# Human Rights Defense Center v. Carmichael

> District Court, W.D. North Carolina · December 27, 2019

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/cases/10255294

## Case

- **Court:** District Court, W.D. North Carolina
- **Decided:** December 27, 2019
- **Opinion:** 100trialcourt
- **Cited by:** 0 later opinions in the Frix Law Library

## Citator (automated)

- No negative treatment found by the automated citator. That is not the same as a confirmation that the case is good law; read the citing cases.
- Full citator and citing cases: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/cases/10255294

## Opinion text

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF NORTH CAROLINA
CHARLOTTE DIVISION
CIVIL ACTION NO. 3:18-CV-218-GCM
HUMAN RIGHTS DEFENSE CENTER, )
)
Plaintiff, )
)
v. )
) ORDER
IRWIN CARMICHAEL, SHERIFF OF )
MECKLENBURG COUNTY, ET AL., )
)
Defendants. )
)

THIS MATTER is before the Court on Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss (“Motion”) (Doc.
No. 14) filed May 30, 2018. The Court, having carefully considered the briefs and materials
submitted in support and in opposition of the Motion, the Complaint (Doc. No. 1), and being
otherwise fully advised, finds and orders as follows:
I. FACTUAL BACKGROUND
On April 24, 2018, Plaintiff, the Human Rights Defense Center (“HRDC”), filed its
Complaint against Defendants Irwin Carmichael, Telisa White, Aujiena Hicks, David Hill, and
Jeff Eason in their individual and official capacities. (Doc. No. 1). Each of the Defendants hold
supervisory positions with the Mecklenburg County Sheriff’s Office (“MCSO”) and at the
Mecklenburg County Jail (“MCJ”), and Defendant Carmichael is the Sheriff of Mecklenburg
County. (Doc. No. 1, at ¶¶ 12, 13, 14, 15). Defendants White and Hill are responsible for the
implementation of jail policies in Mecklenburg County, including inmate mail policies and the
hiring, training, and supervision of the personnel who interpret and apply inmate mail policies.
(Doc. No. 1, at ¶¶ 12, 14). Defendants Hicks and Eason report to Defendants White and Hill and
supervise jail operations, including the mailroom and the routing of incoming prisoner mail. (Doc.
No. 1, at ¶¶ 13, 15).
Plaintiff sends various publications to incarcerated persons at the MCJ, such as Prison
Legal News, Criminal Legal News, The Habeas Citebook, and Prisoner’s Handbook. (Doc. No. 1,
at ¶¶ 1, 18, 19, 20, 21). Defendants rejected delivery of at least 144 copies of those and other

publications and placed Prison Legal News on Defendants’ list of banned magazines. (Doc. No. 1,
at ¶ 27). Defendants did not explain why Prison Legal News was banned or why they had rejected
delivery of the other publications, and Defendants did not give Plaintiff an opportunity to appeal
the rejections or the decision to ban Prison Legal News. (Doc. No. 1, at ¶¶ 32-34).
Defendants accept some legal texts, magazines, and other publications that Plaintiff alleges
are similar to its publications. (Doc. No. 1, at ¶¶ 38-39). However, Defendants prohibit mail that
is “in violation of the [MCSO’s] rules, or detrimental to rehabilitation.” (Doc. No. 1, at p. 8). For
example, the MCSO’s rules prohibit illicit or enticing photos, material containing nudity, and
stamps. (Doc. No. 1, at p. 8).

