRS’s acceptance of a taxpayer’s return or determination. See

Detrick v. Dept. of Rev., 311 Or 152, 155-156, 806 P2d 682, 683-684 (1991) (finding the state is

not required to follow the federal government’s acceptance of plaintiff’s requested refund, nor is

it bound by the federal government’s decision based on a taxpayer’s self-reported income); see

also Okorn v. Dept. of Rev., 312 Or 152, 155, 818 P2d 928 (1991) (acknowledging Oregon

follows provisions from the IRC but not requiring Oregon to be bound to federal tax decisions

and issuance of refunds). Defendant acted within its authority in adjusting Plaintiff’s gross

income and denying her refund claim.

C. Plaintiff is Subject to Sanctions for Filing a Frivolous Appeal

Defendant requests the court impose a penalty on Plaintiff for filing a frivolous appeal

under ORS 305.437. This statute authorizes a penalty up to $5,000 when an appeal is frivolous

or if the appeal was made primarily for delay. Under ORS 305.437(2)(a), an appeal is

1
The court’s references to the ORS are to the 2021 edition.

DECISION TC-MD 250092R 5
“frivolous” if there is no objectively reasonable basis for asserting the position. Plaintiff’s claim

that wages from a private employer are not taxable mirrors the argument rejected in Gordon v.

Department of Revenue, TC-MD 170236R, 2018 WL 3146143 (Or Tax M Div, June 26, 2018)

(imposing a $1,000 penalty). The court imposed similar penalties in Routledge, 24 OTR at 125

(raising the magistrate’s penalty from $1,000 to $4,000 in the Regular Division), and Meacham

v. Department of Revenue, TC-MD 240527R, 2024 WL 4647426 (Or Tax M Div, Oct 31, 2024)

(imposing a $2,000 penalty). Plaintiff’s claim, that income from PacificSource is not taxable

income because it is from a private employer, is not objectively reasonable. That position is

frivolous. In light of the above case law, a $1,000 penalty under ORS 305.437 is warranted.

III. CONCLUSION

After thorough consideration, the court finds that Plaintiff’s arguments are not legally

supported by statute or case law and qualify as frivolous. Her income earned during her

residency in Oregon from an in-state employer makes her income taxable under state law. Now,

therefore,

IT IS THE DECISION OF THIS COURT that Plaintiff’s appeal for the 2023 tax year is

denied.

///

///

///

///

///

///

///

DECISION TC-MD 250092R 6
IT IS FURTHER DECIDED that, no later than 10 days after the judgement in this case

becomes final, Plaintiff shall pay to Defendant a penalty of $1,000 pursuant to ORS 305.437 for

filing a frivolous appeal.

RICHARD D. DAVIS
MAGISTRATE

If you want to appeal this Decision, file a complaint in the Regular Division of
the Oregon Tax Court, by mailing to: 1163 State Street, Salem, OR 97301-2563;
or by hand delivery to: Fourth Floor, 1241 State Street, Salem, OR.

Your complaint must be submitted within 60 days after the date of this Decision
or this Decision cannot be changed. TCR-MD 19 B.

This document was signed by Magistrate Richard D. Davis and entered on
August 22, 2025.

DECISION TC-MD 250092R 7

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/cases/11128221. Public record. Not legal advice.