II. STANDARD OF REVIEW
“Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 8(a)(2) requires . . . a short and plain statement of the
claim showing that the pleader is entitled to relief, in order to give the defendant fair notice of what
the . . . claim is and the grounds upon which it rests.” Bell Atl. Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544,
555 (2007) (citation and internal quotations omitted). Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(6) provides an avenue
to attack a complaint where the “grounds” of a plaintiff’s “entitle[ment] to relief” are insufficient.
Id. (citation omitted). When faced with a motion to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(6), the Court must
“accept as true all well-pleaded allegations and . . . view the complaint in a light most favorable to
the plaintiff.” Mylan Labs, Inc. v. Matkari, 7 F.3d 1130, 1134 (4th Cir. 1993). A court then
“determine[s] whether [those allegations] plausibly give rise to an entitlement to relief.” Ashcroft
v. Iqbal, 556 U.S. 662, 679 (2009). However, a court “need not accept as true unwarranted
inferences, unreasonable conclusions, or arguments.” E. Shore Mkts., Inc. v. J.D. Assocs. LLP,
213 F.3d 175, 180 (4th Cir. 2000). Further, a “pleading that offers labels and conclusions or a
formulaic recitation of the elements of a cause of action will not do.” Iqbal, 556 U.S. at 678

(quotations and citation omitted).
III. DISCUSSION
Plaintiff has asserted three claims against Defendants: (1) violation of the First Amendment
for censoring Plaintiff’s publications, (2) violation of the Fourteenth Amendment’s Due Process
Clause for failure to provide notice with regard to the decision to censor Plaintiff’s publications,
and (3) violation of the Fourteenth Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause for treating Plaintiff’s
publications differently than similarly situated publications. (Doc. No. 1, at ¶¶ 49-76). Defendants
move to dismiss all of Plaintiff’s claims, except for Plaintiff’s First Amendment and Due Process
Clause claims against Sheriff Irwin Carmichael in his official capacity. (Doc. No. 15, at 2).

Defendants provide three grounds for dismissal. First, Defendants argue that Plaintiff’s “official
capacity claims against all Defendants except Sherriff Carmichael are redundant because the
Complaint states a cognizable claim against Sheriff Carmichael in his official capacity.” (Doc. No.
15, at 5). Second, Defendants argue that Plaintiff’s Equal Protection Clause claim is not supported
by factual allegations that the Plaintiff was treated differently for a discriminatory reason. (Doc.
No. 15, at 6). Third, Defendants argue that the individual capacity claims against them should be
dismissed both because Plaintiff does not allege that Defendants were personally involved in the
deprivation of Plaintiff’s rights and because Defendants are entitled to qualified immunity. (Doc.
No. 15, at 9, 14). The Court addresses each argument in turn.
A. Plaintiff’s Official Capacity Claims
Defendants argue that Plaintiff’s official capacity claims against Defendants Telisa White,
Aujiena Hicks, David Hill, Jeff Eason, and Does 1-10 are redundant because the Complaint states
a cognizable official capacity claim against Sheriff Carmichael. (Doc. No. 15, at 5). Claims against
defendants in their official capacity “constitute . . . claim[s] against the entity for which [they] are

agents therefor.” Layman v. Alexander, 343 F.Supp. 2d 483, 488 (W.D.N.C. 2004) (citing Gantt
v. Whitaker, 203 F. Supp.2d 503, 508 (M.D.N.C. 2002), aff'd, 57 Fed.Appx. 141 (4th Cir. 2003)).
It follows that where a plaintiff asserts official capacity claims against multiple defendants acting
as agents for the same entity, dismissal of the redundant claims is appropriate. Id. (Dismissing
official capacity claims against two officers where a plaintiff had also asserted a claim against a
sheriff’s department through an official capacity claim against the department’s sheriff.) (citing
Gantt, 203 F.Supp.2d at 508; Ramsey v. Schauble, 141 F. Supp.2d 584, 591 (W.D.N.C. 2001)).
Here, Defendants White, Hicks, Hill, Eason, and Does 1-10 are or were employed by the MCSO
and Defendant Carmichael is the Sheriff of Mecklenburg County. (Doc. No. 1, at ¶¶ 12, 13, 14,

15, 16). Thus, Plaintiff’s official capacity claims against all Defendants other than Defendant
Carmichael are redundant and hereby DISMISSED.
B. Plaintiff’s Equal Protection Claims
Defendants argue that dismissal of Plaintiff’s equal protection claim is appropriate because
Plaintiff makes no factual allegations that its alleged unequal treatment was due to intentional or
purposeful discrimination. (Doc. No. 15, at 6). In order to survive a motion to dismiss an equal
protection claim, a plaintiff “must plead sufficient facts to demonstrate plausibly that he was
treated differently from others who were similarly situated and that the unequal treatment was the
result of discriminatory animus.” Equity in Athletics, Inc. v. Department of Education, 639 F.3d.
91, 108 (4th Cir. 2011). In other words, a plaintiff must set forth “specific non-conclusory factual
allegations that establish an improper [discriminatory] motive.” Williams v. Hansen, 326 F.3d.
569, 584 (4th Cir. 2003).
Here, Plaintiff alleges that Defendants permitted publications from similarly situated
publishers of legal news and job readiness publications but censored or banned Plaintiff’s

publications. Plaintiff’s only allegations that those actions were motivated by improper
discrimination were its conclusory statements that the unequal treatment was “undertaken
intentionally” and that it was “the result of Defendants’ intentional and/or purposeful
discrimination against Plaintiff.” (Doc. No. 1, at 12, 16). While Plaintiff seeks to circumvent that
deficiency by citing to various portions of its Complaint alleging that “Defendants purposefully
discriminated against” Plaintiff, each of those allegations are that Plaintiff’s publications were
treated unequally, not that such treatment resulted from purposeful discrimination. (Doc. No. 23,
at 7, 8).
Even to the extent that Plaintiff’s allegations of unequal treatment also constitute

allegations of purposeful discrimination, those allegations ask this Court to adopt unreasonable
and unwarranted inferences. For example, Plaintiff argues that its publications were magazines,
legal texts, and education and job readiness books, all of which are permitted by the MCJ’s
policies. (Doc. No. 23, at 7, 8). However, the censored publications Plaintiff attached to its motion
for preliminary injunction contain advertisements for nude and semi-nude pictures, (Doc. Nos. 6-
3, at 18, 35, 47, 52, 62, 68; 6-4, at 19, 22, 24, 26, 37, 46, 60, 62; 6-5, at 7, 12), which are prohibited
by the MCJ’s mail policy, (Doc. No. 1, at 8) (prohibiting mailed items containing “[m]aterial that
is pornographic, illicit, erotic, and enticing in nature.”). Because Plaintiff fails to set forth any
factual allegations showing how the form and contents of its censored materials were in
compliance with the MCJ’s mail policy, this Court declines to accept as true the unwarranted
inference that Defendants’ banning and censorship of Plaintiff’s publications are evidence of
discriminatory intent. See E. Shore Mkts., Inc. v. J.D. Assocs. LLP, 213 F.3d 175, 180 (4th Cir.
2000). Thus, Plaintiff fails to make specific, non-conclusory allegations that establish a
discriminatory motive and Plaintiff’s equal protection claim is DISMISSED. See Williams v.

Hansen, 326 F.3d. 569, 584 (4th Cir. 2003).
C. Plaintiff’s Individual Capacity Claims
Defendants argue that they are entitled to dismissal of all individual capacity claims against
them because (1) Defendants are not alleged to have been personally involved in the deprivation
of the Plaintiff’s rights and (2) Defendants are entitled to qualified immunity.1 (Doc. No. 15, at 9-
15).
1. Personal Involvement
Personal liability under § 1983 is “based upon each defendant’s own constitutional
violations.” Trulock v. Freeh, 275 F.3d 391, 402 (4th Cir.2001) (internal citation omitted).

“Because vicarious liability is inapplicable to . . . § 1983 suits, a plaintiff . . . must plead that each
Government-official defendant, through the official’s own individual actions, has violated the
Constitution.” Ashcroft v. Iqbal, 556 U.S. 662, 676 (2009) (citation omitted). In other words, to
establish liability under § 1983, a plaintiff must affirmatively show that the individual defendants
“acted personally in the deprivation of the plaintiff’s rights.” Wright v. Collins, 766 F.2d 841, 850
(4th Cir. 1985) (internal citations omitted). Personal deprivation can, however, be found on the

1 Because the Court has dismissed Plaintiff’s equal protection claim in its entirety and dismisses
Plaintiff’s First Amendment and due process claims against Defendants in their individual capacity
below, the Court need not consider whether Defendants are entitled to qualified immunity from
Plaintiff’s claims against Defendants in their individual capacity.
part of “supervisory officials . . . for the constitutional injuries inflicted by the[ir] subordinates.”
Shaw v. Stroud, 13 F.3d 791, 798 (4th Cir. 1994) (citing Slakan v. Porter, 737 F.2d 368 (4th Cir.
1984), cert. denied, 470 U.S. 1035 (1985)). “[T]hat liability is not premised upon respondeat
superior but upon ‘a recognition that supervisory indifference or tacit authorization of
subordinates’ misconduct may be a causative factor in the constitutional injuries they inflict on

those committed to their care.’” Id. (citation omitted and emphasis added).
Ultimately, supervisory liability is determined ‘by pinpointing the persons in the decision[-
]making chain whose deliberate indifference permitted the constitutional abuses to continue
unchecked. Id. (citation omitted). The Fourth Circuit has set forth three elements for making that
determination: “(1) that the supervisor had actual or constructive knowledge that his subordinate
was engaged in conduct that posed "a pervasive and unreasonable risk" of constitutional injury to
citizens like the plaintiff; (2) that the supervisor's response to that knowledge was so inadequate
as to show "deliberate indifference to or tacit authorization of the alleged offensive practices," and
(3) that there was an "affirmative causal link" between the supervisor's inaction and the particular

constitutional injury suffered by the plaintiff.” Id. (citations omitted).
With respect to Plaintiff’s First Amendment claim, Plaintiff appears to argue that its
constitutional injury was the banning and censoring of its publications. (Doc. No. 23, at 10). While
it is clearly established that publishers have a First Amendment right to communicate with inmates,
see Thornburgh v. Abbott, 490 U.S. 401, 407–08 (1989), courts give substantial deference to prison
officials when reviewing prison policies, Lovelace v. Lee, 472 F.3d 174, 200 (4th Cir. 2006). That
deference is “achieved in part through application of a reasonableness test that is less restrictive
than the test ordinarily applied to alleged infringements of fundamental rights.” Id. (citing O'Lone
v. Estate of Shabazz, 482 U.S. 342, 348 (1987). Put simply, a “prison regulation that abridges
inmates’ constitutional rights is ‘valid if it is reasonably related to legitimate penological
interests.’” Turner v. Safley, 482 U.S. 78, 84 (1987). When making that determination, courts
consider:
(1) whether there is a "valid, rational connection" between the prison regulation or
action and the interest asserted by the government, or whether this interest is "so
remote as to render the policy arbitrary or irrational"; (2) whether "alternative
means of exercising the right . . . remain open to prison inmates" . . . ; (3) what
impact the desired accommodation would have on security staff, inmates, and the
allocation of prison resources; and (4) whether there exist any "obvious, easy
alternatives" to the challenged regulation or action, which may suggest that it is
"not reasonable, but is [instead] an exaggerated response to prison concerns."

Id. (citing Turner, 482 U.S. at 89-92).
While Plaintiff alleges that Defendants rejected delivery of 144 publications from Plaintiff
and placed one publication on a banned magazines list (Doc. No. 1, at ¶¶ 27, 29), Plaintiff’s
allegations that Defendants’ actions were not related to legitimate penological interests are merely
conclusory. For example, Plaintiff alleges that the MCJ’s restrictions “do not advance any
legitimate government interest” and that, even if they did, they have no “valid, rational connection
to such an interest.” (Doc. No. 1, at ¶ 52). Further, Plaintiff alleges it “has no alternative means of
communicating the material in its publications,” that “[a]llowing [Plaintiff] to . . . communicate
with incarcerated individuals would have no meaningful adverse impact on guards . . . or on the
allocation of resources at [MCJ],” that “[t]here are obvious, easy alternatives to [MCJ’s] blanket
censorship policy” that “would protect [Plaintiff’s] First Amendment rights,” and that Defendants’
conduct was “objectively unreasonable.” (Doc. No. 1, at 14, 15). Plaintiff alleges no specific facts
in support of those assertions, and the mere recitation of the Turner factors does not state a
plausible claim for relief. See Iqbal, 556 U.S. at 678. Thus, Plaintiff’s First Amendment claims
against all Defendants in their individual capacity are DISMISSED.
With respect to Plaintiff’s procedural due process claim, Defendants argue that “Plaintiff’s
allegations fall woefully short of demonstrating supervisory liability” because there was no
“allegation[] that the individual Defendants knew about any constitutional injury to the Plaintiff.”
(Doc. No. 15, at 13). Plaintiff responds that Defendants “likely had actual knowledge.” (Doc. No.
23, at 10). While that conclusory allegation, by itself, is insufficient to state a claim, see Iqbal, 556

U.S. at 678, Plaintiff also argues that an earlier case brought by a prisoner against MCSO for
censoring Plaintiff’s publications gave Defendants actual knowledge of the constitutional injury
to Plaintiff, (Doc. No. 23, at 10) (citing Taylor v. Mecklenburg County Sherriff's Office, No. 3:17-
cv-208 (W.D.N.C. Apr. 18, 2017)). However, Plaintiff does not allege that the censorship
complained of in that earlier case is the same censorship complained of here. Thus, Plaintiff does
not make an allegation that Defendants had actual knowledge of constitutional injury alleged in
this case.
Plaintiff argues, in the alternative, that Defendants had constructive knowledge of the
constitutional injury because they implemented the mail policies and oversaw subordinates who

interpreted and applied the mail policies. (Doc. No. 23, at 9) (citing Doc. No. 1, at ¶¶ 11, 12, 13,
14, 15). However, while Plaintiff did allege that Defendants did not receive notice or an
opportunity to appeal Defendants’ censorship decisions, Plaintiff never alleged that it was denied
process because the MCJ mail policy required it. (Doc. No. 1, at ¶ 33). Plaintiff may not allege
constructive knowledge of a constitutional injury simply by virtue of Defendants’ involvement in
the implementation of policies that Plaintiff never alleged caused that injury. For the same reason,
Plaintiff’s theory of supervisory liability based merely on the advancement of mail policy itself
fails. (Doc. No. 23, at 10) (citing OSU Student All. v. Ray, 699 F.3d 1053, 1076 (9th Cir. 2012)
(“Advancing a policy that requires subordinates to commit constitutional violations is always
enough for § 1983 liability . . . so long as the policy proximately causes the harm—that is, so long
as the plaintiff's constitutional injury in fact occurs pursuant to the policy.”).
Plaintiff also argues that Defendants are liable for violating Plaintiff's “due process rights
by failing to put in place a policy providing publishers with both ... notice .. . and an opportunity
to appeal the rejection of any publications.” (Doc. No. 23, at 11). Plaintiff provides no authority
(and the Court is aware of none) showing that liability automatically follows where a party does
not have a pre-existing policy in place for providing notice and the opportunity for appeal. Thus,
Plaintiff's procedural due process claims against all Defendants in their individual capacities are
DISMISSED.
IV. CONCLUSION
Defendants’ Motion is GRANTED, Plaintiffs official capacity claims against Defendants
White, Hicks, Hill, Eason, and Does 1-10 are DISMISSED, Plaintiffs equal protection claim is
DISMISSED in its entirety, and Plaintiff First Amendment and procedural due process claims
against all Defendants in their individual capacities are DISMISSED. Plaintiffs First Amendment
and procedural due process claims against Sheriff Carmichael in his official capacity remain.
SO ORDERED.

Signed: December 27, 2019
Laban! Leubhe—
United States District Judge ge

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/cases/10255294. Public record. Not legal advice.
